Skip to main content

tv   Real Money With Ali Velshi  Al Jazeera  January 20, 2015 2:00am-3:01am EST

2:00 am
kind of pays attention. >> "surf haiti" remains for now a small project with few customers. with waves like this, it's hoped that will soon change. 1% of people on earth are about to control more than half of the world's wealth, president obama wants to even the playing field with tax cuts for the poor and tax increases for the rich. and we'll take you to philadelphia where hard-working americans have managed to keep their communities together. i'm david shuster in for ali money." ♪
2:01 am
one day before president obama gives his state of the union address to congress and the nation there is now every indication the president's speech will focus extensively on the date of the middle class. jobs are being created at the fastest clip in a decade, the stock market is booming, up 168% in five years. when you add to all of that, the financial boosts many americans are feeling thanks to plummeting energy prices, but there is a public disconnect. a university poll asked americans how much the upturn benefits their families. 32% said not much.
2:02 am
and another 29% said not at all. to understand why the 61% said they feel the strong economy is passing them by, you have to understand the middle sclasz today. wages remain flat, and household median income as fallen by as much as 8% since the recession, so with that in mind, white house officials say in his state of the union speech president obama will propose tax hikes on the rich, and fees to fund programs benefiting the middle class, the total benefits over ten years would be $320 billion. the centerpiece of the president's proposal to pay for it, involves raising the tax rate on couples making over $500 thousand dollars a year to 28%, 4.2 percentage points higher than they currently pay.
2:03 am
wealthy. the president intends to use the new revenue to generate a $500 tax care, expand the child care credit, and consolidate education tax breaks. he wants to add free tuition at two-year community colleges. but given republican oppetition to tax hikes of any kind, it is likely he will face fierce opposition in congress. >> there are two things going on here, david, and it's clear since the last state of the union when the president said he was going to use his pen and phone to go around congress, and the president is going to go his own way without regard, remember
2:04 am
after the 2012 election he was went on something of a charm offensive. he played golf with the republicans, had dinner with them. that went out the window, the president is going to do what he is going to do right now. the president is either trying to blow up any chance that he is going to come together with republicans on this issue of taxes. after always, frankly republicans aren't going to go for this in any way shape or form, sort of a redistributing of the wealth that you just outlined taxing things like inheritance, capital gains, and passing it on to lower and middle income americans, and to finance many of any programs he has been on the road talking about over the last two weeks. the president is ignoring republicans while trying to lay down some parameters, and speaking to base democrats,
2:05 am
those democrats who did not turn out in the midterm elections in november. >> mike how has the white house reacted to the strategy of dribbling out some of this stuff in advance, and taking away the drama of the state of the union address itself. >> i think the president is getting out ahead of the curve, and putting republicans on the defensive. republicans are saying, including many of the presidential candidates in 2016 from mitt romney on down, from 46%, addressing some of the very issues that the president intends to address, stagnant incomes and a tight labor market that is responsible for those incomes. price -- gas prices are down, unemployment rate is down,
2:06 am
consumer confidence is up, so a whole raft of new goods with -- except for the fact that there is still one leak in the boat and that is the income in working class americans. you have seeing all spectrums trying to address this in different ways, and the president thinks he has the upper hand. obviously he is going to have a captive nation tomorrow night. >> and the white house feels a special obligation to take credit for how the government has worked, that so many americans say the economy has essentially passed them by. >> right. there's some vindication, there's no question in the tone that the president and some of the officials have used as the economic news has continued to poor in year, but still the silver line -- as a
2:07 am
matter of fact most americans are not sharing in the prosperity we have seen, so the president feels this needs to be addressed. he feels no need to try to dance around it. >> al jazeera's mike viqueira at the white house, mike, thank you. for how all of this place out politically, we turn to al jazeera's political correspondent mike michael shure. so is this a wise strategy for the president to signal essentially war? >> well, you talk about the politics david, and what mike viqueira said is right, there is no chance this is going to passite ever house of congress. but this puts the republicans in a position to defend the wealthy.
2:08 am
going into 2016, that's not where they want to be, it was a formal that didn't work for them before, and we have talked much much more in the past few years about income and equality and that is going to be in the forefront of the election. >> in the polls the president's approval rating is starting to tick up, as more as more americans start to think maybe the middle class haven't seen their wages go up, but other areas are getting stronger. >> what the white house, the president and the candidates who will be running for the presidency need to do is to find a way to articulate that. 61%, largely it is even higher than that only 8% of the people in the poll said they felt it a great deal, they felt the economic uptick a great deal, that's 92% of americans who
2:09 am
didn't feel it much at all, and so that's a problem. so they have to craft some sort of agenda, so that's what the president is going to try to do to tomorrow so people can start feeling this. >> it always feels like the president make be taking a page out of the republican play book, offering tax credits that would seem normally to be something that republicans would support, does it put them in a box? >> yeah, it is taking ownership of something because you are the president. this is a bully pulpit moment. he can take some of the language, even the language, david of the -- inheritance tax. now they are talking about it as a trust fund loophole. they are taking a few
2:10 am
pages off of the markets they can do. >> and as far as putting things on like what warren buffet said that he plays less tax because of capitol gains. even if they can't get something through congress this year, as you pointed out, if they can put the republicans heading into 2016 having to defend the wealthy, that's going to be good for the president. >> yeah, if you here the wealthy whining, there is not going to be a lot of sympathy for that position. it's also key to what he wants to do with his legacy. this is a place that he can start doing that in the next two years. look as dismal as people have focused on them, they are better than president ronald reagan was
2:11 am
at this point in his presidency, so he has that going for him. >> and the other major proposal we are talking about later in the show, as far as the specifics of two years of free tuition to attend a community college, what is the politics of that? >> it's people for whom it is an expense. you are saying you are going to get a leg up here, your community college will be paid for, and all of a sudden you are a young voter, and we need young voters. >> michael shure thanks, we appreciate. >> coming up, how the super rich ended up on the verge of owning more than the rest of the world. you are watching "real money." ♪
2:12 am
>> tomorrow. from race relations to foreign policies, terrorism and the economy. >> if this congress wants to help, work with me. >> ali velshi kicks off our special state of the union coverage at 7:00. >> we'll take an in-depth look at our nation's financial future. >> then john seigenthaler breaks down the issues. >> we need to know what's going on in our backyard. >> plus, objective analysis and live reports from across the nation and reaction from around the world. the state of the union address. special coverage begins tomorrow at 7:00 eastern. right here on al jazeera
2:13 am
>> start with one issue education... gun control... the gap between rich and poor... job creation... climate change... tax policy... the economy... iran... healthcare... ad guests on all sides of the debate. >> this is a right we should all have... >> it's just the way it is... >> there's something seriously wrong... >> there's been acrimony... >> the conservative ideal... >> it's an urgent need... and a host willing to ask the tough questions >> how do you explain it to yourself? and you'll get... the inside story ray suarez hosts inside story
2:14 am
weekdays at 5 eastern only on al jazeera america later this -- week ali velshi would bring us news from the world economic meeting. the anti-poverty group release
2:15 am
study showing next year the richest people in the world will control more than half of the world's weather. roxana saberi has the story. >> reporter: frustration over growing income inequality sparked the occupy wall street movement. since that that protest has grown from the u.s. to china. since then the world's richest 1% is on track to owning more than half of the world's wealth next year. the portion of wealth held by the top 1% actually fell, but over the next four years it will rise dramatically and will keep rising just as the wealth held dropping. >> incomes are not going up, minimum wages have stayed stagnant, and the rich just continue to get richer as
2:16 am
government policies have moved in that direction. >> reporter: they say the world's 80 richest people control the same wealth as half of the world's population. they are calling on governments to invest in free education and health care, improve worker's rich. >> rich individuals and particularly the richest individuals should pay a reasonable level of tax, the kind of tax they were paying as recently as the 1990s. >> reporter: they say income inequality hurts everyone, because when more people have less to spending the economy suffers. the report was released ahead of the world economic forum. the group hopes to urge the heards to narrow the gap between the rich and poor, and also the day before president obama is expected to call on thewellthy
2:17 am
to help the middle class. >> wealth extaughts the largest collection of the high-wealth individuals. david joins us now. to put that in context. what does it take to be in the highest 1% around the world. >> we call that mass affluent. those would be people that are million -- millionaires. >> how many are worth $30 million or more. >> $30 million net worth and up is what we track. there are individuals. >> and despite that 200 and some thousand, america's middle class continues to shrink how come? >> this is the age-old classic
2:18 am
question of how do you bridge the gap between the haves and have nots. if you look at other economies, it's becoming so acute, but when you look at the u.s., yes, there's a big gap, but the gap is much smaller than if you look at places like russia or china or even latin america. >> over the next three decades, the wealthiest americans are getting ready to transfer some $6 trillion in assets to their next generation. why not make some of that available to the government in terms of inheritance taxes. >> for the ultra afterfluentaffluent, they
2:19 am
are of the most generous. i mean that's a philosophical question as to which governments should do that. ours we do take that. if you look at the estate tax and where it was created originally, i think the original reason is not why it is happening today. a lot of them are giving it away, others are saying, hey, we're creating jobs by debate. >> and when you make money due to investments, you are not necessarily creating a job. president obama is now suggesting it should go up to 28%. that? >> i think, though, if you look at the majority of the wealth, our biggest wealth driver because between 750 million to a billion dollars. and the money they made was
2:20 am
because they took money invested in real estate and other asset classes, things that they knew, that did create jobs, so, you know, it depends on the data, we don't have all of that data in front of us, but you would have to look at what they have done. >> there is a long-running argument in the united states that in order to create economic activity, it is better for the government to take money out of the hands of the wealthy, and spending it, as oppose ed to the wealthy make spending it overseas or do things that don't necessarily make it circulate in the economy. >> yeah, that's a big huge debate. i'm a entrepreneur, and someone invested in us, so based on my personal experience as an entrepreneur, those are the kinds of things we do, and i
2:21 am
i -- see that happening. we need infrastructure, we need all of those things, but me, i can speak only from my own personal experience. in my former life, i did advice investment groups. and all of them are focused on attracting development companies, because that's what drives jobs, especially in places like the middle east where there are so many people out of work and that creates social unrest, and so forth. good to talk to you. some working mothers can no longer afford to work. we'll take a look at how president obama wants to make child care more affordable for more americans. that story and more comingen when "real money" continues. ♪
2:22 am
>> saturday. >> visibility was 3 to 5 nautical miles. >> weathering the storm. >> we want to show people how to replace property against the worst mother nature has to offer. >> experts forecast how to stay safe. >> i'm standing in a tropical windstorm. >> in extreme weather. >> oh my god. >> techknow's team of experts show you how the miracles of science... >> this is my selfie, what can you tell me about my future? >> can affect and surprise us. >> don't try this at home. >> "techknow" where technology meets humanity. saturday at 7:30 eastern. only on al jazeera america.
2:23 am
2:24 am
president obama's plan to help the middle class including triples the child care tax credit to $3,000 per child for kids under five. the white house says the changes will help more than 5 million families cover child care costs. those costs impose a huge
2:25 am
financial burdens on many families. annual child care now costs more than an entire year of in-state public college. as mary snow -- reporting, finding affordable child care is no longer a problem for just the working middle class. >> reporter: for these working parents taking care of their baby and getting their 4-year-old up and running each morning can be nothing short of a miracle. but juggling the costs of child care for their two daughters has become the real daily struggle. >> what book do you want to bring to school. >> one third went to child care, the next third went to rent. so when i'm buying groceries, i'm thinking let me make sure i haven't overdown. >> todd runs a music non-profit
2:26 am
and teaches part-time at columbia university. they can barely play for preschool fees and one day of baby sitting a week. that means trading off days working from home. >> there's something systemically wrong when an associate professor with a partner who is making, you know, some salary truly can't make ends meet. >> we fall in between. >> child care is typically the highest household expense in most regions, exceeded only on the west coast by housing. >> reporter: lanette is executive director of a non-profit that studies the costs of child care. fees vary state to state. massachusetts ranks as most
2:27 am
expensive. with mississippi the lowest. but nationwide child care costs have been growing at a rate five times that of family incomes. >> we're seeing a time in the united states where people are having baby's literally off an economic cliff. >> reporter: she cofounded moms rising, with over a million members across the u.s. she says the larger issue is a matter of supply. day cares in 19 states had waiting lists or turned away families all together, unable to keep up with the de-- demand of the labor force. >> nearly 50% of families are relying on mom's wages as the primary breadwinner. >> reporter: and yet the economic squeeze of child care
2:28 am
has increasingly forced moms like jessica christie, a washington, d.c. mother of three out of work. >> working for the law firm was one of the most satisfying jobs i have ever had. >> reporter: christy gave up a litigation assistant job when her second son was born, but like many families she couldn't afford to give up a second income all together. she picked up consulting work to keep their budget afloat. but even for parents with full-time jobs, professional sacrifice is a constant. she recently landed a coveted teaching fellowship for the fall, but worry that she and todd won't be able to afford the extra baby sitting. >> if we can't get the salary
2:29 am
increases that we need for next year, what will dwoe in what is the plan b? there is no plan b. we have a tiny bit in our savings that will go away that won't be enough. and that's sort of that. studies have shown the expense in difficulty of finding child care hurt the overall economy. a non-profit focused on business investment in education, employee abcentimism cost companies $3 billion each year. a lesson in why this matters returns. ♪ >> al jazeera america presents a breakthrough television event. borderland. six strangers. >> let's just send them back to mexico. >> experience illegal immigration up close and
2:30 am
personal. >> it's overwhelming to see this many people that have perished. >> lost lives are relived. >> all of these people shouldn't be dead. >> will there differences bring them together or tear them apart? >> the only way to find out is to see it yourselves. >> which side of the fence are you on? borderland, sunday at 9 eastern, only on al jazeera america.
2:31 am
>> i'm joie chen i'm the host of america tonight, we're revolutionary because we're going back to doing best of storytelling. we have an ouportunity to really reach out and really talk to voices that we haven't heard before... i think al jazeera america is a watershed moment for american journalism ♪ president obama's plan to offer students two free years of community college would cost u.s. tax pairs $60 billion over ten years. higher taxes on the rich and fees on big banks would fund the plan, which is, republicans will probably not approve it. but student debt in this country
2:32 am
now tops $1 trillion. that directly effects 1 in 8 americans. but the student debt crisis poses serious risks to the entire economy. >> reporter: this 31-year-old graduated with a masters in 2008, during the depps of the great recession. she quickly defaulted on her bill. which brought on fines and fees. >> oh, well, i'll just file for bankruptcy like everyone else is doing, and then you realize the only way to get alone from your student loan debt is to die. >> reporter: some 40 million people are living with student debt, together and other their lifetimes that adds up to a
2:33 am
staggers wealth loss of 4 $4 trillion? why because they are paying off educations that were supposed to level the playing field to give americans of equal ability an equal shot at wealth. >> i'm angry, because it's unfair that it's happening to us, and we eefrn being sort of blamed for the amount of debt that we're putting in. >> it is absolutely cuts in state funding that have been the major cause. >> reporter: this man exams funding trends for state higher education. nice wade state funding plummeted 27% per sunt between
2:34 am
2008 and 2012, while tuition at four-year state institutions increased 20%. and that has huge implications for all of us. consumer spending generates some two-thirds of our economic growth, and young people are the plankton in that ecosystem. >> these students who are paying 300 or $500 a month towards reducing their student death that is $500 they could be spending towards a down payment on a house or a new car. >> reporter: about seven of every ten college graduates in 2013 left school with student debt, the average bill, $28,400. president obama's new proposal to make community college more accessible is aimed in part at bringing down that tab. >> america's college promise
2:35 am
will make two years of community college free. >> the plan requires students to maintain a 2.5 gpa, attend school at least halftime, and enroll in programs that lead to a two-year professional degree, or serve as a stepping-stone towards a four-year college. the free community college plan could save 9 million students $3,400 a year in tuition, but congress would have to approve the cost. $60 billion over ten years. as for this woman, she faced down her debt demons, moved home and worked at the u.n. and as a cocktail waitress to pay off her education. >> it became a game to me. >> reporter: today she is debt financially. >> i have no retirement fund, no savings. >> reporter: thanks to an
2:36 am
education that still has her playing catchup with those who graduated debt free. >> patty what is the other criticism of this free college tuition for community college that the president is likely going to face? >> the major criticism is that it's not means tested. it is available to everyone regardless of their financial position. opponents is likely to point out the burden on lower-class students. there was a study that found that kids from lower income families graduated on average with $10,000 more in student debt than kids with more affluent families. grant. >> is higher education still a ticket to the american dream? >> one of the perverse things about student debt is that it is actually crystallizing
2:37 am
precipitation -- privilege. but because these graduates are paying back student loans precisely in their prime earning years, when they are supposed to be buying stocks, houses, saving mobny for their retirement. and that equals a wealth loss. however, the federal reserve of san francisco did a study and they found it is still a good investment because college graduates by the time they hit retirement they have made $800,000 graduates. victory. >> some of the primary ones have been to help students manage their monthly payments through programs like pay as you earn that cap those payments at 10% of the income. if you default, it is a disaster, it follows you for life.
2:38 am
there's no way to get out of student debt inless you die. but probably the biggest victory for obama is he has made this a kitchen table issue. most americans realize student debt is a crisis. >> even in the alvaz polite came up in the top four in terms of concerns that people have about concerns facing their family. patricia sabga, thank you very much. up next, we'll take you to philadelphia where one middle class neighborhood has managed to stake intact, where areas around it fell into disrepair. o >> beyond the verdict and on the streets >> there's been another teenager shot and killed by the police >> a fault lines special investigation >> there's a general distrust of this prosecutor >> courageous and in depth... >> it's a target you can't get rid of... >> the untold story... >> who do you protect? >> ...of what's really going on in ferguson >> they were so angry because it could have been them >> fault lines ferguson: race and justice in the u.s. one hour special
2:39 am
only on al jazeera america
2:40 am
♪ today marks the intersection of to important events the day america celebrates the garrett of martin luther king, jr., and the eve of president obama's state of the union address. the president is expected to call for tax increases in order
2:41 am
to fund new tax measures that he hopes will help the middle class. philadelphia has lost a critical number of middle class paying residents, but one primarily black african american neighborhood has somehow managed to keep its community together over the last 40 years, while others hallowed out. ali velshi takes a look. ♪ >> reporter: it's sunday morning at penn memorial church in the philadelphia. ♪ >> reporter: francis has been going to this church for decades.
2:42 am
she moved here in the 60s, when the neighborhood was primarily jewish. synagogue. >> back in the 1800s, it was mostly anglo-saxon, then in the 60s, the african-americans -- in fact i was the second black street. >> winfield is one of philadelphia's few predominantly black middle class areas. what you don't see is that many of these blocks have block captains who keep an eye on what is going on. whether it's garbage collection, or snow removal or crime. win field has a strong identity, it is a night knit community spread out on curving tree-line streets with beautiful homes. it's not unusual to see something like this.
2:43 am
tell me why this area has maintained itself in a way that philadelphia? >> well, you have for instance, the win field residence association, and it's one of the oldest residential institutions in the city, in the country. they have marched and walked and had block captains staying up all night with candles, candlelight marches, you have individual block clubs formed because of crime. >> reporter: the middle class is more diverse today than it was in the 1970s. back then 74% of the population was white. now blacks make up 42% of the middle class, but the general feeling here is there's a difference between white and black middle class. >> when you look at the median income, it is such a wide gap from blacks to whites that you never catch up to what whites
2:44 am
are making because you don't have those opportunities. >> reporter: income varies between white middle class and black middle class which neighborhood. in hereby rocks burrow, a traditionally white middle class neighborhood, the median income is $60,000. larry studied this. he said even though there are more blacks in the middle class today, they don't have the same kinds of jobs as the white middle class. >> what some people in the black middle class will tell you is a lot of that is generated by public sector jobs, and related jobs, and some african american analysts and scholars will tell you they haven't made as much progress in the private sector. >> reporter: some economists believe this makes it harder for black middle class citizens to climb the economic ladder or
2:45 am
send their children to better schools. and some of the neighborhoods aren't gentrifying, so their home values are depreciating. austin says the resillance of this neighborhood is due in large part by the resilience of its residences. >> when you look at white neighborhoods, they may not be publicized as much. they have the resources that often african american communities don't have, and they have to work harder to get to that level. they may have a network of relatives who are judges and lawyers and indian chiefs where they can get things done, where african-americans may not have access to that community. >> reporter: the majority of black philadelphias worry about their standing in the middle class.
2:46 am
59% of black philadelphiians fear they will slip out of the middle class, some compared to americans. >> african american community wealth i think over the last few years generally has gone up, not as much as some communities, and we're also seeing immigrant wealth going up as well. the biggest challenge is actually poverty. we're not only seeing that in the city, but even poverty rising in the suburbs. so that has been an inner generational channinger. >> reporter: philadelphia poorer than in the 1970s. but alston says many people who left winfield in the past are
2:47 am
starting to return, and reinvest in their neighborhood. >> you see them moving back because of the taxes and blatant racism. these are middle class people who decided it's much better to come back here, and they are working to fight to make the school system better, to make changes because they have that courage and that passion. >> reporter: ali velshi, al jazeera. next artistic license gone too far. there is oscar buzz for the film "selma," but historians are questioning its accuracy. >> birds and airplanes just don't mix. midair bird strikes can be dangerous and expensive. seattle-tacoma international airport was the first in the country to employ its own, full time, wildlife biologist. for steve osmek, much of the work involves tracking, trapping
2:48 am
and shoeing. >> this is a pyrotechnic launcher... so it does not fire live rounds. it makes a lot of noise, sirens... you know, some birds they'll get used to this too but especially during the migration period, those types of sounds can be really effective at keeping them away long term. >> bird stikes cost airlines hundreds of millions of dollars every year and have killed an estimated 250 people around the world in the last quarter century. in an effort to eliminate those collisions sea-tac became the first commercial airport in the world to use avian radar. >> here's a small flock. >> osmek's fieldwork is helping airport managers realize they can increase avian and aviation safety the same way, by catching and relocating many of the birds in their airspace and on their airfields. >> here is the bird... lands on the perch... one, perhaps two percent of all the birds that we released come back to the airport. >> four other airports have now
2:49 am
followed sea-tac's lead and employ their own, full-time, wildlife biologist. ♪
2:50 am
as the country commemorates martin luther king day, one of the most poignant dedications took place in selma, alabama. to honor dr. king's birthday, civil rights activists marched with oprah winfrey leading the way. she starred in the movie "selma." >> reporter: these days 71-year-old annie peril avery enjoys a stroll across the bridge in selma, but when she set off for a peaceful march in 1965, it was a starkly different scene. protesters wanting to vote were met by armed police, and annie not for the first time was arrested. >> our real heros are the people who died. i could have gotten killed, but i'm just saying i think it was a small
2:51 am
contribution that i paid because other people paid more. >> we have people walking off of the street -- >> reporter: what happened in selma during the 60s is deeply engrained in this community. every year thousands come here to mark protests that lead to one of the most important pieces of legislation in u.s. history. just months after marches were lead by dr. mar tin luther king, the voting rights act was passed. >> it changes the course of world. >> reporter: those changes are the subject of a new film that upset some. some say the president was reluctant to pass those bills. >> what happened here has been universally praised by these people in selma.
2:52 am
and arguments over perceived inaccuracies are simply overwhelmed by the achievement of ordinary men and women. many of selma's residents were extras in the film. >> it's going to give us the opportunity to talk about it. >> it's kind of amazing to have the movie in selma. it's about selma, and it's 50th anniversary in civil rights. >> reporter: for annie pearl avery and the thousands of others who risked so much, this anniversary is not so much about the box office, but more about the freedoms they fought for and won. questions about accuracy is one controversy, the other is
2:53 am
its lack of oscar nominations. our next guest says the snub reflects a larger problem in hollywood that he calls shameful. mean? >> well, i think we can't exactly put our finger blame on the nominations, but an entire industry that doesn't hire women, hispanics or african-americans in this enormously lucrative industry. if the image isn't produced by the same sort of patch work that makes up the country it is is going to be a very flawed image. >> the depiction of lyndon johnson and some of the inaccuracies there, may
2:54 am
have contributed to the subs. any truth to that? >> you never know. these people all fancy themselves movie experts and vote as they wish. each of the smaller awards, the nominations are put together by the people in that guild. actors nominate actors, directors nominate directors, but that said i think the movie industry also know movies are written in crayon, they are black and white sometimes, and i think the portrayal of lyndon johnson representing the resist importance of the united states government is part of the movie, and there's lots of inaccuracies in movies. american sniper" gives a very atenuated portrait of that character too.
2:55 am
>> i had the opportunity to see "selma" this weren't, and i thought the actor that portrayed brilliant. >> he also gave a great supporting performance in "a most violent year." which also got a snub. last year four or five people of color were nominated in the top oscar categories, and again, sometimes there's the luck of the draw. and of course we do have remember that "selma" was nominated for best picture. the director didn't get a best director nomination, but she is the first african american woman to direct a movie that was nominated for best picture, and
2:56 am
achievement. >> the criticism that the academy itself is too white too old, and doesn't reflect the american public. how does that register as them? >> i think a lot of people in the arts think of themselves as good hearted liberals. steve mcqueen narrowly lost out as best director, so the academy can see look at what happened last year, we had extraordinary nominations. katherine biglow recently won best director, so i think the academy would say, look, it's incredible possible that david came in sixth in the best director race. it's probably very likely, and sometimes -- you know, she was obviously in that top mix. so with some -- there's some cause for them to be a little
2:57 am
bit defensive of this understandably. >> bill thanks as always. we appreciate it. >> david, thank you. >> finally about ten minutes after president obama delivers his state of the union speech, freshmen senator will deliver the response. six years ago after president obama first addresses a joint session of congress, the pressure was on louisiana governor bobbyindal. pundits compared him to mr. rogers. ♪ it's a beautiful day in this neighborhood ♪ >> the next year the republican response came from newly elected virginia governor, bob m cdonald. >> i'm joined to share a republican perspective.
2:58 am
>> reporter: he is now headed to prison after being convicted last year on corruption charges. in 2011, the tea party presented a response by michele bachmann. >> the tea party is a dynamic force. >> she looked into the wrong camera for her entire speech. in 2012, indiana governor was preparing a presidential campaign. within weeks he decided not to run, and soon left politics completeny is. in 2013, it was a bad case of cotton mouth that sidetracked another up and coming star florida senator, marco rubio. >> nothing has frustrated me more than the false choices the president laid out tonight. >> reporter: the pressure joni
2:59 am
earnst is feeling could be enormous. she was a state senator until last year. she has no experience on the national stage, and rocketed to commercial. >> i'm joni earnst, i grew up castrating hogs on a iowa farm. >> reporter: instead of marks on tape, earnst will be looking into a camera live, with as many as 30 million americans watching. is that a recipe for disaster? perhaps, and given the g.o.p. track record, could the republican response really be cursed. tune in tomorrow night after the president finishes his state of the union address. that's our show for today. ali is back tomorrow to kick off the state of the union coverage starting at 7:00 pm eastern time. for everybody here at "real
3:00 am
a ceasefire is holding in yemen's capital but houthi fighters are still surrounding government buildings. hello and welcome to al jazeera live from doha, i'm mary ann namazi. afghanistan.'s new president silicon valley