Skip to main content

tv   Third Rail  Al Jazeera  May 23, 2015 8:00am-9:01am EDT

8:00 am
blic schools... >> and his plan to bring music back... >> music makes people happier... >> every tuesday night. >> i lived that character. >> go one on one with america's movers and shakers. >> we will be able to see change. >> gripping. inspiring. entertaining. talk to al jazeera. only on al jazeera america. in tonight's debate billions are believers, we ask does religion do more harm than good. in panel with i.s.i.l. threatening attacks, should washington impose war-time censorship on the internet plus, is president obama trading decades of long-standing ties in the middle east for a questionable deal with iran. kevin durant, faiza patel, and travis smiley will be here. i'm "the guardian", and this is "third
8:01 am
rail" -- i'm imran garda and this is "third rail." >> there'll never be peace or compromise. children... >> what astonishes me is how many problems are the direct result of what people believe about god. >> in any holy book, you can see anything. skyscrapers. >> it's hard to find anything other than religion causing a things. >> a world but religion gave us others. >> that's the way we are wired. >> if you want to find a system encouraging people to be better. worldwide, consistently, the only one we have is religion. >> we have atheist department of transportation, and larry alex
8:02 am
taunton, executive director of the christian based fixed point foundation as our guests thank you for joining us. larry alex taunton, does religion do more harm than good? >> depends on the religion, it's a bread question. christianity, i believe, brings much good to the table. >> like what? >> the data suggests the average evangelical, for instance, gives 10 times the amount of money and time as the average atheist. i am sure that dan is well up the list on that. but they bring a lot of good ben ef lens to a culture. >> so ben esso lens to a culture, religion does more good than harm. particularly larry alex taunton's religion. daniel dennett? >> i believe christianity does a lot of good for many people. many need it.
8:03 am
we should honour and try to preserve that. it does harm, christianity as well. i think the harm these days - don't look at the past, that's atrocious - but if you look at christianity today, to me the big problem with it is the systematic hypocrisy, the way in which it encourages people, obliges them to lie, and it valorizes hypocrisy, and irrationality in a way that is really detrimental. >> how? >> well, when people use faith as an excuse for not thinking, and it seems to me that faith is a gold-plated excuse not to think. problems are difficult, and the answers from your faith is simple, and it's wrong. >> larry alex taunton, in the atlantic you wrote that atheists fascinate you - i'm glad you do, you
8:04 am
have one next to you - but you said you consider their philosophy potentially in my viewee and dangerous. dan is dangerous. >> i don't think dan is dangerous. dangerous. but when i look on the 20th century, an experiment in secular government. what i see is 130 million dead at the hands of secular regimes, suggesting that it is, indeed, dangerous. it's more than all religious wars in all centuries combined. >> the 20th century needed more religion, daniel dennett, not secularism. >> the regime spoken of took their lessons from religion, and turned to stalin and hitler. to call them aith yist regimes is a little much. they basically put forward r.e.m.ageous doc prince --
8:05 am
religious doctrines and cut their followers, enraptured by rhetoric. >> they had idea yoingies. -- idea yoingies. >> it was different from the atheist that i am or the new atheist movement. we are not ideologues we believe in rationality and imperial evidence. >> what about taking larry's point and applying it to, say, china today, right, where the tibetans face cultural destruction. >> yes. >> wiger mousse limbs face destructions, you wouldn't justify that? >> no, i wouldn't. >> satisfied. >> i would put it that which, of the two world fuse, aith yist and christian world few, which
8:06 am
restrains impulses and which exacerbates them. as a christian i'm oblige said to treat you as people made in the way of god. >> whether we want to be viewed that way or not? >> yes, regardless whether you are a member of my community. >> atheists are moral people, they don't need a scripture to come from. >> where does it come from? >> from us, people. who are better judges of what is right and wrong than we, the people. some book says that something that. >> mao was of the opinion that killing 40,000 to 70,000, because he didn't belief there was a god in the next life to judge him for his actions. >> that's not why he did what he did, i am sure. i don't see a relationship
8:07 am
between mao's rein of terror, and his disbelief. >> larry alex taunton, let's have a look at some contemporary trends, if you like, evangelicals in places like uyanda, treading homophobia. is that just final. politics. >> it's not about that, it's americans spreading their role on the take of christianity to places like uganda. >> i can't speak to what dose gone in uganda... >> is it right or wrong. >> christians take scriptures seriously and it speaks about homosexuality. the way in which that is played out in uganda i can't say. >> persecuting homosexuals is okay because... >> no, i didn't say that. it's the teaching of christ, that we treat etch, regardless
8:08 am
of -- everyone, regardless of whether or not they agree with us, whether they are heterosexual or homosexual as an infinite value individual. >> superceding the text that says you may need to persecute them. persecution. >> is it wrong? someone. >> is it wrong to happen in places like uganda. >> i don't know what is going on there. i think it's wrong to persecute. to your general point, it's wrong to persecute in the name of jesus christ. >> is this some of what you are talking about? >> it is, and i have to say the eadvantage illists, how they move into africa and other countries, it's like tobacco countries, now they are wise to products... >> but
8:09 am
tobacco countries don't build schools. >> that's true. but spreading religion to people cell. >> reporter: they do a lot of good work in africa to fight g h.i.v., aids, orphanages. >> let's add up the good and sub tract the value. do. >> i admit they do a lot of good. they can do the same good whout prophetizing, and i think that's unfortunate. >> don't ath exists prophetize as well. the billboards, book sales, if you like. >> we don't tell anybody that they are going to hell if they don't join us. >> right. >> we don't make it a condition of anything, that they believe us. we lay out our reasons and let them decide. >> i want to ask the question is it only about other problems of fundamentalism. from rotten apples,
8:10 am
cherry-picked interpretations of itself? >> i think religion itself lays a foundation for that. this is by encouraging and respecting a certain amount of irrationality. and certain claims beyond criticism, and making it a moral obligation not to criticize the doctrines, not to question them creates an atmosphere that makes fundamentalism possible. i think that is - i would lay that at the doorstep of every religion. in fact, one of the painful paradoxes for good, wise, liberal human community religion in america is that the people that give religion a good name have to recognise it, in doing it that they provide
8:11 am
colourizition for the bad solution. and as i said, if the mafia built schools and hospital we'd organization. >> is religion the mafia. >> bad religion, yes. >> what about within this county, in europe and this country, perhaps we might not have seen the abolition of slavery if it wasn't for fundamentalist christians, quakers and others. >> perhaps not. >> civil rights movement. >> yes, but you have to remember, for all the good that the churches did in furthering civil rights. they were fighting against christian churches in the south segregation. >> that doesn't undo the fact that every meaningful reformed movement in the west has been motivated by judeo christian world few... >> every movement.
8:12 am
>> meaningful reform movement. >> yes. >> throughout the world. >> i said in the we were world. has judeo christian world few with abolitionism and throe. >> how about gay marriage. >> i don't consider that to be a legitimate civil right. >> there we go. >> evangelical christians - of course they are going to get on bard with something like that, because it's counter to what they believe marriage, defined a particular way from millennia, dan, is. so christians have been driving known. >> pause it here, you don't right. >> i do not belief in - i don't believe in gay marriage. do i believe someone can have the right. they can choose to have any union they like. do i believe, however, that that is a moral rite? as an evangelical christian, i'm
8:13 am
not of the view that homosexuality is right in the eyes of god. so, no. position. >> yes. transportation... >> absolutely -- the evidence, daniel dennett... >> absolutely. people. >> absolutely. it shows for hundreds of years people have been kicking and screaming by secular movements. >> that is not so. it is out of a christian world view that your science is born. it's out of a christian world view that the government is born or ethics or morality. >> wouldn't aristotle, plato or that. >> they may well. >> you don't think a judeo christian world view is fundamental to western culture.
8:14 am
>> historically it played an important role. i'll give you this much. religion served as a nurse crop. stability. >> i'll take a break now. coming up, we ask if islam does more harm than the other religions do. stay with us. >> people can point to verses in the koran, these verses are the reason we i.s.i.s. >> are they reading text. >> maybe it's because there was an iraq. >> later on. >> there are some extremist right wing jews calling for websites. i go on websites and stand up against them. >> if i go on to a radical website. i'll get on a watch list. >> and in the
8:15 am
third rail we find what it's like to be a refugee at sea. >> authorities didn't want us to spam to them. >> libya is easy, they have no problem killing people, that's why all of us came here. >> trafficked labor on the front lines? >> they're things, they're commodities... >> we go undercover... >> it isn't easy to talk at this base >> what's happing on u.s. bases? >> the tax payer directly pays the human trafficker >> fault lines al jazeera america's hard hitting... >> today they will be arrested... >> ground breaking... they're firing canisters of gas at us... emmy award winning investigative series... fault lines america's war workers only on al jazeera america
8:16 am
8:17 am
re here to fully get into the nuances of everything that's going on not just in this country but around the world. >> ...as if there were no cameras here, would be the best solution. >> this goes to the heart of the argument >> to tell you the stories that others won't cover. how big do you see this getting? getting the news from the people who are affected. >> people need to demand reform... >> we're here to provide the analysis... the context... and the reporting that allows you to make sense of your world. >> ali velshi on target only on al jazeera america religion. >> it's built on prejudice, injustice and inhumanity. >> when you watch the room, it's not christian terrorists.
8:18 am
>> al qaeda, boko haram, hezbollah, hamas. >> all in name of religion, you put it in the name of our religion. the western press puts it in the name of our religion. >> islam does not just avoid violence, but lays a foundation for a profound societal peace. welcome back. let's bring in imam zaid shakir founder of zaytuna college. the first liberal arts college in the united states. thank you for joining us. is violence in the name of religion more prevalent in islam in this day and age. >> depends how you define islam. people that fly a plane into a building can claim they are muslim and do it in the name of islam. i recall in the introof this
8:19 am
programme mentioning that islam encourages suicide bombing. suicide and murder, the cause in the consequence of the suicide bombing, the suicide and the murder are vehemently forbidden in islam. people can perceive on the one hand or claim on the other hand that their motive or islam particularly, but we need to step back and analyse the true motivations. humans are motivated in any action by a complicated formula. in many instances religion might be part of that value. >> for al-qaeda ore i.s.i.l., it's a main value, they are religious. >> they claim to be reliageo, i would say they are more ido
8:20 am
logs, and the claims to religion are a religion that doesn't accommodate for the religion, including islam, that they have promoted, such as patiently and dignity enduring oppression. working through common shared values, such as the sanctity of innocent life, to solve your problems in ways that are governed by certain parameters. >> like christianity has a bloody history, islam has, it's not just a 21st history. >> i would say it's not true. inquisition. >> i would be delighted to go through all of these, the spanish inquisition is not christian. in much that i here violence being done in the name of islam
8:21 am
is not consistent, as i understand him with truize lambic teaching. jesus christ -- true islamic teaching. jesus christ teaching was against violence. >> you guys are not in agreement. >> i say if i reach across the table and hit you and say i'm a christian, it's not done in jesus christ's name. >> you can look at actions, we say religion plays a part. islam plays a part. people can point to verses in the koran. that's the reason we have i.s.i.s. the verses were in the koran throughout the 20th century, modern history, it doesn't prevent muslims, christians, jews in various places from living together. >> i.s.i.l. is reading their text too closely. >> maybe it's because there was an invasion, an occupation of the iraq that tore apart the
8:22 am
social fabric of that county, and in the ensuing hell, something hellic like i.s.i.s. emerged. i'm not saying u.s. performed policy alone, but i'm saying these things don't occur in a vacuum. you can't say i.s.i.s., all of a sudden they woke up and discovered the violent versus in out. >> bear with me for a second. a couple of days ago another secular blogger was hacked to death in blank, there was no -- policy. >> i don't think there's a sane muslim that would endorse or prove it. islam. >> a lot of things are done in the name of muslim. like i said, i don't think a sane muslim on this planet would encourage, endorse or approve that action. >> to me it seems the main problem with religion can be simply illustrated.
8:23 am
if larry here decided i'd convinced him and he announced he was no longer a christian, he'd break hearts in his family, but he wouldn't fear for his life. on the other hand, if you, as an imam said "i lost my faith, i'm no longer a muslim", you would not. >> i don't think i would be in any more danger. >> really. >> tomorrow if i did that than i was yesterday. >> it's interesting that muslims around the world are afraid .... >> can a muslim change his religion. >> i'm not a muslim around the world, i'm a muslim in the united states of america, and you are talking to me here in the united states of america. putting the situation in context is important. i can do it in malaysia, turkey, i could probably do it in most
8:24 am
places, not all places and... ..a lot of times they are sensationalized individual case, and are role. >> there are countries where apostizeies are punishable by death. size. >> how often would they if they didn't know they'd be killed? >> it's well known. these are usually highly sensational cases. >> i want to ask you about the context. we see in a place like myanmar, the country coming out. and we see people who are considered the most peaceful on earth. buddhist monks, attacking a minority who happen to be a muslim. doesn't it suggest that they are on to something. if they put the right kind of raw materials materials in there, the issues, and stir it
8:25 am
around, you can extract violence out of anyone, even the buddhist system. >> i suppose there are conditions when almost anyone could be made intoxicated enough by something, so they commit acts of violence, it's just that religion has a monopoly. >> it has an monopoly, if anything an atheist does can be attributed to religion, if that's the way we approach things, yes. religion has a monopoly. when it is rely imious, because we want to protect the good name and image ofated yix. -- image of aith yix. >> in 2050, looking ahead, there's a pew poll saying that muslims will be equal to christians in terms of numbers globally. they may be slightly more, if the plummeting rates of
8:26 am
christians leaving the religion conditions. -- continues. how does it make you feel? >> i don't have a response. bad. i'm not particularly alarmed by the data as it relates to this. in many instances, islam is growing at the points of a gun. >> where? >> well, i think i.s.i.l. is making is great men converts in this way. i don't think this is a manner in which christianity is it spread. so i'm not particularly concerned. again you are forgetting about the crusades. >> i'm not sure what your point is about the crusades. >> the spread of christianity, domination of lands. >> i suggest it's the hijacking of religion. >> sanctioned by the highest authorities at the time. >> in what way, shape or form was it christian, or consistent
8:27 am
with the teaching of christ? not at all. >> let me give larry encouragement. for every one person i.s.i.s. might force into islam at the point of a gun, it chases 40, 50 or 100 muslims out of islam because of a repugnant approach to life. >> i'm delighted to hear that. >> i think you are right about that, and i think the pugh study extrapolates into the future. and i am sure that they are making one big mistake. the new transparency in the world means that muslims all over the world, they are raising muslim children, but they are not going to raise the muslim children the way they've been raised in the past. themselves. >> that sounds almost like a fate-based hope that you have. >> no, we are seeing it everywhere. >> i have to wrap. we have run out of time. i have to wrap. thank you.
8:28 am
and a handshake out of it as well. thank you so much gentlemen. executive director of the christian based fixed point foundation. daniel dennett co-director for zaytuna college, zaid shakir. larry alex taunton from fixed point foundation. thank you all. "third rail" panel is next. >> he managed to succeed and alienate every country. no one likes the middle east except the iranians. >> they don't like each other.
8:29 am
8:30 am
8:31 am
8:32 am
8:33 am
8:34 am
8:35 am
8:36 am
... married a woman who is a christian. i don't believe most believe he's not christian, this is where the game comes in. you can distract voters. >> moving on the foiled attack in garland texas featured two
8:37 am
muslims encouraged by i.s.i.l. over social media, leaving many to wonder if the government is doing enough to stop i.s.i.l.'s online propaganda. >> i.s.i.l. claims to gain influence in the united states. >> high quality videos use of magazines and it's used to target those online. >> thousands of home grown terrorists recruited over the internet. the gunmen atacted a member of i.s.i.s. and al-shabab. it raises questions assist to what can be done here at home. >> faisal patel should the government put a stop to this to stop i.s.i.l.'s propaganda. >> there's a couple of things one can talk about. >> go to twitter, tell them to
8:38 am
shut things down. that's what people mean when they say that. anyone who you talk to who deals with the technologies and social media tells you the minute you take one off, there's another. >> waca moll. >>. >> exactly. it's not a useful way for the government to spend their time. they don't talk about it. there are complaint mechanisms available for facebook youtube and twitter. hundreds of guys are inspired by this online like garland, perhaps they were unsuccessful
8:39 am
what if someone is inspired and blows something up. i have no doubt there are some people - free speech is not free we have to get on private sector. folks who feel croppingly and hate the need of terrorism. muslims have to be on the website. i do that i go on websites and debate them. >> here is the difference if i go on i'll be on a watch list.
8:40 am
geller is on a watch list. >> i don't know about geller, i know i'll get on a watch list. >> you mean an american watch list. >> yes. >> not if you go on as an men american anti-person. >> that we can change. if we made sure you never cotton a watch list, would you go on the islamic website and would you make the argument against i.s.i.s. and irrelevant religious... i'm ipp effect mfiin messaging against i.s.i.s., and so are many muslims in the country. the idea that we are suddenly going to empower moderate muslims, when you don't know what the websites are, they don't know what to say in response to those people. . >> we have to teach them. >> we are finding it on twitter feeds. >> how is it twitter mainstream.
8:41 am
>> it's an interesting point you made, alan dershowitz, you mentioned pamela get geller, she should have freedom of speech. to do what she wants to do. >> that's not a close question, whether we support what she says is a different issue. >> you got stick for using her name and mlk's name. that was in the same sentence. >> i said it deliberately. i don't make a moral comparison between her and martin luther king, but martin luther king chose cities that he knew his march holding hands with a white woman or man would provoke reactions. he wanted to provoke reactions. >> it provoke's people to blow things up. >> it stops the people blowing them up, not from provoking. >> let me add two things, if i can. one, the professor is right. we have to be diligent and vigilant about what we need to
8:42 am
do as americans. it is not lost to me that one of these persons were on the watch list back in 2006. and the fact this they lost touch with this person from 2006 until now, underscores a failure of u.s. intelligence, people not doing their work. it's a simple point that needs to be made. >> it's interesting to me, about how we love hypocrites. i think he's right about this . we were not having - i remember this distinctly. we were not having the conversation about whether or not the government ought to shut et cetera et cetera when columbine happened. down twitter accounts. i can give you a number of other examples. >> social media. >> social media was not around, some guys were online, facebook, saying what they would do. we were not having the conversation. when it come again to islam, muslims, we want to have a conversation about how far the government ought to go, but it was not existent a few years ago.
8:43 am
. >> it's a strong point. federal agents said social media would make it tougher to track i.s.i.l. internet traffic can be useful. it's an interesting story. we don't know if it was true or not. some years ago there was a website. saying how many people can you kill in the holocaust. it appeals to the neo-nazis. many civil rights organizations say it's terrible. according to the story, it was put out by the mossad, bringing them in, destroying their record. you never know if it's a good thing. it's both good and bad, like religion. intelligence is like religion in that way. let's shift to international relations, is america risking partnerships with key allies over a deal with iran. tensions led to diplomatic repercussions. >> the new king of saudi arabia a no show at president obama... >> summit of gulf state
8:44 am
leaders... >> president obama calls a meeting to address concerns with neighbour iran. >> some see it as a key message of an ally upset with president obama's policies. >> binyamin netanyahu upset about what he hearse about a nuclear deal with iran. >> is it worth burning relationships in the middle east with allies over a deal with iran alan dershowitz, do you think president obama is destroying existing relationships by this potential deal? >> yes, i think it's the worst foreign policy blunder. what he is doing is endangering strong alliances in the middle east, the saudis, emirates, jordan, egypt, israel on a speculation, a bet, that may be he can bring iran in from the cold. the likely result is nuclear proliferation, all the saudi arabia counties getting nuclear weapons, more guns, weapons,
8:45 am
planes in the middle east and more risk, and for what. the answer is there's no alternative. if he doesn't take the deal sanctions will fail. he's right, he put us in that position. it's not the choice we have now, but how we got to that choice. it shows the major blunder that the obama administration has caused. >> he's talking to them. this is how it happens. >> that's what happened when chamberlain talked to the nazis. >> that's godwin's law invoking the nazis. >> you invoke history or look at history, you look at north korea, if you don't want to look that far back or pakistan. >> you are worried about proliferation and violence. you wrote a book justifying israel, the fourth largest military in the world. nuclear armed, justifying their killing of 1,500 civilians, you wrote a book justifying that.
8:46 am
>> no, i didn't justify killings of civilians but acts of defense taken by the israelis against people. hamas that want to see civilians die. they have a dead baby strategy, they talk about it, putting the civilians in harm's way. giving israel the choice. on not firing and putting others in danger or firing and killing multiple civilians, that's what i justify israel's reaction. >> you know where alan dershowitz stands on this. >> we could have another debate about this. about whether he's right or wrong. there could be a conversation about... >> is president obama hurting the alliances about a potential deal with iran. . >> the professor raised the name of king once said it's either nonviolent co-existence or violent co-annihilation. i come down on the side of diplomacy. a famous quote - who do you make peace with other than your enemies. you have to talk to the people. >> i agree. >> and figure out a way to solve the crisis.
8:47 am
. >> now, the middle east, richard hart has a peace, the error of disorder. he wrote that the other day. and i love that phrase. in the middle east we are lying -- living in an era of disorder. every decision we make will offend someone. there's no easy answer. >> to alan dershowitz point, every deal iran wants we want, maybe a bit more, is he right. >> he nation sa god point. diplomacy, whether we talk about and saudi arabia beheading people for witchcraft and sourcy, saying any deal iran wants, we want. and maybe a bit more. >> i hear the points. i'm saying that diplomacy, whether we talk about iran or saudi arabia has to be the answer and any any decision it ought not to stop us. ought not o allow us to abrogate our responsibility.
8:48 am
>> he managed to succeed in alienating every country in the middle east. the palestinians don't like him. egyptians don't like him. the jordanians don't like him. nobody likes him in the middle east. (all talking at once). that's except the iranians. >> they don't like each other. >> they like france better, they are getting in there now. >> there's an age of disorder. you have to accept an age of disorder. you have had a volatile region. authoritarian regimes don't go easy. the countries have not built demicratic institutions, so the idea that we flip a switch and it will be spring time is naive. it's obvious some of the united states allies disagree that this is a good deal. does that mean that we are not going to talk to egypt? are we not going to talk to israel. >> of course we will. >> will we not be friends with the saudis? >> of course not.
8:49 am
we have strategic interests with the countries that we'll work with. >> the unspoken truth, we have to admit this, not on camera is u.s. foreign policy is schizophrenic. and they shift like the wind. on a given year with a given administration, alliances and relationships shift we have to wrap. thank you so much. thank the panel. travis smiley, faiza patel, and alan dershowitz. straight ahead - would be refugees forced to plunge into the sea, desperate for rescue from a sinking ship. i talk to a reporter that had their stories in our field note segment coming up. >> you realise the long journey that the people make and how difficult. and we see them disembarking. a powerful moment for the whole team.
8:50 am
8:51 am
>> it has been called a colossal humanitarian it has been called a colossal humanitarian catastrophe by the mayor of catania sicily. more than 60,000 migrants made the straight journey across the mediterranean sea, from north africa to europe. more than 1800 perished. each week "third rail" will catch up with an al jazeera correspondent from wherever they
8:52 am
may be to get the story behind the story, to share their experience that you rarely get to hear. stephanie dekker has been in the mediterrainean reporting on the migrant crisis. you have seen thousands of migrants come into europe, hundreds losing their lives along the way, what stood out for you the most, given the death, all this pain that you have seen? >> i think it's the determination of the people. they all will tell you they'd do it again, and the situation on the other side in libya is terrible, and it's a huge amount of people. when i arrived i came off the plane at midnight. there was a flow of people. during the next couple of days we heard rescue after rescue after rescue. they come to land. that is great news, but what happens to them when they get here. we followed up on those stories.
8:53 am
it's difficult. as journalists, we are unbiased. we need to be straight and report the facts and numbers. then you talk to individuals. you learn their names and stories. they are seeking asylum, those that decided to stay here. there's young men here, 18, 19. early 20, and they want better life, better opportunity, that you and i have had. that so many have had. who is to judge why a man or woman is not able to get a better education. they are trying to provide for their families, that many other people had. >> you got a chance to interview some migrants the survivors of a harrowing rescue at sea. let's play an excerpt of that report. interview a family who had a harrowing rescue at sea.let's listen. >> the dinghy is taking in water, people are panicking. many can't swim. it's hard to confirm how many
8:54 am
died and how many bodies were recovered. what some here tell us is as many as 40 people could have lost their lives in the panic. even now safely in port they tell us they all came from libya. >> translator: libya isn't easy, they have no problem killing people. they have no law there. that's why we have come here. even though we don't know what will happen, at least there are laws. >> those who had died had died before the rescue operation had actually occurred. was that a different story to what you had heard from the migrants themselves? >> reporter: that's right. we got there having heard that story having spoken to an aid worker having spoken to them. then once we managed to talk to a couple of them, it's not easy to get access to the migrants, authorities don't want you to speak to them, but we managed, we heard the story that people were rescued, fell out of the boat, one man was telling us how
8:55 am
a rope came down, they grabbed that rope, the rope was supposed to tie to the boat, they pulled on it, it was an absolutely horrible story. the interesting line, we went back to the hotel, i sent it for script approval and i got a story from the news bureau, and there was this horrible rescue video, i said hold on a second this is exactly what the man was telling us, the man was telling us the latter that came down the rope that came down. they we saw his words came to life through the picture absolutely horrendous. even a rescue can cause death. the question was that merchant ship massive ship are they actually equipped to rescue people. >> at the
8:56 am
stefanie, you have covered other places in north africa when you are across the mediterranean in a place like sicily, and you are talking to these survivors, does it feel like you're covering the same story from the other side now? >> yeah, it's interesting you asked me that. because one of the first stories i covered when i got here, 900 migrants, it was a tugboat, they came in at night and the back of the boat was open. we saw these silhouettes of hundreds and hundreds of people they were standing still as they came into port, it was dead silent, it was incredibly powerful for team. as the sun was up there was a family towards the end of the boat and i heard them speaking arabic, i have pigeon arabic. i was talking to one of the girls asking her where are you from. one of the men approached me
8:57 am
again the authorities don't want you to speak. he said to me we're from yarmouk camp in syria. i felt that emotionally, i had covered one of the most recent problems there. this is a palestinian camp that has gone through an absolutely horrendous situation for the last few years. i looked at him and said yarmouk, i said welcome. all of a sudden you realized the incredibly long journey these folks make, how difficult, i see them disembark in sicily, the sea was quiet, just that whole back-story, it does bring home the challenges, the dangers, the determination these people have, to try and get out and look for something different. so yes, that was -- i felt that emotionally, certainly having covered that side and having seen one family from there disembark here in italy. >> like a trickle displacement of these people. stefanie dekker, thanks for
8:58 am
joining us. that does it for this show. the conversation continues on our website, aljazeera.com/thirdrail. i'm imran garda, good night.
8:59 am
9:00 am
announcer: this is al jazeera. welcome to the newshour fighting back against i.s.i.l. in ramada. iran deploys shia militia, and the coalition launches air strikes. myanmar signs off a population law that the u.s. says could fan the flames of intolerance social revolution in ireland, the first country in the world to approve same-sex marriage through a

14 Views

info Stream Only

Uploaded by TV Archive on