Skip to main content

tv   Inside Story 2017 Ep 325  Al Jazeera  November 23, 2017 10:32am-11:01am +03

10:32 am
follows pressure from the u.s. and the u.n. ports were closed two weeks ago after hooty rebels fired a missile at the saudi capital riyadh we are monitoring these developments and we're trying to see whether that actually takes place on the ground of course if that were to happen that would be a very welcome and critically important development we've made clear the tremendous amount of needs on the ground we're ready to help if the ports are open so we'll keep tracking this and and see where we go from there the united nations says that syrians have a siege suburb of the capital damascus or so hungry that they're scavenging from litter bins government forces and their allies have cut off the rebel held district of eastern for five years days of relentless airstrikes bombarded the opposition stronghold the world food program says the situation could worsen for around one hundred seventy five thousand people when food stocks run out in the coming weeks
10:33 am
syrian opposition groups meeting in the saudi capital have renewed that amount for the removal of president bashar al assad in a draft resolution the communique states that a governing body could include members of the government those are the headlines i'll be back with more news right after my inside story next. young rich and famous in china one of the news goes behind the great chinese firewall to meet the cyber celebs of a booming multibillion dollar business. but this time on al-jazeera. hopes running high in zimbabwe following robert mugabe's resignation as this african country enters a new era we ask what difference will a new leadership make this is inside story.
10:34 am
hello welcome to the program i'm adrian finnegan robert mugabe has been in charge of zimbabwe ever since the country was born thirty seven years ago the african nationalist helped lead the rebellion against british colonial rule of what was then rhodesia and he was a political prisoner during white minority rule in the one nine hundred seventy s. and eighty's after independence was achieved the prime minister then president implemented social and economic policies for better or worse critics say he's been a brutal dictator who rose to power when the country was known as the jewel and breadbasket of africa and he's left it in economic ruins his resignation provoked mass celebrations the world's oldest head of state finally accepting that it was time to go as m.p.'s debated his impeachment the historic events for all zimbabweans began with a military takeover just over
10:35 am
a week ago was in barbarians who are celebrating say it's the end of an era paul brennan looks back on the life of the veteran leader there who never made. yet. there will always be people. in control that was two thousand and seven. ten years later when the people let their views be known opiate encouraged by zimbabwe's military robert mugabe ignored them and then surprise them when he didn't announce his resignation by now widely predicted t.v. address i thank you. and good night after thirty seven years in control mcgarvie found it hard to let go he's made a career by deftly apa new for potential rivals. one of the first to be sidelined was joshua como a fellow liberation fighter and comer was leader of the zap to party with gabby merge them with his zanu p.f. party their alliance was uneasy and comer was relegated to the figurehead role of
10:36 am
vice president. at the turn of the century the gobby started seizing farms owned by whites to apiece supporters angry at the slow pace of land reform the economy shrank by a third unemployment soared about eighty percent. out of this economic turmoil another rival emerged we must have given it is sounding defeat morgan chander i formed the movement for democratic change he became popular enough to risk defeating mugabe in a presidential election runoff in two thousand and eight. i was beaten up frequently arrested and intimidated dozens of his supporters were killed allegedly by zanu p.f. thugs and the m.d.c. leader withdrew from the election worried about the stability of its neighbor south africa forced both men into a coalition chuang or i became prime minister but mcgarvey retain control of the
10:37 am
police army and secret service and with that the real power of god he won the election four years ago by a landslide supporters said voter registration lists were manipulated critics said mccarthy was just as ruthless at dealing with rivals in his own party war veteran and vice president joyce maturity was fired in two thousand and fourteen accused of corruption and plotting to assassinate the gobby this time a gabby's wife grace was seen as instrumental in engineering mature its downfall it was the clearest signal yet the mcgarvie was now not only protecting his own position but also laying the path for his wife to succeed him the sacking of emerson made that obvious the vice president nicknamed the crocodile had been in pole position to succeed mugabe. firing him cleared the way for his wife. to but this time the ninety three year old president had gone too far when i got to is close to the military leadership and they stepped in after thirty seven years
10:38 am
robert mugabe's days of exercising unchallenged power well over. the former vice president innocent man and god is due to be sworn in as mugabe's replacement on friday so who is eat well like mugabe he fought for independence from british colonial and then white minority rule and was by mcgarvey side in various leadership roles over the decades he was vice president until earlier this month as you just heard when we got sect him for what he called treachery but on god was supporters say he'll help boost zimbabwe's economy battered by years of sanctions they praise his push to reengage with potential investors worldwide after years of international isolation his critics describe him as fearsome and cruel and not for nothing is his nickname the crocodile they say and he has repeatedly denied overseeing the killing of thousands of civilians in southern suburb way in the one
10:39 am
nine hundred eighty s. well let's explore with our guests what the future holds for zimbabwe joining us from harare via skype is tina berry human rights advocate and former president of the law society of zimbabwe in london should a genuine war analyst on african affairs and author of how to win elections in africa and from reading like a schmidt associate professor of modern african history at the university of reading welcome to all of you. start with you can edison but i'm god what bring about the change that zimbabweans crave given that he's been a part of the system for thirty seven years one of the garbage is closest aides and one of the most powerful people with within zanu p.f. other celebrations that we've seen in harare across symbiote way somewhat premature the. momentum is in its favor. mainly young people do not care about the politics of the day. rooting for government
10:40 am
anything other than. he is not about unity that's momentum. and. give something back to these young people were originally going to move forward against. their part. their ways over his party. visions of his party and of course the enemy is. his most recent enemies that it doesn't add to the things that will work against him but he has a great opportunity if he makes that decision to move the country forward because the entire country is fully behind at least at this moment. in london what do you think are we likely to see any departure from the garbage era politics in the near future or will it be business as usual. p.s. . well first i have to differ. in zimbabwe who has
10:41 am
more coming to meet him on the ground but based on what we see and based on our experience with african democracies they with very little reason to have high hopes . and that doesn't mean that there is no potential for change for. an improvement in governments and the country but it doesn't mean that citizens cannot afford to cut him any slack. he has been a part of this ruling elite for many many years he is most possibly complicit in any of the feelings of the government he was a part of and so while he represents my mentor in the desperation of people so letting go of the mugabe history it's crucially important that everyone is on high alert. everyone quotes him no slack he has earned no slack and that i doubt that citizens deceived by the appearance of change but he is
10:42 am
a very useful start for people who are trying to reclaim their destiny by christmas in reading and i'm god said together we will ensure a peaceful transition to the consolidation of our democracy and bring a fresh start for all zimbabweans and foster peace and unity as i make my way back home i look forward together with you the people of zimbabwe to tackle the political and economic challenges facing our beloved country what do you make of those words will the euphoria that we've seen be short lived. well muslin is the kind of politician of the generation and involving. his personality is of the kind that i think it's very very likely he will want to create his own legacy he will want to become a leader who is setting himself apart from the guard or i do think these are more than just words i do think he's going to make an effort to bring about change but
10:43 am
it is very likely that it is going to be change that will build a legacy for him and what we saw yesterday that second point to consider when the speaker of the house read out the letter of resignation by robert mugabe we saw almost every member of parliament and every senator jumping up and celebrating but we must consider that sixty one percent of the members of parliament belong to the ruling party these are people who just over a week ago there were celebrating their great hero their great leader robert mugabe so even if. wants to build his own legacy he wants to bring about some change he is leading a party that has not made any effort shown any sign that they are taking responsibility for what has happened in the last thirty seven years everything is
10:44 am
put on the shoulders of one man robert gabriel mugabe. do you agree with that what extent is mugabe being made the scapegoat here the people around him complicit in crimes committed against the people of zimbabwe of the many years by focusing on the garbage they try to absolve themselves you think of responsibility for the past. i think. you need to. begin to feel that he had been coming. when you broke into wanted to. talk with him or going in with something they've never seen so she didn't produce strong element. in the politics and therefore that is indefensible i've got to give very generally people he took his wife's side of the united the forces. against mugabe in the picture. they blame him for everything but i think
10:45 am
we're seeing is that they used. this model with to be done after i'm back to back the people are different if you wait related because there is or there dana. was. painted in your eyes or that they had moved a little. do you agree with that. well yes i do agree obviously that. only guns of greece will go being kind of the tipping point for citizens. i do agree that the specter of a dynasty was deeply frightening to people i was slightly about the hint of the surgeon in terms of. well it was when this woman was going to do this and this came up again this might be significant in the bigger picture what i don't want to and you know i show the oil for young africans even though i'm a political analyst i'm also young africa we have
10:46 am
a collective us to ration of our continent for a new kind of leadership and so i share in that aspiration with zimbabweans and in that light i feel like the world is not a scapegoat he was the leader of this country for thirty seven years he was ultimately responsible for every failure in governance for a dysfunctional political in for a country to have been fairly on every significant good government index so there is no sense in my mind there is no ambiguity in my mind as to his level of culpability i worried that the narrative at the end of his. regime was one of a tired old man been manipulated by a woman well who created the circumstances that led to the man of pollution who manipulated a constitution intimidated your position and made it impossible for a competitive democracy to flourish in that country i think that as
10:47 am
a continent we will be doing ourselves no service no favors by cutting will go be any slight he is responsible for zimbabwe as it exists today michael what you make of only responsible. oh i fully agree that robert mugabe is responsible i also fully agree that grace mugabe did provide the tipping point and that she played a significant role in bringing about or causing the change that has occurred now but at the same time if you look at those involve his future then removing their head of a party. is just one step in the direction of democratization assess one step in the direction of change the point is that mugabe did not single handedly carry out a genocide in the early one nine hundred eighty s. in the south of the country he did not single handedly carry out the land reforms
10:48 am
did not sing a handedly silencers opposition or put state violence state sponsored violence into place around election time still force results he was aiming for so all these agents that were involved such as the police such as the army such as the party you're with but also the very understanding of what zanu p.f. the ruling party is how it functions the role of the central committee if that is not fundamentally questioned from within then i don't see how the party continuing to rule the country at least under the next elections how that can bring about fundamental change. you talked about what's needed now is this new generation of leaders to what extent will zimbabwe fail to reach its full potential until the old guard the veterans of independent struggle have. died out a and this new generation of leaders comes through. well first to declare.
10:49 am
their young people who are part of zanu p.f. they are young people who are i mean real young people below forty who are part of this political arrangement their youth wings in this fight is the hidden part of legitimizing this establishments and so by all the god i don't necessarily mean in terms of eight minutes of freshness of ideas i mean in terms of a flourishing of options i mean in terms of a new sense of what it is to be a political responsibility now if we have that if we have new players who are able to compete in a level playing field it gives a zanu p.f. my hopes for that a lot but until we have that until democracy is completed or on to the democracies. sustain themselves by the social permission of the voter constantly it is very difficult for leaders to modify behavior or to sustain
10:50 am
effectiveness or sustain responsibilities so in essence are we going to be able to find. the power for new voices whether young or old hopefully young but new voices who are able to provide a credible alternative who are able to give zanu p.f. a run for its money and who are able to shake off significant feats but then balance the power equation like we have in nigeria where they are true within parties or in guyana and when the simple know that they are at the mercy of the voter that creates an incentive for proper behavior so will we be able to find this fresh voices who are going to create it surely competitive environment things within the same unless true political competition begins to exist from twenty or i believe let us ask you know what will tito will be able to find those powerful new
10:51 am
credible alternative voices will the opposition step up and mounted a credible challenge to p.f. will zanu p.f. is it capable of changing from within. i think i was going to just try and paint a picture of the sort of challenges that illuminate well meaning lead that have to confront and i hope it can answer the question you asked first and foremost the challenge that impunity and violence we have a ruling party that is totally candid and structuralism democratic is a very intolerant of opposition or of different views even among themselves so that often the result of the violently it is it is supported by instead of them including the security forces and divisive when a tip or type of democrats and refuses any form of power sharing so the first test
10:52 am
is from that character can they be formed from within and become a more democratic private given among themselves and they manage conflict differently and be able to take never in the playing field the second challenge is with a point three and laws that centralized and concentrate power in the end of just one person the president of the bobbins the most powerful person who can't easily sponsible for appointment of key persons institutions including medical boards and so as a result we may have a constitution that list and celebrates human rights and political rights of people but do we have a practice we have laws that had in place if and we have had today an institution that struggle not to support one institution the national broadcaster for instance it exists primarily to serve the interests of those that are in power so that they didn't need before but interesting that it is then they have passed along that they have been shelved under the carpet for
10:53 am
a long time the massacre as it might have been in the subsequent killings during a number of the elections in our country there are people were hurting people who are hoping that if you will be better justice competition guarantees. one of the ports in the specter of what went wrong and of course. then in the center of my opponent is a vampire and i think what action most of the function the top level with people is never what it is in their lives in terms of working and we have never had a day jobs. in our country individual young men and women of want to school and we have been denied an opportunity then lastly we just did the damage to one of this no confidence in our economy and it can be sort of organized in that without good governance in the framework for the solution of business confidence even zimbabweans themselves will not planned across their drive to keep their money because they will be afraid that they might lose the open so this is the best
10:54 am
ground in the how one talk or the challenges we don't be going on what we live by. really quickly is going to be the ultimate step to forming an architect because they're used to being in power they believe that in general to be in power even the army and the police believe they should we design. how to disentangle that is to remain friends with the past in popular with this is ok. but i got was been accused of being the chief architect of method being that massacre in the one nine hundred eighty s. given that is he the man to oversee a process of national healing and reconciliation. well he is india's not he is in the sense that the way the political change occurred within the last seven days it is apparently inevitable that he takes over
10:55 am
as president for the time being. the question is are there going to be free and fair elections next year is he going to stick to that road map to use this term. that there are going to be elections are going to be election. election observers going to be allowed in the country that is going to be of crucial importance he himself is certainly not the kind of leader who would bring about the necessary change that zimbabwe needs to see but to be in place for very limited time period that seems to be what both. the leader of the m.d.c. opposition party and the ruling party have now agreed on and it's not something that can easily be changed but the challenges are tremendous as. my fellow zimbabweans just said and. i think the hope that we can see in zimbabwe it's a very very un country the average age is twenty and majority of zimbabweans were
10:56 am
born after the liberation war and even though there are reasons why it's taken thirty seven years to bring about regime change at the same time there is the whole as was said just now that there are sufficient there is sufficient strength among the young population will bring about a strong opposition with a strong voice on the program to bring about economic social and political change. just want to ask you a very quick question a final question how do you think. long term leaders in southern africa will have viewed events in zimbabwe this week. well that's one of the most interesting thing the thing that i don't know if it's fortunate in fortune is the biggest win of the downfall of my dad is the mayor and the numbers of cetacean leaders workweek in india boots now and i think it will have an effect it will at
10:57 am
the very least in bold in civil to say to actors in several countries to begin to build a quote that are necessary to pull down dictators like i want to see dictators a human being and the history of human progress shows us that no matter how powerful a human being is it will take other human beings to pull down a powerful human being and that's the message that the rest of africa will be learning from the downfall of the inevitable no doubt in their afraid we're going to have to leave it thank you to all tear beret and woke up and that hiker schmidt thank you as always for watching don't forget you can see the program at any time just by visiting our website at al-jazeera dot com for further discussion join us at our facebook page at facebook dot com forward slash a.j. inside story you can also join the conversation on twitter our handle at a.j. inside story this of course historic over to zimbabwe's history we live it out with images of robert mugabe over his thirty seven years of leadership for me adrian
10:58 am
figure the whole team here in doha thanks for watching we'll see you again by phone . i am taking historic steps to lift the restrictions on american energy without regulation the profit tax policy on health. and the environment was a surprise to get action. on that side in the habit of the. protection of going to take a decade or two to four lines down and the cost of the. toxic war
10:59 am
at this time on al-jazeera the sams in archaeology graduate from iraq is also a part time guided billings pergamon museum which includes a reconstruction of the famous ishtar gate in babylon most of the people he's showing around came to germany as refugees this is just one of several berlin museums taking part in the project called multicultural meeting point and as well as bringing people together one of its aims is to emphasize the contribution of migrants right up to the present day to western culture office in language here building because i've been here for some time i can help them with lots of things that moves us forward to me the great thing is it's not just about museums about forming a new life here part of life it's culture ahead of the september twenty fourth national election survey showed germans a satisfied with the state of their economy this is easily estonia's biggest tech success story the company was bought by microsoft in two thousand and eleven we
11:00 am
bring you the stories that are shaping the economic world we live in counting the cost at this time on al-jazeera short films of hope. and inspiration. a series of short personal stories that highlight the human triumph against the odds. al-jazeera selects at this time. some of the asylum.


info Stream Only

Uploaded by TV Archive on