Skip to main content

tv   Piers Morgan Tonight  CNN  December 7, 2012 6:00pm-7:00pm PST

6:00 pm
>> red flag. >> she's exquisite but she also lived in vegas for 11 years. >> red flag. >> she's funny but not funny like ha-ha. funny like yikes. >> red flag. >> i've said it before, i will say it again. she is a genius. look, i generally shy away from telling fast food restaurants how to run their perfume business. as a principle, as a rule. but pizza hut canada, come on, get your act together. get a celebrity, throw together some commercials and let's get this in the stores as soon as possible because i got some christmas shopping to do. that does it for us. see you again one hour from now, another edition of "360" 10:00 p.m. eastern. "piers morgan tonight" starts right now. tonight, could you live on just $30 a week for food? mayor cory booker is trying to do just that. >> getting this cup of coffee at
6:01 pm
starbucks will wipe out your entire allowance for a day. >> suffering caffeine withdrawal and hunger pains, he joins me. plus tragedy after the prank call to kate middleton. battleground america. >> i'm encouraged that i think we have turned the corner. >> good new job numbers but same old ways in washington. is it too late to save you from paying higher taxes? i'll ask my all-star panel. and she's a fine girl. my old friend brandi back in the spotlight and speaking from the heart about her mentor, whitney houston. >> i felt like i wasn't there enough for her at the end of her life. >> this is "piers morgan tonight." good evening. we begin tonight with our big story, the reality from an estimated 46 million americans. simply put, they can't afford to eat. they live on food stamps. these are men, women and children in america. hunger is not just a third world problem. it's a massive problem right
6:02 pm
here in the united states right now. cory booker is determined to tackle it. the newark mayor is doing some pretty extraordinary this week, living off food stamps himself, just food stamps. he has just $29 and change for seven days' worth of food. this is what he bought. life-changing experience for him, what he sees as a wake-up call in all of america. he hasn't talked to anyone on camera after starting this but that changes tonight. joining me for an exclusive interview is mayor cory booker. welcome to you. why did do you this? >> you know, it actually started by a late night conversation over twitter with a woman who was pooh-poohing government's role in provision nutrition for kids. i shot back at her, we had a couple exchanges and finally i said why don't we both live on food stamps. i went to bed not thinking much of it and got up the next morning and it had spread through the social media world, and was a bigger story. i called my staff and said we're doing this. >> you were on day four of this. this is the exact pile of food that you got. >> yes. >> what is interesting to me, you spent $29.78 on this, but
6:03 pm
when we tried to match it around here, in new york, we had to spend $57.37. >> right. >> implying that the government rate, if you like, for this food is clearly based right at the lowest possible level and may not be even possible for many people onn efood stamps. >> that's what we want to highlight. you have people who live in nutrition and food deserts who don't have access to fresh, healthy foods. i'm very lucky, i live a mile away so i walked to the superintendent. many people can't get in their car and go to the supermarket. we're trying to see not just what the challenges are living on this amount of money, but also showing the other problems we have that cause food insecurity in the united states of america, that cause obesity, that contribute to our health care costs. there are so many things about food systems that are broken in america and one of them is people having access to healthy, affordable food. >> in 2011, the average monthly food stamp benefit was $133.26
6:04 pm
per person in new jersey, which works out a little more than $33 a week. so just slightly above what you bought for yourself. it's day four of the challenge and this is the s.n.a.p. challenge, supplemental nutrition assistance program, that is the food stamp program. how are you feeling? how are you finding it? >> you know, it's a little more difficult than i imagined and i thought i would be good on eating on a tight budget so i started out not really martialing my food well so i'm cutting back now. the biggest thing for me, people have to understand, going out and getting this cup of coffee at starbucks will wipe out your entire allowance for a day and as a guy who is admittedly caffeine addicted as i now am going through a bit of withdrawal, that's one of the bigger challenges i'm facing right now. >> having no caffeine at all. >> no, because i can't afford it on a budget. >> you're a vegetarian, hence the fact that all this is non-meat product. i would imagine that if you are not a vegetarian, it's probably
6:05 pm
more expensive. >> but let's go even worse than this. i'm an adult, a male vegetarian. so imagine now being a family and teenagers. when i was a teenager, i ate my mom and dad out of house and home. so over 40% of s.n.a.p. family recipients have kids at home and are beneficiaries. 20% of the s.n.a.p. recipients have disabled folks at home, almost 10% are elderly. so this is one thing for the challenges for me and me right now complaining about a headache and caffeine withdrawal, i'm off this in a week. but these are families that are struggling with this. that's been the voices that have been most compelling to me of the people who have been posting on twitter, these incredible videos -- >> i have been following. it's been fascinating. let's watch a little clip from some of the footage of you on this challenge. >> tough choice i have to live with this week is that i used my money to buy a lot of different things but not caffeine, and so i'm going to be going this week without coffee, without diet pepsi, diet coke.
6:06 pm
worried about my food supplies which are actually dwindling down. i'm going to have to figure out a way to ration a little bit better and go perhaps with smaller meals. >> the majority of people i have seen on twitter are supporting what you're doing. they like the way you're highlighting this. some people are criticizing you. cnn's christine romans said this on wednesday. just have a look and react to this. >> to live on s.n.a.p., which is supplemental nutrition assistance program, it's not meant to be your only calorie intake source. supplemental is the key. if the government designs it so this is on top of what little money you might have, food pantries, soup kitchens, if you're going to survive on it, what we have to discuss as a country are taxpayers going to pay for every calorie somebody consumes, are we going to completely support people, 46 million people are getting food stamps. >> your reaction? >> first of all, i hope people are sniping, i hope there's dialogue and attention on this of the kind that it seems our
6:07 pm
media is fascinated with the pregnancy of a princess. why aren't we talking about issues of poverty, about issues of working families who are working full-time jobs and still can't make ends meet. so i'm happy that the discussion and the conversation is going on at a degree we never imagined when it started but i also want to let people know that the reality is the reality. there are many families, and i talked to a group of security guard workers yesterday who make $7 and change, don't have health care benefits, so if they get sick, they have to either take days off of work and lose that money or work through the sickness, who don't have retirement benefits, who find it hard at the end of a month to pay their rent, to buy their food, and are struggling. these are full-time people that are working. so she may think it's a supplemental program but for many americans who are working even, this is the difference between going deep into food insecurity, not being able to provide for their families and having a bridge to stability. so i just right now, what bothers me and concerns me is on
6:08 pm
two levels, the local level and the national level. national level right now in congress, this is where i give senator stabenow and also our president, who are trying to protect the s.n.a.p. programs and a house bill that savagely is cutting this. >> $16 billion. >> $16 billion. right. here you have veterans, families, over a million veterans, people who are depending on this program. you have military families, thousands of them depending on this program. you have kids because but for programs like this, they would be going to school nutritionally unfit to learn. the point about the economy, this is the short-sighted thinking so many people have about government expenditures, there is absolutely government waste, fraud, abuse, but when it comes to programs like this, you actually get a long-term and immediate benefit from that expenditure of taxpayer dollars. >> nobody can tell me this is a wasteful amount of food for an american. >> if i was on food stamps or s.n.a.p. program and i used my money, that dollar that i spend on my food actually comes --
6:09 pm
recycles through the economy and produces $1.70 or more of a benefit to our gdp because you know what, people produce this food. the truckers depend on that. the store owners. it actually creates jobs in communities have millions of dollars of money that people are expending. >> what do you think about this, though, because there's another staggering statistic that 40% of all food supply in america each year is thrown away, discarded by americans, which works out to equivalent of $2,275 annually in food. it's a staggering amount of food tossed away. there is a real disconnect here. >> we have broken food systems in america. that's why the movement of food justice which is gaining steam about creating sustainable food systems at the local level, where one, we have programs in newark that reclaim food that would otherwise be thrown away from everything from businesses to arenas to get it back into the food system. finding ways to get grocers a little corner bodega to have
6:10 pm
fresh and health y foods, getting farmers' markets and farm stands and urban gardens to exist, number one, in urban communities but also to accept s.n.a.p. benefits there. are so many things we could be doing on a local level to stop food waste, to address food systems, to address food deserts but we need the activism, we need attention on this problem. >> where do i send the starbucks on monday morning when it's all over for you? >> i'm trying to decide whether having worked through days of headaches, whether i should go intravenous caffeine right away or stay away from this succulently seductive caffeine. >> the fact we are debating this now on a national level and wouldn't be if you weren't doing this, it takes people to do d dramatic things like this to get people aware of it. let's take a break, come back and talk about your forthcoming battle, many say, with chris christie. you probably ate that for breakfast. >> low blow. [ male announcer ] imagine facing the day
6:11 pm
with less chronic osteoarthritis pain. imagine living your life with less chronic low back pain. imagine you, with less pain.
6:12 pm
cymbalta can help. cymbalta is fda-approved to manage chronic musculoskeletal pain. one non-narcotic pill a day, every day, can help reduce this pain. tell your doctor right away if your mood worsens, you have unusual changes in mood or behavior or thoughts of suicide. antidepressants can increase these in children, teens, and young adults. cymbalta is not approved for children under 18. people taking maois or thioridazine or with uncontrolled glaucoma should not take cymbalta. taking it with nsaid pain relievers, aspirin, or blood thinners may increase bleeding risk. severe liver problems, some fatal, were reported. signs include abdominal pain and yellowing skin or eyes. tell your doctor about all your medicines, including those for migraine and while on cymbalta, call right away if you have high fever, confusion and stiff muscles or serious allergic skin reactions like blisters, peeling rash, hives, or mouth sores to address possible life-threatening conditions. talk about your alcohol use, liver disease and before you reduce or stop cymbalta. dizziness or fainting may occur upon standing. ask your doctor about cymbalta. imagine you with less pain.
6:13 pm
cymbalta can help. go to to learn about a free trial offer.
6:14 pm
what it tells me is that people have different skill sets at different times. that's what it tells me. >> i see. so he wasn't a leader until you needed leadership. >> maybe until he was presented with an opportunity to lead. >> new jersey governor chris christie on the daily show joking about his bromance with president obama. i'm sure mayor cory booker has something to say about this because he may be your rival. should you come up against chris christie politically. what do you make of what's going on with him and the president? >> first, i think that's the way government should work and that's what we should expect from people. what we saw with president obama is he gets into office and people are right away saying we're not going to work with him
6:15 pm
to try to solve a national fiscal crisis, our number one goal tois to get him out of office. that's where politics trumps people and purpose. governor christie and president obama showed the right spirit during one of the worst natural disasters to hit in my lifetime on my state. >> give me three quick denials. booker v christie 2013? >> i'm not even going to give you the denial. i will simply say this is one of the most important races in the country because as much as i agree with things christie has done, therare things going on in the state right now where our state will have to make a choice between women's rights, planned parenthood, between environmental policy and prioritization of education, things like that. there's a definite policy choice in the state of new jersey. >> could you beat him? >> look, i think he's vulnerable. i think he's vulnerable to any democrat. his high mark in public polls that have been published, his high mark right now, he polls only at 53%. >> how would you feel if the president comes down and puts his arm around him again at the height of the battle? >> if there was a cause, a need
6:16 pm
for that, i applaud my president. new jersey is in a crisis, i want him to bond with whoever is in the governor's office. politics should be left to political seasons. governing should be done during governing season. even now before we get to next year, the election year, even now it's time to focus on governing and serving people. >> booker for senate, 2013? >> again, my focus right now is trying to figure out what that next step will be that is in accordance with my values. life is about purpose, not position. my value is i want to find whatever i do that can best make a contribution to the people in the city i love and the state i love. you and i both know this because you have done some great shows on this. we live in a country that has so much work to do. we still live in a country where men and women are denied equal citizenship rights because of who they decide to love. we live in a country where we have an abject failure in war on drugs that is costing taxpayers billions and billions of dollars and locking up more people than any country on earth. we still haven't faced up to immigration policy. we still have poverty, people working full-time jobs, still below the poverty line. there is an urgency to address
6:17 pm
one simple test. when a child stands up in oakland, california and a child stands up in a more affluent area and they say those five words, liberty and justice for all, we are still in a country that's working to make that more perfect union that makes those words real. we all should feel like we should be thinking what can i do in my life to best serve that ideal. >> booker for president any time? >> president of the new jersey "star trek" association? >> of the united states of america. >> because i will definitely volunteer to be a trekkie of the united states. look, it is irrational and takes a massive amount of chutzpah for anyone to say when there has been 40 plus human beings in the history of the united states that have been president of the united states. to me that is not even in the realm of consideration right now. my focus right now is trying to continue to fight to do the things that i think benefit my residents. i have 100,000 plus residents
6:18 pm
that depend upon things like a s.n.a.p. program and these are the kind of things i want to stand up and fight for, issues that i believe in, whether it's marriage equality or finding a drug policy and criminal justice reform that empowers people. how do you grow businesses, how do you get small entrepreneurs from communities like mine to get access to capital. >> i think you're a good politician and may achieve these things, possibly. you have skillfully managed to box yourself in where i can never replay you the moment in an interview where you look me in the eye and told a complete whopper. >> as a vegetarian i'm against whoppers. >> you're dreaming of a big whopper right now. >> even as a vegetarian, that might be true. the reality is all of us in this political world say dumb things. i have size 14 feet so it really hurts when they go in my mouth. >> really. >> yes. but i really wish we were a nation that the political games that we play and the gamesmanship often trumps common sense of what we need to do. i always want to be somebody, whether in elected office or
6:19 pm
not, that helps to be part of a course of conviction among citizens that we drive this country towards pragmatism, common sense and what works for us all. because that's the ideal of america, this idea of e pluribus unum. >> good to see you. continue the work of this challenge. on monday, i think monday morning when you finish, you will be on "starting point" to reveal how it went in its entirety. good luck with that. next, the royal hoax shocker. the nurse who took the prank call about kate middleton commits suicide. we'll have a report from london coming up. people have doubts about taking aspirin for pain. but they haven't experienced extra strength bayer advanced aspirin. in fact, in a recent survey, 95% of people who tried it agreed that it relieved their headache fast. visit today for a special trial offer. to provide a better benefits package... oahhh! [ male announcer ] it made a big splash with the employees. [ duck yelling ]
6:20 pm
[ male announcer ] find out more at... [ duck ] aflac! [ male announcer ] ♪ ha ha!
6:21 pm
tdd#: 1-800-345-2550 at schwab, we're committed to offering you tdd#: 1-800-345-2550 low-cost investment options-- tdd#: 1-800-345-2550 like our exchange traded funds, or etfs tdd#: 1-800-345-2550 which now have the lowest tdd#: 1-800-345-2550 operating expenses tdd#: 1-800-345-2550 in their respective tdd#: 1-800-345-2550 lipper categories. tdd#: 1-800-345-2550 lower than spdr tdd#: 1-800-345-2550 tdd#: 1-800-345-2550 and even lower than vanguard. tdd#: 1-800-345-2550 tdd#: 1-800-345-2550 that means with schwab, tdd#: 1-800-345-2550 your portfolio has tdd#: 1-800-345-2550 a better chance to grow. tdd#: 1-800-345-2550 and you can trade all our etfs online, tdd#: 1-800-345-2550 commission-free, from your schwab account. tdd#: 1-800-345-2550 tdd#: 1-800-345-2550 so let's talk about saving money, tdd#: 1-800-345-2550 with schwab etfs. tdd#: 1-800-345-2550 schwab etfs now have the lowest operating expenses tdd#: 1-800-345-2550 in their respective lipper categories. tdd#: 1-800-345-2550 call 1-800-4schwab tdd#: 1-800-345-2550 or visit tdd#: 1-800-345-2550 to open an account today. tdd#: 1-800-345-2550 funding is easy tdd#: 1-800-345-2550 with schwab mobile deposit. tdd#: 1-800-345-2550 investors should consider tdd#: 1-800-345-2550 carefully information d#: 1-800-345-2550 contained in the prospectus, d#: 1-800-345-2550 cluding investment objectives, d#: 1-800-345-2550 risks, charges, and expenses. d#: 1-800-345-2550 you can obtain
6:22 pm
tdd#: 1-800-345-2550 a prospectus by visiting d#: 1-800-345-2550 please read the prospectus tdd#: 1-800-345-2550 carefully before investing. tdd#: 1-800-345-2550
6:23 pm
tonight the stunning and deeply shocking news from london where a nurse at the hospital where kate middleton was treated for morning sickness has taken her own life. the nurse who killed herself was the one who was tricked by prank call from two australian deejays earlier this week who pretended to be queen elizabeth and prince charles. it's a tragic turn of events. joining me is katie nicholl, correspondent for the mail on sunday. people are snickering, laughing a bit, and it's suddenly become a much more serious, awful
6:24 pm
tragedy. what do we actually know about this? >> reporter: well, i can sure you, piers, no one is snickering or laughing tonight. this story has taken a turn for the very, very worse. it's incredibly tragic. the news is that jacintha saldanha, the nurse who took the hoax call from those two deejays in australia and transferred it to the ward that catherine was staying on was found dead at her house this morning. she was living in hospital accommodations just down the road from the edward vii hospital. she is the mother of two. we don't have an age for her, we don't know how old her children are. the family have asked that their privacy at this time is respected and all quearies are being referred to the police. we are all deeply shocked. it's a terrible story and a terrible twist that will leave william and catherine absolutely devastated. >> i think everyone involved will be devastated. the two deejays have suspended themselves by the sound of it in australia. they must be feeling i would imagine horrendous about what
6:25 pm
happened. it was a stupid thing to do but a lot of people found it sort of a typical deejay stunt, if you like. suddenly it's become a matter of life or death and this woman has died. we don't actually know for sure, i guess at this stage, whether her death is 100% linked to what happened, do we? >> reporter: no, because we don't know the background, we don't know -- there might have been a series of events that culminated in her suicide but were not solely linked to this. we just don't know at the moment. but as you point out, for these two deejays who have suspended themselves from the show, they have been inundated with hate mail on twitter, facebook. it's not just this family's lives who have been ruined, the lives of these two deejays now i expect have been ruined as well because blood on your hands was one of the comments i think i saw on their facebook pages and that they will be feeling -- well, i don't know -- i don't think you can put into words actually how they're feeling. absolutely deeply regretful. they did issue a statement immediately afterwards saying
6:26 pm
how remorseful they were, but i'm afraid words just sometimes aren't enough and i think in this situation, that probably is the case. >> kate and william have issued a statement saying how upset they've been to hear about this. her family's issued a statement saying similar things. it's just one of those awful, awful tragedies. our heart goes out to her, to her family, particularly her two children who now have lost their mother over something that was just intended to be a silly prank. very, very sad. katie nicholl, thank you very much for joining me. suicide is getting as much attention in america. let's bring in the panel of all-stars. charles blow, republican pollster kristin soltis and author joel stein. charles, just on this tragedy in london, a lot of people pouncing on these australian deejays, sickening, disgusting, they should be fired and so on. it was a silly prank that seems to have gone horrendously wrong. >> right. >> what do you make of it?
6:27 pm
>> well, suicides are very complicated. the reasons that a person would choose to take their own life, and i think you have to look at it always as a complicated thing, whether or not there's a prank involved, whether or not there's bullying involved. that probably plays a role in it and obviously in this case, it looks like at this point with what we know that that probably played a role in it, but when a person decides to take their own life, it's a very complicated emotional set of reactions that's happening inside and you do have to take that part into account, too. was there something that was underneath that maybe could have been helped and she could have gotten help for that other than taking her life. i really -- >> my gut feeling is that there's more that's going to come out about this. >> i like to push back against the simplistic rationales for people taking their lives. >> i think that's very sensible. let's move on to something that cory booker was talking about
6:28 pm
earlier. i'll come to you, kristin soltis, first. this whole issue of food stamps in america. i was shocked when i saw these statistics, 46 million americans now on food stamps. when you actually see a pile of food and realize that is it for the week and it's pretty un-nutritious, it's what it is, really quite disturbing, actually. what should be done about this? >> that's such a difficult question. how do you tackle poverty in america is this enormously complex question. unfortunately, it's not one that you can just solve with one quick program or one quick government solution. i think it's very interesting and i think it's admirable that mayor booker is putting a spotlight on poverty in america. it's one of the things i think my own party doesn't necessarily do as good a job focusing on. i really think that the solution, though, is how do we create more economic mobility so that folks who find themselves in poverty have real clear pathways not to stay dependent
6:29 pm
but to be able to build themselves up, to begin to gain the skills to get the employment that they need so that they can have a good life for themselves and provide a better life for their children. >> quickly, i'll come to you in a moment, joe, but do you feel comfortable that the republicans are prepared to slash investment in something like food stamps in an effort to try and protect as it seems to many people, the wealthiest 2% from paying more tax? >> so i would disagree with the premise a little bit. the idea here is that republicans think the way you can get more revenue is by growing the economy and they're concerned if you raise those top tax rates it's going to have a negative effect on the economy and that that's going to actually mean we won't have as much revenue to go towards programs like food stamps but republicans, you are right that they are in a very difficult position at least politically when it comes to these trade-offs. right now, democrats have i think very effectively painted republicans as the party of the rich, particularly on this sort of fiscal cliff fight. you could be forgiven for
6:30 pm
thinking the only thing on which republicans and democrats are really disagreeing are these taxes on the top 2% when really, there are a lot of other factors that are holding up a deal. but democrats have been very savvy in their portrayal of republicans in the last few months. >> i think they have. they won the political battle. charles, bring it round to the fiscal cliff because it's all interwoven here. it's all about basically where should government be spending money, where should cuts be made, and who ends up paying the lion's share of this. my sense is this will not go over the cliff and the reason it won't is that public opinion is now raging so hard against the republicans in all the polls that you see, they've lost the argument so why go over a cliff and make it worse for yourselves. >> i think you're right about that, because all of the polls i've seen say exactly what you're saying which is that the republicans will be blamed if we go over the cliff. but the first part of your question i think is the more crucial part of the question, which is how do you not cut off your nose to spite your face.
6:31 pm
if you do things, you make cuts that harm children who need to learn, who need to be able to go to school on a full stomach and be able to stay a whole day and have programs that will allow them to be competitive with children in china and india, if you need that to be a real situation in america for us to be competitive ten years from now when we're not in a recession, you have to look at that and say this is not smart policy for the long term. and whatever we have to do to protect and insulate those children, we do that. now, how do we do that, you know, they were talking about before with food stamps, that's the hammock versus safety net discussion. we don't want it to be a hammock for people where people just lounge around and expect to get food stamps forever but you need a safety net when the bottom falls out and the bottom has fallen out. at this point, it is very cool to be able to look -- not cool,
6:32 pm
kind of cruel, even, to be able to look at what people can buy, what they can get and whether or not that is sufficient. >> i think cory booker's doing a great thing. just having it on the desk here was fascinating, what you actually buy and realize you try to buy it in new york, for example, could cost you up to $60 which you just don't physically have. let's take a break, come back and talk about this historic announcement the supreme court will now be taking on same sex marriage. potentially big moment for gay rights in america. [ male announcer ] alka-seltzer plus presents the cold truth.
6:33 pm
i have a cold... i took dayquil, but i still have a runny nose. [ male announcer ] truth is, dayquil doesn't work on runny noses. what? [ male announcer ] it doesn't have an antihistamine. really? [ male announcer ] really. alka-seltzer plus cold and cough fights your worst cold symptoms, plus has a fast acting antihistamine to relieve your runny nose. [ sighs ] thank you! [ male announcer ] you're welcome. that's the cold truth! [ male announcer ] alka-seltzer plus. ♪ oh what a relief it is! ♪ [ male announcer ] can't find theraflu? try alka-seltzer plus for fast, liquid, cold, and flu relief. bp has paid overthe people bp twenty-threeitment to the gulf. billion dollars to help those affected and to cover cleanup costs. today, the beaches and gulf are open, and many areas are reporting their best tourism seasons in years. and bp's also committed to america. we support nearly 250,000 jobs
6:34 pm
and invest more here than anywhere else. we're working to fuel america for generations to come. our commitment has never been stronger. hurry in and try five succulent entrees, like our tender snow crab paired with savory garlic shrimp. just $12.99. come into red lobster and sea food differently. and introducing 7 lunch choices for just $7.99. she also likes to ride her bike. she knows the potential for making or losing money can pop up anytime. that's why she trades with the leader in mobile trading. so she's always ready to take action, no matter how wily... or weird... or wonderfully the market's behaving... which isn't rocket science. it's just common sense. from td ameritrade.
6:35 pm
6:36 pm
back now, my battleground america panel, charles blow, kristin soltis and joel stein. joel, pretty big announcement this afternoon. the supreme court will now be looking at both prop 8 and doma. this could potentially be huge for gay rights in america. >> especially with david boyes and ted olson coming together, the guys who were against each other in bush v gore, on the same side fighting for gay rights, for gay marriage. i think it's a really interesting case because they designed this case not to kind of be technical but just to go at the straight heart of the
6:37 pm
issue which is whether not letting gay people marry is discrimination. so it's a pretty direct hit on whether this is allowed or not, and i think they have a really good chance of winning this and kind of basically deciding this once and for all. which is the way this is going to move forward. this isn't the way civil rights get decided, they get decided by our courts because the constitution is designed to protect people's rights. >> i completely agree. i think the state by state element of this just can't wash for much longer. it has to be done at a national level. where will that leave the members of the republican party that feel very strongly about this and there's no doubt many people in the republican party do feel strongly and they are not going to like this. where does that leave the party in four years time if they try and fight on another platform that doesn't fully support and embrace gay rights in america? >> public opinion on this issue has changed very rapidly in sort of just the last 20 years, but you can even really look at the last eight years alone.
6:38 pm
if you look back at the 2004 election, there was lots of debate about whether or not bush's re-election could be pinned on the fact that in many of these states, there were referendum on the ballot about things such as same sex marriage, that the social issues were being dredged up as sort of positive for the republicans. fast forward to this election and as we discussed on the show before, you have gay marriage, you have marijuana, you have these issues on which republicans, you know, not necessarily where the voters were this time around in many of these states that literally in just the last ten years alone, public opinion has shifted a lot. though it's important to remember that i don't think of this as as much of a partisan issue as it is generational. remember, it was just a few months ago that president obama was evolving on his position and you had dick cheney who was kind of to the left of him on gay marriage. so i don't view this as much as a partisan issue. i view this as generational and something that both parties, particularly the republican party, though, will be addressing and dealing with over the next few years. >> i think that's a good point. let's move on to jobs, charles blow.
6:39 pm
u.s. created 146,000 jobs in november, higher than predicted. clearly jack walsh's theory, obama was cooking the books, probably cannot be true now. unemployment 7.7%, lowest in four years. most interesting story of the week, though, because i campaigned about this pretty relentlessly, apple have announced they are going to bring jobs back to america. let's play how i have been trying to force this issue for quite some time. >> companies like apple, you have ten times as many employees in china now than america. what do you think of the concept of moral capitalism? i feel strongly about companies like apple, for example, who outsource all the jobs to china, a lot of it comes back here. >> i have a problem with this. apple makes $100 billion but apple employs more people in china than it does in america. that to me is wrong. >> now, there is a globalization aspect to this and what i don't want to do is tell a company like apple look, you can't be a
6:40 pm
global business anymore because you've got to bring it all back to america. that's not what this is about. i do think this moral capitalism line which howard schultz at starbucks came up with is a strong one, actually. i always believed that the american public would reward companies like apple by going to buy the products if they made them here and they would actually be proud at buying an ipad or iphone that had made in the usa on it more than they would if they see made in china. >> but there are two elements to that. part of it is the moral capitalism and you can debate that on both sides of it. but the other part of it, are we educating enough kids who can do those jobs and compete on a global marketplace. >> that's what he said, the problem is more training than the cost of doing it. but apple can afford to train people. >> apple can afford to train people and what you see now, you see more and more companies, you see on television, ads by companies have nothing to do with education, running ads about improving education and that is because we're not
6:41 pm
training enough people in the science, technology, engineering and mathematics fields. what we have to do is dramatically ramp up the number of kids that we are producing who are in those fields and are capable and competent in those fields. until we do that, we're not going to be competitive and more companies, high tech companies in particular, where they can export, will do that because it will be cheaper and more efficient. >> i totally agree. you have to remove the excuse. joel stein, sum up for me what the priorities should be for president obama. he has his second term, doesn't need to worry about being re-elected. he can be bold if he wants to be. everyone talks about jobs, jobs, jobs but charles may have hit the nail on the head there. it is probably about education and training for america above almost anything else. >> i was waiting for obama to ask me what he needs to do the next four years. i think what he needs to deal with is our long-term problems because he doesn't need to be re-elected. that's education and that's
6:42 pm
infrastructure and inequality. those are the three things that he can really cement his legacy and really move our country in the right direction, instead of worrying about jobs, which you know, there's not that much he can do in the short term about jobs. so i don't know if that's where he should be focusing anymore. >> kristin, final word from you about this. >> i disagree that the focus shouldn't be on jobs. t unemployment ticked down to 7.7% but you still had hundreds of people leaving the work force. i think we still have to deal with the more immediate problems facing the economy although i completely agree with what charles blow had to say about the need for focusing on the s.t.e.m. fields. education is the long term economic challenge for america. >> i think the thing is america has to move with the times. america was with this great manufacturing superpower, now it's a great consumering superpower, eating up everything from everybody else. i like what apple's done. i applaud it. it's not a massive thing yet but it could be if it works and i think it's a great step in the right direction.
6:43 pm
i salute tim cook and all of apple for doing it. thank you all very much. coming up next, singer brandi on her triumphs, troubles and on the death of a great friend, whitney houston. [ woman ] it's 32 minutes to go time, and the candidate's speech is in pieces all over the district. the writer's desktop and the coordinator's phone are working on a joke with local color. the secure cloud just received a revised intro from the strategist's tablet. and while i make my way into the venue, the candidate will be rehearsing off of his phone. [ candidate ] and thanks to every young face i see out there. [ woman ] his phone is one of his biggest supporters. [ female announcer ] with cisco at the center... working together has never worked so well.
6:44 pm
6:45 pm
have led to an increase intands witclinical depression.r... drug and alcohol abuse is up. and those dealing with grief don't have access to the professional help they need. when you see these issues, do you want to walk away or step up?
6:46 pm
with a degree in the field of counseling or psychology from capella university, you'll have the knowledge to make a difference in the lives of others. let's get started at since ameriprise financial was founded back in 1894, they've been committed to putting clients first. helping generations through tough times. good times. never taking a bailout. there when you need them. helping millions of americans over the centuries. the strength of a global financial leader. the heart of a one-to-one relationship. together for your future. ♪
6:47 pm
you are my favorite contestant in this competition. >> thank you! i love you. >> change your hair, change your dress, change your shoes and you will win this tournament. >> and indeed, she did. that was fun times from "america's got talent" with brandi, david hasselhoff and myself having a blast doing the first season of that show in 2006. i'm back with brandi for the first time. i haven't seen you since 2006. >> i know. it's good to see you. >> you haven't changed a bit. >> you haven't, either. >> don't lie. >> just a lot more successful. i love that. >> what about that clip, i was right, that girl did win that year. >> she did. >> bianca ryan. voice of an angel.
6:48 pm
>> amazing. you were right about her. it was a little mean but you were right. you were 99% right. i used to always tell you that. >> how have you been? >> i've been great. i've been great. life has been amazing this last couple years. i'm back with new music, acting again. it's all a fresh new start and i'm just loving it all. >> the most incredible thing about you is that you're 33 years old. >> don't be telling people my age, piers. >> how can you be 33? you have been in the business 18 years. >> yes. >> you don't even look 18. >> good. >> you have weathered like a fine wine. >> thank you. thank you very much. thank you. i'm just trying to keep it -- >> but you ever stop and think wow, i'm still only 33 and yet i've had this 18-year career. >> it's pretty unbelievable. because i started at 15 years old and everything just started happening at that age and it continued and you know, now i'm coming back with all of this new
6:49 pm
stuff and it feels new again but i definitely know that i've been around for awhile. it's amazing. i'm very grateful and thankful for it. >> you have a baby girl. >> i do. she's 10 years old. >> 10 years old. >> she's 10. >> swhat's being a mother like? >> it keeps you on your toes, that's for sure. everything is led by example. like you have to teach by what you do. so i definitely have to stay on it or she'll be looking at me like mom, you did it so why are you telling me. she's amazing. she's definitely my star for sure. >> let's talk about 211. it's a special title because it's your birthday but it's also the date of whitney houston's death. i was in los angeles, i came here and co-anchored the news all night long with a really heavy heart because it was one of those desperately sad things to have happened in the business that i can remember. your relationship was fascinating to me. you were 9 years old when you sneaked in to see your first
6:50 pm
ever concert, a whitney concert. >> yes. >> you starred with her in the 1997 movie "cinderella" where she played your fairy godmother. your brother ray was actually dating her at the time. >> they were really close friends. yes. yeah. >> i realize that's how you can't to characterize it. you were one of the last people to see her alive. an incredible journey you went on with whitney houston. tell me about her. >> wow. from the very first time i saw her,her, i was completely blown away. to see her music, her voice, everything about her just touched my spirit in ways no other singer could. and, you know, working with her and sharing moments with her were just unforgettable. and, you know, one of the last things we talked about was me going forward and what i had to do in terms of my connection with my fans and music and she just told me, you know, you have to be yourself because when you are yourself, that's who people will fall in love with.
6:51 pm
and -- >> was she herself towards the end, do you think? or had she just got lost in the maelstrom of fame and abuse and all the rest of it? >> one of the things that i can't -- i can't put my mind around is where she really was because, you know, at the end of her life, i wasn't there. i wasn't around. i didn't talk to her as much, which is one of the reasons why it was so hard for me to get over her passing is because i felt like i wasn't there enough for her at the end of her life. and i have no clue where she was mentally or spiritually. i don't know. >> what many of her friends told me at the time, and i interviewed many of them on this show, was that you couldn't underestimate how big a blow it was to her to lose the voice, the power that she had. the inability in stage shows to hit the big notes anymore for "i will always love you" and so on. as somebody who still can, do
6:52 pm
you understand what that feeling must be like? >> i understand what that feels like. i don't tond that degree, but i understand, you know, because i feel like when i don't have my instrument, i don't really have -- i don't really have me. >> it is what you're about. >> yes, it's who -- it's almost who you are. of course, there's more to you than your voice, but that's what you use to share. that's what you use to give. it's your purpose. it's what you were born to do. >> and to lose that must be the worst thing. >> yeah. probably drove her insane. it probably drove her insane. >> where were you when you heard the news? how did you hear it? >> i was actually in the same hotel that she passed in. >> at the beverly hilton? >> yes. and we were all getting ready for the clive grammy party. and i was in my room getting ready. but the strange thing is right before i started to get ready, there was this guy and a paramedics guy in the elevator.
6:53 pm
and they were like, hurry up, she's not breathing. she's not breathing. and later on to find out they were talking about whitney, i was like, whoa, like this is crazy. and my mom calls me and tells me that she passed, and i couldn't believe it. i was like no way. and i just -- i fell to the floor in tears and had been crying for weeks and months after that. >> really? it hit you that bad? >> it just hit me in ways i can't even explain. >> how is ray doing because he was very close to her? >> ray has been going through it. he really has been going through it, but, you know, every time we go through something, we always stick to who we are as family and, you know, so we've been there for him. but he's been silent about everything and, you know, just taking his time with it.
6:54 pm
>> very tough thing to deal with. >> yeah, very tough thing to deal with. >> she would have been very proud of you, i think. especially the way you've rebuilt your life and your career now. things couldn't be going better for you. are you excited about having a new album out now with everything that you've been through in the last ten years? >> i am. i'm very excited because this new album is music that i truly believe in. i truly love the music that i'm singing. and love the producers and the writers that i've worked with on this album. and i'm just so happy to go forward and share it and just talk about it and sing about it and so it's a great, great time for me. >> what do you feel, when you sing. what do you feel? >> i feel everything. i feel alm the emotions that's inside of me. i feel especially when i'm singing in front of people, i feel their emotions when they are giving me that love that i need to give them back the love. and, you know, it's just a lot. it's a lot. it's the best way i can express
6:55 pm
myself. it's therapeutic music. >> it's a fantastic album. it's great to see you again. >> thank you. >> it's been too long. let's catch up again soon. brandy. we'll be right back. with dedicated support teams at over 500 branches nationwide. so when you call or visit, you can ask for a name you know. because personal service starts with a real person. [ rodger ] at scottrade, seven dollar trades are just the start. our support teams are nearby, ready to help. it's no wonder so many investors are saying... [ all ] i'm with scottrade. anyone have occasional constipation, diarrhea, gas, bloating? yeah. one phillips' colon health probiotic cap each day helps defend against these digestive issues with three strains of good bacteria.
6:56 pm
approved! [ female announcer ] live the regular life. phillips'. [ female announcer ] live the regular life. let's say you want to get ahead how do you get from here... to here? at university of phoenix we're moving career planning forward so you can start figuring that out sooner. ln fact, by thinking about where want your education to lead, while you're still in school, you might find the best route... leads somewhere you weren't even looking. let's get to work.
6:57 pm
6:58 pm
the red carpet outside
6:59 pm
l.a.'s shrine auditorium buzzed with excitement. but this time the bright lights shined on some special stars. everyday people changing the world. >> welcome to "cnn heroes: an all-star tribute." >> out of thousands of nominees, ten amazing men and women were singled out for their remarkable heroic efforts to make the world a better place. people like rajajon who is providing a free education to hundreds of girls in rural afghanistan. >> i think education is the only thing in the world that can go forward and make life better. >> and leo mccarthy who gives scholarships to kids who pledge not to drink after his daughter was killed by a young driver. >> let's change the culture and keep these promising, vibrant kids alive. >> olympic swimmer collin jones helped celebrate the golden moment, motivated by her son's tragic drowning. she created a non-profit that'