tv State of the Union CNN January 11, 2015 6:00am-7:01am PST
live coverage. we appreciate you being here as always. >> "state of the union" starts right now, with live continuing coverage next. -- captions by vitac -- www.vitac.com good morning from washington. i'm gloria bornger and erborger and this is "state of the union." today a massive showing in the fight against terror. you're looking at live pictures of paris, where world leaders from up to 50 countries are joining what could be a million strong at a national unity rally. the demonstration is in response to last week's deadly and horrific terror attack at the offices of the french magazine "charlie hebdo," and a pair of hostage situations that took 17 lives. today's rally is taking place as france remains on high alert,
because terrorist cells have been activated within the country in the past 24 hours. the french government says that massive security measures are in place, with more than 2,000 soldiers and police officers deployed along the march route. the terrorist attacks in paris raises fresh concerns about security here in the united states and the vulnerability of so-called soft targets. i'm joined now by senator dianne feinstein, the top democrat on the senate intelligence committee. thanks so much for being here with us today. the head of british intelligence this week said something that was chilling. he said that the world should be prepared for a possible mass casualty attack. what's your read on that? you see these intelligence reports. do you feel the same way? >> as far as i know after looking at the reports i've seen there is no credible
defined threat of that. i think this is within the realm of possibility. i think we're in an all-out situation. france has declared war. what that means, i'm not quite sure but we're going to see. >> what's an appropriate response then if they've declared war? what's the retaliation? >> that's not for me to decide. that's for france to decide. i think what they're saying is there will be a unified national effort to rid the country of terrorists and that's difficult to do because they're deeply embedded. i think there are sleeper cells not only in france but certainly in other countries, and yes, even in our own. so i think this calls for vigilance. it calls for seeing that the national security organizations of our country, of the intelligence community, is funded fully, is directed ably is cooperating with whether it be british intelligence french
intelligence german intelligence, as we do, and the french are good at it and so are the british, and the germans. so hopefully we can even be more active in terms of doing those things which enable us to find terrorists to see who they're communicating with in this country, and to try that. >> well you're responsible for intelligence oversight. do you believe the intelligence community here keeps better track than the french did on those people who traveled to yemen, and they just kind of went off the radar screen. do you believe we do a better job of it here? >> to the best of my knowledge, the french have more than we do. >> so how do you explain this failure? >> the expectation has been that the foreign fighters coming back from syria or even iraq train, to some extent will likely first go to the european community.
>> so how do you explain this failure. >> the problem comes -- well this is extraordinarily difficult to do. they had these people under surveillance for a substantial period of time. >> um-hum. >> there are a lot of pressures. i don't know what the financial situation is. i don't know whether they've had cutbacks or what, but this has to now be all-out, and if war means anything it's all-out intelligence. the way you stop this is intelligence and the way intelligence works is to disrupt the plot before it takes place. >> because they were french citizens these terrorists could have come here. they were on a no-fly list. >> that's correct. >> but they could have come here with just their passports under the u.s. visa waiver program. so if the u.s. fly list had not stopped them they could have landed here. so is the visa program a hole in the security net?
>> this is not new for me. i serve on the judiciary committee as well and it's my belief, and i've said this publicly many times, that the visa waiver program is the achilles heel of america, because you're right, gloria. they can come back from training they go through a visa waiver country and they come into this country. now, there are no-fly lists, there are terrorist lists, but they're in the tens of thousands and even millions so it's difficult to ferret someone out. there are stolen travel documents, large numbers that they can pick up a false passport et cetera. so we have a big problem there. i think we need to take a look at the visa waiver program again, and see what we can do to prevent this kind of thing from happening. because i believe it will happen if it hasn't already. >> when the president spoke about his anti-isis campaign
last fall he said that he was going to he compared his strategy to the one that the u.s. "had successfully pursued in yemen and somalia for years." looking at what happened in paris this week and looking at the connections between emwhyyemen and these terrorists was the president on the wrong track with that example? >> well i don't quite know what he was referring to. >> yes. >> so it's hard for me to comment, but yemen, you know we have a very serious bombmaker still alive. they are now putting out propaganda for the most serious kind of bombmaking target list planes to bomb where to sit on the plane, and this material circulates freely throughout the internet. it is comprehensive. i've just reviewed it and it's a very deep concern to me. now, what you do about this, i
don't know. is it a problem in terms of recruitment? i believe it is a big problem. >> so could you sensor the internet? could you say these things should not be allowed on the internet? >> i don't know. i did the bombmaking legislation that's now law waysbased on the terrorist handbook in the '90s, and if you have knowledge and intent that your material is in fact going to be used for an attack it is a felony. the justice department has prosecuted a few people for this not a lot. they say it's very difficult, as we know, but that's where we are. when you have a recipe for a very serious bomb out there on the internet, you need to deal with it because we know the people who put it there intend to have it used for a criminal act. >> let me just switch topics on
you for one quick second about general petraeus. you have worked with general petraeus. there are reports that the justice department prosecutors may have a document on the attorney general's desk recommending prosecution. would an indictment be appropriate as far as you're concerned and has this been handled appropriately. >> let me say what i think. this man has suffered enough in my view. he's the four-star general of our generation. i saw him in iraq. he put together the army field manual. he put together the awakening and how it worked out. he i think is a very brilliant man. people aren't pefb. he he made a mistake. he lost his job as a cia director because of it. i mean, how much do you want to
punish somebody? i don't know if i believe he directly gave material to her or not. i know she had access to classified data by her own classification, so it's murky, but be that as it may, it's done. it's over and he's retired. he's lost his job. i mean how much does government want? >> so i hear you saying that he shouldn't be indicted. >> i think that's correct. >> senator feinstein, thanks so much for being here today as always. >> thank you. >> let's go to paris to jake tapper where almost 1 million people are attending that unity march we spoke of before. so jake, what do things look like now from your perch? >> reporter: bonseur, mad moye sell bonseur. we are here in paris at the place de la republique which is where this rally is beginning. we've been here for hours now as
the crowd went from dozens to hundreds to thousands to now tens of thousands. it has been cold taken hasand it has been rainy but i have to tell you the feeling here is warm. it is a crowd that is excited, it is a crowd that is united. they just finished singing the marseilles the national anthem in france sorry for botching the pronunciation of that. for the third time they've been chants "who are you, charlie who are you, charlie." there are flags from countries all over the world, even a flag from the state of california here. people here holding signs saying not only "i am charlie" standing of course for "charlie hebdo," the french satirical magazine where 12 innocent people were slaughtered by terrorists on wednesday, but also je suis ahmed, referring to the muslim police officer killed wednesday, je suis jewish talking about
solidarity for the four jews targeted and killed in that kosher grocery store on friday. there is a lot developing behind the scenes when it comes to investigation in the terrorist attacks. obviously one of the suspects one of the terrorists amedy coulibaly released a video in which he pledged allegiance to isis that was released earlier today. but beyond that beyond the hate and the investigation into the terrorism, this is really a remarkable scene of the country of france coming together with world leaders, ranging from british prime minister david cameron to israeli prime minister benjamin netanyahu to the palestinian authority president mahmoud abbas, leaders from turkey germany, eric holder the u.s. attorney general here. >> sure. >> reporter: all coming together standing with france saying -- >> jake -- >> reporter: -- we will not be bowed. >> jake does it have a feeling,
you were in this country as was i for 9/11. does it have that sort of same sense that we witnessed in this country when every member of congress came out on the steps of the capitol and sang together and you know, the feeling in this country was very much one of unity, one of fighting back one of not letting the terrorists take charge? >> reporter: you know i remember the immediate days after 9/11 being a little bit more fearful, because, a, it was such a shock to the system so new, at least to people in the united states, including myself the concept of terrorism striking on our shores. >> sure. >> reporter: but also because the loss of life was so massive. it reminds me a little bit more of the rally outside the white house after bin laden was
killed. >> um-hum. >> reporter: after it was announced that sunday evening, when all those people spontaneously organically came to the white house and said "usa usa" it's almost that kind of feeling, a pride, a defiance of saying, we will not be on our knees, as the late editor of "charlie hebdo" once said i'd rather die on my feet than live on my knees. that's more the spirit i think. >> everybody is standing up for him and all the others who lost their lives. thanks so much jake. we'll be coming back to you. but when we come back attorney general eric holder on what steps the u.s. might take in response to these terrible parterrible paris attacks, in a minute. she inspires you. no question about
that. but your erectile dysfunction - that could be a question of blood flow. cialis tadalafil for daily use helps you be ready anytime the moment's right. you can be more confident in your ability to be ready. and the same cialis is the only daily ed tablet approved to treat ed and symptoms of bph, like needing to go frequently or urgently. tell your doctor about all your medical conditions and medicines, and ask if your heart is healthy enough for sex. do not take cialis if you take nitrates for chest pain as it may cause an unsafe drop in blood pressure. do not drink alcohol in excess. side effects may include headache, upset stomach, delayed backache or muscle ache. to avoid long term injury, get medical help right away for an erection lasting more than four hours. if you have any sudden decrease or loss in hearing or vision or any allergic reactions like rash, hives, swelling of the lips tongue or throat or difficulty breathing or swallowing, stop taking cialis and get medical help right away. ask your doctor about cialis for daily use and a free 30-tablet trial. [ male announcer ] you wouldn't leave your car unprotected. but a lot of
us leave our identities unprotected. nearly half a million cars were stolen in 2012, but for every car stolen 34 people had their identities stolen. identity thieves can steal your money, damage your credit and wreak havoc on your life. why risk it when you can help protect yourself from identity theft with one call to lifelock, the leader in identity-theft protection? lifelock actively patrols your sensitive, personal information every second of every day, helping to guard your social security number, your bank accounts and credit, even the equity in your home -- your valuable personal assets. look. your bank may alert you to suspicious activity on your credit or debit card. but that still may leave you vulnerable to big losses if a thief opens new accounts in your name or decides to drain your savings, home equity, or retirement accounts. and your credit report may only tell you after your identity's been compromised. but lifelock is proactive protection and watches out for you in ways that banks and credit-card companies
alone just can't giving you the most comprehensive identity theft protection available. whenever the patented lifelock identity alert system detects a threat to your identity you'll be notified by phone, text, or e-mail, helping you to stop identity thieves before they do damage. you even get a $1 million service guarantee. that's right. if your identity is ever compromised, lifelock will spend up to $1 million on experts to help restore it. you wouldn't leave your car unprotected. don't leave your money, credit and good name unprotected. call now, and try lifelock risk-free for 60 days. act now, and get this document shredder free. that's a $29 value. ♪ or go to lifelock.com/go. try lifelock risk-free for 60 days and get this document shredder free -- a $29 value -- when you use promo code go. call now. is your high-performance laptop your office bff?
then you might be gearcentric. right now, all pc's are on sale, like this hp 15" laptop now only $249.99. office depot & officemax. gear up for great. and you're look at live pictures of a national unity rally getting under way in paris. dozens of world leaders are participating, including british prime minister david cameron, german chancellor angela merkel israeli prime minister benjamin netanyahu and cnn is going to have live coverage of this rally starting at 10:00 a.m. eastern. attorney general eric holder
is also in paris today, where he's representing the united states at the rally, and he's also attending a terrorism summit. i spoke with him a short while ago about the paris incident. mr. attorney general, thanks so much for being here with us this morning, from paris. americans have watched in shock and horror as events unfolded in france this week. did anything about the nature and the sophistication of this attack surprise you? >> well certainly we're horrified by what happened and we express our condolences to the french people but i think what we saw in france over the course of this last week is unfortunately what we're going to have to confront into the future. we have seen these kinds of attacks, or attempts at these kinds of attacks certainly in the united states. we've seen things like this in the united kingdom. we've seen this in nairobi and australia and canada. this is the nature of the new threat that we must confront. we can, i think, successfully
confront it if we share information in a way that perhaps we have not in the past and do a variety of other things but i am very concerned about what we saw this week in france. >> we're now being told today that one of the terrorists has activated other sleeper cells in france. do you believe that all of these terrorists are part of a larger sleeper cell operation? >> well the french have the lead on this investigation, and i would defer to them as to what their investigation has so far uncovered. what i will say is that the united states is working with our french counterparts as best we can sharing law enforcement information with them sharing intelligence information with them making available to them the information that we have in our various databases, and i'm confident they will ultimately be able to determine exactly who was responsible for these acts and roll up all of the people who were in fact involved. >> should we assume there are
similar sleeper cells in the united states? yes? no? >> well, one of the things that we are constantly doing is looking at the body of people who we are concerned about in the united states use legitimate means to monitor their activities. we don't stereotype but we are constantly looking at those people to make sure that we are doing all the things that we can to keep the american people safe in stopping them from engaging in the kinds of activities that we saw here in france this week. >> one terrorist is still on the run and she's apparently headed to syria, if she's not there already. do you have her in your sights? >> well we're working with our allies. we have looked at the number of westerners who have gone to syria. we focus mostly on the americans who have gone to syria, about 150 or so have gone to sear yar or attempted to do that syria and iraq. we think there are 12 there now who are actually engaged in the
fight, but we work with our allies allies. we share information and one of the things that we frankly have to do better. we have to monitor each other's citizens because the reality is that any one nation can be hurt by the citizens of another nation given the way in which people can transit from one country to another. so -- >> the french seem to -- >> concerns about american citizens and french citizens have to be shared by all. >> the french seem to have lost track of two of these terrorists let them off their radar. was that an intelligence failure and do you worry that could happen here, because as you point out, you have people who have traveled to yemen, for example, who are in the united states so if the french lost track of these folks, could do? >> it's too early to say what happened here. there will have to be abaction report and analysis of exactly what was done correctly, what was done incorrectly. we try to do in the united
states the best we can, in monitoring those people who we are most concerned about. we also have to understand that we have lone wolves people who act as individuals, and who kind of float under the radar screen and who are potentially going to do things that are harmful to the american people. we do all that we can. we work with our state and local counterparts to monitor these people. we ask the american people themselves to see something and to share that information so i think that we're doing a good job but we're doing -- well, that we'll have to see. we're dealing at this point the french are dealing with just the impact of the heinous acts that occurred last week as the investigation unfolds, i'm sure that they will make determinations as to what the extent of any other people's involved. >> and let me just ask you, from your read of this aqap, al qaeda in the arabian peninsula has claimed responsibility for the paris attack and one of the brothers as we know trained in
yemen. do you believe that aqap ordered, paid for and coordinated this? >> we don't have any credible information at least as yet to indicate who was responsible, who sponsored this act. that is clearly one of the things that we have to make a determination of. i will say this that aqap remains the most dangerous of the al qaeda cells, the al qaeda organizations, and we are constantly focused on them. >> let me just switch subjects here for a little moment on you. there are reports that prosecutors in your department have recommended bringing felony charges against former cia director david petraeus for sharing classified information with his mistress. is that the case? is that on your desk? that recommendation? >> well, i don't want to comment on -- i don't want to comment on what is an ongoing matter.
i will say that frequently those things that are leaked to the media are done so by people who are not in a position to know and are frequently inaccurate. >> so is it inaccurate? >> so let me leave it at that. >> well john mccain says that this entire process has taken way too long -- >> as i said -- >> -- and that it's been grievously mishandled. how would you respond to that? >> well i've got great respect for senator mccain and senator graham who i understand sent a letter to me as well. we have done this investigation, i think, in an appropriate way, and appropriate determination will be done, and it will be done in a way that i think the american people will ultimately decide what was fair to everyone who was involved. >> attorney general eric holder thanks so much for being with us this morning. >> thank you. >> and the paris attacks have
launched a new round of criticism here in the u.s. about president oobama's foreign policy. with me now is the man we were just talking about, senator john mccain chairman of the armed services committee and also a member of the homeland security committee. thanks so much for being with me this morning, senator mccain. we will get to paris. let me just have you respond to what eric holder said on general petraeus. he said that this investigation has been handled appropriately. you say it's been grievously mishandled. >> gloria is it appropriate to leak information that is supposed to be kept sealed until a decision is made? the recommendation not the decision it's a violation of any citizen's rights to have that information leaked much less a man as dianne feinstein just said that is a genuine american hero and by the way, i
don't know if there's guilt or innocence. i might add as an aside, classified information is leaked to the media every day in our nation nation's capital but that's beside the fact. >> senator dianne feinstein didn't think he should in fact be indicted. >> well i think that -- look, i can't make that judgment because i don't know the information but i do know that this is -- one of the great honors of my life is to meet have known some great military leaders. this man is unique. he is one of the great leaders. ask anybody who served under him. he was an architect of the surge which turned iraq around. he may have saved thousands of young americans' lives, and obviously he deserves better treatment than have a leak to the "new york times" about a recommendation which is a violation of his rights and any citizen's rights. >> okay and senator, thank you on that. let me just switch now, if i might, to paris, the terror
attack there, the unity rally we've been watching and is now up on our screen as well in paris. you just heard the attorney general eric holder saying that he's going to try to coordinate more with the french. there needs to be better coordination among all the allies. you have said that what occurred in france is a direct threat not only to europe but to the united states. can you elaborate on that? >> sure. i paid attention to what the head of british intelligence mi5 said in his speech and others have said experts, that these, these organizations pose a direct threat pose a direct threat. whether it's an immediate threat or not, i don't want to get into wordsmithing but when mr. baghdadi left our camp bukka after spending four years in iraq he said "i'll see new new
york." he wasn't kidding. the point here is that i'm glad eric holder is keeping an eye on people and all that but this is because the result of leading from behind. this is the same organization these people are trained from that the president of the united states said yemen and somalia were success stories. we made when we didn't leave a sustaining force behind in iraq and when the president turned down the advice of his head national security advisers not to arm the free syrian army and a number of other decisions, that a laid the groupedwork for isis and now we have a situation where the largestndwork for isis and now we have a situation where the largest extremist caliphate in history is now in iraq and syria and we have no strategy we have no strategy to degrade or defeat it. >> well you are calling for a coherent strategy to combat this global terrorist movement which we're clearly witnessing but
what would that be? would that be more boots in syria, iraq afghanistan, yemen? what would that coherent strategy look like senator? >> well, first of all, it would require some boots on the ground not like before but we certainly need air controllers. we haven't been able to drive isis out of a town called cowanie using the full weight or american airpower for several months now. we lost 86 brave americans and 400 wounded to take fallujah. that's one-tenth the size of mosul. isis right now is winning, and we need to go after them and we need to have more boots on the ground. we need to understand that syria and iraq are the same. we need to arm the free syrian army and we need to man the no-fly zone and a coherent strat
g-that can be presented to the congress because they're going to be wanting an authorization for use of military force. >> let me clarify that when you say boots on the ground do you mean intelligence? do you mean combat? >> i mean intelligence. i mean forward air controllers. i mean traipertrainers. i mean more air assets. i mean across the board an increase and if you talk to any of our military experts, those not in the administration they'll tell you that's basically what we need and it's fairly obvious what we need and it's also obvious when the president did not leave a resid residual force behind as ryan crocker, bob xwaets and leon pa net ta said we could have that was the sem mole moment that led to the situation we're in today, the largest terrorist organization in history, so i appreciate eric holder keeping an eye on people that come and go but the fact is as long as
the incubeiator is there we're going to have people who are going to try to do what they did in paris a few days ago. >> senator, before i ask you another question, i want to point out to our viewers what they're seeing on the screen which is a picture now of all the world leaders, more than 50, who are linking arms and are marching in unity against terror down the streets of paris. it's quite an astonishing view you see, angela merkel there with hollande. let me get back to you, senator, on this. if you put boots, if you put intelligence on the ground how does that stop what attorney general holder called the lone wolves the folks who are being radicalized over the internet as senator feinstein was talking about, those people who are
uneducated perhaps, may be poor may be looking for some kind of salvation in another world, and how will that stop those people because that's what some folks are saying the kouachi brothers may have been and how can you combat all of the activity and what the british director of intelligence called all those dark places? >> well first of all, we have to have every muslim cleric in the world, especially in the west condemn this as a violation of the koran, and an honorable and decent religion. that has to happen and it hasn't been happening. second thing is obviously we have to try to track these people but look it's a threat the lone wolf. it is a serious threat but that's far different from sleeper cells manned by people who were trained as one of these young men was in yemen, the
success in yemen trained in yemen and training them right now in syria, where we have refused to help the free syrian army. they're killing more than we are training and we have to go to the heart of it because there's one thing to have a lone wolf and that's bad, but far worse is a person who has been trained and equipped and sent on a specific mission. that's where you get the big attacks. >> and senator, this female suspect as we know is probably on her way to syria, if she's not there already. >> yes, and obviously there was at least some training. the nature of that attack showed a degree of professionalism that no lone wolf could have carried out, and right now, in training camps throughout particularly syria, where we are leaving bashar assad alone with some incredible hope that the iranian iranians will work with us which is bizarre but right now
in syria, they are training people to go back to the country they came from and commit acts of terror. that was the view of the head of british intelligence not just mine. >> okay senator, thanks so much for being with us this morning, because now we're going to go back to paris where jake tapper is. jake we've been looking at these powerful pictures. can you tell us a little bit more about what you're seeing from your vantage point? >> reporter: well i'm in the thick of it here at the place de la republique where the crowds have gathered. the unity rally and march is set to begin at any moment and you can see these pictures. now people are starting to walk. you can see these pictures of, ads you say, very moving images of various world leaders, palestinian president mahmoud abbas, german chancellor angela merkel french president
francois hollande benjamin netanyahu, the prime minister of israel starting to walk from here the place de la republique and i believe they go north to the place de la nationale. there will be a couple of different pathways. security is very intense here gloria but the sentiment is strong. rain and cold and wind has not done anything to dissuade the crowd from being here and being excited to be here gloria. >> one can only imagine with all these heads of state netanyahu there for example. i know eric holder is representing the united states you're talking about the security being massive, but do you get any sense among the crowds that there's any fear of anything occurring, given what went on in paris this week? >> reporter: i have not been able to discern any fear at all. in fact quite the opposite defiance by being here. people are saying we're here we're strong we're not going
anywhere and you know when you walk down the street holding a sign saying "je suis charlie" "i am charlie, reference to the french satirical magazine "charlie hebdo," saying i don't care what you think, terrorists i'm standing here and standing up for the values represented by this country. it is a very stirring very moving display of solidarity and defiance by the people here hundreds of thousands now have gathered here. gloria i want to take one note to note a development, which is that rtl radio, a french radio here is reporting that paris police have told them they found amedy coulibaly, the terrorist who killed the policewoman on thursday and then took the hostages killing four innocent people at the kosher supermarket
on friday that they found an apartment that he was renting and they found a stash that included automatic weapons, detonators cash as well as isis flags. they're right now testing to see if they can find any evidence any forensic evidence that hayat b boumeddiene, that is the woman, his girlfriend also wanted, now thought to be in turkey or syria, whether she was there recently. that's just the latest on the investigation, gloria. >> jake you're talking about isis flags that he has. the other two seem to be aqap in yemen. i guess the question we have this morning is whether it actually has become such a global movement that it doesn't, the distinctions are blurring or whether these groups are competing with each other now for recruits. >> reporter: well the counterterrorism experts with whom i've been speaking both
here in france and back in the united states this morning, when i. you the that very question to them does this mean al qaeda, aqap and isis are working together they've really said first of all reports of a chasm between the two were perhaps overstated. it's more like a power rivalry, not that al qaeda has been so much disapproving of isis' tactics, as has been reported and also that this seems to at the very least be a matter of what senator condition can bejohn mccain was referring to not necessarily coordinated in syria and yemen, but more individuals put, who have self-motivated self-radicalized gone to france and organized, gloria. >> thanks so much jake.
we'll see you again at the top of the hour to talk more about this. >> reporter: thanks, gloria. >> for more i have two people who know about as much about counterterrorism as anybody i can think of that's jeremy bash former chief of staff to leon panetta at the cia at the defense department and fran townsend who ran homeland security at the white house for george bush and is now a cnn contributor. you heard what i was just talking to jake about which is isis aqap. are we now in a world where they're competing for each other, and this is a recruitment tool what we saw in france or are they all under the same banner at this point? i'll start with you, jeremy. >> well i think they're wolves. they may not be lone wolves. i think they're acting somewhat in concert with each other. the individual who took hostages at the supermarket clearly was
doing that to help his buddies who were across town at printing factory. so there is coordination. i think the fact that the individual at the kosher supermarket had pledged allegiance to isis and the others had clearly met with awlaki and gone to yemen and pledged allegiance to aqap i think that's disturbing. i think it shows this is a global anymad this is a networked jihad and they will cooperate when it suits their end. >> cooperate with each other rather than competing with each other. >> that's right, remember they share this ideology right, at its core this is a radical extremist, violent version and because they share that, there will be instances where they compete but their tactics and ideology are things they share. >> jeremy if you were at langley right now, and you were advising the cia director what would you be red flagging here? we had a rant this morning from the terrorist who took the hostages at the kosher market.
we've had a link with abdulmutallab, the underwear bomber. so what would you be red flagging over at the agency now? what are they doing? >> i think we first and foremost have to be looking at any individuals who have connections with any of these suspects so the analysts out at langley and the national counterterrorism center in northern virginia are scrutinizing all of our terrorist databases looking at travel looking at communications trying to understand who in the united states may have been in touch with these individuals and also whether we have any information that we can share with french authorities, with british authorities, with german authorities. >> was this a french failure of intelligence? >> fundamentally, when you lose 17 individuals in broad daylight it's a failure and no leader is proud of that moment. i think only time will tell to determine the extent of the failure, whether in fact if they had these people under surveillance probably some electronic surveillance, listening to the phones and watching what they write and
communicate but probably they didn't have them under physical surveillance surveillance and that's really an issue that the intelligence agencies don't have the resources to do that for everybody. >> is the physical surveillance a problem in this country as well? we don't have the manpower we don't have the resources. we have budget cuts. >> that's right, gloria but let's at least have one glimmer of good news and the good news is we have far fewer we believe, based on what eric holder told you this morning and the intelligence community said far fewer we have to worry about. when you ask about what should we be doing right now, the other thing is we know that one of the kouachi brothers trained at eman university under awlaki in sanai yemen. this was a known recruiting and training school. boy, oh boy, we ought to go back to see what americans trained there, where are they and what surveillance do we have against individuals who can pose a direct threat to the united
states. >> do you presume that the cia is looking at those links between americans and these terrorists in france as well as people who attended this university? >> absolutely. and i think they're looking at all those connections and they're looking at the individuals who have traveled back and forth to syria. they're looking at whether these people have links inside the united states and they're also going back and probably analyzing all the links to the aqap network that sent abdulmutallab on christmas day 2009 to blow up northwest flight 253 and detonate that underwear bomb that i saw a government demonstration of what that bomb would look like. that would have knocked the plane out of the sky. i have no doubt. >> well he met with one of these brothers, correct? >> he may have roamed with oneomed with one of the brothers and everybody will be unpacking, pulling the threads on sharing information and that basic blocking and tackling of intelligence work that will help us tisdisrupt the
plot. >> abdulmutallab is in the supermax prison somewhere. do you presume we are reinterrogating him about his links to these terrorists? >> sure american investigators are trying to do just that north to be able to understand what that relationship is what additional they may be able to learn about his movements and his contacts inside yemen, when they were together. >> now, two of these men were on the no-fly list. so that's great because we know they could not have gotten into this country. but generally they can roam on their eu passports around europe something that dianne feinstein was talking about that really worries her, this visa issue, and particularly if the know-fly list has holes in it taken could. how worrisome is that? >> i think it's worrisome first
of all, there are two issues. one is they can go between european countries seamlessly because they carry these shagen visas which allow them to cross borders without getting visas for each country. some countries don't require a visa to get into the united states. really our own line of defense is to ensure they are on a no-fly list and there are responsible airline security and airline officials at the airlines and airports who can stop them. >> so i want to bring in eirshad manji who can talk to us a little bit about how muslims have not been assimilated in france the way they may be assimilated in this country and that contributes to the problem france had that hopefully we will not have here. >> it doesn't help the fact in
france although it is a democracy there is a dogma that don't we don't experience here in the united states. [ speaking in foreign language ] which translates into secularism but is not the secularism as in separation of church and state that we know here rather french secularism is more of a disappearance of religion all together. so that many muslims, including young muslims, who may not be particularly religious, in fact most are not, nonetheless feel quite stifled in that area of their lives. on the other hand gloria and this is where some of the good news some of the optimism should come to play in you know the rate of intermarriage between muslims and non-muslims in france is high and is only growing, and historically intramarriage is a great indicator of integration. it also keeps a check on each of the parties, you know communities, and the most
extremist elements in them. so again that piece of the story will never make the news where the visuals what is the sensationalism behind it? but let's not forget this is a bigger picture here. >> you may be saying it's a generational issue, as much as people like fran and jeremy are out there fighting this terrorism that, in fact it may take a generation or two. >> precisely. >> to -- >> i can't begin to tell you how many messages i get from young muslims around the world, including in frabsnce who say that we are going to be raising our children with the values represented by reformist islam. >> we're going to go to paris for a moment. we're going to go to fred pleitgen who is in the middle of the massive rally there. you see there are more than 50 state leaders there rallying in defiance of the terror that struck paris this week. fred from your vantage point, tell me what it's like.
>> reporter: well it's absolutely amazing, gloria. we're right in the middle of this massive march called the unity march. i'm actually marching with the folks right now and what they're obviously showing is that in the aftermath of what happened here the past couple days of the horrible attacks, france as a nation is not going to allow itself to be divided. they want to show unity and that's exactly what this rally is about it's about unity of the nation really people here were telling me is that after what happened here after the terror attacks they believed that france had two possibilities. they were either going to let themselves be divided by the radical forces obviously on the one hand you have the radical islamists you have here and the radical right wing that you have in france but they say instead they want to show unity so what they're doing right now is beginning this march and it is absolutely amazing to see how many people came here because remember it's a fairly impromptu organization here. there's no speakers here. there's no stage or anything. there's a couple people here in the middle of the place de la
republique who were sort of leading the chants a little bit, but they don't have any sound system. nevertheless this crowd is absolutely on the same page with the way that they talk with the chants that they give and all of them are about unity. all of them is about not being intimidated, freedom of the press, freedom of speech and of course generally liberty, the freedom that france stands for and that's so important as a french value. so it is a positive vibe that's come from here as you can see the french flag sort of dangling over my head, that's the vibe coming from the people the reaction to all of this is going to be one of trying to unite everybody in france the jewish community, the muslim community and of course the christian community as well. they see that as something that is very important, and something that certainly is under threat gloria. >> a tremendous showing of national unity. thanks so much. we'll be getting back to you later. let me go to my panel here. first to you, jeremy bash. when you do have this sort of
outpouring, as you have in france how does that affect intelligence operations? do people become more aware, more supportive, more willing to fund? more willing to surveil after going through something like this? or not? >> i >> i ni you put your finger on a very good point. at moments on 9/11 the public in general has lost focus on the threat. and this has kind of waxed and waned in our country and in the public dialogue in the last 13 years and at times of danger and at times when we see terrorist attacks, there have been more support for more aggressive intelligence operations but then when we go through several months where we don't have an attack you hear choices saying why do we have to have more security, why do we have to have so much intelligence? i think this is a wake-up call. the international unity is i think is the exactly right
message to send that we have to be united we have to come together and we have to be forceful and aggressive in our confrontation of these terrible terrible, evil forces. >> fran you sat at the white house. talk about the coordination. i mean eric holder said earlier in the show we'll increase coordination. there's going to be a meeting in mid-february about increased -- i thought there was koord nationcoordination between the european allies and america in all our counterterrorism activities? is there not enough? >> the french have been -- and the british -- >> very aggressive. >> very strong allies a good exchange of information. but we know pre-9/11 we evenally didn't share the way we should have. >> do french operatives not like to share? >> you're trained to keep secrets but the show of national unity, what viewers are seeing on the screen what's most
important to me from my time at the white house is you've got to harness that now, right? it's more than just showing up. you see king abdullah and the queen of jordan. where are the leaders of egypt and saudi and the emirates? it's their fight, too. i think it's very important that it's not just a show of unity. you've got -- jeremy pointed out earlier to me you have mahmood abbas there, the palestinian leader who just cut a deal with hamas, a terrorist organization. it's more than just showing up gloria. >> it's kind of interesting he is actually showing up though. >> that's right. but you got to do more than show up. >> it's not -- >> i can tell you all that having been on the receiving end of death threats myself for writing about the need for refortunatelyre reform reform i have sometimes received information about those threats from journalists before i have received them from either the fbi or from other police forces around the world.
nypd by the way, the best counterterrorism force in the world as far as i'm concerned. everybody else they need work. >> and i should say that you are the founder of the moral courage project, and i just want to ask all of you if a young person about -- who is in the process of being radicalized is watching this picture that is so stunning to us, what's the reaction of that person? wouldn't it just inspire more defiance if you're already sort of on the road to being radicalized? it may unite us but what does it do to the young radical? >> it's hard to get inside that individual's head and on some level, gloria i think we have to be kind of radically honest. on the fridge of this islamic
fringe is a death cult. it's a stop at nothing, they don't share any of our values. they're not going to look to do anything and there are terrorists around the world who fan that emotion and that movement. and so there's very little we can do other than frankly, gird ourselves for a fight and take them off the battlefield. but then there's a whole other swath of individuals who are wondering, hey, wait a second do they have a point here? is there something here in it for me? is there something i'm attracted to? that's where i think, frankly -- >> martyrdom. >> -- muslim voices need to take the lead in explaining the faith of i was lanl isslam is not one that preaches radicalism. >> this is why part of what the moral courage program does we run a worldwide network of advisers who are available to anybody, including any muslim who is struggling with faith and has questions about faith. we are trying therefore, to be on the front lines of preempting
violence that might occur if we weren't there. but, you see, this is where support from governmentintelligence forces from governments, from private corporations that might be able to finance some of the work that my kind of a network does we're all in it together. a lot of people assume that fran does what she does and jeremy does what he does and, you know, i'm appreciative of them all but i can't contribute not true. everybody has a role in this. >> well fran you heard john mccain earlier talk about coming up with a coherent strategy out of the white house which he believes the white house has not had. he believes that you need more boots on the ground in a lot of places. he's not talking combat. he's talking counterterror. is he right? >> well there are several aspects to this right? you absolutely need a coherent
military strategy to attack the problem. but that has to be accompanied by as we saw, all tools of national power. a diplomatic financial sanctions, intelligence in law enforcement, and that then has to be integrated with your allies. you have to be working off common sets of objectives about what's the intelligence you're going after and how do you collect it. how do you deconflict and leverage assets that are limited. >> you need more intelligence on the ground. >> absolutely you need more intelligence on the ground. >> and jeremy, you're agreeing. >> absolutely. i'm kind of old-fashioned on this. i think if there's a no kidding plot out there the only thing that will stop it is recruiting an agent to go into the plot and report back to us. it's impossible to do for all the nation plots and all the people who are thinking about should i take up arms against -- >> so you don't think what happened in france was a game-changer? you think it's more of the same that we've seen or --
>> i do think it's a big wake-up call. >> as we see in these pictures it has been. >> and it's creating this international movement now to really wake up the world to the threat of radical islamic -- the global jihad. and i think that is not only a wake-up call but also an opportunity here for us to put more resources behind our security our law enforcement, our intelligence. look congress is now working trying to work out funding for the homeland security bill and that's going to be something that's going to happen over the next couple weeks and it remains to be seen whether congress will fund it. homeland security actually funds the security for a lot of our organizations inside the united states. if you're a nonprofit, you need that money. >> yeah. and you need that money to fight proper. right now we'll take a look at these pictures in paris. they're astonishing. we're going to go to christiane amanpour and jake tapper who are right there on the scene of this
amazing and inspirational rally. ♪ >> good afternoon from paris. i'm christiane amanpour along with my colleague jake tapper. it is a historic day for france. a human tidal wave millions of people have come out to say no to the bar barity that struck this nation on wednesday. >> it's been quite a week here starting with the attacks on the french satirical magazine charlie hebdo, but right now you see a demonstration of support from world leaders. you see benjamin netanyahu on the left there, the prime minister of israel. towards the right side mahmoud abbas and in the middle francois hollande arm in arm with german
chancellor angela merkel. >> this is a unique sight. we have seen this many world leaders circling in france linking arms walking in solidarity and in unity to say no to the bar barity that struck this nation and to join what is at least a million so far and they expect millions more. in the center of your picture, the president of france the chancellor of germany. perhaps the president of mali just next door. the foreign ministers and leaders of western europe. the king and queen of jordan. and as jake pointed out the prime minister of israel benjamin netanyahu and in the same row the president of the palestinian authority mahmoud abbas. as the french prime minister said today, we are not just all charlie. we are all police. we are all jews. we are all french today. as the french foreign minister said there is no democracy
without freedom and there is no freedom without freedom of the press. this is personal for our community. it was journalists doing an honest day's work who were slaughtered in cold blood on wednesday midday here in france and on friday the gunmen turned their sights on the jewish community at the hyper cacher market in the port de vincennes and five people were killed. the prime minister of israel benjamin nntetanyahu said to jews in frabsnce, we are your ref few. >> the prime minister of france has said there is no france without jews. >> the four jewish men killed at the kosher superintendent have been invited -- their families have been invited to bury them in the state of israel the jewish state. it's been inspiring, christiane and i have been here