Skip to main content

tv   Smerconish  CNN  November 21, 2015 3:00pm-4:01pm PST

3:00 pm
3:01 pm
i'm michael mer. this has been a tragic week for the world and pitiful week in american politics. to my ear, no one person has set forth both a strong and yet thoughtful response. several things stand out. last saturday night in des moines, despite isis' claim of responsible for the paris attacks, none of the democratic debaters would use the word radical islam. hillary clinton, bernie sanders, mart. o'malley, they all took a page out of the president's book assuming that using the term would be badmouthing all muslims. not true. look at what just happened in mali. gunmen stormed the radisson shouting allahu akbar and then reportedly released some hostages because they could recite the koran. why ignore the obvious religious motivation of the terrorists where it's entirely possible to distinguish their actions from peace loving muslims? on sunday, at a middle school in myrtle beach, ted cruz told reporters the u.s. should accept only christian refugees from syria. senator cruz, our constitution
3:02 pm
forbids religious tests as a qualification for federal office and it should be the same for refugees. and on monday when asked by the press at g-20 summit in turkey, as to whether he had underestimated isis, the president grew testy. but, mr. president, the questions pointing out that you once referred to isis as a jv squad, and more recently you said that isis was contained, they were totally fair. that same day presidential contender, chris christie, whose state shares statue of liberty off its shore told a radio interviewer that the u.s. couldn't risk allowing anymore syrian refugees, not even young children who had lost their parents. he said, quote, i don't think orphans under 5 should be admitted into the united states at this point. hey, governor, have you read what it says on that statue? what happened to send us your weary? tuesday i was disappointed to hear the routinely rational
3:03 pm
governor of ohio, john kasich, make a reactionary proposal. while speaking at the national press club, he proposed a new federal agency to promote judeo christian values. no, governor. promoting a set of religious values, that's what they do. it only got worse as the week wore on. thursday, when a reporter asked donald trump whether his white house would compile a database of all muslims in america, trump replied, i would certainly implement that, absolutely. and then he added that he would go beyond a database. he later tried to blame his poor response on the reporter's question. mr. trump, such a list doesn't sound fascist. it is. that same day in mobile, alabama, ben carson likened some syrian refugees to rabid dogs. dr. carson, do you realize that you're referring to people that isis itself regards as traitors? and then the house voted to halt the syrian refugee resettlement program, with 147 democrats joining 242 republicans.
3:04 pm
let me remind everyone, if we reject true refugees, we leave them with no choice but to choose between isis and bashar al assad. look, we're living in trying times that present a defining opportunity for american politicians to distinguish themselves. and somebody needs to step up and offer solutions as to how we best combat the threat we face from radical islam. i believe it's a combination of sober thinking, a strong response, and fewer sound bites. this story is far from over as the hunt for terror suspects continues. brussels is now on high alert. and for the latest, we go to cnn's senior investigative correspondent, drew griffin. drew, presume bring they got the specific intel or they would not have closed the metro system. what can you tell us? >> reporter: they said it is an imminent and serious threat. the prime minister went on tv
3:05 pm
this morning saying that they had information it was something akin to a paris-type attack, guns, explosions, in many locations but nothing specific in the targeting and that's what has so many concerned here. the belgian area is a wide region to be on high alert. basically what you're saying, we don't know where this could take place, could take place anywhere in the entire city and that's why concert venues have been closed, theaters have been closed, some shops have been closing. and people have been encouraged believe it or not the not to gather in groups. so on the one hand they are reacting to specific information. on the other hand, this is such a wide ranging threat, it seems pretty clear that belgian authorities don't have a handle on exactly where that threat might be targeted. michael? 6 >> in the span of the last week, a number of individuals have been taken into custody not only in belgium but also france. do we know whether this information came from anyone who has been apprehended?
3:06 pm
>> reporter: we know they that one arrest in a muslim community, three kilometers where i'm standing, where many of these paris attackers have come from or were hiding prior to the attack. we don't have many details on that arrest other than it was one man, he had some weapons and the police were clear to say there were no explosives found and in their press release, no suicide explosive vest was found. we don't have the exact timing of that arrest as it relates to the emergency threat measure which was put into place overnight. but the timing is somewhat suspect in that they made that raid last night, and then in the middle of the night, threat level raised from three to four, belgium's highest level, somewhat unprecedented here. >> and finally, why belgium? >> reporter: belgium has been the weak link, by all
3:07 pm
counterterrorism expert analysis, this country has not been doing enough to share income, and has not been doing enough to get its own information. the prime minister and other security officials vowed to put more money, resources, more manpower into fighting the terrorist threat within belgium, where many terrorists have come to buy their guns, weapons, fake passports and we know many terrorists have come to plot and plan attacks in europe. >> grew griffin, thank you for the update. there is hardly consensus among american politicians as to hour response to the terror threat. my next guest sees the debate as one involving stark choices. joining me now is the former cia intelligence officer who was in charge of the alex station, the hunt for bin laden at the cia. you know blogs at nonintervention.com. michael, anything i said at the outset that you want to respond to? >> i think the point you made, michael, about fascism is very
3:08 pm
important. notice both in europe and in the united states the first thing that happened after attacks was demand for more surveillance of the entire population and collecting their phone numbers and their calls and all of that. the founders were very clear. longer a war goes on, the more power accrues to the central government and you create a despotism. i think what we need more than anything is an american politician who will stand up and say listen, america comes first. what do we need to do? the answer at this time is that for the first time since 1996 when bin laden declared war, we have the ability to break the back of the caliphate. there wasn't one then. there is one now. but to have a caliphate, to have a nation state, you need hydroelectric dams and oil wells and electrical system and cell
3:09 pm
tower networks and you need minds engrained and a railroad. we have all of those targets, all of those targets play to our strength for a change. but there is not the one person out there who is willing to kill a civilian. so no matter what we do on the periphery, the islamic state and its caliphate continue to grow. basically because we are afraid to behave as if america counted more than anything. >> i read your blog, as you know, and it seems to me that you've presented this as an all in or all out proposition. i know what all out looks like. what does all in look like to michael scheuer? >> it would take out every piece of infrastructure, hospitals, universities, irrigation systems that a make it impossible for the islamic state to raise money, to provide electricity, sanitation, potable water. do exactly what we did to the
3:10 pm
germans. this is finally something that our military can do. it can't defeat these people on the ground, but it can destroy buildings and facilities. >> but we don't have the stomach for that. you've advocated not only going after hospitals, but also universities. do you think that the western world, americans in particular, would stand by for the film footage that would be shown on cnn and elsewhere of the so-cled innocent civilian death count? >> i don't know if they would. they should. what's the difference? they're not americans. we're defending ourselves. we wouldn't be there if we weren't attacked. my idea would be to destroy their infrastructure, and senator graham and senator mccain say the arabs are happy do this on the ground. let them do it after we're gone. and if they don't, it's their problem. >> is there anybody on the 2016 stage who is channeling you in the noninterventionalist path would seem to be a rand paul.
3:11 pm
the advocacy of an all in solution, i think would be donald trump. where are you as you look at candidates? >> i would never vote for anyone who served in the government so far. this government is corrupt. it is uninterested in protecting americans. and it drifts toward fascism. instead of being willing to take the footage you just described, you know, i'm a complete noninterventionist. i would rather get out of there right now and leave it all to the europeans and the arabs to sort out and come home, and let what's going on continue. and that will an all out shia- sunni war. >> so even though you've described the all-in approach, michael scheuer says, with your years of experience running the bin laden unit at the cia, we should stay out and let the sunni and shia forces have at it? wait until the dust settles, am i understanding you correctly? >> that's correct. it's almost a godsend for these people who believe in ala, ala
3:12 pm
may not be looking correctly at them because if it comes to a sunni/shia civil war that would engulf the region and be detrimental to their ability to both construct a caliphate and to attack us. >> let me ask this question. they use you for propaganda purposes i'm want to show a short snippet of video, and then ask a question. roll it, please. >> even with combat troops on the ground, we've proven that we cannot defeat these people. we are so incompetent in terms of conducting foreign policy and in terms of conducting military operation. >> why are they using you, what is the message they're trying to convey with michael scheuer? >> i think they're using the message that what i'm speaking of is the reality. and their reality, and they need that reality to continue to grow the caliphate and to attract people. >> michael, we've lost two wars. not because our marines and soldiers are bad, they're the best in the world, but because our politicians have lost the idea that fighting involves killing. and until you kill the enemy to the point where he does not want
3:13 pm
to fight anymore, you will lose. i don't think we have that gumption. i that you're exactly right. so the only option is to come home, defend our borders, rebuild our military and take care of ourselves and let the rest of the world go wherever they want to go. >> take away from michael is, either all in, or let the sunni and shia factions have at it or stay out. and i worry that we don't have the stomach for either. but thank you so much for being here. >> the halfway approach leads directly to fascism. >> so what do you think? tweet me and i'll read some of the best at the end of this program. just ahead, the new york city police department is stepping up its ability to rapidly respond to terror. with the closing of mass transit in brussels, i want to ask ray kelly what precautions need to be taken here. and as congress turns anti-muslim rhetoric into policy, i'll talk to one key governor who is not shutting the door to syrian refugees. ♪
3:14 pm
yeah. that's the one right? we forgot dave! thank you. so, can the test drive be over now? maybe head back to the dealership? it's practically yours, but we still need your signature. the sign then drive event. zero due at signing, zero down, zero deposit, and zero first months payment on a new tiguan and other select volkswagen models. but life was inviting us all this time. to step into the great unknown.
3:15 pm
in a place where riches... were measured in footsteps... flavors and friends. we tasted cuisine we'd only heard about and for the first time... felt like locals. ♪ call it magic. we called it ours. mazatlan. live it to believe it. whei just put in the namey, of my parents and my grandparents. and as soon as i did that, literally it was like you're getting 7, 9, 10, 15 leaves that are just popping up all over the place. yeah, it was amazing. just with a little bit of information, you can take leaps and bounds. it's an awesome experience.
3:16 pm
3:17 pm
digestive core.r so choose ultimate flora by renewlife. it has 30 billion probiotic cultures. feel lighter and more energized. ultimate flora. more power to your gut. we've learned new york city's police department is
3:18 pm
beefing up its ability to rapidly respond to terror with a new permanent unit that by year's enwill have more than 500 officers. that move has been in the works for a while, but it adds resources. the brussels subway system is closed today and threats by isis to hit new york city and washington, d.c. so how safe are americans and how difficult would it be to mount attacks here while many analysts have called the paris attacks sophisticated and coordinated, my next guest disagrees, saying they were shockingly simple. ray kelly is former new york city police commissioner, vice chair of k-2 security, he's written a memoir called "vigilance." for the brussels subway to be closed today, you'd think they have pretty specific intel, no? >> it appears that way. in fact that's what they said, it was the result of very specific information. but they're closing a larger area than just in brussels itself. so they have something going on.
3:19 pm
what it is, we can only guess. >> so here we are about to begin one of the biggest, if not the biggest travel weeks for the year in america. how concerned are you about americans flying, americans on the new york city subway, americans going back their day to day activities? >> look, we live in a dangerous world. but in new york's case, new york has done more than any other city in the world to protect itself. this latest move of creating a permanent unit, i think, is a good move. if i could have done it, i would have. we had a reduction of 6,000 police officers in our head count. this administration is hiring another 1,300 police officers. this is a good move. but we don't have specific information. i will say this, though, isis will try to do what it says it is going to do. they don't do too much bluffing. if they say they want to come to the u.s., want to come to new york and washington, i believe they will try to do it. >> chief bratton says we've gone
3:20 pm
blind regarding technical advances. that isis now has this capability of encryption. will you briefly speak to that concern? >> yeah, we have encryption now that has exploded all over the place. we have apps that are encrypted, obviously, cell phones don't allow law enforcement to get into that system. i think it should, but it looks like this administration and certainly the i.t. industry is against that. so we'll have a standoff, and the immediate situation is we simply can't get into these iphones and encrypted apps. >> in other words, they have apps now that isis is able to use for terror purposes that individuals who do what you used to do for a living, they can't crack, and if i understand what commissioner bratton is saying, we're not getting the support from silicon valley that we need to combat this? >> oh, that's correct. obviously very much against it. the administration says there is
3:21 pm
a key it will soon be breached, so it defeats the purpose of it. so, yeah, i don't see it changing anytime soon unless there is legislation from washington that mandates it. >> commissioner, mayor de blasio in new york city ended the dem graphics unit. what was that and is there still a need for it? given this threat? >> demographic unit was a unit to determine who was living in new york city. new york is the most diverse city in the world. and we wanted to know who was in the city. in many ways it's very tribal. it came about in 2003 when we saw suicide bombers in iraq coming from certain towns in libya. we wanted to know who in new york perhaps is from that area. so it was done above board, it was done in the open. it was never meant to create leads. and as we said many times, people have said no leads coming from this unit, it's like saying derek jeter never scored a touchdown. that was not the purpose of the
3:22 pm
unit. i'm assuming that function is going on now someplace else in the department without the unit being in existence. >> it seems like so much of the law enforcement activity in belgium is concentrated in one particular neighborhood, a neighborhood where there is a large muslim population. and my recollection is that the hands have been tied here in new york city for doing the type of mapping that you've just referenced because some people use the word profile as a pejorative. speak to that. >> i certainly hope that is going on someplace else in the department. as i say, new york is the most diverse city in the world. it's constantly changing. people come from all over. i think it's a very legitimate function of government to know where people are coming from and where they're settling in new york city, a city attacked twice 3,000 people killed. it's a clear function of
tv-commercial
3:23 pm
government that should be supported and not touted for its elimination. >> your book is titled "vigilance." thank you for being here. >> thank you. up next, in the wake of the paris attack, more than three dozen of america's governors have closed their borders to syrian refugees. i'll talk to one of the few who is letting them in. some cash back cards love to overcomplicate things. like limiting where you earn bonus cash back. why put up with that? but the quicksilver card from capital one likes to keep it simple. real simple. i'm talking easy like-a- walk-in-the-park, nothing-to-worry-about, man-that-feels-good simple. quicksilver earns you unlimited 1.5% cash back on every purchase, everywhere. it's a simple question. what's in your wallet?
3:24 pm
3:25 pm
3:26 pm
some neighbors are energy saving superstars. how do you become a superstar? with pg&e's free online home energy checkup. in just under 5 minutes you can see how you use energy and get quick and easy tips on how to keep your monthly bill down and your energy savings up. don't let your neighbor enjoy all the savings. take the free home energy checkup. honey, we need a new refrigerator. visit pge.com/checkup and get started today.
3:27 pm
digestive core.r so choose ultimate flora by renewlife. it has 30 billion probiotic cultures. feel lighter and more energized. ultimate flora. more power to your gut. in america the fallout of the recent isis attacks has been to amp up anti-islamic rhetoric and turn it into policy. the house easily passed a bill thursday that would suspend the program allowing refugees into the u.s. and and there were 47 democrats. the total is enough to override obama's promised veto. 31 governors have closed their doors to all syrian refugees,
3:28 pm
all but one are republican, a dozen on the fence and only seven states keeping the door open. including colorado whose governor john hickenlooper joins me now. i'll put up on the screen a map of the country that is color coded and shows the relative position of the different governors. you're one of the very few allowing refugees. what is it that you see that you think the others do not? >> well, first, my understanding is we don't really have a choice. in this country, our constitution, our laws, say that once someone is legally in the united states, governors can't say that they can't drive through your state, you can't say that they can't live in your state. we have the freedom of mobility. it's one of the reasons isis hates us. and i think sacrificing that freedom to make a political statement, you look at all the risk from terrorists, refugees go through years of background checks. that's not where terrorists come from.
3:29 pm
they're getting student visas or tourist visas. it's just you out of balance. so our sense is if the president of the united states says that this is our foreign policy and part of our war on terror, then i think i feel that as a governor, i took an oath to uphold the laws of this country, i think i have to follow through. >> i know that we invited at least ten of the republicans who feel differently about this to come on and explain themselves and they opted not to. have you satisfied yourself that the vetting process that is currently used for the syrian refugees is satisfactory and safe for colorado residents? >> well, like any governor, the safety and security of our community is the number one concern. so i have every belief that the federal government is continually trying to improve the vetting and making sure that that screening process goes through. but at a certain point, after
3:30 pm
2010 they redid the whole thing. the top minds in the department of state and all the military agencies all worked together on this, the counterterrorism institute -- or counterterrorism center, all these people are doing the best they can and at a certain point you have to say you know back since 1980, we've had millions of refugees come here, through vetting processes and traditional law enforcement, so far not one of the refugees has done an act of terrorism in the united states. >> why then, i'll put on the screen polling data, 53% of americans feel differently than you do. why do you think the polling is as decidedly opposed to your view? i mean, it says only 28% want to resettle 10,000. has this not properly been explained to the american people? what do you see in that data? >> well, it's an election year so a lot of voices with a lot of
3:31 pm
different opinions. and anyone who watched the events in paris as they happened, i mean, these people are creating terror. the terror ifs are succeeding in creating fear. but we have to fight back against that. and i think this is -- and this is -- we are at war and we have to recognize that winning a war is not just military. we're fighting for the hearts -- at some point five, ten years from now, syria, we'll win this war and we'll want people to go back to syria and want to live there. and we want them to come with some sense of that this is where democracy can be. and ideally, they will want to live there and defend their country and fight for it in a way that they can't do or at least they feel they can't do now. >> finally, let me show you a paul ryan quote, the speaker paul ryan said this, we cannot let terrorists take advantage of our compassion. this is a moment where it's
3:32 pm
better to be safe than sorry. we were all raised with that adage. why didn't it apply here, according to you? >> well, i think -- i think we have to keep improving and make sure our safety is at our maximum highest priority. i don't disagree with that at all. but i also recognize that a terrorist is not going to go through a refugee program where they spend 2 1/2 to 4 years of intensive interrogation and process. these are the tailors and candlestick makers, these are mostly orphans and widows. the reason they are refugees generally is because isis hated them and they were being persecuted or terrorized in their home country. i think if we send them away, we're playing right into isis' hands. >> they then have a choice of either joining bashar al assad or joining isis. i totally get your point. governor, thank you for being here. this week, another governor,
3:33 pm
john kasich, who is running of course for president, said our government should have a judeo- christian values agency. i have a problem with that. isn't that the concept that is awfully close to what isis is all about? and, in fact, what is the ultimate goal of the isis terrorists? the author of a widely read article, what isis really wants, says it's all about the koran. an american professor who is a muslim scholar says they're criminals and ignoring their religion. both of them are next.
3:34 pm
ono off-days, or downtime.ason. opportunity is everything you make of it. this winter, take advantage of our season's best offers on the latest generation of cadillacs. the 2016 cadillac srx. get this low-mileage lease from around $339 per month, or purchase with 0% apr financing. i was on the bus and i couldn't stop streaming. i don't even want to think about the overages. it's okay. t-mobile now has binge on, so you can stream all the movies, tv and sports you want without using your data. it's like...free. so it's okay that i binged an entire season during my kid's piano recital? i've done that. yeah. i'm binging right now. you know, i think we've made a real breakthrough here today. what? aw, he dies in this episode. introducing binge on. with t-mobile, stream video free without using data
3:35 pm
from netflix, hbonow, hulu and many more. how much prot18%?does your dog food have? 20? nutrient-dense purina one true instinct with real salmon and tuna has 30% protein. support your active dog's whole body health with purina one. it begins from the the second we're born.er. because, healthier doesn't happen all by itself. it needs to be earned every day. using wellness to keep away illness. and believing a single life can be made better by millions of others. as a health services and innovation company optum powers modern healthcare by connecting every part of it. so while the world keeps searching for healthier we're here to make healthier happen.
3:36 pm
milk has 8 grams of high-quality protein. which could be the difference between just living life. and milking it. start every day with the power of protein and milk life.
3:37 pm
i'm asking, is our strategy working? >> what strategy? tell me what the strategy is and i'll tell you if it's working. that right there is the problem because they have a strategy. they're gathering right now in raqqah by the tens of thousands. hidden in the civilian population. and they know exactly why they're there.
3:38 pm
>> why is that? >> they call it the end times. what do you think the beheadings are about? crucifixions, revival of slavery. do you think they make that [ bleep ] up? it's all in the book, the only book they read it all the time. they never stop. they're there for one reason and one reason only, to die for the caliphate and usher in a world without infidels. that's their strategy and it's been that way inside since the 7th century. so do you really think that a few special forces teams are going to put a dent in that? >> that scene from the showtime siris "homeland" couldn't be more relevant. so what does isis really what? graham wood is it a contributing editor at the atlantic and lecturer at yale university. when he wrote an essay with that as the title, it was posted more than a million times on facebook and tweeted more than 41,000
3:39 pm
times. and an expert in islamic law who teaches at rutgers university law school. graham, peter quinn was channeling your essay. no? isn't that your point? >> yes, he got most of it right. when isis describes what it wants, it wants exactly as is he says islamic state along a particular line, closely associated with end times belief, the belief that they are ushering in the apocalypse by doing this. >> and you say their most ardent followers derive from a coherent even learned interpretation of the koran. >> that's right of i'm spoken to followers of isis and the writings of some of the leaders of isis. and yes, they know their text. they have a very specific and weird interpretation of the texts, but they read them very carefully. >> is it a weird interpretation or a literal interpretation? >> it's a kind of literal weird interpretation. there is a long history of
3:40 pm
islamic law that is not literal in the sense that they read it, but they have a kind of learned view of this that breaks from islamic tradition. but breaks in creative ways that are closely attached to the text that they cite. >> do you agree? >> absolutely not. it is the farthest thing from a learned interpretation, it's a political reading. of religious texts. isis is nothing but a political ideological movement. they're a bunch of criminals that are deforming the religious text to serve a political agenda. their agenda is a reign of terror that contradicts the overarching moral and humanitarian framework of the koran. the koran and the directives of islam prevent and prohibit the killing of women, children, elderly. desecration of houses of worship. destroying harvests are not acceptable. if an enemy asks for peace, the
3:41 pm
koran says you have to give him that peace. there's no compunction in religion, there's no coercion. this is directly against every tenet of what islam is. they are a political group that has a reign of terror to serve a political agenda. it's deformed. it's disjointed. it's incohesive and it's based on the ba'athist regime who have created this agenda. >> is this what we would be if we acted via a literal interpretation of deuteronomy? >> i think that's a good way to look at it. >> we've been able to discount some of that kind of stuff in the older new testament. >> that's right. and what he just said is, i think, a good reflection of the mainstream islamic point of view about isis. however, what isis agrees with him about is that they are taking 1,000 years of tradition and reforming it, they're reading it in a different way and in a what that is disagreed
3:42 pm
with by most muslims. >> is i reformation necessary of islam, is that what eneed cleanse the koran or some of that which they point to? >> absolutely not. a reform is not needed. there is discourse and theological discussions going on for 100 years about the role of the koran and the moral message that is in the koran that that has relevance to modernity in what we're having. what we need to do is look at the underlying causes, political social and economic underlying causes for the rice of isis. isis was created because of our foreign policy in that region and it was created by the regional dictatorships that are in that region that are repressive. and keep in mind, all of these tortures and things that we're seeing that isis is doing, these are not new to that region. mubarak regime, assad, saddam did that. this repression, torture, excessive repelling force has been in existence, all has happened is the secular nationalists, for example the
3:43 pm
ba'athist general, he's one leaders of isis. he's doing the same repression. >> again, those is something isis would agree with. isis, when it talks about its origins, they say that it was born out of a vacuum of governance, that the american invasion allowed to come into being. but then they say that they are reviving practices. they are in that vacuum finding a space to take these practices that they read from the 7th century and then enact them. when they do that, they do it in a way, again, that is surprising to many people, that is shocking and is in itself i think a kind of reformation of islam. >> it's hard for me to be the arbiter of what islam does or does not represent, but in your piece you quote from a princeton professor bernard hakkel who says that the distorted the text is a politically incorrect view.
3:44 pm
respond to that. >> there are many people who would simply see practices like slavery, like beheading of infidels, say that these have nothing do with islam. they certainly have nothing to do with the practice of islam by most muslims today. but are they things that have happened in islamic history? islamic histories a vast tradition that includes these things. so there is a cotton candy view of islam that forgets that these were practices. >> respectfully, is he promoting the cot. candy view of islam? >> and he is well aware of the history of islam and well aware of the many ways that you can interpret islam not to require any kind of beheading or stoning today. >> final thought. >> i'm not coming cotton candy islam. i'm advocating the concept of mainstream. isis is the fringe of the fringe of the fringe. does not represent islam. the problem is not islam. blaming islam won't resolve isis. isis will only be resolved by the underlying causes that we
3:45 pm
need to take care of militarily and also by economics and political solutions in that region. >> appreciate you both being here. i wish we had more time. thank you. so where do you stand on this debate? tweet me and i will read some of your tweets at the end of the broadcast. just ahead, for me, john kasich has been one of the rational gop presidential candidates. now he want as government agency to promote judeo christian values. i don't think it's a good idea and i will talk with a top conservative about that next.
3:46 pm
3:47 pm
3:48 pm
3:49 pm
.
3:50 pm
presidential candidate john kasich is touting an idea to spread judeo-christian ideas. >> i will consolidate them into a new agency that has a clear mandate to promote the core judeo-christian western values that we and our friends and allies share, the values of human rights, the values of democracy, freedom of speech, freedom of religion, and freedom of association. >> i want to ask tony perkins about that. he's the president of the family research council, a conservative policy and lobbying organization. tony thanks for being here. i've been favorably disposed to john kasich from what i've seen of him thus far. that disappointed me. what was your reaction? >> well good morning, michael. i actually would have to agree with you on that. i don't think we they'd more government. government is the problem. we don't need government to promote judeo-christian values. what we need are government
3:51 pm
leaders that respect our constitutional freemgs of the freedom of religion and that means the foreign minister of expression which has been consistently under attack under the last seven years of this administration. so we need elected leaders that are committed to upholding and living by the constitution. >> i know that governor kasich walked back a portion of that but i focused more on what you just said which is the establishment of a new agencies or a new arm of the bureaucracy. that wasn't the part that was troublesome to me. the troublesome part is we'll seek to expand our religious interpretation, so-called judeo-christian values, that plays right into the hands of isis. that's the part i was finding problematic. >> right. well, let me be very clear. i don't want a government that embraces a religion and promotes a religion. what set up a government that respects religion, which is what we are supposed to have. i don't want a government that is exporting their brand of christianity or anything else.
3:52 pm
what i do want is a government and not just me but millions of americans a government that respects the right of christians to live according to their faith and take that abroad and we do want those principles of religious freedom. that's not an american right. that's a fundamental human right even the united nations recognizes that. it should be a factor in our foreign policy that we expect other nations to respect the human right of the religious freedom of religion which this administration has not done. >> i think we're saying the same thing. i expand to it say freedom of religion or even freedom from religion because you and i both know what the establishment clause says. leapt me ask you about a related subject. the syrian refugee situation. how does tony perkins look at that. should we be letting them in? >> well, i think what was expressed by congress this week and coechoed by the american people throwing open the door to refugees was confirmed by the french prime minister yesterday who said the attacks, the
3:53 pm
terrorists that did the attacks there last week used the crisis created by the syrian conflict to slip into the country. look, we have an obligation to protect americans. now, i think what congress did was reasonable. slow down this process. make sure we're vetting them. we let those who meet the criteria into this country. i would say the president has impose ad reverse religious test in some ways that opposite of what some have called -- >> how so? >> when you look at -- when you look whose come in under the president's policy. 97% have been muslim. 2.5% christian. if you look who isis is targeting forex termination it's christians, yazidis other religious minorities. they should be given higher priority. >> i only have 30 seconds left. isn't that a reflection of the fact that christians are few and far between in that part of the
3:54 pm
world. >> no. they are 10 puerto ri% of the p in syria. that should be reflected in the amount of refugees coming in to this country and it's not. >> tony perkins thank you for being here. still to come -- your best tweets of the program. they are just moments away. ♪ the way i see it, you have two choices; the easy way or the hard way. you could choose a card that limits where you earn bonus cash back. or, you could make things easier on yourself. that's right, the quicksilver card from capital one. with quicksilver you earn unlimited 1.5% cash back on every purchase, everywhere. so, let's try this again. what's in your wallet? i am totally blind.
3:55 pm
and sometimes i struggle to sleep at night, and stay awake during the day. this is called non-24. learn more by calling 844-824-2424. or visit your24info.com. withof my moderate to severe rheumatoid arthritis... ordinary objects often seemed... intimidating. doing something simple... meant enduring a lot of pain. if ra is changing your view of everyday things orencia may help. orencia works differently by targeting a source of ra early in the inflammation process. for many, orencia provides long-term relief of ra symptoms. it's helped new ra patients and those not helped enough by other treatments. do not take orencia with another biologic medicine for ra due to an increased risk of serious infection. serious side effects can occur including fatal infections. cases of lymphoma and lung cancer have been reported. tell your doctor if you're prone to or have any infection like an open sore, the flu, or a history of copd,
3:56 pm
a chronic lung disease. orencia may worsen your copd. if you're not getting the relief you need... ask your doctor about orencia. orencia. see your ra in a different way. ok, wehere's dad. mom. the twins. aunt alice... you didn't tell me aunt alice was coming. of course. don't forget grandpa. can the test drive be over now? maybe just head back to the dealership? don't you want to meet my family? yep, totally. it's practically yours, but we still need your signature. the sign then drive event. zero due at signing, zero down, zero deposit, and zero first months payment on a new jetta and other select volkswagen models.
3:57 pm
3:58 pm
i like to say you can follow me on twitter if you can spell smerconish. a lot of reaction including comments about my open commentary. she said, you know, i'll say stuff is getting real when smerconish starts his show angry and sounding very hawkish. she said i think we had a really pitiful week in american
3:59 pm
politics and the response from so many of our elected officials is not what it should have been. gary said excellent opening monologue. as long as we govern in sound bites no solid solution exists. we're harmed this is being played out in political season. it's being condensed in 20 second sound bites. this from julia who comments we have christians in our own land who distort the bible as isis has done with the koran. remember waco. i would say this. there's justification in the bible for a lot of bad behavior. we've been able to learn to discount all of that and not act in accordance with it and frankly i think many muslims need to learn to do the same thing with regard to the koran. i'm making reference to only those that perpetrate jihad in the name of allah. did that guest really say bomb hospitals to stop people who
4:00 pm
hate snaus that's h hate you? he says look we either got to go all in or just stay the heck out. keep the tweets coming @smerconish. i'll see you next week. hello and welcome to our viewers in the united states and around the world. i'm poppy harlow joining you live tonight from paris. this is our special continuing coverage of the aftermath of the tragic terror attacks. we begin in brussels where it is 1:00 in the morning and the city is on lockdown because of the quote, serious and imminent possibility of a paris style terror attack there. that warning coming directly from the belgian government as it raised the terror threat level to maximum. the fear is that individuals with weapons and explosives could target multiple locations at once. also new tonight french m

100 Views

info Stream Only

Uploaded by TV Archive on