Skip to main content

tv   CNN Newsroom With Fredricka Whitfield  CNN  October 21, 2017 10:00am-11:00am PDT

10:00 am
for a speech in which he rejected trump-era nationalism. listen to just some of bannon's remarks last night. >> president bush to me embarrassed himself. speechwriter wrote a hi high-falooting speech. it's clear he didn't understand anything he was talking about. he equates the industrial revolution, the agricultural revolution, globalization, he has no earthly idea whether he's coming or going. just like it was when he was president of the united states. i want to apologize up front to any of the bush folks outside, in this audience, okay. because there's not been a more destructive presidency than george bush's. the rise of china started with the clintons and bush. when they had this great theory that you let them in to the world trade organization and give them most favored nations, they're going to become a liberal democracy as they get bigger, okay, and they're going
10:01 am
to become more free market capitalist. this is not a small mistake. this is a strategic mistake of incalculable problems. >> cnn's boris sanchez live right now from the white house. boris, bannon was outwardly promoting president trump. any reaction from the white house on that effort? >> none yet, fred, but this is really something we've seen from steve bannon before. he has a track record of going after these republican establishment figures like senator bob corker or the senate majority leader mitch mcconnell. just last week he compared mitch mcconnell to julius caesar, saying people on capitol hill were searching for his brutus. this, however, is on a different level. these visual attacks on a former president fully questioning his intelligence, saying that he didn't know what he was saying. when former president bush gave that speech on thursday in which he talked about the dangers of
10:02 am
nativism and of trade protectionism. he also talked about bigotry, being emboldened in our country. and he specifically said that he believed that the nation was more susceptible to conspiracy theories. he didn't call out president trump or steve bannon by name but if you read between the lines, he's referring to things like birtherism and economic nationalism. so in a sense this is a bit of a tit-for-tat. steve bannon certainly vowed to go after anyone that challenged president trump when he left the white house as the chief strategist here. he's certainly doing that. don't forget that he is now currently recruiting republican candidates to challenge incumbents. and he's fund-raisinging for the midterm elections next year. some of the people he likely will challenge are people that the president will now need to move his agenda ahead. whether on a reforming obamacare or tax reform, fred. >> and, boris, stay with me on this.
10:03 am
because tonight we'll also see all five former u.s. presidents take the stage for a benefit concert for hurricane relief efforts and part of the one america appeal campaign. the concerts will feature rock and country musicians. the white house apparently just released a message from president trump who will not actually be on stage at the event tonight. but listen. >> my fellow americans. the heartbreaking devastation cautioned by hurricanes harvey and maria and nate, a long with the terrible wildfires in california, have impacted millions of our fellow americans. as a nation, we mourn for those who died and we pray for those who lost their homes or their livelihoods. in the aftermath of these terrible storms, the american people have done what we do best. we came together, we helped one another. and through it all, we remained resilient. we came together as one. as we rushed to the aid of
10:04 am
texas, louisiana, florida, puerto rico, and the u.s. virgin islands. now, as we begin to rebuild, some of america's finest public servants are spearheading the one america appeal. through this effort, all five living former presidents are playing a tremendous role in helping our fellow citizens recover. to presidents jimmy carter, george h.w. bush, bill clinton, george w. bush, and barack obama, melania and i want to express our deep gratitude for your tremendous assistance. this wonderful effort reminds us we truly are one nation under god, all unified by our values and our devotion to one another. i also want to thank every person, including everyone here tonight who has contributed to this vital effort. there's a lot of work ahead of us. i want to thank groups like the points of light for making such a big difference in our disaster
10:05 am
response efforts. together, we will recover. we will rebuild. and we will come back stronger and better than ever before. thank you, god bless you and may god bless the united states of america. >> all right, so that's the video statement that will also get some air time during the concert tonight in texas. so boris, back with me now, also joining us, cnn's calley hearttongue. calley, you first, in the release of this video, the appearance of the sitting president while five former presidents are there live. >> well, fred, it was not long after we confirmed with the george h.w. bush presidential foundation that president trump would be involved tonight by way of that video message that the white house then released the video. quite frankly, it's been really difficult to get a straight answer from either party about whether or not the president was invited and why he wouldn't be a part of tonight's event
10:06 am
otherwise. this video, the answer we're getting from both sides, when asked that question. this event on people's calendars for a long time. it was originally scheduled to be the 20th anniversary celebration of george h.w. bush's foundation. but as those floodwaters ravaged houston and hurricane harvey devastated so much of the coast of texas, it was george h.w. bush himself had the idea to turn this celebration into an opportunity to raise funds for those in need. that need of course grew with hurricanes maria and irma. we do know tonight we will see all five former living presidents on stage together. though, fred, it's unclear who among them will address the crowd. >> portion, tboris, the white h strategy, the importance of releasing this video now as opposed to saving it until this, you know, this evening, and then unanswered from the white house as to why the president wouldn't be there live.
10:07 am
>> hey there, fred, yes, so there was a bit of a response from the white house in terms of the video. they said that -- they expressed a deep gratitude for being asked to participate in the event. there's no clear indication as to why the president wouldn't be there in person. but it's not really hard to imagine that the optics would be odd. just this week, you had two former presidents, as we were discussing earlier, george w. bush and barack obama directly and indirectly talking about the state of politics in this country in a negative light with some allusions to this administration. bill clinton is also going to be there. the president as recently as last week been tweeting about the former first lady and secretary of state hillary clinton in not positive terms. there's no love lost between president trump and the clintons so it would be an odd optic to be on stage at the same time, even if for a good cause. i did want to point out the president did thank all these
10:08 am
former presidents, even those who have been critical of him by name, saying he's deeply grateful for their efforts and a built to work together signals we are all one united nation, fred. >> okay. boris sanchez, caylee hartung, thank you. let me bring in our cnn contributor, a national political reporter for "the washington examiner." also cnn analyst nathan gonzalez. good to see you both. okay so now we have this video of the president, the sitting president's message that will be played during the concert tonight where there will be five living, you know, former u.s. presidents and president trump expressing there that melania want to express deep gratitude, to the assistance for all here and showing this great unity and values and there's more after that. sell ly selena, what's your reaction to the video that sends a message of unity, and yet the sitting
10:09 am
president won't be there and then you have that with this backdrop of all kinds of language disparaging former presidents obama and george w. bush, and their criticism, even though they didn't use the name trump, but seemingly directed at the sitting president. so how do you make sense of all these varying messages? >> well, i think that americans have actually for centuries been able to separate the drama and the theatrics of politics and going after each other even though we've entered a new phase in terms of twitter, social media and so forth in the way that president trump uses those social media applications. but also that ability at the end of the day to be gracious and show unity when it's really important. especially, you know, in the aftermath of all the disasters that this country has faced in the past 2 1/2 months.
10:10 am
so i don't know that it's that big of a struggle for the american people to see, you know, on a daily basis the president trump butting heads and taking on his political opponents. when it's important and benefits the country for him to be gracious and say hay we're all in this together, this is really important, and i want to thank all the former presidents, you know, who are involved with this. can i say it's so cool that we have six presidents, five former presidents -- >> it's extraordinary. >> yeah, i don't know that's ever been repeated in our history. that's really great. >> it is extraordinary. but, myth, it also seems like this would be a beautiful opportunity, a real opportunity seized to have the former presidents and the sitting president speak in a unified voice, particularly when there has been so much dissension expressed. so is this a missed opportunity for this white house? >> well, i tend to think that
10:11 am
the way it looks like it's going to play out, as boris was saying, is probably the best way. i mean, if the president had showed up at the event, i think there would be so much media attention on every comment, every look and glance, every comment between the former presidents and the current president. i think, you know, what we're seeing, we're seeing the president fill what most people would call a presidential role in this event. and if people are going to criticize president trump for not being there, they're probably criticizing his overall performance and performance on the hurricanes and the other natural disasters. but i think it could be -- you could see it as a missed opportunity but i think it would be a distraction from the real purpose of the event. >> okay. meantime, as we're talking, we're also coming off a very tough week for so many. for the families involved. of the four fallen green berets in niger. the white house is handling of criticism of congresswoman,
10:12 am
listening to a conversation, and now live pictures right now of the procession of the hearse carrying sergeant la david johnson there in cooper city, florida. his body returning to the family this past week. now the hearse and this motorcade now taking the body of this young man after the funeral, taking place at the christ rock church there in cooper city. and so now selena, the white house is also, you know, still dealing with just a series of events surrounding this sergeant and now the ongoing investigation which might be intensifying about niger. what do you see the pathway now for the white house in terms of dealing with so many controversies surrounding the deaths of these young men, and at the same time, trying to offer some control of what
10:13 am
appears to have been a sequence of rather chaotic events. >> well, i think it's really important and i hope it's the direction that the president and the administration takes in that they get to the bottom of what happened in niger. you know, we don't have all of the facts. we have some here, some there. and, you know, it is clear that these young men that were put in this position were not prepared, nor was the auxiliary operation was prepared as it appears. so i think that's the most important thing out of all of this. obviously honoring the soldiers that have fallen. in terms of everything -- the soap opera that played out this year, this week, was really embarrassing on all parts. in that, you know, it probably would have -- probably had been best that congresswoman wilson had -- after she -- after that event happened, that she called the white house privately and said, hey, look, i don't think that this went the way you
10:14 am
wanted it to. i think you need to give this family a call. and for the president, on the president's part, he didn't need to react the way he did. i think all of this could have been avoided if people were a little more discrete and a little less theatrical about their politics but unfortunately, that's the era we live in now. >> and nathan? >> i think if we take a step back -- i want to be careful not to -- if we take a step back specifically from the congresswoman and the fallen soldier, you know, this isn't a president who backs away from conflict. i think he enjoys conflict. i think he sometimes incites conflict intentionally. and so he doesn't -- this doesn't bother him. i don't know what we're going to -- as long as he's president, there's going to be a time where we -- where we lack a consistent drum beat of some level of drama and conflict going on because i think that the president, he almost feeds off of it. so this is a -- he came in as a very different type of president.
10:15 am
i think he's going to govern as a very different type of president. >> all right, again, live pictures right now out of coopers city, florida. the body of 25-year-old ladavid johnson. sergeant ladavid johnson, on its way to the burial ground, after a funeral taking place in his hometown of cooper city at the christ rock church. he's a father of two. father of a 2-year-old and a 6-year-old. now being laid to rest. at any moment when they do reach that burial ground. all right, is elena and nathan gonzalez, thank you so much, appreciate it. all right, coming up, a sobering warning from a top republican. >> the war is headed to africa. it's beginning to morph as we suppress the enemy in the mideast. they're going to move. they're not going to quit. >> details on the latest u.s. effort to combat the expanding global terror network.
10:16 am
hey, you every talk to anybody about your money? yeah, i got some financial guidance a while ago. how'd that go? he kept spelling my name with an 'i' but it's bryan with a 'y.' yeah, since birth. that drives me crazy. yes. it's on all your email. yes. they should know this? yeah. the guy was my brother-in-law. that's ridiculous. well, i happen to know some people. do they listen? what? they're amazing listeners. nice. guidance from professionals who take their time to get to know you. looking for a hotel that fits... whoooo. ...your budget? tripadvisor now searches over...
10:17 am
...200 sites to find you the... ...hotel you want at the lowest price. grazi, gino! find a price that fits. tripadvisor. pabut with odor free blue-emu continuous pain relief spray, i can box out any muscle or joint pain immediately. blue-emu continuous pain relief spray, it works fast and you won't stink. our recent online sales success seems a little... strange?nk
10:18 am
na. ever since we switched to fedex ground business has been great. they're affordable and fast... maybe "too affordable and fast." what if... "people" aren't buying these books online, but "they" are buying them to protect their secrets?!?! hi bill. if that is your real name. it's william actually. hmph! affordable, fast fedex ground.
10:19 am
from thecompanystore.comwith the new lacrosse comforter made in america and handcrafted in wisconsin. our exclusive hypoallergenic down and special breathing technology senses your body to never be too hot or too cold, so you are guaranteed the best sleep ever. starting at only $99 including shipping and a lifetime guarantee. for your best friend - our new dog beds are just as dreamy and made with the same quality and advanced technology. this offer is for a limited time, so visit today.
10:20 am
welcome back. the hearse carrying sergeant la david johnson now making its way to the burial ground after a morning funeral of the 25-year-old. he is one of four green berets killed in an ambush in niger. this father of two now being laid to rest. and husband. there in his hometown of cooper city, florida. flags across the state are flying at half-staff today as a sign of respect. you see the arrival there. now the burial grounds. the 25-year-old killed during that ambush just earlier this month. the incident prompting a deluge of questions over the past week. a formal investigation is under way after early reports that johnson's body was found nearly a mile from the three other u.s. troops killed in niger. many civilians here in the u.s. asking why were the u.s. troops in niger in the first place and even u.s. senator lindsey graham issuing this stark warning.
10:21 am
>> the war is headed to africa. as we suppress the enemy in the middle east, they're going to move, they're not going to quit. >> cnn senior diplomatic correspondent michelle kosinski. the fbi is now on the ground in niger, helping to evaluate evidence there. are there any new details? >> there are a few and you know there's been criticism and all of these questions over the last two weeks really. even over some of the most basic details. there's been back and forth reporting from u.s. officials over whether these troops were even in their unarmored vehicles or were they outside. you know, what was the situation really. and what was the time line. a lot of that is unknown. a few details that have come out of this investigation being led by africa command, the fbi, all four branches of the military,
10:22 am
include that, as soon as it was realized that 25-year-old sergeant la david johnson was miss i missing the search started immediately. they want the public to know dozens more u.s. troops were moved into the capital to be ready. some of them did go into the field. in terms of the investigation itself, we know all members of the team is there been interviewed. there's also something new out of the state department today. there was beginning in the los angeles times that is viewed by some u.s. officials that the u.s. ambassador to niger had been pushing back or was resistant to u.s. military requests for more support, more equipment, more medical support. the state department is flat out denying that any requests were
10:23 am
rejected by the ambassador. this close cooperation ensures activities are coordinated and sustainable. the president directs that disagreements, which are rare, are quickly referred to the secretary of defense. what they didn't answer, was there resistance to request for more support in niger? because that's how they're saying that the disagreements or pushback or any of that is handled. there are question marks that remain in terms of the situation on the ground. the investigation and what contact may have gone on between the state department and the department of defense over this, fredricka. >> michelle, the fbi is involved, is apparently
10:24 am
customary, but is there any reason to believe the investigation will be any different in this case? any different from any other mission that results in the death of u.s. troops? >> that's a good question. obviously because of these questions and because of the time frame, that some of these basics are not known at least to the public two weeks after the firefight. that's disturbed people like senator john mccain, the chairman of the service committee. he's alluded to the fact there could be calls for a congre congressional over this. given the pressures there, we know the pentagon has wanted to emphasize, you know, all of the aspects of this investigation. that it's broad. but he hasn't wanted to rush it. so we know some of those details that the pentagon has given us. but we also know because of the complexity here, it could take quite a long time too. >> all right, michelle, thank you. all of this of course as we look at live pictures out of cooper
10:25 am
city, florida. very sad painful day for the family of 25-year-old sergeant la david johnson. being laid to rest. we'll be right back. tais really quite simple.est it comes in the mail, you pull out the tube and you spit in it, which is something southern girls are taught you're not supposed to do. you seal it and send it back and then you wait for your results. it's that simple. i am totally blind. and non-24 can throw my days and nights out of sync, keeping me from the things i love to do. talk to your doctor, and call 844-214-2424. t-mobile's unlimited now includes netflix on us. that's right. netflix on us. get 4 unlimited lines for just $40 bucks each. taxes and fees included. and now netflix included. so go ahead. binge on us.
10:26 am
another reason why t-mobile is america's best unlimited network. i know when i hand them the it's gonna be but i also know that we're gonna have usaa insurance for both my boys. it's something that they're not even gonna have to think of. it's just gonna be in the family. we're the tenneys and we're usaa members for life. copdso to breathe better,athe. i go with anoro. ♪go your own way copd tries to say, "go this way." i say, "i'll go my own way" with anoro. ♪go your own way once-daily anoro contains two medicines called bronchodilators,
10:27 am
that work together to significantly improve lung function all day and all night. anoro is not for asthma . it contains a type of medicine that increases risk of death in people with asthma. the risk is unknown in copd. anoro won't replace rescue inhalers for sudden symptoms and should not be used more than once a day. tell your doctor if you have a heart condition, high blood pressure, glaucoma, prostate, bladder, or urinary problems. these may worsen with anoro. call your doctor if you have worsened breathing, chest pain, mouth or tongue swelling, problems urinating, vision changes, or eye pain while taking anoro. ask your doctor about anoro. ♪go your own way get your first prescription free at
10:28 am
throughout history, the one meal when we come together, break bread, share our day and connect as a family. [ bloop, clicking ] and connect, as a family. just, uh one second voice guy. [ bloop ] huh? hey? i paused it.
10:29 am
bam, family time. so how is everyone? find your awesome with xfinity xfi and change the way you wifi. welcome back. live pictures out of florida. family members lining up there with the arrival of the body of sergeant la david johnson. he is one of the four green berets killed in that ambush in niger. you are seeing family members there arriving, all wearing
10:30 am
white. a painful day, especially how the investigation now is intensifying, surrounding the details of the ambush. it was one of the facts revealed that sergeant's body was found some one mile away from the location where the bodies of his three fellow soldiers was retrieved. among the family members there. his wife, myisha johnson, their two small children, and there, a close review of congresswoman fredricka wilson, who got into a rather heated exchange of facts surrounding her call or a call from the president of the united states made to myisha johnson. the congresswoman who is also a mentor of the family who was in the vehicle when the phone call
10:31 am
was on speaker. it is the congresswoman who said that the family was so disappointed in the way in which the telephone call transpired, that in her view and in the family's view that the president didn't seem to know the sergeant's name. didn't show compassion. then it was following that of course you heard from the white house by way of the chief of staff john kelly. who also is very critical that a congresswoman was on that phone call that should have been very sack rid between the president and the united states and the family members of the fallen soldier. then the chief of staff going on to be very critical of what he believed to be inappropriate behavi behavior, and then a dispute of
10:32 am
facts, that the congresswoman said he misremembered the events videotaped material. then showed that john kelly's facts were not quite that of the case in describing the congresswoman's verbiage during the dedication ceremony of an fbi building in miami. but now a very solemn moment of the burial of sergeant la david johnson. not to be lost on the sequence of events. and now he being laid to rest. 25-year-old father of two. and a husband. so many turning out. turning out for this cooper city florida event. also with me now, media, chief media correspondent brian stelter. there are four young men involved here. the consequences of this ambush. still the investigation intensifying what took place, how is it, what were the circumstances of these four
10:33 am
soldiers and their death. why sergeant johnson's body was found a mile away 48 hours after the retrieval of the other three. but it is sergeant la david johnson's name that has become a household name, brian, the one most familiar in what is still, you know, a fog of circumstances surrounding their deaths. >> i think this sergeant's life and his death have in some ways personalized america's forever wars. you think about casualties in afghanistan and iraq and now niger, a place that many americans didn't know there was fighting or u.s. military action going on. so to have this ambush in october 4th and now more than two weeks later, we see this funeral for the sergeant. there have been other funerals as well. our colleague caylee hartung was at one of them last weekend.
10:34 am
now here we are this saturday watching this sergeant's funeral. i'm struck by how la david johnson has become a household name. in his death. it was partly because of that incredible and painful video of his widow meeting his casket at the airport, that video from several days ago, where you see her spend time with the casket with one of their daughters standing next to her. and then you realize she's pregnant with their third child as well. so that video there, you see on the right side of the screen, i know i'm not going to forget those images. i don't think you are either, fred. that moment where his body is arriving back, back in florida. absolutely painful to see. and frankly we don't see it often enough. we don't see often enough the consequences of the wars that are being fought in our name around the world. so i'm grateful in a way to be able to see this today and reflect on what an awful week
10:35 am
it's been. you know, this started, let's remember the conversation about sergeant la david johnson began because president trump was asked why he hadn't commented publicly on the ambush in niger. he was asked that question on monday. it seemed like as a result he made phone calls to the families, including to this family, and that is what touched off, as you were describing, days of scandal, days of controversy, days of falsehoods and confusion and back and forth. but you look at these pictures and you realize what actually matters. >> yeah. and what a moment that flag draped coffin, followed by family members, mostly wearing white. the camera right now is fixated on the congresswoman who has made it very clear in her many appearances how close she is with the johnson family. it is staff sergeant -- it is sergeant la david johnson who is being laid to rest here, 25
10:36 am
years old. the names of his three comrades also fallen in this ambush attack in niger. staff sageant bryan black, staff sergeant jeremiah johnson, and staff sergeant dustin wright. the circumstances surrounding their deaths still very cloudy, brian. the fbi, as we've been reporting on the ground in niger also trying to talk to witnesses, gather evidence. which is customary when there are deaths that involve u.s. troops. but this investigation has reached a certain level, you know, a particular pitch because, as you underscore, so many americans had no idea there were u.s. troops in niger. there are americans, you know, dotted across the map of the continent of africa. all the circumstances not always clear. particularly now with the growth and the spread of isis and
10:37 am
terror groups. there apparently are circumstances taking place in niger which may surround this ambush that involves the terror activity of isis or splinter groups, and we heard from senator lindsay gram who says, you know, everyone should be paying attention to the potential of terror activity now rooted deeply in africa. >> this was the greatest single combat loss since president trump took office and this was on october 4th, the day of the office. at first, it appeared only three u.s. service members had died. that was because johnson's whereabouts were unknown. then we found out about the fourth death as well. for a week, there was little information until more questions began to be asked by the media to president trump and to the white house and to the pentagon. and now more than two weeks later, like you said, senator
10:38 am
lindsey graham, we're seeing congressional officials pushing for more information, as well as members of the press corps, pushing for more information from the pentagon about the circumstances of what happened that day in niger. this is, like i said, i think it's a moment to see up close right here in our living rooms the consequences of these ongoing military actions. we rarely see these sorts of funerals taking place. and it's partly because it was politicized as the week went on. we see the congresswoman there i believe and some of the other friends and loved ones of the family all gathered there in florida now. >> heartbreaking moment, a heartbreaking day. the nation's heart breaks for sergeant la david johnson and his three fellow soldiers brian black, jeremiah johnson, dustin wright. we'll be right back. if you've been struggling with belly pain
10:39 am
and constipation, and you're overwhelmed by everything you've tried-- all those laxatives, daily probiotics, endless fiber-- it could be wearing on you. tell your doctor what you've tried, and how long you've been at it. linzess works differently from laxatives. linzess treats adults with ibs with constipation or chronic constipation. it can help relieve your belly pain and lets you have more frequent and complete bowel movements that are easier to pass. do not give linzess to children less than six and it should not be given to children six to less than eighteen. it may harm them. don't take linzess if you have a bowel blockage. get immediate help if you develop unusual or severe stomach pain, especially with bloody or black stools. the most common side effect is diarrhea, sometimes severe. if it's severe, stop taking linzess and call your doctor right away. other side effects include gas, stomach-area pain and swelling. talk to your doctor about managing your symptoms proactively with linzess.
10:40 am
10:41 am
when it comes to helping maria iher daughter,le mom. shopping for groceries, unclogging the sink, setting updentist appointments and planning birthday parties, nobody does it better. she's also in a rock band. look at her shred. but when it comes to mortgages, she's less confident. fortunately for maria, there's rocket mortgage by quicken loans. it's simple, so she can understand the details and be sure she's getting the right mortgage. apply simply. understand fully. mortgage confidently. ♪ ♪ you nervous? ♪ ♪ ♪ ♪
10:42 am
duncan just protected his family with a $500,000 life insurance policy. how much do you think it cost him? $100 a month? $75? $50? actually, duncan got his $500,000 for under $28 a month. less than $1 a day! his secret? selectquote. in just minutes a selectquote agent will comparison shop nearly a dozen highly rated life insurance companies, and give you a choice of your five best rates. duncan's wife cassie got a $750,000 policy for under $21 per month. give your family the security it needs, at a price you can afford. since 1985, selectquote has saved over a million families millions of dollars on life insurance.
10:43 am
welcome back. as disgraced hollywood producer harvey weinstein completes rehab, he is facing multiple investigations spanning the country and globe. police in los angeles, new york, london, are all looking into multiple claims of weinstein's unwanted sexual advances on women going back decades. this all happening as the number of women coming out against the producer grows to more than 40. here, you see 17 of the names and faces. let's discuss with our legal guys right now, avery friedman, a civil rights attorney and law professor in cleveland. and richard herman, a new york criminal defense attorney and law professor joining us from las vegas. good to see you both. okay, so richard, you first,
10:44 am
because when we talk about allegations that span decades, first comes to thought, you know, statute of limitations. but in some cases, there really is no statute. so define how prosecutors, investigator, will go about trying to see if they can potentially impose charges against this producer. >> okay, fredricka, in most cases, civil assault is usually a one-year statue of limitations so those are gone in the majority of any of these cases there, if that even occurred. criminally, many jurisdictions do not have a statue of limitations for sexual assault, but you have to understand, fred, harvey weinstein has become the face of the visceral disgust for the casting couch culture in hollywood. if a young person, an actress or an actor, meeting with him and he solicits them to give him a massage or take -- watch him take a shower or have sex, that
10:45 am
is not criminal, fred, and at that time, that person has a right to say yes, i'll participate, in hopes of a benefit, or no, no thank you, and walk out the door. if they participate, fred, that's consent. that's a total defense. and there's no claim here for that. >> avery, you're shaking your head on almost all of that. why? i mean, as it pertains to touching versus alleged assault and even that consent that richard was defining. >> well, that isn't how you define consent when you have something like this. again, the difference between civil and criminal. what surfaced this week was very important. rose mcgowan, who's a studio executive, claimed in 1997 she was raped by wipestein in a hotel in park city, utah. well, there's a four-year statute of limitations in utah.
10:46 am
to the credit of the legislature, they changed the law and got rid of the limitations. so the problem here is you have the original four years. then you have something called tolling which from 1997, the date of the rape, you add 11. 11 and 4 is 15 and this happened 20 years ago. so in that particular case, would surface this week, there may be a problem. the other problem is that she settled it, at least according to one source, for $100,000. but what it means is that in other states that have a tighter timetable here, there may very well be criminal charges and that of course remains to be seen. we've got 40 cases. one or two or three may very well surface within that critical statute of limitations. >> so then, richard, there are a variety of accusations here. you talk about, you know, richard, rose mcgowan, utah and alleged sexual assault.
10:47 am
richard, you talked about, you know, massaging and how you define that as, you know, consent if the person does, you know, carry out the massage, that reminds me of the lupita nyong'o nyong'o, you know, most recent allegations, that's how she was approached, you know, from him. so you have all these varying types of experiences and different jurisdictions. at what point might all of these jurisdictions try to work together or, you know, compare and contrast these allegations before setting out to pursue any types of charges? >> well, they may try to gain information to find some sort of similar conduct in the other jurisdictions but they're never going to work together, fred. with respect to mismcgowan, i don't know if she was raped or not. if she was, that's horrible. but she didn't go to the police and she didn't file a complaint and she didn't compile dna efld
10:48 am
and she didn't press charges. she didn't do any of that and that's what you have to do -- >> well, except, you know, that becomes so common in so many alleged rape cases because, you know, of so many circumstances. there's fear, there's shame, and sometimes people are worried about, you know, what will happen next in terms of the consequence of not being able to work, et cetera, so that isn't necessarily an admission that it didn't happen at all. >> but you're talking about a criminal crime here, fred. and there's a burden of proof that has to be sustained. and the fact that they fear coming forward does not sustain that burden of proof, fred. there's a burden that has to be met. if it's not met, there's no conviction and there's no convicted crime. that's a fact. >> avery. >> well, i mean, look, you have to recognize the reality is that as you've mentioned, fredricka, women that go through this, and frankly, my civil cases involving people that do things like this that is alleged
10:49 am
usually will happen after a quick criminal prosecution. you've got time. the difficulty here is that for the suffering that women go through when they experience a big shot, who has all the power, who has all the authority, to get away with this, it take as enormous amount of strength to move forward. if rose would have gone forward before, i think it would have been a lot different situation. but, again, it's typical. because of the pain, because of the suffering, it is very difficult to move forward. and hopefully people will be inspired by saying you see what happened here, we're going to stand up, we're going to fight back we're going to do something about these dikinds of allegations. >> any nonconsensual touching is a crime. if that occurred, you have to move forward and press charges. you have to do it. you can't hold back and then 20 years later say this happened. you're never going to prove it. >> we'll leave it right there, richard avery, thank you so much, always good to see you.
10:50 am
all right, also this just in now. "the new york times" reporting today that bill o'reilly, formerly of fox, settled harassment claims to the tune of $32 million, then went on to re-sign a contract with fox news. shocking story just in the past few minutes. i've confirmed from the source that that $32 million is accurate. that is a september that bill o'reilly paid to a long time fox contributor this early january of this engineyear. he paid because she had come forward with last of allegations suggesting she was going to sue for sexual harassment. these included claims of nonconsensual sexual relationship. it was negotiated between
10:51 am
o'reilly and the attorneys. this was far more than any septembers we previously knew about involving bill o'reilly. in april that's what the other september settlements came out. this is what led 21st century fox to leave him without the door. what's notable about this is the idea that the bill o'reilly just months before, that story came out, actually reached a there is 32 million settlement with another accuser. no comment from "fox news" about that right now. >> interesting. so brian, you said o'reilly attorneys and the attorneys of the woman, now, are we saying that fox did or did not participate in that settlement? >> this is apparently between o'reilly himself and between the accuser. so that means "fox news" wasn't
10:52 am
paying the money, but what's important here is that the company did know about the settlement and went ahead and renewed his contract anyway, a $25 million a year contract. what's curious is "fox news" went ahead and renew the the contract even though he had just paid out another settlement, $32 million settlement. of course all of this happened earlier this year. fox was in turmoil in the wake of the roger ailes scandal. there was an investigation. this is going to raise new questions about what fox decided to do, why it decided to keep o'reilly way back last winter and whether that's going to have any impact on the federal investigation. >> wow. pretty significant. all right. brian stelter thank you so much. we'll be right back. so he took aleve this morning. if he'd taken tylenol, he'd be stopping for more pills right now.
10:53 am
only aleve has the strength to stop tough pain for up to 12 hours with just one pill. tylenol can't do that. aleve. all day strong. all day long. also try aleve direct therapy with tens technology for lower back pain relief. you or joints. something for your heart... but do you take something for your brain. with an ingredient originally found in jellyfish, prevagen is the number one selling brain-health supplement in drug stores nationwide. prevagen. the name to remember. will people know it means they'll get the lowest price guaranteed on our rooms by booking direct on hey! badda book. badda boom! mr. badda book. badda boom! book now at
10:54 am
10:55 am
welcome back. tonight's episode of the wonder list cnn's bill weir explores a sunken egyptian city and the treaders that lie beneath. >> on seas so calm, a fan tail captures a nap. >> i'm too excited to doze. mind full of details from an old roman mosaic i saw.
10:56 am
back in the day, we could skr made that journey on foot or by donkey but today, the only way to get there is through the princess duda, research vessel of a guy named frank. >> so great to be here, frank. >> the ship is a hive of activity. a united nations of soggy antiquity. cuban, russian, american divers, french egyptian oarchaeologists. >> you can take -- 2,000-year-old artifacts. >> look at that. absolutely intact. >>. >> okay. joining me now. that was extraordinary, and then i can't wait to see what's bemete. as a skuber diver myself i think
10:57 am
i'm going to have to add that to the list. maybe i'll be your grip next time. so, what was the most fascinating part about this journey for you. >> that sunken city was the whole reason we went to do the story there. it is unbelievable to think that you're holding a piece of dish ware that the last person to hold it lived in a 1400 years ago on the nile delta and that entire city went down. it was a big earthquake, the earth turned to liquid. temples crashed on to ships. it was the biggest city outside cairo and alexander the great built alexandria to replace the city. this frenchman found that lost city and took is down there. jaw bones of concan donkeys. >> oh, my goodness. so what is the biggest threat
10:58 am
potentially to -- it really is kind of a graveyard, right? >> it is. the but the biggest threat is rising sea level. the nile delta is the bread bask of africa and the middle east. it is becoming inundated with salt water. the farmers, every crop every year is getting smaller. imagine when those people go hungry. this has ramifications for everybody. also the rising water is threatening all these antiquities that are in alexandria, catacombs and all these amazing wonders that need preserving but egypt, so much turmoil. tourism industry has plummeted. we look into all of that as we try to take lessons from the past to warn us about our future if it we don't figure stuff out. >> oh, my goodness, so you saw intact dishes and donkey bones. but what surprised you the most?
10:59 am
>> sort of the mun a dandanmund. imagine the family that owned it and how the table was set the day the whole world changed. le we live that everything's term nent. the visibility isn't awesome, as you -- >> i was just about to ask you that. >> it's super silty but it protected it from looters. if it had been clear grave robbers would have picked it clean years ago. >> so what a challenge of a dive that was. bill wear. weir. thank you so much. we'll be watching. do not miss the wonder list airing tonight at 9:00. we've got so much more straight ahead. it all starts right now. . hello again everyone. i'm fret rica field --
11:00 am
>> farewell, sergeant la david johnson is being remembered this hour as he is laid to rest there near his home town of cooper city, florida. you see family members all wearing white, paying homage to him. people lining the streets of this funeral procession, holding flags and saluting the fallen soldier in a sign of respect. that moment right there. a precious moment. there are no words. the 25-year-old was killed ng


info Stream Only

Uploaded by TV Archive on