tv Finding Jesus Faith Fact Forgery CNN December 25, 2017 7:00pm-8:00pm PST
jesus endured during his crucifixion. the shroud of turin. >> is this the real burial shroud of jesus, or fake? >> it could be likened to a detective story. a scientific detective story. >> the possibility that a piece of archaeology could prove to us that jesus christ was crucified, buried and raised from the dead. this is the most significant moment in human history. ♪
>> turin, northern italy. in a specially built chapel in the city's cathedral lies the most famous religious relic in the world, the shroud of turin. the cloth that many believe wrapped the body of jesus of nazareth nearly 2,000 years ago. protected by bulletproof glass, the 14-foot rectangular cloth is so precious and so valuable, it's rarely seen by the public. the last time that the turin shroud was displayed was in 2010. more than two million visitors were drawn to see it. >> the shroud is a fascinating object because it tells the story of jesus' passion in one object. >> for believers, it's much more than a relic. it's evidence of jesus rising
from the dead. >> some people think the turin shroud was produced by radiation at the resurrection. in which case, that would be material evidence of the resurrection of jesus. that could be nothing more important than that. >> for millions, the shroud is not only proof of the death and resurrection of jesus, but the only record of what he looked like. >> there are no physical descriptions of jesus in the gospel. none. we don't know what he looked like. we don't know how tall he was. we don't know what the set of his eyes was. but he had a face. he was a real person. >> it fulfills almost a
temptation. a temptation to fixate on the face of christ. to fulfill that idea of the true likeness. what did the son of god look like? >> a week before his death, jesus arrives in jerusalem, along with thousands of pilgrims for the festival of passover. within days, he's been betrayed by judas. >> jesus of nazareth! >> arrested in the garden of gethsemane after he provokes the authorities. he's handed over to the romans for trial and crucifixion. it's here that the story of the shroud begins. all four gospels talk about the
burial cloth in which the crucified body of jesus is laid to rest. the bible tells that the cloth was given by joseph of arimathea, a wealthy member of the jewish counsel. the sanhedrin. >> the gospels describe joseph of arimathea as being a sympathizer with the jesus movement. he's fascinated by jesus. so fascinated that even after the crucifixion, he wants to make sure that the right thing is done, that jesus gets the right burial. >> everyone who encounters jesus in the gospels is in some way transformed. they're either healed or following him. meeting jesus for one time was life changing. that probably changed joseph's life.
>> but first, joseph needs permission to take jesus down from the cross. >> you think this is acceptable? >> he goes to see the roman pontius pilate to ask for the body. >> get out. >> pilate is an essential figure, because only he had the power to pronounce a death sentence. so it was he who ultimately is responsible for jesus' crucifixion and death. >> you've come for me, rabbi? >> pilate is famously anti-semitic. he doesn't like jews or being in judea. >> jesus of nazareth, i've come to ask for his body. >> we have to wonder what joseph is thinking. he's taking quite a risk. he's going to pilate and asking for the body of a convicted
criminal, a criminal who is guilty of political sedition. >> i have a tomb. somewhere secure, somewhere we can prepare his body. >> by going to pilate and asking for this rather personal favor, it's almost as if he might be guilty himself. >> you can imagine it being a very tense meeting between the two men. >> yes? >> pontius pilate gives joseph the body, but he was probably thought he was just letting some jewish custom play out. as far as he was concerned, that was going to be the end of it. >> in allowing joseph to take the body, pilate had unwittingly started a journey that would turn jesus' burial shroud into one of the most venerated and mysterious relics of all time.
it's the final days of the ford year end sales event. ♪ i'm on top of the world, hey. ♪ it's your last chance of the year to get our best offer of the year: zero percent financing for seventy-two months, plus an extra one-thousand cash back across a full lineup of ford cars, trucks and suvs. so hurry and save big on america's best-selling brand. it's the final days of the ford year end sales event with zero percent financing for seventy-two months plus an extra one-thousand cash back! see your ford dealer before jan 2nd and save. went to ancestry, i put in the names of my grandparents first.
i got a leaf right away. a leaf is a hint that is connected to each person in your family tree. i learned that my ten times great grandmother is george washington's aunt. within a few days i went from knowing almost nothing to holy crow, i'm related to george washington. this is my cousin george. discover your story. start searching for free now at ancestry.com
allow you to take advantage of growth opportunities. with a level of protection in down markets. so you can head into retirement with confidence. brighthouse financial established by metlife. hey julie, i know today's critica...a sick day. need... dads don't take sick days... dads take dayquil severe. the non-drowsy, coughing, aching, fever, sore throat... ...stuffy head, no sick days medicine.
(dog growls) named after a star. crafted to celebrate an unforgettable holiday. host one to remember. not in this house. 'cause that's no average family. that's your family. which is why you didn't grab just any cheese. you picked up kraft mozzarella with a touch of philadelphia for lasanyeah! kraft. family greatly. good friday, the romans leave jesus' dead body hanging on the cross. wrapping any victim of a crucifixion in a burial shroud was very unusual.
>> after you breathe your last breath, you were just garbage. you were left there to rot. and to be eaten. >> but the gospel of mark tells that jesus' body is wrapped in a fine linen cloth, brought by joseph of arimathea. the bible also reveals that joseph had help in burying jesus. another member of the jewish counsel, nicodemus. >> nicodemus, much like joseph of arimathea, was also a member of the sanhedrin, a prominent man in jewish society. >> it's clear that not all the jews in jerusalem were behind jesus' death for the simple reason that jesus was jewish, his followers and disciples were jewish. not all the jewish authorities were responsible for jesus' death because you have people like joseph of arimathea and nicodemus.
>> the body is taken to joseph's tomb and prepared for burial. >> when nicodemus is willing to get involved is in the burial. he's supplying really very expensive products to be used in the process of embalming the body. >> first century jewish law said that to touch a dead body would make you unclean. for joseph and nicodemus to go through the process of preparing jesus for burial, there had to have been tremendous love and devotion, just to care for him. >> a rock is rolled across the entrance to seal the tomb shut.
three days after the crucifixion, john and simon peter, two of jesus' disciples, visit the tomb. they find it empty. according to john's gospel, then simon peter came and went into the tomb. he saw the linen wrappings lying there. but the bible doesn't mention what happens to the linen cloths next. more than 1,300 years later, a shroud showing the crucified body of jesus appeared from out of nowhere in a small village in northeastern france. when it was moved to turin, 40,000 people were there to welcome it. then centuries later, in 1898,
it became a global phenomenon, when italian secondo pia first took the world's first photograph of the shroud. >> all of a sudden, a negative image of the man of the shroud pops out at him. it's like staring at the face of jesus. it suddenly turns the shroud from an object of religious devotion to an icon of scientific obsession. if you prove that the shroud of turin is real, you're proving that jesus christ existed. >> in 1978, former u.s. air force physicist john jackson from the shroud of turin research project was given unprecedented access to study the relic. >> you see the image of a human
man. where you can see, for example, the head, crossed arms. in fact, you can even see elongated fingers. >> leading a team of 40 scientists, jackson set out to investigate the shroud, using tools at the forefront of science. >> we really didn't know what we were going to find. was this going to be a painting? was it going to be something else? >> working around the clock for five days, the scientists reached conclusions that seemed to advance the authenticity of the shroud and deepen its mystery. >> the fibers themselves are all individually colored, so there's no evidence of something that you would expect, say, from a paint medium. we don't see that. it doesn't penetrate through the thickness of the cloth. it lies just on the very surface. the question is why is that? >> jackson and his team also wanted to investigate the dark marks that appeared to be
bloodstains. >> so what we did is take micro samples from these bloodstain areas, which were taken back to the united states for micro chemical analyses. the result was these features are, in fact, blood. >> with no explanation for how the image was made, and the apparent presence of blood on the cloth, jackson looked to the gospels to see whether there was a connection between the last day of jesus' life and the shroud. according to the gospel of john, then pilate took jesus and had him flogged. >> what i think stands out the most are the many marks that are all over the cloth. to me, this looks like blood residues of a person who was
whipped or scourged. >> everything about the passion narrative speaks about the pain, the humiliation of jesus' death. it begins with the most appalling flogging. flogging that will have brought jesus to within an inch of his life. it's a really appalling spectacle, when you think about it. >> he was spat upon, laughed at,
anything to just crush his spirit as much as possible. >> but the shroud of turin also bears witness to one of the most famous events of the crucifixion story. [barking] let out your inner-child at the lexus december to remember sales event. experience amazing at your lexus dealer. a trip back to the dthe doctor's office, mean just for a shot. but why go back there, when you can stay home, with neulasta onpro? strong chemo can put you at risk of serious infection, which could lead to hospitalizations.
in a key study, neulasta reduced the risk of infection from 17% to 1%, a 94% decrease. applied the day of chemo, neulasta onpro is designed to deliver neulasta the next day, so you can stay home. neulasta is for certain cancer patients receiving strong chemotherapy. do not take neulasta if you're allergic to neulasta or neupogen (filgrastim). ruptured spleen, sometimes fatal as well as serious lung problems, allergic reactions, kidney injuries, and capillary leak syndrome have occurred. report abdominal or shoulder tip pain, trouble breathing or allergic reactions to your doctor right away. in patients with sickle cell disorders, serious, sometimes fatal crises can occur. the most common side effect is bone and muscle ache. so why go back there? if you'd rather be home, ask your doctor about neulasta onpro.
john's gospel describes what happens next to jesus. and the soldiers wove a crown of thorns and put it on his head. for 40 years, john jackson has been comparing the shroud of turin with descriptions of jesus' death in the bible. >> when we come to the final image, we see what looked like bloodstains that are coming from essentially puncture-type sources. they correspond to what the gospels tell us what happened to jesus, the crown of thorns. >> the purpose of the crown of thorns was to crush all jewish aspirations that they would ever
have self-rule. >> they press it into his head so that you see blood trickling down his face. >> i find that one of the most poignant parts of jesus' life. to have anyone be mocked like that, it's very difficult to see. >> after the scourging and the crown of thorns, the next thing the gospels tell us happened to jesus was that he was taken away to be crucified. >> the cross jesus carries through the streets of jerusalem weighs more than 300 pounds. >> when jesus is carrying the cross, there was a crowd that followed.
some of the crowd would have been sympathetic. and others were jeering. it would have been a really horrible scene. >> evidence for jesus' final journey, jackson believes, can be seen on the shroud. >> where the shoulder boundary would be, we find bloodstains. they seem to be more smudged, more smeared, as opposed to what we see down further on the back. maybe what we're looking at is the action of that cross being on the shoulders that are smearing the bloodstains from the pre-existing scourging that
jesus received. >> as he was pushed through the streets, it's believed that the weight of the cross became too much for jesus to bear. >> at some point, the soldiers solicit simon of cyrene to carry the cross for him. this isn't out of the goodness of their hearts. we have to assume that jesus is flagging. he's unable to carry the cross at this stage. he's that weakened. and this is why simon of cyrene is brought in to help him. >> two criminals are crucified
alongside jesus. >> they throw them on the ground. they're talking to them as roughly as possible. and they're showing him, he has no control at all. he has no protection. >> father, forgive them. for they do not know what they are doing. >> every part of the crucifixion experience was meant to cause further agony, further humiliation, and for fear and horror among those watching. >> the crucifixion, we know that there was mary, jesus' mother, and mary magdalene, watching the horrendous scene unfold.
>> if you were one of jesus' sympathizers, if you were family or a friend of jesus, then it must have been incredibly difficult to witness this event. >> and he sees this big spike, and they're holding his arm out. he's straining to pull his hand away. and they strike. >> but at this point, the mystery of the shroud deepens. the marks on the cloth challenge everything we thought we knew about crucifixion. the wounds appear to be in the wrong place. genomic testing and immunotherapy. see how we're fighting to outsmart cancer at
cancercenter.com/outsmart my hygi...a mouthwash.o try... so i tried crest. it does so much more than give me fresh breath. crest pro-health mouthwash provides all... ...of these benefits to help you get better dental check-ups. go pro with crest mouthwash. checkup? nailed it it's the final days of the ford year end sales event. ♪ i'm on top of the world, hey. ♪ it's your last chance of the year to get our best offer of the year: zero percent financing for seventy-two months, plus an extra one-thousand cash back
across a full lineup of ford cars, trucks and suvs. so hurry and save big on america's best-selling brand. it's the final days of the ford year end sales event with zero percent financing for seventy-two months plus an extra one-thousand cash back! see your ford dealer before jan 2nd and save. ♪ ♪ give a little bit ♪ ♪ give a little bit... -hello. ♪ give a little bit... ♪ ... of your love to me oh, haha. ♪ there's so much that we need to share ♪ ♪ so send a smile and show that you care ♪ ♪ i'll give a little bit of my love to you ♪
for centuries, artistic tradition has shown nails going through the palms of jesus' hands. the figure on the shroud appears to have been crucified through the wrists. jackson believes the shroud is the historically accurate version. >> you want the person who is crucified to stay up on the cross until they die. there have been experiments performed on cadavers. both with the placement of the nail hypothetically in the palm and in the wrist. these experiments have shown that the weight-bearing value always settles upon the wrist, like you see on the shroud, rather than the palm. the palm will just simply tear
through. >> he's raised up. imagine the agony of being raised up after your feet and your hands are nailed in. every little movement is agony. the cross was lifted up by ropes and then dropped into a hole to keep it from falling. imagine what that's like. >> one of the difficulties with imagining crucifixion is that we've had 2,000 years of chriiatradition, which sanitizes the cross. we have put jesus in nice church buildings, have crosses made of gold, and it prevents us of thinking through what crucifixion actually involved. when we pause and look at the historical nature of the crucifixion and remember what the romans were trying to do by humiliating and torturing people, for a moment, we see it as something quite difficult. something appallingly painful
and utterly humiliating. >> the weight of the body pulls on the arms, making breathing increasingly difficult. most victims of crucifixion finally die of asphyxiation. >> it -- is -- finished. >> imagine your mother or your father or your best friend nailed to wood. hung out in the open sun. and die a terrible death of asphyxiation. it's hard to find words to explain what it would have been like to see that.
>> this had to be the darkest moment of their life. >> the final mark on the shroud would have been made after jesus died. >> this blood mark is not part of a normal crucifixion. but in the case of jesus, the gospels tell us that it was delivered by a roman soldier to ensure that he was dead so that his body could be released and taken down from the cross before passover. >> in the gospel of john, a soldier stabs jesus' dead body in the side. blood and water leak out. >> we see clear areas, which some have hypothesized might be due to this fluid associated with the blood and water, as the
gospel says. >> the shroud of turin appears to be a silent witness to all the final sufferings of jesus. ♪ >> and then, according to the gospels, after he was laid to rest, jesus is resurrected. the only thing left behind in his tomb, the linen used to cover his body. >> the crucifixion is among the most powerful parts of the gospel, simply because it's the death of jesus, the son of god. but it's also his entre into new life. >> it is extraordinary to find an archaeological piece that is proof of his existence, of his
death and of his resurrection. >> based on the research that i've been involved in, i think that we are looking at the historic burial cloth of jesus 2,000 years ago. >> but there was one part of the investigation that jackson had been unable to complete. an accurate dating of the material. then in 1988, the catholic church took the unprecedented step of giving permission for pieces of the cloth to be removed for carbon testing. samples were cut from the edge of the shroud and sent for testing in three independent laboratories. in london, zurich and arizona. >> the possibility that a piece of archaeology could prove to us
that jesus christ was crucified, buried and raised from the dead, this is the most significant moment in human history. hi, i'm paul. i used to ask if you can hear me now, but i made the smart choice and switched to sprint. these days all networks are great. so why would anyone pay twice as much with verizon. now when you switch you'll get 4 lines of unlimited for $25 a month with the 5th line free. 5 lines for only $100 a month. that's 50% off the unlimited rates of the other guys. it's the best price for unlimited. (vo) don't let a 1% difference cost you twice as much. plus, switch and get 50% off samsung's newest phones. think about what you can do for people with hearing loss, with all that extra money. visit sprintrelay.com.
♪ prices of the season' on the only bed that adjusts on both sides to your ideal comfort your sleep number setting. and snoring? does your bed do that? it's the lowest prices of the season on the queen c4 mattress with adjustable comfort on both sides. now only $1199, save $400. plus, 24 month financing available. ends monday. visit sleepnumber.com for a store near you. even when nothing else is. keep her receipts tidy, brand vo: snap and sort your expenses with quickbooks and find, on average, $4,340 in tax savings.
but some of us make somethinge make sommuch more. dinner. mom would be proud. with blue apron, any night is a chance to see what cooking can do. i use herpecin l.re, it penetrates deep to treat. it soothes, moisturizes, and creates an spf 30 barrier, to protect against flare-ups caused by the sun. herpecin l. turin, 1988. three small pieces of the shroud have been cut off and sent to laboratories around the world
for carbon date testing. >> this is really the moment of truth for the shroud of turin. is it fake, or is it real? >> for hundreds of years, the shroud of turin has been a powerful symbol of faith for catholics and believers around the world. today the archbishop of turin confirmed recent tests that the piece of linen bearing an image of christ does not date from the time of christ. >> the shrda century. it's a medieval forgery. there is no way this could have been the burial shroud of jesus christ. this is huge. i mean, people, to this day, look at this and say, this is jesus. this is our lord. this is what he went through. to say, no, sorry, it's a very clever forgery, that's painful. >> in medieval europe, there was a lucrative trade in creating
religious relics. people were willing to pay to get close to jesus, and forgers were prepared to take advantage. but despite being revealed as a fake, fascination with the shroud intensified. >> how did that image get on the shroud? nobody could explain that. there's still all kinds of theories out there that we need to test. >> but south african art historian professor nicholas allen thinks he knows the answer. he believes it's the world's earliest surviving photograph. >> i looked at the shroud and i said, how were you made? and the shroud tells us that it is acting like a negative photograph. i'm quite aware that that might sound like a crazy idea, to
think that somebody was able to make a photograph 600 years ago. but when i started to look at the technology that was available at that time, i realize they had everything already. >> from his study of art history, allen knew that medieval artists already used an optical device called a camera obscura. >> it works exactly like a human eye. what we've here is a box which is sealed. no light can enter through it, except through this big hole over here. like a human eye, there is a lens. whatever is outside this box, it's focused through this lens and forms an image on the back wall of the camera that is inverted. in other words, it's upside down. >> the lens at the front of the camera ensures a sharp image is projected on the back wall. >> we know for a fact this is
very ancient technology. there is no doubt that this technology was available in the late 13th and early 14th century, exactly when it would have been needed to make something like the shroud of turin. >> allen positions a model in front of his camera and faces it to the sun. >> the whole setup has to be calculated very, very carefully before you can start the exposure. >> a medieval artist would need to ensure that any image projected on a sheet could be permanently fixed. the sheet would be soaked with photographic chemicals. today, this means using silver salts. >> both silver nitrate and silver sulfate have been around in europe from at least the 13th century. and it's very easy to make. >> a sheet is soaked in silver sulfate solution. dried. and then mounted in the camera. >> after eight hours exposure,
you will notice a discoloration on the linen. that discoloration would be a negative image of what was outside the camera. >> the silver sulfate would have been washed out of the cloth to complete the process using a chemical in plentiful supply. >> to remove silver sulfate from a piece of linen, one can use urine, since it contains levels of ammonia. whoever made the shroud of turin didn't do it on their first attempt. this probably took a lot of organizing, a lot of planning and a lot of trial and error before they got it right. >> when the image is analyzed, allen's method is shown to
produce astonishing results. >> the result image has all the characteristics of the image that is found on the shroud of turin. those are, it is negative, no dyes, pigments or stains. here, we have the image produced after three days using the camera obscura. to turn this into the shroud of turin image, we'd have to add blood to it. you'd take a paintbrush and artistically paint the stigmata onto the image. in my opinion, this is the oldest example we have of a phenomenon we call photography. it dates back to medieval times. >> allen's work has divided opinion and left even more questions unanswered. >> if it is a medieval photograph, then where are all the other medieval photographs? that's the other problem with the shroud. it's unique.
there is nothing else like it. >> and there are some who, despite the carbon dating, continue to believe in its authenticity. >> some people refuse to believe the result. they question the samples that were taken. they weren't taken from the very center of the shroud. they were taken from the edge of the shroud. >> and recent work on another mysterious relic has introduced new doubts into our understanding of the turin shroud. it's an artifact that may suggest the shroud is far older than claimed. in a small annex of a cathedral in northern spain, is the cloth believed to have covered jesus' face after he died on the cross?
>> what we are looking at in front of us are bloodstains of jesus of nazareth. this is his actual blood in front of us. ear: zero percent financing for seventy-two months, plus an extra one-thousand cash back across a full lineup of ford cars, trucks and suvs. so hurry and save big on america's best-selling brand. it's the final days of the ford year end sales event with zero percent financing for seventy-two months plus an extra one-thousand cash back! see your ford dealer before jan 2nd and save. you or joints. something for your heart... but do you take something for your brain. with an ingredient originally found in jellyfish, prevagen is the number one selling brain-health supplement
in drug stores nationwide. prevagen. the name to remember. 40 million americans are waking up to a gillette shave. and at our factory in boston, 1,200 workers are starting their day building on over a hundred years of heritage, craftsmanship and innovation. today we're bringing you america's number one shave at lower prices every day. putting money back in the pockets of millions of americans. as one of those workers, i'm proud to bring you gillette quality for less, because nobody can beat the men and women of gillette. gillette - the best a man can get.
over 25 years. this is another separate cloth mentioned in the bible. and he saw the linen wrappings lying there and the cloth that had been on jesus' head. >> we've taken this to the laboratory, analyzed what the stains are made of, and most of them are one part blood and six parts pleural edema fluid which collects in the lungs when somebody dies of asphyxiation. >> scholars believe that most victims of crucifixion would have died of suffocation and the fluids associated with this would be left in the lungs. guskin's studies appear to shine new light into a part of the jesus story that was previously
unknown using a near perfect replica of the cloth. >> now, what these experiments showed us is that, first of all, the cloth was placed on a dead body because all the blood stains coming out are absolutely incompatible with any kind of breathing movement. if guscin is collect, then joseph of arimathea would have wrapped this around jesus' face when he was still on the cross. >> the face cloth was used in jewish burial custom because the face is really the seat of the soul when that person dies. it must be treated with the greatest respect. the reason joseph became proactive in making sure that jesus had a proper, honorable burial, i think this was
joseph's own way of saying i did not do what i should have done. i should have spoken on your behalf. >> guscin believes that marx from the sudarium where the forehead would have been helped explain how joseph removed the body from the cross. >> the only way that we could reproduce these was if the body was lying face down on the ground so that all this liquid and blood trickling out of the nose would move down on to the forehead, but then the body was carried face down for between five to ten minutes while somebody was holding the cloth to the face. >> in the tomb, the sudarium would have been removed. and jesus then wrapped in the shroud. >> so this teaches us what happened between the death of
christ and when the body was laid in the tomb. >> but guscin believes that there's an even more important reason to study the sudarium. for him, the stains on the cloth are like a fingerprint, unique to one person. >> if this cloth was wrapped around the head of another person who had maybe even suffered the same kind of torture and wounds, then the stains would have a different shape and a different format. >> for guscin, this was to prove critical because when the team compared these blood stains on the sudarium with those on the shroud, they made an extraordinary discovery. the blood stains appeared to match. >> so we can conclude that the two cloths were used at the same time for the same event to cover the same body. >> carbon testing of the cloth has not delivered any clear
results, but the first written record of the relic tied it to jerusalem just over 500 years after jesus' death. for guscin, these records suggest it is at least 700 years older than the shroud. how could that be? guscin believes the dating of the shroud must be wrong. >> now, that is an incredible conclusion because they could only have coincided in jerusalem some time before the 5th century, which says an awful lot about the dating of the shroud of turin and how it does not date from the medieval times and is, in fact, a much earlier cloth. >> despite decades of scientific scrutiny, for many, the mystery and power of the shroud of turin still remains. >> i do think it would be
possible for the shroud that wrapped jesus to survive until now. clearly it would have been an important artifact for the disciples and then the early christians, so the notion that it would have been preserved makes total sense to me. >> my gut tells me that it's real. >> it doesn't seem likely to me that it's real, but it focuses our attention on something unavoidable about the jesus story, just how much he suffers. jesus may be glorious, enthroned in heaven, lord of lord, king of kings, but this moment of suffering and pain is etched into the turin shroud. it's his most human moment. >> for many, the shroud is also a poignant reminder of a man tryingo do the righthi. >> i think a part of joseph's story is our story. even though he didn't understand the outcome, even though he
didn't understand how the story was going to play out, what he knew was being on the side of jesus was being part of god's story in human history. king herod is one of the most notorious characters in the bible. he is the man who tries to kill the infant jesus. >> kill them all. >> he orders this appalling act where all the male children are slaugh