Skip to main content

tv   CNN Newsroom With Fredricka Whitfield  CNN  July 4, 2020 8:00am-9:00am PDT

8:00 am
8:01 am
♪ hello and thank you so much for joining me. happy independence day to our nation. i'm fredricka whitfield. we begin this fourth of july with many places across the u.s. enforcing strict new rules to stop spread of the coronavirus. new cases surging once again on friday, topping 50,000 for the third-straight day. it's a trend that has been growing in recent weeks. and right now, the numbers are down in only one state, vermont. but in the many hot spots, alarming and concerning the growing rate of hospitalizations. florida, by the way, continuing to show signs of being the new epicenter of the disease. the state reporting more than 11,000 new cases today. those numbers just coming into
8:02 am
the news room. its biggest case rise to date. >> then there's texas, icu beds in at least two counties are reaching capacity. at least two severely ill patients were forced to be flown to other cities. in a georgia 14,000 health care workers signed a letter to the governor asking him to impose more restrictions to slow rising cases. and in the midst of the climbing case count, president trump held a campaign-style rally last night in the shadow of mount rushmore. where there was no social distancing being enforced and not many people were wearing masks. the president saying only this about the on going pandemic. >> let us also send our deepest thanks to our wonderful veterans, law enforcement, first responders and the doctors, nurses and scientists working tirelessly to kill the virus.
8:03 am
they're working hard. >> president trump spending most of his speech stoking the fire of culture wars in the u.s., lashing out at what he calls a merciless campaign to erase the country's history and making several unsubstantiated claims along the way. >> in our schools, our news rooms even our corporate board rooms there is a new far left fascism that demands absolute allegiance if you do not speak its language, perform its rituals, recite its mantras and follow its commandments. then you will be censored, banished, blacklisted, persecuted and punished. it's not going to happen to us. >> we have a team of reporters covering the coronavirus surge in the states across this country. let's start in florida, a state
8:04 am
once again which saw its largest new case count again today. cnn's boris sanchez is in clear water beach, one of the many beaches that does remain open this holiday weekend. so boris, these are stunning numbers. but i also see a lot of people behind you, kind of describe the contrast or how these two are going together right now. >> fred, it is simply a staggering number, 11,445 new coronavirus cases in the sunshine state setting a record for florida. also rivaling some of the biggest single day records that we saw from new york in april back when the pandemic was hitting the high water mark in that state. to give you some perspective, over the last 72 hours, we've seen more than 30,000 cases in florida. that follows the month of june where more than 100,000 new cases were reported in the sunshine state. despite all of that the governor
8:05 am
ron desantis leaving it up to local officials to establish restrictions in their areas. he's remained adamant he does not want to reinstall that stay-at-home order that froze the sunshine state a few months ago. he maintained that his administration has done everything they can within reason to keep the state safe, though they have not imposed the sort of wide-spread mask mandate that we have seen in other states like texas. ultimately, what that approach leads to is some imbalance, for example, in the southeastern part of the state in palm beach, broward, miami dade county, the beaches are closed this weekend. there are strict curfews in place, mask mandates in place. here in clear water beach, it's wide open. families have been coming here all morning. we have seen folks playing volleyball and drinking on the water, kids playing in the sand. i should point out there are some signs up that make clear that there are ground rules for social distancing. they're asking folks who do not live in the same household stay
8:06 am
at least six feet apart and banning groups bigger than ten people. the question is how is that being enforced? we have not seen police or health officials trying to wrangle folks who may be breaking those rules. i have seen groups of more than 10 people showing up out here. obviously the big question is how this holiday weekend is going to impact the numbers moving forward. we saw a huge surge after people were ignoring the social distancing recommendations on memorial day weekend, this another holiday weekend could potentially spell even worse circumstances for florida. fred? >> all right, boris sanchez, keep us posted. thank you so much. another state seeing a surge in coronavirus cases, california. there are more than 251,000 confirmed cases and more than 6,000 deaths. cnn's from huntington beach. paul, this fourth of july weekend will look very different for many people in that general
8:07 am
vicinity. as well as really across the country. so what are the restrictions? how are people respecting that or protesting that? >> reporter: well, funny you say that because there's the very end of the now revamped and totally overhauled huntington beach fourth of july parade. we'll catch up with more of it later. what they did is this is a big event in huntington beach. there's usually half million people lining the streets watching it. it goes right along famed pacific coast highway. but this year they decided to make it more of a neighborhood parade. you can see i'm in a neighborhood. they're going to weave through neighborhood streets and basically make it a situation where people are going to wear their mask to watch the parade. they just announced the parade route this morning. they say it will come within a mile of everybody's house and just about 20 cars or so in two separate caravans. so they made that big adjustment and then up and down the california coast these major counties shut down. the beaches shut down. we looked at the beach earlier
8:08 am
today. we saw nobody on it in huntington beach despite the fact it's a big surf day. santa barbara county, ventura county, orange county all of them shutting down their beaches and officials applauding that because that cooperation will keep it so there's no pressure on anyone community. so as we said here in huntington beach, they decided that they were going to celebrate the fourth of july any way. it's a very patriotic city and the mayor explained why we're going to see so many vw buss in this parade. >> vw vans, that's huntington beach. we do a lot of events. they're always here driving people in parades. big part of it, yeah. >> reporter: and so that's the strategy now just to allow them to have a small parade here, keep those beaches closed, socially distant, keep the mask on. a new way of life this fourth of july weekend here in california. back to you, fred. >> that's right. a new way all across the
8:09 am
country. thank you so much, paul, appreciate that. in arizona, the number of new reported coronavirus cases continues to climb. hospitals are also getting dangerously close to capacity as the number of people requiring treatment soors. cnn evan mcmorris santoro gins us. >> good morning, fred. it's still early in the morning here in scottsdale. i'm in this mall area. you can see it's still pretty quiet. as you mentioned the situation here in the state is getting increasingly dire. 91% of intensive care beds are currently occupied, leaving 156 beds left. that kind of number is why the governor last week reimposed lockdowns on things like gyms and movie theaters and is calling on smaller gatherings for this holiday weekend. i want to show you what he is
8:10 am
facing in arizona with a tale of two signs. so first we'll walk over here to one of 18 locations the mountainside gym, fitness gym locations which is a gym that the governor ordered shut down last week but has been fighting him. if you come to this location here, you can see there's a sign on the wall kind of a lot of legalese saying we understand the governor wants us to shut down, but we don't think we have to and we'll remain open. they are still open despite the governor's orders. just next door here is a coffee place where i grabbed coffee this morning. it's pretty good. you can see the sign here says look, face coverings are required. keep healthy social distance. it's the law and we support it. so there is a political fight under way here about these new rules. and that's really governing how this state is trying to approach this rising pandemic here, fred. >> contrast right next door to one another. we look forward to all those
8:11 am
businesses or folks waking up in bigger numbers to hear more from scottsdale, arizona. thank you so much. meanwhile, in texas, as the state battles a massive wave of new cases there, hospitals in at least two counties are already at full capacity. that reality caused county judges to urge residents to stay home and shelter in place this holiday weekend. cnn correspondent lucy cavanaugh is in houston with a closer look now. >> reporter: well, texans are being encouraged to take all possible precautions this fourth of july weekend as the state continues to battle with a surge in coronavirus cases. friday saw 7555 new cases bringing the total now to more than 183,000. those numbers are quite high. hospitals feeling the pinch. more than 7,600 coronavirus cases. pardon me, patients at hospitals.
8:12 am
that's something that the medical facilities are dealing here. here in houston, the positivity rate is hovering around 25%, it's really putting a strain on some facilities. some hospitals, in fact, so overwhelmed they have to start transferring patients out to other facilities. now, on friday, the governor's mask mandate went into effect. what it means is that if you are a texan, if you live in a county that has 20 or more cases, you have to wear a mask in public. this applies to roughly 95% of all texans. that's one of the precautions that they're putting into place to try to curb the stem of this virus to try to reduce the rates. and of course, doctors here are still concerned that despite this mask mandate people might still gather, people might still expose themselves because what doctors at this facility, for example, tell us every time there's been a holiday weekend, whether it's mother's day or memorial day, they often see a spike in cases. and so they're sending the important message out, try to
8:13 am
stay home. try to socially distance. definitely wear your mask. remember, that this virus is very much out there. it's a different kind of fourth of july this time around. lucy kafanov, cnn texas. >> a very common reframe this fourth of july weekend. in georgia now, more than 1,400 health care workers have signed a letter to the state's governor imploring him to implement more restrictions to slow the virus's spread. their requests include closing down bars, nightclubs, prohibiting gatherings of more than 25 people and mandating residents wear face masks. this comes as the state continues to see a steady climb in cases. one of the doctors who penned the letter warned that there is a distinct possibility that the state will need to shelter in place again. still ahead, president trump uses mount rushmore as the backdrop for a divisive speech, railing against what he called a merciless campaign to wipe out
8:14 am
history and launching a staunch defense for confederate monuments. plus, multiple people close to the president are now confirmed to have covid-19, including donald trump jr.'s girlfriend. is the president increasingly at risk of exposure? and a critical shortage of contact tracers could change how the u.s. fights the virus. we're live next.
8:15 am
8:16 am
8:17 am
♪ book two separate qualifying stays and earn a free night. the open road is open again. and wherever you're headed, choice hotels is there. book direct at
8:18 am
♪ all right. president trump is back at the white house today after delivering a divisive speech during an independence day celebration at mount rushmore friday night instead of delivering an inspirational uplifting message of unity and patriotism as the nation battles a growing pandemic. the president chose to make an impassioned culture wars speech aimed before a crowd that was
8:19 am
packed in with no social distancing and very few masks to be seen. he railed against the removal of statues and monuments that some believe are symbols of racial oppression. >> our nation is witnessing a merciless campaign to wipe out our history, defame our heroes, erase our values and indoctrinate our children. our children are taught in school to hate their own country. and to believe the men and women who built it were not hero's but that were villains. >> sara westwood is at the white house for us. so sara, was this a preview of what we can expect from the president in his re-election campaign? >> well, fred, this was certainly a new chapter in the president's fight to preserve statues. and perhaps his strongest entry yet into the culture wars. in that speech the president argued that monuments to america's founders should never be removed, and he blamed
8:20 am
democrats for the unrest that we've seen in some cities that in some cases have led to statues being vandalized or toppled. >> our people have a great memory. they will never forget the destruction of statues and monuments to george washington, abraham lincoln, ulysses s. grant and many others. the violent mayhem we have seen in the streets and cities that are run by liberal democrats in every case is the predictable result of years of extreme indoctrination and bias and education, journalism and other cultural institutions. >> now the president's appeal went far beyond statues. he characterized the entire social justice movement as essentially a tool to silence
8:21 am
dissent going after culture in that speech. as you can see from some of those images people were not socially distancing at that event. they were given masks. they were voluntary to wear and people certainly not staying six feet apart throughout the evening, fred. >> so that is very similar to his tulsa rally, where in that case there were people on his advanced team that pested positive and now a positive covid test for someone who is even closer in the inner circle of the president's sphere. >> reporter: that's right, fred. hitting home for the trumps. kimberly guilfoyle the girlfriend of the president's son donald trump jr. tested positive last night for the coronavirus. she was at that south dakota event. as you know, everyone who will be in contact with the president, who is going to be in close proximity with him, they have to get tested. as part of that screening process, kimberly guilfoyle learned she is positive for coronavirus. she is self isolating and asymptomatic.
8:22 am
luckily donald trump jr. has tested negative. >> all right, sara westwood. thank you so much at the white house. we'll check back. so the news that a top trump campaign official has tested positive for covid-19 comes as several secret service agents have also tested positive, at least eight secret service agents are now stuck in phoenix after coming down with the virus while repairing for the trip to the area by the vice president. a former secret service agent under president obama and a cnn law enforcement analyst. good to see you, jonathan and happy fourth. >> happy fourth to you, fred. >> talk to me about the surprise that secret service agents would test positive and what many of them are customarily risking when traveling with the president or in this case it was the vice president. >> well, fred, when it comes down to it, this should be no surprise. this virus does not discriminate. so, if you put yourself in a
8:23 am
position of exposure, this virus is going to exploit vulnerabilities. the secret service does not direct the actions of our protectees, whether it's the president or the vice president. we have to look at the vulnerabilities around them and mitigate those physical security vulnerabilities. what you're seeing here is that the secret service is in a very tough position where they're putting forth their agents in harm's way to protect the president and vice president from physical threats, but we have this overarching health security threat that is severely impacting the agency. >> uh-huh. i mentioned how there were many with the president's advanced team who tested positive just ahead of the tulsa rally, but now we understand there are, what, 15 secret service agents who also tested positive. you mentioned, yes, it comes with the territory. there are certain level of risks. but what, if anything, are you
8:24 am
understanding that secret service agents are doing to perhaps protect themselves in this growing pandemic? >> listen, it comes down to awareness of how this virus is transmitted. and following the guidelines. whether it's social distancing, the proper utilization of protective equipment, personal protective equipment, engineering controls, administrative controls. so there's a lot that can be done to mitigate the health security issues that covid-19 presents. the problem is that there's a k governance issue. who is mandating this? who says all agents must wear masks at all times. that's what i'm not hearing. i'm talking to a lot of agents. they're feeling frustrated that these trips are going on, that they're not getting the right level of guidance from their supervisors in terms of how to best protect themselves. so again, it's awareness and
8:25 am
understanding how this pandemic is spreading and this virus is spreading and how they can best protect themselves. >> already a risky job made that much more during this growing pandemic. jonathan, thank you so much. have a great independence day weekend. >> great. thanks, fred, you too. next, the cdc director warned the u.s. needs to be more aggressive at tracking down people with coronavirus to contain the spread, but is it already too little too late? and a quick programming note, this fourth of july, tonight an evening of fireworks and an all-star musical lineup with jewel, john mclean and more, don lemon and dana bash host "cnn's fourth of july in america" live at 8:00 p.m. eastern. presentation of a capitol fourth! with your hosts john stamos and vanessa williams and performances from coast to coast. featuring: patti labelle, john fogerty, the temptations, andy grammer yolanda adams, renée fleming, trace adkins
8:26 am
brian stokes mitchell, chrissy metz, mandy gonzalez, and a tribute to our frontline workers. it's the fortieth anniversary of a capitol fourth. saturday july fourth, eight- seven central. only on pbs.
8:27 am
8:28 am
8:29 am
8:30 am
cdc director robert redfield told lawmakers this week that the u.s. needs to aggressively modernize contact tracing to fight the coronavirus pandemic. and as cnn's brian todd found out, there's also a critical shortage of contact tracers. >> reporter: an army desperately needed in the war against coronavirus is undermanned and losing on the battlefield in states recently hit the hardest. they're contact tracers, people who track down those who have coronavirus infected person has had contact with to monitor them for infection. public health officials say they're a crucial component to being able to reopen the economy so snu cases can be contained. but they say tracers are working in an outdated system. >> they really are in need of
8:31 am
aggressive modernization. >> contact tracing in this case, i'll be very quick, really doesn't have any value unless you can do it in realtime. >> reporter: and america doesn't have nearly enough tracers. >> we need to do more, including hiring at least 100,000 federally-funded workers to perform contact tracing and other public health tasks. >> reporter: one estimate says america needs about 30 contact tracers for every 100,000 people in a community. but a firm now says in eight states the ranks of contact tracers are dangerously low. texas only has about 11 contact tracers per 100,000 people. florida has about seven. arizona five. and five other states also have fall well short. >> now as we see a lot more transmission it's going to be a lot harder to do contact tracing because we really just can't get our arms around the epidemics. they're out of control. >> crystal watson who co-authored a report on contact tracing says many states did not
8:32 am
come up with the resources to hire enough contact tracers. as for the type of person needed -- >> it's a detective, investigator in the public health space. >> experts say contact tracers have to interview an infected person to get them to help identify anyone they've been in close contact with. >> you ask them about close contacts, that's within six feet for more than 15 minutes. anyone who fits that description would be considered a close contact. >> reporter: and contact tracers have to race against the clock. experts we spoke to say they have on average less than three days to find someone who an infected person has been in contact with and get that person to isolate. at this contact tracing center in arizona, working virtually, a team leader tells us it's time intensive, emotionally taxing work. >> our biggest challenge honestly is just getting people on the phone initially and talking to them. and then getting them to open up once you get ahold of them. >> reporter: and there are more challenges.
8:33 am
experts say contact tracing is now more complicated than ever because of the decisions by some governors to reopen their states so quickly. >> so as these cases grow and spike because of reopening and because people have come together in large numbers, it's going to get harder and harder to do that. >> reporter: it's getting so difficult that america's top voice on coronavirus says the armies of contact tracers should start acting like real armies. >> you can get community people to get boots on the ground and to go out there and look for the people instead of getting on a phone and doing so-called contact tracing by phone. >> reporter: but experts say contact tracers going out in neighborhoods should be from those neighborhoods so they understand the community and the culture, but they also add another huge challenge with contact tracing is that it's like a police officer trying to get a witness account of a crime. people's memories of their encounters are often shady and unreliable. brian todd, cnn, washington. a lot to discuss there. let's bring in dr.ester chew,
8:34 am
associate professor of emergency medicine at oregon health science and university. good to see you. is the problem the method of contact tracing? >> well, it's again a problem of sheer resource. you know, from the beginning we've always been chasing this problem of trying to test enough. so the virus has just been galloped out of control beyond our capacity to identify people who have been in contact with each and every case. and as force for this effort, the magnitude of this problem is kind of marching beyond our ability to recruit enough people and to do enough of this that we can get on top of it. >> so when you say it's now galloped out of control, do you feel like it is so out of control now -- i'm talking about the whole issue of the coronavirus positive tests now, that it's just too far, you know, flung to even try to contain? is the u.s. in big trouble?
8:35 am
>> well, i think -- i don't want to say something as dispairing as it's too out of control to contain, but i do think we need to get really creative. certainly using people in communities, taking advantage of areas where we do still have the opportunity to control it. and then bringing in methods like pooled testing where we can test large groups of people at a time and build in efficiencies and really go to scale on this. >> okay. you say get really creative. oregon was doing fairly well but then this week for two days the state broke records for new daily cases. that's where you are. what would be a creative approach, if not for your state, then any other to try to get a handle of things? >> yeah. oregon, we were so proud of doing so well and then now, you know, we doubled our cases over the past month. this week we had two consecutive
8:36 am
record-breaking days. i think there were a number of factors. people really, you know, i think it was really a problem of the big urban places and then the disease headed out into more rural and distant areas as we knew that it would. but i think in those places the disease just seemed very far away and not realistic. and people weren't taking social distancing measures and masks as seriously. i think, too, we were kind of proud of our ability to flatten the curve. and we got comfortable and started going out a little bit too quickly. and so i think again we need to be very strong with our public messaging. we need to really emphasize that we need to be nimble and what is true one week will not be true the next week. i think we need to make testing much more accessible, particularly outside of urban areas where there are very few testing centers. that may mean really mobilizing efforts in communities, putting more testing out there, mail-in testing, things that people can do at home will increase our
8:37 am
reach for testing and then a lot of really good on the ground boot strap epidemiologic efforts so we understand where disease is surging and what communities and really mobilize on our containment measures there. >> so let's go to the eastern sea board of the u.s. just moments ago cnn received new numbers out of florida, more than 11,000 cases reported today. that's the biggest case rise to date there. so, what, if anything, can florida do to get those numbers down and then are you particularly concerned, you know, only two of the counties dad and broward have closed the beaches. the rest of florida, people are at the beaches at perhaps large gatherings. that could be a recipe for more cases, is that your fear? >> absolutely. i mean, beaches are open and i'm seeing very little mask wearing. and of course florida, in addition to having the population that will go out to the beaches also has a very
8:38 am
large vulnerable population of older people. these numbers are scary. those are record-breaking numbers going into a holiday weekend. so, i am concerned that florida will exceed all expectations in a negative way. we're also seeing more concerning end points increased hospitalizations and deaths. and so i think for floridians who are really thinking about how can i best care for my neighbor? it's not about caring for yourself. it's how can i best be a good community citizen and really love my neighbor? the decisions they make this weekend will determine what happens over the next four to six weeks in florida. this is their opportunity to celebrate the holiday in a slightly different way. to watch fireworks from a distance. to do that little thing of mask wearing and keeping their distance if they do go out and really try to change the
8:39 am
trajectory. this weekend could be make or break for florida. they can double down on what's happening in their trends or they can really start to turn it around by being a little restrained on this holiday weekend. i hope that is the case for them. >> yeah. that really is a great lasting impression. you know, lesson for everyone, you know, in really song to sing in their head. even if you feel you're invincible, love thy neighbor, do the right thing if anything for your neighbor. even if you, yourself, feel so invincible and don't want to wear a mask. do it for your neighbor. dr. esther choo. thank you so much. coronavirus pandemic taking its toll overseas and leading other countries to ban americans. the latest next. [indistinct radio chatter] (mom) come on, hurry up!
8:40 am
all systems go? (mission control) 5 4 3 2... ignition and liftoff. (vo) audi e-tron. the next frontier of electric. the first and only full prescription strength non-steroidal anti-inflammatory gel available over-the-counter. new voltaren is powerful arthritis pain relief in a gel. voltaren. the joy of movement. i see all the amazing things you have been doing. you are transforming business models, and virtualizing workforces overnight. because so much of that relies on financing, we have committed two billion dollars to relieve the pressure on your business. as you adapt and transform, we're here with the people, financing, and technology, ready to help.
8:41 am
you can't always stop wefor a fingerstick.betese, financing, and technology, with the freestyle libre 14 day system, a continuous glucose monitor, you don't have to. with a painless, one-second scan you can check your glucose with a smart phone or reader so you can stay in the moment. no matter where you are or what you're doing. ask your doctor for a prescription for the freestyle libre 14 day system. you can do it without fingersticks. learn more at the sleep number 360 smart bed. prices of the season on can it help keep me asleep? absolutely, it senses your movements and automatically adjusts to keep you both comfortable. it's our 4th of july special the queen sleep number 360 c4 smart bed is only $1,299 plus, free premium delivery when you add a base. ends monday.
8:42 am
8:43 am
as coronavirus cases surge in the u.s., officials in cuba say they have been successful in reducing new cases and flattening the curve there.
8:44 am
cnn correspondents have that and other top international coronavirus stories. >> reporter: i'm patrick oppmann in havana where for the first time in over three months businesses, like restaurants, public transportation, even the beach have all begun to reopen. you can feel life slowly returning to the city even though people are still required to wear face masks, are still required to maintain social distancing. cuban officials say that cubans have managed to flatten the curve of new cases. one problem, though, remains the economy. most of this island, including havana remains off limits to international tourists. there are no flights coming in and out of havana. at least for the moment. and probably for the immediate future. so while the city is reopening, it remains cutoff from the outside world. >> reporter: i'm anna stewart in london. today is being called super saturday here in england.
8:45 am
it marks the biggest stage in the lifting of lockdown restrictions since the pandemic began. from today, pubs, restaurants, cinemas and hair salons can all reopen if they have covid-19 safety measures in place, like this pub behind me which embraced new measures, socially distanced tables and also taking the contact details of any customers which they'll keep on record for 21 days to allow for contact tracing should an outbreak occur. the prime minister has noticed some caution, though. he says we are not out of the woods yesterday. he wants the public to get spending. he wants them to save the brit i ish economy but they must act responsibly. they are ready to slam on the brakes should there be any outbreaks should a second wave of coronavirus look imminent. five american tourists were denied entry into the italian island. they were trying to skirt the regulations that the european
8:46 am
union put forth when they opened their external borders on july 1. united states is not on the safe list, therefore it is not legal for americans to come here for anything but essential travel. tourism, of course, is not considered essential travel. now, they were traveling with people from the united kingdom from new zealand, germany and italy and worked for 14 hours to try to find a solution. the family, which included three children, were just not able to enter the country and went on their way to england. >> pthank you so much. we have so much more in the news room right after this. to shower-skipping. these days call for a quick clean. luckily, help is still one wipe away. love, neutrogena®.
8:47 am
8:48 am
8:49 am
8:50 am
8:51 am
a book that you're ready to share with the world? get published now, call for your free publisher kit today! happening right now, demonstrators are filling the new black lives matter plaza in d.c., rallying against racism and police brutality. the march began at the nearby african-american history museum, and this is one of several protests happening around the country on this independence day. we'll take you there live as they all happen. president trump's celebration at mt. rushmore is shining a light on the culture war happening right now in the u.s. the president touted the event as a way to honor america, but for many native american tribes in south dakota, the black hills are a sacred place that was systematically taken, despite a treaty signed by the u.s. government. some have called on the monument
8:52 am
to be removed. it's a similar situation unfolding across the country as cities and states grapple with what to do with many civil war monuments. joining me right now to talk about all of this, archaeologist and host of "expedition unknown" on the discovery channel, josh gates. good to see you, and happy fourth. >> happy fourth. good to see you, too. >> we like to think of monuments, many do in america, as being a permanent reminder of a person or important event. you have traveled the world. are these monuments really as permanent as many would like to think? >> well, clearly no. you know, and that's the short answer. i mean, archaeology tells us that destruction of monuments is actually more than norm than preservation. we are a young nation, but if you look back through history, toppling of monuments and statues is something that, you
8:53 am
know, has been going on for a very long time. >> and this kind of underscores the whole dispute and the way of looking at it. is it about preserving history? is it about honoring, you know, particular leaders of movements, whether it be honorable or shameful? >> it's a difficult question, and i think each case is different. i think the first thing that we have to really grapple with when we talk about monuments like this is this really simple question of, what is a monument? you know, these are objects that are more than just art, right? they're not just out in a park to look pretty. they have a purpose. monuments historically are designed to commemorate a person or an event as you say but also an ideology associated with them, right? we are putting them up on a pedestal quite literally and we're trying to reinforce that something from our past is so important that we want to bring it into our present. we want to preserve it for our future. so we've got to be really
8:54 am
careful what are those things that are worthy of our honor and our admiration. especially in public places. so it's a thorny question. >> yeah, and, of course, you're hearing at the core of this as it pertains to the confessed rat statues and monuments, some argue they are symbols of heritage and many others will remind the time in which they were placed or erected really as symbols of white supremacy. >> yeah, and, look, i mean, as i said, each case is different. it's hard for me to make an argument to preserve these confederate monuments. i think that, for me, one of the basic litmus tests here that these statues and our country should pass is, are they honoring people who worked to strengthen our union? are they honoring people that worked to make us a stronger nation? and when you look at jefferson davis and you look at robert e. lee, these are not guys who were fighting to strengthen our
8:55 am
union. they were insurrectionists. the constitution defines treason as levying war against the united states. these are guys that we are putting up on pedestals who tried to tear our nation apart. i have a hard time making the argument for keeping them there in these public places. i think context matters. now, you know, there may be an argument to preserve some of these statues in an educational context somewhere else. but i think that it's important to remember that there have been decades in some cases of protests and people really pleading about removing these statues. they've caused a lot of pain, and they did, as you say, a lot of them went up in the jim crow era and went up in the early 20th century, and are very, very problematic. but as we look back through history, as i said, this is nothing new. and i think one of the things that's important is we have to grapple with the idea that not everything is permanent just because it's big and heavy and goes up on a pest stal.
8:56 am
we have to continuously re-evaluate what are the things we want to honor and what are the things worthy of admiration. you're essentially saying there's room for rethinking its purpose. all right. thank you so much, josh gates. appreciate it. have a great fourth weekend. thanks for being with us today. >> cheers. and we'll be right back.
8:57 am
8:58 am
8:59 am
9:00 am


info Stream Only

Uploaded by TV Archive on