tv Anderson Cooper 360 CNN June 22, 2011 2:00am-3:00am EDT
tonight new york lawmakers are just one vote away from legalizing same sex marriage. president obama is heading to new york this week for a fundraiser with members of the gay community. new questions are being raised about what the president actually believes about gay marriage and whether his public opposition to it is real or just
political posturing in 1996 when he was a college professor running for illinois state senate from a wealthy liberal chicago neighborhood, barack obama answer add question in a local paper called outlines. he checked a box next to the sentence i favor legalizing same sex marriages and would fight efforts to prohibit such marriages. seems pretty clearcut, doesn't it? once he was actually in office his position suddenly and inexplicably began to change. in 1998, responding to an illinois state legislative national political awareness test here's how he responded to the question, do you believe that illinois government should recognize same sex marriages? his answer undecided. by 2004 on the verge of his campaign for national office, the united states senate, mr. obama was telling the windy city times that he supported civil unions saying "i think that marriage in the minds of a lot of voters has a religious connotation. i know that's true in the african-american community". then four years later, running for president appearing at the
saddle back megachurch in southern california talking with pastor rick warren he said quite clearly he was against same sex marriage. >> i believe it marriage is the union between a man and a woman. [ applause ] >> now, for me as a christian -- for me as a christian, it's also a sacred union. god's in the mix. [ applause ] >> would you support a constitutional amendment with that definition? >> no, i would not. >> why not? [ applause ] >> because historically -- because historically we have not defined marriage in our constitution. it's been a matter of state law that has been our tradition. now, i mean, let's break it down. the reason that people think there needs to be a constitutional amendment, some
people believe, is because of the concern about same-sex marriage. i am not somebody who promotes same-sex marriage, but i do believe in civil unions. i do believe that we should not -- that for a gay partners to want to visit each other in a hospital, for the state to say, you know what, that's all right, i don't think in any way inhibits my core beliefs about what marriage are. i think my faith is strong enough and my marriage is strong enough that i can afford those civil rights to others even if i have a different perspective or different view. >> so that's the chronology. 1996 he supported same-sex marriage and said he would fight for it. 12 years later, running for president, he opposed it and says he still does, though he now says his position is evolving. hard to see how president's position has changed so much. the only thing that has changed is his need for a wider audience to vote for him.
now, in the last several days the white house seems to have struggled with exactly what to say about the president's flip-flop over the years on gay marriage. and net roots nation last week, white house communications director dan pfeiffer was asked about that 1996 questionnaire. >> i've got his answer right here. i favor same-sex marriage and would -- >> that questionnaire was actually filled out by someone else, not the president. there was a long debate about this in the campaign. >> so it's a fake questionnaire? >> so what i was going to tell you, his position has been consistent on this. what he has said -- >> so well, hold on a minute. you're saying that this is a fake questionnaire? >> this was litigated in the campaign there. were a number of other issues in the campaign. >> i don't think it's actually been clarified. i would like to clarify it now. there are a lot of people here concerned about this issue. so the president has never favored same-sex marriage? >> the president's position on gay marriage, i will say, is that he has been against it. but he has said that the country
is evolving on this and he is evolving on it. and he has said why. this is an answer he gave when some of the folks in this room were in the white house with a meeting with the president. and the president said that -- he said, it's clear the country is moving on this. it's evolving and he's evolving. >> so he seems to be saying the president didn't ever support same-sex marriage. dodging whether he said what he said in it. yesterday a reporter for the washington blade asked president secretary jay carney about that same questionnaire. as you'll see the answer? well, i guess you can say it is evolving as well. >> can you clarify whether or not the '96 survey was signed by obama? >> it is my understanding that it was. i think we clarified on friday that dan was referring to another questionnaire. >> well, did the president in fact support same-sex marriage in 1996? >> what i know his position was during the campaign and what it is now. he's been very clear about it. he was very clear in the
campaign. he's very clear about the fact that his position that it's evolving. and i really don't have anything to add to it. >> so it's interesting. he admits the 1996 survey was signed by barack obama, but you'll notice he avoids saying if the president believed what he said back then and avoid explaining why the president has apparently changed his position or why he's evolving back to what it may have been 12 years ago. i spoke about all this a few moments ago with a democratic strategyist and human rights activist founder of the names project aids memorial quilt. >> paul, how is it possible that then professor obama said he's in favor of same-sex marriage, and now he's had this evolution to where he's now no longer in favor of it? it's got to just be politics. >> well, probably it is. i don't like to criticize other people's motives, but at that time his politics were all about winning a state senate district, a very progressive part of chicago, which is a progressive city. then the politics changed.
he became a young man on the move, illinois a much different place than just his little district. and he then came out against it. it is just politics. i have to say on this one he's kind of behind the american people. he was way ahead of us frankly on healthcare, on the auto bailout, on any number of issues. but on this one he is lagging politician. we have a narrow majority of americans who now support full equality in marriage for all americans. and i think the president's a little late to the party, frankly. >> it's interesting, cleave, because people who are opposed to same-sex marriage point to president obama and say, well, look, president obama doesn't support it as well. do you believe he actually doesn't support it? or do you think this is just he made a political calculation of you know what i'm just going to say i don't support it even though maybe i real will i do? >> well, i think it's clearly a political calculation. and sadly i think it's the wrong one. i think this president needs to re-energize his base. i support the president. i campaigned for him.
i anticipate campaigning again. and i believe that the role that he and his advisors would wish me to play would be to be re-energizing the base. and this is not the way to do it. he is definitely behind the curve. the evolution of the country on this issue is proceeding at a far more rapid rate than his own. so i'm concerned about it. and this visit to new york, given the situation there right now, i think puts him in a very difficult position. >> you know, paul, democrats attack conservatives for being hypocritical on issues that they're hypocritical about. but i don't hear a lot of democrats attacking their own president for hypocrisy. the president is now saying, well, my opinion on this is evolving, which is clearly kind of a hint to people in the gay community to people who do support same-sex marriage that maybe he will one day support it.
i mean, is he trying to have it both ways? >> well, sure. all of us do and certainly politicians no different from the rest of us. i don't think it's hypocritical at all. i can't peer into his heart. there maybe some authentic evolution here. cleave makes a good point. he's a little late to this. >> how do you evolve from i support it in '96 so i don't so support it to i'm thinking i may support it. >> he seems to be evolving backwards. that is of concern. >> sort of deevolution. but look, the politics did change. here's the politics he needs to worry about. were i advising him i'd say, mr. president, you've got 73% of the gay vote when you ran in 2008. now, that was less than john kerry got. john kerry got 77. it's the only real heart of our base where you did less well than john kerry, at least that i came across. and by the way, two years later in 2008 the democrats in 2010, rather, only got 69%. so we've had an 8 point erosion in our performance among gay americans. we need to do something. cleave is exactly right.
we need to do something to energize this base or republicans will continue to gain with gay americans, even though i don't think their agenda reflects the gay community. >> does the democratic party take gay americans for granted? feeling that well, look, they're not going to go to the republican party? >> there's great cynicism and enormous frustration with this administration. and of course, as in my case it's also mixed with a lot of affection and respect. but the fact that they would continue to defend don't ask don't tell for as long as they did, for the fact that he's already stated that in his view of the core of the defense of marriage act is unconstitutional. well then he should sign on to senator feinstein's bill to repeal it and signal some support there. i've been working with the courage campaign trying to get more cosponsors for senator feinstein's legislation. the momentum is clear. the tide of history is clear. his window of opportunity to stake his claim on the right side of history is diminishing rapidly.
he needs to move. and right now with this opportunity in new york is an extraordinary opportunity. he could really move us all forward very decisively. i hope he'll hear this and do that. >> paul, just politically, though, this is a president who's a politician and he weighs things very carefully and often tries to find consensus and walk a middle ground. do you think it's likely that here actually would say he is for marriage equality for gay americans before the election? or is that something he would do after the election when politically there wouldn't be a price to pay? >> well, i think he's likely to do it -- this is not based on any insights. i don't talk to those guys and gallons down at the white house. but i think he's likely or certain to do it before the election because he's going to have. to people are going to come to him as the white house press corps today. >> you think he will come out publicly for it? >> that's my best guess. now, one political problem he's got with doing it right now? he should.right now because of this vote in new york. new york state senate is one full vote away from full marriage equality.
he's going to be in new york. here's the problem politically. he's going to be at a fundraiser hosted mostly by the lgtb community. if you go to a fundraiser and endorse the agenda of the people who are giving you money that looks kind of bad politically as well. i hate to say i almost wish he didn't have the fundraiser and could focus on that vote in the new york. >> it's going to look a lot worse when he goes to ask these people for money and has to explain to them that in his view they still don't deserve equal protection under the law. he's in a difficult position. the right thing to do would be to do the right thing. >> cleave jones, great to have you on the program, paul begala as well. >> let us know what you think. we're on facebook or follow me @ anderson cooper. up next, president obama getting ready to announce troop pullouts from afghanistan. we're going to preview that and talk about how our unreliable ally pakistan has cost american lives in the war. and are they giving up secrets to help the militants?
new evidence of that. and later a potential shocker in the casey anthony trial. her father's alleged mistress, george anthony's alleged mistress may take the stand as early as tomorrow. there was new testimony today on duct tape, dna and leaves where caylee's body was found. full details ahead. that's helping drive the future of business. in here, inventory can be taught to learn. ♪ machines have a voice. ♪ medical history follows you. it's the at&t network -- a network of possibilities... committed to delivering the most advanced mobile broadband experience to help move business... forward. ♪ carol. fiber makes me sad. oh common. and how can you talk to me about fiber while you are eating a candy bar? you enjoy that. i am. [ male announcer ] fiber beyond recognition. fiber one.
two of the most important are energy security and economic growth. north america actually has one of the largest oil reserves in the world. a large part of that is oil sands. this resource has the ability to create hundreds of thousands of jobs. at our kearl project in canada, we'll be able to produce these oil sands with the same emissions as many other oils and that's a huge breakthrough. that's good for our country's energy security and our economy. and today, we're re-inventing aspirin for pain relief. with new extra-strength bayer advanced aspirin. it has microparticles so it enters the bloodstream faster and rushes relief right to the site of your tough pain. ♪ in fact, it's clinically proven to relieve pain twice as fast. new bayer advanced aspirin. extra strength pain relief, twice as fast.
president obama speaks to the nation tomorrow night about afghanistan. a congressional source telling us he's going to announce plans to pull out 10,000 troops this year and another 20,000 by the end of 2012. i was going to bring you his peach speech as 8:00 p.m. eastern. tonight we're keeping them onnest on pakistan. it's where a lot of the ieds that kill and maim american troops are made in pakistan's tribal areas near the afghan border. in recent weeks, however, american officials have reportedly told pakistani intelligence about four bomb-making factories. and in all four cases, the intelligence has apparently leaked to the insurgents. by the time pakistani troops get there, the factories are empty. someone has been tipping them off, though pakistani officials including the country's top military spokesmen today deny it. in addition pakistani authorities have arrested dozens of people for helping in the raid that killed osama bin laden while steadfastly denying he had a support network helping him
live for years in the very heart of pakistan. >> this is a man who was living in a for the tress. you have intelligence agents swarming all over the country. how did they not know? >> 9/11 happened in new york with all the maximum and the best available intelligence to, the american parties could not make out 9/11's culprits and they were still taking training in the institutions there. so sometimes intelligence failures are there. >> in your investigation have you found any evidence that bin laden had a support network here in pakistan? >> there is no such thing at all. not an i yo that of doubt. >> so you categorically deny that he had a support network here? >> no support network. >> even if that unlikely claim is true he had no support network, new polling from pew research tonight suggestion bin laden had plenty of popular support among pakistanis. 63% disapproved of the raid that pulled him out. 12% had a positive view of american.
12% despite billions of dollars in humanitarian aid and military aid flowing into pakistan since the 9/11 attacks. i talked about the problems with fareed zakaria and editor at large of time magazine. >> there have been several incidents of insurgents in pakistan abandoning bomb-making facilities after the u.s. informed the pakistani regime about them. that certainly seems to play into all of u.s.'s concerns about collaboration between elements within the pakistani military and terrorist groups. >> look, at this point there's really no question. everybody has now notice add pattern in which when you ask the pakistani military for help with regard to certain militants, certain groups, certain bomb-making factories, by the time you get there in 50% of the cases the militants have been tipped off. i think it's important to point out, i don't think this is happening at the very highest level. i don't think general kuyani the hezbollah of the army or general pasha knows about this. but that's even worse.
what it suggests it that there are elements of the pakistani military that are infiltrated with this radical islamic ideology and they're being insubordinate. they have become rogue elements within the pakistani military. this is very disturbing we believed that for all its problems the pakistani military was a professional military. >> we've always talked about lower levels of the isi that may have connections but now you have a brigadier general, highest-ranking senior officer arrested in pakistan and being held for links to a banned group in pakistan. >> yeah. this is quite striking. for the reason you say, very senior guy, a brigadier general, and with a very nasty organization. >> it's called -- i had never heard of it. called hizba al tarir? >> founded in the 1950s i think in jerusalem. really one of the original pan islamic terrorist organizations in a way a role model for al qaeda, very strong in central
asia. >> they want u.s. troops out of pakistan, out of the region, and muslim -- >> exactly. there goes pretty much al qaeda's goals. kalifaid, a hard line sunni organization. they don't believe in women being educated. it's about as extreme as you can get. . musharef tried to ban them. but in pakistan they haven't done any real violence yet, so a court order overturned the ban because it said this is jut free speech. but still, they're a very nasty group. and the fact that he would be tied to them suggest that there is again some international dimension to this as well. >> do you think his arrest is sort of an olive branch to the united states or do you think it's in pakistan's best interests? >> no, i think it's precisely that. i don't know if it's an olive branch. but i think that the cia and the obama administration have been pressing the pakistani military. i know that they've given them a list of specific things they want them to do. and among them are to try and figure out really who is
infiltrated within the pakistani military, and they're trying to deliver on those things. it is in pakistan's best interests, but unfortunately that is not always how the pakistani military sees it. >> were you surprised by the announcement of the levels of the troop withdrawal that we're going to be seeing or allegedly will be seeing in afghanistan? >> i'm not surprised because i think obama's heart was always more with joe biden. if you remember there was this debate. biden wanted a much smaller troop presence in afghanistan and a focus on counterterrorism. petraeus and gates said no, let's go in there and do the surge. i think that obama really was more in biden's camp, but military outfoxed him by leaking the recommendations and a democratic president can go against certainly a military advisor like petraeus. >> so you think he was really more wanting the counterinsurgency strategy. >> i think so. i think his basic view is that we have too large a military footprint in these places, that
what we need to do is draw down and broadly rebalance american foreign policy away from this massive investment in afghanistan, iraq, and the broader middle east. he wants to move to dealing with issues reeling to the rise of china, india, russia, and this i think means that you stay bogged down. because when you have those many troops in a country, anderson as you know, 90% of the president's time ultimately is taken up where american troops are. >> fareed zakaria, appreciate it. >> thanks. >> pleasure. quick reminder, president obama is speaking on afghanistan tomorrow night from the white house 8:00 p.m. cnn will start carrying is live 8:00 eastern time. we'll have full details on "anderson cooper 360" at 10:00. coming up tonight you probably heard newt gingrich and his wife had a line of credit at tiffany's up to $1 million. now we've learned about another line of credit at tiffany's. you're not going to believe how much this one was worth later a potential bombshell in the casey anthony trial. george anthony's alleged mistress could be testifying as early as tomorrow in the case. she was outside the courtroom
today. we'll also have the latest on the dna testimony today when we continue. ♪ [ male announcer ] every day, thousands of people are choosing advil. here's one story. my name is lacey calvert and i train professional athletes with yoga. i know how my body should feel. if i have any soreness, i'm not going to be able to do my job. but once i take advil, i'm able to finish my day and finish out strong. then when i do try other things, i always find myself going back to advil. it really works! [ laughs ] [ male announcer ] make the switch. take action. take advil. [ male announcer ] make the switch. right now, go to priceline for a sneak peek at recent winning and better than ever! hotel bids to find where you n save up to 60% on hotels. * we'll even email you other people's winning bids, so you'll know what price to name. *á
the weapon used to kill him was purchased in the united states, but what's really stunning is that it was intentionally allowed into mexico by u.s. authorities. see, it was an operation call fast and furious. and the idea was to monitor gun trafficking, link them to mexican drug cartels and then make arrests in mexico. but once the sales were made, atf whistle blowers say that agents had actually no way of knowing where the gunsened up. and unbelievably, their mexican counterparts who were supposed to make the arrests, they were never even told about this operation. so a program meant to stop gun smuggling actually put weapons into criminal's hands in mexico. and there are at least 1800 other weapons out there mostly still missing. so far no one in the u.s. government has admitted they approved this program, and no one has taken responsibility. now, the acting director of the bureau of alcohol, tobacco & firearms kenneth melson is expected to resign in the next day or two. he might just be the fall guy. attorney general eric holder was
grilled about this program by the head of the -- >> you probably heard about fast and furious for the first time over the last few weeks. >> now that you've been briefed on it, the president has said on march 22nd that he didn't authorize it. did your deputy attorney general james cole authorize it? >> my guess would be no. mr. cole i don't think was in the -- i think -- i don't think he was in the department at the time that operation started. >> how about the head of the criminal division, lanny brewer? did he authorize it? >> i'm not sure whether mr. brewer authorized it. >> no one seems to know who authorized this. border agent pry an terry, drew, was murdered back in december of 2010. considering the atf is part of the justice department does anyone buy that holder wasn't aware of the program when agent terry was murdered or even before it? >> you know, i've been on the
phone talking to some of these atf agents today. i've talked to them over the weekend. it's really hard for them to imagine that holder wasn't at least briefed about it. this was a major operation, anderson. and quite frankly, up until the disastrous death of brian terry, this they thought was going to be a big hit or a home run for them. they were going to arrest cartel members. that required a lot of approval, a lot of approval for overtime just to do the surveillance, wiretaps, surveillance video being done, all of that requires approval up the chain all the way into the department of justice. and to the boots on the ground it's unimaginable that high up people in the department of justice, including holder himself, at least didn't know about it. >> so now you have the acting director of the atf, this guy kenneth melson expected to step down in the next day or two because of this program. is he just the fall guy? >> he seems to be being set up that way. the question i think to ask is, for justice, does this end? justice obviously is trying to
get this behind them as quickly as possible. if they can replace kenneth melson, get somebody else in there and try to smooth this over with congress, they think they can move on with their own internal investigation and maybe come out with something in a few months. but members of congress say no way. congressman darrel issa head of the house oversight committee is going to press hard. we got a statement from senator chuck grassley the republican from iowa who's been pushing hard on this. he said, "it would be a shame if the justice department makes mr. melson the only fall guy for this disastrous straeblg. there's plenty of blame to go around at both the atf and justice department. a resignation by the acting director would be by no means the end of our inquiry". grassley also said he'd be interested in hearing what melson has to say to him after he is kicked out of justice as we all believe will happen. >> and when president obama and eric holder were asked about the program, they both pointed to an investigation that's being conducted by the inspector general of the justice department.
do we have any idea when the findings of that are going to be released? >> we don't. the members of congress think they're being stone walled. we've gone over this, why does it take five, six months to find out who in your own department approved anything. that should be a decision that you can come back with in five minutes. but the stonewalling, according to congress, continues while atf, the department of justice try to fix this. >> all right, drew, appreciate the followup. we'll continue to follow it. why the alleged mistress of casey anthony's father, george anthony is expected in court tomorrow. we'll tell you what she's expected to testify about. first randi kaye has a 360 bulletin. >> reporter: an unmanned u.s. navy helicopter went down while on a nay vo station mission over libya. nato says it lost contact with the helicopter this morning. libyan state tv reported it was a manned apache helicopter but nato says no apaches have been lost during the entire mission. newt gingrich had at least apparently two lines of credit at the jewelry store tiff thinks. one worth $1 million.
about a month ago, financial disclosure forms for gingrich's wife showed they had a line of credit at the store for between a quarter and a half million dollars during 2005 and 2006. the campaign says the account has a zero balance and has been closed. republican john huntsman announced his bid for the presidency today at liberty state park in new jersey. huntsman is the former governor of utah and also served as u.s. ambassador to china under president obama. more than 10,000 firefighters are at work against 52 wildfires now burning in 12 states. the fires have burned almost 2200 square miles, nearly the size of delaware. the u.s. forest service says the number of acres burned is three times the 10-year average. congresswoman gabrielle giffords's husband mark kelly is retiring from nasa and the u.s. navy october 1. he commanded the final flight of the space shuttle endeavor. he says he wants to be by giffords's side as she continues her recovery meanwhile,
scribner has announced it will publish the couple's memoir at a date to be determined, anderson. >> crime and punishment day 24 in the casey anthony murder trial. the focus today, dna. duct tape and plant growth at the site where caylee anthony's remain were found. in the meantime, big surprise from the prosecution plus george anthony's alleged mistress may be called to testify as early as tomorrow. we'll talk to you about what she may say. also ahead, the death of ryan dunn. the autopsy report is now out on the star of mtv's jackass. we have details on that. [ female announcer ] what if your natural beauty could be flawless too?
discover aveeno positively radiant tinted moisturizers with scientifically proven soy complex and natural minerals. give you sheer coverage instantly, then go on to even skin tone in four weeks. aveeno tinted moisturizers. then i've tried it.kin tone in four weeks. but nothing's helped me beat my back pain. then i tried this. it's salonpas. this is the relief i've been looking for. salonpas has 2 powerful pain fighting ingredients that work for up to 12 hours. and my pharmacist told me it's the only otc pain patch approved for sale using the same rigorous clinical testing that's required for prescription pain medications. proven. powerful. safe. salonpas. now,listen to a magazine,aper, curl up with a movie, and see a phone call.
crime and punishment tonight, a new twist in the casey anthony trial. word tonight that george anthony's alleged mistress may take the witness stand tomorrow morning. her name is crystal holloway. the woman says she had an affair with mr. anthony. she told the police one thing, the national enquirer something else. it's an affair george anthony denies. this woman told an orlando television station she'd been subpoenaed to appear in court at 8:30 a.m. holloway said she's prepared to testify about what she says mr. anthony told her in 2008 before his granddaughter's rye mains were found. >> what did george tell you about that? >> that it was an accident that snowballed out of control. i don't believe that george picked the body up like they said. i think it was an accident.
>> well, more on this development in just a moment. first though day 24 in the trial many today the defense called a string of expert witnesses to testify about dna and duct tape and leaves. but the question is, did the testimony actually help or hurt the defense's case? gary tuchman was in the courtroom. he joins us now. >> reporter: casey anthony often covers her mouth in court when she talks to her attorneys. she doesn't want others to read her lips. but if she was asking how day was going, a candid answer would have been not so great. >> my name is richard -- >> reporter: the defense is now calling its witnesses. this is the time where anthony's attorneys have the best chance to bolster their case. dna scientist richard eicllenblun was asked about the lakt of dna on caylee anthony's skull. the defense theory because no dna was found that means it was put on the skull after the crime, after her body decomposed by someone other than her mother. >> if you would put tape on a face, it's very likely you would
get a dna pro fill. >> reporter: prosecutors have said that after months in the woods the dna disappeared, a theory he did not deny when pushed in cross-examination. >> that dna could have simply degraded and decomposed, correct? >> that is possible. >> reporter: the defense also called a government chemist to try to discredit the prosecution finding that poisonous clear row form was in casey anthony's car trunk. the jury heard this. >> the relative abundance of clear row form seemed very unusual to me. >> reporter: and then there was another defense witness. botanist jane balk. anthony's attorneys are trying to convince the jury somebody tampered with caylee anthony's body and dumped it in the woods a couple of weeks before it was found. defense attorney dorothy clay sims asked her -- >> can you tell me whether or not you have formed an opinion as to the shortest period of time that remains of caylee anthony could have been at the scene in which they were found?
>> yes. two weeks. >> and what is the basis for your opinion? >> because of the pattern of the leaf litter. >> reporter: but the prosecution got her to sing a different tune, too. >> are you presenting the opinion that that growth into the bone could have occurred in two weeks in december? >> i suspect so, but i'm no expert on bones. >> it's also possible it was there for a great deal longer than two weeks. >> yes. >> reporter: casey anthony's defense is that her daughter accidentally drowned in the swimming pool. casey's father conspired with her to keep the death a secret. with that in mind, listen to this attention-getting statement made by the prosecution in court. >> it was made outside the presence of the jury. the prosecution had just learned about something that happened to an inch mate who was in the same jail as casey anthony. >> apparently her child died in a swimming pool and was found by the child's grandfather. >> reporter: there is no
evidence yet the two women had talked to each other. but the prosecution will investigate whether it's possible casey anthony made up a story based on the true story of another woman. >> you know, it's interesting, gary, how hard a time the defense is having in this case to even kind of make their own case. >> you know, anderson, the defense is swimming against a strong tide. we've seen over the last few weeks a lot of circumstantial evidence. but they've also put themselves in a box, defense attorneys, because of the opening statement where they say casey's daughter drowned and then casey decided inexplicably not to say anything about it. and it's a crazy statement. it's a crazy defense. and i use the word crazy purposely. because if it's 100% true that's still crazy. who does something like that? so the jurist certainly expecting to hear something about that. this trial has been going on for weeks and they haven't heard anything about that. in addition, you have prosecutors who are at the top of their game, you have a judge who is very smart, he's gentle and strict at the same time and he's very careful not to allow
any inadmissible testimony or questions to come in via the lawyers. and so far the defense lawyers have had most of the inadmissible questions. >> gave, thanks very much for the update. today is the first we've actually heard during the trial about this woman, april whalen, the woman whose child apparently died in a pool. i talked with jean kazarez and dr. michael hunter forensic pathologist and chief medical examiner in panama city, florida. >> jean, as we heard from gary, this woman april whalen in the same jail as casey for a brief period of time had a very similar story to hers about her own son drowning in the family pool, being found by his grandfather. what more do we know about this? do we know if there really was a link between her and casey? >> no. and that's what prosecutors are investigating right now. they said today in court outside of the presence of the jury that a citizen had actually called the orange county sheriff's department to report this, that an april whalen who was an inmate back in 2009 and she was a couple cells down from casey anthony, that in 2007 on
christmas day her little son that was close in age to caylee actually drowned in the family swimming pool about 2:20 in the afternoon. the child disappeared for 20 minutes. the whole family was out trying to find her little son. and it was the grandfather that found the little boy deceased in the pool. so the issue is, april has said she never spoke to casey. she never told case yichlt never even met casey. but she said she did talk with some other inmates and told them about her son. so could casey have overheard that? could the other inmates have told casey? and in so doing, would casey have then gotten a story, a fictional fantasy story about an accidental drowning? >> right and even though the prosecution has rested they can call her as a witness later on. dr. hunter, the forensic botanist seemed unsure about the length of time that caylee's remains were actually at the crime scene before they were found. is there any way to know for sure how long they were there?
>> you know, i don't think so. as far as time of death goes. what a forensic pathologist can do is look at the remains early on and give a good estimation. the intermediate range is really going to be the entomologist's field. he's going to be able to look at the remains, look at the insect infestation going on, and look at the life cycle of insects to give an estimation at least within that week to two weeks to maybe a little bit longer time frame. the botanist, he can go out further than the entomologist. he can look at what's going on around where the victim is subsequently found, the growth around where the skeletal remains are found, the deposits on the skeletal remains, the leaf material, other types of material that may settle, and provide an opinion. >> jean, how well do you think the defense's experts, the forensic experts, the pathologist and botanist, how well do you think they are doing
to disprove the prosecution's experts? >> here's the thing, anderson. there were some renowned experts on the side of the defense. but as they testify, and especially on cross-examination, it appears as though that they don't know the facts of the case. they don't know what the defense believes to be the case or factually is the case. so when it comes to cross-examination and the facts are brought out by the prosecution, they become prosecution witnesses. and i think the challenge for the defense with these forensic witnesses is immense in this case. >> jean, also george anthony's alleged mistress was subpoenaed. what is the defense going to try to prove with her testimony? >> i saw her in the hallway today. well, here's what she testified to authorities. she said in a sworn deposition that george anthony had told her -- and by the way, she denies any affair in the sworn testimony before law
enforcement, but she came out public to the national enquirer saying she had an affair. but she said under oath that george anthony said to her in an intimate moment that this was an accident that snowballed out of control. but was that just wishful thinking on the part of george anthony or did he even say it at all? >> you said jean today the mood in the court was especially sad. >> you know be today was a tough day. jurorses were taking notes, but as the day went on they got restless, they got listless. and you know, the forensic experts possibly could cancel each other out. they really could. because you're seeing inconsistencies. and you know what jurors could rely on in the end is the smell in the trunk that witness after witness that has experience with deceased bodies could smell the decomposition odor from casey anthony's truck. dr. hunter, that is i guess the danger when you have duelling experts like this they kind of can sell each other out and people just go with the explanation that seems most basic or simple, a smell in the trunk they can relate to.
>> right, anderson. you've got to keep in mind, witnesses for the prosecution, those experts, they really have to testify to a higher standard. they're testifying beyond a reasonable doubt. the witnesses for the defense, these experts, they really have to bring in the question of what's possible. you know, when you open up what is possible, then you have arguments that can come about. you have a lot more that i think the defense can work with. possible does not rise to the level that i think the prosecutors really need to get in a case like this. >> very interesting stuff. dr. michael hunter, thanks, jean kazaraz as well. up next how much would you pay for a gun that once belonged to the gangster al capone. wait until you hear what one auction house hopes to rake in to sell one of his revolvers and you'll meet the 51-year-old actor who married a 16-year-old aspiring singer and actress. and while they maybe getting
and if we get lucky, really lucky, it dawns on us to go spend them in a world where a simple sunrise can still be magic. twenty-five thousand mornings. make sure some of them are pure michigan. your trip begins at michigan.org. we get double miles on every purchase, so me and the boys earned a trip to dc twice as fast! oh hi! we get double miles every time we use our card. and since double miles add up fast... one more chariot please. ...we can bring the whole gang! i cannot tell a lie. he did it. right... it's hard to beat double miles! read my lips -- no new axes! [ male announcer ] get the venture card from capital one, and earn double miles on every purchase, every day.
go to capitalone.com. what's in your wallet? so, you're a democrat right? bridgestone is using natural rubber, researching ways to enhance its quality and performance, and making their factories more environmentally friendly. producing products that save on fuel and emissions, and some that can be reused again. ♪ and promoting eco-friendly and safety driving campaigns. ♪ one team. one planet. bridgestone. and my dog bailey and i love to hang out in the kitchen. you love the aroma of beef tenderloin, don't you? you inspired a very special dog food. [ female announcer ] chef michael's canine creations. chef inspired. dog desired.
be the next secretary of defense. panetta currently heads the cia. at the pentagon hooelg succeed robert gates who is resigning in 10 days an autopsy report shows jackass star ryan dunn and a passenger in his car died of blunt and thermal trauma. dunn was driving his porsche when he crashed and caught on fire in pennsylvania early monday. police believe speed was a factor in the crash. and they won't know for several weeks when toxicology reports come back if alcohol was also involved a photo posted on dunn's twitter page just two hours before the crash showed him at a bar with a drink in his hand. and a handgun once owned by notorious gangster al capone is going up for sale tomorrow in london. the auction house chrsti's is telling the 39 special revolver. chrsti's expects the winning bidder to cough up at least
$80,000600. >> that's cool. neat randi time for the redick luft. tonight we're adding those heartless folks criticizing the love between this actor and his new bride. talking about a guy named doug hutchison. apparently he was in the movie "the green mile" and had a small role on "lost "and "the x files q. he's 51 years old. in a few weeks ago in las vegas he married a 16-year-old girl. a lot of people are making a bunch of noise about how the girl, courtney stodden, is a minor and how there's a 35-year age difference between them. blah blah blah blah blah. i don't see what the big deal is. the wedding was on may 20th. according to my calendar that was a friday. she probably only had to miss one day of high school. what was she going to miss in 11th grade, any way? algrebra? whoever uses that? but it got me thinking who is this young lady who found true love with a character acted in his early 50s. luckily like a lot of 16-year-olds she has a youtube channel where she posts video, probably talks about her homework and getting her driver's license and justin bieber and stuff. let's take a look.
>> when i'm a walking, they'll be talking, when i walk by, it's not my thought you can't control -- >> oh. goodness. well, i'm sure there's more to her than just that. >> don't put it on me, girl. don't put it on me, girl. no. don't put it on me, girl. don't. >> well now, a lot of people are suggesting that someone should have told courtney don't marry that guy, he's too old for you, you have your driver's test coming up. someone like her parents maybe. guess what, romance haters. her parents gave their permission. they're not those uptight parents that don't let their teenage daughter stay out past 11:00 or make music videos on boats or date someone three times her age. her mom said they're totally supportive of this new marriage. and her dad said his new son-in-law 4 years older than he
is is the nicest man i've ever met in my life. here's another one of her youtube videos. >> i have never done pornography. i never will. about myself, i am a christian girl. i hold my faith very tightly. >> believe me. you learn how to hold things very tightly when you go to the beach wearing nothing but american flag. i like that at age 16 she makes it a point of pride that she's never done pornography. that's like basically saying i'm about to do pornography. or i inevitably will do pornography but i haven't done it yet. i wonder if her parents booked her for that photo shoot. they are so cool! >> i'm a virgin and i plan to stay that way until i am married. >> okay. a little bit of an overshare. but i'll say this about courtney, she likes to keep it real. >> my breasts are real. everything about me is real. my harris real, my teeth are real, my eyelashes are real, my
breasts are totally real. you know, believe it or not but they are. >> did she mention that her breasts are real? i think she mentioned twice. you know what's is real? their love is real. courtney, i wish you nothing but best in your singing career and your marriage. but if it doesn't work out, someone's recently back on the market. and to all you haters, remember age is only a number. 51, just a number. 16, just a much, much, much smaller number. ain't love grand? so to all you doubters and haters don't be too hard on these lovebirds at least not until the divorce or the inevitable reality show about the divorce comes out. until then all of you on the ridiculist. we'll be right back. the plannedn of at&t and t-mobile would deliver our next generation mobile broadband experience to 55 million more americans, many in small towns and rural communities, giving them a new choice. we'll deliver better service, with thousands of new cell sites... for greater access to all the things you want, whenever you want them. it's the at&t network... and what's possible in here is almost impossible to say.
and all we need to do is change the way we're thinking about them. a couple decades ago, we didn't even realize just how much natural gas was trapped in rocks thousands of feet below us. technology has made it possible to safely unlock this cleanly burning natural gas. this deposits can provide us with fuel for a hundred years, providing energy security and economic growth all across this country. it just takes somebody having the idea,
and that's where the discovery comes from. the morning after the big move starts with back pain... and a choice. take advil now... and maybe up to 4 in a day. or, choose aleve and 2 pills for a day free of pain. smart move. ♪ no matter when you get around to booking, hotels.com will have a great last minute deal waiting for you. like at the hotels.com 48 hour sale. this tuesday and wednesday only. hotels.com. be smart. book smart.