Skip to main content

tv   Anderson Cooper 360  CNN  May 9, 2012 10:00pm-11:00pm EDT

10:00 pm
should be legal. >> at a certain point i've just concluded that for me personally, it is important for me to go ahead and affirm that i think same-sex couples should be able to get married. >> supporters of same-sex marriage have long pressed for the president to say just those words. but for the past two years, he and the white house would only go so far as to categorize his position on same-sex marriage as one that was in the process of evolving. >> whether gays and lesbians should be able to get married, i've spoken about this recently, as i've said. my feelings about this are constantly evolving. i struggle with this. >> you've said your position is evolving. you said you're struggling with it. what more do you need to know? >> well, you know, i probably won't make news right now, george, but i think there's no doubt that as i see friends, families, children of gay couples who are thriving, you
10:01 pm
know, that has an impact on how i think about these issues. >> again, what i know is what his position was during the campaign and what it is now. you know, he's been very clear about it, he was very clear in the campaign, he's very clear about the fact that his position -- that it's evolving. the president said that he was evolving. >> in explaining that process of evolving today, the president said he has always been adamant that gays and lesbians should be treated fairly and equally, but he hesitated on gay marriage partly he said because he thought civil unions would be enough. they would let people visit their partners in the hospital, for instance. in the abc interview, he acknowledged that same-sex marriage is an issue that eli t elicielici elicits strong feelings both for and against. >> i was sensitive to the fact that for a lot of people, the word "marriage" was something that evokes very powerful traditions, religious beliefs and so forth. but i have to tell you that over
10:02 pm
the course of several years, as i talk to friends and family and neighbors, when i think about members of my own staff who are incredibly committed in monogamous relationships, same-sex relationships who are raising kids together, when i think about those soldiers or airmen or marines or sailors who are out there fighting on my behalf and yet feel constrained, even now that don't ask, don't tell is gone, because they're not able to commit themselves in a marriage, at a certain point i've just concluded that for me personally, it is important for me to go ahead and affirm that i think same-sex couples should be able to get married. >> just a short time ago we got even more insight into president obama's thought process. more of that abc interview. robin roberts asked the
10:03 pm
president if he discussed the issue of same-sex marriage with first lady, michelle obama. he said they have talked about it over the years and she feels the same way he does. watch. >> in the end, the values that i care most deeply about and she cares most deeply about is how we treat other people. we're both practicing christians and obviously this position may be considered to put us at odds with the views of others, but, you know, when we think about our faith, the thing at root that we think about is not only christ sacrificing himself on our behalf, but it's also the golden rule. treat others the way you want to be treated. >> the most recent gallup poll says 50% of americans say it should be legal and 48% say no. half the country supports same-sex marriage and tonight that half includes the president of the united states. joining me now, democratic
10:04 pm
strategist paul begala, chief white house correspondent, jessica yellen and cnn contributor, alex castellanos. jessica, some in the white house have been telling you this was the plan all along. given the past few days the way it sort of rolled out, some believe it doesn't seem all that planned. was it? >> reporter: no, it doesn't look planned at all, does it, anderson. so the official story here is as follows. senior administration officials telling me a few months ago the president came to the conclusion that he is for same-sex marriage. he came to that because in part through discussions with mrs. obama, also because of sasha and malia, his children have parents who are same-sex and he kept saying -- it's not fair that -- >> you mean they have friends who have parents. >> reporter: yes, friends who have parents who are same-sex
10:05 pm
couples. those conversations as well as the others he referenced helped him come to this decision. then it was just a question of time when he would make that decision public. these officials say the president was going to make that decision public at some point before the democratic convention and then when vice president biden made those remarks on the sunday show this weekend and then the press jumped all over jay carney in the briefing room the other day, they felt they had to do it this week. can i just add to that, i've talked to another democratic official who says, it was a little iffier than that. there was some division in the white house even this week whether he should make this decision and announce it this week. >> how does the white house expect it to play politically, jessica? >> reporter: you know, they're saying that they haven't gamed it out fully and they don't think they'll lose votes over this, although i think that's yet to be seen. but you have to acknowledge that there are more risks. i believe there are more risks than upside to this, although some on this panel will disagree. and in the end, though, the
10:06 pm
president has made the decision that is more consistent with what he believes to be honest with his -- truthful with his -- to his beliefs. and that's consistent with his brand. they are selling him as somebody who stands on principle. and so in the end, that works for him politically, anderson. >> evan wolfson, you have been working on this harder and longer than just about anybody. a, your thoughts about the president making this statement and your thoughts on how it plays politically. >> i think this is a big day for the country and wonderful day for the freedom to marry movement. not just because the president of the united states is on the right side of history but the way he explained it to the american people. the way he talked from the heart, the way he gave personal examples of people he knew. he looked at his own kids and thought about the values he and michelle are teaching them of treating others as you want to be treated. that rang true because it's the same journey, the same way in which other americans have grappled with this question and it's how we've come to a majority. people have thought it through.
10:07 pm
the same way the president exemplified and have embraced the idea that treating others the way you would want to be treated is the right way for the country to be. >> paul begala, in terms of the politics on this -- first of all, you called in on this program last june and said you believe the president would publicly support same-sex marriage before the election. a lot of people doubted that. how do you think this plays politically? >> first, i'm just grateful you haven't reminded the audience of the 10,000 things that i said that were wrong, like jon huntsman would be a strong candidate for the republicans. but evan makes a very powerful pointing. the president wasn't reading talking points, he wasn't reading a teleprompter or repeating cliches. this really seemed to me, i don't know him very well but i watched the tape, seemed very authentic and it is the journey many familiars are going on. i was struck that he was enormously respectful of people that may arrive at a different conclusion. we need our president to be a unifying figure, this is a very polarizing issue. i think he has stitched those
10:08 pm
two roles together. very powerly. you see he's standing on principle. it may hurt him politically but he is being respectful of those arriving at a different conclusion. >> do you think it will hurt him politically? there are many african-americans who traditionally vote democratic who are more socially conservative and who, you know, may not like what he's just said. >> yeah, actually i think the african-american community, even those who disagree with him will still be there. i think this will help with young people. they have developed off terribly with him. it will hurt with older people where he's hoping to do well, taking about issues like medicare and social security. so it really is too soon to tell. the economy is going to drive this election fundamentally. it's not going to be about social issues, even one this historic. i don't think he did this strictly for the politics. everything he does is political, because he's a politician, but i don't think this is an easy or clear political call at all. i think the guy just got tired of pretending that he was not for gay marriage when clearly i think for the last several months he has been.
10:09 pm
>> alex, i want to play what mitt romney had to say in the wake of the president's announcement. >> i have the same view on marriage that i have -- had when i was governor and that i've expressed many times. i believe marriage is a relationship between a man and a woman. >> he also has said that he doesn't believe in civil unions if they have the same rights as marriages or if they're marriages in everything but name only but does favor some rights of domestic partnerships like hospital visitation rights. how do you think the president's announcement plays? >> well, i think -- i think the president, you know, gets a thumbs up today because i think paul is right and jessica too, that he's taken some political risks today. not that there isn't a political plus side for him. i think the risk is he's not going to lose republicans. he doesn't have any. can't fall off the floor. and he's not going to lose black evangelicals, they're going to stay. but there are some reagan democrats out there, some guys with names on their work shirts who are going to think the president is culturally different from them.
10:10 pm
paul is right, they're older voters. and he's putting something on the line there for something that he believes he's come to believe in and that's important. the plus side for him is i do think this tells us something about the obama campaign and that is that he's really not working at the middle. he wants to make sure that his base and his support is there at the base. and that's what i think he's doing here. he's putting all his eggs in that basket. but overall, jessica is right, more downside than upside politically for the president. you've got to admire him for that. >> evan, you've been working to support, encourage same-sex marriage in states. does this actually change anything, though? because the federal government still doesn't recognize this, same-sex couples even if they're married in new york city, for instance, they can't, if one partner is from a foreign country, the immigration department doesn't recognize that and they don't get a green card, so does this actually make any difference?
10:11 pm
>> well, it doesn't change everything, there's plenty of work left to be done. freedom to marry and the rest of us who believe this have to take the president's lead and take the president's example and go out and make the same case and have the same conversations that helped him and the vice president and others to where we now have a majority. >> are you frustrated that the president didn't say i believe in this and i'm going to work to make this more widespread? >> barack obama is president of the united states. he's not president of freedom to marry. i don't expect him to be out there campaigning on this every day. i expect him to do what we elect presidents to do, which is stand for freedom, for fairness, for families, to provide moral leadership in the country and to do what the president needs to do with regard to the federal government. the rest is up to all of us to take that lead and inspiration, but i think the president's words will reverberate across kitchen tables across the country in the hearts and minds of people who are wrestling with this as he and first lady and others have and will provide a powerful example of where the country ought to be.
10:12 pm
i also think that those who do not fully agree with the president will still respect the president's authenticity, what your commentators are describing as his courage and his willingness to stand for what he believes in and then will be able to move on to the broader and bigger questions that many of them care more about in this very important moment for our country. >> paul, it does fight against the narrative of those who criticize the president who said look, he's voted present, he doesn't take a vote. he talks about the urgency from time to time but he's not really there on the front lines of it. certainly this statement you could say counteracts that. >> well, i think so. i think that the worst thing a president can do is vacillate and he has been vacillating on this quite some time. now he's taken a strong position. i also think it is resonant with his campaign message, forward, not back. the equal rights movement is moving forward. it is inexorable.
10:13 pm
it is inevitable. i know this is a big setback for those of us who believe in freedom to marry in north carolina yesterday, but in time this will be, i know, the law of the land because of the demographics. younger people very strongly support this. so it's a forward-looking thing. i think he can then cast his opponent, mitt romney, who's been on a journey as well but he's been on a journey the other way. he was an advocate of gay rights when he ran for the senate against ted kennedy. said he would be more gay rights than the late senator. and now today he's for repealing don't ask, don't tell. he wants to reinstate it. and discrim nate against the soldiers and airmen and marines. now he wants to amend the constitution to discriminate against gays in marriage and doesn't support most civil unions. i think he can cast that as a backward-looking position. >> anderson, there is one other factor at play to put this in context. the president did also have to contend with the fact that at the democratic convention there were many people who were pushing for a plank on gay marriage to be included in the party's platform. so if he wasn't going to come out for gay marriage, his hand
10:14 pm
was going to be forced one way or another. he was going to be called out on his hedging. so, you know, when you say that he was standing up on principle, yes, we can acknowledge that here. but there was also going to be some consternation if he didn't say something at some point. >> evan, briefly. >> i want to go back to what paul said. while the president was evolving, governor romney has been revolving and has settled on a position that is more extreme than that of dick cheney and even george w. bush. dick cheney supports the freedom to marry. george w. bush stated his support for civil unions. governor romney has said he opposes all of that. >> thank you. let us know what you think. we're on facebook, google plus. let me know on twitter. let's have this discussion, @andersoncooper. coming up, hundreds of thousands of tsa equipment not being used. is the tsa wasting your money
10:15 pm
and trying to hide it from congress? curry. gingersnaps. soup can tower. 5% cash back. right now, get 5% cash back at grocery stores. it pays to discover. holding down the fort while you're out catching a movie. [ growls ] lucky for me, your friends showed up with this awesome bone. hey! you guys are great. and if you got your home insurance where you got your cut rate car insurance, it might not replace all this. [ electricity crackling ] [ gasping ] so get allstate. you could save money and be better protected from mayhem like me. [ dennis ] dollar for dollar, nobody protects you from mayhem like allstate. in here, great food demands a great presentation. so at&t showed corporate caterers how to better collaborate by using a mobile solution, in a whole new way. using real-time photo sharing abilities, they can create and maintain high standards, from kitchen to table. this technology allows us to collaborate with our drivers
10:16 pm
to make a better experience for our customers. [ male announcer ] it's a network of possibilities -- helping you do what you do... even better. ♪ a body at rest tends to stay at rest... while a body in motion tends to stay in motion. staying active can actually ease arthritis symptoms. but if you have arthritis, staying active can be difficult. prescription celebrex can help relieve arthritis pain so your body can stay in motion. because just one 200mg celebrex a day can provide 24 hour relief for many with arthritis pain and inflammation. plus, in clinical studies, celebrex is proven to improve daily physical function so moving is easier. and celebrex is not a narcotic. when it comes to relieving your arthritis pain, you and your doctor need to balance the benefits with the risks. all prescription nsaids, like celebrex, ibuprofen, naproxen, and meloxicam have the same cardiovascular warning. they all may increase the chance of heart attack or stroke, which can lead to death. this chance increases if you have heart disease
10:17 pm
or risk factors such as high blood pressure or when nsaids are taken for long periods. nsaids, including celebrex, increase the chance of serious skin or allergic reactions or stomach and intestine problems, such as bleeding and ulcers, which can occur without warning and may cause death. patients also taking aspirin and the elderly are at increased risk for stomach bleeding and ulcers. do not take celebrex if you've had an asthma attack, hives, or other allergies to aspirin, nsaids or sulfonamides. get help right away if you have swelling of the face or throat, or trouble breathing. tell your doctor your medical history and find an arthritis treatment for you. visit and ask your doctor about celebrex. for a body in motion.
10:18 pm
keeping them honest tonight. with a disturbing new report that the agency tasked with keeping us safe while we travel is spending millions of dollars on screening equipment sitting in warehouses unused. it's fact according to the house transportation oversight committee. the tsa tried to hide it from congress. this comes in the wake of the foiled al qaeda plot to blow up a plane bound for the united states. the goal had been to use an innovative type of bomb. it would reportedly be difficult to detect even in a patdown. security concerns at airports are more serious than ever. today a scathing congressional report said the tsa is storing about 5700 pieces of security
10:19 pm
equipment at warehouses in dallas, texas. equipment worth an estimated $184 million. the report also says the tsa dragged its feet when congress tried to get information about how it buys and stores screening equipment. the tsa, quote, provided inaccurate, incomplete and potentially misleading information to congress in order to conceal the agency's continued mismanagement of warehouse operations. in response, the department of homeland security said the tsa buys technology in bulk to save money but doesn't buy more inventory than it expects to use. that it quote, utilizes warehouse space as staging locations until airports are able to accept the equipment. the congressional report says the vast majority of that equipment has been sitting there more than six months and that 35% of the equipment has been in storage more than a year. get this, according to congress, it's costing the tsa $3.5 million just to store that equipment at the dallas warehouse. at a hearing on capitol hill today, a tsa official said that's down from $7.6 million in 2009.
10:20 pm
so while the tsa seems to want to highlight how much it's trying to save taxpayers, the congressional report says all it's really doing is throwing millions of dollars at the problem of airport security without solving anything. representative darrell issa is leading this investigation, the head of the house oversight committee, a republican. i spoke with him earlier this evening. congressman issa, $184 million of equipment sitting around in warehouses not being used. that seems like just on the face of it an enormous waste of money. >> anderson, it's a small amount of money considering the $13 billion plus dollars of expenditure, but it's part of the tip of the iceberg of what's wrong with tsa. they have over 65,000 employees, over 4,000 that just work here in washington doing the administration. it's an organization that doesn't seem to have ever developed their plan. their own inspector general made it clear that they're not making a lot of progress toward efficiency. and their buying practices seem to be more about buy a lot of stuff to look like you're doing
10:21 pm
well rather than finding out whether a particular piece of equipment will work properly and then fielding it more economically. >> they say, essentially, look, a lot of the airports weren't ready for the equipment or didn't have the personnel to staff the equipment. >> well, you know, anderson, i spent a lot of time doing the logistics of a comparatively small company, but you when something. your vendors are more than happy if you prepay to hold the goods and drop ship them to locations. there's lots of logistic ways to deal with it. what we heard today is in some cases two years after delivery they still hadn't identify the airports for things to go to. which means they bought them without knowing if or when they'd go anywhere. in the case of the so-called puffer devices, they spent a billion, they never worked and then they didn't know how to dispose of them so they sat in storage a couple more years. >> you say the tsa did not even want your investigators to show up.
10:22 pm
what happened when you showed up on site at the warehouse? >> the inspector general today has agreed to look into this more thoroughly. what appears to have happened is that they gave us a list in advance of what was in the warehouse and a dollar figure. and then in the hours, two or so days before they got there, they brought in extra work early and liquidated at least 1,300 pieces that were not on that inventory that they didn't want to show us. in other words, they cooked the books to make it look better but did it after they gave us an inventory list. something that at least in my background in the army, if you tried to smuggle stuff around before an inspector general inspection, you'd go to jail. and so we're deeply concerned that this kind of hiding of laws is exactly what you don't want when you're doing oversight, whether you're the congress, inspector general or general accountability office. >> the tsa i know said they weren't trying to hide anything, the equipment was already scheduled to be moved. do you not buy that?
10:23 pm
>> i can only say what my own employee said to me. he talked directly to warehouse managers who when he asked why there weren't any employees there, he said we brought them in especially early to get this stuff out so they're gone. in other words these were not segregated and were not to be gone, but they had to work overtime to do it. again, we've turned that over to the inspector general. it's a distraction because it's not the cover-up in this case, it's what we now know, which is this is an organization that buys before it plans, that hires before it trains, and that uses as an excuse that they don't have enough training when in fact even our democratic members pointed out that when it comes to morale and effectiveness of leadership, tsa is almost at the very, very bottom of all federal organizations. we're not talking about the employees, we're talking about the morale of employees because of bad management. >> supporters of the tsa will say that this report is biased that chairman mica who led the investigation with you has it
10:24 pm
out for the tsa, wants to privatize the screening. to that you say what? >> well, chairman mika may have a lot of things and i can't know that. what i can say is my investigators found an organization in need of improvement with an extremely important job. one we believe could be done with less federal workers, better organized with better morale, paid well, trained well with good equipment. and that's the goal unless congress and the president change their mind that we're working toward is an organization that instead of being ninth from the bottom in morale and training, in fact starts to look where it needs to be if we're going to keep america safe and people flying efficiently. >> this obviously comes right on the heels of the discovery of a terrorist plot to blow up an airplane. should americans have faith that the tsa is capable of doing what's necessary to keep them safe? >> anderson, i think in the case of that failed bombing attempt, we should be proud that the restructured cia that has been rebuilt in the last decade in fact proactively had agent involved, found this and uncovered it before we ever had to ask the question of would tsa
10:25 pm
have found it with their equipment that you may or may not have gone through. so i'm happy to say cia did their job. my job is to make sure that the men and women of tsa have the tools and the training they need so that we can be more confident that our fliers are safe. by the way, we'd like to get them through the lines a lot faster too. >> chairman issa, i appreciate it, thank you. >> thank you. cnn's investigation into a charity that claims to raise money for disabled veterans has resulted in one of the most mind-boggling responses to a story that we have ever received. you do not want to miss it next. we'll be right back.
10:26 pm
10:27 pm
the suspect wanted in the kidnapping of four members of a tennessee family is now on the fbi's ten most wanted list. adam mayes is accused of murdering two of the victims.
10:28 pm
police are desperate to find the other two. young sisters hopefully still alive. we'll have more details ahead.
10:29 pm
360 follow now to the special investigation we've reported on the past two nights, about the activities of a charity that claims to raise money for disabled veterans. i hope you've seen at least one of our reports the last two nights. today we received a response from this organization. i have to say that the e-mail sent to us is mind boggling and bordering on the outright bizarre. we're going to get to that in a moment. first i want to give you the background in case you missed it. we've been examining the activities of a charity calling themselves disabled veterans national foundation. it looks very official. they've got a seal and everything. its own tax filings show that
10:30 pm
it's raised nearly $56 million in donations for veterans in the past three years. but not one dime of all that money americans have donated to help veterans has actually gone directly to help disabled veterans. so our drew griffin went to the president of the organization. a woman by the name of precilla wilkewitz. remember that name. here's what happened when he tried to ask questions. >> you're the one from cnn -- >> reporter: meet precilla wilkewitz, president of the disabled veterans foundation. we found at a small vfw office in baton rouge, louisiana. >> well, this is the veterans of foreign wars and i really didn't think you'd do something like this. we've agreed to talk to you and answer questions. >> reporter: so here is the question. >> only in writing. thank you so much. >> reporter: none of the money has gone to any veterans. ma'am?
10:31 pm
while she's the former national legislative liaison for the veterans of foreign wars, it's another veterans group that she's president of that we wanted to discuss. so the bottom line is you're not going to give me an interview. cnn has been trying to get an interview for two years since we began tracking its fund-raising. we've gotten angry phone calls, angry e-mails, promises of written responses and now a slammed door. >> ma'am? >> reporter: but no answers. and when you see just how this charity operates, you'll understand why. >> we're paying down our start-up costs. >> reporter: wilkewitz on the organization's website likes to boast about the charitable gifts that her group gives away, and they do give away stuff. stuff. actual veterans groups say they really don't need. >> stuff, items like chef's aprons, surplus navy dress shoes and bags of coconut m & ms. hundreds of them. here's how it works. on its tax forms, the foundation
10:32 pm
lists gifts in kind, items it gets for free like these m & ms and then passes on to veterans groups or chef's aprons. but how many disabled vets actually need a chef's apron? and there's still the main question that needs to be answered. what has the foundation done with the $56 million it's collected from americans concerned about the welfare of disabled veterans? last night on this program i issued a direct invitation, a challenge, if you will, to precilla wilkewitz, make yourself available to us anywhere, any time, we'll be there. drew will be there, i'll be there, any one of us will be there, we'd love to ask you questions. she slammed the door in drew's face saying we'd agreed to talk to you but she hasn't agreed to talk to us. in response, she sent drew griffin what can only be described as a bizarre e-mail. he's here to talk about it. all right, drew, tell everybody the response you got. >> reporter: yeah, it is indeed one of the strangest i've ever had after reporting a story. i contacted her on your behalf asking her to come on the program today. the e-mail we got in response,
10:33 pm
precilla wilkewitz says this. i have our official statement replying to everything you guys claim and proving a lot of the claims to be completely inaccurate. then she wrote the entire lyrics to this 1980s george michael hit, "careless whisper." ♪ time can never mend the careless whispers of a good friend ♪ >> i mean, yeah. i just -- it boggles my mind. it's funny on the one hand. it's infuriating on the other hand. they have raised $56 million. they have a lot of money. they could craft a statement. they could answer questions. instead, they send you the lyrics to "careless whisper." >> the entire lyrics, anderson. this was a very long e-mail and i didn't remember that song, but i certainly read through the whole e-mail to see if there was something else.
10:34 pm
it ends -- she says it ends with the words was what i did so wrong, so wrong that you had to leave me alone? have a good day, precilla landry wilkewitz. i thought maybe it was a mistake. but the president of the disabled veterans foundation that took in $56 million and failed to spend hardly any of it on veterans said in a second e-mail, said, yes, all we have to say right now "the careless whisper" lyrics although we'll come up with more later. thank you. your viewers can make of that what they wish. i don't understand it. >> and i mean just -- they have a -- like a pr person who you've been dealing with on the phone, right? >> i think that guy has been canned. he has been with them for a couple of years. a very, very aggressive pr guy in new york. we got yesterday a call from another pr firm, another pr guy who tried to explain something to us. nothing getting us quite to an interview. but, no, this is a legitimate,
10:35 pm
supposedly, group. they raised $56 million. all of that money went to their fund-raising operation quadriga. we have just been trying to figure out what has been going on here with all the donations. >> do we know how much precilla wilkewitz actually makes? a lot of the charities pay salaries to the people working for them. >> you know what, it's really a negligible amount, if anything at all. that's not what caught our attention. the money that everybody has donated, all the thousands and thousands of people, that's what we want to know where that money went to and, quite frankly, whether or not precilla wilkewitz knows where that money went. >> we'd love to ask her again. we extend an invitation. we can play "careless whisper" when she's here. maybe that's her calling you. drew, we'll continue on. i appreciate the reporting. you may have heard a rumor where the police force is in a part of the sect that worships warren jeffs.
10:36 pm
believes he's a prophet. the town operates under its own brand of justice and tonight it seems untouchable. that's next. is that rain?
10:37 pm
[siri] yes, it appears to be raining. oooh...let's get tomato soup delivered. [siri] i found a number of restaurants [siri] whose reviews mention tomato soup and that deliver. good, 'cause i don't wanna put on real shoes. remind me to clean up...tomorrow. [siri] ok, i'll remind you. excellent. today, we're dancing. play 'shake, rattle and roll.' ♪ whose non-stop day starts with back pain... and a choice. take advil now and maybe up to four in a day. or choose aleve and two pills for a day free of pain. way to go, coach. ♪
10:38 pm
an emotional day for jennifer hudson. she sobbed during closing arguments in the murder trial of the man accused of killing her mom, brother and nephew. the latest ahead.
10:39 pm
tonight a 360 follow. another example the powerful hold a polygamist sect maintains in colorado city, arizona. it's incredible this is
10:40 pm
happening in this day and age in the united states. colorado city is a desert town that remains deeply loyal to the poe legist sect leader, warren jeffs, despite the fact that he's serving a life sentence in texas for sexually assaulting two underage girls. the story's many twists and turns have taken gary tuchman to colorado city where visitors are definitely not welcome. >> load up and leave the property. now. >> reporter: why can't i talk to you? >> now. >> reporter: sir, that's fine but why won't you talk to me is all i'm asking you. >> reporter: load now or i'll cite you. >> reporter: you'll cite me for what? >> that officer and most of the police force in colorado city are members of the sect, the flds. they have long ruled the town with their own brand of justice and now their control seems stronger than ever. tonight gary tuchman reports on why state lawmakers who wanted to dissolve the force failed. >> reporter: colorado city, arizona, is a very unusual place. the desert town is the religious
10:41 pm
seat of the flds church, which promotes and practices polygamy, and whose leader has been convicted of raping underage girls. >> the police force in colorado city is without a doubt the most crooked police department in the country. >> reporter: sam brower is an investigator who has dug into flds allegations for most of the last decade. he said the cops make the community increasingly unstable. >> i've never seen the tension so high. >> reporter: so we wanted to ask the police about their support and allegiance to a convicted polygamist, warren jeffs, but they didn't want to talk. >> can i ask you a question, officer? can i ask you a question? >> reporter: mojave county is where colorado city, arizona, is located and tom sheehan is the sheriff. he says his deputies can't trust the local police. >> they are doing only what the church wants them to do and what their leaders tell them to do. >> reporter: so your belief is that it's their religion and their prophet is far more important than the laws of the state of arizona. >> that we know for sure.
10:42 pm
>> reporter: with that in mind, the arizona legislature took up a bill to dissolve the department known as the colorado city marshal's office and leave enforcement up to the sheriff. under the law, any arizona police department in which more than half of officers were decertified by the state for corruption or crime in an eight-year period would be dissolved. >> if you have more than 50% of your officers decertified, do you have any business having a law enforcement agency? i mean that's ridiculous. >> reporter: colorado city currently has six cops. six other cops have been kicked off within the past eight years. the state says each of those cops was decertified for different reasons, such as felony sexual conduct with a minor, bigamy, refusal to testify and answer questions at a grand jury and a deposition and seeking advice from a fugitive. that fugitive being warren jeffs when he was on the fbi ten most wanted list. a letter recovered when jeffs was arrested written by the former chief declared i am praying for you to be protected and yearn to be with you again. the arizona senate passed the bill unanimously.
10:43 pm
but then something very surprising happened in the arizona house. representatives nancy mcclain and doris gooddale, nonflds members who represent colorado city took up the church's cause to keep the police department intact. with their leadership, the bill died in a close vote. they say the bill is unconstitutional because they claim the city is being singled out. they also acknowledge they want to support their flds constituents who will cast ballots for them come election day. another part of their argument? listen to this. >> things are changing up there and it just doesn't seem fair to go backwards in time when things are finally opening up. >> reporter: but that directly contradicts what gary engel sees. he's the primary investigator of the flds for the county prosecutor's office. >> do you think things are getting better in colorado city? >> no, things are getting much worse. it's getting worse by the day. it's getting more fanatical. >> reporter: so where is the representative getting her information? we asked her. >> there's more commerce there.
10:44 pm
they are more willing to talk with people who are not members of the community. i get e-mails from the community. so i see that as opening up. >> reporter: when i go there, people come to me and say they're scared, there's no one to talk to, they want to get out, they're trapped. their children are being taken away from them. the cops are doing nothing. have you ever heard anything like that before? >> no. no one has said that to me in any of the times i've been up there. >> reporter: but it does happen repeatedly. this past february i covered the story of this man. warren jeffs had kicked him and many other men out of the church for not being faithful enough. in the middle of the night his wife and seven children were told to leave him and left the house with the local police standing by. >> just about killed me. i just closed my eyes and i felt like my soul is out there just floating around somewhere. >> reporter: when warren jeffs kicks people out of the church, their families are taken away from them. the cops helped take their
10:45 pm
families away from them. >> that was five years ago. >> reporter: no, that was a few months ago because i just covered a story about that. >> well, we never heard about it. >> reporter: representative gooddale testified to the other legislators that this is a very open community. one of her quotes was when we come here, we go to the baseball games, the little league games. we can tell you from talking to people who were in the church that there has never been a little league here. one woman says she doesn't even know what the term little league means. as far as baseball games, this was the main baseball field in colorado city. this was the first base line. years ago kids did run down and now it's a garden because several years ago warren jeffs made the decree kids should not be playing sports or games and they got rid of the baseball games. i've been here at least 15 times to colorado city and never seen baseball being played. and this, the main basketball courts, three once beautiful courts but now the courts are used to house mountains of recycled rubble. we wanted to get the colorado city police chief's reaction to
10:46 pm
the criticism in this story. >> anybody in the police station? >> reporter: we did see movement in the office, but as usual we got no response. >> gary joins me now. on the phone michael watkiss, investigative reporter at ktvk in phoenix. he's been covering the flds for years now. gary, did these legislators do a thorough investigation before voting against this? >> reporter: with all due respect to those two women, there does not appear to have been a strenuous investigation. they made a number of misstatements to their fellow house members. one statement by representative gooddale is these are normal citizens who live there. this is the most abnormal place i've been to in the united states. i've been to 50 states for this program and this network. it is the opposite of normal. these are men who in many cases have sex with lots of women under their roofs. in some cases these women are under the age of 18. even the people who talk to us who live there acknowledge they're totally different than the rest of the country. they think they're right with god but they even know it's not normal.
10:47 pm
but even more importantly, you saw in our story we talked to the sheriff, we talked to the chief prosecutor, we talked to the investigator, three very important people in that county. they are flabbergasted that these two representatives never reached out to them to talk to them. they can't believe that. >> mike, what's your response? you've covered this group for so long. when you hear the state congresswoman saying things are getting better there? >> it is another example of the absolute moral and intellectual bankruptcy on the part of arizona leaders when it comes to this issue. the flds have been in texas less than ten years. they have incarcerated mr. jeffs and thrown 11 of his followers in prison, making a very strong statement. that's more than the state of arizona has done to help the women and children in colorado city in well over a century. i should have a public disclaimer. i have very publicly calling for the decertification of this outfit for many years because we have followed the very stories that gary is talking about.
10:48 pm
the cop who took an underage girl and had sex with her. the cops that have committed bigamy. the cops that won't testify to grand juries. the cops that write basically love letters to warren jeffs while he's on the fbi's most wanted list. this is truly the most corrupt police agency in america. arizona continues to ignore this. and these two women should be ashamed of themselves because it's not just disingenuous, it's outright dishonest when they say to their colleagues because mr. jeffs is incarcerated, his strangle hold on that community has diminished. that's just flatly untrue. you replaced a bunch of flds cops who have been thrown out, well, get what? they're every whit as beholden to mr. jeffs as their predecess predecessors. gary engels is right, things are probably more tense or strict or
10:49 pm
stringent against the women and children and the lawmakers cry about the rights of a handful of flds cops, while arizona continues its century-long complete abrogation of its responsibility when it comes to the rights of the women and children in that community. >> we're going to continue to follow it. mike, appreciate as always your reporting, gary tuchman as well. the fate of the man accused of killing three members of jennifer hudson's family is in the hands of the jury. the latest on that ahead. are you still sleeping? just wanted to check and make sure that we were on schedule.
10:50 pm
the first technology of its kind... mom and dad, i have great news. is now providing answers families need. siemens. answers. ♪ [ male announcer ] with 50 horsepower, dual overhead cams and fierce acceleration, the gator xuv 825i will shatter your expectations. ♪ before your next big trip outdoors, visit for huge savings at this year's john deere green tag event. ♪
10:51 pm
10:52 pm
i'm isha sesay with a news and business bulletin. the suspect in the kidnapping of four members of a tennessee family is now one of the fbi's ten most wanted. adam mayes is accused of killing two of the victims. the reward for his arrest has grown to $175,000. the face of the man accused of killing jennifer hudson's mother, sister and nephew is now in the fate of the jury. the judge said there is no dna evidence tying him to the murders. hudson kept her head down as the prosecution shared autopsy photos. a bomb blast in syria nearly hits a convoy carrying u.n. observers. they were traveling from damascus to dara. no observers were hurt but
10:53 pm
several of the military escorts were injured. the postal service says thousands of rural post offices that were on the chopping block will stay open. to save money, they'll operate for fewer hours and convert thousands of full-time positions to part-time. and vidal sassoon has died. a police spokesman said he died of apparent natural causes at his l.a. home surrounded by family. he was 84 years old. anderson? >> isha, thanks. the ridiculist is next. hi, i just switched jobs, and i want to roll over my old 401(k) into a fidelity ira. man: okay, no problem. it's easy to get started; i can help you with the paperwork. um...this green line just appeared on my floor. yeah, that's fidelity helping you reach your financial goals. could you hold on a second? it's your money. roll over your old 401(k) into a fidelity ira and take control of your personal economy.
10:54 pm
this is going to be helpful. call or come in today. fidelity investments. turn here. but proven technologies allow natural gas producers to supply affordable, cleaner energy, while protecting our environment. across america, these technologies protect air - by monitoring air quality and reducing emissions... ...protect water - through conservation and self-contained recycling systems... ... and protect land - by reducing our footprint and respecting wildlife. america's natural gas... domestic, abundant, clean energy to power our lives... that's smarter power today. i think we should see other people. in fact, i'm already seeing your best friend, justin. ♪ i would've appreciated a proactive update on the status of our relationship. who do you think i am, tim? quicken loans? at quicken loans, we provide you with proactive updates on the status of your home loan. and our innovative online tools
10:55 pm
ensure that you're always in the loop. one more way quicken loans is engineered to amaze.
10:56 pm
10:57 pm
time now for the ridiculist and tonight i'm adding anyone who talks about themselves online. and, yes, i include myself. look, i'm down with the twitter, i appreciate the facebook. i'm sure i posed for instagrams and i've heard of foursquare. though i still have no idea what it is. but here's what i caught my attention. but a new harvard study entitled disclosing information about the self is intrinsically rewarding. tweeting about what you had for lunch makes you feel important. the study didn't focus on online behavior. since i'm not a harvard researcher that's the way i interpreted it. where else do people talk about themselves more than online? where else can you find a photo of me tweeted by me showing me on vacation? the "l.a. times" broke down the study and reported that in a series of experiments, the
10:58 pm
researchers found that the act of disclosing information about one self activates the same sensation of pleasure in the brain that we get from eating food, getting money or having sex. let me stop right there. first of all, the pleasure you get from talking about yourself is similar to the pleasure you get from eating food? are you kidding? have you never seen "eat, pray, love"? >> i'm in love. i'm having a relationship with my pizza. >> yeah, that's right. julia roberts, that's what i'm talking about. and i'm a pretty regular twitter user. can be quite useful at times. but don't try to tell me that tweeting about yourself can compete with making sweet, sweet love to a pizza. twitter is something most people scroll through while they're on the toilet and frankly even then they have got more important things to do. don't get me wrong, i get that social media has seemingly given everyone a voice and the twilight zone-like universe in which we now live, everyone should care what everyone else is doing. i'm going to tell you a little secret.
10:59 pm
you know when you tweet rihanna, to tell her lol i just burped you know what doesn't care? rihanna. and the idea that it's as pleasurable as sex? please. i'm no dr. ruth but if you're getting the same amount of pleasure from having sex as you are from using twitter, you're doing something wrong. the bottom line is we shouldn't spend so much time talking about ourselves online. no one really cares. also please don't forget to follow me on twitter, facebook, google plus and of course on the ridiculist. tomorrow by the way is the "ac 360" hanging out with me, isha, randi kaye and watch it on the anderson 360 google plus page at 6:45 p.m. eastern. thanks for watching. "erin burnett outfront" starts right now. >> an exclusive with barney frank. the first openly gay member of congress. tonight, on the president's announcement. then the man becoming the new face of terror. so who is the al qaeda bomb maker whose mission is


info Stream Only

Uploaded by TV Archive on