tv State of the Union CNN May 20, 2012 9:00am-10:00am EDT
set of rules. he ran up massive debts, and the middle class lost. >> centerpiece of his campaign is quite clearly character assassination. >> exclusive interviews with david axelrod and republican national committee chairman reince priebus. also spending cuts, tax cuts, and what do women want in 2012 with senators barbara boxer and kay bailey hutchison. plus, an exclusive interview with nato secretary-general anders faux rasmussen and the exit of afghanistan. and chewing over the week with jeff zell mi and cnn congressional correspondent dana bash. i'm candy crowley, and this is "state of the union." vice president biden questioned mitt romney's business credentials on the stump. the obama re-elect team pumped out a small buy ad with a big bite attacking bain capital, the equity firm romney founded. >> they made as much money off it as they could, and they closed it down, they filed for
bankruptcy without any concern for the families or the communities. >> like a vampire. they came in and sucked the life out of us. >> within hours camp romney was up with a web ad of its own and a story of its own. >> sti almost never got started. when others scheide away mitt romney private sector leadership team stepped in. >> building over a dream with over 6,000 employees today. >> if it wasn't for a company like steel dynamic, this county wouldn't have a lot. >> joining me to discuss this week's tale of two steel mills and other campaign adventures, obama campaign senior adviser david axelrod. david, thanks for joining us from beautiful downtown chicago, we appreciate it. >> beautiful indeed. >> yes, it is pretty. i wanted to start out with something that mitt romney said characterizing what your advertising is about. >> the purpose of the president's ads are not to describe success and failure but to somehow to suggest that i'm
not a good person or not a good guy. >> and do you quibble with that? is not the gist of the ad that you all put out about bain capital, romney's former firm, that he is a rich, greedy guy who doesn't care about the middle class? >> no, i do quibble with that. the point of the ad is to look at his business record. the only credential that governor romney has offered the people of this country for running for the presidency is that he was a businessman. he never talks about the fact that he was governor of massachusetts because when he was governor of massachusetts, they went from 36 to 47th in job creation, and it was a pretty much of a disastrous period. so that he doesn't talk about. he talks about being a businessman and hints that somehow the things he did there prepare him to lead the country and its economy, and so it behooves us to look at what exactly he did. and the fact is that he wasn't about job creation, and he and his partners have acknowledged in candid moments, our job wasn't to create jobs, it was to create wealth for ourselves an
our partners. they did it by any means necessary. >> well, it was to find -- he has had success stories, you will agree to that, but i mean what they are saying is, look, this was a private equity firm, an investment firm. we invested in businesses. we wanted them to succeed. some of them did, and some of them didn't. doesn't that tell you this is a guy with a business background who understands -- >> some of them -- >> -- what makes businesses tick. >> some of them did and some of them didn't, candy, but he always walked away with money, and that was the point. the point was that he didn't -- they didn't fail with the company. they didn't embrace the failure. they loaded that company, gst steel, with debt, and then they bankrupted the company. the company was in kansas city. they filed for bankruptcy in north carolina so this they could vacate some of their obligations to their workers. so the workers lost health care benefits and additional benefits that they were -- that they had negotiated for that they were
promised, and governor romney's team walked away with at least $12 million. that is not -- that is what vice president biden was referring to. it is not right when you have two sets of rules where the guys at the top prosper no matter what happens and the workers down the line bear the brunt of it. that's the kind of dislocations we have had in our economy. it's what concerns people about what we're been. >> i want to move you on since you mentioned vice president biden to something that he talked about in youngstown, ohio. >> my mother and father believed that if my brother or sister wanted to be a millionaire, they could be a millionaire. my mother and father dreamed as much as any rich guy dreams. >> absolutely. >> they don't get us. they don't get who we are. >> do you understand why some people listen to that and do
believe that the obama campaign is engaged in class warfare? that this was very definitely an attack on the rich? >> here is the point, we believe strongly, and most americans do, that we honor success, we celebrate success, but we want everybody to have a fair chance at it, a fair shot at it, and the question really is moving forward, what kind of economic policies do we want? if governor romney says that his business experience informs him about how he's going to move forward, look at that business experience and ask if episodes like gs steel are the ones that we want governing our economy. we want an economy in which people can get the education they need and the training they need. we want an economy where there are good middle class jobs available, and not where those jobs -- where wages are cut, benefits are cut, and people can't live a good middle class -- >> this happens to a lot of businesses, does it not, and it's happened over the course of time, that businesses -- this was in a particularly bad time
for the steel industry, as you know, and isn't failure every much as instructive as success in terms of giving you an idea of what makes -- >> candy, let me ask you a question. if you were a worker at that steel mill and you lost much of what you worked for over a period of decades and your pension it turns out was underfunded by $46 million, your pension system, and you then watch the people who loaded your company with debt walk away with a profit leaving you without what you thought you earned. would you feel that was fair? >> if i were that person i certainly wouldn't. >> of course. well, i think that's the point. >> how i feel about it sort of is not at all germane. i was wondering if you think that isn't a business experience? romney's job, as you said -- >> i think -- look, i absolutely -- if you ask me was
romney good at making money for himself and his partners? yes. if you ask me whether i think that outsourcing of jobs, offshoring of accounts, bankrupting companies, and profiting off those bankruptcies are a prescription for building the american economy and is good for -- is a good vision for our future, the answer to that is no. >> let me move you to the other thing that happened this week, which was "the new york times" report that a proposal before one of these super pacs, in this case a fairly wealthy conservative, although he says he's listed as an independent, that perhaps they would bring up reverend wright in a series of ads in time for the democratic convention. i want to play you some of the response from democrats to that. >> if ricketts wants to do that, if the gop, they want to do that? then guess what? you're putting mormonism on the table. >> should we look at the leaders of mitt romney's religion and
examine whether they affected his politics? fair question isn't it? >> then we have to say what are the vies on the church that mitt romney put forth, the view that is black people were subsidiary to and inferior to white people? >> david, simple question in the last 30 seconds we've got. does the re-elect committee repudiate the idea that mormonism should be on the table? >> absolutely, and we have right along. we've said that's not fair game, and we wish that governor romney would stand up as strongly and as resolutely, consistently to refute these kinds of things on his side. instead, he's amplified them in the past and put logs on that fire, and that's not leadership. >> he did repudiate the reverend wright thing know, right? >> tepidly and reluctantly he did, but in february he actually raised the issue and said he thought it was fair game. so, you know, the problem is you have to be consistent in your position, and you have to be genuine and firm in your position. you can't be grudging in your
position or you send the wrong signals and i think he sent the wrong signals. >> yet you all did put out a fund-raising letter on this suggesting that mitt romney was going to -- suggesting that republicans would use it, although the super pac in question said -- >> we put out a fund-raising letter because we're facing about $1 billion of super pac spending. this was one gentleman who was willing to write a $10 million check potentially to fund this campaign. that was the proposal. and we're facing that all over the country. karl rove has a $25 million campaign up right now with undisclosed money. money we don't know where it came from, running negative ads. he got one $10 million anonymous donor. our average donation is $55. it would take 181,000 donations to match the one donation karl rove got. we need to combat this kind of tactic. >> david axelrod, it's always great to have you on. i appreciate it. >> thanks, candy.
good to be with you. the republicans' playbook for defeating president obama, the economy. >> where we're headed under this president is an economic decline, and what it is going to take is to have a president who is willing to lead and to fight. >> but highlighting a faltering economy may not sit well with republican governors in some key swing states. that with the chairman of the republican national committee. plus, the breaking news from libya that the lockerbie bomber has died. stay with us. today i'm talking with melonie who loves to garden
but doesn't think walmart has all her favorite brands. you want to check it out? let's go. yes. ok, you're a gardener -- you're going to love this. low prices on round-up, miracle-gro -- it's a miracle! did you know walmart had the same great brands as every other gardening store? no, honestly i didn't. you know what'll really make your yard look great? what? these mosaic solar lights. oh they're beautiful. sunshine not guaranteed. low prices, gnome what i mean? even miracle-gro potting mix. you want one? three. three? uh, it's okay. see for yourself. walmart's got just what your garden needs.
backed by our low price guarantee. now's the time to move from to where you want to go. look up. with u.s. bank let's get the wheels turning. use our strength & stability to open new opportunities. to lend, and lift ...every business...every dream... to new heights of prosperity. good things are happening. just look up. with u.s. bank. i tell you what i can spend. i do my best to make it work. i'm back on the road safely.
and i saved you money on brakes. that's personal pricing. i am joined by republican national committee chairman reince priebus. let me start out with where i left off with david axelrod, and that is these outside super pac groups. you all spent about a day and a half trying to distance yourselves from the notion that reverend wright would be brought up by one of these fab lutionly wealthy people that want to come in and have their say-so in an election in the form of tv ads. isn't there just a huge problem here for you all as you move forward that you don't have or are not supposed to have control over what goes up on the air in your name? >> i think both sides have the same problem, and -- >> you have a lot more super pacs than we do. >> we don't know who's got what and how it's going to shake out.
certainly obama spends nights raising tons of money whether it's george clooney and hollywood or people on wall street. mitt romney repudiated this particular issue and what's amazing about it to me, a day and a half spent and that the mediaened a "the new york times" would pick up on a proposal to perhaps do something in regard to a particular subject. i mean, this thing is so strong out, and to take a day and a half talking about this. you know what -- >> you know how this works. this was a big -- >> oh, i know how it works. it's the democrats and barack obama that want the story out there. he wants this story to play out in the media because for every day that david axelrod and this president don't have to talk about their broken promises when it comes to jobs, the debt, and the deficit, and the more time they can spend about talking about hypotheticals that may or may not come true, is a day they want to win on. so, look, this president's got a bigger problem, and his problem is no matter what he puts out there, no mat wear distractions
he puts out there, he can't change the truth and escape the reality of where we are in this american economy. and it's no good. >> you know, mitt romney has to go through a lot of battle ground states and obviously that is the message. this economy is still bad. we spent a lot of money, still bad. i can do this better. and yet you have states like ohio, florida, virginia, iowa all battlegrounds to some degree or another with republican governors who are out there going, hey, the economy is getting better. how are you going to synthesize republican governors in states where they're trying to do some good things, where the economy is improving, with romney coming in and saying the economy is really horrible. >> it starts at the top. this is going to be a referendum on whether or not barack obama fulfilled the promises he made to the american people. i get your point, but the reality is things could be much, much better if we had a president that could actually make a promise and follow through on a promise. you have someone like mitt romney who spent his entire life
making promises, keeping promises, understands how businesses work, understands how small businesses work. helped save hundreds of businesses. companies like staples and sports authority and others. no matter what david axelrod may say, president obama's business experience hasn't seen the inside of a lemonade stand. i think it's time to put someone in the white house that understands how job creation works in this country. >> the president has in fact during his term created jobs when we were hemorrhaging jobs when we started. >> mitt romney has helped create more net jobs in the state of massachusetts as governor than barack obama's helped net create in the entire country. >> he had a pretty bad record at least in terms of the 50 states in job creation. he was down near the bottom when he was governor. >> not only did he help create more net jobs than barack obama, he helped save the olympics, he helped save companies out there that were hurting, and the fact is every state has its own
unique challenges, candy, and we all know that. wisconsin has different challenges than tennessee. we have different laws there than alabama. so every state is different, but as far as massachusetts goes in a vacuum, they're much better off with a mitt romney governor than many others. and so i would say this, if david axelrod and this president want to make this campaign about jobs, which is what we want it to be about desperately and we're going to keep going back to that, there's no chance that barack obama wins the presidency in november if the issue is jobs. >> is there anything at all that you give the president credit for in the last 3 1/2 years, something he did good? >> certainly i think we're all grateful and blessed that bin laden is not alive anymore, and we give him that, but, you know, when it comes to this country's long-term economic safety and long-term economic health, he has failed in regard to capturing -- >> but it's better now, is it not, than when he took office? >> absolutely not. >> you don't think the economy is better now than when he took
office and everyone was tearing their hair off and jumping off cliffs? >> i think it's all relative. i think people across the country that can't fill up the gas tank because gas is too expensive, they can't buy a full set of groceries. if you look at what's happening in greece, in europe, across the atlantic ocean, we can all live -- >> we can't help what's happening in greece, can he? >> what i'm say something we can't keep whistling past the graveyard. we have the debt king for a president who had added $5 trillion to the debt who has 23409 done a thing about getting the deficit under control as promised. he hasn't followed through on promises. while we may whistle past the graveyard today, the day is coming when i believe that the debt bomb facing this country is going to be a big problem for us, and we need a person like mitt romney in office that can do something about it. >> quickly, as of a year ago, more than half the babies born in the u.s. were minority. what is the implications of a majority minority as we call it for a party that is still seen and still is in reality largely
white and largely male? >> well, i think we've had great successes when it comes to hispanic communities across america. you look at marco rubio, susana martinez, brian sandoval, the governor of puerto rico, but it's not just messengers. as party chairman it's our job to get into the communities, to do our social victories headquarters, to do headquarters in places like kissimmee. the metrics on the ground matter, making sure we go to door to door, getting ballots in the municipal clerk's office and checking our success with what we're doing on the ground. >> i have to run. i hope you'll come back. >> that's a big question. >> i know that preponderance priebus, chairman of the national republican party. thank you for being here. next up, pushing tough decisions past election day could cripple the economy, so why won't somebody in washington do so. plus, breaking news from libya, that the lockerbie bomber
has died. cnn's nic robertson joins us in two minutes. and zyrtec® is different than claritin® because it starts working faster on the first day you take it. zyrtec®. love the air. [ sneezes ] on the first day you take it. are you still sleeping? just wanted to check and make sure that we were on schedule.
ch. some breaking news, the only person convicted in the 1988 lockerbie bombing has reportedly died. joining us by phone from london is cnn's nic robertson. with this death, nic, do secrets of lockerbie and who was behind it die with him? >> reporter: well, megrahi always said that he was innocent, always said that he would prove his innocence before he died, was never able to do it. it always appeared that it was unlikely that one person could have been behind such a complex operation, and other elements of the libyan regime were involved in ways we still don't know. one of the people who would know would be the head of libyan intelligence. perhaps the biggest clue to his importance to ma gr hi was when ma gr hi was released from
scotti scottish jail three years ago, it was this man who was waiting at a car to take him away. he's still in live, he's in custody. perhaps he will one day tell the whole truth, but perhaps megrahi has taken some of the secrets to the grave with him if he is, in fact, dead. >> nic robertson on the death of al megrahi, the only convicted criminal in the lockerbie bombing so many years ago. joining me now is california democratic senator barbara boxer and texas republican senator kay bailey hutchison. they will be -- you see them both there. good morning, ladies. thank you so much. i wonder, senator boxer, i know that you had been involved in the release of megrahi, had wanted to look more into this. sna as far as you're concerned, has justice been done in the lockerbie case? >> i don't believe so, and i wasn't for him being extradited. i've listened to the families.
they feel some type of closure, but they also believe that there are more leads that have to be followed, and one thing we know about our country, we'll come after you. so we need to keep on searching. we really do. >> senator hutchison, do you similarly agree that there is more to be done in what was such a hellacious thing. it's history now to some of the folks listening, but it still was an ongoing case to so many. >> absolutely it was because it was an outrageous act, the fact that no one else has been convicted, that we didn't have that kind of opportunity to really find out and that he was actually let out of prison early i think does leave a question and i agree with barbara 100%. >> nor hutchison, senator boxer sta
stick with us. we'll be back with more after this. across america, these technologies protect air - by monitoring air quality and reducing emissions... ...protect water - through conservation and self-contained recycling systems... ... and protect land - by reducing our footprint and respecting wildlife. america's natural gas... domestic, abundant, clean energy to power our lives... that's smarter power today. domestic, abundant, clean energy to power our lives... how did the nba become the hottest league on the planet? by building on the cisco intelligent network they're able to serve up live video, and instant replays, creating fans from berlin to beijing. what can we help you build? nice shot kid. the nba around the world built by the only company that could. cisco. [ male announcer ] for our families... our neighbors... and our communities...
america's beverage companies have created a wide range of new choices. developing smaller portion sizes and more low- & no-calorie beverages... adding clear calorie labels so you know exactly what you're choosing... and in schools, replacing full-calorie soft drinks with lower-calorie options. with more choices and fewer calories, america's beverage companies are delivering. with more choices and fewer calories, it doesn't look risky. i mean, phil, does this look risky to you? nancy? fred? no. well it is. in a high-risk area, there's a 1-in-4 chance homes like us will flood. i'm glad i got flood insurance. fred, you should look into it. i'm a risk-taker. [ female announcer ] only flood insurance covers floods. visit floodsmart.gov/risk to learn your risk.
joining me again, senator barbara boxer and senator kay bailey hutchison respectively from california and texas. thank you again both. i want to talk to you about what is going on on capitol hill, which appears to be really pretty much nothing in terms of final results. senator boxer, first to you, senator hutchison wrote an op-ed recently, i think this wednesday, about the number and the sheer amount of tax breaks that will expire at the end of the year if congress doesn't do something about it. and in there she wrote, there has been a conspicuous lack of you are enji from both the president and congressional democrats about addressing these tax increases and here he is talking about the health care tax increases going into effect as well as the tax increases that will happen if nothing is done to maintain the tax cuts. the white house strategy seems to be one, do not nothing until after the november election,
two, blame a government shutdown and economic meltdown on congress if it doesn't approve higher taxes before the end of 2012. i wanted to get your response. >> certainly. well, we slooel aabsolutely areo look at these tax cuts because the democrats believe it's very important to ensure that the middle class and the working poor have their tax cuts renewed and maybe even have deeper tax cuts, but we are also for fairness and justice, and we believe people earning over $1 million, multimillions, don't deserve to have another tax cut, don't need it, and a lot of my people in california say they don't want it. so there's a lot of other things that are on our plate also, and we need to move forward with jobs, jobs, jobs. and i will say something very positive here. kay bailey hutchison and i may not agree on everything about who should get a tax cut and how much it should be, but we do believe in creating jobs, and we work together on the faa bill. she was a key voice there. i'm on that committee.
she's the ranking member. and now i'm the chairman of the environment of public works committee, and she's a very key ranking member in negotiating an agreement on highways, roads, transit, and you know that will be 3 million jobs. >> which is great except -- >> so, yes, we have to approach it all. >> except for the problem here, senator hitchson, isn't it that you all both agree this something has to be done to address these tax increases that are going to happen if congress doesn't do something, and yet we have a stalemate and it seems to me that's always the case. ev says we agree on the ultimate goal but we can't agree on how to get there, and the country just gets this feeling that the entire process has broken down. >> well, first of all, i want to say thank you to barbara and agree that we are working together to lead our country in building the infrastructure and the planning capability for our highways and roads. she's taking the lead on that as the chairman of the committee, doing a great job.
but on tax cuts, honestly, we do have a disagreement with the democrats in congress. right now 50% of the people in this country don't pay taxes, and so you are taking care of the working poor with that. but on the other hand, we've got 25 million people will go into paying the amt, these are middle class people who are working every day, trying to do a little better for their families, they're going to go into the amt at the end of this year if we don't address it, if we don't keep these tax cuts that we have had in place. it is going to increase the tax on capital gains and dividends, on energy. we already see how high the energy costs are. it will increase the cost of energy. small business people need to be able to plan, and they are scared to death to hire people when you've got the obama taxes and fines coming into place at
the end of this year plus an increase in everybody's taxes, and they're not hiring, and that's what's causing our employment to be so low. we want to hire people. >> i think what you and senator boxer are both saying is you do agree with your parties' main line on these issues, and i get that. i want to posit something actually via david brooks who wrote an op-ed on friday about congress and said, leaders today do not believe their job is to restrain popular will. their job is to flatter and satisfy it. a gigantic polling apparatus has developed to help leaders anticipate and respond to popular whims. democratic politicians adopt the mindset of marketing executives. give the customer what he wants. the customer is always right. do you think politics has become too election-driven, too poll-driven, and that it impedes remarkably great people, you know, i know you both, i know a lot of people on capitol hill
hill, and it is mystifying to people why there cannot be some coming together in something so important as the budget process. do you agree with the brooks column? >> well, let me take a shot at this. let me tell you what i agree with. i agree with the fact that we're not meeting each other in the middle. i agree with the fact that why do we need to fight over passing a violence against women act and have the house over there instead of taking our bill that was a bipartisan bill start a big fight, leave women out. we don't need that. why do we need to be in this conference on the highway bill that i mentioned before where 3 million jobs are at stake? the house could have worked with us, picked up the senate bill, and passed it. so i don't think it's so much poll-driven as it is just a decision, and this is my view and, of course, kay is going to disagree with it, but it is backed up by two scholars who just wrote a very independent
study, they're nonpartisan, that said the republicans simply are in their corner, they won't move forward. now, i think what i hear coming from kay is some kind of crisis about tax cuts when we agree we're going to renew a lot of those to the middle class, and by the way, in the house they are taxing the working poor. that's the ryan budget. >> i'm going to have to give you the last 20 seconds here on that. >> sorry. >> yeah. candy, look, the congress, both the house and senate, rejected the obama budget 100%, not one democrat even voted for it because it had so many tax increases. what we're looking for is a way forward, leadership from the president, that would provide us a way to go forward, create jobs, keep taxes low on our small businesses, make sure they have the opportunity without strangling regulation to get this economy going again.
that's why i am supporting mitt romney, because he has had the ability to see the private sector work. it's not big government that's going to create jobs. it is the private sector, and we need to take the shackles off. that's what we're talking about. senat >> senators hutchison and boxer, i have to leave it there. i hope you will come back. i so enjoy having you. >> thank you. vice president joe biden in attack mode? >> i resent the fact they think we're talking about we're envy, it's job envy, it's wealth envy, that we don't dream. and later, when does a commencement address become a stump speech? hint, in an election year. people measure commitment by what's getting done. i'm mike utsler, and it's my job to make sure we keep making progress in the gulf. the twenty billion dollars bp committed has helped fund economic and environmental recovery. another fourteen billion dollars
has been spent on response and cleanup. long-term, bp's made a five hundred million dollar commitment to the gulf of mexico research initiative... to support ten years of independent scientific research on the environment. results will continue to be shared with the public. and we're making sure people know that the gulf is open for business - the beaches are beautiful, the seafood is delicious. last year, many areas even reported record tourism seasons. the progress continues, but that doesn't mean our job is done. bp's still here, and we're still committed to seeing this through. so i wasn't playing much of a role in my own life, but with advair, i'm breathing better so now i can take the lead on a science adventure. advair is clinically proven to help significantly improve lung function. unlike most copd medications, advair contains both an anti-inflammatory and a long-acting bronchodilator,
working together to help improve your lung function all day. advair won't replace fast-acting inhalers for sudden symptoms and should not be used more than twice a day. people with copd taking advair may have a higher chance of pneumonia. advair may increase your risk of osteoporosis and some eye problems. tell your doctor if you have a heart condition or high blood pressure before taking advair. if you're still having difficulty breathing, take the lead. ask your doctor if including advair could help improve your lung function. get your first full prescription free and save on refills at advaircopd.com.
here so hash out the week that was in politics, "new york times" political correspondent jeff zell ni and cnn senior congressional correspondent dana bash. i want to start by putting a period on the story you wrote this week which is the consideration of a proposal by a super pac that would bring up reverend wright again timed to go with the democratic convention. in the aftermath, did someone
win and someone lose or was it a summer squall in. >> i think this is a summer squall but the romney campaign wants to talk about the economy and they have a bunch of potential renegade super pac and wealthy republicans who mean well who want the same outcome but they're not on the same message perhaps. we did talk about reverend wright again this week, so it's not necessarily a win for obama either, but it just sends the message that the campaigns are not in control of their election. >> big time. look at romney's first ad this week. it was positive. it was really on the issues, what he would do on day one. you know, it might be a little bit too cute by half in that he can do that, and he can still have side shows talking about things like reverend wright. whether or not they're going to put out an ad or not, he can distance hymns and himself and put out a narrative.
>> this proposal we obtained, it was pretty far in the discussion phases. >> very quickly, after the story appeared, it was nobody's plan and -- let's face it, the democrats are, they were fund-raising on it, saying they're coming after us, holy cow, when, in fact, nothing had happened. >> right. >> so it was good for both bases do you think? >> i mean, perhaps -- >> or bad for both. >> i think it shows neither campaign is in as much control of the election as they would like. there are these outside forces that want to spend a lot of money and a lot of consultants who are eager to spend their money for them. >> and the republicans do make a good point, that anytime the obama administration is not talking about the economy, if they're attacking the republicans attacking them, that's okay with them. >> i want to play you something marco rubio, often thought of as a short list for vice president, but certainly a star in the republican party, had to say last night in south carolina.
>> the strategy that this white house and this party is employing is a destructive one that pits americans against each other, rich versus poor, men versus women. never have we seen such an effort to divide the american people in an effort to win an election as we have seen today. >> so as i said, when we get to the superlatives and never, we are really heavy into an election season, a general election season, which seems to me to have started nasty and early. >> it doesn't feel like it's may, does it, if you get the feel of things like that. i think the beginning of what he said, he might have had a point. certainly there's no hiding the fact that the campaign strategy in chicago, the obama world, is the populist message and the war on women. the fact that it's more than ever in history is perhaps stretching. >> perhaps in the history since he's been in the senate.
>> five minutes. >> i want to put a period on one other issue that came up last week. that is the president's personal support for gay marriage. this is something -- we saw the naacp, first of all, come out yesterday and say we also support gay marriage as a civil right, which is very important to president obama because there were those in the african-american community who were not supportive, so to have this big prestigious group come out and say we're with him is great and this is what newt gingrich had to say. >> it's unfortunate that he's so political but it eliminates any attack on romney ever flip-flopping with obama flip-flopping on something so big and doing it after the people of north carolina voted north. it was almost like he was unsults the people of north carolina. >> he's talking about the president came out with his personal support even after north carolina came out and said, no, we're against it. net gain or net loss for president obama or net we don't know? >> i think we don't know yet, but there's no question that the
naacp's support for this is very important. it gives this president and vice president a lot of cover among some black leaders and pastors and things but we still don't know how this will affect the campaign in states like ohio, these working class voters who may not be as far along on this issue. >> if you look at the way republican leaders reacted to his change, the president's change, the fact they stood back and they didn't want to touch it, they don't know, they think it might be a wash, because it's a 50/50 issue. >> right. even if it's a 50/50 issue it depends on who votes only on that. >> it's still about the economy. >> exactly, exactly. i'm sorry it's so short. come back. >> thanks. president obama is talking about the next phase in afghanistan, but will the u.s. have to foot most of the bill?
the nato summit is under way in chicago, and topping the agenda, afghanistan. joining me now is nato secretary-general anders fogh rasmussen. thank you so much for being here with us. with the end in sight, we believe, for afghanistan, one of the things that's outstanding certainly in the minds of many americans is will other members of nato besides the u.s. pony up the amount of money the u.s. would like to see to help keep afghanistan stable after combat ends?
>> yes, indeed. i am optimistic about fund-raising for the afghan security forces because at the end of the day, it is less expensive to finance the afghan security forces to do the combat than to deploy our own troops. nevertheless, a number of countries have announced substantial contributions to the afghan security forces, so i'm optimistic. >> does france share that view? does germany share that get thed they have monetary problems of their own at the moment, spending problems of their own, but is your optimistic view shared by the individual members? >> germany has announced a significant contribution to afghan security forces. this is a responsibility for the whole international community. not only nato. not only isaf, but, of course,
nato and isaf countries will pay their fair share of the total bill, but countries in general in the international community have a responsibility and also have an interest in insuring that the afghan security forces maintain a capability to take full responsibility for security in afghanistan after 2014. >> mr. secretary general, when you were on our show last, we spoke about libya and you said -- you called the attacks on libyan civilians by their government outrageous and systematic and said it's hard to believe that they would ever stop as long as qadhafi is in power. why isn't that same metric applied to syria as far as nato's response is concerned? >> there is a clear difference between libya and syria. we took responsibility for the
operation in libya to protect the civilian population because we had a clear mandate from the united nations, and we got clear support from a number of countries in the region. none of these conditions are fulfilled when it comes to syria. >> and i want to read you something that was said about the future of nato as we move beyobtd afghanistan. this was written by our cnn foreign affairs correspondent, and she wrote the decade long nato involvement in afghanistan has produced what some have described as collective fatigue among european allies and questions about whether nato should be involved in conflicts outside of europe's backyard. what is your feeling? should state nato, when it's necessary, be involved in conflicts outside europe? >> they certainly know fatigue. on the contrary. you are never seen so many
european forces deployed overseas and out of area than today, and in today's world our allies realize that territorial defense of our populations and our countries may very well start beyond our borders, like in afghanistan. we are in afghanistan to prevent the country from once again becoming a safe haven for terrorists who can use that safe haven as a launching pad for terrorist attacks against europe and north america, so though territorial defense remains the core task of nato, we realized that defense of our borders may very well start far from our borders in today's world. >> nato secretary general andrew rasmussen, we so appreciate your time as always. good luck to you in chicago.
>> thank you very much. >> it is the end of a school year, and the beginning of a general election campaign. you know what that means? >> hello, class of 2012. so many tough decisions i felt lost. unitedhealthcare offered us a specially trained rn who helped us weigh and understand all our options. for me cancer was as scary as a fastball is to some of these kids. but my coach had hit that pitch before. turning data into useful answers. we're 78,000 people looking out for 70 million americans. that's health in numbers. unitedhealthcare.
the teacher that comes to mind for me is my high school math teacher, dr. gilmore. i mean he could teach. he was there for us, even if we needed him in college. you could call him, you had his phone number. he was just focused on making sure we were gonna be successful. he would never give up on any of us. at bank of america, we're lending and investing in communities across the country. from helping to revitalize a neighborhood in brooklyn... financing industries that are creating jobs in boston... providing funding for the expansion of a local business serving a diverse seattle community...
and lending to ensure a north texas hospital continues to deliver quality care. because the more we can do in local neighborhoods and communities, the more we can help make opportunity possible. like a squirrel stashes nuts, you may be muddling through allergies. try zyrtec® liquid gels. nothing starts working faster than zyrtec® at relieving your allergy symptoms for 24 hours. zyrtec®. love the air.
it's graduation time in an election year, and you know what that means. a campaign trail running through commencement. >> we can assume that there were founding mothers whispering smarter things in the ears of the founding fathers. >> fresh off all that campaign chatter about the 30r7bs of the female vote, president obama went to new york to toast the graduating class at barnard, the all women's school. zim. >> i'm not saying the only way to achieve success is by climbing to the top of the corporate ladder or running for office, but let's face it, congress would get a lot more done if you did. >> he railed against a cynical off point media, a gridlocked congress, and ticked off a few of his priorities. >> we developed more clean energy, so we could use less foreign oil and reduce the
carbon pollution that's threatening our planet. >> when there are rules that stop big banks from making bad bets with other people's money. >> when insurance couples aren't allowed to drop your coverage when you need it most. >> 48 hours earlier mitt romney was busy bonding with conservative christian voters at liberty university founded by the late jerry fallwell, one of the most influential evangelicals over the 20th century. >> today we remember him as a courageous and big-hearted minister of the gospel who never feared an argument and never hated an adversary. >> liberty is in lynchberg, virginia, which is, yes, a swing state. >> strikes me as odd that the free exercise of religious faith is sometimes treated as a problem, something america is stuck with instead of being blessed with. perhaps religious conscious upsets the design for those that feel the highest wisdom and authority comes from government. >> so far as we can tell,
liberty is romney's only graduation ceremony this year, but to the president go the perks and a lot of invitations. when the season is over, the bidens and the obamas will have collectively delivered 11 commencement addresses. eight of them in swing states. thank you for watching state of the union. i'm candy crowley in washington. find today's interviews, some analysis, and web exclusives at our website, cnn.com/sotu. fareed zakaria gps is next for our viewers here in the united states. this is "gps, the global public square." welcome to all of you in the united states and around the world. i'm fareed zakaria. we have a very important show today dealing with the biggest problems facing the world. as europe is crumbling, the man who is seen as its potential savior is italy's new prime minister mario monti, super mario. i have an exclusive interview with him. monty has been trying to reform it