tv Fox and Friends First FOX News November 28, 2016 2:00am-3:01am PST
>> kind of the first official monday of the christmas season in new york city. all of the lights are set up and the christmas tree. f they are firing up the lights over rockefeller center. >> good morning to all of you. you are watching "fox & friends first" on this monday morning. i am clayton morris. >> i am heather childers. thank you for starting your day with us. we appreciate it as always. wisconsin election officials are set to kickoff a recount. >> president elect donald trump calling it a scam and blasting hillary clinton's involvement. kristin fisher is live in washington with all of the details. >> the election is not over yet. >> we thought it was almost. here's the deal over the last 24-hours mr. trump has gone on a twitter tirade. his longest since becoming the president elect. he posted 11 tweets on twitter
slamming the fact that hillary clinton had joined this recount effort led by green party candidate jill stein in wisconsin. trump said i won the popular vote if you deduct the millions of people who voted illegally. he alleged serious voter fraud in new hampshire and california. why isn't the media reporting on this? serious bias. no problem. >> he has zero evidence supporting either claim. the secretary of state calling the claims reckless absurd and unbecoming of the president elect. this recount effort is nothing more than a scam. the current vote count is trump 2.9 million clinton with 1.4 and jill stein 31,000. kelly ann conway equated stynes number of votes to the number of people who tailgate at a packer's game. >> ridiculously fantastical
recount that jill stein is engaging in in wisconsin and perhaps elsewhere. you have the president elect donald trump being mag man mouse to hillary clinton and her responding with joining into this recount. why in the world can't the democrats quote accept the election results? >> it is taking place. the green party has the legal right to do it. we have recounts probably every election is a recount. no one expects there will be profound change but there's nothing wrong with going through the process. >> that process will likely start around 10:30 this morning p. that's when they will sit together and set the schedule for this recount. >> it happens this morning 9:30 a.m. in wisconsin. >> 9:30, wisconsin. >> thanks, kristin. the special elect trump meeting with cabinet ab mets in new york city after spending thanksgiving with his family in florida. kelly wright is here with
details on the battle for secretary of state. >> there's a brouhaha going on within the republican circle about secretary of state. before we get to that donald trump gets back to the business of interviewing people he has in mind to fill his cabinet. he will meet with a list of people today. paul atkins former security i say and exchange commissioner possibly treasury position there. sheriff david clark from milwaukee for possible department of justice or department of home lapped security or advisory commission. scott pruitt oklahoma attorney general for department of justice. sandeep mathrani general growth. kathleen white possible epa. david steward technology ceo and lou bar let taw president of pennsylvania. last week mr. trump met with
former governor mitt romney and he had sterne m-- ed stern. many upset about romney's attack against trufrn. they are concerned with possibly them electing romney as secretary of state. >> governor romney went out of his way to question the character and intellect and integrity of donald trump now our president elect would be given the most significant cabinet post of all secretary of state. that is a decision only one man can make. i will respect it and support it 1,000 percent. i am reflecting what the grass-roots are saying. >> kelly ann conway saying she will stand by her man with the decision he makes that is of course the president elect. other people he may consider are rudy giuliani, tosulsy gabbard david petraeus or john f. kelly.
many say they are inexperienced. sanderson is urging democrats to work with mr. trump if he is serious about protecting working families. there you have it. heather? >> thank you, kelly. days ago president elect trump promised not to order an investigation into hillary clinton's personal e-mail server or her role in the clinton foundation. kierd to go the new york post she isn't off the hook just yet. mr. trump will have u.s. ambassadors push ep foreign governments to probe the clinton foundation financial dealings in their country. according to the post the administration will focus on massive donations involving haiti and columbia. fox news alert. a third straight night of celebrations in miami following the death of former cuban dictator fidel castro. a rush of americans as they
thread through the streets. >> you are taking a look at havana where a nine-day mourning is set for the leader. >> we are in little havana with the latest on this. >> good morning clayton and heather. still early out here but we are expecting crowds to gather as they have been for the past couple of days and nights spilling out in h street carrying cuban and american flags singing songs and chanting and honking horns and celebrating the death of a dictator who they say killed or imprisoned thousands of dissidents sealing their homes and forcing millions to flee on small boats over those 90 miles of ocean to reach the u.s. remember back in march president obama became the first sitting president to visit cuba opening diplomatic relations with the castro regime and allowing commercial flights through
executive order. on fox news sunday yesterday president elect incoming chief of staff told krisz wallace that deal could be undone very soon. >> he already said that would be the case. what the deal is yet to be determined. there has to be some movement from cuba in order to have a relationship with the united states. the president elect has been very clear about that. >> many cubans here didn't like that deal very much. they say not much has changed on the island nation in terms of diplomatic and human rights. another demonstration is expected here to coincide with the parade of fidel castro's ashes in side later today. >> rick ef en thall in little havana. bullets flying on bourbon street one man dead and others hurt. >> we will find them and bring them to justice.
>> tourists and party yirs sent running for their lives on new orleans' busiest street. they say the shooting started as an argument between the two people. none of the victims were the intended tash get. one was arrested for illegal firearm and not considered a suspect in the are learning chi details about the california mother who disappeared for 3 weeks after going for a run. her captors released her 150 miles away from her home early thanksgiving morning. police now releasing some chilling audio from the moment they found her on the side of the interstate. >> she is heavily battered. (indiscernible) >> her sister speaking out about how thankful they are to be reunited. >> everyone's tireless efforts has made our family whole again this thanksgiving.
>> police are hunting for two hispanic women in connection with the kidnapping. they are believed to be armed and dangerous. >> four isis fighters are dead killed after launching the terror group's first direct atakt on israel. the israeli military targeting the jihadis in an air strike after the terrorists ambushed soldiers in the israeli held part of syria. israel has avoided getting directly involved in syria's civil war. a former marine facing decades hientd bars for scamming the government and stealing medal of valor. >> he told people he was seriously injured after running over an ied in iraq. he was awarded a purple heart and given a frae house. it turns out that story of valor actually bea longed to a now dead marine and double amputee casey owens. black stone was exposed by norma reason who questioned his story.
>> poetic justice for colin kaepernick. he is ripped for wearing a fidel castro shirt supporting the dictator. >> he played in miami sunday. how did dolphin fans greet him? >> you can hear the crowd immediately letting their feelings be known. >> on the final play he tries for the game winning score but he is stopped. the son of a cuban immigrant. the col fins beat the 49ers officially eliminating them from the playoffs. that wasn't even close. >> he wore the t-shirt after the last game and there was a reporter there that confronted him about it a. oo nice t-shirt. where do you get a castro t-shirt? >> 10 minutes before the top of the hour. what would hillary clinton say if someone questioned our election system? >> that is horrifying. every time donald thinks things are not going in his direction
he claims whatever it is is rigged against him. >> now she is changing her tune. our panel weighs in next. >> she murdered add new jersey police officer that fled to cuba. now new calls to face justice after castro's death. >> one college's efforts say people burning the flag just don't fly it. that's not flying with these vets. >> raise your flags everybody.
♪ p is for privileges. o is for ordinarily i wouldn't. l is for layers of luxury. a is for alll the way back. r is for read my mind. and i... can't see a thing. s... see you in the morning. polaris, from united. when i was too busy with the kids to get a repair estimate. liberty did what? yeah, with liberty mutual all i needed to do to get an estimate was snap a photo of the damage and voila! voila! (sigh) i wish my insurance company had that... wait! hold it... hold it boys... there's supposed to be three of you... where's your brother? where's your brother? hey, where's charlie? charlie?! you can leave worry behind when liberty stands with you.
liberty stands with you™ liberty mutual insurance (vo) black friday may be over but the best cyber monday deals are at verizon. because a deal is only as good as the network it's on. verizon gives you the best network and a lot more. great deals on our hottest smartphones. like the droid turbo 2 by motorola for $10 per month. or the iphone se for $5 per month. our lowest price ever. the best cyber monday deals are at verizon. shop online all day. hurry, and get it all at vzw.com. and grease in just a minute on dirt and grime mr. clean will clean your whole house and every room that's in it floors, doors, walls, halls he's so tough, he cleans 'em all mr. clean! trust number one doctor recommended dulcolax constipated? use dulcolax tablets for gentle overnight relief suppositories for relief in minutes and stool softeners for comfortable relief
of hard stools. dulcolax, designed for dependable relief we'd do anything for kids. yet 1 in 6 children in the us struggle with hunger. help end childhood hunger near you. learn how at feedingamerica.org. i>> donald said a lot of things troubling but he said something truly horrifying. he became the first person running for president, republican or democrat who refused to say that he would
respect the results of this election. (booing) >> that is a direct threat to our democracy. that is horrifying. every time donald thinks things are not going in his direction he claims whatever it is is rigged against him. that is not the way our democracy works. >> hillary clinton once horrified at the prospect of president elect donald trump daring to question the results of the election now joining jill stein in demanding a recount in wisconsin. rear to weigh in is kristin tate from the libertarian chick.com. thank you both for joining us this morning. >> no longer a threat to democracy. kristin? >> this is the height of hypocrisy. of course when trump wants to question the results if he loses, that would be appalling, but now that hillary is the one
that lost she has completely changed her tune. here's the bottom line. she would have to win all of these states where they are doing recounts. wisconsin, michigan and pennsylvania to win the election. there's no chance of that happening. this is a big type dream. there's no evidence there was election tampering in these states. and onwhat's most funny about ts story is perhaps the most corrupt person to run for president who was under federal investigation per pay to play politics and who received the big questions ahead of time for cnn now wants to be in charge of the integrity of the election. it is hilarious. >> what is going on here? hillary clinton's campaign itself has come forward saying they have been looking into it. there's no evidence of hacking or wrong doing in that regard. yet they are joining on to this
effort. >> i actually agree it is a pipe dream. yesterday member of congress tum ryan who is challenging nancy pelosi for the leadership job in the house is on meet the press. it is time for us to move on. it is time for us to move on. we need to work on not harping with something. wisconsin has 10 electoral votes. just 10. as kristin just said that's not going to be enough to flip the election. maybe they are banking on some kind of a crazy faceless elector scenario. it is not going to work. >> 107,000 was that correct between all three states the difference of those votes. let's talk about the money that has been raised so far. jill stein raising over 4 million. the rae count cost $2 million. the money not used will go towards the green party.
what a going on here? 6 million so far when she can raise that amount of money in the general election? >> it's hillary's people. >> it's hillary's people for sure. hillary people looking for a miracle invested in jill stein and jill stein is going to pocket that money unfortunately. it will be a lose lose situation. here we are 2016. >> kristin you get the final word here. >> you actually look at jill stein's own web site, it says right there in the fine print that all of the money raised may not even go to this recount effort. we don't know where this money is going. it acts as a financial scam. jill stein is not exactly as pure as wind driven snow. this is a woman who has been arrested multiple times. she was behind bars in 2012. we don't know where this money is going or what the motive behind this is. >> the deadline to file in pennsylvania is today.
wisconsin slated to have a meeting at 9:30 a.m. this morning wisconsin time. we will see. >> thank you so much for joining us. 19 minutes after the hour liberal mayors defy president elect trump and keep their city's sank arias for illegals. one governor just said not so fast. how would you like to earn tickets for the super bowl for the rest of your life? whoa, this is awful, try it. oh no, that looks gross what is that?
you gotta try it, it's terrible. i don't wanna try it if it's terrible. it's like mango chutney and burnt hair. no thank you, i have a very sensitive palate. just try it! guys, i think we should hurry up. if you taste something bad, you want someone else to try it. it's what you do. i can't get the taste out of my mouth! if you want to save fifteen percent or more on car insurance, you switch to geico. it's what you do. shhh! dog, dog, dog.
this holiday, the real gift isn't what's inside the box... it's what's inside the person who opens it. give your loved ones ancestrydna, the simple dna test that can tell them where they came from -by revealing their ethnic mix. you'll save 30%-and they'll have a new story to tell. order now at ancestrydna.com. offer ends monday.
>> raise your flags everybody. >> it stands for all veterans around the whole nation. everybody who fought for this flag. it is more than just a symbol. >> i fought tore this flag. live for it. >> 1,000 protesting to remove the american flag from their campus. hampshire college from massachusetts lowering the flag to half mass after trump won the election. the decision was a protest against support of harassment and hate speech not mr. trump. that flag was found burned on veteran's day prompting them to remove it indefinitely.
>> they were raising the controversy getting us away from the underlying sal us that we wanted to discuss. >> they say the school's decision is disrespectful to former and current military members. >> take out your lab tops. typ siper monday is here. online sales surging. >> we are breaking down the numbers. >> if you add up thanksgiving day and black friday, just for online sales that gave a billion dollars. there's a lot more shoppers but they spent less money. people are looking for deals. internet sales combined over the two-days 3 billion alone brought up strength. more and more americans are going online, guys.
>> did you go shopping? >> you can order movie tickets. >> star wars tickets went on sale at knmidnight. i already bought 10 of them. >> i got mine for star wars. it is a spin-off/free quill takes us to the story of the rebels trying to steal the plans of the death star being built. it has a lot of big stars in it. opens december 16th. tickets on sale today if you want to go in the month of december buy your tickets today. matt was saying it got jammed. >> i haven't seen any star wars movies. >> i am sure i will hear about it on twitter.
thanksgiving weekend box office lots of movies. >> blockbuster. this one has the release of picture thanksgiving weekend. $88.1 million. wayne the rock johnson is one of the big stars and voices in the movie. they try to save their people. inspiring uplifting movie. people are going for gstuff. >> lynn manuel. >> what about free super bowl tickets for life? >> heather and i were there last year. we should go again i think the w i don't think the cowboys will be there. budweiser and bud light offered a really cool promotion.
they are going to put 37,000 gold cans in 1820 for 30 pack of 12 ounce beer cans. if you get the cogold can take e picture of it you tweet and of course you can e-mail them, too. hashtag sb ticks for life. you will be put into a drawing to get tickets for life. >> i think all of our teams are in trouble this year. >> thanks, cheryl. >> thank you. >> you bet. >> 30 minutes after the top of the hour. he may only there two months left in office but he still has his pen and phone. he is planning big things. >> atlanta falcons thanks to the navy seals. we will explain that next.
[vo] quickbooks introduces jeanette. and her new business: i do, to go. jeanette was excellent at marrying people. but had trouble getting paid. not a good time, jeanette. even worse. now i'm uncomfortable. but here's the good news, jeanette got quickbooks. send that invoice, jeanette. looks like they viewed it. and, ta-da! paid twice as fast. oh, she's an efficient officiant. way to grow, jeanette.
>> hillary clinton joins the recount effort in wisconsin. this morning president elect donald trump is firing up and firing back. we are live in washington as the effort to recount the vote begins. >> president elect trump amping up after the holiday break. speculation grows over what place mitt romney could have or not have. >> i am all for party unity but i am not sure we have to pay for that with the secretary of state position. >> it is siesh monday. how does 75 percent off of everything sound? >> great. >> we are breaking down the best deals. fox & friends first continues right now. >> good morning to you. you are watching "fox & friends
first." hope you had a great weekend. everybody at home as well. >> i am talking about star wars. get out there and order your star wars tickets. i am clayton morris. it is 31 minutes after the hour. wisconsin election officials set to kickoff the recount. >> president elect donald trump calling it a scam and blasting hillary clinton's involvement. >> kristin fisher is live with that. >> the trump transition team is calling this recount effort led by jill stein and joined by clinton nothing more than a scam. listen to what the incoming chief of staff reince priebus said about it yesterday. >> total and complete hypocritical joke that the group of people that thought they were nervous about president elect trump not conceding are the people conducting recounts and states won over 68,000 votes.
>> even bernie sanders is conceding these recount will likely change little. >> they are taking place. the green party has the legal right to do it. they have recounts probably almost every election there's a recount. no one expects there to be profound change. there's nothing wrong with going through the process. >> that process will start later this morning when the wisconsin election commission sits down and does the recount. clinton with 1.4 gary johnson with 100,000 and jill stein with 31,000. trump posted in addition to winning the electoral college with a land slide the million people who voted illegally. why isn't the media reporting on this? serious bias, big problems. they had zero evidence providing
either claim. sp they are calling it reckless and absurd. what is unbecome something clinton rule out a criminal probe of clinton views of a private e-mail server as secretary of state. >> it is not over yet. president elect trump meeting with cabinet cabinets in new york city after spending thanksgiving with his family in florida. kelly wright is live in washington with the spoils of the ramped up battle with secretary of state. >> mr. trump is back getting back to hand picking his cabinet. here's the list of people you can meet with today. exchange commissioner for possibly the department of traesh ry clark in walker county it is rumored he could be considered for homeland
security. possibly the doj. general gross property chief executive. public policy foundations possible foundation at the epa. stewart technology ceo and lou bar let taw republican from pennsylvania. president elect met with former governor mitt romney. many republicans are upset with romney's attack on trump during the campaign. they are voicing concern over the potential secretary of state pick. there's a lot of opinions about this. if you were to go toward the governor romney concept. i think that should tell all americans about where president elect's head is at. with they will place the best people together no matter who you are what your religion whatever your opinion is he
wants to look forward looking through the oned shield not the rearview mirror. calm down see what happens. other people mr. trump may consider are rudy giuliani, diff vaid petraeus and john kelly. democrats are critical of mr. trump's choices saying they are inexperienced. bernie sanders is urging democrats to work with mr. trump if he is serious about working families. meanwhile president elect pulling out a brand new hat. it says usa45 for the 45th president. this is in exchange for the trademark hat make america great again. back to you guys. >> thanks, kelly. now to a fox news alert a third night of celebrations in miami following the death of former cuban dictator fidel castro. a lye look at cuba celebrating
the life of the brutal dictator. he his remains will be buried sunday. how they deal with post cuba. a oo what that deal is yet to be determined. there has to be some movement from cuba in order to have a relationship with the united states. i think the president elect has been very clear about that. >> during the campaign mr. trump promised to roll back president obama's executive actions on cuba. >> castro's death bringing a cop kirl back to the u.s. to face justice. he was given asylum and he has 30 years to go as she was convicted of murdering warner forrester during a traffic stop in 1973. he scaped prison and fled to cuba five years later.
they reversed the shape of white house policy. the government allowed convicted cube tives to get harbored and given safe haven. >> bullets flying on bush bonn street. >> fund them. we will go to the end of the earth to make sure we bring them to justice. >> police think the shooting started there's an argument between two people but none of the victims were the intended targets. one victim raised and charged with illegal possession of a firearm. they are not considered a suspect in the shooting. >> we are learning brand new chilling details of a california mother who disappeared for three weeks after going for a run. ch her captors released her 150 miles from her home. this is amazing.
police release chilling audio from the moment they found her on the side of an interstate. >> she is heavily battered and (indiscernible) >> her sister is now also speaking out about how thankful they are to be reunited. >> everybody's effort made our family whole again this thanksgiving. >> they are looking for two hispanic women in connection with the kidnapping. they are believed to be armed and dangerous. >> four isis fighters dead killed after launching the terror groups for the direct attack on israel. >> the terrorists ambushed soldiers in an israeli held part of syria. >> they are getting directly involved in syria's civil war. >> they go down to the wire for an insane finish.
star quarterback makes history in lead 12. >> sirius xm 115. serious sunday football highlights. >> five weekend remain in the regular season. battle beyond regulation over time one minute left. tied at 27 broncos brandon mcmanus no good from 62 yards away. the thin air doesn't help him on this long distance field goal. the air wasn't thin enough for him. he is going to be the man with five seconds to go for 34 yards out. watch this.
>> afc west 8 and 3 behind the raiders who were 9-2. get to the history books. game winning drive by number 12. malcolm mitchell with the winning score past 22 jets 17. 200th career win for tom brady ties payton manning. kaepernick wearing a castro shirt. they sent a message when kaepernick entered the field. >> on the final play of the game, caber nick who ran for 113 yards trying for the game winning score but was unable to do so stopped by alanto the son of a cuban immigrant. dolphins hold off the 49ers.
>> my family my wife is a 49ers fan. >> not an easy season. i am an eagles fan. neither on that side either. >> the falcons have been trying to grab anything they could do to try to help them turn around. they have the navy seals to help them. >> yeah. back in april of this year the atlanta falcons blew out the cardinals 39.18. they had struggles. matt ryan the quarterback said he never panicked and credits the navy seals. he brought them in during the training. they hit the reset button. they have taken the training from the seals talked about carrying logs around and stuff get to see what hard work is all about. >> i think that's an awesome idea. i think my carolina panthers need to do that.
the death of kate steinle. steinle shot dead in san francisco by a convicted felon who had been deported five times. >> if a in his final weeks in office president obama is pushing a flurry of el executive actions. nearly 100 midnight regulations before president elect trump takes office. environmental protections and protecting funding for planned parenthood. >> someone is wrapping up thanksgiving weekend with 421 million reasons to be thankful. the winning $421 million ticket sold in tennessee one of the biggest jackpots in the game's history. chances of winning 1.290 million. no word yet on who the lucky winner is. it turns out it pays to be from tennessee the power ball winner is the second from this state this year. >> in that town chances are they probably know who won it because there are only 5,000 people who live there. >> he is going to have a lot of
friends. >> where can you find the best cyber monday deals. >> cheryl where should we go? what should we do? >> happy cyber monday. hit the buy button and spend more. americans spending over the weekend with online purchases on thanksgiving and black friday alone hitting $5.27 billion. that is a jump of 18 percent from last year according to the latest numbers we got this morning from adobe. wal-mart is offering deep discounts with free shipping on 50 or more major offerings like a vizeotv, the dragon fly drone with camera dell lap top and prada sunglasses. dell is offering hourly deals on laptops cd's games and more and spur on14 and smart tv and spx13
is now available as well. macy's for you. 20 percent off of any order free shipping if you spend 25 or more. instore deals on many other items if you are willing to get off of your computer and go to the store. target has a surprise deal. free shipping on all orders. that's not the surprise. there's a surprise deal but you have to go to the web site to find out what it is. i have a feeling it will be changing throughout the day. amazon will have its sale go through december 22nd with prime membering getting early access. amazon devices like echo and kindle are going to be on sale. tv's home automation systems and could is a toys are big as far as sale items. over stock they have 75 percent off. that's the number. 75 percent off. big discounts on laptops android
tablets and more. the big deals over the weekend have been tablets on average tablets are 25 percent off no matter where you shop. >> thank you, cheryl. appreciate it. >> check in with steve doocy see what's coming up on "fox & friends." >> one member of the electoral college getting hundreds of death threats from hillary supporters demanding he switch his vote. he is not going to. one message bigotry hatred and racism, i hope you die. that elector is going to be here life from michigan. tim tebow, whispering bill anderson, the legend and the legendary 7:00 p.m. host on fox tucker carlson. busy three hours kicking off 9 minutes. >> 9 minutes and counting. thank you so much, steve.
>> we will be back. (vo) black friday may be over but the best cyber monday deals are at verizon. because a deal is only as good as the network it's on. verizon gives you the best network and a lot more. great deals on our hottest smartphones. like the droid turbo 2 by motorola for $10 per month. or the iphone se for $5 per month. :. shop online all day. hurry, and get it all at vzw.com.
one pennsylvania town is fighting to keep blue lines on the road honoring police. a conway township in pennsylvania painted a blue stripe between double yellow lines as a nod to first responders. the state department of transportation says it could confuse drivers and cause an accident. town officials dispute that and have no plan to remove the blue stripe any time soon. 1,000 veterans pro -- to remove the american flag from their campus. >> hampshire college in massachusetts lowering the flag to half-mast after president-elect trump won the election sparking controversy. that flag was found burned on veterans day prompting officials to remove it indefinitely
outraging veterans. >> stands for all the veterans around the whole nation. >> everybody who fought for this flag. it's more than just a symbol. >> i would die for this flag. >> i fought for this flag. i live for it. >> veterans at the rally say the school's decision is disrespectful to former and current military members. >> it is now, what, five minutes until the top of the hour. >> and counting. >> this is not how the trip was supposed to go. he set the whole place on fire. ♪
one minute until the top of the hour. before we leave the house, here's what's happening. wisconsin election official also hold a news conference about a recount spearheaded by green count nominee jill stein. president-elect calling it a publicity stunt. president-elect meeting with possible cabinet picks after spending thanksgiving with family in florida. panic on bourbon street. nine were injured. time for the good, the bad and the ugly. meet polly, the rescue goat. suffers from anxiety. but she's living the good loy thanks to this duck costume. she stopped crying as soon as the outfit goes on. looks like me.
next the bad. ed sheer han flashed by british princess beatrice. the ugly. a fire breather accidentally setting ayu crainian nightclub on fire. you don't want to do that. >> no. >> bye. it is monday, it's november 28th. we hope you had a great thanksgiving weekend with your family. i'm ainsley earhardt. hillary clinton joins a recount effort despite her saying this. remember? >> we've accepted the outcome when we may not have liked them and that is what must be expected of anyone standing on a debate stage during a general election. >> you should accept the outcome she says or she said. we are liv