Skip to main content

tv   Justice With Judge Jeanine  FOX News  March 16, 2019 9:00pm-10:00pm PDT

9:00 pm
remember, i'm watters and this is my world. [♪] ♪ >> he asked if i wanted to go swimming, i didn't think that was appropriate, i turned. i was by myself, i was running, he caught me again and tackled me, i fell to the ground out by the pool.
9:01 pm
9:02 pm
in early hours of march 30. teddy kennedy, his younger son patrick and 30-year-old nephew william kennedy smith found themselves at grounds of a trendy palm beach bar. what ted didn't know, when he suryed the boys out of bed, this night would end up in a courtroom with a sensational rain trial of his nephew. >> young woman claims she was brutally raped. for those who were able to reminisce about previous kennedy embarrassments, the palm beach story seemed all too victim. but it was centered on william
9:03 pm
kennedy smith. william kennedy smith was one of its most conpic conhe commandedf the attention
9:04 pm
ted kennedy drives off a bridge, leaving a young campaign aide to drown, that is the beginning of the kennedy saga. not just a darker turn but the public seeing. the givthe darker reality of whs going on. >> as rumors naming mr. smith as suspect, fuel the clamor of palm beach, questions surfaced and
9:05 pm
answered regarding willie's backgrounds emerged as he remained in hiding, william kennedy smith, grandson of late ambassador joseph kennedy, nephew of senator edward moore kennedy, nephew of slain president of united states john f kennedy, and slain former attorney general of u.s. robert kennedy, cousin of the assistance district attorney, and of caroline kennedy, and cause up of maria shriver, but with the kennedy name, willie smith was described as least spoiled, a humanitarian, a philanthropist. and soon to be doctor. >> he never boasted, bragged about his kennedy lineage. he was willie smith, that is the way he liked it and wanted it. >> the ke name gave willie supp,
9:06 pm
he retained support residents of crown jewel, palm beach. >> if it was not the kennedy its would never have happened. >> you don't think he did it. >> i don't think it was rape. >> i it takes two to tango. >> details of about night in question and alleged victim, were still amisas tight lipped palm beach police department withheld information. but before police released the information. media to get story first. media circus began. >> i was also here just hours ago, i learned tail end of a kennedy plan powwow. here is what happened.
9:07 pm
>> no comment does not help anyone. >> first big break was i interviewed this woman michelle. who was at the bar the night that william kennedy smith meets the alleged victim. >> michelle, a 27-year-old waitress from palm beach area, meets cousin of william kennedy smith at obar that night, they sipped champagne. >> they observed easter weekend, good friday, one of the holiest days of the catholic calendar. >> not only can she leak to reporters she saw the alleged victim, a 29-year-old woman from
9:08 pm
jupiter florida with smith that night, and explained details of the after party at the kennedy estate that night. >> they had a couple of drinks, no wobbling wa was there, but ss differently, william on the beach with the alleged victim and later, she saw a naked woman in front of them. >> she said they went back to the mansion after the drinking, at obar they was continuing drinking and saw teddy keen deey in his yo underwear. >> i was this the house. >> no pants. >> no pants. >> i don't know if that was true. but she claimed it, she cid, he was drunk. she saw the alleged victim, who was in terrible state, she said.
9:09 pm
>> sitting and talking, i noticed a woman walking naked into the ocean. i made a comment there is a naked woman walking into thing . >> michelle in the end would talk to anyone with a notebook and a pen. she scoffed up every bit of attention she could get. >> everybody wanted to talk to me. nobody wants to support me, you want to hear me. but nobody wants to pay to hear what i have to say. >> now, she was not a witness to what happened between william kennedy smith and the young woman he met that night, but came back to the compound but her story added atmospherics to the story. >> after a barrage of tv show
9:10 pm
appearances, she lost her job. >> i cannot remember names. >> i saw a picture of her. >> she was caught battering front door of oh oh, oracl obare finger of a reporter. >> a real bite. >> michelle, the fighting machine, went on the offensive. now. as a gentleman, i could not hit her. and as a reporter, i couldn't run away. i just had to stand there and take it. >> she was arrested for violating her probation for driving violations.
9:11 pm
>> michelle could not be a credible went, she lied to the press, and probably to the police. she had some photographs that are really not to explain able. >> michelle, one of only witnesses at compound in early morning hours of march 30, who offered candid details on the press, and possibly only unbias source needed for a condirection would be found a unreliable wat midas, with every oil change you get a free tire rotation. makes you feel like a king! king for a day! well, maybe not the whole day. our 19.99 or 49.99 oil change includes a tire rotation.
9:12 pm
they have businesses to grow customers to care for lives to get home to they use print discounted postage for any letter any package any time right from your computer all the amazing services of the post office only cheaper get our special tv offer a 4-week trial plus postage and a digital scale go to and never go to the post office again!
9:13 pm
(woman) too late for lunch.o minutes. starkist saves the day. sweet and spicy tuna in a pouch! smart choice, charlie. (charlie) no drain, no pain. just tear, eat... and go! try all of my tuna, salmon and chicken pouches. guys go through a lot to deal with shave irritation. so, we built the new gillette skinguard with a specialized guard designed to reduce it. because we believe all men deserve a razor just for them. the best a man can get.
9:14 pm
gillette. a business owner always goes beyond what people expect. that's why we built the nation's largest gig-speed network along with complete reliability. then went beyond. beyond clumsy dials-in's and pins. to one-touch conference calls. beyond traditional tv. to tv on any device. beyond low-res surveillance video.
9:15 pm
to crystal clear hd video monitoring from anywhere. gig-fueled apps that exceed expectations. comcast business. beyond fast. >> nothing proven at all that the palm beach police department has tried to conduct any type of cover-up in this matter, that word cover-up as been brought up only by the media and the public. >> although the aleppe alleged m went it police department, police were not able to reach william kennedy smith for 6 days, after two weeks of withholding much in, palm beach police released a report friday april 12, including victim's statements.
9:16 pm
william kennedy smith's name, detail regarding the on going investigation. and the examinations conducted by emergency room doctors at humana hospital. >> now finally, palm beach police department -- releases a report on what they say happened that night in the kennedy compound. >> i'm going to elaborate briefly on the alleged allegations cop contained in that report, the victim met william smith after -- midnight march 30, a short time later victim drove william smith back to the kennedy compound.
9:17 pm
>> all this was never examined by palm beach cops until 11 days after. >> they should have done it immediately, they had a chance to do it right afterwards, they done bother to go up there for 24 hours. >> why didn't -- >> according to police records
9:18 pm
when sergeant robson arrived to investigate the report, william berry, kennedy's beloved friend and security guard met him at door. chief of police in palm beach joseph, has stated mr. berry deliberately misled police officers when they arrived on march 21, and twice told police that no members of the family were inside of the mansion when he knew otherwise. >> detectives were misled by william berry, a long time family friend, police said they were wrongly told that kennedy and smith left town. >> mr. berry told invest getters about 1:30 p.m. march 31, that mr. smith might have already left palm beach in a deposition give confident spring, -- give confident spring, he said police had just festivitied the estate. police investigation determined
9:19 pm
that senator kennedy and his son patrick remained at the estate until april 1, when they left town without having talk to police, and mr. smith, sent most of easter sunday at the mansion before being driven to the airport by mr. berry himself that afternoon. >> police have not named berry a suspect. but they believe berry is the focus of the investigation. >> so mr. berry, shifts from being strong man in the shadows protects the family from out said harm, became the subject of a possible be o obstruction of justice charge that would later surface in a grand jury hearing after the trial. but, the police circled another, as they his details from the night in questions as well. several hours after the jupiter woman left the kennedy estate, she went to humana hospital to conduct a rai rape rape examinat
9:20 pm
determined a possible rib fracture. >> she turned to leave, she said, he attacked her and raped her, that night, she suffered what doctors later diagnosed as a likely rib fracture in the police report was downgraded to minor injuries, it is important to remember that night, the doctors, the police, believed her. prosecuters believed her. her rape crisis counselor believed her. >> she was shaking, in my mind she was traumatized. >> they pass a poligraph, but it cannot be used in court. >> on friday april 12, reports came out this samples of smith a hair, blood and semen were found
9:21 pm
to be consistent with evidence from the woman. >> a standard beyond probable cause for a prosecutor, i filed this information in tbl good fa. >> she was subject to 6 different recorded interviews in her case, something that sun sun heard of -- is unheard of. >> while alleged victim under went intensive analysis, william kennedy smith had gone almost a week without confronting there was a moment, my son i believe was about four, where he actually asked me "mommy what's wrong with your teeth?" if i would've known that i was gonna be 50 times happier... i would've gone into aspen dental much sooner. it was a very life changing experience... and it felt like i was me again. that's when i realized i hadn't been for three years.
9:22 pm
at aspen dental we're all about yes. like yes to flexible hours and payment options. yes to free exam and x-rays for new patients without insurance. and yes whenever you're ready to get started, we are too. call now at 1-800-aspendental.
9:23 pm
9:24 pm
9:25 pm
[♪] aishah: live from "america's news headquarters." i'm aishah hasnie. yellow vest protesters rocked paris for the 18th consecutive weekend. french firefighters had to rescue a mother and child after a city building caught fire. the protesters are a grassroots movement seeking changes to the economy. nebraska is dealing with the
9:26 pm
worst flooding in half a century. the missouri river reaching nearly 26 feet in the city of st. joseph. just shy of what's considered major flooding. the river is expected to continue rising in the middle of the week at 29 feet.
9:27 pm
>> her high school grades and her jobs, her social habits, they even published the titles of two books on her two -year-old daughter shelf. >> at the time it came out one new york times ever to the story was flushing her and another critical the op-ed. >> i think identifying the victim by name is not appropriate unless they want to release it. that goes against my grain is reporter that i feel that
9:28 pm
evidence should be a. >> not everyone who accuses him of rape is a rape victim. she is an alleged rape victim. i don't believe a person who is an accuser is right to anonymity while the accused has his face splattered all over the newspapers. that shifts the presumption of innocence to a presumption of guilt. >> i think turning that name against not only unethical but against the law. we had a long-standing law that sexual assault needs to be redacted and not released. >> however, after the globe discharged from using the sam same -- >> to protect the constitutional right and its response ability of reporting the events of this prosecution to the public is make the trial circuit judge but otherwise. >> this came out the trial judge dismissed or granted the globe, negations motion to dismiss the charges against. the judge said state law was
9:29 pm
unconstitutional on its face and one of the things the judge said was the privacy rights of the alleged victim in this case from a prosecution setpoint are not hers to command. >> so the name patricia bowman would be known treading forward. more personal details about her life soon unravel. >> when i first heard about the alleged rape i got the feeling that it could have been that it could have been, a young tourist girl first time in palm beach looking for a little bit of a celebrity play and perhaps a little bit of getting money but as it turned out of course, that was totally not the facts that
9:30 pm
patricia bowman was a 29 -year-old single mother from jupiter, florida. compared to the power and fame of that elastic kennedys, a bit player in the big criminal drama. even with her background the nation wanted to know more. back all of who did not know her identity that she would leave her house in the trunk of her car. the 29 -year-old single mother of one of against the kennedy machine. >> while a no trespassing sign was put up in front of the jupiter woman's home the persistent media continued to camp outside her front door. finally, forced patricia to retreat elsewhere. >> there were literally reporters sitting in trees with long-range cameras looking at her house so we decided to put it in the trunk in the garage was down and i open the garage and drove away but they were not going to follow me but did not see patricia in the car.
9:31 pm
>> but as patricia went into hiding willie came forward. >> it's time get your free trial of vaccination.
9:32 pm
this is your invitation to a higher standard of luxury. this is the invitation to lexus sales event. lease the 2019 es 350 for $379 a month for 36 months. now thru march 31st. experience amazing at your lexus dealer. run with us on a john deere 1 series tractor. beacuse changing your attachments, should be as easy as... what about this? changing your plans. yeah. run with us. search "john deere 1 series" for more. ♪ it is such a good time to dance ♪ ♪ it is such a good time to [ laughing ] ♪ scoobidoo doobidoo ♪ scoobidoo doobidoo [ goose honking ] ♪ [ laughing ] a bad day on the road still beats a good one off it. ♪
9:33 pm
progressive helps keep you out there.
9:34 pm
makes you feel like a king! king for a day! well, maybe not the whole day. our 19.99 or 49.99 oil change includes a tire rotation.
9:35 pm
9:36 pm
>> into. >> in the city of the uncommonly rich please think they now have a common criminal, william kennedy smith. laurent was immediately issued for his arrest the please don't plan to track him down. >> we stated to them would give mr. smith a reasonable amount of time to turn himself in. in that reasonable time is determined to be early next week. >> smith was charged thursday with raping a 29 -year-old woman. >> i'm obviously very sad and worried about my family, my future and my friends but i'm
9:37 pm
confident when this thing is resolved often by my original statement that i did not do th this. >> there was also an abundance of news media, never has any georgetown graduation attracted so many publicity. after 46 days of investigating, police release at all. 1300 pages of testimony that your new light on the alleged rape at the kennedy compound. >> as patricia bowman try to keep a low profile from the relentless media willie started to form a strong defense team spirit get back, william kennedy smith was the picture of confidence as he entered the courtroom for 11, smiling to observers and the press. >> i am not guilty, your honor. if convicted, he faces a maximum sentence of 4.5 years in prison with probation is more likely to. >> this guy had a good
9:38 pm
defensive. roy black was the best, defense lawyer in miami. soon as he signed on to renew this would be a tough case for the prosecution because they were up against the man. >> he combines all the skills of your needs and wonderful with people. very likable. jurors like him. >> roy black, 46, was known in miami legal circles as the professor, taking on all challenges and challengers. >> while the defense attorney herbert jack muller who helped ted kennedy in the chappaquiddick affair was originally assigned to this kennedy spectacle roy was matched with former chief of the kernel division of the us attorney's office of miami, ma mark. >> roy black a lot of people working for him. it was more an eye on the other side. >> thirty-seven -year-old lashed with the no's feels prosecuting attorney, veteran of sexual assault education and some call her a goody-goody for an all catholic girl school.
9:39 pm
>> if we could con and other attorney into helping us, we do that but roy black had a big staff working for him. he could afford to get background information on every witness and he could -- he had a lot more power to get the investigation done than we did. >> and so, roy did. he hired five private investigators, including patrick mckenna, one of the masterminds behind oj and casey anthony acquittals. they not only dug up dirt on the alleged victim which included information about cocaine and her three abortions. >> were not here to embarrass everybody but we are to seek the truth and if the truth is embarrassing and embarrassing it may be but it will come out in this courtroom. >> [inaudible]
9:40 pm
>> i do not think the trial of abortion should never be allowed to be used by a defense attorney to question the credibility of a witness because it be prejudicial. >> on her friend, anne mercer, patricia telephone to pick her up from the kennedy compound. >> if william kennedy smith was sitting here right now what would you say to him connect. >> i probably spit in his face. >> on the trial was set to begin on august 5, smith defense attorneys while the 68 page motion to delay the rape trial for at least 90 days. due to sensational publicity a and, in black's words, complete insensitivity by the prosecution's release of three women's accounts of past sexual attacks by smith without the defenses retaliation. >> now three more women have come forward. prosecutors hoping these witnesses to testify against smith at his trial to prove he
9:41 pm
has a history of violent attacks on women but she did not have to release the documents to the public and some attorneys say she's only trying to sway opinion against smith and could make it more difficult to give him a fair trial. >> while these other allegations were known to the public debate about whether they were able to testify was still unknown. >> alas, the trial judge permitted the delay allowing the defense more time to prepare. >> more time passes from the event of issue and the more it helps the defendant, passion school, memories fade and everything that delays the trial, generally helps the defendant. >> roy black is a good pr guy. they made william kennedy look like he was your average joe not from a political family or wealthy family but just an average guy and had a picture of him with his dog. >> william kennedy smith, renamed from his actual name that he went by willie with this unfortunate sexual juvenile
9:42 pm
connotation renamed by the defense as either will or william for the trial. >> one more information was being leaked up patricia the entire family was on their best behavior. >> i'm the one in charge. i'm the one on trial. it is difficult sometimes not to feel like my family is on trial for me and in some strange way, i'm a trial for my family. >> there were no limousines or chauffeurs just a better 1989 mercury station wagon and low-key evenings. other than the courthouse the only other appearances the kennedy's were made with the saint edwards roman catholic church. >> we tried to keep it light and really as possible to get minds of the stress of the day. >> throughout the month leading up to the trial several kennedy members, friends and experts gave statements favoring willy's
9:43 pm
character. cat bennett, willie's cancer stricken jury selection expert, arrives on november 4th announcing her she put off her chemotherapy to help an innocent man. willy's aunt and founder of special olympics also spoke out on his behalf. >> he has the same loyalty from his cousins, 30 of which are coming down here to stay with him. >> on november 14 during jury selection smith's uncle, showed up to give more support. >> my personal feeling is he's a fine young man and always thought he had a affable personality and i'm happy to be here associated with him in his defense. >> is replaced smith's mother in court. she traveling overseas listening to potential jurors as they discuss the personal opinions of smith's guilt or innocence spirit william smith has been subject to unfair publicity and i also feel that if he were not
9:44 pm
a member of the kennedy family all this would never have happened. >> uncle ted kennedy was already here and cousin john junior made an appearance, though at least one gossip editor said mom, jackie onassis, had other ideas. >> jackie had told jfk junior, stay away from smith, willy smith and left keep ourselves separated from the scandal. >> there was no one here in palm beach who is not hurt the explosive and damning relations against them which light reflection will be a long labor is process that may last for weeks. >> [inaudible] spinner in court, he helped his lawyer roy black choose those who judged him. how's life was the first up and look like she did not even want to be there. [inaudible]
9:45 pm
>> i did read articles in the newspaper because it was in the news almost every day. i may have thought maybe it's another kennedy scandal. >> i think it was -- i think the fact -- they are very smart but when they get horny they [bleep] takes over in their brain closes. >> roy not only how to do to get the nation to fall for smith but the judge. >> she would stop the trial. whatever they were doing and welcome them to the courtroom and i see sargent shriver is here and she made a big deal out of the presence of the kennedys. >> article is entitled south florida's toughest judges and says judge is one of the ten toughest but tough can be fair
9:46 pm
quoting now the article says judge is known for trying to reason with defendants and that she doesn't necessarily inflict the maximum punishment and that she is hard on defendants and lawyers but there is a heart underneath that tough exterior. >> would you like to withdraw -- >> meanwhile, previously asked for a new judge saying she does not like a negative facial question. >> prosecutors they are tone of voice is different which addresses them. in documents filed with the court they charged negative facial expressions of the judge sewing cheese prejudice. >> from what i say a trial would be fair and people will be chicken?! chicken. chicken! that's right, candace-- new chicken creations from starkist. buffalo style chicken in a pouch-- bold choice, charlie!
9:47 pm
just tear, eat... mmmmm. and go! try all of my chicken creations! chicken! it's nice. ♪ you got this! ♪ woo! ♪ ♪ ♪ woman: ahh! need a change of scenery? kayak searches hundreds of travel sites and lets you see how your baggage will affect the cost of your flight,
9:48 pm
so you can be confident you're getting the right flight at the best price. kayak. search one and done.
9:49 pm
9:50 pm
♪ ♪ >> the president, i can report to the nation, aggression is defeated in the war is over. [cheering and applause] >> what else is going on in 1991? anita hill comes forward to make her accusations against clarence thomas. >> it says he likes to discuss pacific sex acts and frequency of sex. >> if someone wanted to block me
9:51 pm
because they don't like the conversation of the court, that is fine. but to destroy me, a senator, i would have preferred an assassin's bullet. >> while ted kennedy already had one sexual allegation to addre address. >> expanding those opportunities right now he had two. >> senator kennedy who sat on the judiciary committee the liberal voice on the judiciary was conspicuously silent. he would not say a word and would not champion anita hill's allegations against clarence thomas. why? because he knew anything he said on the subject would immediately raise questions about his own conduct, not just going back to chappaquiddick but what had taken place in palm beach. >> i want to make it clear. >> on the number seven nation
9:52 pm
received more striking news. >> [inaudible] >> even with the breaking news, traffic circulating throughout 1991, trial of william kennedy smith was still one of the most watched television dramas of the year. >> sometimes look more like a ballgame than a news event in the star for business hotel the former is the smith child could be the equivalent of the super bowl. >> many of the crews are renting space in a church parking lot across the street from the courthouse. >> twenty dollars a day and $100 week for the trucks for microwave issues back heavy demand, i guess. >> the style was perfect for tv, of course. it had sex, privilege, power, the kennedys.
9:53 pm
>> 150 media passes are being issued and all will be spoken for. one goes to playboy magazine. >> why is playboy interested in the story? >> same reason everyone else's. the issues involved are compelling and we want to see how they play out. >> the trial itself was fascinating because we were witnessing the birth of a new phenomenon which was the televised criminal trial of a very prominent person. >> i've got to believe the family was used to the media attention, the whole scheme came to the events with an acquittal in mind and i never saw any waiver of competence. >> even though the kennedys were used to the media attention even roy black but allowing television in the courtroom would turn the trial into a hollywood style mockery of the justice system. >> here at bradley's, popular bar they're planning a pretrial look-alike contest for the night
9:54 pm
before opening arguments begin december 2nd. palm beach, or even a rape trial is an excuse to party. >> the national attention did not shield patricia's privacy like she wanted to before the trial he contacted me and i have done work in florida on behalf of crime victims and particularly issues concerning their privacy in dealing with the media. >> they depicted bowman as a scarlet woman, card party girl who cannot hold down a job and blew her to spend on champagne. >> national centers for become a crime did a survey that was well done by dean kilpatrick and her colleagues in that study started out with 4000 women and ended up identified over 700 rape victims. they said quite conclusively the victim said they were more worried about the newspapers and tv publishing the name, people finding out about the case then they were about contracting a --
9:55 pm
>> the media make claims it would feed into the already feverish national case and hope to win the trial by tablet. >> president of the media affects the trial. this is their 15 minutes of fame and want to do the right thing but they also want to be liked by community and will come back to the community. >> with the legend victims face is covered with a blue dot. >> when i cross-examine someone to see how they react to my question so i don't think the public was given the ability to public was given the ability to make a decision about her when we started our business
9:56 pm
9:57 pm
9:58 pm
we were paying an arm and a leg for postage. i remember setting up shipstation. one or two clicks and everything was up and running. i was printing out labels and saving money. shipstation saves us so much time. it makes it really easy and seamless. pick an order, print everything you need, slap the label onto the box, and it's ready to go. our costs for shipping were cut in half. just like that. shipstation. the #1 choice of online sellers. go to and get 2 months free.
9:59 pm
makes you feel like a king! king for a day! well, maybe not the whole day. our 19.99 or 49.99 oil change includes a tire rotation. the death penalty? >> on the next episode of scandalous, the trial of william kennedy starts. >> what about the other woman? >> this was a famous prominent person, unknown person. >> i don't think she would have done there with this if she knew what harassment everyone was
10:00 pm
going to go through. >> good afternoon. greg: when a massacre like the one in new zealand occurs, it's tempting to opine, but we're going to leave that to others. we do know that evil exists, and it's often hard to stop it. the vile terrorist left behind a manifesto, but his twisted beliefs only exist to mess with us. his views veer all over the place. he hates immigration, but he loves the environment. he hates diversity and individuality. he's an eco-fascist, a green nationalist. when you think about it, he's nothing. so as usual, his name shall never be mentioned here. but the point worth noting is this: he wished through his violent act to create a civil war here. the terrorism was meant to foment unrest and conflict.


info Stream Only

Uploaded by TV Archive on