Skip to main content

tv   Hardball With Chris Matthews  MSNBC  June 27, 2012 4:00pm-5:00pm PDT

4:00 pm
schemes, we must all be against. i don't care how you vote but i care you have the right to vote. with no games. this is what people gave their lives for. we cannot let it be turned around now. thank you for watching. i'm al sharpton. "hardball" starts right now.ç fast, furious and fiction. let's play "hardball." good evening. i'm chris matthews in washington. let me start with a shocker. you know the story of how u.s. government agents allowed guns to go to the drug cartel? the story for issa, the nra, and the entire american right?
4:01 pm
well, according to a new report from "fortune" magazine, not the nation or "the new york times," "fortune," it didn't happen. the u.s. government never used a tactic of letting the guns reach the bad guys in mexico. it just didn't happen. which raises the bigger question. if it didn't happen why is eric holder and the obama administration failed to kill the story? didn't they learn from the charges against john kerry if you don't knock down a story, it knocks you down. our guests tonight are matt miller former spokesman for the department of justice and msnbc political analyst david corn. help me out here. how did i and so many of our viewers and so many people in the country believe for the last 18 months that the united states government was so risk-prone that they sent guns allowed guns to fall into the hands of the bad guys in mexico, cartel people, and as a tactic that somehow tracked them down. according to "fortune," having interviewed a bunch of agents aç atf, that never happened. >> i think there are two things. first, the department of justice is trying to conduct its
4:02 pm
investigation in a responsible manner in the way the departments of justice typically do. they interview the people and it takes a long time. a.g. appointed the -- asked the inspector general to start investigating this in february of last year. that is still ongoing. >> last year. >> february of last year. still ongoing. >> does eric holder know there is an election being held and this is one of the issues? >> department of justice does not take those things into consideration. for better or worse. what happens is the inspector general's investigating and that takes time. the other thing is -- >> okay. i don't like that answer. okay? >> i can tell. >> 18 months of -- messing around. "fortune" magazine blockbuster says darrell issa's investigation is built on lies. it reads there's a fundamental miskongs at the heart of the fast and furious scandal. nobody disputes that suspected straw purchases under surveillance by the atf bought guns and eventually fell into criminal hands. issa and others charge that the atf intentionally allowed guns
4:03 pm
to walk, to walk, operational tactic. five law enforcement agents directly involved in the fast and furious effort, tell "fortune" the atf had no such tactic. they insist they never purposely allowed guns to be illegally trafficked. the opposite. they say they seized weapons wherever they could and were ham strung by weak laws which stymied them at every turn. now this isç part of the malary about this. the second amendment fanatics out there say you can't stop trafficking and even semiautomatic weapons going to drug dealers. you can't do it. david, get in here. let me get your take on this. how did we believe for 18 months the atf was stupid enough to go to the drug dealers? >> to begin with there's nothing nuttier than gun politics. democrats run to the hill s when gun -- when issues of -- involving guns come into the political debate. also, atf is a dysfunctional agency. i don't say it the way issa says it. i say it because it's always the target of conservative attacks. this agency, which is supposed
4:04 pm
to do something about guns going into mexico, is hampered by budgetary restrictions, placed on it by republicans who are doing the bidding of nra which hates this agency. so this is the only law enforcement age soy the books that's despised and targeted again and again by the right conservative republicans and thus throws everything out of kilter. you go after the atf, justice department does not how to respond. gun politics puts the white house on the defensive. and we don't talk about the policy issues and we get lost in this -- >> let's get back to the focus here. did the united states government ever let guns move down into mexico and into the cartel and eventually allow people to get killed as a way of tracking those cartels? did they ever do that? >> yeah, they did. one of the things that came out -- >> they did allow them to dot it. >> yeah. >> the "fortune" magazine article is wrong. >> well, no. it appears inç the "fortune" magazine article, it didn't happen in fast and furious.
4:05 pm
happened in several other operations. one that started under the bush administration. wide receiver that darrell issa never talks about. and then happened another smaller operation. >> but it didn't happen under the watch of holder. >> happened in a smaller operation. i don't know if we know if the guns made it to mexico or not. >> did it happen under holders watch or obama's watch? >> there was one story that say it was by one of the whistle blowers. dodson. that's right. >> clarify this to me. no one charged the united states government went out and bought guns and gave them to the straw buyers and allowed them to go into mexico, did they? did anybody charge that? >> issa has. >> you say we paid for the guns? >> i don't know if he says -- his charges have shifted many times. many of the republicans on the hill said that we have paid for the guns or u.s. taxpayers were -- funds were used. other times said that they let all the guns walk. you have to remember where this comes from. this is -- conspiracy theory on the right that the administration did this intentionally to drum up support for gun control. >> that's crazy. >> of course it is.
4:06 pm
but people believe it. darrell issa said it again. >> i like to get the facts first, analis and then the opinion. did the united states government in fast and furious, the campaign being held run by this administration, did they allow guns to go into mexico and could have been used to kill people? >> according to "fortune" magazine piece, no. the inspector general has not yet finished the report p.m. >> when do you think he'll finish the report? >> the next few months. >> has been going on since 2011ç >> that's right. jeesh. you think that's okay? >> i think that's how long it takes to do the reports. if you look at -- >> two seconds to make a charge and year and a half -- >> that's the problem. >> darrell issa knows that. and he has been going after the administration at -- every which way he can. the thing is he's mad -- >> how about innocent until proven guilty? saying we don't know that's true. allow it to look like it might
4:07 pm
be true. why didn't they just deny it. >> they did early. then they found conflicting allegations. some people in the atf that said it happened and others that didn't. >> some people in the atf and united states government under this administration, under its campaign of fast and furious, they were sending guns into mexico hoping to somehow trap -- by the way -- i don't know how that traps anybody. >> that's right. >> illegal to buy guns in this country. nra and darrell issa are working together on this and say the fast and furious operation is a white house conspiracy to crack down on gun rights here in the u.s. here is issa on fox in december. let's listen. >> very clearly, they made a crisis and they are using this crisis to somehow take away or limit people's second amendment rights. >> absolutely pandering there. crazy pandering. conspiracy theory cooked up by issa and nra so far-fetched that stephen colbert laid bare the insanity with this explanati explanation. let's listen.
4:08 pm
>> very clearly, they made a crisis and they are using this crisis to somehow take away or limit people's second amendmwnt rights. >> yes. very clearly. obama started this gun tracking program in 2006 when he hypnotized george bush. then he secretly ordered holder to order the justice department to order the atf to order the gun shops to sell guns to the mexican drug cartels and then lose track of them. panicking americans to get support the draconian gun control measures that obama has never introduced. >> can't say it better myself. house speaker boehner won't support this conspiracy nut case stuff. he was asked for evidence that fast and furious was all a plot to create a gun control initiative here in the states. let's listen. >> i have never indicated that that was the case. i don't know whether that's the case because we don't have the documents. >> you know, you are laughing because you think it is funny. here is a guy -- sane
4:09 pm
conservative, boehner, having to deal with people who are not. >> at the same time he won't shoot it down. he says i don't know -- >> he will be defeated if he does. >> of course. the big issue here is that they say that they are upset that the u.s. government sent guns to mexico. actually, the problem was there are lots of guns going to mexico. this isn't a ginned up crisis. it is a tremendous crisis. tens of thousands of guns a year, not hundreds of thousands, are flowing from the united states to mexico, arming the drug cartels there and killing sometimes americans in the border regions but it is a ç tremendous -- it is legal because the republicans and nra prevent any laws or regulations from going to -- >> let me explain this. what i have been able to read from the "fortune" piece, you can go to phoenix right now. there are over 800 gun shops that legally sell semiautomatic guns down there. any kid 18 years old can walk into the store, buy 20 of them.
4:10 pm
walk down the street and sell them to somebody going to mexico working important the cartel. all legal. if you held the gun for five minutes you are allowed to own it and then sell it five minutes later, all legally. semiautomatic weapons go right down to the cartels. >> that's right. when the administration proposed to illustrate how crazy things have gotten, when they proposed that just the sale of those guns be tracked, someone went in and bought multiple assault rifles -- >> discount. >> that's right. the -- nr app went crazy about it. house republicans went crazy about it and voted to block it. then didn't go anywhere in the senate. just the tracking of that was opposed. >> final point. not only is the story not true but apparently fictional that we impact, encouraging guns to go down so we can track them. this conspiracy theory that was all an attempt by the establishment, bad guys in washington, to track down your guns at home, where you have a semiautomatic. the politics of this. it is on display now. david, you start on this. looks like 30-plus democrats in the house of representatives
4:11 pm
will now vote for a criminal charge of criminal contempt of congress against the attorney general and not because they believe in the merits of the case. because the nra listed this as one of those votes that decidesç whether you are pro or against guns. >> yeah. as you know, there are a bunch of democrats who support gun rights, more importantly, are scared of the nra back in -- >> west virginia, utah. places like that. >> for good reason. here comes the nra saying that this isn't a gun rights issue but they are going to make it a gun right issue so that democrats are going to be put in a box and it is going to give some form of bipartisan cover so tomorrow darrell issa will be -- bipartisan effort against eric holder. >> there are a lot of democrats in the nra. this is a partisan move. this is to help the republicans. is not help the gun owners. i'm saying it to the nra. you are working for the republicans now and you are not supposed to do that. thank you, matt miller. >> thank you. >> complicated case here. tell them to move their asses over there. david corn.
4:12 pm
thank you. three strikes and you're out. strike one was the supreme court stopping the 2000 recount in there. strike two was citizens united that said corporate fat cats can spend all they want on political campaigns. could strike three be killing the historic obama health care bill? that's coming up tomorrow. obama campaign smells blood on bain. they are calling romney the outsourcer in chief. it seems to be working. one thing for sure, romney hates it. what's more interesting, what more entertaining than watching a birther run for congress? two of them running against each other. the battle of the birthers coming up on the sideshow. up next, remembering nora ephron who wrote the screen play of our lives and knew more about how we lived than most politicians will ever know. rob reiner will join us. this is "hardball," the place 1 for politics.
4:13 pm
recently, students from 31 countries took part in a science test. the top academic performers surprised some people. so did the country that came in 17th place. let's raise the bar and elevate our academic standards. let's do what's best for our students-by investing in our teachers. let's solve this. president obama has a slim lead in several stales of mitt romney. time to check the "hardball"
4:14 pm
score board. in ohio obama is up by nine points over his likely republican challenger. 47-38. similar story in florida with president obama with a lead by four. the lead increased since early may. in pennsylvania, it has gotten slighter tighter. obama up by six in the keystone state. 45-39. down from eight last month.ç we'll be right back. not in this economy. we also have zero free time, and my dad moving in. so we went to fidelity. we looked at our family's goals and some ways to help us get there. they helped me fix my economy, the one in my house.
4:15 pm
now they're managing my investments for me. and with fidelity, getting back on track was easier than i thought. call or come in today to take control of your personal economy. get one-on-one help from america's retirement leader.
4:16 pm
welcome back to "hardball." nora ephron was the woman that wrote hit movies including "you've got mail" and "sleepless in seattle." finding humor in love in the lives of regular people. nora passed away last night after battling leukemia. she left behind classic lines and terrific moments in movies like this one. in 1989's "when harry met sally." >> just that all men are sure it never happened to them and women at one time or another have done it before. you do the math. >> you don't think i can tell
4:17 pm
the difference? >> yes! yes! yes! oh! oh! oh! oh, god! oh. >> i'll have what she's having. >> here to remember, rob reiner. a friend of çnora's. he directed that movie "when harry met sally." with me is joan walsh who called me or e-mailed me at dawn today. she wanted to talk about this, my buddy. i know why you did. rob, it is great to have you on, even on this side. any night to have you. you directed that film. i have to tell you, i don't think there are many movies i can think of -- maybe besides "casablanca" people talk about all the time as having gotten them. connected with them. >> yeah. no. i mean, it is -- it was so sad. i mean, i -- i had a really hard night last night. i was -- hard for me to sleep. so shocking for me to find out
4:18 pm
what happened to nora. but she, you know, she touched us all. i mean, you know, she made all of our lives richer and i'm going to miss her terribly. i mean, i will miss the times i spent, you know, having dinners with her and at her house. and with her and nick and -- it is really, really sad. i mean, she really brought a lot of joy to everybody who she touched. not just through her films. if you had the fortune to have dinner with her, i mean, it was always the best. and just like in the film "when harry met sally," she had a way of -- she made you eat what she wanted you to have. if you were at a restaurant she made you order. you order this. have you this. she just basically orchestrated your life for you. it was -- she was such a -- she was so much fun. >> that was your mom that said i will have what she's having, right? >> that's my mother, yeah, that's my mother. that scene -- that scene was -- nora's idea.ç the idea of the woman faking an
4:19 pm
orgasm which she said -- i said nora, i need something where there's going to be something that men don't know about women. she said, well, you know, most women faked an orgasm at one time or another. i said no, that's not possible. and so we did a little survey around the office and found out that that was true. and so that became the basis of that scene. that last line there, that's my mother delivering the last line which is considered now one of the great lines in american film. >> mrs. carl reiner, who can forget sally's incredible ordering skills. same film. let's watch it. >> hi. what can i get you? >> i will have the number three. >> i would like the chef's salad with the oil and vinegar on the side and apple pie ala mode. >> i would like the pie heated. i would like the ice cream on the side. i'd like strawberries if you have it. if not, whipped cream but only if it's real. out of the can.
4:20 pm
if not, nothing. >> not the pie. >> no, i will have the pie. heated. >> uh-huh. >> what? >> i don't know. i worked at restaurants. i don't want her as a client. anyway, joan, your thoughts about this because i'm thinking about single women, divorced people, people who are still dating and later years people who have had memories that never go away in this area of male-female relations or whatever these days.ç this is male-female we are talking about. your thoughts? >> right. she was brilliant about it, chris. she was brilliant about it and really brought a feminist sensibility to screwball comedy. she gave us female characters with who with rich complexity, maddening and annoying and confused and the men are confused too. we are equals in this realm in nora's movie, equally crazy sometimes. and i think she brought a lot of comfort to women. women and men.
4:21 pm
you can be traveling, all of us traveling. i found myself in a -- in a strange hotel and there is "sleepless in seattle." there is "you've got mail" or "when harry met sally." soundtrack to our lives. it is comforting. you remember it. you remember them as funny and they are funnier the second or third or fourth time you see them. you know, it is a tremendous loss for women. >> i think that she was more connected to us than most politicians. 1998 "you've got mail." tom hanks and meg ryan. then she met the guy. let's watch. >> kathleen kelly. hello. this is a coincidence. would you mind if i sat down? >> yes, yes, i would, actually. i'm expecting someone. thanks. >> "pride & prejudice." i bet you read that book every year. i bet you just love that mr. darcy and sentiment beats wildly
4:22 pm
to the thought that he and -- ç whatever her name is, truly, honestly going to end up together. >> can i get you something? >> no, no, he's not staying. >> decaf. >> no, no. you are not staying. >> you know, this is about the -- this is for the even younger than me. younger than you, rob. this is people who are dating over e-mail. and getting to know each other. she finds out that the guy she hates is the guy she loves because she hates him in literal life and loves him in e-mail and meets him and decides ultimately after two hours she does like this guy. >> yeah. she had a wonderful way of observation. she just was the -- greatest observer of this awkward dance that men and women do with each other. she had -- she was able to tap into herself. she was able to observe others
4:23 pm
and she expressed, as joan points out, for all of us, what we all went through. that's why she was so good. she made us see ourselves in ways that we knew were exactly true and she had the wonderful curvy way of expressing it. >> you know, i was thinking, joan, you know, about connection. and here we are watching pictures of her with all these people. i want to you make one final thought. i want on show a scene from "sleepless in seattle" which -- certainly got to be -- everybody else that watched. i have a comment about this at the end of the show tonight about the timelessness of these stories, how cary grant and deborah carr can have the same ç scene that tom hanks has 50 years later with meg ryan and nothing has changed. it is as fresh in the morning and will prove it again in a minimum. here is your final eulogy. why is a single woman, woman of great brains and great poise and beauty, like yourself in fact, yourself, why is -- why is this writer so important we just lost? nora ephron. >> because i think she really
4:24 pm
did show us who we are and also reassure us it all turns out well in the end. there's always a happy ending. and she lets you embrace all of your own neuroses and inconsistencies and reassures women that they are beautiful the way they are. world is complicated. and that they can have fun. she made feminism fun. women -- we can care about equal pay and also care about our love lives. we are complex people. i think she really brought that out into american culture in a way that i don't think i had seen before. >> okay. i'm not sure heartburn had a happy end. i'll have to see it again. thank you. rob reiner, my friend. good luck with your political work this year. joan walsh. we will be right back. >> it is you. >> it is me. >> i saw you in the street. >> are you annie? >> yes.
4:25 pm
>> we better go.ç shall we? down here, folks measure commitment
4:26 pm
by what's getting done. the twenty billion dollars bp committed has helped fund economic and environmental recovery. long-term, bp's made a five hundred million dollar commitment to support scientists studying the environment. and the gulf is open for business - the beaches are beautiful, the seafood is delicious. last year, many areas even reported record tourism seasons. the progress continues... but that doesn't mean our job is done. we're still committed to seeing this through. if someone took mid-sized sedans and broke the mold? if we took our best-selling altima back to its essence, kept its dna, then reimagined nearly everything in it? ♪ gave it greater horsepower... ♪ ...and a lighter and stronger body... ♪ ...advanced headlight technologies for greater visibility... ♪
4:27 pm
...and zero gravity seats that reduce fatigue? ♪ yeah, that would be cool. introducing the completely reimagined nissan altima... ♪ ...with best in class 38 mpg highway and better acceleration than camry and accord. it's our most innovative altima ever. nissan. innovation that excites. ♪ ♪ ♪ [ male announcer ] we believe you're at your best when you can relax and be yourself. and at thousands of newly refreshed holiday inn hotels, you always can. holiday inn. stay you. and now stay rewarded with vacation pay. stay two weekend nights and get a $75 prepaid card.
4:28 pm
back to "hardball." we are in the sideshow. mitt romney has been racking up facebook fans the past month. is the uptick in social media all important the best? you asked jimmy fallon. >> let's take a look at the pros and cons of mitt romney being on facebook.
4:29 pm
pro, change his status every five minutes. con, mostly on his side of political views. pro, football pages have a like button. con, romney's facebook page has oh, you like that? i like that, too. pro, romney's latest status is hopping in the car for a road trip. con, his dolg's latest facebook status is noooo! >> romney's been gaining fans but is still way behind. 2 million fans on romney on facebook. 27 million for obama. the immigration status of anyone they detain or arrest if they ç have a reasonable suspicion they are in the country illegally. the illinois congressman unleashed on that remaining portion today with props in tow.
4:30 pm
>> justin bieber and selena gomez are apparently a happy couple. i'm sure justin helped gomez learn all about american customs and feel more at home in her adopted country. oh, wait a minute. i'm sorry. because i'm not a trained arizona official. i got that backwards. miss gomez of texas has helped mr. bieber of canada learn about his adopted country. justin, when you perform in phoenix, remember to bring your papers. >> pretty smart move there by gutierrez. he was criticized when jan brewer calls the heart of the law. here's a question. what's worse than having a birther running for congress? how about two birthers running against each other. that's what's happening in north carolina, a republican primary. here is one of the candidates. mark meadows at a tea party rally earlier this month. >> what we are going to do is take back our country 2012 is the time that we are going to send mr. obama home to kenya or wherever it is.
4:31 pm
we're going to do it. >> what a loser. doesn't end there. here's meadows' opponent, vance patterson. responding to a question on the president's citizenship days after that rally. >> i know you are concerned and i'm conse 91"ujjy i hate the thought it would be led by somebody who is not an american. there's something there that's not right. yes, he's produced a birth certificate. it is not the one that i have got. and that most of us here in the room have as far as proving our origin. >> i see it as if we do our job from a grassroots standpoint, we won't have to worry about it. you know what? we will send him back home to kenya or wherever it is. you know. we will send him back home. >> dancing pander bears. here's the kicker. when asked the comments during roll call yesterday, meadows said i think it is a non issue. obviously bringing it back is probably a poor choice of words on my part.
4:32 pm
more than anything else. i believe he's an american citizen and i believe that in my district, he is going to lose overwhelmingly. i don't know when what it means. opponent patterson was also in the backpacking or backing up mood there on the birther remark. standard procedure, you suppose, by now. throw it out there for the yahoos and pull it back after someone with a pen and notebook shows up. disgraceful. up next, the supreme court taking up health care in the most conservative -- it's the most conservative since the 1930s. are these justices really out there to dismantle president obama's signature policy achievement? are they going to do it or not? let's find out tomorrow. we will talk about it tonight. what we can look for tomorrow. you're watching "hardball," the place for politics. to our economy, delivering mail, medicine and packages. yet the house is considering a bill to close thousands of offices, slash service and layoff over 100,000 workers. the postal service is recording financial losses, but not for reasons you might think. the problem ? a burden no other agency or company bears. a 2006 law that drains $5 billion a year
4:33 pm
from post office revenue while the postal service is forced to overpay billions more into federal accounts. house bill 2309 is not the answer. at liberty mutual, we know how much you count on your car, and how much the people in your life count on you. that's why we offer accident forgiveness, where your price won't increase due to your first accident. we also offer a hassle-free lifetime repair guarantee, where the repairs made on your car are guaranteed for life, or they're on us. these are just two of the valuable features you can expect from liberty mutual. plus, when you insure both your home and car with us, it could save you time and money. at liberty mutual, we help you move on with your life, so get the insurance responsible drivers like you deserve. call us at...
4:34 pm
or visit your local liberty mutual office, where an agent can help you find the policy that's right for you. liberty mutual insurance, responsibility -- what's your policy?
4:35 pm
hey, there. here's what's happening.
4:36 pm
president obama will travel to colorado tomorrow to survey wildfire damage. the blaze burning in colorado springs now covers about 24 square miles. dozens of homes have burned. and more than 30,000 people have evacuated. studies show it helps users lose 3% of body wiegt. and congressional leaders have reached an agreement on student loans and highway bill. back to "hardball." welcome back to "hardball." tomorrow will be a dramatic day in washington and across the country when the supreme court releases its decision on the fate of the president's signature legislative achievement. affordable care act. will the justice uphold it? will they throw it out? will they gut it by taking away key provisions the individual mandate? tomorrow's decision will have
4:37 pm
major implications for millions of americans and they could be a turn point. we all know that in this presidential election. it will also be a milestone for chief justice roberts. presides over a partisan court. a court that's moved right certainly in recent years. how much has that -- will that be weighing on him when he considers this case? lawrence tribe has the unique distinction of being able to say he taught both president obama and chief justice roberts. both were students of his at harvard law.ç robert klein, msnbc policy analyst. let me ask you to go at this from separate ways. from the entirely legal question. justice roberts, what are his concerns do you believe, professor prescribe? if he were to be part of a -- 5-4 striking down of this law. >> i you this, chris, it would concern him as it would any good chief justice that the court would appear to be very partisan and politically divided.
4:38 pm
even if all of the justices in very good faith voted their constitutional principles, couldn't blame the country for looking at that. especially after citizens united and bush v. gore. in saying that this is a more political than legal institution. he would want very much to avoid that because that would undermine the well spring of trust that the court commands. the court that's already less trusted than it was just a few years ago. >> let's think about three strikes you're out in the sense of the baseball or law. here is the court that base you cannily interrupted the recount in florida in 2000. i think the best thing we ever got to cover but blew the whistle and said no more counting. it's going to be bush. and then, of course, brought citizensç united and they appre
4:39 pm
ed basically unlimited cash. basically overruling all the reforms of watergate. big, fat money now dominates politics. thanks to this conservative court. if they now do it again, do you think it is going to bring into real question their moral and legal authority in this country? >> i think it will be an -- in this way in particular. these aren't just big controversial rulings. what you named here and particularly citizens united and bush v. gore are major rulings slanted in the same direction towards the same party in which the court helped elect. republicans. right? bush v. gore was decision, decision they have never -- never pled the reasoning to another case. in which they clearly helped tilt the election to george w. bush. people are going to argue which way the round would have gone in florida. but it wasn't allowed to proceed. citizens united, very clear partisan implications where we are seeing this year may be a significant reason that barack obama could lose re-election and what's dangerous about this and the -- health care, of course which would certainly harm obama if it is overturned, what's dangerous about this, one thing for the court to be able to have
4:40 pm
this kind of last word on the constitution and for people to say oh, it's a fair player and we have a abide by that. when they can self-perpetuate ideology on the court by electing people that put into office other people who, you know, believe in these things and that court will in turn help elect those people again, that makes the court partisan player in a way i think people will find ill-legitimate. >> back in the nixon administration, professor tribe, when he was holding in there -- holding on, i should say, proposed an employer mandate.ç which i would argue would be worse than an employee mandate. are you going to hire somebody, give them health care. no one talked about the constitutionality of that proposal at the time. interest didn't seem to be vaguely unconstitutional. >> well, a lot has changed in the years since. there are more justices now who have a very strong belief in states rights and more skeptical about national legislative power. my own sense, all show i don't want to go out too long a limb, my own sense is that six of the
4:41 pm
justices of the current court are likely to vote to uphold this mandate and vote to uphold the expansion of medicaid. i would actually be more surprised if the court strikes it down than if it upholds it. i would expect the chief justice to write an opinion perhaps saying the mandate isn't really a mandate at all. but a choice people have. and either to purchase health insurance or to paw more taxes so that there isn't as much prewriting. it's after all, basically republican idea that they ended up with. and i actually expect the court to uphold the mandate so that the idea that this would be the third strike just may not come to pass. >> you know, one other concern here, ezra, a friend of mine fellow roman catholic said he doesn't want to be the second roger tenney.
4:42 pm
a roman catholic that upheld the slave law before the civil war and was villainized. with full than mandate of the ç american people reflect medical the election of 2008, strike down something like that really does seem radical. my question to you is do you think he suffers that same fear either of those fears that he is just too radically conservative or look that far or doesn't want to go down individually as the guy who struck this thing down? >> it's a big move he would have to take here. i think he takes it seriously. if you look at it from his perspective it looks different. right? the he comes out of conservatism. he has a lot of conservative friends. the way it is pushing in this direction. it's been strong. doesn't want to be a huge betrayal to his side which universally believes he should strike down this mandate, one of their biggest in generations to limit the commerce clause. and significantly, and then -- i think it is important to say this while barack obama came in
4:43 pm
with a significant majority in twagt, conservatives in the republicans that have done a good job in making the bill unpopular, majority of people do think the bill is unconstitutional. i think if he is looking for the idea he would have a certain amount of public support for this, or at least enough expectation without it no longer be seen as radical, i think there has been a good job laying the groundwork. i don't think people would be shocked the way it would create a heavy and counter revolution. >> are you a lawyer? >> i'm not. >> you should be. i think you should be on the court. really. you have a great mind. i love your comps. dead serious. we need more liberal minds like yours on the court.ç thank you professor tribe. honor to have you on. >> thank you. >> thank you. it was an honor to have you on. wishful thinking or brilliant or clairvoyance. the reason for the obama campaign just won't give up on those bain attacks because it is working. wait until you hear what this guy is yelling out. went to "the washington post" today to complain about it. that's romney. he is crying at the door of
4:44 pm
newspapers he won't even read. we'll be right back. comes to mind for me is my high school math teacher, dr. gilmore. i mean he could teach. he was there for us, even if we needed him in college. you could call him, you had his phone number. he was just focused on making sure we were gonna be successful. he would never give up on any of us. you walk into a conventional mattress store, it's really not about you. they say, "well, if you wanted a firm bed you can lie on one of those. we provide the exact individualization that your body needs. wow, that feels really good! once you experience it, there's no going back. hurry in now for our lowest prices of the season. save $300 to $1000 on selected sleep number bed sets. sale ends july 8th. only at the sleep number store, where queen mattresses start at just $699.
4:45 pm
our friend missouri democrat claire mccaskill is answering questions about skipping the convention. here's what she had to say on "morning joe." >> you have to say to people at home which is more important going to a place with a bunch of party honchos and cocktail parties or being at home and talking to them. this has never been a hard call
4:46 pm
for me. everybody is trying to make this a big deal. it is stupid. >> some people suspect mccaskill and several other democrats trying to distance themselves from president obama by missing the convention which is not an ir rational observation. we'll be right back.
4:47 pm
the president from interview: i talk to folks on rope lines and in coffee shops. people who have been out of work. you can tell it wears on them. narrator: he's fought to pull us out of economic crisis for three years. and he still is. president obama's plan keeps taxes down for the middle class, invests in education and asks the wealthy to pay their fair share. mitt romney and his billionaire allies can spend milions to distort the president's words. but they're not interested in rebuilding the middle class. he is. i'm barack obama and i
4:48 pm
this will be hot. we are back. obama campaign's bain attack against mitt romney got a big boost on friday when "the washington post" reported that bain capital was a pioneer investing in firms specializing in outsourcing the american jobs. sending them overseas. latest nbc news "wall street journal" poll shows the attacks seem to be working. having their effect. nationally, 23% say they feel good about romney's experience. while 28% are negative. in swing states, catch these
4:49 pm
-- it's got the romney campaign so concerned they retracted from the washington post. afternoon after a meeting with "the washington post," candidate himself or spokesman for the candidate said we are very confident in our reporting. howard fineman is an msnbc political analyst and director of the huffington post media group. you know, i -- these numbers basically tell me, cynthia, that this populist campaign, that the president's running against big money and big outsourcing and big whatever you want to call it, capitalism, seems to be working. >> well, of course it is working. just because a few affluent democrats didn't like the bain ads doesn't meanç they don't work. they work among people who have had some bad experiences with the manufacturing economy. they work with people who know somebody whose jobs have been
4:50 pm
outsourced. you know, they may not strike folks inside the beltway as particularly fair to mitt romney, but if you don't have a college education, if you're working class, if you're in a swing state that has been hit hard by the loss of manufacturing, yeah. you're interes interesting to know that mitt romney helped to ship jobs overseas. >> is this his way of getting to the working class and his only root to the sea, if you will, because the african-americans feel it's tremendous, anybody would, and hispanics have been beaten up and buffaloed by the other candidate, but in the case of white working class guys who didn't go to college, 31% in the poll, to say, wait a minute, you're thinking of voting for romney, you're thinking of voting for the guy outsourcing our jobs? >> they have been probing along the line here. i think the outsourcing,
4:51 pm
offshoring, call it what you want, taking jobs from here and putting it over there, abroad, is a good way to get at the fears and the passions of the people who you're talking about. >> you and i know -- >> it's one thing to complain about cceos getting big slryes. not every working class person when you talk about manipulation of stocks and all that, it's mystery to them. but when you say they're shutting down the plant down the job and sending the jobs to china or a call center in india or indonesia, they get it. and also, mitt romney has spentd the last couple weeks on the campaign trail talking a tough talk about trade and jobs. he set himself up for this. >> the supreme court, you with a law degree should be head of one of these. one of these international union bosses.
4:52 pm
when the post story ran on friday, romney's response hinged on the new aunlss. this is a fundamentally flaws story that does not differentiate between domestic o outsourcing versus offshoring. as you might imagine, on monday night in boston, here is the president trashing back. >> his advisers tried to clear this up by telling us that there was a difference between outsourcing and offshoring. seriously. you can't make that up. >> well, sijt yeah, here we go again. and obviously, they're trying to draw a distinction. people don't care what you call de. they think jobs going out of the country, they're mad. >> exactly. and that's -- that is whatç th washington post story said happened. these jobs weren't outsourced from kansas to nebraska.
4:53 pm
they were shipped to china. indonesia, and americans understand that. and obama, you know, can be very good about having a little fun at the expense of his rival. it was a very awkward response which meant that they really didn't have any defense. and the president went right back at him. >> could this be -- you bow, i think part of the reason it worked well is everybody here, mitt romney, they're saying how tough he's going to get with china. now the word goes forth he was helping them. >> i think as it happened, they set themselves -- the romney campaign set themselves up for this because of what he's been saying on the campaign trail. i said what is your response going on "hardball." tell me what to say. and they -- their point was that the obama campaign has been doing nothing but negative advertising. that they had only negative -- >> excuse me. >> only negative ads. >> that's what we watched them do all year. did they really say that? >> yes, and i think they're
4:54 pm
right. but i think this is called "hardball." >> are we going to outlaw negative advertising? you're great. thank you, howard. i think an international union presidency awaits you. cynthia, thank you for joining us. >> let me finish with a woman who wrote the screen play of our lives,ç nora ephron. she's great. i brought your stuff. you don't have to do this. yes i do. i want you to keep this. it'd be weird. take care. you too. [ sighs ] so how did it go? he's upset. [ male announcer ] spend less time at gas stations. with best in class fuel economy. it's our most innovative altima ever. ♪
4:55 pm
not in this economy. we also have zero free time, and my dad moving in. so we went to fidelity. we looked at our family's goals and some ways to help us get there. they helped me fix my economy, the one in my house. now they're managing my investments for me. and with fidelity, getting back on track was easier than i thought. call or come in today to take control of your personal economy. get one-on-one help from america's retirement leader.
4:56 pm
focus lolo, focust sanya let's do this i am from baltimore south carolina... bloomington, california... austin, texas... we are all here to represent the country we love this is for everyone back home it's go time. across america, we're all committed to team usa. sleep train's 4th of july sale is ending soon. time is running out to get the hottest deal on a new mattress.
4:57 pm
right now, save on sleep train's most popular posturepedic and beautyrest mattress sets. plus, pay no interest for 36 months on tempur-pedic and serta icomfort. big savings and interest-free financing? these deals aren't just hot... they're explosive! sleep train's 4th of july sale is ending soon. ♪ sleep train ♪ your ticket to a better night's sleep ♪
4:58 pm
let me finish tonight with nora ephron. why? because this is about us. you know, people who have dated, have dealt with the prize, joys, heartbreaks and mysteries of romantic relationships. like screen writer nancy meyers. nora ephron was a master of writing movies about relationships, usualry from the woman's point of view and a deep fascination to men. she wrote about this emotionally treacherous place in which a woman gets asked out on a date and has no idea whether she'll hear from the guy again. guys have another hardship, you take the leap of asking someone out who can shoot you down cold. that can hurt. do you struggle to hold on when you think the relationship is fading? we have all been hurt, buthere's hope and that's what keeps some of you trying. i love "sleepless in seattle" because it's about a story that goes back to the days of carey
4:59 pm
grant and debra karr and stays as fresh as it can be forç tom hanks and meg ryan and will be as fresh for people in the next mille millennium. the belief that there's a jack for every jill is, let's shout it to the religion, is a united religion shared by billions and it's the faith that nora ephron preached. when harry met sally, which our guests and my friend directed so brilliantly and "you've got mail" and "sleepless" we get the good news that comes after the bad news of heart burn. nora gave it to us all, the bad, the ugly, and finally the good. when she wrote about men's obsessions about women pfsz breasts, who wrote movies how how men need to satisfy women. i can't believe we showed that scene here tonight, to nora who told us we're not alone. our relatiops

81 Views

info Stream Only

Uploaded by TV Archive on