tv The Ed Show MSNBC April 9, 2015 2:00pm-3:01pm PDT
president personally asked him questions about solar energy and he told him it's a growing industry and a great opportunity for a stable career path. of his brush with fame and improper choice of at tire he quipped, if i had known it was my commander in chief, i definitely would have been wearing my blues. that's all for now. "the ed show" is up noex. >> good evening, americans. welcome to "the ed show." live from new york. let's get to work. tonight, hillary's issues with the issues. >> everyone who is running for president should be talking about what they plan to do to strengthen and rebuild america's middle class. >> plus new details in the south carolina police-involved shooting. >> what do we want? >> justice. >> i took my phone out and started recording. >> later a drought dilemma. >> water is so precious. >> and wisconsin's anti-climate change crusade. >> the climate change threat real?
good to have you with us tonight, folks. thanks for watching. hillary clinton's reputation or position as the 2016 front-runner might be fading a little bidt. a new poll out today in key swing states doesn't look good for hillary clinton. in iowa, rand paul has polled ahead of hillary clinton by one point. in virginia, she's in good shape. her lead has slipped to four points. in colorado, rand paul has a three-point lead on hillary clinton. if clinton wants to fix these numbers early on she needs to start talking about the issues when it comes to middle class americans and what they care about. hillary clinton, i think, has deliberately remained silent squeezing out the potential of the competition because of the money. but at this point we don't know where hillary clinton stands on the keystone xl pipeline. we don't know where she stands
on the trans-pacific partnership. many people think she's too friendly with wall street. would she really implement it again? we don't know if she would break up the big banks. we don't know if she wants to reinstate glass steagll, and we don't know where she stands on corporations sticking profits offshore so they don't have to pay tax. this is what americans are talking about. clinton also needs to speak out directly about iran. news today that if all the sanctions were not lifted at the same time there was not going to be any deal. pel low. nothing from hillary clinton on today's development. that's par for the course. being silent on the issue is starting to hurt clinton. earlier today, senator elizabeth warren, who seems to be the benchmark as of late as generals didn't sound too excited about a clinton run for the white house. >> hillary clinton could announce any day now that she is going to seek the presidential nomination and presidency in 2016.
do you think she's the future of the democratic party? >> well i think we have to see, first of all, if she declares. and what she says she wants to run on. >> what she wants to run on. that's right. if she declares -- i think she's going to declare. she's hiring people all over the country. senator warren is starting i guess the veting process. she's the first one in the senate to come out and say we don't really know where she stands on a number of different issues. at this point we have no idea wh sh se on a number of different issues. elizabeth warren expressed concerns about her position on trade. >> name me one thing that you would like to see hillary clinton do and say and commit to that she has not committed to. >> well i would like to see her address all of these issues. you know we have a big debate going on right now on trade. within the democratic party. i have real concerns about something called the investor
state dissput resolution that basically would permit multinational companies to sue other countries when they try to put regulations in place to protect their own workers, to protect their own citizens. i think this is a really dangerous provision in a trade deal. >> thank you. it is very dangerous. you know not to put too much pressure on hillary or come off as anti-hillary but the issues are far different from 2008 and 2007. and it's time for hillary clinton, at least when she does announce, and i guess it's going to be pretty soon. that she sets the record straight right away. democrats deserve to know exactly where she stands on the key issues of contemporary time. she needs to start talking about issues like trade. medicare medicaid. social security. minimum wage aren't those all easy lips for any democratic
candidate? eventually clinton is going to have answer the tough questions about the ones shoost been coy about. it's obviously clinton feels no pressure to step out and talk about these things because she's unopposed. she doesn't have to. until she feels the pressure to say something, she probably won't. so it's a run out the clock scenario. this is a late announcement, whenever it's going to be. but elizabeth warren is the person people are listening to. if she has questions on trade and the issues i listened to previously. that means there could be a slit in the democrat ig camp. now liberal groups are pressuring hillary to come out. they're saying we want you to sound like elizabeth warren. can we at least find out where she stands on the keystone xl pipeline. that will take us into a discussion about the environment. get your cell phones out. we'll ask the question in a few
moments. first i want to ask the questions to larry cohen. good to have yo we us tonight. you have spent an enormous amount of time on the tpp and fast track and yet the presumed democratic nominee, hillary clinton, has been ominously silent. can your union, and can you support hillary clinton if she supports tpp? >> i think it would be hard regardless of the party, to support a candidate who supports tpp, as we now know it. obviously still a secret. where just as importantly to support fast track, and we don't know what's in fast track. we need populous politics. we need candidates who say i care about jobs. net jobs. imports. killing jobs in america. not just a few export jobs. that we care about pay and how our pay gets held down.
i think it's essential that she speak out on these issues. >> essential that she speaks out. i'm hearing that in a lot of corners of the country from a number of different groups. so here comes senator elizabeth warren asking these questions. what kind of pressure do you think that puts on hillary clinton? >> i think what senator warren is doing is great for all of us. as she said in the clip you played, we now have 500 cases under the settlement. this is a reality. and cases like petroleum getting $2 billion from ecuador because they want to save the environment. ecuador doesn't have $2 billion. we know the record on isds stinks. it's what it does to the environment in every country. we have one world here. i think it's essential sh speak out on trade. it's one of the few things the president controls. much of the rest is up to the
congress. but the president controls the trade agenda. >> okay. so how important is it if she runs unopposed. i mean there's a real chance that workers this this country might no have total confidence that this is the best of the lot. >> yeah, i think workers in this country will number one, believe money and politics has taken over. few people can raise 1 billion to $2 billion. that's what this election will be. and as a result they don't get to the front end. there's other factors as well. working people are quite concerned it will be about who is worse instead of where is our vision for america? i think senator clinton -- or secretary clinton can rise to that occasion. she needs to do it quickly. we're beginning to believe that it's just about sitting it all out and getting the candidacy regardless. >> okay, larry, good to have you with us tonight. appreciate your time. a major headache could be
senator bernie sanders. the vermont senator has been thinking about a presidential run for some time. he's a much needed voice in the the national debate, as i see it. a new article gives analysis of his run. ted devine said sanders could win by bringing disillusioned tea partyers. that caught my attention. it's a real possibility, they want a lot of the same things that he has been talking about for a long time. . for more let's turn to the senator from vermont. good to have you with us tonight. >> good to be with you. >> you have been very clear on the issues that we have talked about. but now senator warren is questioning hillary clinton for not stepping out. does that change your schedule at all if there's going to be one? >> no it doesn't. look, the american people understand, ed. that something is profoundly wrong when 99% of all new income
generated in the country goes to the top 1%. when we have lost 60,000 factories since 2001 and millions of decent paying jobs. in my view every candidate, not just hillary, but everybody else has got to be clear about what we do to expand the middle class, to tell the wealthy and large corporations that they have got to begin paying their fair share of taxes. how do we create the millions of decent paying jobs we need? >> senator, you have been out and about around the country and all regions of the country. what are people asking you? when you go out to a town hall and they want to talk to bernie sanders, what are they asking? >> well i will tell you, ed. what people are talking about, is how we create the millions of jobs this country desperately
needs. and the reason for that is that real unemployment in america is not 5.5%. it's 11%. they want to know how we raise wages so people are earning $7.25 an hour. they want to know how we're dealing with climate change. and how we reverse climate change by moving to sustainable energy. and there's a lot of interest about trade policies and how we defeat fast track for the tpp. >> what is this analysis that you might get disaffected tea partyers? do you sigh a parallel in that? >> absolutely, ed. look. you have a lot of white working class guys out there. they can't afford to send their kids to college. they don't have any health care. go you think that they really believe in the the republican agenda giving tax breaks to
billionaires and cutting social security medicare and medicaid? they don't. but somebody has to reach out to them and say okay we may disagree on this or that issue. but are you concerned about your kid being able to go to college? are you concerned about having a de decent job. do you want to see your job go to china? we can bring forth a common agenda that brings a number of people into an approach that says enough is enough. the billionaire class can't have it all. >> senator, news today, the iranians are saying the sanctions are going to be have to be lifted across the board if there's going to be a deal. what is your perspective on this? if you were president, if you were making the deposition exhibit, where would you be right now? zbr well i got to say, ed. i think the president and secretary kerry have done a very good job in making it clear that, "a", we want to make sure
that iran does not get a nuclear weapon. but "b", we have to do everything possible to prevent another war in the middle east. i can't not believe i have republican colleagues very nonchalant after the wars in iraq. after the war in afghanistan. yeah, well maybe we'll have a war with iran. disaster. so i applaud with the president is doing. the devil is in the details. i will study them. he and john kerry deserve credit for trying to goeshtd an agreement that prevents iran from getting the bomb and does it in a way without a war. >> from what you know of it would you lift the sanctions across the board to get a deal? >> i don't have all the details, but i think the president is moving in the right direction. as soon as i see the details, i'll be able to give you a better decision. >> thank you, senator bernie sands ers, good to have you with us. get your cell phones out no u. we want to know what you think. do you want bernie sanders to run for president? go to pulse.msnbc.com/ed to cast
your vote. we'll have the results for you in our bing poll right after the break. share your thoughts with us on twitter @edshow. like us on facebook. you can get the video podcast. police in south carolina have released within moments the dash cam video from the walter scott case and we'll bring it to you next. and later, wisconsin's war on words, badger state republicans ban climate change talk just like florida. stay with us. formula penetrates 10 surface cell layers deep and fades the look of dark spots. see bright, pearlescent, healthy- looking skin in just 2 week # # #
the pursuit of healthier. it begins from the second we're born. after all, healthier doesn't happen all by itself. it needs to be earned... every day... using wellness to keep away illness... and believing that a single life can be made better by millions of others. healthier takes somebody who can power modern health care... by connecting every single part of it. for as the world keeps on searching for healthier... we're here to make healthier happen. optum. healthier is here.
we have breaking news at this hour. we have just gotten in the dash cam video from the walter scott case in south carolina. the video does not show any of the shooting. we see officer michael slager speak with walter scott at his car. out of the officer walks back. out it have camera's view walter scott takes off running. from there we can only hear audio. this is the officer in the stop. that was the dash cam. and we can't see anything beyond that once he exits the car and takes off. it's only audio. and there will be certainly no doubt that this is going to be central in the investigation. meantime, this case has broken into the political spectrum. hillary clinton called the incident heartbreaking and too familiar. she says we can do better to rebuild trust, reform the justice system and respect all lives. lindsey graham senator from south carolina called the video
horrific. rand paul, previously called the incident a tragedy. but today on a presidential campaign stop in south carolina he didn't mention walter scott at all. but he did have this critique of the media coverage. >> i do think that sometimes the way we report news we tend to report the news of crime, and so we see a lot of crime. we think it's representative of the whole. and when you look at police across the country, 98 99% of them are doing their job on a day-to-day basis and aren't doing things like this. >> there's no basis of that comment. he doesn't know what percent of police officers do their country and have excellent at it. not to say that most of them aren't. are we not supposed to show this tape? constantly the new media critic on the scene. the nation is still consumed by the cell phone video showing discrepancies between the recorder and the bystander who
got the video. feidin santana explains the shooting. >> there was just the three of us at that moment. like i say, i didn't -- i couldn't tell what was going to happen. >> sarah from nbc news has more. >> as investigators and the public continue to scrutinize cell phone video of the shooting, new details are emerging about the police officer charged with murder. michael slager joined the force six years ago. personnel records show a complaint against him two years ago for improper use of force with a taser. slager was exonerated, but the man who filed the complaint and his attorney spoke about what they call a systematic problem within the police department. >> we believe we're going to uncover other instances of where there have been aggressive behavior. >> investigators and the public scrutinize cell phone video of
the shooting. why does slager appear to retrieve an object near the ground where the shots were fired and drop it near the the body. they believe that object was the taser slager initially used to try to subdue scott. >> he then took that back to where mr. scott's body was and essentially planted the taser directly beside mr. scott's body. >> another troubling question why are no officers seen on video performing cpr when the initial report says they did? >> there are questions that i have in my mind that i can't answer right now. >> no quick or easy answers in a case that's reignited debate over deadly police force. >> joining me tonight, paul henderson, veteran prosecutor and legal analyst. also with us dr. james peterson, director of studies at lee high university and msnbc contributor. gentlemen, good to have you with us tonight. >> thanks for having us ed. >> mr. henderson, i assume you just saw the dash cam video. how do you think this plays into
the the case? >> well i think it shows us that but for the video tape that we received that came outside of official means and came from the community, we still would not have the hard evidence and the facts that show their lies and it goes beyond the lies into perjury where we have claim being made by the officer, that he was struggling that he was in fear, or that anyone else was in fear. so it's going to be helpful and corroborative corroborative. but it doesn't show as much as the first video tape that we all saw from the day before where we witnessed the entire incident playing out from the perspective of a thinker party. >> right now it looks like a routine traffic stop. there's nothing ordinary about it from what the video tape shows. i mean that's my first impression of this. there's been numerous reports about this officer's background mr. henderson.
how does this play into the scenario? >> it's absolutely going to play a significant role on three levels. both in the criminal case, it's going to come in in terms of the bad behavior that's been done by the officer. it's going to come in any civil case and for the same thing to say that the department should have had notice about his bad behavior, and at a third level, it's going to be brought in as part of the analysis if a third party or federal government comes in to review a pattern and practice of behavior from the police department where they will be evaluating how other officers and this officer specifically was land led when there were allegations made against him. so you will see this evidence being useded over and over and over again as we analyze just this incident that took place. and the subsequent accountability. >> you're going to see scott run from the vehicle here in just a moment as the officer has gone back to the police vehicle. we can only assume that he's
running a license plate of the vehicle. mr. henderson, does this video, the video that was recorded there you see scott opening the door. it's not like he's taking off right away. >> right. >> and now he's going back into the car. >> right. >> and this is -- that's important because that shows intent, doesn't it? >> it shows intent. and the thing to focus on is when are you allowed to use justifiable deadly force? and so what you're analyzing is when, if ever do you see the officer in the zone of danger for either himself or of others, which would justify the use of deadly force? that's why i said this video tape will be used corroboratively to show that there is no evidence of that flash point taking place. there's no evidence anywhere of something showing that that officer was either in danger for the -- to justify the use of deadly force, either for himself
or for the public. >> okay. i'm just going to put it in street terms here for just a moment. just folks talking on the street. how in the hell could this police officer not know what has happened over the last year in ferguson, missouri with michael brown, with trayvon martin with the gentleman choked to death in new york city, eric garner. and i mean this looked like a normal traffic stop. what elevated this guy, as you see it dr. peterson, to bring it to the point where he would think that he should unload his pistol on an unarmed man running away from him? i mean don't these -- it would seem to be that every police officer in this country would get the message, don't shoot unarmed people? >> you would think, ed that that would be the case. but at the top of the case you mentioned a routine stop. just from the ways in which
we've had to cover the cases, it seems more and more routine that law enforcement are engaged in the shootings of unarmed civilians. they have a particular script about scuffles and going for the gun or taser and then fearing for their lives. and this story shows us the limitation of dash cams. this is why i'm not a huge fan. the same type of law enforcement who will use deadly force on an unarmeded civilian on the way this officer did is the same kind of officer who might manipulate the cameras or the urn the cameras off. the routine nature that you're talking about, ed i think filters into this entire discussion. law enforcement folk are looking at cases like trayvon martin ta mir rice eric garner and they're siding with law enforcement. they're saying it's tough out there. it's dangerous out there. they have to protect themselves. and this is the narrative that they use every time in these shootings. we were fortunate and this family was blessed to get access so we could have the truth in this particular case, and it explodes the previous narratives. your common sense question is going to continue to go
unanswered. i don't think that law enforcement has gotten wake-up call just jet. i really don't. if you think about these as sit-ins and die-ins and some of the organized ways in which the dream defenders are trying to raise awareness. if you look at their assistance in michael brown's funeral. their attitude their positionalty, they're still defensive. we haven't had the kind of conversations to lead to resolution and rebuilding the public trust with law enforcement. >> and finally, mr. henderson, the discrepancy between the police report and the video tape your thoughts? >> i think it's a real problem. as i said before it goes beyond mere lies. it drifts into an area of perjury, which is real accountability in terms of what this officer was willing to say, and then beyond that what that report shows in terms of how cpr was administered to this individual, to walter scott, who had died. there was no cpr, and we saw that on the video tape. and that's going to speak directly to the analysis and the overview of the pattern and
behavior of that entire area of what police were doing. someone has to sign off on that police report before it gets filed. it will extend beyond the officer under arrest right now. that's the problem. >> james peterson paul henderson, thanks for the conversation tonight. thanks for your time. still ahead, the rapid response panel takes on the gop's climate silence. and next president obama is taking big steps forward in getting good relations with cuba, but not everyone is happy with the progress. stay with us. is impactful?" what the cloud enables is computing to empower cancer researchers. it used to take two weeks to sequence and analyze a genome; with the microsoft cloud we can analyze 100 per day. whatever i can do to help compute a cure for cancer, that's what i'd like to do.
new york state is reinventing how we do business by leading the way on tax cuts. we cut the rates on personal income taxes. we enacted the lowest corporate tax rate since 1968. we eliminated the income tax on manufacturers altogether. with startup-ny, qualified businesses that start, expand or relocate to new york state pay no taxes for 10 years. all to grow our economy and create jobs. see how new york can give your business the opportunity to grow at ny.gov/business
you drop 40 grand on a new set of wheels, then... wham! a minivan t-bones you. guess what: your insurance company will only give you 37-thousand to replace it. "depreciation" they claim. "how can my car depreciate before it's first oil change?" you ask. maybe the better question is why do you have that insurance company? with liberty mutual new car replacement, we'll replace the full value of your car. see car insurance in a whole new light. liberty mutual insurance. there's nothing more romantic than a spontaneous moment. so why pause to take a pill? and why stop what you're doing to find a bathroom? with cialis for daily use, you don't have to plan around either. it's the only daily tablet approved to treat erectile dysfunction so you can be ready anytime the moment is right. plus cialis treats the frustrating urinary symptoms of bph, like needing to go frequently, day or night. tell your doctor about all your medical conditions and medicines, and ask if your heart is healthy enough for sex.
do not take cialis if you take nitrates for chest pain as it may cause an unsafe drop in blood pressure. do not drink alcohol in excess. side effects may include headache, upset stomach, delayed backache or muscle ache. to avoid long-term injury, get medical help right away for an erection lasting more than four hours. if you have any sudden decrease or loss in hearing or vision or any symptoms of an allergic reaction stop taking cialis and get medical help right away. why pause the moment? ask your doctor about cialis for daily use. for a free 30-tablet trial go to cialis.com there's a process involved in reviewing. whether or not a country should be on the state sponsored terrorism list. that review has been completed. our inner agency team will go through the entire thing and
then present it to me. >> he's expected to accept a state department recommendation to remove cuba from the government's list of state sponsors of terrorism. the president is on his way to panama at this hour for a summit of america's meeting, while in panama expecteded to meet with raul castro. not everybody is happy about that. in panama city there have been clashes between proand anti protesters. a new poll shows midwest americans do support better u.s. relations with cuba. the new msnbc telemundo poll shows 16% of latinos approve of diplomatic registration in addition of cuba. but the florida state legislature, they're not on board. the three-page letter says fidel and raul have mistreated cuban citizens since they took over in power in 1959.
anna revis logan joins us tonight. former florida state representative. good to have you with us, anna. >> good to be here. the pulse of this in florida what does this mean that the house is sending a letter to the president. do you think that reflects the mood of the people? >> absolutely not. we've seen what the president is doing. when the president first announced his relations issue with cuba in december 41% of south floridians approved of it. today it's 51%. so people are accepting this we're not talking about the rest of the nation. we know the cuban relations support the president's move on cuba. >> is there much conversation about the state sponsor or testify richl lift. if he takes the recommendation to remove cuba what do you think the reaction will be?
>> well it shouldn't be there. it shouldn't have been there for a while. it was placed on there many many moons ago. it's time they come off. >> so as time goes by momentum seems to be swinging in favor of everything the president is doing with cuba or trying to accomplish. i think the gop members of the florida house haven't gotten the memo. >> so how does this play in the next election? is this going to be a political calculation by say, the rubio crowd? >> well, of course there's always going to be the cuban hard liners that are not going to move on the issue. and they do represent a big part of the primary voters in the gop base. and so there will be a lot of rhetoric of that. i imagine with rubio and several gop primary, you know in the primary. so they're going to be playing to the far right. which is the republican primary. but they're against everything
president obama is doing. >> that is the truth. anna revis logan. good to have you with us tonight. appreciate your time. >> pleasure. >> coming up denial in wisconsin. republicans don't want state workers to talk about. don't talk about it. don't think about it. don't e-mail about it. climate change. rapid response panel weighs in. stay with us. i'm josh lipton with your cnbc market wrap. stocks gain ground. the dow adds 56. the s&p is up nine. earning season is officially under way. they share more than 3% after revenue missed estimates. meanwhile, beth bath and beyond shares slid more than 5%. profits and sales fell short and warned results would mistargets in the furnt quarter. and less than expected increasing 14,000 to 281,000. that's it from cnbc, first in
business worldwide. 268 mph. three times the speed of a fastball. take care of your brain with centrum silver men. multivitamins with 20% more vitamin d. my heart beats 100,000 times a day sending oxygen to my muscles... again! ...so i can lift even the most demanding weights. take care of your heart with centrum silver men. multivitamins for the most important parts of you. audible safety beeping audible safety beeping audible safety beeping
the nissan rogue with safety shield technologies. the only thing left to fear is you imagination. nissan. innovation that excites. ♪ ♪ i love my meta health bars. because when nutritious tastes this delicious i don't miss the other stuff. meta health bars help promote heart health. experience the meta effect with our multi-health wellness line. ♪ ♪ kellogg's® frosted mini-wheats®... have 8 layers of nutritious wheat... and one of delicious sweet. to satisfy the adult.... and kid - in all of us. (supergrass' "alright") plays throughout ♪ ♪ ♪ nutritious wheat for the adult you've grown into. and delicious sweet for the kid you'll never outgrow... feed your inner kidult... with frosted mini wheats®.
and we are back. florida isn't the only state staking its head in the sand when it comes to climate change. now they have joined the ranks of the withfully ignorant. meet matt. he advocated for eliminating his own roll. he also hates environmental people. he's on record. which is bad for the folks in wisconsin. on tuesday adamczyk success pli passed a ban to prevent the board of commissioners of public lands from doing any work involving climate change or discussing climate change or
e-mailing about climate change don't talk about it. well, this will make the board's job of protecting a lot harder no doubt. don't expect governor scott walker to step in hean make this right at all. he's a poster child for r the war on science. in fact, walker has the lead. he's been leading the charge against the the efforts to reduce carbon emissions. walker signed the koch brother's no tax pledge. he tried to slash millions from state subsy died recycling programs. congratulations, wisconsin. a pioneer of anti-worker policies and now going backwards on climate change. joining me now on the rapid response panel, ruth editor in chief of the progressive magazine wisconsin state senator, chris lars on. what is the motivation here?
what is this about? what is the the root of this? >> it's a petty vendetta by the tea party state treasurer who is really pretty out there against the daughter of the great environmentalist. founder of earth day. senator nelson from wisconsin. basically he tried to fire her. he was overruled by the other members of the state land board who defended her. she is an environmentalist. and he's attacking her for serving on a task force that she was appointed to by the former governor, a democrat on climate change and then talking to the timber industry that is concerned about climate change and invited them to speak about how it affects the industry. and so then he's gone further and said she shouldn't be allowed to speak of climate change, to do any work on climate change which she hasn't done since she was asked to do work in her capacity. it's about this petty vendetta. this other piece is just across the country, we see the folks
like the state treasurer, tea party folk who is are really worked up about the idea that there is such a thing as climate change, like making it very expensive to use solar energy. we know he's friends with the koch brothers. he has pushed to make wisconsin a less environmentally friendly state. this mostly originates with one peculiar individual our state treasurer. >> senator larson you just can't raise any money admitting that there's climate change. so walker is not going to be an ally here at all. so this is pretty obviously. so how much is this going to hurt the state? as you see it? >> well in wisconsin, we have timber agriculture and tourism. and they depend on us having a reliable climate. they will be hurt if climate change is not addressed on a
wide scale. so this is going to hurt. and he's trying to bury his head in the sand. walker is trying to do that. other republicans are trying to do. and this is not your grandfather's republican party. this is the regressive era republicans who are denying inging climate change. and not just that. they don't want people talking about this. as hay demand silence, it's important for us to speak up baa it's not just a matter of saving trees or something environmental. it's the future of the history in this state. >> isn't this a form of intimidation of employees, though? telling them they can't think of talk or e-mail or mention climate change at all? what about that, senator? >> absolutely. #. >> absolutely. yeah, and this is -- it's not just -- ruth mentioned how he is trying to fire her since he came in.
and he issued edd dozens of open records request. this may be his close-up on national spotlight. but we know him here. he worked for senator who is in line to be the next president of alec who denied turning over documents to find out what bills they were trying to move forward. he's using the same process to try to silence somebody in our state. it's important fortous speak up on it. there's great foot a 7-year-old calls governor walker to the mat and asks him to questions about climate change. i encourage people to speak up on this. and we need to speak up. >> and what was the response ruth? >> i posted the video on twitter. basically he ignored the 7-year-old. the 7-year-old was bold enough to ask a follow-up question that said do you care about climate change. and walker ignored him and walked away. >> all right. now he says this isn't part of
the board's mission, which is to make money for our beneficiaries. what is your response to that, ruth? >> well part of the board's mission, it's the oldest state agency, is to manage these public forest lands, and the money from their sale. more were sold off 100 years ago. they have about a billion dollars in their trust. not taxpayer funds. but this is publicly owned wealth. they use a loot of it to support public libraries. they also mansioned the lands. and to talk about what is happening to forestland. as the senator points out, the timber industry itself wants to know what to do about climate change. so this is completely within a reasonable per view. to say they should be silenced is preposterous. even the tea party is catching up with that. >> say that again? >> even the tea party is catching up with us. a bunch of people who don't like having it made more expense i have for them to generate their own power is growing across the
country. so the world is moving past all this. >> if it's clean, it shouldn't cost more. no doubt. ruth, good to have you on tonight. thank you. get your last-majority votes in at msnbc.com/ed. we'll have the results for you after the break. still to come a california congressman plays politics to try to keep money flowing to his drought ravaged district. oh, the house majority leader wants a bailout. shopping online... ...is as easy as it gets. wouldn't it be great if hiring plumbers carpenters and even piano tuners...
were just as simple? thanks to angie's list now it is. start shopping online... ...from a list of top rated providers. visit angieslist.com today. okay, listen up! i'm re-workin' the menu. mayo? corn dogs? you are so outta here! aah! [ female announcer ] the complete balanced nutrition of great-tasting ensure. 24 vitamins and minerals antioxidants and 9 grams of protein. [ bottle ] ensure®. nutrition in charge™. ♪ ♪ [ girl ] my mom, she makes underwater fans that are powered by the moon. ♪ ♪ she can print amazing things right from her computer. [ whirring ] [ train whistle blows ] she makes trains that are friends with trees. ♪ ♪ my mom works at ge. ♪ ♪
and here's where we stand on tonight's poll. let's check it out. should the phrase climate change be banned. 100% of you say no. we'll be right back. stay with us. ♪ it's back! xfinity watchathon week. the biggest week in television history. it's your all-access binge-watching pass to tv's hottest shows free with xfinity on demand. xfinity watchathon week. now through april 12th. perfect for people who really love tv. meet the world's newest energy superpower. surprised? in fact, america is now the world's number one natural gas producer... and we could soon become number one in oil. because hydraulic fracturing technology is safely recovering lots more oil and natural gas. supporting millions of new jobs. billions in tax revenue... and a new century of american energy
security. the new energy superpower? it's red, white and blue. log on to learn more. i will take beauty into my own hands. olay regenerist. it regenerates surface cells. new skin is revealed in only 5 days. without drastic measures. stunningly youthful. award-winning skin. from the world's #1. olay your best beautiful jeff... hey, scott! this is no time for lollygaggin', lad. but we love lollygaggin'. we do. but it's a battlefield out there! you know the chickweed is surrounding yer sidewalk and the dandelions are stealing precious nutrients! now's the time to send in the scotts turf builder weed and feed, man! it kills weeds while it feeds and strengthens your grass. that sounds easy. get scotts turf builder weed and feed. it's guaranteed. feed your lawn. feed it! and to clean your outdoor space without harming your grass get scotts new outdoor cleaner plus oxiclean. okay, listen up! i'm re-workin' the menu. mayo? corn dogs? you are so
outta here! aah! [ female announcer ] the complete balanced nutrition of great-tasting ensure. 24 vitamins and minerals antioxidants and 9 grams of protein. [ bottle ] ensure®. nutrition in charge™. why do we do it? why do we spend every waking moment, thinking about people? why are we so committed to keeping you connected? why combine performance with a conscience? why innovate for a future without accidents? why do any of it? why do all of it? because if it matters to you it's everything to us. the xc60 crossover. from volvo. lease the well equiped volvo xc60 today. visit your local volvo showroom for details. all right. two-minute drill. under way at augusta is the masters. 97 players in the field going for the green jacket. jordan spieth is ahead by two
strokes ahead of ernie els. two-time defending champion bubba watson back to defend his title, making a run for a third victory in four years. rory mcilroy is on a quest to complete a career grand slam. he teed off with the masters, par 3 contest yesterday, but he might have been upstaged by his own caddy. what a nice guy. mcilroy brought along one direction pop star niall horan was there to caddy. there's no word whether he'll fill in the former one-directioner on their next gig. stick around. more on "the ed show." we're right back.
keeping a billion customers a year flying means keeping seven billion transactions flowing. and when weather hits, it's data mayhem. but airlines running hp end-to-end solutions are always calm during a storm. so if your business deals with the unexpected hp big data and cloud solutions make sure you always know what's coming-and are ready for it. make it matter. okay, listen up! i'm re-workin' the menu. mayo? corn dogs? you are so outta here! aah! [ female announcer ] the complete balanced nutrition of great-tasting ensure. 24 vitamins and minerals antioxidants and 9 grams of protein. [ bottle ] ensure®. nutrition in charge™.
finally tonight, the story unfolding in the central valley area of california should have the attention of the country. this historic drought in california is now in its third year and it's devastating farms and the economy. house majority leader kevin mccarthy's district is taking a hit. >> there are some cities that have more than 30% unemployment. the number one factor -- water. >> in an exclusive interview with "the hill" congressman mccarthy said it's no longer a
political issue, but has been become a life or death issue. i think he's using the drought as a plasm form to to show he's still in touch. how about some disaster relief? is that what he wants? interesting here is that every time a democrat has a proposal for disaster relief whether it be for a hurricane or a flood, republicans always want to talk about budget offsets, what are we going to cut to make this possible? so the question tonight is how does mccarthy feel about offsets now? is there going to be a big political fight in washington while the people in california suffered? i've spoken to friends out there who are telling me that people are economically suffering right now, and there's no end in sight. congressman john garamendi joins me tonight. good to have you with us. >> hello, ed. >> now that it's hitting the leadership in the house, would the philosophy change somewhat for the role of the federal
government? because if people are losing their farms and their ranches, what is the role of the federal government and our commitment to american citizens? >> certainly the federal government has a major role to play in dealing with this drought. it's not just a california drought, but it's stretching across the entire southern united states all the way to florida. this is a national issue. the federal government has a specific set of opportunities to deal with it. in california without new money, we could focus the existing federal government programs to really augment, to coordinate and to really cause the california bond act, which passed by a 60% majority just last november to actually get up and going earlier. we talked about the communities that are losing their water system the department of agriculture has existing programs, but they need to be focused. we have aquifers that are depleted. we need conservation programs
both urban and agriculture. all those programs are in effect, so what we really need to do is stop fighting in washington and focus our attention that are in place in federal law with money already available. if they want to bring new money in they're more than happy to spend money on their favorite projects without an offset but for the things they don't care about, they demand an offset. in this case let's solve the problems of the drought all across the southern part of the united states, put the money there to help the communities, to help with conservation recycling, all of those things need to be done now. >> the experts are predicting that the economic loss is going to be roughly $3 billion in this year alone, 2015 for the state of california. that means job loss. >> exactly. >> that means folks losing farms, generations, you know some of these farms are like three, four generations. that's hard on people. >> absolutely.
>> what do you do to avert that? >> well first of all, don't steal somebody's water. for the last four years mccarthy and the folks from the southern san joaquin valley have put forth legislation in congress actually passed that would steal waters from farmers and the environment from the north, the fishermen, the salmon fishermen. don't do that don't engage in a pointless water battle but focus on the things that can be done to assis people. some communities in my direct for example, do have 30% unemployment. we need to employ those people putting in place the conservation measures and it's everything from toilets to agricultural conservation, drip irrigation, better management of the canal systems. all those things are jobshat we need now and we need toss conservation programs. we know we need to take care of the aquifers and replenish them.
>> john garamendi in california good to have you with us this evening. >> thank you. "politics nation" with reverend al sharpton starts right now. good evening, rev. \s. >> good evening, ed. breaking news the new dash-cam video connected to the deadly shooting in north charleston. it was just released by south carolina state's law enforcement division. it shows the traffic stop before officer michael slager shot and killed walter scott. you can see the broken taillight is there. there's also a second person in the car in the passenger seat and the video shows officer slager approaching the car. the audio isn't clean, but you can hear him asking walter scott for his license and registration.