Skip to main content

tv   Hardball With Chris Matthews  MSNBC  April 17, 2015 4:00pm-5:01pm PDT

4:00 pm
right now. chicken hawks. let's play "hardball." ghenk. i'm chris mat these in san francisco. tonight we live in the land. chicken hawk. always with a love of war but not an actual appetite. he speaks and writes a tough game but flies away at the prospect of actual combat. for example, you can hear the cries of the chicken hawk growing loud for a quick air strike on iran but not a peep for the grim struggle on the ground in iraq and syria against isis. 47 republican senators wrote a letter to theitia trying to derail the negotiations over nuclear weapons in iran but you can't find one republican senator ready to pass a war resolution against isis. what gives here? does the right like to blow the bugle only to scramble when they have to send in troops?
4:01 pm
david corn is the washington bureau chief for "mother jones" and evan coleman is an nbc news terrorism analyst. let's start. republican leaders and the right wing allies love blowing the bugle for war. love the notion of war. let's watch. >> isis says they want to go back and reject modernity. well, i think we should help them. we ought to bomb them back to the stone age. >> they are barbarians, and we're over there kind of poking them in the nose. we're not really there to defeat and destroy. >> i would hit them so hard and so fast that they wouldn't know what happened. >> i think it's time to bomb iran anything that resembles a nuclear facility with centrifuges. it's time to bomb. >> israel struck iraq's nuclear program in 1981 and they didn't reconstitute it. israel struck syria's nuclear
4:02 pm
reactor in 1997 and haven't yet constituted it. rogue regimes get the picture whether there's a credible force of military force on the table. >> enough of bates motel. let's go to john mccain who is at least cerebral at times. here he is telling what he thinks is a joke about bombing iran. let's catch this act. >> how many times do we have to prove that these people are blowing up people now never mind if they get a nuclear weapon. when do we send them an air mail message to tehran? >> that old beach boy song "bomb iran iran." ♪ bomb, bomb bomb ♪ >> david corn, that captures the level of thought. it is easy to talk about bombing iran because it involves a bombing raid with a couple of
4:03 pm
american pilots it's a quickie and it's over and an actual cakewalk though it never happens as a cakewalk. there's allies in the field, iraqi government iranian forces shia mill sharks but we can't get the congress the republican senators, corker the foreign relations committee, nobody wants to get involved in saying this is what we should be doing over there in terms of a war resolution. explain. >> this is an amazing and stark juxtaposition. when it comes to diplomacy, when barack obama is out there trying to negotiate a very difficult deal to, you know try to prevent war with iran what happens. republicans want to intervene when they don't necessarily have a strong constitutional role in this, and they are hot to trot. when it comes to iraq when the issue is what to do in a hot war of military action republicans are basically like monty python's knights. they are screaming run away run away. they don't want to have debates or hearings about what to do
4:04 pm
about this war resolution where they arguably have much more of a constitutional role in the matter and that's why when it comes to iran they want to obstruct obama. when it comes to iraq they want to be in a position to blame obama. they don't want to come up there and be on the hook and even get any buy-in on what is a very difficult proposition, and it's a project that the american public is really not that keen on in terms of military involvement, further military involvement in iraq. >> evan, i have a sense that they are politicians, just a guess, people like bob cork ker and the rest. they are all politicians, let's face it, but the republicans who love to talk like hawks, love to be warriors and john wayne and ronald reagan and all this. we're going to go bomb them back to the stone age. heard the talk there even from somewhat less serious people like donald trump, though he doesn't know he's less serious, he just is. i don't think anybody told him yet but he is less serious, and yet when it comes down to the actual grim fight of sending people over on new tours. we have to do another year or so
4:05 pm
away from your family maybe getting killed or dismembered, and those people going over there, and republicans don't want to push that button. explain how people say they want to fight. they say they want to meet the security concerns of the united states but then all of a sudden you know i love this idea of a quickie pilot, go over there and knock them over and we go home and it's a cakewalk we don't get hurt. it's a bite-sized war. >> it's the first thing we need to disabuse these folks of the idea we can bomb iran surgically with no repercussions for us easily cleanly. that is a pipe dream of the utmost significance or the utmost level. there's no way that would happen. iran controls the terrorist group hezbollah. hezbollah for the last few years has not been directly attacking u.s. interests. i guarantee you if we bomb any location inside of iranian territory hezbollah will start targeting us actively and they will target us in ways that we are not able to stop.
4:06 pm
so that considered that this is cleanless or bloodless or there's some kind of silver bullet solution to bomb iran into submission that does not exist. in the meantime, you're right. in iraq there is a shooting war that we don't have much choice right now to get involved in, and nobody seems to want to commit the assets to actually solve the problem. look what's going on in ramadi right now. this is shameful. american soldiers lost their lives in 2004 and 2005 and 2006 to try to control this city to get it back and stable and secure hands, and we're letting fall to isis right now, and we're talking about iran a country that we don't even have to fight. that is a very sad state on the political scene right now and the impact it's having on u.s. foreign policy. >> and you know, chris, the issue that evan brings us is incredibly difficult. how to respond to isis in iraq using the iraq military the shia militias that are allied
4:07 pm
many with iran and dealing with the kurds. it's a very complex issue to which nobody seems to have the best and right answer. you know anybody responsible in congress, even someone like, you know senator corker when i think is trying on iran not to go with the yahoos on right, they have an obligation to try to work with the president and come up with a best possible options, but they are completely ignoring that while they are playing these games to try to obstruct negotiations that aren't even over yet and that -- and that don't -- that are not a pressing crisis no matter what benjamin netanyahu says so they are really giving up tremendous responsibility that they do have to pursue this political ven data against obama because he's trying to solve the iranian issue without military action. >> let me ask you a political question, it's a little tricky but we've got to get to t.netanyahu, when i mentioned
4:08 pm
it, david, netanyahu came over and defined how he saw foreign policy saying iran is a much more serious threat than anyone else in that ballpark. he represents israel. is israel not afraid of isis because you don't hear him talking about isis at all, really, not like he talks about iran. >> that's a really good question. i mean, he is more worried are iran and if he's talking about isis and takes the eyes off the ball that he cares most about. it's the situation where the bad guys, people who think are the bad guys and israel thinks are the bad guys are winning. >> i think the answer is this. i think the israelis see iranian as the greatest strategic threat. >> i see. >> isis won't have their hands on atomic weapons any time soon but iranians might and right now iran is backing bashar assad, the regime in damascus. i don't think the israelis fully
4:09 pm
appreciate that isis might be worse for them than bashar al assad. they hate bashar al assad so much they loathe him so much they have gone through so much with him that i'm not sure they are convinced that anything could be worse than him, and i think they are making a mistake because isis is a much more difficult threat to contain than what they think. it's not just a matter of shooting across a border and keeping people in place. it's not going to work like that, so i think the israelis to be fair they have a reason to respect iran and to think that iran is a threat but they might be underselling the kind of damage that isis could cause them if they are right up against the golan heights which is exactly the direction they are pushing towards. >> well, the situation in iraq remains a mess as of today. a car bomb killed at least two people outside the united states consulate over there in irbil, the kurdish medical official tells nbc news that one americans among eight injured today, wounded. here's the state department informing reporters about that incident today.
4:10 pm
>> a vehicle-borne improvised explosive device was detonated on the consulate in irbil today. no injuries to personnel or local guards. we do not have any details on who is responsible at this time. >> evan they are coming at us over there. who do you think did this? >> look we don't know for sure but it certainly looks like either isis or a group that may be affiliated or sympathetic to isis and that's part of the problem, even in kurdistan which is a region technically full of american friends there are still people there that don't like that. there's ansar al islam, a terrorist group, doesn't like isis but likes al qaeda and doesn't like the united states and they could just as we will have been responsible for this as isis. our interests are going to be targeted. i mean let's face it. we're there. we're a target. isis wants to try to scare us out of that region. they are going to do everything they can. this is just the beginning. they are going to go after our interests. they are going to go after our
4:11 pm
personnel as long as they are able to. >> and the great irony, jerks i'll have to leave it at this and i'll get back to it at the end of the program is the republican party has been scoring lots of political points as the hawkish party as of late without ever committing itself to the real hot war going on against isis, a great terrible irony. politicians ought to be accountable for their rhetoric and be accountable to actions which support improving our security, not just talking and blowing that bugle. anyway, david corn as always you know what you're talking about and evan coleman, thank you so much for your expertise. >> sure thing, chris. >> here comes huckabee the guy who talked about uncle sugar and kenyan maw maws. won iowa back in 2008. will he now be spoiler? i think he's going to be the spoiler keeping the religious right vote away from ted cruz and rand paul and walker, scott walker. plus there's nothing fun about being poor but now a strict new law in kansas is making it illegal for people on welfare to go to the movies or to a local
4:12 pm
swimming hole on taxpayers' money. critics say the law is cruel, but the state's republican governor says it's about helping people become more self-sufficient. and this week the 2016 race did get under way for real so who's got the inside rail coming out of the gate and where is this thing headed between now-at-and the first debate, believe it or not, coming up this summer it's happening, and we'll keep you going, and we're going to ask our roundtable who is winning this thing. finally, let me finish with this whole idea of voting for the person, not the party, and how dangerous that is. this is "hardball," a place for politics.
4:13 pm
president obama is demanding that congress hold a vote on his nominee for attorney general, loretta lynch. here's the president. >> this is the top law enforcement job in the country. what are we doing here? and -- and i have to say that there are times where
4:14 pm
dysfunction in the senate just goes too far. this is an example of it. it's gone too far. enough. enough. call loretta lynch for a vote. get her confirm. put her in place. let her do her job. this is embarrassing, a process like this. >> well, the president nominated lynch back in november. she's been waiting longer for a confirmation vote than any other attorney general nominee in 30 years and yesterday senate democratic leader harry reid said he'd try to force a vote on lynch. he'd need republican help to do that, but his plan was foiled today when two republican senators who support lynch told nbc news they wouldn't allow the vote, wouldn't allow the vote. we'll be right back after this.
4:15 pm
relief rig site of pa when you take advil you get relief right at the site of pain. wherever it is. advil stops pain right where it starts. relief doesn't get any better than this. advil.
4:16 pm
you know i wasn't sure that i would ever be able to love a state as much as i love my home
4:17 pm
state of arkansas but tonight i love iowa a whole lot. >> welcome back to "hardball." that was former arkansas governor mike huckabee winning iowa caucuses back in 2008. huckabee lost the gop nomination that year to john mccain but now it looks like he wants another crack at it. late today huckabee told reporters he's formed a presidential exploratory committee and moments ago he said this about his 2016 campaign plans. >> may 5th is the day i'll make an announcement and i hope people will come to hope arkansas, and not just to tour the bill clinton birthplace. >> huckabee has a history of colorful talk. here he is on gaze women and his favorite punching bag, president obama. >> do you believe you're born gay or you choose to be gay? >> i don't know whether people are born that way. people who are gay say that they are born that way, but one thing i know that the behavior one practices is a choice.
4:18 pm
>> in iowa you would not have people who would just throw the f-bomb and use gratuitous profanity in a professional setting. >> right. >> in new york not only do the men do it but the women do it and, you know you just are looking around saying my gosh this is worse than locker room talk. this would be considered totally inappropriate to say these things in front of a woman and for a woman to say them in a professional setting, we would only assume that this is a very as we would say in the south, that's just trashy. >> so i'm beginning to think that there's more freedom in north korea than there is in the united states. >> i've said many times publicly that i do think he has a different world view and i think it's in part molded out of a very different experience. most of us grew up going to boy scout meetings and, you know our communities were filled with rotary clubs, not madrassas. >> everything he does is against what christians stand for, and he's against the jews in israel. >> robert costa is a political
4:19 pm
reporter with the "washington post" and joins us from nashua new hampshire where the republican field is gathering up there this week and ron reagan is an msnbc contributor. ron, i was just wondering where the madrassas are in honolulu. i guess there were some in indonesia, but this shot at this guy is right up there with the mao mao charge. he's some third worlder, not one of us even after all these years. >> huckabee's constituents or who he thinks his constituency, is they believe this kind of stuff. they nod their heads when they says this kind of stuff. they tune into his tv show when he says this kind of stuff. this is, you know this is his stock and trade. >> well robert it seems to me he's narrowing his constituency when he takes shots at the big city. okay, the language may be a little racier in big cities can i live with that, but what's the point of saying it unless you're cultivating the anti-big city vote that doesn't like the
4:20 pm
sophisticates or even the trashy-talking people. i mean what's the point? does he intend to rule this country without ever coming into contact with new yorkers? new yorkers? >> well, you know where the anti-big city vote does pay attention is in iowa, and if you're an evangelical conservative, if you're a ted cruz if you're rick santorum ben carson huckabee is a political threat. he's someone who can storm into iowa create chaos on the right and helpful to someone like jeb bush who ignores iowa perhaps and goes straight to new hampshire. >> so that's -- i don't like the term but it is sort of an appeal for a yahoo anti-big city country mass versus city mass and that to me is a very short-term strategy. i have a feeling -- i'm going to try this out with both of you guys. i think what huckabee threatens to do here is own the religious right vote the people that are very much against same-sex and will be infuriated bay court decision, a 6-3 decision this summer this, june, that basically recognizes that right to same-sex marriage.
4:21 pm
infuriated the way they were infuriated by no prayer in public school decision in the '60s and they will get infuriated. they will all vote for this guy huckabee which means ted cruz won't get their votes. means that scott walker won't get them and even rand paul won't get them so he'll freeze them out of this because he'll be so fiery. is this possible what he could do, just be the dog in the manger, grab the religious vote and keep it away from them so none of the other three candidates with build up the support they need to real take on the more establishment candidates. your thought robert? >> and then become something of a king-maker as well. if he owns the evangelical right on the republican party, then let's say a jeb bush looks like he's going to get the nomination, he needs to go courting huckabee to get that vote from huckabee but he's not just an evangelical. he's doing some smarter things too. he's actually carved out a little exceptional nis for himself with social security. most republican candidates are talking aboutration the eligibility age. not huckabee. huckabee is saying no, we leave the program alone. it's a pact with the american people that we've made.
4:22 pm
he knows that his, you know his constituency is an older constituency, too, and he's playing to that. >> yeah, so he's a politician. >> yeah. >> chris, a few hours ago just behind me here in this ballroom in nashua governor jeb bush was asked by one of these activists about a coronation happening in the republican party what. huckabee is doing is playing on name pulls in the base. he knows there's a lot of skepticism with bush. they think this is an aristocratic movement from the gop establishment. he's going right at that feeling saying i can be your candidate and i'm against the cities. followed huckabee on his book tour. it's uber popularism, god, guns gravy, that's the pitch. >> somebody in the other play i forget, who are flank that democrats are exploiting the fact that all they have to do is ask republicans about same-sex would they go to a same-sex marriage and they call it a wedge issue f.huckabee says this
4:23 pm
is what the republican party is all about, opposition to same-sex marriage, opposition to abortion rights, if that's what the party is all about and its moral kernel how can the republicans always say you democrats are picking up on little things and use them against us ron. you know what i mean. either it's central to the party or it's not and if it is central to the party's doctrine or platform why shouldn't the democrats go after it? >> well, exactly. entirely fair for the democrats to point that out and this is the problem for the republican party. are they going to be the republican party of let's say jeb bush who is you know he's going to cater to the evangelical right, you know to the extent that he has to, but he's not really of them or is it going to be somebody like huckabee or, you know potentially a ted cruz somebody like that, who really is tight with the evangelicals and, you know at least pretends not to believe in science and things like that. >> oh, that's right. >> these are two radically different visions of the republican party. >> let me go back to you, robert. robert, you've got to play this straight, robert but here's the straight question.
4:24 pm
those debates are going to be coming up this summer and as much as the republican organization is going to try to control them and keep away moderates and liberals and establishment journalists, somewhere along the line these candidates are going to be asked fundamental questions about their world view about science, about evolution, about abortion rights about sexuality and identities, sexual identity. are they going to try to avoid all those issues? is that the republican game plan? is this reince priebus' plan protect them from being studied by people so we can't look at them ant throw poe logically you know keep them away from us. >> i've checked in with all these republican presidential campaigns today here in new hampshire, and they look at horizon, and they are worried chris, because they see the supreme court about to decide this summer on same-sex marriage, and so as much as the republican party may want to avoid an internal battle on the social issues it's coming and you know who recognizes, that huckabee. he sees the party is going to be
4:25 pm
battling this in the in the summer. he wants to be there in the center of it and perhaps ride that momentum into the nomination. >> well, it happened before back in the '60s when the supreme court outlawed public schools having prayer in school and all of a something called the moral majority was created because of that, robert so there's -- ron, there's a precedent on this. >> yes. >> once the supreme court acts whether it's "roe v. wade" or brown case or anything else it doesig night the right. >> yes, there's a backlash exactly. i think we have to say one more thing about mr. huckabee as well. i'm not entirely sure that he's running for the presidency. i don't know that he really thinks he can be elected president. i may be wrong about this but he -- you know let's -- he spent the last some years as a television host. he may be running as some people do just to kind of help his career along for after the election. so we should keep that in mind too. >> is he going to be the next reverse mortgage guy, is that what you're saying?
4:26 pm
>> possibly. >> let me ask you, robert. >> it's a crowded field. it's a crowded feel. >> is he for real? >> i've been following him on campaign trail and i know what it's been. it's been a book tour and huckabee knows it's a tough time for him. cruz was at liberty university. evangelicals are looking at a lot of different contenders. ron is right. huckabee may explore for a while and may end up not running. >> thanks so much robert costa. you're becoming my favorite straight reporter out there, very much so. thank you, and ron rage answer, thanks for coming on my friend. >> till ahead, roundtable and where the presidential race is headed it is a comes out of the chute. what a first week and they are all joining in this race. up next, some of the biggest news stories of our time through a reporter who covered them, john parmlmer, and this is "hardball," the place for politics. the up all-nighters. and the ones who turn ideas into action. we've made our passions our life's work. we strive for the moments where we can say, "i did it!" ♪ ♪
4:27 pm
we are entrepreneurs who started it all... with a signature. legalzoom has helped start over 1 million businesses, turning dreamers into business owners. and we're here to help start yours. meet the world's newest energy superpower. surprised? in fact, america is now the world's number one natural gas producer... and we could soon become number one in oil. because hydraulic fracturing technology is safely recovering lots more oil and natural gas. supporting millions of new jobs. billions in tax revenue... and a new century of american energy security. the new energy superpower? it's red, white and blue. log on to learn more.
4:28 pm
when a moment spontaneously turns romantic why pause to take a pill? and why stop what you're doing to find a bathroom? with cialis for daily use, you don't have to plan around either. it's the only daily tablet approved to treat erectile dysfunction so you can be ready anytime the moment is right. plus cialis treats the frustrating urinary symptoms of bph, like needing to go frequently, day or night. tell your doctor about all your medical conditions and medicines, and ask if your heart is healthy enough for sex. do not take cialis if you take nitrates for chest pain as it may cause an unsafe drop in blood pressure. do not drink alcohol in excess. side effects may include headache, upset stomach, delayed backache or muscle ache. to avoid long-term injury, get medical help right away for an erection lasting more than four hours. if you have any sudden decrease or loss in hearing or vision or any symptoms of an allergic reaction stop taking cialis and get medical help right away. why pause the moment? ask your doctor about cialis for daily use. for a free 30-tablet trial go to
4:29 pm
about a minute after the launch of the space shuttle "challenger" from cape canaveral
4:30 pm
this afternoon, there was a huge bright ball of fire and explosion in the air about 28 miles west of the cape canaveral launch site. it was just after the nasa controllers told the crew aboard the "challenger" to go to full throttle that the explosion occurred. >> back to "hardball," certainly a horrible day, death of the people on the "challenger." nbc's john palmer was breaking the news of the space shuttle "challenger" tragedy back in 86. in his 50-year career in broadcast news he distinguished himself as an outstanding broadcast news reporter to the time he landed a spot on the "today" show and he was an eyewitness to history as it unfolded but it was during the iranian hostage crisis in april that have year he was the first to break the news that the carter administration rescue attempt had failed in the iranian desert called desert one. here's how he described it at the time. >> reporter: last night just after 11:00 nbc news learned
4:31 pm
that there was unusual activity here at the white house. when i arrived to see what was happening the street adjoining the white house was crowded with official cars. the lights were on in the executive mansion, and the press room was deserted but the presence of many secret service agents indicated the president was in the oval office. the rescue mission had been aborted, and eight americans had died. >> before his death in 2013 palmer was able to finish a memoir about his life in journalism, "news catcher" which he called it and i'm joined right now by his wife nancy palmer. nancy, thanks for joining us. how did john get that scoop because i do know one thing about journalism. when there's a lot of fuss going on it's a big sign that something is going on so just look for a fuss. people even around work at the wrong hours and i love the fact there was nobody in the press room except john palmer. your thoughts, your memories? >> he told me about it. i was working with him at the
4:32 pm
time. he saw a lot of food left that the staff had been eating and the answer he kept getting is i have nothing for you from the one press aide on duty which doesn't mean there's no story. he just won't going to tell him. john just touched it out and got in there and finally got to jody powell and said i know something is going on and at that point he had his camera man put the lights on on the lawn on the white house, and he said i'm going out there. i know something's going on and i need more and i've got enough and jody wasn't happy about it, but jody did arrange to finally tell him the details, and john had to bargain to get it on before johnny carson ended "the tonight show" so he would get the national audience which did not make jody happy, but i think it made the viewers happy to know what was going on so he did get the story and got the merriman smith award for breaking it. >> everyone thinks that the white house is a great beat but the problem is it's almost like feeding time at seaworld because you're in that press room and, you know you only get told what they want to tell you so have you to develop these back
4:33 pm
channel sources. you have to have people basically willing to rat out the white house in the white house. i worked at the white house, and i know that guys like john palmer and leslie stahl were always working people around the edges of power to say oh, come on, fell me what's going on. don't be so squeamish. don't be so loyal. isn't that what the job is getting behind the scenes to the people that aren't supposed to talk? >> absolutely and you left out sam donaldson and bill plante they call themselves larry, moe and curly sometimes, but they are out there. you have to do it that way, and job had this southern charm and this ease about him, but he was also very competitive and made sure he had his own sources and got the stories, and he did. >> so you had your first date when i was working in the carter white house as a speech writer. that's when you two got together, you and john. >> john invited me to the white house, and i don't know if he was just being nice because i worked in the office and didn't get out much in the news room or if he was interested and we didn't find out because we didn't know when you're a guest of the white house you don't sit with the person you come with
4:34 pm
so i sat at one end of the east room and he was at another, so i didn't get to know him that well that night but we had a more proper date a week later. >> and at one point you were kept from your wedding by ronald reagan. explain that quickly. why did ronald reagan screw up your wedding day? >> ronald reagan called john to say congratulations and launched into a long story about how he met nancy 30 years early and john wasn't going to hang up on the president. >> thank you so much. the book is called "news catcher, "about the real talent and profession of getting the story first. thank you very much nancy palmer. >> thank you very much. >> up next, the strict law that makes till legal for welfare recipients to go to the local swimming hole or to go to the movies on the taxpayer dime. they are getting tough in kansas. you're watching "hardball," the
4:35 pm
place for politics. i've saved $75 in checked bag fees. no foreign transaction fees means real savings. we can go to any country and spend money the way we would in the u.s. one of the best things about priority boarding is you can just get on the plane and relax. i put everything on the explorer card. i really want my united miles. ♪ where do you get this kind of confidence? at your ford dealer... that's where! our expert trained technicians... state of the art technology and warranty parts keep your vehicle running right. it's no wonder we sold more than 3.5 million tires last year and durning the big tire event get a $120 mail in rebate on 4 select tires. ♪ kid: hey dad, who was that man? dad: he's our broker. he helps looks after all our money.
4:36 pm
kid: do you pay him? dad: of course. kid: how much? dad: i don't know exactly. kid: what if you're not happy? does he have to pay you back? dad: nope. kid: why not? dad: it doesn't work that way. kid: why not? vo: are you asking enough questions about the way your wealth is managed? wealth management at charles schwab denver international is one of the busiest airports in the country. we operate just like a city and that takes a lot of energy. we use natural gas throughout the airport - for heating the entire terminal generating electricity on-site and fueling hundreds of vehicles. we're very focused on reducing our environmental impact. and natural gas is a big part of that commitment.
4:37 pm
4:38 pm
i'm paige hopkins and here's what's happening. a spacex capsule carrying 4,000 pounds of supplies docked at the international space station earlier. it will return to earth in may carrying experiments and discarded equipment. basketball great kareem abdul-jabbar is recovering from heart surgery at an l.a. hospital. he underwent a quadruple bypass on thursday. and stocks ended sharply lower today on concerns about trading regulations in china. the dow slid 279 points after falling more than 350 points at the worst levels of that session, and now we're going to take you back to "hardball." let us say that all of us who are able body will be given an opportunity to work for their
4:39 pm
welfare grants. we will not make them lifetime recipients of a dole as clients of an ever growing welfare bureaucracy. >> welcome back to "hardball," ronald reagan on the woes of welfare back in 1975. this week another republican governor has his own lamont, kansas governor sam brownback signed a new law blocking his state's welfare recipients from using their government-provided debit cards to purchase alcohol, tobacco, pro or college sports tickets or paying for services at nail salons even local swimming pools and movie theaters and while many states restrict what welfare recipients can spend their money on the new kansas law is thought to be the most restrictive in the country. the conservative republican governor there says the new law motivates kansans to get off welfare and work. here he is. >> there's a human toll of misguided compassion and what we are attempting to do here is put work programs and work
4:40 pm
requirements to help people. >> well critics call the law punitive and judgmental and also limits atm withdrawals to $25 a day. i have no idea how to do that. advocacy groups say that limit makes it tough for someone without a checking account to pay doctor bills or transportation expenses. and joining me right now the roundtable is the "washington post" opinion writer jonathan capehart and the guardian sabrina sideki and jeremy peters. tell me the thinking about it. i've grown up with this way back since before reagan talked about welfare abuse. people signature around and watching television all day, generation after generation living off the dole. nobody likes that picture. i don't think people on that picture like being in it. it's not a happy seen. it's a loser scene in many ways generation after generation. first of all, is that an accurate portrait of the person receiving public assistance and, secondly, is the amount of money you get so low, i calculate it to be about $5 per person per
4:41 pm
day, that you won't be going off on cruise ship trips like this thing prohibits, it's an absurdity that you can even stack that kind of money together. your thoughts about the whole debate and whole incident here? >> i think you're right. largely this is based oncaricature, a very popular caricature among a lot of conservatives, but i would also look at it from this point of view. it's not particularly innovative policy. i mean this is one of the oldest tricks from the conservative policy book but you contrast that with what's going on among some other big thinkers in the republican party, marco rubio and his poverty plan to create a federal program to give states more authority to do what they would with their anti-poverty programs. you have what for example, rand paul, rob portman and mike lee are doing on criminal justice reform. it's just so much -- there's so much more innovative thinking on what to do going on. >> yeah. well, you know let me tell you. jonathan, i understand this whole thing emotionally, like
4:42 pm
when you have a hard day at work you come home and kick the dog. if you're middle class and not feeling that happy about life stick it to the poor people. >> right. >> we know the politics. everybody watching knows what this is about, everybody knows what this is about. >> everybody do, and -- and it's so -- it's wrong on so many levels. look no one begrudges the government placing limits on what people can and can't do with the money that's given to them when they are at the most vulnerable moments in their lives, but it's really humiliating to constantly remind those people in public what they can and cannot do with that money, and so for someone like senator -- governor brownback, we're not really surprised that he would go down this route, especially since a lot of the restrictions he's placed into law were already part of state policy, but it's really for him to thrust himself this way into the national debate when as jeremy said a lot of people within his own party are moving beyond the tried and true and
4:43 pm
trite welfare argument. >> let me go to sabrina because one of the laughable parts of this, it's an emotional issue, the laughable part you make $200 a week two kids at home three people splitting 100 bucks a way, about $5 a day. the idea that you're going to take that money and scrounge it together and end up on a cruise ship liner somewhere is such a laugh. why do they put cruise ships on this trip? on this deal? >> it's laughable because it's creating in misconception that this is what families low-income families are spending their welfare subsidies on the same thing applies for food stamps and the effort to drastically cut food stamps and make food stamp recipients undergo drug testing. try to perpetuate this image that food stamp recipients are spending that money on drugs when in fact if you have $29 a week which comes out to roughly $1 a day there's simply no way that you're spending it on the most essential needs for your household. i also want to make the quick point, you know, we dis
4:44 pm
disproportionately target the poor when it comes to government assistance and majority of americans on some sort of government subsidy. why aren't we making sure that people receiving student loans are putting that money towards a degree that would potentially lead to a viable degree and why aren't we looking at how people spend their mortgage tax breaks because we have sort of perception that's been created that the poor are not adequately using this money and they are not actually work when in fact that's not the case. >> well jeremy what would work because i do know we all know about food deserts, we all know about that. you live in an urban area and where i grow up the neighborhood has changed. basically kfc on the corner and chinese restaurant. some people aren't eating the right food. they don't have a grocery store. they probably go shopping at the last minute and once you get low nutrition and low energy it's a vicious cycle. you don't get off your butt. i know all that, but is there any way that the government can improve it besides this draconian stuff, any way to get people to live their lives more rationally when they are at the
4:45 pm
bottom, is there a way, or are we just messing with people? >> i think you just touched on it, right. enhancing nutrition would be one way to do it but look what happened when michelle obama tried to do that. she was pilloried by conservatives >> you know, chris, to add to jeremy's point, how do you get people, you know off their butts, as you said. conservatives like to talk a lot about the dignity of work how the poor need to have the dignity of work. well, you know what the poor also need they need to have the government treat them with dignity and give them a leg up or a step up or some sort of assistance so that they can actually fulfill their hopes and dreams fulfill their version of the american dream. >> yeah. >> that's the kind of dignity that people who are on welfare would like to see from their government. >> yeah, and i wish the democrats all these years had been just warehoused these people and i don't think -- i don't think either party has been very good five hours a week where you go and have to meet with people and dress up for the occasion you have to get up for it.
4:46 pm
a little sense -- a little dignity that comes from just a good meeting somewhere rather than just being hounded and made fun of. the roundtable is staying with us. this is the week that kicked off, believe it or not, the 2016 presidential race which is not going to race into this summer. we'll have debates this summer iowa caucuses coming up in nine months. it's begun, and this campaign has reached its moment of conception, full. i want to know what we've learned and where we're heading and is there anybody out there winning besides hillary and she is winning. this is "hardball," a place for politics.
4:47 pm
♪ if you're looking for a car that drives you... ...and takes the wheel right from your very hands... ...this isn't that car. the first and only car with direct adaptive steering. ♪ the 328 horsepower q50 from infiniti. meet the world's newest energy superpower. surprised? in fact, america is now the world's number one natural gas producer... and we could soon become number one in oil. because hydraulic fracturing technology is safely recovering lots more oil and natural gas. supporting millions of new jobs. billions in tax revenue... and a new century of american energy security. the new energy superpower? it's red, white and blue.
4:48 pm
log on to learn more. after iowa and new hampshire, primary fight for president goes to south carolina, of course. we've got an early look at where the race stands, according to a new winthrop poll wisconsin xof scott walker leads the pack at 2%, just ahead of jeb bush comes in at 13. everyone else is in single digits. ted cruz is at 2% as is south carolina senator lindsey graham. rand paul is next with 6% and chris christie, ben carson and mike huckabee down at 5%. by the way, it looks like scott walker's winning in iowa new hampshire and now south carolina. he's got something going. we'll be right back.
4:49 pm
you could sit at your computer and read all about zero-turn mowers. click. scroll. tweet. or you could just sit on a john deere z435 eztrak and feel its power. you'll know it'll get the job done fast. when it's time to pick a mower you've got to get on one. visit your local john deere dealer for a test drive today. sign up to take your turn on a z435 and save 100 dollars on your purchase. nothing runs like a deere.
4:50 pm
there's some facts about seaworld we'd like you to know. we don't collect killer whales from the wild. and haven't for 35 years. with the hightest standard of animal care in the world, our whales are healthy. they're thriving. i wouldn't work here if they weren't. and government research shows they live just as long as whales in the wild. caring for these whales, we have a great responsibility to get that right. and we take it very seriously. because we love them. and we know you love them too.
4:51 pm
we're back with the round table. this is the week the 2016 presidential race truly got under way. hillary clinton got into the race. while there are a handful of official candidates on the republican side up to a dozen more are likely to join soon ppts first. the first debates are scheduled for august and the first voting is just nine months away from now. who is leading out of the gate. jeremy hillary clinton has all the credentials, all the resumé ready. i think she's had a pretty good week, she didn't get hurt and i think the people out there who are not political junkies are quite happy with the fact she's throughout hanging out with people. your thoughts. >> i think that's exactly what i would have said. i think this week was all about not making a mistake. and by all accounts she didn't make a mistake. i mean the political media could obsess about these little
4:52 pm
things, she said her grandparents were immigrants and it turned out that they weren't. who cares. i think ultimately the vast vast majority of americans either didn't pay attention to this or thought that you know she did just fine. there were no unforced errors. >> i think she's getting her sea legs sabrina. bill clinton didn't need to get -- he doesn't need spring training, bill clinton. i mean he's always in training that guy. but she does and she's doing it. that's what it looks like she's doing, spring training. getting ready. >> i think her campaign has taken the right approach because there's just so much scrutiny around every move that she makes, as jeremy says. so it's good for her to do these low-key meetings with vote that's face to face interaction because the reality is that she does have to contend with her familiarity. and republicans in particular are trying to cast her as this elitist out of touch creature of washington. so the best way for her at least in the early phases because at the end of the day there's a long road ahead for her to
4:53 pm
really introduce herself to the public reintroduce herself at a national level and that seems to be exactly what she's doing. >> chris, i would add that watching this week i've had a sense of deja vu. sabrina and i were talking about this earlier where i was there in new york covering her 2000 senate campaign from the lofty purchase of the daily news editorial board but still following her and watching her campaign and her listening to it and remembering how the new york press killed her for these listening tours. they derided the listening tour. they thought it was just theater and show and nothing and when she was done listening and started speaking and talking about how she would represent the people of new york she floored everyone with her knowledge of the state, her deep knowledge of very picky y pickiune
4:54 pm
things, she will weave in the remarks from people she's heard from people in iowa, north carolina. >> have you watched the copy book where she writes down everything people are saying to her? i want to read it. what does it say at the top, "jesus mary, joseph with" with a cross on it? i want to read it myself. hillary, i want to know what you're learning. it's been a good week. we all agree a good week for hillary clinton and the rest of the country politically way up in the air. we don't know where it's going. anyway jonathan have a nice weekend. jeremy peters from the times. when we return let me finish with this whole idea of voting for the person, not the party and how dangerous that idea seems in reality compared to how nice it looks when -- well when you're thinking about it. you're watching "hardball," the place for politics.
4:55 pm
at your ford dealer... that's where! our expert trained technicians... state of the art technology and warranty parts keep your vehicle running right. it's no wonder we sold more than 3.5 million tires last year and durning the big tire event get a $120 mail in rebate on 4 select tires. ♪ are you still getting heartburn flare-ups? time for a new routine. try nexium® 24hr. the latest choice for frequent heartburn. get complete protection. nexium level protection. to unlock the possibilities of tomorrow......"lift tab." behold the beauty of balance. crisp flakes of fiber-rich bran. answered by the perfect quantity of sun sweetened raisins. and with the sublime addition of ice-cold milk, the day begins. ♪sun'll come out, tomorrow♪ tomorrow is waiting. own it, with kellogg's® raisin bran
4:56 pm
see you at breakfast™. and delight in temptingly tart and sweet new kellogg's® raisin bran with cranberries. the pursuit of healthier. it begins from the second we're born. after all, healthier doesn't happen all by itself. it needs to be earned... every day...
4:57 pm
using wellness to keep away illness... and believing that a single life can be made better by millions of others. healthier takes somebody who can power modern health care... by connecting every single part of it. for as the world keeps on searching for healthier... we're here to make healthier happen. optum. healthier is here.
4:58 pm
let me finish with this whole idea of voting for the person, not the party. the problem is you don't just get the person, you do get the party. if you voted for george w. in 2000 you got dick cheney and the defense department. you got a war in iraq for your vote. expect the same problem the next time around. you vote for what seems to be a reasonable republican candidate and you get the party apparatus
4:59 pm
with a and a whole bunch of neocons jumping into jobs you'll find hawks edging toward their favorite war, their most desirable regime change. believe me we've been there. i've been there. why? because even now they sit antsy and festy over there at the american enterprises and froont group sounding places like the committee for the present danger or emergency committee on whatever, all packed with senior fellows who busy themselves writing op-ed columns pushing for the next regime change. but when it comes to putting their personal or political boots on the ground watch them scatter. find a republican pushing for a war resolution against isis. just try and find one. lots of bugles on iran and how they should shut it down and bomb the place. that's the notion of a bite-size military operation, a single bombing raid a cake walk like the one they promised in iraq.
5:00 pm
this is how they get us in every time it's the only way to go promise it will be quick an easy them. call any one whoey yopposes them an appeaser. "all in with chris hayes" starts right now. tonight on "all in." >> good to be back in new hampshire. >> new hampshire. >> new hampshire. >> the first big gathering of republican hopefuls in new hampshire as the 2016 campaign gets under way. then the first public interview with the tulsa county volunteer reserve deputy who shot and killed an unarmed suspect. >> this is the second worst thing that ever happened to me. >> then sean penn talks about his exposure to every day chemicals. and the viral rant that got an espn reporter suspended. >> "all in" starts right now. >>


info Stream Only

Uploaded by TV Archive on