Skip to main content

tv   All In With Chris Hayes  MSNBC  April 29, 2015 5:00pm-6:01pm PDT

5:00 pm
"all in" with chris hayes starts right now right from baltimore itself. good evening. from baltimore city hall i'm chris hayes. you just heard from commissioner anthony bat, who's described a fairly calm scene, including peaceful protests a march late this afternoon. hundreds of students protesting police violence chanting all night, all day, we will fight for freddy gray. city still felt unsettled today two days after violence broke out following the funeral of freddy gray, the 25-year-old black man who suffered a severe spinal cord injury and died in baltimore police custody ten days ago and whose dealt the death has still yet to be explained. this afternoon an unprecedented scene, the baltimore orioles played the chicago white sox in a stadium kept empty for security reasons. we'll have much or on that in a
5:01 pm
bit. we'll talk about what's happening here has hit the presidential campaign trail with hillary clinton delivering an impassioned speech today, calling for an overhaul of the criminal justice system. >> yet again the family of a young black man is grieving a life cut short. yet again, the streets of an american city are marred by violence. what we have seen in baltimore should, indeed i think does tear at our soul. >> when mien while, protests tonight have spread to new york city where a massive solidarity protest has been taking place, is still taking place at this hour with many people now being arrested by nypd. here in baltimore, for the second night are-in a row, the city will once again be under curfew starting at 10:00 p.m. last night when curfew began or shortly after 10:00 p.m. there was a briefly intense standoff between a small, small group of protesters and police. by midnight, the streets were
5:02 pm
calm. 16 adults and two juveniles were arrested today. 35 were arrested last night. and 101 people arrested on monday night were released today without charges because police could not quickly process them. discussing where things now stand in baltimore, officials sounded a cautiously optimistic tone. >> it's been less than 48 hours since we declared this state of emergency. and things are looking a lot different than they did monday night. we will continue to be here until the threat of violence end. >> baltimore's mayor stephanie rawlings-blake today called under criticism for the young people who engaged in rock throwing and looting and fires on monday "thugs," a term also used by barack obama. she said "when you speak out of frustration and anger, one can say things in a way that you don't mean." joining me now msnbc national reporter tremain lee. you spent all day with the
5:03 pm
protesters. there was a huge protest that came right through penn station. what did you see? >> there were several hundred marchers, a more diverse crowd than we've seen in days march from penn station down to city hall. one thing interesting not just the diversity but there was no police presence there. several hundred, maybe 600 students marching peacefully chanting that they're here for forfor for -- in support of freddie gray's family. they gathered at city hall more chanting speakers on the microphone turned back around and marched back to penn station. one thing for certain, things can always begin peacefully. so even the sense is that everything has been peaceful and quiet, what happens tonight when the curfew is enforced? how will police respond to any
5:04 pm
crowd that gathers? folks are saying go home but there are a number of people out here still carrying signs, young and old, black and white, very diverse. what had been a jubilant and vibrant crowd of several hundred. >> if you were watching us in the previous hour you saw a news conference with anthony batts, commissioner of baltimore police talking a bit about the situation that the baltimore police have faced today and arrests but several questions about friday, the day that the internal investigation conducted by the baltimore police is set to be presented to the state's attorney. lots of anticipation about what that means, what information the public are will get, what it means for possible criminal prosecution against the six officers who have been identified or had contact with freddie gray in custody. with me now, msnbc national correspondent joanna reed today was talking to the mayor and others doing a little bit of reporting about what exactly is going to happen.
5:05 pm
we don't know what friday means. originally what happened is the police indicated they were going to truncate a process that usually takes much longer than three weeks into three weeks. there was so on friday may 1st a public report would be issued but today officials walking that back. joy reed has been reporting on this today. i'm confused about what we should be expecting friday and what we'll get. >> you are not alone. there has been widespread anticipation in this city on friday there would be public release of a report summarizing at least as much of what happened to freddie gray as police were willing to disclose publicly ahead of an investigation. today we had as you mention the police chief say that's not the case, there won't be a public report. they'll simply turn over their findings in the internal investigation over to the state
5:06 pm
prosecutor. that was news to a lot of people. apparently to a local pastor i spoke with major stephanie rawlings-blake attended a meeting with about 15 ministers and a couple of by leaders in which they said she tried to explain to them that essentially it was always just going to be a turning over of information that may 1st had no significance at all and that this was something that she wanted those ministers to then go and communicate to the members of the community. of course the pastor i spoke with that is also the understanding of the attorney for freddie gray's family and they said at least this one minister said he was satisfied that the major had been transparent about it. i have not been able to find anything in the reporting that either has been done on this network or some of the local newspapers that said that it was just going to be a turning over of information to the prosecutor. so call it a miscommunication maybe it was just us hearing what the police department has been saying and just assuming
5:07 pm
that they meant public. i can't get to the bottom of what that's about, but you now do have an ktive effort by the mayor's office to convince the public to stand down on the notion of may 1st as a significant date. we'll see how it goes over. people we've been talking to and i'm sure you've been talking to were anticipating information and they're not going to get it p. >> joy, let me ask you this. i'm unclear about what the legal status of this investigation is. investigation being conducted by the baltimore police department. there are some legal guidelines having to do with a law enforcement officials bill of rights which is passed in maryland in 1974. there are some constitutional issues about what kind of testimony they can and can't use if they instruct officers in their employ to speak to them. but the actual document produced there, that is not a criminal investigation in an official sense. am i right about that? >> reporter: yeah. i mean, it is a little bit confusing, chris, but first of all, there's also -- putting aside whatever the federal
5:08 pm
agencies want to do as well. but, yeah things like the autopsy, any reports about what the incident -- what started the incident. the question we've all been asking, what was freddie gray being detained for in the first place, any information about his injuries. all of that documentation has been the subject of an internal investigation inside the baltimore police department. now, what they're saying is they're going to now turn all of that over because of what you mentioned, the law enforcement officers bill of rights. police officers get a great amount of leeway in terms of their privacy in terms of the investigation of them in this state because of state law. our experience i've seen in cases like this referencing the walter scott case in south carolina, once these cases go to the state law enforcement agency, the state's attorney's office there's almost never a public disclosure of information. but in a sense insulates the local police department because when people like us come and ask for information, they can say this is in the hands of the state and they refer us to them.
5:09 pm
i anticipate that's what we're going to see. is that going to dispoint people greatly? we'll find out. there are going to be a couple marches and big rallies this weekend. we'll see how it goes over. >> all right. joy reid thank you for that. if you've been watching our network today, you saw at the top there have been solidarity protests in new york city. a lot of arrests i've been seeing on social media reported. joining me on the phone from union square is amanda segunda. what is it like there? >> reporter: there's a turn of a peaceful protest to a demonstration against police. people tried demonstrating against police and made it only half a block before the streets were barricaded. we've seen a dozen arrests so far and there have been multiple people taken into custody. one woman was hauled into an
5:10 pm
ambulance. as we were trying to film it a police officer pulled us aside and yelled at us, please do not shoot that. it's quiet now. things are starting to slow down. there are people still gathering on the streets wanting to protest. remember, these are the same groups that were able to shut down the brooklyn bridge in the past. they've been able to block traffic all the way to lower manhattan. we've seen them in the middle of streets marching and this is the first time we've seen them been stymied pli bipolice early on in the protest. >> amanda sakuma live in new york and union square thank you for that. join meganow, councilman representing the district where freddie gray was arrested. >> thanks for having me. >> what is your expectation for the report being produced by the police department and what do you feel you need to see for accountability for an individual who was a constituent of yours?
5:11 pm
that you represented? >> from your report, it appears the police have said something different or changed the communications and there actually will not be a report on friday, that they are just going to hand over, you know, the contents of their investigation to the state's attorney's office. i think that, you know, what folks -- what the catalyst behind a lot of the protests and the issue was that, you know the basic level of information, why was he a suspect, why was he pursued, why was he detained ultimately, whufs he arrested this is what folks want. when you get arrested you're supposed to know what you're charged with. unfortunately, the baltimore city police department did not come out with that information right away and i think that's the catalyst that started all of this. >> the mayor stephanie rawlings-blake was on with reverend sharpton yesterday and talked about essentially balancing the need for transparency and also essentially a public safety concern. do you think -- it seems to me and i've now covered over the past year a number of thee cases
5:12 pm
in which people have died in police custody or been shot by police, this is the least amount of information that i have experienced, and that includes ferguson missouri. do you think that balance has been struck properly? >> no. basic information is why was the person originally charged? that's something that should come out immediately. >> what was the suspicion, why were they apprehended or arrested? >> basic information. freddie gray should have known why he was arrested. his friends, family community should have known what he was charged with why he was arrested. they should have come out with that right away. they had a video camera right there. they didn't release the video until seven, eight days later and it had nothing on it. that was something you could have released immediately. folks want to feel like you're being transparent without hurting the criminal investigation. >> when the investigation is finished or when it's turned over, right, the next point in a process would be the state's attorney's office and we have seen in other incidents a lot of focal point on the state's
5:13 pm
attorney accusations of the state's attorney essentially for case. your wife is the state's attorney. >> yep. >> marilyn moseby she's not been state's attorney for very long. >> first term. >> is that going to be a conflict ultimately? >> no. i represent -- >> your constituent -- are your constituents going to say we want to see prosecutions and your wife might have to come back and say we don't have enough to prosecute with? >> at the end of the day, if that's the dialogue, if that's the way the situation turns, whether, you know, it's my wife or a friend or i don't know her that's still that conflict that's there. what i need to do is represent the voice of my constituents. we have a clear demarcation her office versus my office. >> obviously i would imagine you have confidence in this state's attorney's office to make a criminal case if there's a criminal case to be made. >> yeah. i think we just need to be very settled with a thorough investigation to ensure that they get to the bottom of this. you know, since day one the
5:14 pm
state's attorney's office has come out and communicated they've been doing their own independent investigation. so i think that we just need to see it through and allow them to -- the process to play out. >> i was in west baltimore yesterday talking to people. over the course of eight hours i had 18 people two dozen people talk to me about the police. >> yeah. >> and tell me stories. >> yeah. >> broke my ribs nabbed me for no reason, pushed me out of a van. is there sthijs systemic that freddie gray aside has to be addressed more robustly than it is being addressed now? >> extremely systemic. when we show the violence a lot of times we're pointing back to freddie gray. freddie gray was a culmination of decades of things in this community. i'm not excusing the violence. we have to calm our communities. however, it's important not to just talk about the what but tallas why. and when you have decades old of poverty, un or undereducated
5:15 pm
generations, they don't unfortunately know how to communicate their frustrations. that's what they did with their violence. >> commissioner anthony batts was brought here to change. is the change happening fast enough? >> many people are not seeing the change. they're upset with the current situation. at the end of the day, we haven't seen a major american city go up like this in quite some time. i think this is a very tough time. i think this is a time of collaborative effort. i think they did an excellent job yesterday of calming the streets. but folks are disgruntled and angry in the communities. >> nick moseby represents win chester on west baltimore where freddie gray was. >> thanks chris. >> nice to see you. first was made in major league baseball today. for the first time since the game has been played since about 1882, a game played in front of zero people. we're going to show you some pictures of that and talk to the baltimore orioles exec twhoif had some very surprising thoughts on the roots of the baltimore riots. after this.
5:16 pm
i take these out... put in dr. scholl's active series insoles. they help reduce wear and tear on my legs, becuase they have triple zone protection. ... and reduce shock by 40%. so i feel like i'm ready to take on anything. (music) boys? stop less. go more. the passat tdi clean diesel with up to 814 hwy miles per tank. just one reason volkswagen is the #1 selling diesel car brand in america. constipated? .yea dulcolax tablets can cause cramps but not phillips. it has magnesium and works more naturally than stimulant laxatives. for gentle cramp free relief of occasional
5:17 pm
constipation that works! mmm mmm live the regular life.
5:18 pm
a life-long resident of baltimore came up and talked to me and how we're portraying it with our baltimores. i asked him act the iconic representation of the city and he said i love it and i'm sick of hearing about it. you can move the world. but to get from the old way to the new, you'll need the right it infrastructure. from a partner who knows how to make your enterprise more agile, borderless and secure. hp helps businesses move on all the possibilities of today. and stay ready for everything that is still to come.
5:19 pm
there are lots of ways to save money. here's one way. esurance. they were born online and built to save. they major in efficiency which means when they save, you save. they have smart online tools that help you find the right coverage. so you only pay for what's right for you. plus a personalized set of discounts you can take to the bank. cha-ching! that's insurance for the modern world. esurance, backed by allstate. click or call.
5:20 pm
>> it has attracted people in to see the place and not just massive shelters for poor. >> when camden yards was built, it was a crowned jewel of a revitalization effort to turn around a city many perceived as being caught in inexorable decline. in some ways it achieved that. the cornerstone of a revitalized downtown inner harbor, a baseball park people have modeled their own stadiums after across the country.
5:21 pm
but it also stands as a representation of one baltimore in a city that very much as we're seeing has two baltimores. this weekend, those two baltimores clashed at the stadium and in the wake of that the orioles decided to postpone two games and today facing a third postponement they made a different decision -- casey hunt was there to record history being made at camden yards today. >> beautiful look at baltimore downtown on a glorious spring day. 74 degrees, sun shining, so pretty outside. >> reporter: they usually chant "let's go o's" but today at camden yards, "o" meant zero. what should have been a routine afternoon game against the white sox made history. it's unprecedented in the history of baseball. >> that's unprecedented. and, you know, it's not ideal. you know, we acknowledge that.
5:22 pm
the comfort of our fans and public safety are paramount concerns for the orioles. >> reporter: fans watched and cheered through the gates. shut out of the stadium. as a police helicopter circled. team with major league baseball made the call after days of civil unrest in baltimore. >> i think that, you know the people that -- it wasn't the right thing to do but they made it very clear and we need change here and hopefully that will happen. >> reporter: tensions ran high this weekend after a west baltimore man, freddie gray died in police custody. >> we're going to take north avenue and we ain't giving it back. >> reporter: outside the ballpark on saturday protesters clashing with police. >> don't shoot! >> the chant is "hands up don't shoot," which we heard starting in ferguson missouri. >> reporter: that night fans held in the stadium. officials concerned about public safety. the next two games were canceled as riots raged in the city. some wondered if today's game
5:23 pm
should be played at all. other major league games have been moved because of public unrest. in 1992 in los angeles after the rodney king verdict and in 1967 in detroit because of rioting. but there never has been a game quite like this. when the ball players took the field at camden yards this afternoon, they came out to this unprecedented sight -- no one in the stands. >> every day it's normal to hear the national anthem or people screaming "o" during the national anthem. there's nothing. >> it's not easy you know. this whole process is not easy, man. we need this game to be played but we need the city to be healed first. >> reporter: the o's were supposed to play the tampa bay rays here this weekend. instead, they'll play as the home team down in florida. it means die hard fans will have to wait a little longer to come to a home game. and so will the vendors, concession stand workers, and everyone else around baltimore who depend on the orioles to make a living.
5:24 pm
>> on saturday night in the footage that casey presented there, and you saw those sort of clashes between some of the protesters, some of the fans at the game fans held in the stadium afterwards the chief operating officer of the baltimore orioles took to twitter. john angelos was exchanging opinions with people on twitter and he had a really interesting perspective. he said this -- "the innocent working families of all backgrounds whose lives and dreams have been cut short by excessive violence surveillance, and other abuses of the bill of rights by government pay the true price and ultimate price and one that far exceeds the importances of any kids' game played tonight or ever at camden yards. we need to keep in mind people are suffering and dying around the u.s. and while we are thankful no one was injured at camden yards there's a far bigger picture for poor americans in baltimore and everywhere who don't have jobs and are losing economic civil, and legal rights. and this makes inconvenience at a ball game irrelevant in light of the needless suffering government is inflicting upon ordinary americans."
5:25 pm
that got a lot of attention considering he's the man in charge of the baltimore orioles on a day-to-day level. john angelos today talked to me about what he meant in tinner harbor. >> we're playing a game. i think it's the lowest attendance in the history of baseball was in the 1880s. >> 1828. a game with six people. >> so you know it. there you go. and we're going to beat that record i think. >> the best you can make of a strange situation. >> yeah. i think the city officials and the state of maryland and major league baseball and along with the orioles attempted to come up with a good solution and there really wasn't any ideal solution so we're doing the best we can in light of the larger circumstances out in the community. >> so saturday, you know they had this peaceful march, 4,000 or 5,000 people largely without incident until the very end. there were some sort of conflict around folks when they came down to camden yard for the baseball game.
5:26 pm
some concern about that. that picture on the cover of the pap we are the young guy beating up the car smashing windows. you read this saying i'm upset about the car but really i'm upset about the conditions that have produced the kind of unrest we're seeing. why did you write that? >> i think i wrote it because perspectives on this issue are multiple and i was concerned that the perspective was going to shift too far too quickly to what was going on at an entertainment venue. camden yards is a great asset to the community. it's done wonderful things. baseball has a lot of benefits for baltimore and the community. at the end of the day, it's entertainment, discretionary. what's more important is the community itself. i just wanted to move the discussion back to the real lives of everyday people living throughout the community. >> living in a city as you said you know, once had a very big kind of blue-collar base. it had an industrial core. people were able to get jobs
5:27 pm
fairly easily sustain middle-class life pap lot of that is left. there's under armour there across the harbor still a fairly active harbor folks working the shipyards, but a lot of that base has been hollowed out. you've now got a city where we're in fells appointment, right, a city that looks like a lot of cities in the 21st century america where there's a lot of poor folk some service jobs, then some people with money. >> that's right. i think the word hollowed out is a good term to use. i don't think it a baltimore phenomenon. it's a national phenomenon. baltimore is reflecting the nation's problem in that regard. 50 years ago, the percentage of manufacturing jobs in this country was in the 30% to 40%, and the impact of it was much much greater because today you have 12 million manufacturing jobs. you have another 17 million jobs let's say that are supported by that. of course manufacturing jobs have a much higher wage premium attached to them. and they also benefit the nation as a whole because you can't
5:28 pm
train services globally. you can trade goods. so manufacturing has always been key for this country for cities like baltimore and cities around the country. and it's always going to be key. the question is why is the system failed to keep that in mind and how do we get that back on track so that we can bring high-paying, long-term lasting jobs to people in baltimore and around the country. >> but if you look at the plan for urban renewal here in baltimore and we'll use baltimore because we're walking through it lovely neighborhood in fells point, we have bar, hotel, ice cream shops. this looks like if you go to the kind of revitalized downtown across america, it looks like, this right? >> that's right. >> that's the plan. the plan is like get some high-tech entrepreneurs, get some yoga going, get your whole foods, you know, bring in this sort of class of people that are educated and hope that brings enough investment to a place to revitalize it. but if you drive through west
5:29 pm
baltimore where we were yesterday, it doesn't look like it's reaching out there. >> that's right. it's sort of a derivation of of trickle-down economics of the '80s perhaps. if you look at baltimore in the '80s and early '90s, it was going through the rejuvenation, dollar house program in federal hill harborplace, camden yards, all of which by the way were controversial at the time. >> yep. >> public referendums that were fairly close, state legislature votes that were close. and because of the bravery of certain politicians, those projects were pushed through. and if you look at as you say, the periphery of the baltimore inner harbor it's wonderful. if people come here as tourists they're completely safe. there's no crime problem here in those areas if you're a tourist. but if you live in poor neighborhoods in baltimore, because every criminologist study you look at the overwhelming majority of crime is perpetrated by poor people on other poor people not poor people on middle clas and wealthy and the elite. so the problem is not on the
5:30 pm
inner harbor. the problem is the same time that tourism rejuvenation was going on on a national level, the manufacturing base of the country was being gutted by notions of globalization and offshoring and it takes a village and all the rest of that. now, that was the philosophy that became policy. and i think if you look back on that 25 to 50 years, now in hindsight, you can say, and a lot of people thought that then but we've all had the benefit of the experience, has it worked i don't think it's worked at all. you know, my grandmother worked at a factory called western electric. that was one of many factories, bethlehem steel, bethlehem shipyard unilever western electric automotive plant, none of that exists anymore. so it's easy to look across the aisle and say -- or across the city and say, well look at these poor neighborhoods. why don't people just work harder. well, people depending on your educational level, only have certain options. the educational system is
5:31 pm
failing in part because the manufacturing base has gone away producing tax incomes and so forth. the opportunity my grandmother had, i don't see that here today. and i don't think the people in these neighborhoods are working-class people and some of the neighborhoods that have been featured on television where the local people are working hard every day, community organizer, et cetera. you've seen them on television. it's not any failing of theirs. they need jobs. >> final question. folks that sell concessions at camden, they just out of luck today? >> no. i think that that would be an unfair result. i think that we need to do something that will make people whole. >> okay. >> this is an extraordinary situation that happens, you know, hopefully never happens but when it does happen you got to solve the larger problem but you don't want individuals to pay the price. >> baltimore orioles chief operating officer john angelos, son of peter angelos, who owns the team weather me in the iper harbor today. more coming up. baltimore's own son barry
5:32 pm
levenson, two actors from "the wire" to talk about the way that representation of baltimore has become a phenomenon. and also we'll talk to a congressman who voted for the crime bill about what he thinks of what's happened to the politics of crime. taxi. vo: after years of being treated like she was invisible it occurred to mindy she might actually be invisible. ♪♪ but mindy was actually not invisible. ooh, what are you doing? can you see me? she had just always been treated that way. yeah. you don't have to look at me like that. there are worst things than an attractive woman touching your body. i'll go. join the nation that sees you as a priority. ♪ nationwide is on your side ♪ working on my feet all day gave me pain here. in my lower back but now, i step on this machine and get my number which matches my dr. scholl's custom fit orthotic inserts. now i get immediate relief from my foot pain. my lower back pain. find a machine at
5:33 pm
let's take a look at your credit. >>i know i have a 786 fico score, thanks to all the tools and help on so how are we going to sweeten this deal? floor mats... clear coats... >>you're getting warmer... leather seats... >>and this... my wife bought me that. get your credit swagger on. become a member of experian credit tracker and find out your fico score powered by experian. fico scores are used in 90% of credit decisions. ♪ nexium 24hr. it's the purple pill.
5:34 pm
the #1 prescribed acid blocking brand. available without a prescription for frequent heartburn. get complete protection. nexium level protectiontm.
5:35 pm
there is an ancient rhythm... [♪] that flows through all things... through rocky spires... [♪] and ocean's swell... [♪] the endless... stillness of green... [♪] and in the restless depths of human hearts... [♪] the voice of the wild within. a solidarity prost protest has resulted in a bunch-arrests. in the street earlier tonight
5:36 pm
new york city police circulating flyers warning protesters not to go in the street, that they would be arrested. early on sh lots of arrests made. it seems now the police have essentially made them onto the street on west side highway blocking off traffic. we'll continue to monitor that. it appears the police have sort of backed off a bit after initially doing quite a bit of ares although it now seems they are darting if into the crowd to grab people and arrest them. you can see that right there. new york city police has had an oscillating attitude towards these kind of protests. early in the days after it was announced eric garner -- the police officers who were involved in his death would not be facing any prosecution, there were many protests in new york. those protests tended to be in the street. new york city police officers essentially receiving orders to fall back and keep a limited presence ashgs lou presence, allow protesters to take the streets. least at least at the outset of this protest, a different
5:37 pm
posture. we see now police sort of lining up next to protesters in the street there. they have been doing snatch-and-grabs. we will be monitoring this situation and also bring you two actors from "the wire" to talk about that show ahead. ♪ ♪ the beautiful sound of customers making the most of their united flight. power, wi-fi and streaming entertainment. that's... seize the journey friendly. when it comes to good nutrition...i'm no expert. that would be my daughter -- hi dad. she's a dietitian. and back when i wasn't eating right, she got me drinking boost. it's got a great taste and it helps give me the nutrition i was missing. helping me stay more like me. [ female
5:38 pm
announcer ] boost complete nutritional drink has 26 essential vitamins and minerals, including calcium and vitamin d to support strong bones and 10 grams of protein to help maintain muscle. all with a delicious taste. grandpa! [ female announcer ] stay strong, stay active with boost. these days you may be hearing more about data breaches in the news. it's possible your personal information may be at risk. research shows that if your information is compromised due to a data breach you are 6 times more likely to become a victim of identity theft. now is the time to get protection.
5:39 pm
sign up today and lifelock will begin monitoring your personal information, including your social security number alert you about suspicious activity and if needed, take steps to help restore your losses. you only have one identity. protect it with the best. lifelock. bring us your aching... and sleep deprived. bring us those who want to feel well rested and ready to enjoy the morning ahead. aleve pm. the first to combine a sleep aid... plus the 12 hour pain relieving strength of aleve.
5:40 pm
for pain relief that can last until the am. so you... you... and you, can be a morning person again. aleve pm, for a better am. kwet again the streets of a major city are marred by violence violence, by shouts of anger and shows of force and shatter glass. yet again a community is reeling, its fault lines laid bare and its bonds of trust and respect frayed. >> democratic presidential candidate hillary clinton was widely expected at her speech at columbia university to at least mention recent events in baltimore. she did much more than that, laying out a vision of criminal justice reform that would create
5:41 pm
a divisive break with her huh's policies and the whole of the democratic party. >> it's time to end the era of mass incarceration. we need a true national debate about how to reduce our prison population while keeping our communities safe. today there seems to be a growing bipartisan movement for commonsense reforms in our criminal justice system. senators as disparate on the political spectrum as cory booker and rand paul and dick durbin and mike lee are reaching across the aisle to find ways to work together. >> republican presidential candidate rand paul did not quite return the compliment. instead, here's what he said in a statement. "earlier today hillary clinton proposed various criminal justice reform ideas in an attempt to undo some of bill clinton's work -- the same work she cheerily supported a first lady. the
5:42 pm
." the very fact the two are competing whoever are will reform the criminal justice system is a testament to how much the politics of this issue have changed. former chair of the congressional black caucus kweisi mfume. nice to have you here. you represented baltimore in the 1990s when the crime bill came before you and when crime was very high compared to what it is now. >> mm-hmm. >> and when the national political discussion was more cops, more punishment more jail. what's changed? >> well we have more crime, we have more disparity, more poverty and more distrust. trying to do this in a bill that was flawed -- they put some stuff in it to sweeten it up -- was really not the answer. the core of all that you are seeing and that the nation is seeing is the fact that poverty, despair, homelessness hunger depravation, degradation continues in these communities. you can't box it in with a piece of legislation. >> here's the thing that's so strange about the last 20 years, is that in new york city where i'm from in the bronx where i'm
5:43 pm
from, baltimore, the murder rate has gone down sharply, still very high in certain neighborhoods, gone down sharply. crime has gone down sharply. poverty hasn't gotten any better. >> no. >> so it allows the political system to say, well we don't have to worry about it anymore. >> the political system likes washing its hands. the fact of the matter poverty is increasing. unemployment in these communities in west baltimore where freddie was killed and most of the pockets around the city for black men, latinos and poor whites is astronomical. two, sometimes three times the national average. so i don't understand what's going on. i see where harry reid directed his staff to come back with some ideas about what to do with this issue. i'm trying to figure out where was that kind of thinking back seven years ago when my party, the democratic party, controlled the white house, controlled the senate controlled the house of representatives and you could have gotten anything through because you controlled the volts. harry reid please, give mae break. >> do you think the democratic party has basically done wrong
5:44 pm
by the folks of sandtown win chest sfer. >> i don't know if the party has done wrong. i think all of america has looked the other way and hoped that what we know and see day in and day out would either fix itself or go away neither of which was going to happen. so it's a matter of talking the talk but not walking the walk. these communities -- people are not stealing because they want to be criminals. they're not walking away and setting cars on fire -- what they're saying is look at me i exist, i'm not invisible. is it right? no, it's wrong. it's absolutely wrong. and it will be dealt with. that's why men have been all over the streets and i've been with a bunch of them for the last few days trying to talk this thing through. the community needs a conversation. but what they're saying is look at me, i exist. don't look away from me anymore. >> did you vote the wrong way on the crime bill in '94? >> here's the thing about the crime bill in 1994 there was no vote. it was a voice vote. you didn't even have to be there. all in favor, aye, all opposed no, and that's how it passed.
5:45 pm
>> now uncontroversial the day was. more cops three strikes -- >> 41 new categories for the death penalty. increase in the amount of money for prisons, decrease in the amount of money for fre vengs. >> that was just a unanimously held opinion across both parties. >> well, you know, when you have a vote and say all in favor, aye, all opposed no and there is no roll call you sort of sweep it under the rug and assume that everybody's going to support it. >> the law and order politics that have given us mass incarceration, many people point to nixon, particularly the watts riot, after king that happened in baltimore in 1968, detroit and other places as the starting point of that right? >> mm-hmm. >> are we going to see a different trajectory come out of the kind of black lives matter movement we've seen over the last nine, ten months? >> well let's go back over the last 47 years because when this city erupted in 1968 and all of us were out in the streets being arrested just for being on your doorstep and arrested 6,000 people, what has changed in 47 years? you walk the streets of east baltimore, west baltimore, some of those areas still look like
5:46 pm
they looked in '68. you know, so the crime bill had its detractors had those who supported it. did anything come out of it? well, it took the violence against women's act and drove it in because they knew everybody would vote for that, and they took several other pieces of legislation, but, you know, the fact of the matter is that when you control the house, the senate, and the white house for two years and you can't find a way to use the votes to do what you have to do i got issue with that, i have an issue with my party and that respect. ain't party that is progressive and that takes the opportunity to do what it can. >> mr. mfume, thank you very much. that was well said. >> thank you. appreciate it. >> former congressman kweisi mfume. we will be back with barry levenson.
5:47 pm
5:48 pm
joining me now, barry levenson i was talking to somebody who came up to me who wanted to talk to me about what i was getting wrong about baltimore. one of the things he said was people focus on race and there's a lot here that has to do with race but there's also the insiders and the outsiders, people who are from here really from here and people who aren't from here. i'm curious what you make of that distinction. >> you know, first of all, i just want to say i've been listening to the entire show. you've had some incredibly articulate people making some wonderful points this evening, which i wonder where what i'm doing here because they've been sensational. the question you ask, look i
5:49 pm
come from baltimore, i grew up -- it's in my dna and i've tried to show different aspects of baltimore in the films and in the homicide tv series. >> what is it about the city that's kind of lent itself to dramatic representation so well? >> it's a city of characters really colorful character, and, you know i hear those -- i hear those sounds and how they behave and how they talk and i've tried to, you know, bring that to television and to film over the years. and that's my background. you know, a lot of times when i'm, you know, going out to promote a film they'll say, you know, why baltimore? and i say well, that's where i come from. i mean, those are the people that i know and i hear and i try to depict different times in the films i've dealt with in the '40s, the '50s, the '60s, and of course "homicide," which was
5:50 pm
shot in real time during the '90s. but i just try to portray that i know something about. >> do you ever find yourself -- and i know i'm from the bronx and i'm -- i grew up in the bronx in the 1980s which kind of became this sort of national icon for urban decay and burned-out buildings, graffiti on subways, empty lots. it was the stand-in in people's imagination. people in the bronx still have a chip on their shoulder about that. they're very touchy about representations in the bronx. do you feel hike you have that or you think about that when you think about how you're representing the city? >> no. i'm first and foremost trying to think of characters that stood out, that were strong in my mind that i hope other people can relate to in some way. and i just use that as the building blocks to try to tell various type of stories. >> do you think that we are going to see more art made about baltimore -- obviously you and david simon have played really
5:51 pm
instrumental roles in bringing these things to the stream. do you think we're going to keep seeing representations of baltimore? >> i think, look an entire new generation comes up that grew up in baltimore and they will have their own viewpoints and hopefully they'll be able to get their stories, you know, into film or on to vel television and they'll be telling it in their own way and in their own style. so i think there's a bit of a tradition of it. you know and i think that should continue hopefully. like john waters that grew up in another section, he was looking at it from his point of view from the side of the city that he came from. i was trying to portray it from another side. and there are a lot of young filmmakers that are coming up that have stories to tell and hopefully they'll get that opportunity. >> all right. baltimore's own barry levinson thank you very much. appreciate your time. >> thank you, chris. thanks. bodie and chris from "the wire" ahead.
5:52 pm
there's nothing more romantic than a spontaneous moment. so why pause to take a pill? and why stop what you're doing to find a bathroom? with cialis for daily use, you don't have to plan around either. it's the only daily tablet approved to treat erectile dysfunction so you can be ready anytime the moment is right. plus cialis treats the frustrating urinary symptoms of bph, like needing to go frequently, day or night. tell your doctor about all your medical conditions and medicines, and ask if your heart is healthy enough for sex. do not take cialis if you take nitrates for chest pain as it may cause an unsafe drop in blood pressure. do not drink alcohol in excess. side effects may include headache, upset stomach, delayed backache or muscle ache. to avoid long-term injury, get medical help right away for an erection lasting more than four hours. if you have any sudden decrease or loss in hearing or vision or any symptoms of an allergic reaction stop taking cialis and get medical help right away. why pause the moment? ask your doctor about cialis for daily use. for a free 30-tablet trial go to
5:53 pm
keeping a billion customers a year flying means keeping seven billion transactions flowing. and when weather hits, it's data mayhem. but airlines running hp end-to-end solutions are always calm during a storm. so if your business deals with the unexpected hp big data and cloud solutions make sure you always know what's coming-and are ready for it. make it matter. when you do business everywhere, the challenges of keeping everyone working together can quickly become the only thing you think about. that's where at&t can help.
5:54 pm
with the tools and the network you need to make working as one easier than ever. virtually anywhere. leaving you free to focus on what matters most. ugh... ...heartburn. did someone say burn? try alka seltzer reliefchews. they work just as fast and taste better than tums smoothies assorted fruit. mmm... amazing. yeah, i get that a lot. alka seltzer heartburn reliefchews. enjoy the relief. (music) boys? stop less. go more. the passat tdi clean diesel with up to 814 hwy miles per tank. just one reason volkswagen is the #1 selling diesel car brand in america.
5:55 pm
you're not the first one to do this pr campaign against baltimore. hbo is our flagship with "the wire" at "the coroner" who's already painted a broad sweeping stroke of poverty and crime. >> all right. joining me now are two actors from "the wire," a show that for many people outside of baltimore defines the city of baltimore. one was raised in maryland, is reporting from baltimore for vice and j.d. played bodie, of course. j.d. you're from newark right?
5:56 pm
when you came down -- first of all, i want you to respond to what reverent bryant was saying. i've heard that from a number of people. their feeling that ultimately the feeling they had "the wire," that it's become so synonymous in echk's minds with baltimore, i know baltimore, i saw "the wire," they have a little bit of a resentment of it. >> i feel like people who take that view haven't taken time to watch the series. i think that the work that mr. fontana -- i'm sorry -- mr. simon did -- i max sawicky barry levinson so i'm thinking about tom fontana -- but that david simon did and all the other writers, the work that they did, they took the time to try not to paint that broad stroke he accused them of. he made sure he covered many different facets of people. there was not necessarily one good guy, one bad guy. you know, i think they try to make it as human as possible. so i can't personally agree with
5:57 pm
that even just coming from a critical standpoint. >> the show was, when it was on was relatively popular but not this huge sensation. then it became a -- this kind of cultural trove like people do feel like they know baltimore because -- is that how -- when they come up to you like -- >> every day, every day. i'm associated with "the wire." "the wire" never ended for any of us who were on the show because it's still such a part of the social consciousness but not just in the united states and baltimore but around the world. it's a great thing to still be a part of. so, yeah people feel they know baltimore and i think unless you have been here and lived here for some time and are affected by the city you don't know baltimore but "the wire" is a good way to start to have that conversation. like j.d. said they went out of their way to make sure no one was painted all good or all bad. if you take that from "the
5:58 pm
wire," even people on the streets who loved some of the street life aspects of it, if that's all they saw, i think they missed the point of the show. >> what are you doing down here? you're down here as a reporter right? >> i am. i'm here reporting for vice hbo on what's going on here. i'm from maryland and we got in the car and just came down about 40 hours ago. it's been like almost no sleep. it's been crazy. i got tear gassed last night trying to just show and depict what's been going on. it's wild. rubber bullets going everywhere. they were shooting at us and other press. it was wild. >> j.d. you're from newark, which is a city that has its own very intense experience of some of the same trends of the industrialization, police, high crime. you came down and you lived here in baltimore for a few years while you were taping right? >> correct. the first year actually i was really excited to come down. i had been there since i had done had had, but i was all into just being away from home and work ong a television show so i rented an apartment down there the first year. that first year was something i
5:59 pm
tweeted about earlier today was the year i actually did get detained. i can't call it arrested. but i was detained for eight hours. that's a whole other story. be, that first year i went through the process of trying to get to know baltimore. it reminds me of home in that it's really historic mostly black, has its own language and culture, just a lot -- there's a lot to it. the next year i decided to stay home because it was so much to try to learn and learn and squeeze into. by the third year i was used to baltimore and felt like it was a second home to me or a third home to me and i was able to go down this and actually find somewhere to stay that was a reasonable place. i actually stayed at fells point, where you were earlier. by the third year i was used to baltimore, knew the spots. it felt like home. fourth year also stayed down. it takes a while to grow on you. you have to grow into the city.
6:00 pm
>> all right. we're telling you go rewatch "the wire," study it this time. don't think you know baltimore. bodie and chris. in "the wire." thank you both. rachel maddow starts right now. >> excellent, my friend. well done. thanks for staying with us. under an hour away from the second night of a mandatory curfew in the city of baltimore. in one hour from now people protesting, ordinary citizens everybody not going to or from work or having a medical issue or working as press or law enforcement, everybody else will be asked and then told for a second night in a row to go home and clear the streets. law enforcement may use their discretion past 10:00 p.m. we expect they'll


info Stream Only

Uploaded by TV Archive on