tv The Last Word With Lawrence O Donnell MSNBC August 26, 2015 7:00pm-8:01pm PDT
left unconscious on the ground but lived to tell the tale. this spring on the 50th anniversary of bloody sunday she was back at the bridge with president obama, side by side, hand in hand. her in the wheelchair there making her way across the bridge. she died today and the white house released a statement praising her quiet heroism. she died at the age of 104. she was at the white house when president lyndon johnson signed the voting rights act in 1965. something that may have never happened without her. she was already 54 years old when she helped to organize the selma march. in which she almost lost her life. she was 104 years old today when she passed. a hard life well lived. that does it for us tonight. see you tomorrow. now it is time for "the last word with lawrence o'donnell." >> good evening, rachel. >> thanks. >> the father of a reporter
murdered on television issued a powerful statement about the need for gun control legislation. one of the key negotiators of this iran nuclear deal will join us. >> look at the deal we have with iran. >> it reflects the best of american foreign policy. >> the single worst thing the president has done. >> this is a national embarrassment. >> countries are going to line up for notes. >> a deal that makes sure iran does not get a nuclear weapon. >> if ever seen a deal take so long? it has been going on forever. >> ripped to shreds this catastrophic nuclear deal. >> this historic diplomatic breakthrough. >> we should have doubled and tripled up the sanctions and negotiated from strength. >> we negotiated from a position of weakness. >> stop financing radical islam and terrorism. >> we don't rely on bluster or bravado. >> they have kerry going on bike races, he falls and breaks his leg. he walks in like what a sh muck.
>> exports lined up to support it. >> strong principle diplomacy and showing to the world what american leadership really means. >> when secretary of state john kerry led the united states and five other countries to reach a nuclear deal with iran there was probably no one in the room wondering what donald trump would say about the deal. they all knew there would be critics of the deal. they were concerned about what israeli netanyahu would say, also what senator john mccain would say and other prominent washington critics in the negotiating effort. now there is no critic of the deal with a bigger microphone than the front runner for the republican presidential nomination. >> look at the deal we have with iran. look at this deal. it's going to, in my opinion, lead to an arms race, the likes
of which there's never been. countries are going to line up for no for nuclears. you are going to perhaps have nuclear proliferation. >> that is donald trump last night. in the "washington post" former general petraeus co-authored an op-ed piece saying there can be little doubt that a deal leaves us far better off and we don't believe if congress blocks the deal a better one will be negotiated. the support of general petraeus is weeks before congressional vote on the deal. 29 democratic senators have announced their support for the deechlt only two have announced oppositions, senator schumer and senator menendez, 15 undecide. the president needs only five of them to support the deal and sustain his veto if congress votes against the deal. joining us now is one of the key
negotiators at secretary kerry's side throughout the process, undersecretary of state for political affairs, wendy shermanen. thank you for joining us. >> thank you for having me, lawrence. >> it must come as a surprise to you that you are now in a position to have to respond to criticism being offered by donald trump who clearly now has a bigger microphone than any of the republicans in washington who are arguing against this deal. i want to play something that donald trump said last night because it's an echo, the trump version of what you have heard from many republican senate critics about the inspection periods an the possible delays involved. let's listen to the way donald trump put it last night. >> we have a 24-day wait period. so if we think they are doing nuclear, we have to wait 24 days. that's not the worst part. the worst part is, the clock
doesn't start ticking, could be 24 months. there's a whole process. they could build, shoot, a couple more build, shoot and we still wouldn't be in there checking. >> your response? >> my response is i hope mr. trump has read the agreement because if he had he'd understand that what he said is actually not accurate. indeed the international atomic agency which will do the verification of the agreement, an agreement based on verification and monitoring, not based on trust, can ask for access to any site that it is suspicious of with 24 hour's notice. if iran under the protocols in the international community is allowed to have a conversation with iran about whether they can go because it might be to a military site, same kind of conversation we or any other country might be able to have with the aiaea in any other country in world that
conversation can go on forever. in this agreement we negotiated a special access agreement. which means the iaea and iran can have it only 14 days after which will is a vote and if the majority rules and i suspect it will with the united states and our european partners, than i ran must give access within three day s. quickly as 24 hours or at the most 24 days and as secretary moniz at the department of energy said, you can't hide nuclear material for 24 days or 24 months. probably for 24 years. it's hard to get rid of it. >> i'd like to raise another point that trump mentioned last night. it is on obscure point. there was an ap report indicating there would be a form of self inspection that iran would be granted in one particular location, the ap since scrubbed that report. they erased it to the point
where you can not find anywhere some of the paragraphs contained in that report. they never issued a form iffal correction about it but donald trump seized on that. this is the way he referred to it last night. let's listen. >> we just found out they are going to do in the most important section, they are going to do their own inspections. did you hear this? i ran is going to do their own inspections. >> can you clarify that point? >> again, lawrence, that's just not true. the international atomic energy would never allow iran to do a self inspection. i think mr. trump is referring to iran's past. this is a project they have had under way for four years. they use the leverage of the negotiation to get access they want to that site. they worked out a technical arrangement that they think will get them the information they need. we have great faith and confidence in the international
atomic agency, the entire world does. mr. trump doesn't have the facts. >> there's another element to the deal which frees up certain financial resources that will be available to iran over time. that's an issue that's been attacked by many critics of the deal. let's listen to how benjamin in netanyahu phrased it. >> this will fuel iran's terrorism worldwide. its aggression in the region and its efforts to destroy israel, which are ongoing. amazingly, this bad deal does not require iran to cease its agresive behavior in any way. >> your reaction to that? >> look, i understand all of the concern and anxiety about iran's destabilizing activities in the region. i share those, the president does, secretary kerry does, but no deal can carry all of the problems we face with iran. the real objective of this deal
is to make sure iran does not have a nuclear weapon because if iran had a nuclear weapon, their ability to wreak more havoc in the region would be unthinkable and their ability to deter our efforts and our efforts with israel and our gulf partners to stop their nefarious activities would be nearly impossible. i share the concern but the president of the united states believes, president, secretary of state john kerry believes if we don't get the nuclear issue resolved we won't be able to get the other issues resolved and all of our sanctions around iran's actions, state sponsorship of terrorism, abuses of human rights, arms sales, all of these things remain on the books. what we are talking about in this deal, once they take the nuclear steps to severely limit their program, invite the iaea in, so they can verify what they are doing and make sure they do
not acquire a nuclear weapon and make that commitment forever, not just 15, 20 years but forever. that's what we have to be focused on in this deechl it just can't carry the weight of the other things but we have plenty of strategies, tools and work we are doing with israel and our gulf partners to deal with the other problems which are real. >> we have a quinnipiac poll that indicates 86% of republicans oppose the deal, which is an indication of what is happening in the senate where you don't have republicans supporting it. it is also an indicator of how donald trump, as vague as his statements may be and as inaccurate as some of them maybe is clearly mirroring the republican voter out. there i want to go to another point raised by general petraeus in the op-ed piece today where he endorses the deal. he says "we're better off with this deal" but two things concern him. one, he'd like the president to
overtly and clearly announce that a violation of the deal would absolutely provoke an american military response, and then he would like the administration to provide israel with an extra powerful bunker-busting bomb, more than anything israel is in possession of now. what is your reaction to those suggestions? >> my reaction is that the united states has an absolutely indy visible bond with israel. we will do everything we can do to have israel's back. we always have. president obama has provided more security assistance to israel than any other president, and he, in fact, developed the weapon that dave petraeus mentioned. not only developed, commissioned, paid for it and employ de employed it so it is ready and the president has been declarative that if, in fact, he needs to take military action he will. i think -- you know, i had a reporter ask me today, what is
in this deal for the average person? why should they care when they care about their wages, their kids' education, they care about their future, they care about security on the streets not necessarily first and foremost security in the world and what i said is if iran has a nuclear weapon, that's a threat to the united states. that's a threat to israel. that's a threat to the gulf. that's a threat to the world. that means that american men and women who might be some of those families or friends of some of those families will have to go off and fight a very, very difficult, complicated and explosive war with. we will use up all of our blood and treasure for that when we could be increasing wages, when we could be ensuring jobs, good educations and getting crime off our streets. so i think the president has the right priority. let's assure that iran can't have a nuclear weapon. let's have the option, all of the options on the table if iran doesn't comply we'll know if
they don't. this is not about trust. let's see if becan't give peace a chance, diplomacy a chance first. if it doesn't work, because we have done this with six other countries, and the u.n. security council has endorsed it unanimously, we will have the world on our side to take whatever other action is needed, but i think the american people prefer peace over war if a solution can be found. >> wendy sherman, thank you very much for joining us tonight. >> thank you, lawrence. coming up, the father of the reporter killed on live tv this morning just issued a passioned plea for gun control legislation. later, the general manager of that tv station will join us to remember the friends they lost today. ♪ ♪ ♪
if you can't stand the heat, get off the test track. get the mercedes-benz you've been burning for at the summer event, going on now at your authorized mercedes-benz dealer. but hurry, offers end august 31st. share your summer moments in your mercedes-benz with us. isn't it beautiful when things just come together? build a beautiful website with squarespace. it's the brand more doctorsose recommend for minor arthritis pain. plus, just two aleve can last all day. you'd need 6 tylenol arthritis to do that. aleve. all day strong.
jorge ramos remove last night. he came face to face with a trump supporter in the hallway. >> very rude. it's not about you. get out of my country. get out. >> i'm a u.s. citizen. >> well, whatever. univision, no. >> up next, the father of one of the victims of the virginia shooting, the reporter shot on live television this morning says tonight that he wants new gun laws. that's next.
of that virginia television reporter, who was murdered on live tv this morning, appeared on fox news. he discussed his daughter's life. he discussed the horrors of what he's been through today, and at the end of that discussion with megyn kelly, he said this -- >> everybody that she touched loved her, and she loved everybody back. you know, i'm not going to let this issue drop. this is, you know -- we've got to do something about crazy people getting guns. you know, and the problem that you guys have -- and i know it's the news business. this is a big story, but next week, it isn't going to be a story anymore and everybody's going to forget it. but you mark my words, my mission in life and i talked to the governor today. he called me and i told him, i said, i'm going to do something, whatever it takes to get gun
legislation to shame people, to shame legislators in to doing something about closing loopholes in background checks and making sure crazy people don't get guns. and he said, you go. i'm right there with ya. so, you know, this is not the last you have heard of me. this is something that is ailson's legacy that i want to make happen. >> joining us now april ryan, white house correspondent and bureau chief for urban merge radio networks and author of the book presidency -- economic advisers to president obama, kurptly a professor of economics at the university of chicago and here in new york with us jonathon alter, msnbc column i nis for "the daily beast." it had been a day in which various politicians made comments about this. they came in for some criticism on fox news. there's always an objection to raising anything about possible legislation on the day -- the
inevitable days of coverage we have of these kinds of events. then on fox news tonight that dramatic moment, something that is not a very welcome message on that network that we have to do something legislatively. >> we have seen this before, i hate to say it. after these terrible tragedies, where family members come forward and pledge to do this. the point is you have to have a ten nasty about it. political struggle, change in this country is hard. it's a long slog. the problem is people in favor of common sense gun control, most of them don't have the passion with those loved ones do about the issue. they have to develop the passion, if this is going to change. it requires movement building. it requires people who have not had somebody in their family who's been a victim of gun
violence to decide i'm going to pitch in. i'm going to lobby. i'm going to make this important. when that starts to happen, then change is possible. >> april ryan, andy parker, who we just heard on fox news, the worst imaginable day of his life or any parents life said he wants to shame legislators in to doing this. that's what he told megyn kelly, closing loopholes and background checks and making sure crazy people don't get guns. that seems like something that should be unanimous agreement on. >> the way we understood it, there was an agreement between democrats and republicans on it but it wasn't acted upon. one of the main reasons was because of a powerful gun lobby called the nra. i just understand this is happening. you see this happen in columbine. you seen this happen with the school children. we have seen this happen so many
times, over and over again. we saw it most recently in roanoke and just before that the situation in charleston. it happens over and over again. the calls go out, but we're not hearing the ground swell that we would think would be happening, particularly on capitol hill and republicans who, are listening to the powerful gun lobby of the nra. >> let's listen to what chris herself said tonight. he is actually the boyfriend of alison parker who was murdered this morning. >> i think we need to be careful with how we identify this man and we don't label him and then discriminate against everybody else who has a mental illness in this country who needs access to services, but clearly something went wrong here between him leaving our station and being able to purchase a gun and commit a premeditated act. what happened behind us was clearly wrong, but there's been ample time beforehand where many
other things went wrong. those need to be addressed. not any of the allegations he is saying about the love of my life. >> austin goolsbee, there's -- this becomes political no matter how much people try to keep the politics out of this, ssh especially in the first day of coverage. some people believe there shouldn't be any political references to it but we saw the father of this murdered reporter tonight going straight to that. >> yes. i mean, god, your heart is just broken for this father. the day this is going to happen and then you are thrust in to the national spotlight in that way. i guess my only feeling on this is this has happened so many times that we are kind of stuck in this rut. we know what the advocates of gun control are going to say, we ought to pass these laws and o.swill say no, we will oppose it. i wonder if the approach that
the father is advocating, we're going to shame them, try to confront them, maybe we have to take a different approach. one, there are in this case and some of the other cases laws on the books that weren't enforced properly or things like that where you could take action, executive -- by executive order you could take some actions just in keeping with the laws that are on the books perhaps and then second, i kind of think we almost had april said bipartisan agreement on the issue of should those with mental illness be able to purchase weapons. it feels like that's an area of, let's press on that and see where there might be some overlapping agreement rather than just get it in to c
connotaticoto confrontation. >> let's listen to what hillary clinton said today. >> we have to do something about gun violence in america and i will take it on. there are many people who face it and know it but then turn away because it's hard. it's a very political, difficult issue in america. i feel just great heart ache at what happened. i want to reiterate how important it is we not let yet another terrible instance go by without trying to do something more to prevent this incredible killing that stalking our country. >> jonathon alter, we just heard andy parker say that he says i know this is the news business. i this is a big story, but next week it isn't going to be a story anymore and everybody's going to forget. that's what he feels tonight
will happen. >> well, i'm sorry to say he's right. i mean that's just the nature of the news business. that's the nature of the short attention span of the american people. it's up to the politicians and the people whose job it is to mobilize and pressure those politicians to keep the issue going in state legislatures and in washington. i think austin goolsbee's suggestion is an interesting one. the white house to take another look at whether there are things that could be done by executive order to better enforce the laws that are on the books, and the rest of us have to be willing to develop arguments against people on the other side that we are not doing. for instance, you always hear a law wouldn't have stopped this guy. he would have gotten a gun any way. that is like saying all laws are futile. just because people commit murder, does that mean we shouldn't have laws against
murder. because people commit tax evasion doesn't mean we shouldn't have laws against tax evasion. that's a nonsensical argument you hear all the time. just because a law wouldn't have prevented this particular case, doesn't mean it might not prevent some other cases of gun violence. you know, the people who are engaged in this debate need to get more serious about confronting the nra on each of the arguments. >> lawrence, i would also highlight, we have had a background check environment structure in place for some time. yes, there are loopholes in it. i think it is worth highlighting there's been a number of dramatic number of reductions during the time we have had the background check in. just highlighting these things can work is also part of the equation. >> yeah. there's never going to be a news story about the person who was denied access to a gun who was
never able to pull this off. that story will never make it to our attention. >> the states that have more gun safety laws do better in restricting gun violence than those that don't. the nra lies and says the opposite. >> quick break in here. coming up, we will be joined by the general manager of the virginia television station, his reporter and camera operator were murdered on live tv this morning. when you're not confident your company's data is secure, the possibility of a breach can quickly become the only thing you think about.
introducing otezla, apremilast. otezla is not an injection, or a cream. it's a pill that treats plaque psoriasis differently. some people who took otezla saw 75% clearer skin after 4 months. and otezla's prescribing information has no requirement for routine lab monitoring. don't take otezla if you are allergic to any of its ingredients. otezla may increase the risk of depression. tell your doctor if you have a history of depression or suicidal thoughts, or if these feelings develop. some people taking otezla reported weight loss. your doctor should monitor your weight and may stop treatment. side effects may include diarrhea, nausea, upper respiratory tract infection, and headache. tell your doctor about all the medicines you take, and if you're pregnant or planning to be. ask your doctor about otezla today. otezla. show more of you.
it's my very sad duty to report that we have determined through the help of the police and our employees that alison and adam died this morning shortly after 6:45 when the shots rang out. i cannot tell you how much they were loved. alison and adam by theed wi/* b team. they were in love and we will talk about that. and our hearts are broke and our sympathies go to the staff here and the families. >> the general manager for wdbj tv speaking about the murders of alison parker and adam.
the shooter sent a 28-page fax to abc news two hours after the shooting with a list of grievances including how he was treated when he was a reporter at that station himself. he apparently posted his own video of the shooting on social media, which was quickly taken down by facebook and twitter. the gunman's own 56-second video showed him deliberately waiting until the journalists were on air before raising a handgun and firing at point blank range, ensuring it would be seen live or recorded by thousands. joining us now, jeffrey marks, the general manager of wdbj tv in roanoke, virginia. mr. marks, first of all, i'm sorry for your loss today, your personal losses in this. i can't imagine what this day has been like for you.
i very much appreciate you staying with us tonight. can you tell us where you were at 6:45 a.m. and how this event came in to your life? >> i was running an errand and very near the television station. so right after the incident occurred my news director called me and said did you see that and of course i had not seen that. she told me what immediately had happened and i was here within five minutes. >> mr. marks, at the point where you are being called -- i assume in the control room they don't really know what happened, what the actual results were there on the ground? >> i think they weren't sure whether it was fireworks or something else. i think some of them knew instantly but didn't want to imagine it. but they immediately lost touch with adam and alison, couldn't reach them on their cell phones and that's a very bad sign.
>> after the camera went down, they heard in the control room, what was it, eight shots were fired when the camera wasn't picking up anything? >> i guess that's right. i didn't count them. i watched the video once or twice, but it was such a horrifying scene, i didn't stop to count the shots. >> what was it like on a personal level? i saw you go through an extraordinary day where on the air at wdbj you had to bring this to your community, your viewing community and share everything you were going through live because the community was going through it, too. what was that experience like? >> well, we were grieving while doing our jobs. we were trying to breathe while doing what journalists do. we have such a fine team here of people on the air and behind the scenes and every department of
our building rallied, came through the newsroom and said what can we do? our friends at the station down the street, offered to help us in any way they could. we heard from folks around the world anda there are flowers everywhere here and signs at our entrance expressing people's solidarity with us and their sense of community of loss. it was the worst day for all of us in terms of our careers. >> tell us what you would like us to know and remember about alison parker and adam ward. >> first of all, they had both found love here. they were above in love. those relationships were going strong. those of course -- there's no way to even imagine how awful the other parties feel. you saw one earlier, i believe, chris who was speaking to
another network. the sense of loss for everybody in our building was palpable. alison was exuberant and fun and smiling and jumping at every opportunity she was given, whether it was to cohost a parade or work on a very intensive child abuse special we aired last week. adam was with the life of the party. he was a cut up. in latin class at the university, i'm told, and a cut up in our newsroom but also a serious journalist who made instant friends with everybody he covered. i can't imagine that if you put 1,000 people in front of me for candidates for those jobs that i wouldn't have picked out alison and adam. >> you have really brought them to life for us throughout the
day with everything you have had to say about them. since we are in the same business, i think we here all feel like we know them because we know so many people like them, with that same kind of commitment and same joy about doing this kind of work. >> yeah. >> and in my experience, that depends almost entirely on the tone set by the boss. so there's definitely a tribute to you here in how that place operates and everything worked at your station today. >> well, let me also pay tribute to the senior management team, who work with me to create an at moss fear in which these people can flourish. i'm not in the newsroom every day slugging it out. our team of fabulous news editors try to bring out the best in everyone and let them be themselves and they certainly did that with adam and alison and you saw the results in the performance we got on the air.
>> jeffrey marks, thank you very much for joining us tonight. i'm very sorry for your loss and i wish you all the best in trying to get through the coming days. thank you very much. >> thank you, lawrence. coming up, joe biden and hillary clinton both talked about joe biden running for president today. you owned your car for four years. you named it brad. you loved brad. and then you totaled him. you two had been through everything together. two boyfriends. three jobs. you're like "nothing can replace brad!" then liberty mutual calls. and you break into your happy dance. if you sign up for better car replacement, we'll pay for a car that's a model year newer with 15,000 fewer miles than your old one. see car insurance in a whole new light. liberty mutual insurance.
♪ mother nature can turn in an instant; don't turn back. introducing the new 2016 ford explorer. be unstoppable. ♪ this is my fight song... ♪ ♪ isn't it beautiful when things just come together? build a beautiful website with squarespace. to folks out there whose diabetic nerve pain... shoots and burns
its way into your day, i hear you. to everyone with this pain that makes ordinary tasks extraordinarily painful, i hear you. make sure your doctor hears you too! i hear you because i was there when my dad suffered with diabetic nerve pain. if you have diabetes and burning, shooting pain in your feet or hands, don't suffer in silence! step on up and ask your doctor about diabetic nerve pain. tell 'em cedric sent you. can you tell what makes them so different?. did you hear that sound? of course you didn't. you're not using ge software like the rig on the right. it's listening and learning how to prevent equipment failures, predict maintenance needs, and avoid problems before they happen. you don't even need a cerebral cortex to understand which is better. now, two things that are exactly the same have never been more different. ge software. get connected. get insights. get optimized.
the rest of the show is going to feel much lighter after what we have just been through the last couple of segments. today in iowa, hillary clinton for the first time discussed the possible of a biden for president campaign. >> let me start by saying vice president biden is a friend of mine. he and i were colleagues in the senate. i worked with him as first lady. i worked with him obviously in president obama's first term. and i've a great deal of admiration and affection for him. i just want him to reach whatever he thinks the right decision is, and he has to do that. it has to be a really hard one. i was at his son's funeral.
i cannot imagine the grief and the heart break. i mean joe has had more terrible events than most people can even contemplate. losing his first wife, losing his first daughter, now losing his son. he has to do what he has to do. i'm just going to continue with my campaign. i'm going to do i believe i should be doing, and he will have to decide what he should be doing. >> after a quick break, what joe biden had to say today about running for president. rthritis . and you're talking to a rheumatologist about a biologic, this is humira. this is humira helping to relieve my pain and protect my joints from further damage. this is humira helping me reach for more. doctors have been prescribing humira for more than 10 years.
humira works for many adults. it targets and helps to block a specific source of inflammation that contrubutes to ra symptoms. humira can lower your ability to fight infections, including tuberculosis. serious, sometimes fatal infections and cancers, including lymphoma, have happened, as have blood, liver and nervous system problems, serious allergic reactions, and new or worsening heart failure. before treatment, get tested for tb. tell your doctor if you've been to areas where certain fungal infections are common, and if you've had tb, hepatitis b, are prone to infections, or have flu-like symptoms or sores. don't start humira if you have an infection. talk to your doctor and visit humira.com this is humira at work. imagine - she won't have to or obsess about security. she'll log in with her smile. he'll have his very own personal assistant. and this guy won't just surf the web. he'll touch it. scribble on it. and share it. because these kids will grow up with windows 10.
get started today. windows 10. a more human way to do. ♪ (vo) you can pass down a subaru forester. (dad) she's all yours. (vo) but you get to keep the memories. love. it's what makes a subaru, a subaru. when a moment spontaneously turns romantic, why pause to take a pill? and why stop what you're doing to find a bathroom? cialis for daily use, is the only daily tablet approved to treat erectile dysfunction so you can be ready anytime the moment is right. plus cialis treats the frustrating urinary symptoms
of bph, like needing to go frequently, day or night. tell your doctor about all your medical conditions and medicines, and ask if your heart is healthy enough for sex. do not take cialis if you take nitrates for chest pain, as it may cause an unsafe drop in blood pressure. do not drink alcohol in excess. side effects may include headache, upset stomach, delayed backache or muscle ache. to avoid long-term injury, get medical help right away for an erection lasting more than four hours. if you have any sudden decrease or loss in hearing or vision, or any symptoms of an allergic reaction, stop taking cialis and get medical help right away. ask your doctor about cialis for daily use. insurance coverage has expanded nationally and you may now be covered. contact your health plan for the latest information. nbc confirmed that vice
president biden discussed the possibility of running for president on a conference call this afternoon. the vice president spoke with democratic national committee members about the obama administration's nuclear deal with iran, but according to a democratic source familiar with the call, the vice president also said this "we're dealing at home with whether or not there is the emotional fuel at this time to run f. i were to announce to run, i have to be able to commit to all of you that i would be able to give it my whole heart and my whole soul and right now both are pretty well banged up." . ezra klein writes in a piece that a joe biden campaign would be a good thing but it would be a good thing for hillary clinton. he writes an actual fight will gift the press an presidential campaign to cover rather than a front rubber to investigate and a fight will sharpen clinton's instincts. we're back with the panel here. jonathon alter, i'm always
intrigued by people who think it will be good for the candidate if another strong candidate gets in there and campaigns against the candidate. i don't think any campaign has ever felt, boy, this would be -- the only thing that could make this campaign better is if we had a stronger candidate running against us. >> i used to agree with ezra that i thought the batting practice might be good for hillary clinton, but there was a good column convincing me otherwise. when you think about it, they don't disagree on the issues. so what would that mean for a joe biden campaign? he'd have to get in and start attacking her integrity. basically say i got in to this race because hillary clinton is not trustworthy enough to be our nominee. that is an angry, tough bitter campaign that would make hillary versus obama look like a game
. >> what we saw hillary clinton do in talking about joe biden, i think it is one of her most touching moments of her campaign, one of her most human moments if not the most human moment. it was real what she was saying about the suffering he has gone through was heart felt and then the model that bernie sanders has laid down here which is not one negative word about hillary clinton. bernie sanders is not running against another democrat. to step in to this campaign at this stage with the table set by hillary clinton and bernie sanders who are not attacking each other it would be hard to see how joe biden or any other democrat could come in and start a negative campaign. >> because of the closeness of some of the candidates with one another i think they have to stay above the fray and deal with the issues. not necessarily personal attacks as of yet, i say as of yet,
right now. i think if joe biden were to jump in it would make hillary clinton a strong candidate and fine tune her more than she is because there would be competition. on another note, when it comes to joe biden -- lawrence,ly never forget last year, there was an event and joe biden and ashley biden were guests of honor or the speaker of the hour. ashley and joe biden talked about 201 6. arvely, the daughter of joe biden
running with that. >> austin goolsbee, you know something here. you are in on the inside has the campaign reached out to you for their advice yet? >> no. i haven't spoken with the vice president in any way. what i would say is this, first of all, we know joe biden -- if you could wave a wand and became the president. he ran for president twice. he'd like to be the president. that said, i find it extremely unlikely there's going to be the kind of extended primary battle, like what we hadded in 2008. i think it is really unlikely. hillary clinton is a formidable candidate. i think joe biden would only get in the race if he thought there was with a very good chance he could get the nomination. i think that's sort of a cloud over his head at this point. could he actually do it. i don't think if he did enter he
would attack hillary clinton or her character at all. i think he would be kind of taking a populous line. i think it would be chewing in to the support of sanders or chewing in to the support of some other candidates on the left. i really don't think he would enter unless he thought there was some way that he actually could get the nomination. >> the problem for him is when you get in, your numbers usually go down. because voters want what they can't have. so the guys who are on the sidelines are generally higher than the ones, if they are well known, than the ones who get in. he could actually go down after he got in to the scrum. the trap he's in, i agree he's not going to want to go out there and wail on hillary clinton. but what else does he have? he is not a populous, he's not a
bernie sanders. can't disagree with her on the issues. than why is he running. >> can he run as the proper inheriter of barack obama? >> oh, yes, he would be. he would be, i guess you would say the prince, prince biden 3.0 that could wind with up becoming -- i guess you would say king to a certain extent but president. so he would have to be above the fray and keep it going even heel. >> i think he would go after the banks. >> that will be the last word. thank you very much for joining us. coming up, a special edition of questions for donald trump starring some of your questions and a couple of very special guests who have their own questions for trump.
♪ (dorothy) toto, i've a feeling we're not in kansas anymore... (morpheus) after this, there is no turning back. (spock) history is replete with turning points. (kevin) wow, this is great. (commentator) where fantasy becomes reality! (penguin 1) where are we going? (penguin 2) the future, boys. the glorious future. (vo) at&t and directv are now one- bringing your television and wireless together- and taking entertainment to places you'd never imagine.
(rick) louis, i think this is the beginning of a beautiful friendship. for tonight's questions for donald trump, it says op your cards you are an intern for "the last word with lawrence o'donnell" and mo, you are a intern with the last word for lawrence. you are the summer interns. as your service comes to a close you of course come on the show
and tune things up. mo, you are following the tradition of wearing one movie my ties. >> i am. >> that is yours. you now own that tie. you are not leaving here with nothing. >> isabella, off question for donald trump. what is your question? >> i do. my question is, you recently said that the u.s. economy should be decoupled from china's. how would you deal with the $1.3 trillion of debt the u.s. owes china? would you default on it? >> such a good question. decoupling is trickier than he seems to recognize. >> absolutely. >> mo, your question for donald trump? >> sure. mr. trump, if you are president and a member of your cabinet asks you a hard question will you have them removed from the white house. >> and will it be the same guy that got jorge ramos out. we keep getting great questions on-line.
michael barkley, i read this question from him last night. i said this question in the office, i think two days ago, word for word almost. here's what michael barkley read my mind. here's his question for trump. dear mr. trump, why do you say, excuse me, when you really mean, shut up, i'm interrupting now. he goes excuse me, like every other paragraph begins with excuse me and then he pushes through. >> right will this be your first presidential election that you vote in? >> my second. >> second as well. >> old are you? >> 20. >> wait a minute, how can you be 20 voting in your second presidential election. >> second election but first presidential election. >> yes. >> second. i'm 21. >> okay. you have been at this for a while. >> here's another one from michael moskowitz. he says to trump, say i'm undocumented do i get a letter,
a call, a knock on the door, a hearing, 30 days, 10 days and mo, this is one of the things he's not talking about. how are you going to physically get these people, 11 million and drag out of here. >> he is a very blunt talker. i think whatever trump says will go. we're not hearing much, but we're supposed to take his word for it. so -- >> isabella, you get to witness another historic election. what is now the trump election. >> the trump election, it certainly is and i totally agree with mo. he makes all of these brash statements about the economy, related to my question or immigration and mr. trump, where are the numbers? >> we just went 28 seconds over time for you guys. isabella and mo get tonight's last word. thank you for joining us. chris hayes is up next. tonight on "all in" -- >> they're going to be so miss asked not easily replaced. >> two journalists murdered on