tv The Rachel Maddow Show MSNBC October 6, 2015 6:00pm-7:01pm PDT
and that is "all in" for this even. the rachel maddow starts right now with steve kornacki in for rachel. congratulations on your new role here. it's exciting. > and by the way, i hope that scandal you're talking about destroys fantasy sports because i think they destroy the concept of cheering for a team. >> that's strong words. i stayed out because i know i would get addicted. that's why i've stayed out of it. that's time objection. >> thinking that keeps people away from it, i'm happy. thanks to you at home for joining us this hour. rachel is off tonight. and let's start with a trip in the time machine all the way back to the summer of 1987. gary hart, he was the original overwhelming front-runner. he had just dropped out of the race for the 1988 democratic presidential nomination. democratic field then suddenly had a new, young, rising star. he was a senator from the state of delaware. his name was joe biden. now, joe biden back then was
many things. he was a prolific fund-raiser. he was an energetic campaigner. he was also just about to get a major national boost in recogniti recognition. he was the chairman of the senate judiciary committee. that role he was about to run the supreme court nomination hearings for robert bork, robert bork was an extremely controversial pick that president ronald reagan had just sent up. this was a major event in politics. most of although, back at that time in 1987, joe biden was gaining a reputation as a captivating speaker. and a democratic presidential debate in iowa that july, he wowed the audience with an eloquent and inspiring closing statement, the consensus after that debate seemed to be that joe biden had come out on top, that he was going to head into the fall with the wind at his back. that was joe biden's position as the summer of 19 7 came to a close. but then, on september 12th, 1987, nbc news the des moines
register newspaper and a "new york times" reporter named maureen dowd all came out simultaneously with a story that cast that barn burning iowa debate performance in a very different light. >> democratic presidential candidate joseph biden today faces a controversy that his opponents could use in raising questions about his character. three weeks ago at a debate at the iowa state fair, he used phrases identical to those delivered by british labor party leader neil kin nick. he did not attribute the words to kin nick. instead he said they were his own thoughts. was it is plagiarism? ken bode reports. >> joe biden is known as one of the best orators in the democratic party. so it was no surprise at a forum in iowa recently, he knocked their socks off with a stirring close. listen. >> i started thinking as i was coming over here, why is it that joe biden is the first in his family ever to go to a
university? why is it that my wife is sitting out there in the audience, is the first in her family to ever go to college in. >> people in britain would have been familiar with those words. they heard the same ones in a political commercial from labor party leader neil kin nick. >> why am i the first knnock in a thousand generations to be able to get the university? why is gladys the first woman in her family in a thousand generations? >> biden saw the knnock commercial and evidently loved it. >> was it because they were weak? those people who worked eight hours underground and then come up and play football weak? >> my ancestors who worked in the coal mines in pennsylvania don't come up after 12 hours and play football for four hours. >> biden had told other audiences he admired knnock. not this one. this one he later said he had listening in hushed silence.
>> no, it's not because they weren't smart. it's not because they didn't work as hard. it's because they didn't have a platform upon which to stand. >> anybody really think that they didn't get what we had because they didn't have the talent or the strength or the endurance or the commitment, of course not. it was because there was no platform upon which they could stand. be. >> aides to biden say another democratic campaign is passing out the knnock commercial to discredit biden. that's true. they also say it wasn't conscious plajism that he's been under great pressure preparing for bork hearings and that night he was just on automatic pilot. september 12th, 1987, did you catch an toward the end from ken bode, the nbc news correspondent? he said aides to biden say another democratic campaign is
passing out the knnock commercial tosh discredit biden. that's true. the whole story was put out by a rival campaign. at the time, no one knew whose campaign was responsible for putting that tape out. but once the story was out, once that is piece aired on nbc, once maureen dowd's story ran in the "new york times" it, had a life of its own. reporters started looking into joe biden's other peach speeches, all of his writing. there were more instances of passages apparently lifted from other politicians including it seemed robert kennedy. biden was forced to admit he plagiarized a law review article during his first year of law school. the entire thing snowballed into a giant immediate scandal and in a remarkably short 11 days, it was all over. >> the presidential campaign claims another victim as senator joseph biden drops out of the race. >> "nbc nightly news" with tom brokaw.
>> good evening. i'm gary utley. tom brokaw is on assignment. once again, the question of character dominates presidential politics. first it was gary hart who pulled out of the race because of his relationship with donna rice. today it was democratic senator joseph biden in his case, the transgression was using other people's words and ideas. while embellishing his own record. these are john nancy. >> joe biden found himself living the presidential candidate's worst nightmare. television crews lying in wait for him everywhere, at the train station where he wasn't, and at home where he was. the cam presence part of this year's flars drama, the candidate in trouble. this afternoon the familiar end to the drama as biden butted out of the presidential race. >> i made some mistakes. but now, the exaggerated shadow of those mistakes has begun to obscure the essence of my candidacy and the essence of joe biden. i'm angry with myself.
for having been put in the position, put myself in the position of having to make this choice. and i am no less frustrated for the environment of presidential politics. >> and that was it it, september 23rd, 1987, joe biden at that moment took himself out of the presidential race. it was five months before the first primary was held in 1988. and a week later, we found out exactly how this all happened. we found out because biden's rival for the nomination it turned out michael dukakis was forced to apologize. two of the aides to dukakis, including his campaign manager sent to reporters a videotape with clips of the similar joe biden and neil knnock speeches. dukakis fired both aides and he did go on to win the democratic nomination. he lost to the vice president george h.w. bush. bush became the president of the united states. it turns out the whole biden episode had started with a phone
call between maureen dowd at "the new york times" and dukakis's campaign manager, john sass so who tipped her off to the story. dowd asked for proof and then the campaign sent her and also sent to nbc news that videotape that you just saw. and dowd's article accusing joe biden of plagiarism appeared on the front page "the new york times," the nation's newspaper, the paper of record on september 12th, 1987. nbc followed that night with the piece we just showed you. by september 23rd, that was it. joe biden the big rising star in the democratic field in 1988, he was out of the race. it was a stunning collapse for biden. it was a reminder of how powerful a phone call to "the new york times" can be. so let's fast forward this year. joe biden went back to the senate. he presided over the robert bork hearings. he helped to rederail the bork nomination. he crafted some major legislation in the 1990s, became something of an expert on foreign policy. he restored his reputation.
and he took that restored reputation and he tried it again for the presidency. and 20 years later in 2008. but his candidacy went nowhere that year except that he did end up on the ticketing with barack obama. he became vice president of the united states. he got almost all the way to the top. 20 years later and is fulfilling at that job has been for hip, the dream of the oval office, the ultimate prize, the top job that dream is still there. joe biden is 72 years old right now and this is it. we are staring at it right now. his finally chance. if he ever wants to take one last shot at the presidency, it is here. 28 years after that campaign fell part. he really is down to about ten days right now. to make his decision. he may be thinking how is this deadline different from any of the other arbitrary time lines reported about when biden will decide whether to run for president. it's because the vice president
is genuinely coming up on some hard nonnegotiable real world deadlines he needs to meet if he's going to compete for the nomination. you know how this works, in order to win the primary, you have to win delegates. in order to win delegates you have to be on the ballot in primary states. to be on the ballot in any given primary state you generally have to submit signatures, pay a filing fee, do something proactive and the deadline for getting on the ballot in several states, those deadlines are fast coming up. these are the states with the deadlines that come up first. alabama on november 6th. exactly one month from today. arkansas comes three days after that. michigan november 17th. florida at the end of the month. new hampshire the first in the nation state is somewhere in there, too. ifio biden doesn't make a decision in the next ten days or so to start organizing to start putting a team together to start raising some money, maybe to start gathering signatures to get money ready for fees to get on these bales he's going to
start missing deadlines. if he starts missing deadlines he misses on the chance to win delegates. candidate's going to need 2,232 delegates to win the democratic nomination for president. that's the red line right there. as you can see, if joe biden doesn't get on those november deadline ballots, he loses on the chance to compete for 500 delegates. those hundreds of delegates would be guaranteed to go to someone else, all of this before biden entered the race. if he were to wait longer, it would become just about impossible. so right now, as vice president joe biden is forced to make this decision, there's actually no denying the country is in something of a joe biden moment. it's because of the tragic loss of his son beau. it's because of how he has handled it with such public grace and dignity. it's because he has baird as a grief to the nation. you saw him do this on steven colbert's show and elsewhere. he's more peculiar now than he's been before. he's more popular than any of
the other democratic candidates and he's in a political position that he's never been in before. look at this, less than a year ago, joe biden's favorability in an nbc poll was a negative 3 points. this month though, that same poll he's jumped to a plus 12 favorable rating. that's a stunning turn around. that puts had imin better position than hillary clinton when it comes to that question, than just about anybody else on the national political scene. now as joe biden's star is once again on the rise, as he is starting to gain moment tum, as he faces those hard deadlines and makes this choice, now there's a new controversy. and just like 2 years ago, just like back in the summer of 1987, one of the most prominent players in it is maureen dowd "the new york times." back in august, dowd published a column in which she said that biden was exploring a run for president. she wrote that his son beau had urged him to run while he was on
his deathbed quoting from that column. beau tried to make his father promise to run arguing the white house should not revert to the clintons that the country would be better off with biden values. this was a remarkable story when it ran. it got everybody of talking. it was also remarkably unsourced. caused a lot of mystery. today politico published an explosive piece that claimed that joe biden himself leaked that story to maureen dowd in the "new york times." the politico piece cast the vice president's move as "calculating," quoting from the story, biden effectively placed an ad in the "new york times" for his presidential aspirations. and a spokesman for biden said "the bottom line on the politico story is that it is categorically false and characterization is offensive." we reechbed out to dowd today. her office declined comment. she and her source are the only
ones who can kay say for certain who told her what for that story but that column she published in august was unusual. not only did it contain these intimate details of beau biden's last interactions with his father, some of the most personal moments in joe biden's life but one mass passage was even written from inside joe biden's head "at the table, beau told his dad he was worried about him. my kids dying in anguish joe biden thought to himself and he's making sure i'm okay." even before today's politico piece, a reader half column would have to wonder where did she get something that intimate? even and as a culpist, you would expect such a statement to be qualified with i don't know, two sources characterizing the vice president's thoughts as or some language like that. if it is true, if it's true that joe biden leaked his son's deathbed wish and its explicitly anti-clinton motivation, was it calculating? was it just joe biden saying
what came to his mind? we know that's how he talks so many times. he's talking to a reporter who despite all those events in '87, he has now had a good professional relationship with her for years. maybe he was just talking and talking and talking and that's one of the stories that came out. if it's true though, does it change anyone's feelings about biden? all those warm feelings that people started having about joe biden over the last six months? on joe biden's end, does this politico piece be as a chilling reminder that if he does make the decision to get into the race for president that politics are going to be as nasty as ever? and nothing not even his son's death will be off-limits? does it make him think that remaining bob the fray like he is right now, well liked, well respected on the sidelines, does it make him think that maybe that's where he wants to stay? he's got a decision 0 make and time is running out. joining us now is e.j. the
"washington post" columnist who covered the biden campaign for the "new york times" along with maureen dwoud. well, i want to start with just your interpretation of this whole, call it a saga. i remember when i read that dowd lum back on august 1st, i was struck by the intimate detail about bide be's thoughts being quote on the page. i assumed joe biden must have talked to her for this. hugh did you read that? >> first of all, it was fun to sit here and see my life of 28 years ago roll before my eyes on your monitors. yeah, i did cover that campaign. and i think this is a really peculiar controversy. i am quite sure joe biden has talked to maureen dowd and if you notice in their statement, they didn't deny that he talked to maureen. and joe biden was very open for a long time about what beau biden said to him. in "the wall street journal" a month before, there was a story, more than a month before, june 28th, there was a story that beau biden had wanted his father
to run for president. so that wasn't a secret. you know, there is a spin being put on this story that biden said this stuff in order to i guess the words in politico are put an advertisement for his campaign for himself. i'm sorry, maybe i'm naive. but i've heard joe biden talk about the death of beau biden. he did talk a b how he felt, how beau biden felt. and anybody who has kids knows that that is a devastating loss. and i just refuse to believe that when he was talking to anybody including maureen, he was -- he had somewhere in his head the notion. i just really can't believe that. if makes me naive, i'm happy to be naive. >> i had the same doubt i think and the aim question. i thought of the biden who the nation saw on steven colbert's show a few weeks ago who was jumping from one anecdote to
another. i imagined that conversation playing out whether it's with maureen dowd or somebody else. and maybe this is one of the details that emerges from joe biden putting his thoughts together like that. that seems plausible to me. when we look at the raw politics of this, he is facing a decision here right now. part of that is do i want to subject myself ms. and my family at this time to negative attack politics and like it or not, that's one way of reading what happened today. do you think what happened today has a bearing on his decision or will? >> i think it might. i think you were exactly right at the beginning of the show when you said that when you're out of politics, when you're not a candidate, people tend to be nicer to you. and the moment you become a candidate, then every action that you take including talking about your son hob died suddenly gets put into a political motif. and you know, i think beau biden will play a big role in this decision in his head one way or
the other. on the one hand, running could be his way of answering beau biden's request that he run, a way to move forward with his life. and if he doesn't run as he said 0 colbert, i think it will also play a big role because he will just decide he is not ready, he is not in a frame of mind to run for president. so i do think beau is central to this. i just don't think beau is central to a kind of calculating strategy. >> i put you on the spot. just a quick answer. does your gut tell you one way or the other if he's going to get in this thing? >> my gut a long time ago said he wasn't going to run. a few weeks ago it said he was going to run. if he's trying to confuse us, he's totally confused me. my understanding from a conversation tonight is he hasn't made up his mind and hasn't made up his mind on a date. they're very aware of the deadlines put up there. they're ready to roll when he announces if he announces. i just don't think he's there
yet. now i have absolutely no idea what he's going to do. >> you and many, many other people. we are all waiting to see. e.j. dionne, thanks for joining us tonight. >> good to be with you. much more ahead here on this very busy news night, including a remarkable argument for gun controlling from nearly half a century ago. and -- >> which means you can access your dvr at the dmv. change channels while he changes pants. you don't have to be a couch potato, you can be a train potato! and let them watch all the shows they love, inside the ride that you really kind of hate. introducing the all in one plan. only from directv and at&t. ♪
♪ the beautiful sound of customers making the most of their united flight. power, wi-fi, and streaming entertainment. that's... seize the journey friendly. ♪ i'm a gas service my nrepresentative. n. i've been with pg&e nine years. as an employee of pg&e you always put your best foot forward to provide reliable and safe service and be able to help the community. we always have the safety of our customers and the community in mind. my family is in oakland, my wife's family is in oakland so this is home to us. being able to work in the community that i grew up in, customers feel like friends, neighbors and it makes it a little bit more special. together, we're building a better california.
♪ can't afford to let heartburn get in the way? try nexium 24hr, now the #1 selling brand for frequent heartburn. get complete protection with the new leader in frequent heartburn. that's nexium level protection. when you think aarp, then you don't know "aarp." life reimagined gives you tools and support to get the career you'll love. find more real possibilities at aarp.org/possibilities.
it's also as we now know very clearly the way that the republicans are trying to bring my as they admit poll numbers down and so excuse me, so you know, i'm very committed to answering questions, to being as transparent as possible. i'm scheduled to testify before their committee, which we now know is nothing but a partisan exercise. >> that was hillary clinton yesterday to nbc's savannah guthrie attacking the house select committee on benghazi. this after republican majority leader kevin mccarthy basically let slip last week the committee was created to lower hillary clinton's standing in the polls. clinton obviously seeing a bill political opening here. today she upped the ante with this new ad. >> the republicans finally admit it. >> republican kevin mccarthy saying the committee investigating benghazi and clinton's e-mails was created to
destroy her candidacy. >> everybody thought hillary clinton was unbeatable, right? but we put together a benghazi special committee. what are her numbers today. >> republicans have spent millions attacking hillary because she's fighting for everything they oppose from affordable health care to equal pay. she'll never stop fighting for you and the republicans know it. >> i'm hillary clinton. and a prove this message. >> and that ad is actual hillary clinton's first national ad of this campaign. it started airing today on this network and on cnn. it's going to air through thursday. and thursday is a very important day for kevin mccarthy because thursday is when his fellow house republicans will meet and he hopes officially select him as their candidate to become the next speaker of the house. mccarthy was quick to respond today to this new clinton ad. his office saying "the mission of the select committee on benghazi is to find the truth period. the integrity of chairman trey gow do i the committee and the work that effect accomplished is beyond reproach.
the serious questions secretary clinton faces are due entirely to her own decision to put classified information at risk and endanger our national security." kevin mccarthy has two opponents in that vote among republicans that's going to take place on thursday. one of them is jason chaffetz of utah, the other dan webster of florida. neither of them though appears to have anywhere near the level of support that mccarthy does. mccarthy is expected to win that vote on thursday with ease. but that won't necessarily settle the matter. because to become speaker you need to win a majority in a vote of the full house. both parties coming together every member declaring his or her choice in public. and that vote, ha vote of the full house is still three weeks away. and during that vote, any republican who doesn't want to vote for mccarthy doesn't have to. when they're called on, they can call out any other name they want. doesn't have to be someone who's a member of the house right now. this isn't just a theoretical
thing. the last two times there were elections for speaker back in january of 2013 and this year, there were multiple republicans who refused to vote for yuan boehner. john boehner came awfully close to being denied the majority he needed to continue as speaker. in 2013, there were 1 republican who's defied boehner in the vote of the full house they either abstained or voted for other random people like former congressman west or colin powell. this year 25 republicans turned on boehner on the house floor. boehner still had enough votes to hang onto the speaker's gavel but it was very close and very embarrassing. for kevin mccarthy as he looks ahead to the big vote in three weeks, the magic number is 28. he can afford up to 28 defections from his fellows republicans. anything more than that, and he won't have a majority. he won't have nufd to become
speaker of the house. joining us now is jake sherman, senior congressional reporter for politico. let's give mccarthy the win this thursday when the republicans vote. take it to the full vote of the house. 25 defects for boehner the last time we did one of these. is there a chance there will be more than 28 defections when kevin mccarthy faces the full house? >> three weeks is a very, very, very long time for him to hang on. i think most people most insiders that i've talked to expect he will be able to win the speakership and fortunately for mccarthy, john boehner was looking out for him and pushed off the majority leader down the road into november. the number two and number three slots. so conservatives are expected to try to take out perhaps steve scalise who they don't consider conservative enough and try to direct their energy that way. these floor votes are never easy. the house is in a constant state of chaos. if you're a gambling man, you do
not put money on kevin mccarthy winning. obviously, he thinks he's going to win. and that's why they're holding the vote on thursday. >> game this out a little bit from the sort of conservative renegade standpoint. if they want to deny him the majority in this vote, let's say he gets stuck on 205 or something like that. there's a second ballot. what is the theory? at that moment he is sort of rebuked. a new candidate emerges? what happens? >> there's really only a couple people who could get to 218 which is the magic number to win that you were referring to. kevin mccarthy, paul ryan are the only two people that most insiders in the capital think could get to the level. jason chaffetz and daniel webster don't stand any chance of getting to that level. the problem is, i was talking to one these agitators who led the charge that led to yuan boehner having to step down, they kind of shook everything up and caused this huge mess. but they really don't have the next step.
they don't have a candidate. there's not one candidate who is running for speaker majority leader or whip from the freedom caucus or the right -- the right flank of the house republican conference. so they were able to mess things up pore john boehner and put kevin mccarthy at risk but 30 votes isn't enough to put forth their own candidate. that's a problem for them. >> very quickly i'm curious about this, too. there's a report ted cruz will meet with.so of the conservative who's gave boehner such a hard time. from kevin mccarthy's standpoint is he at risk of having to overpromise to the conservatives to keep them in line? >> absolutely. there's no question. is he constantly overpromising. that's what you have to do to win an election and hope people forget and realize they don't want to the shut down the government, default on the debt and all these things that the republican establishment really wants to avoid. i wouldn't put a ton of stock in the ted cruz news. he meets with these guys all the time. he has pizza and that's basically all ha comes from it. >> jake sherman, senior
congressional reporter with politico, thanks for your time tonight. appreciate it. >> thanks. >> we'll be right back. become the only thing you think about. that's where at&t can help. at at&t we monitor our network traffic so we can see things others can't. mitigating risks across your business. leaving you free to focus on what matters most. prge! a manufacturer. well that's why i dug this out for you. it's your grandpappy's hammer and he would have wanted you to have it. it meant a lot to him... yes, ge makes powerful machines. but i'll be writing the code that will allow those machines to share information with each other. i'll be changing the way the world works. (interrupting) you can't pick it up, can you? go ahead. he can't lift the hammer. it's okay though!
you're going to change the world. this woman... this cancer patient... christine... living her life... loving her family. moments made possible in part by the breakthrough science of advanced genomic testing. after christine exhausted the standard treatment options for her disease, doctors working with the center for advanced individual medicine at cancer treatment centers of america suggested advanced genomic testing. the test results revealed a finding that led to the use of a targeted therapy that was not considered for christine before. now, they're helping fight her cancer on another, deeper level... the genetic level. this is precision cancer treatment, an approach to care that may help patients like christine enjoy the things that matter most in their lives while undergoing treatment. the evolution of cancer care is here. that's definitely something worth celebrating. learn more about precision cancer treatment at cancercenter.com.
long rainy while. the death toll from the devastating flooding in that state is still rising. 17 people are now confirmed dead. most of them in south carolina. roughly 11 trillion gallons of rainfall soaked the carolinas in the past week. columbia, south carolina, got six months worth of rain in just two days. search and rescue efforts around the capital city are going to continue tomorrow. officials say they will stay out there until the entire keep the has been covered. be right back. we could enjoy life's simple pleasures. now it's our turn. i'm doing the same for my family. retirement and life insurance solutions from pacific life can help you protect what you love and grow your future with confidence. pacific life. helping generations of families achieve long-term financial security for over 145 years.
romantic moments can happen spontaneously, so why pause to take a pill? and why stop what you're doing to find a bathroom? with cialis for daily use, you don't have to plan around either. it's the only daily tablet approved to treat erectile dysfunction so you can be ready anytime the moment is right. plus cialis treats the frustrating urinary symptoms of bph, like needing to go frequently, day or night. tell your doctor about all your medical conditions and medicines, and ask if your heart is healthy enough for sex. do not take cialis if you take nitrates for chest pain, as it may cause an unsafe drop in blood pressure. do not drink alcohol in excess. side effects may include headache, upset stomach, delayed backache or muscle ache. to avoid long-term injury, get medical help right away for an erection lasting more than four hours. if you have any sudden decrease or loss in hearing or vision, or any symptoms of an allergic reaction, stop taking cialis and get medical help right away. why pause the moment? ask your doctor about cialis for daily use. for a free 30-tablet trial go to cialis.com
looki had the whitest smile. now i'm going to show up to the reunion with this whole situation. oh please. do what i'm doing. use crest whitestrips! crest 3d white whitestrips... remove 14 years of stains. i knew i recognized that smile. crest 3d white whitestrips the way to whiten. at safelite, we know how busy life can be. these kids were headed to their first dance recital... ...when their windshield got cracked... ...but they couldn't miss the show. so dad went to the new safelite-dot-com. and in just a few clicks, he scheduled a replacement... ...before the girls even took the stage. safelite-dot-com is the fast, easy way to schedule service anywhere in america! so you don't have to miss a thing. y'all did wonderful! that's another safelite advantage. (girls sing) safelite repair, safelite replace. i was out for a bike ride. i didn't think i'd have a heart attack. but i did. i'm mike, and i'm very much alive. now my doctor recommends a bayer aspirin regimen to help prevent another heart attack. be sure to talk to your doctor before you begin an aspirin regimen.
inch may of 1968, a young democratic presidential candidate held a campaign event in oregon. where he addressed what he said was the need for gun control in this country. >> now, does that make any sense that you should put rifles and guns in the hands of people who have long criminal records, people who are insane, or people who are mentally incompetent, or people who are so young they don't know how to handle rifles and guns? as presented by the john burge as somebody's going to come in, the federal government is going
to take your guns or rifles away. mog is going to happen about that. >> that of cures senator robert f. kennedy. he went on to lose the primary in oregon that month. he lost to u oo jean mccarthy but quickly bounced back and less than two weeks later after that speech he won the california primary. it was on that night just after he claimed victory in california just after he vowed to fight onto the convention in chicago and to win there, it was just after that that bobby kennedy then just 42 years old was assassinated. he was shot to death by a man armed with a .22 caliber handgun. but that speech that kennedy gave in oregon days before he was killed was remarkable, not just because of the subject matter. it was also striking because of the reaction he got. the crowd there in oregon heckled him at points like when he suggested that some people shouldn't have guns. "the new york times" reported at the time "a man in a cowboy hat booed loudly and shouted they'll get them anyway."
it's also striking about this article you're looking at is this. look at it, the date line. kennedy was speaking that day in roseburg, oregon. and now of course, roseburg is back in the national spotlight following last week's mass shooting at umpqua community college. but so too is the sentiment heard in that 1168 newspaper article. the sense that no matter what the legislation, no matter what the solutions on the table, the wrong people will always get their hands on guns. ing. > unfortunately, in this case of mental illness or in the cases of someone who just wants a gun to carry out a crime, they're not going to follow the law. >> of course it is the person behind the gun. guns don't kill people. >> guns don't kill people. the refrain we've been hearing for years. today, ben carson went a step further. take a listen. >> dr. carson, if a gunman walks up and puts a gun at you and says what religion are you, that is the ultimate test of your faith. >> i'm glad you asked that
question because not only would i probably not cooperate with them, i would not just stand there and let them shoot me. i would say hey, guys, everybody attack him. he may shoot me but he can't get us all. >> given remarks like this and the fact he's consistently polling as a top tier republican candidate for president, it would seem as if gun legislation is politically impossible. but not everyone in washington thinks so. and one of the senators who doesn't joins us next. asking qu. having new experiences. are you ready? the key to a happy satisfying life is to always be curious. jibo, how are you doing? i'm great! every moment is our moment. are you enjoying this? it's been such a whirlwind. i want to get to know people and understand their ideas about everything. so you can too.
for adults with an advanced "squamous non-small cell", previously treated with platinum-based chemotherapy, he may shoot me but he can't get doesn't joins us next. it's not every day something this big comes along. a chance to live longer with... opdivo, nivolumab. opdivo is the first and only immunotherapy fda-approved based on a clinical trial demonstrating longer life... ...for these patients. in fact, opdivo significantly increased the chance of living longer versus chemotherapy. opdivo is different. it works with your immune system. opdivo can cause your immune system to attack normal organs and tissues in your body and affect how they work. this may happen any time during or after treatment has ended, and may become serious and lead to death. see your doctor right away if you experience new or worsening cough; chest pain; shortness of breath; diarrhea; severe stomach pain or tenderness; severe nausea or vomiting; loss of appetite;... ...swollen ankles;
extreme fatigue; constipation; rash; or muscle or joint pain, as this may keep these problems from becoming more serious. these are not all the possible side effects of opdivo. tell your doctor about all your medical conditions including immune system problems or if you've had an organ transplant, or lung, breathing or liver problems. a chance to live longer. ask your doctor if opdivo is right for you. bristol-myers squibb thanks the patients and physicians who participated in the opdivo clinical trial. in a political season where doing anything about guns seems all but impossible, one senator thinks she may be able to get something done. senator amy klobuchar has proposed a bill that would make it more difficult for domestic abusers to obtain firearms. joining us is senator amy klobuchar, democrat from minnesota. thanks for taking a few minutes tonight. i'll start by asking you about this legislation. the scope of it is very narrow.
you're dealing with a very specific issue here given all of the failures to get gun legislation through really over the last decade plus. is that what the key is to really narrow the focus? >> well, i think the key is to look at what we can get done prag mat clickcally. that doesn't, of course, hurt big gun owning state. my state, hunting. i always look at things, does it hurt my uncle dick and his deer stand in the answer with the background check bill that i think is so important the answer is no, it doesn't. what my bill does is makes very clear if you're convicted, convicted of a stalking crime which we know a lot of the domestic homicides involving intimate partners start with stalking, over 50% of them, then you're not going to have access to a gun. it also changes some definitions with domestic abuse that are really important and even the republican witnesses supported the change to include dating partners. when we had a hearing on this
bill last year. so i think that bill is a strong possibility. there is a bipartisan effort in the house, the republican cosponsor with debbie dingell of michigan. also, the background check bill. i think we need to look at ha again. senator mansion put together this bipartisan bill two nra "a" rated senators were willing to step up. the victims families in sandy hook worked so hard to get that bill passed. that has to be still to me one of the most disappointing days we had in the senate. >> that universal background checks was a different senate. that was a democratic controlled senate. they were unable to get to the 60 votes they needed to break that filibuster. there were a few republicans who came on board. there were a few democrats who defected. let me ask you whether we're talking about background checks or your legislation, let me ask you about this. what i hear about the strategic politics of this from opponents of gun control.
they say it's a slippery slope argument. maybe there's nothing wronging with universal background checks or nothing really wronging withing what senator klobuchar is proposing. but if we give the gun control forces a victory on anything, they're going to come back for more and then it's going to start to hurt us. what do you say to that? >> i'd say first of all, have you people that are supporting these bills that are strong believers in the second amendment that believe you have a right to have guns. but what we're talking about here is something that 70, 80, 90%, even the majority of gun owners support having stronger background checks. closing those loopholes that allow people to not have background checks when they buy a gun at a gun show or over the internet. it's a pretty straightforward idea, steve. the other thing is to make sure we're putting the data like we didn't have happen in virginia tech, putting the data in the background check system so that the states are doing that. these are pretty straightforward criminal justice ideas. supported by law enforcement. and i think when you look at the
numbers of americans that support this, what we need here is a grassroots movement. a grassroots movement to say you know what? we know this won't solve everything. but we have to do something that makes a difference. and this will make a difference. and the people of this country when you look at those numbers you know where their hearts are, i'm hopeful this will be different this time. >> all right. amy klobuchar, seminar from minnesota. appreciate your time tonight. thank knew hank you, steve. >> and still ahead, could we be at the beginning of a major change in the republican race for president? stay with us. but grandmcause we uses we don't charmin ultra soft.clean. charmin ultra soft gets you clean without the wasteful wadding. it has comfort cushions you can see that are softer and more absorbent, and you can use up to 4 times less.
i thought the debate was very fair. i thought the cnn people were very professional. the questions were good. i mean the one complaint would be it was a long debate. you know, to be three hours has got to be a record. i would say the one thing is it was very, very long. lee hours. and i hope viewers liked, but you know, they obviously sold a lot of commercials but it was a very long debate. >> that was donald trump last month immediately following the second republican debate complaining about how long he had to stand on the stage. three whole hours. and now just three weeks later, well, while he's still leading in the polls, there's a question we want to ask about donald trump's campaign. that's next. look like this.
feel like this. look like this. feel like this. with dreamwalk insoles, turn shoes that can be a pain into comfortable ones. their soft cushioning support means you can look like this. and feel like this. dreamwalk. [ scanner beeping ] sir, could you step aside? "sir"? come on. you know who i am. progressive insurance? uh, i save people an average of over $500 when they switch? did you pack your own bags? oh! right -- the name your price tool. it shows people policy options to help fit their budget. [ scanner warbling ]
crazy that a big shot like me would pack his own bags, right? [ chuckles ] so, do i have the right to remain handsome? [ chuckles ] wait. uh-oh. you think it smells fine, but your wife smells this... sfx: ding music starts luckily for all your hard-to-wash fabrics there's febreze fabric refresher it doesn't just mask, it eliminates odors... ...you've gone noseblind to woman inhales use febreze fabric refresher till it's fresh and try pluggable febreze... ...to continuously eliminate odors for up to 45 days of freshness pluggable febreze and fabric refresher two more ways [inhale + exhale mnemonic] to breathe happy. iflike i love shrimp, come to red lobster's endless shrimp... ...for as much as you want, any way you want it... sweet, spicy, and crispy. like wood-grilled teriyaki shrimp... ...and buttery garlic shrimp scampi. and yeah, it's endless, but it won't last forever. when you're not confident your company's data is secure,
the possibility of a breach can quickly become the only thing you think about. that's where at&t can help. at at&t we monitor our network traffic so we can see things others can't. mitigating risks across your business. leaving you free to focus on what matters most. we heard you got a job as a developer!!!!! its official, i work for ge!! what? wow... yeah! okay... guys, i'll be writing a new language for machines so planes, trains, even hospitals can work better. oh! sorry, i was trying to put it away... got it on the cake. so you're going to work on a train? not on a train...on "trains"! you're not gonna develop stuff anymore? no i am... do you know what ge is?
>> and do trump's new show opened up this weekend in mexico city. it's an 80-minute sketch made up of mexico's most popular comedians basically roasting and lampooning trump. it premiered last friday. there's already talk about taking it to l.a. or chicago or some other american cities. donald trump's showmanship, his schtick, his persona, it turns heads. that's part of the appeal of watching him. the appeal of how fun he is, seeing him put on a show, even watching others put on a show about him. but when you're a showman, there's one rule above all others that you have to live by. you have to keep it fresh. you have to keep it fresh constantly or you eeld lose your audience. on june 16, donald trump announced his candidacy for president and it's now been more than three months since that announcement and since that time
he has succeeded wildly in being a presidential candidate than we've ever seen before. trump ridicules his opponent, he tweets outrageous things, he calls people names. he gives out his opponents' phone numbers. he says and does things that are supposed to destroif a candidate and instead he spends the entire summer surging in the polls, dominating in the media's coverage and becoming the republican front-runner. >> when mexico sends its people, nay ear not sending their best. they're not sending you. they're not sending you. they're sending people that have lots of problems. and they're bringing those problems with us. they're bringing drugs, they're bringing crime. they're rapists, and some, i assume are good people. he lost. i never liked him as much after that because i don't like losers. >> he's a war hero. >> he's not a war hero. he's a war hero because he was
captured pip like people that weren't captured. he's a war hero because he was captured. okay? >> i think she's got a beautiful face and i think she's a beautiful woman. >> what donald trump managed to do this summer, what he has done for the first three months of his campaign is to keep things fresh. the number one rule for a showman, he's always coming up with some new shocking or outrageous or funny twist. keeping the audience on the edge of its seat, wondering what could possibly come next. and that's hard to do. to hold the entire press, the entire political world's attention for three whole months. and let's give donald trump credit. he has managed to do that. but guess what? it's still only october 6. the first primary is still four months away. four months. that's longer than the entire trump campaign has lasted so far. that means donald trump has to find a way to keep it fresh for four more months, to stay fresh,
to stay exciting, to avoid becoming stale, to avoid falling back on a familiar bag of tricks. to keep that audience from getting restless in its seats, from getting up and just walking away. and that's why the last couple of weeks have been that's why the last couple of weeks are interesting. there may be some signs that donald trump's freshness is wearing off. the first indication is his poll numbers. he's still ahead, but his lead has shrunk in new hampshire, it's shrunk in iowa. that according to marist polling. his rise in the national polls, it has stopped. it's maybe even reseeded a bit. ben carson is creeping up right behind him in the polls. carly fiorina suddenly not so far behind. then there's his speeches and his rally. all summer, cable network, this network included wouldn't think
twice of carrying his speeches fresh. last week, he decided to surprise the crowd with choice words. >> they hate more than anybody in this room hates their neighbor. but it's political [ bleep ], you understand? that's what happened. and then as soon as we left they knocked the [ bleep ] out of everybody. >> so the networks aren't always carrying his speeches live anymore. they missed that part of it. and when you think about it, that moment seemed kind of uncharacteristic of donald trump. was swearing his way of trying to stay fresh, of trying to add a new twist, the candidate who's happy to be profane. and now this week, trump is taking swings at marco rubio. he's trying to do it in a flashy way. he sent a 24 bottle case of trump spring water to rubio's washington campaign office complete with his face on it, plus two make america great again towels and bumper stickers
and said, quote, since you're sweating, we thought you could use some water. enjoy. that care package was delivered yesterday. trump went after jeb bush, poked fun at lindsey graham, ridiculed rand paul. it helped him, it seemed to hurt all of them. but is there a chance with ru o rubio, maybe he's picking the wrong target? >> donald trump is saying over and over again that you're sweaty -- >> only when it's hot. >> are those personal attacks getting under your skin at all? >> no. this election is about the future of america. it's not about these other things. it can't be. we can't afford to get it wrong this time. >> that's the kind of confident, coolly dismissive response that the other republican victims of trump's attacks haven't been able to muster. another sign that things might be changing a bit for donald trump, he's telling nbc chuck todd this weekend that if his poll numbers do drop and the public loses interest in his
campaign, he wouldn't subject himself to the nominating process. essentially, he wouldn't let anyone actually see him lose. now again, donald trump is still ahead in the polls. he is still getting plenty of media attention, maybe all of this doesn't add up to anything. but, but is it possible that all of the tricks that have made donald trump the most unusual presidential candidate we over seen, that have riveted the media, that have filled convention hall, that have propelled him to the top of the field, is it possible they're starting to get just a little old? that donald trump, the candidate, donald trump the political phenomenon, isn't quite as fresh as he used to be? when he first started moving up in tt polls, many predicted his campaign would end in a bang. but maybe that's all wrong. is it possible his campaign will end sometime down the road, not because the masses revolt against him in outrage, but
simply because the act stops being fresh and the audience just slowly gets up and files out. a wimper, not a bang. donald trump's demise has been predicted before and so far he's still standing. maybe he'll stay standing all the way through this race. but the first primaries and caucuses in february are still a long way off. and that's a long time for even the most talented showman to keep it fresh. that does it for us tonight. rachel will be back here tomorrow night. now it's time for "the last word" with lawrence o'donnell. good evening, lawrence. >> good evening, steve. i have a question to your answer, is it possible? it's actually the answer that i give to that question most of the time no matter how it's applied. the answer is yes. it is possible. >> that means i successfully hedged. >> there you go, it is possible. >> thank you, steve. marco rubio sounds like a character from "veep." >> please don't make me go to work today. i'll fake