Skip to main content

tv   Hardball With Chris Matthews  MSNBC  November 20, 2015 4:00pm-5:01pm PST

4:00 pm
we'll hunt them down, we'll kill them in their beds, we'll wipe them off the face of the earth. that may not be what you're going to do tomorrow, but it's damn right what you want to do. and that's just not what we're seeing. >> christopher dickey, an american who's been living a long time in paris. thank you. >> thank you. >> it's good talking to you. and that's going to do it for me now. thank you for watching "msnbc live." i'm chris jansing. "hardball" starts right now. another attack. this is "hardball." good evening. i'm chris matthews in washington. i want to start tonight by making what i believe to be an important historic point. the number one goal of the mideast terrorists is to ignite an east/west war that forces moderate arab governments from power and establishes a caliphate in their place. only through such a war can they achieve this goal.
4:01 pm
why? because the terrorists do not threaten the power of western governments and certainly not ours. their real threat is to arab and other countries, such as those in africa, where muslims live in dominant numbers. so, if arab governments in egypt, in syria and iraq remain in power, if all the other governments in the islamic world stretching westward to morocco and eastward to indonesia do the same, the caliphate will remain small, and ultimately, vulnerable. the one great danger is that arabs and other muslims get drawn into an east/west war. the one sure way to ignite that war is for the west to begin calling the east the enemy, calling the fight against terrorism a war against islam itself. i believe this is president obama's thinking and the reason he resents the calls for mass bombing of syria and iraq, why he fears that rejection of syrian refugees here will trigger even more bitterness from the arab world, why he refuses to call or make a call to arms against "islamic terrorism" and why he stubbornly
4:02 pm
refuses to conflate acts of terrorism with the religion of islam itself. well, today, terrorists struck again, this time in mali. the target was a luxury hotel in the capital. at least 20 people were killed, including 1 american. nbc's ayman mohyeldin has been covering that attack from brussels. he joins us now. what happened there? just give us the facts on what happened today in mali. >> reporter: yeah, we're still learning a little bit more about what happened in the early hours of the morning, chris, but what we do know is that a group of armed gunmen entered the hotel, launching grenades with armed weapons, and took the hotel hostage, according to the radisson hotel company. they took about 170 people hostage in the early hours of the morning. and as this day unfolded, we saw that malian security forces backed by a few u.s. special forces that were in the area at the time, by chance, just
4:03 pm
providing some support, as well as french special forces that arrived on the scene later, all of them entered the hotel throughout the course of the day and began to clear that hotel out floor by floor, room by room. by the end of the day, we got a clearer picture of exactly what happened. according to the united nations, at least 20 people were killed. that includes 19 hostages, 3 of the gunmen and 1 member of the malian police force that stormed that building. in terms of who was behind it and why, that yet is not clear. we do have a claim of responsibility, not yet independently verified by nbc, but it is believed to be credible at this stage. it is a group that is closely affiliated with al qaeda in west africa, al qaeda, and we know they went after a symbolic target in the heart of bamako, the malian capital in an area that is dominated by diplomatic buildings, western diplomats,
4:04 pm
western embassies. it is a highly symbolic target, chris. >> thank you so much, ayman. now to the latest in paris. and for that, we go to nbc's chris jansing. chris, 800 raids over there, 90 people detained, 174 weapons seized. what's the threat level tonight in europe? >> reporter: the fear is high, obviously. they consider the threat level to be extremely high. they believe that the possibility of another terror attack is not just out there, but the possibility, chris, of a chemical or biological attack. and you can see just how wide a net they are casting with those numbers. by now probably more than 800 raids that they have done. i think the significant number you talked about is the number of weapons they have confisca d confiscated. remember how tough the laws are here, but 174 arms seized, 84 long arms, 68 handguns, also 64 cases of narcotics, drugs being one of the key ways that isis is
4:05 pm
self-funding, and 250,000 euros. in the meantime, chris, we're learning new information about who we thought was the female suicide bomber, the cousin of the mastermind. in fact, now officials are saying she did not blow herself up. it's hasna aitboulahcen. she was someone who communicated with police. she was asking them to come, help me, help me. and then she had that conversation about he's not my boyfriend, he's not my boyfriend. the person who ran the raid said they believe that she was trying to get police to come in, so when that bomb exploded, they would be closer and that she would take them down with her, chris. >> wow. thank you so much, chris jansing. great work this week. i'm joined right now by don burrell, former assistant special agent in charge of the joint terrorism task force and msnbc contributor, and a former u.s. intelligence officer who is now executive director of the terror project and author of
4:06 pm
"defeating isis." here's how the director of the cia -- i was quoting somebody from the fbi and it was pulled down on me right there. but here's how the director of the fbi, james comey, yesterday assessed the threat to america. let's watch. >> we are not aware of any credible threat here of a paris-type attack, and we have seen no connection at all between the paris attackers and the united states. of course, we investigate all of those propaganda threats. but instead, the threat here focuses primarily on troubled souls in america who are being inspired or enabled online to do something violent for isil. >> and i guess the question for everybody here, don and malcolm -- i'll start with don -- is what is going on over there that might affect our security situation here in the states? don first. >> well, the key thing over there is the amount of training and planning, the
4:07 pm
sophistication, the operational security and the direct contact that those attackers had with isis. a lot of them came out of syria. they presumably had training. they certainly had the weapons and the firepower to launch a large-scale attack. the difference in the threat here is that there is a lot of inspired by-type swesiinvestiga that the fbi's looking at, people that don't necessarily have access to weapons and training, but nonetheless, you know, they're inspired. although i've got to say, there is no shortage of weapons in the united states, assault rifles and so forth, that should be obtained legally. however, the level of sophistication is not here what we've seen in paris. >> what do you think accounts for this sense that there's more coming? and if you look at all of the weaponry that's been picked up in paris and elsewhere, all the drugs, in fact, that chris jansing just mentioned, all this power that was out there, just sitting out there, not in plain
4:08 pm
sight, but is only reachable through the emergency powers of the french authorities now because of what happened last friday night. but there it was, sitting there all this time. but is there a sense over there, or can you capture that sense of imminent series of explosions occurring? is there more coming? is this going to be an uptick in the action over there on the side of the terrorists? >> well, as far as i'm concerned, it certainly could be. we don't know. you have to give a lot of credit to what the investigators in paris have uncovered over the last week, so many weapons, as chris jansing mentioned, explosives, a rocket launcher. you know, i think to say that absolutely there's more coming, it's anybody's guess. they're making significant progress, but they're certainly not out of the woods yet. >> malcolm, your thinking on this, just in terms of the dynamic. these are -- you know, i don't think this brings down a government, an attack on a cafe, a series of cafes and a nightclub and a concert hall
4:09 pm
with a band playing. so, what's the purpose of it? i keep thinking, it's just to inflict damage with people committing suicide? well, they're giving their lives cheaply in many cases, so i don't see what the purpose is, except to create a war, to get the west so angry, it really begins to attack the islamic world by name and with bullets and guns and bombing raids that ignite something over there. what is the strategy here? >> well, you're absolutely right. in your opening monologue, you spelled out the strategy perfectly. this is designed as a psychological operation, which is implemented through an active tactical operation which was done through the infiltration of agents who were already trained, brought over, came back, put them back into their society and let them kill themselves within their society. this is just pure perfect, standard dogma for the isis group and al qaeda-like groups. they intend not to survive any of these attacks, but that's what they do on the ground.
4:10 pm
what they want on the national-international scale is for us to react in such a way that we will overcompensate and that we will take out what they've done, which is with an apocalyptic, cultic ideology -- they're a cult -- and take that out on the other 1.5 billion muslims by, you know, limiting immigration and all of the other rhetoric that we're hearing these days. and we are playing into their hand. it is terrible that -- >> and i think the ultimate -- tell me if i'm right here, and i think the purpose of that is to destabilize, discredit all moderate forces in the arfterab islamic world. >> absolutely. you're absolutely correct. their goal is the elimination of traditional islam. they're actually an existential threat to islam itself. most muslims have nothing to do with this. they don't even understand that this ideology's additional cult facets in it are completely unislamic to the point that it's anti-islamic. they are the victim base first. and it shows you the power of eight men, what they can do to
4:11 pm
change the entire strategic dynamic of the political relationship between the united states and europe and europe versus the muslim world. >> check us on that, don borelli. your thoughts on what we're talking about, because i think it's an elaborate case of jujitsu. take the strong western powers, you get them to use their muscle to help you become more powerful back in the east and the islamic world so you can build a caliphate. >> well, malcolm could speak to this better than i can, but as i'm reading and watching some of the reports and some of the isis rhetoric out there, there's talk of, you know, this ultimate, this final crusade, you know, the west against islam. and this seems to be just one of the things, the messages that resonate with these young people when they're drawing all these recruits, giving them some sort of a sense of empower mament an hope that they're going to be part of this final crusade, and it's their duty to go. and again, and i believe malcolm is correct in this, when we
4:12 pm
overreact, that just fuels the fire and, you know, underscores the message that's getting these young people to join the fight. >> thanks so much, don borelli, and thank you, malcolm nance. still ahead this hour, donald trump responds to questions of whether he's willing to create a database of muslims in this country. is this what isis wants from america? maybe that's what they're triggering us into. and paris has changed the course of the presidential election here in the u.s., and arguably, not for the better. the ""hardball" roundtable will dig into that one. this is "hardball," the place for politics. yea. okay, uh, may i? 50% more data for the same price. i like this metaphor. oh, it's even better with funnel cakes. but very sticky. now get 15 gigs for the price of 10. hey! how are you?g? where are we watching the game? you'll see.
4:13 pm
i think my boys have a shot this year. yeah, especially with this new offense we're running... i mean, our running back is a beast. once he hits the hole and breaks through the secondary, oh he's gone. and our linebackers and dbs dish out punishment, and ne♪er quit. you didn't expect this did you? no i didn't. the nissan altima. there's a fun side to every drive. nissan. innovation that excites. one week after the paris attacks, the french senate today voted to extend that country's state of emergency for three more months. also today, the death toll from the attacks has increased by one bp france's prime minister announced another victim has died due to the attacks, bringing the count from last friday night to 130 dead.
4:14 pm
but the quicksilver card from capital one likes to keep it simple. real simple. i'm talking easy like-a- walk-in-the-park, nothing-to-worry-about, man-that-feels-good simple. quicksilver earns you unlimited 1.5% cash back on every purchase, everywhere. it's a simple question. what's in your wallet? and sometimes i struggle to sleep at night,blind. and stay awake during the day. this is called non-24. learn more by calling 844-824-2424. or visit you do all this research then smash it into a tree. your insurance company raises your rates. maybe you should've done more research on them. for drivers with accident forgiveness, liberty mutual won't raise your rates due to your first accident. liberty mutual insurance.
4:15 pm
4:16 pm
in the aftermath of paris, i think that there is just a very strong tendency for us to get worked up around issues that don't actually make us safer but make for good political sound bites. >> welcome back to "hardball." that was president obama yesterday on the alarmist rhetoric we've been hearing from republicans in the aftermath of the paris tragedy. since friday, the republican candidates for president have taken a hawkish stand, especially when it comes to the syrian refugee issue. they're even hawkish on that one. yesterday, dr. ben carson used an analogy, likening to dogs with rabies. that's what he's calling these people, dogs with rabies. let's listen. >> you know, if there's a rabid dog running around in your neighborhood, you're probably not going to assume something good about that dog, and you're
4:17 pm
probably going to put your children out of the way. >> well, speaking about the refugees on fox, ted cruz said their religion encourages them to lie and that the president wants to admit the same people that carried out the paris attacks into this country. >> there is a religious philosophy in islamism that encourages them to lie to carry out jihad. we know that at least one of the terrorists who committed these horrible attacks in paris came in with the refugees, and president obama and hillary clinton and the democrats are willing to allow those same refugees to come to our shores. and apparently, they're willing to just roll the dice and take the risk that hundreds, or god forbid, thousands of americans will be murdered by jihadists. >> thousands of americans will be killed by jihadists in this country if belet the refugees come in. anyway, donald trump told yahoo! news that "we're going to have to do certain things that were, frankly, unthinkable a year ago." and when asked about placing
4:18 pm
muslims in a national database, he didn't rule it out. then last night, trump told an nbc news reporter that he'd absolutely enact such a program if he becomes president. >> should there be a database to track muslims here in this country? >> there should be a lot of systems, beyond database. we should have a lot of systems. and today you can do it. but right now, we have to have a border, we have to have strength, we have to have a wall, and we cannot let what's happening to this country happen -- [ inaudible ] >> oh, i would certainly implement that, absolutely. >> specifically, how do you actually get them registered into the database? >> it would be just good management. what you have to do is good management procedures, and we can do that. >> do you go to mosques to sign these people up or -- >> different places. you sign them up at different -- but it's all about management. our country has no management. >> well, today trump tweeted this clarification -- "i didn't suggest a database, a reporter did. we must defeat islamic terrorism and have surveillance, including a watch list to protect
4:19 pm
america." i'm joined by david corn of mother jones as well as paul singer, washington correspondent. he obviously is sharpening up what was kind of a sloppy statement. >> right. >> putting together a database. well, okay, i don't know how we keep track of religion in this country, but you certainly want to keep a lookout for people that give you reason for suspicion, which is where he's working his way back to sanity here. >> but at the same time, he's also called for possibly closing down mosques, making muslims carry identification papers of some type -- >> has he actually done that? >> yeah, so -- >> wait a minute, let's get back to this. where's he say about identification papers? >> "first read" of nbc news this morning outlined some of the statements he's made. and so, it's all the same piece, that muslims are the other, you know. this is the argument that a lot of them try to make about barack obama, the secret muslim, and they're feeding the fear or responding to the fear and paranoia of a good part of americans, particularly of the republican primary electorate. >> yeah. >> they want a visceral reaction
4:20 pm
and are equating terrorism with muslims. ben carson has done that a bunch of times, and you just saw ted cruz say islamism, which i don't think is a word, basically leads to terrorism. >> well, here's the problem, you have people in this country who are islamic who come from the former yugoslavia. you've got people here from pakistan, bangladesh, india, indonesia. islamic people come from all around the world. it's 1.75 billion people. >> right. >> they're not, first of all, if you're bringing into a subset of arabs, even, it's like 300 million arabs. let's get down to arabs, who -- and then you have the small number of people who have given reason to be thought of as possible stow members. let's face it the french have been rounding up a lot of people, a lot of guns. >> part of the issue is americans at the moment are smothered in fear. i mean, there is a palpable fear of another terror attack in america. i mean, abc news has a new survey out just today, in fact,
4:21 pm
that showed that something like 81% of americans are expecting a terrorist attack in america. >> but some of the numbers are worse. people believe they will be hit in a terrorist attack. those numbers blow my mind, how people actually think -- >> it's stunning. >> -- they're going to win the reverse of the -- >> lottery. >> yeah, right, exactly. >> some lottery. >> when you think of how rare it is, as you're making the point -- >> the sweepstakes, like the chances are one in millions. >> and we've had muslims come into the country for years, and it's so rare that it occurs here in the united states, and yet, there is this fear, palpable fear that it's going to happen. and of course, the candidates spon respond to that. and when they respond to it -- >> here's the weird part. we travel light. people who travel with the tsa are islamic people. people who work in hotels are islamic people. people who drive cars -- >> my brother is a muslim. we adopted a refugee to afghanistan -- >> around us did. >> it's part of our culture. >> it's seen as a fervetive operation. >> that's what's happening. you have the republicans mainly
4:22 pm
running, these lead candidates, who are equating muslim or islamic with terrorism. >> right. >> they're making this direct "a" to "b" point, and you've got jeb bush and a few others pushing back, but those the tone. even john kasich, who has seemed to be reasonable in the past, the other day called for a u.s. federal agency that would promote judao christian values around the world. so, like, they really want to make this an us versus islam fight. >> like i said in the opening. but i'm telling you, i said it during the break, i'll say it now loudly -- if you believe the president of the united states against every estimate of his life, every account of his life, everything about the reverend wright and all the rest, his family, everything about his history, if you still insist he's a foreigner -- >> right. >> if you still insist he's from africa, if you still insist he's a muslim, then it's easy to say these guys coming in as refugees are dangerous. if you accept that kind of base line. >> and he's doing it on purpose. you know, about 30%, 40% of the republican base believes that! >> but the issue is, there's no
4:23 pm
answer. honestly, even obama doesn't know how to prevent every single possible act of terrorism. we can't do it. so, all the candidates can say is i'll stop it. >> i know. >> how? >> thank you, david, have a nice thanksgiving. paul singer, thank you. up next, congress and the white house battle over the refugee policy in the wake of the paris attacks. i'll speak with one congressman who represents a district that includes a significant syrian community. allentown. so what's your news? i got a job! i'll be programming at ge. oh i got a job too, at zazzies.
4:24 pm
(friends gasp) the app where you put fruit hats on animals? i love that! guys, i'll be writing code that helps machines communicate. (interrupting) i just zazzied you. (phone vibrates) look at it! (friends giggle) i can do dogs, hamsters, guinea pigs... you name it. i'm going to transform the way the world works. (proudly) i programmed that hat. and i can do casaba melons. i'll be helping turbines power cities. i put a turbine on a cat. (friends ooh and ahh) i can make hospitals run more efficiently... this isn't a competition! romantic moments can happen spontaneously, so why pause to take a pill? and why stop what you're doing to find a bathroom? with cialis for daily use, you don't have to plan around either. it's the only daily tablet approved to treat erectile dysfunction so you can be ready anytime the moment is right. plus cialis treats the frustrating urinary symptoms of bph, like needing to go frequently, day or night. tell your doctor about all your medical conditions and medicines, and ask if your heart is healthy enough for sex. do not take cialis if you take nitrates for chest pain, as it may cause an unsafe drop in blood pressure. do not drink alcohol in excess.
4:25 pm
side effects may include headache, upset stomach, delayed backache or muscle ache. to avoid long-term injury, get medical help right away for an erection lasting more than four hours. if you have any sudden decrease or loss in hearing or vision, or any symptoms of an allergic reaction, stop taking cialis and get medical help right away. why pause the moment? ask your doctor about cialis for daily use. for a free 30-tablet trial go to
4:26 pm
welcome back to "hardball." more now on the political fight over syrian refugees coming to the u.s. nowhere is this issue more relevant than the towns and cities directly affected. allentown, pennsylvania, for example, is home to one of the nation's largest populations of syrians. it is a settled, established community there. 38 refugees, by the way, arrived in allentown and scranton
4:27 pm
between october of '14 and september of this year, according to the local press, and more are on the way. republican congressman charlie dent grew up in allentown. he represents the area and he joins me now. congressman, i'd love to know your think being this and how we deal with syrian refugees now. >> sure. well, thanks, chris, for having me on the show. i do live in allentown, pennsylvania. we do have one of the largest syrian communities of any in the country. and i would let you know that the syrian community that i represent is largely christian. and many of them are outspokenly in support of bashar al assad, the president of syria. they're very pro-assad. we have had some very tense moments here when there was an anti ass-assad demonstration a couple years ago, and it was met by a large pro-assad rally. there was violence, police were called out. so, we've had some incidents. and i will tell you, though, our syrian community is well established. in fact, the republican chair just elected, a good friend, johjoe
4:28 pm
hannah, but the community is largely split on the syrian refugee question. i think eight refugees have been resettled in the area by the lutherans. some syrians feel it's their obligation to open their hearts and their homes to their fellow syrians, whether they be muslim or different faith. others are very concerned because of the pro-assad, pro-government feelings of many local syrians. they're concerned that many of the people coming are islamic and are antiregime and that that can create some tension. >> where do you stand on the issue? where have you been voting? >> look, i supported the legislation the other day that would allow for a pause, a pause to allow us just to better reinforce our existing programs on refugees. and so -- and by the way, i'm on the committee, the appropriations committee, i'm on the committee that actually does provide the funding for refugee assistance, and we've provided over $3 billion of refugee assistance in this fiscal year, $2.5 billion for the refugees
4:29 pm
overseas, $500 million here and i'm not counting the monies for the unaccompanied children. i understand we have a responsibility, but let's get this resettlement program right. i also just want to be clear -- i don't believe the refugee issue is the major security threat. there is a threat. we have to take al qaeda at their word. they intend to penetrate or infiltrate some of the refugee communities. and so, but we should take them at their word, but i would also tell you, chris, that the bigger threat in my view are europeans who are citizens of various countries who are already radicalized and can enter our country by passports through the visa waiver program and come in this country very easily right now. >> what can we do about that? >> well, we're going to have to look at it. we're going to be talking to our friends in europe about the insuring that we share information a lot better than we do. we have, obviously, a very robust terror watch list and the no-fly list. i don't think we are as well coordinated with the european countries as we ought to be. we're going to look at it.
4:30 pm
we're not going to talk about shutting down the visa waiver program. it's just too darn important. there's a lot of americans and europeans who go back and forth on passports. >> i know. >> and obviously, there would be a big economic effect, but i believe that's a greater threat to our country. >> yeah, we don't want them going back and forth to syria. that's what we're worried about. thank you so much, congressman dent -- >> well -- >> yeah, you have a thought? go ahead. >> i was just going to say one thing. i have legislation i'm going to be introducing, the enemy expatriation act, which would basically make it easier for an individual to have his or her citizenship relinquished if that individual were to leave this country and go to syria or to join some foreign terrorist organization, deal with them the same way we dealt with individuals during the second world war who went to fight for the nazis or for the imperial army of japan. it was very important that we established that kind of program, because we've had over 250 americans who have gone there. >> and that's an easy argument to me, i think. if they go to express their loyalty to some other part of the world that's out to kill us, i think it's time for us to end our relationship.
4:31 pm
thank you, congressman charlie dent. have a good thanksgiving. up next, in the wake of the paris attacks, american politics gets nastier here at home. when it comes to helping you reach your financial goals,t taking small, manageable steps can be an effective... and enjoyable approach... compared to the alternatives. push! i am pushing! sfx: pants ripping how you doing eddie? almost there. small steps. at axa, we'll help you take the next steps, with more confidence. for advice, retirement and insurance, talk to axa today. want bladder leak underwear that try always discreet underwear and wiggle, giggle, swerve and curve. with soft dual leak guard barriers and a discreet fit that hugs your curves. so bladder leaks can feel like no big deal. get your free pair and valuable coupons at always
4:32 pm
if you don't think beat con mewhen you think aarp, you don't know "aarp." the aarp fraud watch network helps everyone protect themselves and their families against scams and identity theft. find more real possibilities at hey! how are you?g? where are we watching the game? you'll see. i think my boys have a shot this year. yeah, especially with this new offense we're running... i mean, our running back is a beast. once he hits the hole and breaks through the secondary, oh he's gone. and our linebackers and dbs dish out punishment, and never quit. ♪ you didn't expect this did you? no i didn't. the nissan altima. there's a fun side to every drive. nissan. innovation that excites.
4:33 pm
4:34 pm
welcome back to "hardball." there's a new republican technique out there. it goes something like this -- we don't want to do anything because we don't trust president barack obama to do it with us. and here's an example. >> i do not trust this administration to effectively vet the people who are proposed to be coming in, in order to protect the safety and security of the american people, so i would not permit them in. >> what if they were orphans under the age of 5? >> you know, sure, we can come up with 18 different scenarios.
4:35 pm
the fact is that we need appropriate vetting, and i don't think orphans under 5 are being, you know, should be admitted into the united states at this point. >> well, president obama also used a bit of a snarky tone the other day to strike back when he was at that summit over in manila, the philippines. let's listen. >> these are the same folks oftentimes who suggest that they're so tough that just talking to putin or staring down isil or using some additional rhetoric somehow's going to solve the problems out there. but apparently, they're scared of widows and orphans coming in to the united states of america. now suddenly, they're able to rush in, in a day or two to solve the threat of widows and orphans and others who are fleeing a war-torn land, and that's their most constructive contribution to the effort against isil? >> joining me now is roundtable
4:36 pm
tonight. jane cummings, political editor for the "wall street journal," brad pittner is a columnist with "the daily beast" and eliana johnson is editor of "the national review." strong members tonight. let's get through this. eliana, did you notice that technique there? even 3-year-old orphans can't come into the country because we don't trust obama. that leads you to a lot of discernment. you don't have to think anymore. just say if obama is associated with this, i'll stand become and blame it on him. isn't that a new technique in government? if the president's involved, i don't like anything. >> i don't think it engender as a lot of trust when the president's overseas and his most passionate response to the massacre in terrorist is to point fingers at those raising questions about the refugee policy when, in fact, one of the perpetrators came on the migrant trail, and to say they are thoughtless bigots when they are actually speaking for a majority of the people in the country. i think a more constructive response from the president would have been to try to disage
4:37 pm
some of the concerns they are raising, rather than to denounce them -- >> you took that as a legitimate concern, we can't let 3-year-old orphans in the country. that was a legitimate concern? >> i don't think the concern is that we can't let 3-year-old orphans in the country -- >> but that's the issue that was raised. >> but the concern is not that, it's do we have the right protections, securities, screenings, and i think it's ridiculous to respond by saying you're a cold-hearted bigot. >> go ahead. barrett? >> yeah, i think obama supplants that he doesn't have any more campaigns to run. he is positioning himself and the rest of the democratic party to be in a strong position against the gop. like, he is not -- if it may hurt him in the long haul, it may help the other democratic candidates. and you brought up a good point about the regulations or the security we have for those coming into the country. we need to have conversations about that, not conversations about whether the gop wants to engage with the president or they trust him. like, if we have something serious, if we have a serious conversation about these regulations and not whether we want to trust obama or not. >> it's getting snippy out there
4:38 pm
on both sides. >> it certainly is, and it's going to get a lot worse. i mean, i don't think this is the first time that candidates or members of the party have said, look, i just don't trust that guy with "x," and so, i'm not going to do something. so, i don't think it's a brand-new tactic. they're using it on a whole lot of issues. >> yeah. >> and i'm not sure that the president, if he'd taken a very reasoned position over in the philippines, if that would have changed any minds. i mean -- >> part of the problem -- >> they've barely talked to each other. however, the debate now is going to the senate, and the senate, they do have real negotiations. and over in the senate, they are looking at both the refugees and the visa programs, both of which -- >> just a second -- >> we're thinking it's democrats in the senate who are leading the charge to put more restrictive efforts on visas and so forth. so, it's really a bipartisan issue, and the president's response pointing fingers at republicans for being bigots i don't think is constructive. he's not addressing the democrats' concerns on this. >> well, i think he should
4:39 pm
address dianne feinstein. anyway, a pair of polls after the terrorist attack show the majority of americans are opposed to allowing syrian refugees here. according to bloomberg politics, they do not want to accept them into the country. 54% of those surveyed in a new abc news/"washington post" poll say the same thing. but there are a chunk of people in this country on the republican side, a large chunk, that believe the president is here illegally and the president is -- i'm serious! look, i'm as staggered by these polls as anybody who's chuckling right now, but people keep saying it the pollsters. is it a screw you sort of answer? yeah, we'll have fun with it. i know he's an american, but i'm going to have fun with this. or i know he's christian, but i'm going to say he's a muslim. why are they saying that? >> i think it's amusing that it's hillary clinton, it's the clintons who first put this out there about obama being a muslim -- >> why did she do it? >> i think because it's a pretty effective way when you start to question somebody who's american
4:40 pm
or their origin -- >> do you think that's an american thing to do? >> no, i think it's an abominable campaign tactic. but i think it's worth it to remember that it was in 2007, the clintons who did this. >> i know. >> the dirtiest campaign in the country. >> i know, it was al gore who used billy horton. we know that -- why is that fun snaey it's terrible. let me ask you this about the mentality of the country. is it just they're foreigners? >> i think so. it's the fear of the unknown, because we have a history in the country of, you know, there was a lot of angst when the irish came, there was a lot of angst when the italians came, and so on and so forth. and so, that's part of it, but i think add to that -- i mean, the irish came because they were starving. these people are running from a war zone, and you know, the kind, the sort of drive-by attacks are really scary. and so, i think you put those both together, and i think that
4:41 pm
raises the level of anxiety. >> the question is we have to behave like americans, no matter what's going on. following donald trump's comments yesterday that he would certainly implement a muslim database in the u.s., several of his gop republican competitors condemned the stance, including ted cruz. let's listen to him. >> senator, your reaction to donald trump's suggestion yesterday that muslims be tracked as part of a national registry. >> well, listen, i'm a big fan of donald trump's, but i'm not a fan of government registries of american citizens. the first amendment protects religious liberty. >> there they go. it's an interesting division there among people, very nationalistic, like trump -- i think he's a supernationalist -- and somebody who's a libertarian as well. >> well, i think a lot of people in the gop field are not too pleased that donald trump is leading right now, so, any opportunity that they can have that they can use to hopefully knock him down a peg and increase their polls is something they're going to use. but frankly, we all have to say that this idea of a database or
4:42 pm
registering all muslims is just -- >> i've got to be careful. i don't think he said registering them. under the mccarran act from 1950 to 1965, until it was ruled unconstitutional, we forced the communist party members to register, but that's different in this sense. i'm not defending it, but if somebody chooses to join the communist party under stalin, they know what they're doing. that's a political move. that shows loyalty to the other side in the cold war. that's not being born a muslim or born jewish or being born anything else. it's totally different. it's a signal of where you stand on world politics. and back then in the cold war, we had attitudes about those people. >> going back to cruz, though, a couple of interesting thoughts to add is that he's actually tried not to say anything about trump. he's tried to avoid -- >> he's riding behind him -- [ everyone talking at once ] he's hoping he'll wipe out and he'll be the first one in the race. >> exactly. >> by the way, that's not working, is it?
4:43 pm
>> not yet. maybe it will work later. >> that's not working. trump is still out there. >> okay, wait, wait, he's also appealing to his evangelical base. in the republican party, the evangelicals are those that bring in refugees, and so cruz represents that part of the party. >> they're christian in the best sense. by the way, who's got the personality least applicable to the presidency, cruz or trump? which is least likely to fit into the line of presidents we've had? >> i'll let you answer that. >> i think trump becomes plausible because of cruz. anyway, the roundtable's staying with us. and up next, with the presidential campaign changing focus to terrorism, which american politicians have lost their footing?
4:44 pm
snowmen with buttons, snowflakes with icing ♪ candy corn feathers, sure look enticing ♪ ♪ rice krispies treats, the fun doesn't stop - ♪ ♪ how many ways can you snap, crackle, pop? ♪ make the holidays a treat with kellogg's rice krispies. can a a subconscious. mind? a knack for predicting the future. reflexes faster than the speed of thought. can a business have a spirit? can a business have a soul? can a business be...alive?
4:45 pm
as you mentioned earlier, more than eight in ten americans believe a terror attack is likely here in the u.s. in the near future. that's according to new numbers from a "washington post"/abc news poll. 81% believe it could happen here soon. that's the second highest number ever cording to pollsters. the highest came in 2005, when 85% feared a threat in the wake of the london subway and bus bombings. meanwhile, a majority of americans, 54% disapprove of the president handling the issue. i am totally blind.
4:46 pm
and sometimes i struggle to sleep at night, and stay awake during the day. this is called non-24. learn more by calling 844-824-2424. or visit theand to help you accelerate,. we've created a new company... one totally focused on what's next for your business. the true partnership
4:47 pm
where people,technology and ideas push everyone forward. accelerating innovation. accelerating transformation. accelerating next. hewlett packard enterprise. plan well and enjoy life... ♪ or, as we say at unitedhealthcare insurance company, go long. consider an aarp medicare supplement insurance plan insured by unitedhealthcare insurance company... go long. ono off-days, or downtime.ason. opportunity is everything you make of it. this winter, take advantage of our season's best offers on the latest generation of cadillacs. the 2016 cadillac srx. get this low-mileage lease from around $339 per month, or purchase with 0% apr financing.
4:48 pm
isis is demonstrating new ambition, reach and capabilities. we have to break the group's momentum and then its back. our goal is not to deter or contain isis, but to defeat and destroy isis. >> we're back with the roundtable. jeanne and barrett and ileana. that was former secretary of state hillary clinton, of course laying out her plan to defeat isis. it was a good week if you were a hawk running for president in 2016, but it was a bad week if your answer to the paris attacks is to do nothing or if you're the odd man out like bernie sanders. as his rival was outlining her plan to defeat terrorism, sanders was defending socialism and laying out his attack
4:49 pm
against this country's billionaires. >> the next time that you hear me attack as a socialist, like tomorrow -- [ laughter ] -- remember this -- i don't believe government should take over, you know, the grocery store down the street or own means of production. democratic socialism means that we must reform a political system which is corrupt, that we must create an economy that works for all, not just the very wealthy. the billionaire class must be told loudly and clearly that they cannot have it all. >> what do you make of that this week, that speech? >> this week was about terrorism. bernie sanders gave a speech largely focused on domestic
4:50 pm
politics. and so, i really think it got lost in his delivery, but he's slipping in the polls and he needed to deliver largely a broad side against hillary clinton, and i found it ironic that his definition of socialism is what you don't leak right now, in other words, we don't like billionaires. that's the new definition of socialism. it's a great one. >> he had to reframe the conversation. the title of socialist is something that americans are not comfortable with and that's a title on him, he has to have that conversation and he has to have this if -- >> why now after all the successes does he feel the need to fight the definition? >> i don't think he's fighting it, i think he's trying to explain it so it's not scary to voters.
4:51 pm
he's got to figure out some way to appeal to a broader base and some way to knock her off of her game. but they felt like he first needed to establish who he is. and to his credit, it is a definition of democratic socialism that fits the times. >> very conveniently. it's the one thing he knows everybody hates, which is the koch brothers because of citizens united controlling our politics. >> but bernie's been saying this for a decade. >> not citizens united. >> we've been talking about this have -- >> and if he were playing jeopardy, would not say foreign policy. i think he would pick something along the lines of domestic moral issues or something. he didn't know to name one ally to fight isis on behalf of, these are easy.
4:52 pm
just say a name. i don't think he's familiar with the topic. >> i think there's a mistake republican voters are making that because he's a neurosurgeon and smart that he's informed and he's clearly smart but not informed about world politics and when your arer running as a president, that's a problem. >> we've been really patient and thus far, it hasn't transferred over. >> things don't transfer over. i always loved basketball, my favorite sport. i don't know anything about hockey and everything i know about basketball tells me nothing about hockey. and that doesn't help me when it comes to hockey. >> right. >> i think for carson it's an even bigger problem. i agree with everything they've said. his language is wrong, his knowledge isn't there and i think he has a temperament issue
4:53 pm
and that's why trump is not doing so bad this weak because when people are afraid and they want someone to defend them, they want energy. >> he doesn't have enough juice. most people you say you have a temperament problem, you fly off the handles. >> i think his temperament problem is he's way too cool and way too key. >> i've talked fast my whole life and he talks this very deliberate intellectual level. i've been amaze bid by that suc says but anyway, people like him. thank you and coming up, how will historians look at this week in politics and it's rep repercussio repercussions. yeah, especially with this new offense we're running... i mean, our running back is a beast. once he hits the hole and breaks through the secondary,
4:54 pm
oh he's gone. and our linebackers and dbs dish out punishment, and never quit. ♪ you didn't expect this did you? no i didn't. the nissan altima. there's a fun side to every drive. nissan. innovation that excites. they come into this iworld ugly and messy.
4:55 pm
ideas are frightening because they threaten what is known. they are the natural born enemy of the way things are. yes, ideas are scary, and messy and fragile. but under the proper care, they become something beautiful. the way i see it, you have two choices; the easy way or the hard way. you could choose a card that limits where you earn bonus cash back. or, you could make things easier on yourself.
4:56 pm
that's right, the quicksilver card from capital one. with quicksilver you earn unlimited 1.5% cash back on every purchase, everywhere. so, let's try this again. what's in your wallet?
4:57 pm
welcome back to "hardball" the question about whether to allow syrian refugees into the u.s. has become a hot topic and it's a big topic by this man. in his case, it was jewish people from europe fleeing nazi purse cushi-- purse cushion and author of a good book, and thank you for this. how does this reawaken the
4:58 pm
echoes of what you lived through as a family member and what you studied? >> the st. lewis came november 9th, 1938 and on bord were more than 900 jewish refugees turned away first by cuba for political reasons and the united states and canada and it was so close to the coast of florida, that they could see the lights of miami during the couple of nights they were in the waters off the coast of florida. and edward robertson sent letters to roosevelt to convince him to let them get off in miami and it was denied. and earlier in the show you shows the 53% of americans were
4:59 pm
against allowing syrian refugees into the u.s. in 1938, people thought jews should be treated differently now and 10% said jews should be deported. >> people here as americans? >> exactly right. jews living in america. my grandfather and uncle got off and i got off in france and spent years going one camp to another before dying in auschwitz. so, it is personal and when i hear these ideas of reg straes and keeping track of muslims. i think of cards that my grandfather and uncle filled out p . >> you should show them. >> and just days after the -- >> there they are. we don't want that here.
5:00 pm
thank you so much. i listen to you all the time on sirius radio and jour back, "alex's wake" about you checking this out and what did occur to those memories of your family. and that's "hardball" for now. good evening from paris, i'm chris hayes, it's one week tonight since the attacks killed 130 in paris. and parisians came out in the street and at 9:20, there were celebrations and defiance that sietsz of tsites of the attack. and people coming out in drones and the precise moment the attack began and designed to show a


info Stream Only

Uploaded by TV Archive on