tv MSNBC Live MSNBC March 1, 2017 11:00am-12:01pm PST
that will wrap up this hour of "msnbc live." my colleague katy tur picking thing s now. we follow the big questions following the president's kinder, gentler speech. that's focus at the white house between the president and gop leadership. about last night, supporters are cheering it, but critics say the message was hollow, full of misleading statements and old campaign promises. >> we want all americans to succeed, we must restore integrity and the rule of law at our borders. the time has come for a new program of national rebuilding. we will provide massive tax relief for the middle class. i am not going to let america and its great companies and workers be taken advantage of us any longer. sdmroot country looks a lot
like the room did last night -- divided. although there was no olive branch to the other side, there was a demand. work together or america's future will be at stake. >> the time for small thinking is over. the time for trivial fights is behind us. we just need the courage to share the dreams that fill our hearts. everything that is broken in our country can be fixed. every problem can be solved and every hurting family can find healing and hope. >> we have got our teams fanned out across the country and outside the beltway as well as in d.c. let's go to kelly o'donnell who's inside the white house. talk to me about how the white house is planning on following up with what was largely accepted to be a well-received speech? >> reporter: well, trying to give some room for those good reviews to sort of settle in and to try to maximize what they
believe was a good night for the president, where he was able to lay out a vision that they think matches what many of his supporters want. and also believing there are elements in that that could reach across the aisle, could reach support among those who have not been sure about president trump so far. also giving room to do work behind the scenes. this kind of speech is never meant to be chock-full of specifics but he laid out policy ideas that will require a lot of difficult work in washington to accomplish. things like immigration, for example. so, by meeting with top congressional leaders from the republican party here today at the white house, a chance to sort of take in a breath, look at what can be done, talk about policy ideas, gauge how things were received and see -- knowing this president likes to stress his negotiating skills, what was laid on the table in terms of ideas, like oe talked about the merit-based immigration as one example, and other ways they might be able to achieve something that can be passed.
much easier in the house of representatives where they have a dominant majority, much tougher in the senate where it's such a narrow one. i think the initial reaction from the white house is one of trying to take a bit of a victory lap and at the same time capitalize on what they believe is momentum to try to actually accomplish a few things in short order using that as, perhaps, a little lift in their sails. >> we also have our friend robert costa of "the washington post." your sources are telling you they were a bit surprised in the white house that the pundits were having such a positive reaction to donald trump's speech because the policy wasn't changing? >> that's exactly right, katy. i woke up this morning and connected with my sources inside the white house and said, what do you make of the reaction? they said, we're actually, frankly, surprised that different pundits on different networks and different papers are embracing this speech. some kind of toned down president trump. they said they set out to have a different kind of tone, an inside voice as one of them put to me, but when it came to his
policies, there was still the populism, still the steve bannon nationalism, the stephen miller recommendations on immigration policies, the fingerprints of attorney general sessions were everywhere. on presentation they said there was a moderate sheen, but this was still the same president trump. they're going along with some health care policies in the house and on taxes. in terms of the broader agenda, nothing has changed, in their view. >> to that, charlie sykes, this was a milder tone, a softer tone, one certainly that republicans are applauding. they wanted to see this more presidential version of donald trump. this is the question we always ask -- can it last? >> that is a good question. it helped him, it will reassure jittery republicans, but give it a minute. how many times have we had this discussion, is he going to make a pivot, is he going to make a turn? i think robert costa's piece is very important. the point here is nothing actually changed. there is no policy. he is the same donald trump as
he was 24 hours previous. >> and he does have this ability to change his tune when he needs to be in a different audience or needs to give a different style of speech. we have seen that from time to time in the campaign trail. this certainly was quite different from what we're used to with donald trump. >> it was a solid speech. although i do think with the exception of robert costa, there's almost a battered pundit syndrome going on out there. he comes home and he's not abusive and he's not drunk so we're so incredibly grateful, it's so incredibly good. again, you would hope the white house, they would be sitting around saying, you know, when you dial it down from 11, you get good results. there are positive reviews that are out there. >> the bar is much lower. let's go to robby mook, former clinton campaign manager. robby, what didn't he say last night? >> well, i think as the panel has just said, what's stunning to me about this is that the speech was devoid of any specifics whatsoever. it was full of the same
platitudes we heard on the campaign. but this is one of the first times we've seen donald trump be anything remotely close to well behaved. all of a sudden, you know, we're heaping praise on him because he wasn't abusive, he wasn't insulting, he wasn't erratic. you know, that wild temperament we're so used to didn't flame up. look, i think any patriotic person in our country wants our president to be successful. i certainly count myself in that group. but i think, you know, faung over him paying close attention to the teleprompter and delivering on the talking points he got is a little excessive at this point. let's look at what he's done. at every juncture his policies have been divisive. we haven't seen him deliver on the core promise, which was to make life better for working people. we heard him talk about cutting taxes for the richest people in the country. we heard more divisive
rhetoric -- i think we need to hold him accountable for delivering on the tone that we heard. i think it's encouraging that he did have a lighter tone. let's hold him accountable for continuing that. >> kasie hunt on capitol hill. the broad strokes from this speech on policy, tell me what's going to be most tricky going forward to get it passed through congress? >> reporter: well, there's a lot of hurdles here. frankly, they have a pretty ambitious agenda. they to want do health reform, they want to do tax reform, they want to do infrastructure, now maybe the president wants to do immigration. any one of these things would normally be enough to tie congress up in knots for many, many months. trying to do them all at once is quite an undertaking. each one is finding hurdles within the republican party. forget about where democrats stand. the one i want to highlight is repeal and replace of the health care law. they campaigned aggressively on repealing obamacare throughout the course of the last year. and there had been this kind of
consensus that they should repeal and replace at the same time because there were a lot of republicans who were worried if you repeal it, there's no replacement. that leaves a lot of people hanging. potentially they have to answer for all of the results and political problems. we're starting to see legislative language. that prompted backlash from conservatives who are focused on one particular piece of it. a section that would give tax credits to people to help them buy insurance and that is suddenly getting a lot of push back. it's something leaders here in the capitol have supported to far, but suddenly conservative rank and file are not so willing to jump on board with. i talked to senator ted cruz about it earlier today. i think we can play a piece of that, if we have it. >> for six years we've been promising the american people we'll repeal obamacare. we have to keep our word on that. and the president, quite rightly, laid out a set of principles that should govern replacing obamacare. >> reporter: but you're not ready to say yes to tax credits
quite yet? >> in 2015 virtually every republican in both houses of congress stroetd repeal most of obacare. think we should start with that 2015 repeal language. >> reporter: you will note he did not say repeal and replace and he refused to say he would support tax credits as a way to help replace this law. that is going to underscore, i think, what is an emerging divide where leadership want to be on this issue and where the rank and file conservatives may come down. why is that important? it could sink the whole thing. this is, as president trump said, recently, extraordinarily complicated. katy? >> nobody knew that, nobody. kelly o'donnell, let's talk about what was supposed to happen today. there was supposed to be a revised executive order on the travel ban. why is it not coming out today? >> reporter: all of the guidance we this is this would be the day for a retooled travel ban. we've seen the deadlines on that slip and slip and slip. and the press secretary is
telling us there was nothing officially announced. they're going to take all the time they need to take. sort of the other story to that is to give a little bit more space to talk about issues that are less controversial than the travel ban that came out of the speech last night. things we've been discussing here where they think they have a little more room to move forward and not attract another firestorm of criticism. so we don't know exactly how quickly that will happen. and it may look different than the first one. we knew there would be some response to some of the court challenges that are still in progress to try to adjust the seven countries that are involved, the rules regarding those persons who would be restricted from travel into the u.s. so, they're taking a pause. instead we'll seat president talk about education in the coming days. something he stressed last night and something that has broader support and a little softer in tone instead of something we saw drove headlines and drove criticism for days.
>> charlie, they're taking a pause on this. they sold this as something that needed to happen -- >> guy says would rush into the country -- >> if we don't do it right now, we're not going to be safe. that's why the president doesn't need any oversight on this. he's protecting the american people. now he's saying they want to enjoy this victory lap from last night's speech? >> who knew pdits from last night's speech would suddenly change the national security evaluation of allf this? that whole justification for rushing that through is even if you gave a heads up, a 48-hour heads up, the terrorist would rush into the country. again, one of the many iron aie of this administration. >> one of the ideas from last night is donald trump would come out and propose some compromise on immigration, some sort of bill that would allow people in this country who did not have papers, who would be able to find legal status in this country. we didn't quite hear that last night. was that something where he really fell short on a potential olive branch to the democratic
party? >> i think that's absolutely right. and the american people want comprehensive immigration reform. it's a very popular thing. i just -- gerngs i'm skeptical. i think he had a good night because he followed the teleprompter. as the other contributor said, they're having a good day and that's been a rare thing, so i think they're trying to dial back and bask in the glow of this. boy, i don't see how something constructive grows out of this. what's disappointing about that is the bipartisan consensus really is there to pass something real. we hear more stories today about people being denied visas because, again, i think it's important to remember, a restriction on people in countries except where he's doing business. so, look, let's take a look. maybe they'll come with something reasonable. i do think it's a missed opportunity f nothing else, to get something really positive done. >> robert, donald trump is going to get back on the road as of
tomorrow. this weekend he'll be at mara l mar mar-a-lago. >> before he heads to mar-a-lago, the president will be in virginia giving a speech about military spending. you see him making that a priority for his budget, $54 billion in increased is his recommendation offset by $54 billion in cuts across domestic agencies, including the environmental protection agency. trump sees an opportunity to maybe bring the hawks and republican party who are very skeptical of him, privately and publicly, senators like john mccain, to come to his side. he doesn't support this defense sequestration, these automatic budget cuts. last night in the chamber of the hois, you saw senator mccain stand up and applaud when trump spoke about military spending. whether this is a long-term good feeling among these hawks
towards trump we'll have to wait and see. >> kelly o'donnell, kasie hunt, robby mook, charlie sykes and robert costa, thank you for joining me. vice president mike pence will join "for the record with greta" at 6:00 p.m. tonight. we're asking in our microsoft pulse question, are you more hopeful common ground can be found after donald trump's address to congress? let us know what you think at puls pulse.msnbc.com. the moment that brought everyone to their feet. a fallen navy s.e.a.l. and his wife honored in the chamber. under it all are the questions about the success of that mission that took ryan owens' life. a republican senator joins me next with his view. anything els. but then i realized there was. so, i finally broke the silence with my doctor about what i was experiencing.
he said humira is for people like me who have tried other medications but still experience the symptoms of moderate to severe crohn's disease. in clinical studies, the majority of patients on humira saw significant symptom relief. and many achieved remission. humira can lower your ability to fight infections, including tuberculosis. serious, sometimes fatal infections and cancers, including lymphoma, have happened; as have blood, liver, and nervous system problems, serious allergic reactions, and new or worsening heart failure. before treatment, get tested for tb. tell your doctor if you've been to areas where certain fungal infections are common, and if you've had tb, hepatitis b, are prone to infections, or have flu-like symptoms or sores. don't start humira if you have an infection. if you're still just managing your symptoms, talk with your gastroenterologist about humira. with humira, remission is possible. for over 100 years like kraft has,natural cheese you learn a lot about what people want. honey, do we have like a super creamy cheese with taco spice already in it? oh, thanks. bon appe-cheese! okay...
warrior and a hero, battling against terrorism and securing our nation. ryan's legacy is etched into eternity. thank you. thank you. >> that was the widow of navy s.e.a.l. william ryan owens in what was the most emotional moment of last night. the audience rose to his feet as trump paid tribute to owens who lost hisife to a january raid in yemen, the first military operation ordered by trump after
he took office. there are a lot of questions about that raid which resulted in a 50-minute fire fight that left owens dead, killed 25 civilians, including 9 young children and destroyed a $75 million helicopter. despite this, the president agained the mission last night. >> i just spoke to our great general mattis just now, who reconfirmed that, and i quote, ryan was a part of a highly successful raid that generated large amounts of vital intelligence that will lead to many more victories in the future against our enemy. >> yet multiple senior u.s. officials teld nbc news exclusively that the raid has so far yielded no significant intelligence. let's go live to capitol hill with republican senator james inhofe of oklahoma, member of the senate armed services committee. senator, thank you for joining me. i want to first start off with
that raid in yemen. at least half a dozen senior officials across the government who are familiar with the intelligence related to that operation have told nbc news that the raid so far has not yield any valuable or significant intelligence. how do you respond to their assertions? >> well, first of all, i don't believe that. and i'm not sure they're actually making that statement. this thing was put together and was planned during the obama administration. then it was approved finally after a long period of time. not just by president trump and not just by the vice president, but by mattis and everybody else. any time you have an operation like this, you don't know exactly what you're going to produce. i believe mattis when he said they got valuable information. i believe mattis over whoever is trying to torpedo the operati from the other side. >> on a human level, there's a lot to suggest this raid did not go as planned. in addition to the death of ryan owens, six other service members
were injured, $aircraft was destroyed and 25 civilians were killed, 9 under the age of 13. is that consistent with a well-planned and successful operation? is it worth it. >> no, obviously, something went wrong. anything that would go wrong in an operate like this, covert operation, thing can't go off exactly as planned. that doesn't mean you shut down the tent, you don't try to find information that's going to save american lives. you can overly dramatize it, talking about the loss of lives in this thing. yes, we all regret something went wrong in this operation. but if this is the only one you've heard in recent years even, i can tell you, you're not looking close enough because every once in a while this is going to have to happen. have you to get information from the enemy. you have to be in a position where you can do an operation and gather the information. if you don't, you have to think of the downside, how many hundreds or thousands of people could die.
now, they got information. if mattis says that, i believe it. >> so, who is responsible for the death? i ask you this because yesterday in an interview before his speech, president trump has seemed to indicate that it wasn't him. let's take a listen. >> this was a mission that was started before i got here. this is something that was, you know, they wanted to do. and they came to see me. they explained what they wanted to do, the generals and are very well respected. my generals are the most well respected in decades, i believe. and they lost ryan. >> senator, those words right there, they lost ryan. a lot of folks say those wds should have been, w lt ryan. >> i think it could go either way. let's keep in mind, we just talked about when it was planned. that's not controvertible. nobody questions that. it was brought to him. i hadn't seen that particular clip before. if it was brought to him, obviously it was because it was
planned before he became president of the united states. that along with many other things were brought to him. that had a timing on it. it had something if you're going to go ahead and implement it, improve it, go with it, it's going to have to be right now. he was faced with that. i don't see anything inconsistent other than the word "they" and you could take that either way. >> let's talk about russia. the president seemed to have tougher talk for nato last night, more so than russia's leader. what's your take? >> say that again. i'm sorry. >> talking on russia. last night during the speech, donald trump had tougher talk for nato and our allies than he did for russia or its leader vladimir putin. >> no, you're talking about having -- he had conversations with them. >> no, no, i'm talking about last night in the speech, talking about nato and how they need to pay their fair share and america won't be -- >> oh, okay. that's a different issue. >> he didn't talk about russia at all. >> i can understand that.
nato is -- well, of course, nato is something he said negative things about. he was referring to the fact that the burden-sharing is not proper between the different countries. and so he is now a supporter of nato. i just got back from afghanistan. i got back from several of the countries over there. and they're very pleased that nato is a very integral part and we're participating. however, they even admit that they have not been paying their share. that's a major issue. now, as far as talking to russia's concern, that's not what russia is all about. >> i understand that. why go so hard on nato in his speech and not go hard on russia as well? why leave it out entirely? there's been a lot of questions surrounding donald trump and his ties to russia, his campaign and its ties to russia. and these are questions still unanswered. why would he not come out last night and stand very tough against russia and its leader
and the incursions not only made into the ukraine but also politically here in the u.s.? >> katy, you know, when you put together a major speech like that, you have to make a determination. now, if he had mentioned russia if any context at all, then you and several other people who might end up being his critics would find something about that to criticize him for. the fact he didn't talk about russia and did talk about nato but recognized nato, there are some problems with our relationship. i don't see anything that is a problem in terms of not directly talking about russia. because he knew the criticism he would get if he did that. he was trying. he was trying. i think he succeeded in making a very positive statement, looking at the future. it's optimistic. good things are going to happen to america. we haven't heard that in a long time. i think we respectfully did that. >> respectfully, i don't count myself as donald trump's critics. i count myself as a journalist. thank you for joining us.
i appreciate it. jim inhofe, republican of oklahoma. the dow skyrockets, breaking above 21,000 for the very first time. so, is it the trump effect? stephanie ruhle joins us next. it's just a date. i can stay. i'm good. i won't be late hey mom. yeah. no kissing on the first date, alright? life doesn't always stick to a plan, but with our investment expertise we'll help you handle what's next. financial guidance while you're mastering life. from chase. so you can.
don't put off checking out your medicare options until 65. now is a good time to get the ball rolling. medicare only covers about eigh per o part b medical costs. the rest is up to you. that's where aarp medicare supplement insurance plans insured by unitedhealthcare insurance company come in. like all standardized medicare supplement insurance plans, they could help save you in out-of-pocket medical costs. taking informed steps really makes a difference later. that's what it means to go long™.
call now and request this free decision guide and explore the range of aarp medicare supplement plans. all plans like these let you choose any doctor or hospital that accepts medicare patients. these are the only medicare supplement insurance plans endorsed by aarp. call now and request your free decision guide... and start gathering the information you need to help you go long™. the stock market is soaring today following the president's speech. take a look at the dow. breaking 21,000 for the first time ever. this follows three months of growth since donald trump was elected. my colleague stephanie ruhle is here to explain this for us. can donald trump take the credit for this? >> listen o some level you cannot president trump gives a speech last night and the markets are soaring.
you can't completely disconnect the two. the disconnect is will this translate to that american worker that donald trump got to support? income inequality has been a growing issue over the last five years. president trump was the first leader to say, i'm going to fix this for you. here we have, he's announcing tax cuts, we're going to have infrastructure -- >> obamacare, res leg rags laish. >> without obamacare, small businesses can thrive. look at the markets. this has helped investors. that forgotten worker, they don't own stocks. >> rich people are getting richer? >> rich peopler are getting richer. quet s will poor people get poorer? think about in president trump's budget all the social things being cut. when they reinvest they could spend that money on technology. they could pocket that money. they could buy back stocks. it's unclear if there's a true road to create jobs.
>> you know, spend the money on automation, which is technology. are these coal mining jobs coming back, are these manufacturing jobs coming back or have they already gone the way of automation and there's turning back now? >> there's some level of both. also, you have business people now in the cabinet. one of the things the market likes so much is saying, well president trump's speech last night basically said, i've got these ideas. 're going to let these guys do the work. the people around them are extraordinary business people with business pragmatism and principles. that doesn't mean they can get anything done in washington. washington is where big ideas go to die. this infrastructure plan, tax policy plan, they're great ideas, we've yet to see them executed. >> we'll see if this only helps the rich. so far it's looking that way. stephanie ruhle, thank you so much. president trump also talked about the border last night. so, what do those who live on the border think? we'll go there next. first, as we head to break, could it be trump versus oprah
in 2020? the daytime tv icon says she's rethinking a run for the white house. so, why now? >> i -- -- i actually never thought that this was -- i never considered the question even a possibility. i just thought, oh, oh. >> right. because it's clear that you don't need government experience to be elected president. >> that's what i thought. i thought, oh, gee, i don't have the experience. i don't know enough. now i'm thinking, oh. >> all right. >> oh. >> okay. >> she thought, oh. donald trump changed that game in november, apparently giving new life to the idea of a president winfrey. watch this space. imes before their deaths. the valiant taste of death, but once!! uh, excuse me, waiter. i ordered the soup...
of course, ma'am. my apologies. c'mon, caesar. let's go. caesar on a caesar salad? surprising. excuse me, pardon me. what's not surprising? how much money matt saved by switching to geico. could i get my parking validated? fifteen minutes could save you fifteen percent or more. let's take a look at som mbers: 4 out of 5 people who have a stroke, their first symptom... is a stroke. 80 percent of all strokes and heart disease? preventable. and 149 dollars is all it takes to get screened and help take control of your health. we're life line screening... and if you're over 50... call this number, to schedule an appointment... for five painless screenings that go beyond regular check-ups. we use ultrasound technology to literally look inside your arteries... for plaque which builds up as you age- and increases your risk for stroke and cardiovascular disease. and by getting them through this package, you're saving over 50%. so call today and consider these numbers: for just $149 you'll receive five screenings
that just tastes better. so fresh from the farm. delicious. perfect. only one egg with more great nutrition- now with 5 times more vitamin d, 10 times more vitamin e, and 25% less saturated fat. only one egg good enough for my family. because why have ordinar when you can have the best. eggland's best. the only egg that gives you so much more: better taste. better nutrition. better eggs. better nutrition. new pantene doesn't just wash i wiyour hair, it fuels it.gain. making every strand stronger. so tangles don't stand a chance. because strong is beautiful.
we want all americans to succeed, but that can't happen in an environment of lawless chaos. we must restore integrity and the rule of law at our borders. >> president trump received a standing ovation from republican lawmakers when he delivered that line last night. he called for strengthening our borders. it's the message that he repeats a lot. so far, is it being received as enthusiastically among those who actually live at the border itself? we're going to go to nbc's gadi
schwartz, give you a different view. so far, what are people saying down there in nogales? >> reporter: hi, katy. i want to apologize for the buzzing. we want to show you what's going on with this drone. this is exactly why ranchers around here are angry. this right here is where the border fence ends and a barbed wire fence begins stretching for miles. about an hour away, we met a rancher named jim showing the barbed wire fencing on his property saying drug smugglers constantly cut. he shows us hill tops saying senaloa cartels bring drugs through his ranch, and he has come face-to-face with drug smugglers. he says -- for him it's a safety issue for his family and a
humanitarian issue to immignts who are dangerous -- who pay people to smuggle them through his ranch. he loved what he heard from president trump last night. >> we need to get rid of the rascals that are here, that are undocumented and poisoning our neighborhoods with crimes. we need to all come together and give people an opportunity in this country to live legally. >> reporter: and that was him talking about the possibility of donald trump looking at a path for legal status for millions of undocumented respects here. something chilton says he supports. another thing, he says he doesn't care who pays for this wall, he doesn't care if it's mexico or the united states. he says that's something the two
katy, back to you. >> you've been down to nogales for 40 or so days, for the first 100 days of the trump presidency. tell me about the general consensus about how residents feel the president is going in? >> reporter: so far, we heard a lot of rhetoric from president trump. we've also seen border patrol out here. we've talked to some border patrol agents. off the record they said they do support donald trump, the ones we've spoken to, and they're inspired by this idea that their handcuffs are off and they can do their jobs. when it comes to actually seeing change out here, seeing any of the wall going up, we haven't seen that and residents are kind of holding off. >> goadi schwartz, who sounds like he's going to be taken over
by bees. that's the sound of the drove. did president trump's message about drugs hit home with workers in the rust belt? we go to kevin tibbles in ohio. he watched trump's speech last night with supporters. >> reporter: we're coming to you from janelle's diner in pemberville, ohio. we watched the speech at the century old opera house with a number of people we followed throughout the campaign and post-campaign. they voted for donald trump not because they're dyed in the wool republicans but they wanted change. one thing they noticed last night, they still believe this is a divided country and they don't like it one bit. are we a country divided? >> yes, we are. >> is that disturbing? >> it's terrible. it's terrible. the thing is, this guy is doing what he said he was going to do. he's doing things that the
american public want done. and we've got congress people -- senators, congress people that don't even want to listen to him. >> reporter: the advice from people in small town america, those who were watching the speech last night, those who still think that this country has a long way to go in terms of uniting itself and perhaps representing all americans, well, they say people should come over to a place like janelle's diner and settle their differences in the small town america way -- over a cup of coffee at a corner table. back to you. >> over a cup of coffee at a corner table. nobody does it like kevin tibbles. thank you very much. a dangerous storm is still churning after spawning deadly storms in the midwest. we'll take a look at the damage and where it could hit next. let's take a look at what you're saying about today's microsoft pulse question.
so far only 9% of you say yes. 91% say no. didn't do much to heal a divided country, at least on our pulse poll online. we'll be right back. will your business be ready when growth presents itself? american express open cards can help you take on a new job, or fill a big order or expand your office and take on whatever comes next. find out how american express cards and services can help prepare you for growth at open.com. when i got into my accident find out how american express card♪ and services i broke almost every bone in both my legs.
when i came home from the hospital i needed to be able to recover. tempur-pedic allowed me to do just that. because i don't have the average body type anymore i feel like my tempur-pedic really conforms to my body shape. power is not giving up, it's choosing to thrive. tempur-pedic. this sleep is power. i've got a nice long life ahead. big plans. so when i found out medicare doesn't pay all my medical expenses, i looked at my options. then i got a medicare supplement insurance plan. [ male announcer ] if you're eligible for medicare, you may know it only covers about 80% of your part b medical expenses. the rest is up to you. call now and find out about an aarp medicare supplement insurance plan, insured by unitedhealthcare insurance company. like all standardized medicare supplement insurance plans,
it helps pick up some of what medicare doesn't pay. and could save you in out-of-pocket medical costs. to me, relationships matter. i've been with my doctor for 12 years. now i know i'll be able to stick with him. [ male announcer ] with these types of plans, you'll be able to visit any doctor or hospital that accepts medicare patients. plus, there are no networks, and virtually no referrals needed. so don't wait. call now and request this free decision guide to help you better understand medicare... and which aarp medicare supplement plan might be best for you. there's a wide range to choose from. we love to travel - and there's so much more to see. so we found a plan that can travel with us. anywhere in the country. [ male announcer ] join the millions of people who have already enrolled in the only medicare supplement insurance plans endorsed by aarp, an organization serving the needs of people 50 and over for generations.
remember, all medicare supplement insurance plans help cover what medicare doesn't pay. and could save you in out-of-pocket medical costs. call now to request your free decision guide. and learn more about the kinds of plans that will be here for you now - and down the road. i have a lifetime of experience. so i know how important that is. i did... n't. hat? hey, come look what lisa made. wow. you grilled that chicken? yup! i did... n't. smartmade frozen meals. real ingredients, grilled and roasted. it's like you made it. and you did... n't. right now a powerful line of storms is headed toward the mid-atlantic and northeast. that sale storm system triggered tornadoes overnight that killed at least three people in the midwest. blake mccoy is in the hard-hit
town of naplate, illinois. blake? >> reporter: yeah, small town but, man, did they get pounded by those storms overnight. one of the tornadoes ripped right through here. can you see the damage it caused. look at this on the ground. this is the siding of someone's home. whose home is anyone's guess because as you look street after street after street, just remarkable damage out here. there has been no one reported dead at this point in this town, so some very good news when you look at the dwef station. a man was killed after a tree fell over on him, a man am his 70s. i spoke to someone a street over whose house is totally destroyed. take a listen to what he had to say. >> this is 100 times worse than i saw last night. this is what i got. it wiped it out. now it will be years to rebuild. this doesn't happen overnight. >> reporter: back out here live. the national weather service hasn't yet said how powerful the
tornado that struck this town was. you can see by the damage this was a very strong storm. the tree snapped. some stories from the street here, the person in this white home, a renter, doesn't have renter's insurance. she doesn't know what she's going to do to be able to rebuild. the person, if we can swivel over here who lives on the second floor of that apartment building, that brick part right,there she says she was home at the time the tornado came through, wasn't able to mike it to the basement for cover. so, instead, she grabbed her dog, jumped in the bathtub and covered the dog as all of the debris was flying around her. after the storm passed, she looked out of the tub and her roof was gone, many walls were gone and was thankful. her porch was gone. she couldn't get out of her second floor unit. she had to text and call friends. they put a ladder up to the second floor to get her out. a really sad scene here, especially as that man mentioned when you realize this is not going to be rebuilt overnight. a lot of people have lost everything and it will take
quite some time. the people who are displaced will be helped by the red cross and they're all at a community center a few blocks away. katy? >> blake mccoy live in illinois, thank you. wnbc's dave price is here to talk about what's going to happen next, what should expect to be hit and how bad it will be. >> this powerful system continues to make its way towards the northeast. blake was reporting from illinois. 25 different reports so far of tornado touchdowns. those are now being investigated by the national weather service. so, those numbers may go up or down, depending on what they find. keep in mind, powerful system. now it races towards the northeast. the storm system going at 60 miles per hour right now. that's the speed with which this system is rolling its way towards the mid-atlantic region. now, keep in mind, we have tornado watches as we head to the south. we have severe thunderstorm watches as we head into the northeast corridor. it's going to be a rough evening
for many, particularly from birmingham to atlanta, charlotte, raleigh, into the washington, d.c. area, the capitol district. it's going to be a very rough go. stretching all the way into central new jersey and even into the new york metropolitan area. 78 million people at risk from this storm. this is a fast-mover. by the time we get to about 7:00 tonight, all of it is through. behind it, windy conditions and a big drop in temperatures. upwards of 30 degrees bit time we get to friday. we could be looking at flurries one again. up and down. 71egrees today here in new york cy. >> yeah very strong system beginning to roll through. >> that's weird. it's february. it's very odd. wnbc weather anchor dave price. thank you for joining us. we'll go back to politics with former congressman ron paul who took trump to school last night on twitter. his overall grade of the president's performance, a d-minus. ron paul joins us next. ery doll.
that's why i have the spark cash card from capital one. with it, i earn unlimited 2% cash back on all of my purchasing. and that unlimited 2% cash back from spark means thousands of dollars each year going back into my business... which adds fuel to my bottom line. what's in your wallet? i did... n't. hat? hey, come look what lisa made. wow. you grilled that chicken? yup! i did... n't. smartmade frozen meals. real ingredients, grilled and roasted. it's like you made it. and you did... n't. befi was a doer.gia, i was active. then the chronic, widespread pain drained my energy. my doctor said moving more helps ease fibromyalgia pain. she also prescribed lyrica. fibromyalgia is thought to be the result of overactive nerves. lyrica is believed to calm these nerves. for some, lyrica can significantly relieve
fibromyalgia pain and improve function, so i feel better. lyrica may cause serious allergic reactions or suicidal thoughts or actions. tell your doctor right away if you have these, new or worsening depression, or unusual changes in mood or behavior. or swelling, trouble breathing, rash, hives, blisters, muscle pain with fever, tired feeling, or blurry vision. common side effects are dizziness, sleepiness, weight gain and swelling of hands, legs and feet. don't drink alcohol while taking lyrica. don't drive or use machinery until you know how lyrica affects you. those who have had a drug or alcohol problem may be more likely to misuse lyrica. with less pain, i can be more active. ask your doctor about lyrica. by simply enjoying it. boost® simply complete. it's intelligent nutrition made with only 9 ingredients, plus 25 vitamins and minerals and 10 grams of protein. and look where life can take you! boost®. be up for it.™
as republicans in congress applauded president trump during his speech last night, one former gop lawmaker was tweeting from home. let's just say ron paul's tweets were not exactly complimentary of the commander in chief. the former texas congressman tweeted 33 times during the president's address. the final tweeted was a libertarian grade of the speech and that was an "f "for plans and strategy and a d-minus
overall. congressman, thank you for joining me, number one. tell me, why did you give donald trump such poor grades last night? >> well, you have to realize, i was analyzing this from a libertarian viewpoint. most people are analyzing it from a democratic viewpoint or republican viewpoint. but a libertarian looks at it, you know, we want less war, less spending. we don't more militarization. we don't like more debt, so i would say that from a libertarian viewpoint, it wasn't much we could be cheering about. it looks like there will continue to be a war on drugs and marijuana. that's not conducive to protecting civil liberties in this country. there was no expression of real concern with debt. that, to me, is a problem. and the subject of the real culprit in our weak economy happens to be monetary policy something, i've talked about for years. most people are starting to recognize that there is a great significance about our federal
reserve system contributing to some of the problems we have. so, i didn't get to hear any of that. i thought it was more, you know, more of the same with a variation of what i've heard for the 30 years i've been involved in politics. >> what do you think of your former former -- your former congressman -- or your former fellow congressman, that's what i was looking for, applauding at gop members applauding at an expanded role the government could take, applauding at spending more money? >> yes. even when trump -- i think he was talking about cutting something on foreign aid and republicans are fighting with him. no, i think that shows you that the congress has been pretty inept to standing up to the executive branch. something i've always said congress should be protecting the people and protecting us, and exert their authority, such as the war issue and things like this, but they don't. and i would say that the
republicans are joining in with the spending. i'm very fearful of the foreign policy because right now i think there's a growing number of people who are working together to further bash russia and paint them as the enemy and maybe stir up trouble there. republicans and many democrats who just don't like trump. so, i think foreign policy is a big issue for me. and i think with him appointments, mcmaster wants more troops over there. the amount of money, what's conservative about increasing the military budget and ignoring defense? every time you spend money on the military, doesn't mean you're helping defense. you might be annoying people who make us more vulnerable and we might be less secure. and any spending that goes along, but there is a segment of conservatives and basically the supply siders have argued, republicans spend too much time worrying about deficit. we don't have to worry about that, but liberals are known to be that way.
but then they come up with these crazy schemes of saying, well, this dynamic scoring, we're going to stimulate the economy, we're going to take it from 2% to 4%. it's going to pay all the bills, don't worry, don't worry about the deficit. so, didn't sound like less government to me. it sounded like trying to actually appease democrats to some degree where they like infrastructure spending. i think those kind of things will get passed easily. the military spening is going to get passed, too. and i just don't think that i've done a very good job over the years, or doesn't seem to be too many libertarians in the u.s. congress. >> i don't mean to interrupt but i want to get through -- i want to talk about some tweets you sent out last night. you sent out, i believe, 33 of them. one you were criticizing the president's use of the term radical islamic terrorism. you say, protect against radical islamic terrorism? you can't do it until you understand concept of blowback. that's notable because donald
trump's national security adviser h.r. mcmaster according to one of my sources, did tell president trump to take it out ofs his speech. he didn't tell him to. he recommended he take it out of his speech because he said it would be counterproductive to try and alienate a number of muslims in the process. what is your take? >> that's a good strategy because people are starting to wake up to this effect. but they haven't minced words on we are going to expand. we will go anyplace, any spot to root out anybody who's a terrorist. well, they're suspects, you know, this sort of thing. they're madder than the devil. they're furious with us. because, you know, we're bombing their country. that's why there's migration all over europe. we have participated in the destruction of many, many countries in the middle east. so that does not seem to be changing. i think they're bearing down on that. mcmaster wants to use troops -- actually, obama was a little more reserved.
he cut back troops on the ground getting killed. that wasn't a solution because people still get angry at you from bombing people. but, no they want to change that policy. they want to g away from that. they want more troops on the ground. i think it's a very dangerous trend away from, you know, the little bit of effort that was done the last several years to try to avoid some of these conflicts. >> former texas congressman, ron paul. i was trying keep up with you. you were talking so fast and my mouth doesn't quite move as fast as yours does, congressman. thank you for joining us. >> you're welcome. before we leave you, we want to go back to a moment we had earlier today. a simple thank you from president after his address to congress last night. many are asking if it's a sign of trump changing hi tone. before we leave you, we want to go to historian doris kerns goodwin. with my colleague, andrea mitchell, she gave historical advice.
>> if he's going to be able to leave this message lie, then he only has to tweet when he's happy, not angry. there should be a fake twitter account when he's angry and nobody should see it except for him and his family. >> the results are in, 43.3 million people watched his speech, down from 52 million who watched president obama's speech back in 2009. that wraps things up for me this hour. i'm katy tur. ali velshi picks things up for kate snow. >> i really enjoy that conversation with ron paul. we've had our debates and disagreements over the years, but he thinks very clearly. >> does he. >> he does talk fast. >> he does talk fast and he keeps going and he's a great interview. >> he really is. a lot of personality. >> i think you meant it as a compliment when you said he talked really fast. >> i did. >> you're a fast talker, so am i and we have to work fast as we have a lot of news. i'm ali velshi in for kate snow. our top stories. it's a big final hour on wal