Skip to main content

tv   The Last Word With Lawrence O Donnell  MSNBC  October 18, 2018 10:00pm-11:00pm PDT

10:00 pm
>> good evening, rachel.
10:01 pm
i'm glad you talked about abigail coming on. it's a fascinating video we're going to show what congressman bratt said. but i want to talk about what donald trump has been doing in relation to the fbi building across the street from his multi-million dollar hotel business in washington, d.c. and in the middle of your conversation you asked the congressman just what are the possible legal implications for the president, and i found him to be kind of reluctant to go right into a forceful answer, because i was sitting at it looking at it saying at any previous time the president would be under serious impeachment investigation threat at minimum threat that would be the beginnings of impeachment investigations over this very issue. we've never had a president with a multi-million dollar business
10:02 pm
on pennsylvania avenue before. so we've never seen this particular thing before, but it is truly stunning. >> well, and also just nailing a president black and white, with photographic evidence and the e-mails to back it up, they have nailed down a very solid case i think that i think any prosecutor would take as a president taking official action to benefit his business and then lying about it and then orchestrating a cover-up of it, it's really cut and dry. this is not something you need to understand this whole sprawling thing about, it's basically rank basically proven corruption. and congressman comings is a smart guy and savvy guy and politic politician, and i don't think he's going to come out before the election and say that's impeachable. but that's a story you teach to prevent. >> if you go back to nixon, if he owned a building on
10:03 pm
pennsylvania avenue, he would never have been caught himself in the conversations about anything about any federal business that could affect that building. you would have made sure that maneuver was done in a way he could do anything about it. >> and the president's orders and the time line he wants to do it on, i mean this is -- this isn't even dramatic. it's just a question of -- it's not dramatic in terms of figuring out what happened here. it's clear of what happened here. just a question of whether there will be accountability. >> and have i to wonder how many of those people who put that in writing wanted someday that to find out what the president has actually done. thank you, rachel. >> thanks. well, today the president of
10:04 pm
the united states finally agknowledged the obvious about "the washington post" colonist jamal khashoggi. >> do you believe jamal khashoggi is dead? >> it certainly looks that way to me, it's very sad. it certainly looks that way. >> what are you considering as a possible consequence for saudi? >> well, it would have to be severe. i mean it's bad, bad stuff but we'll see what happens, okay? >> that came toward the end of a long day at the white house where the trump administration's continued to avoid the simplest question that anyone has ever asked a secretary of state. >> sir, is he dead? sir, is jamal khashoggi dead? >> is he dead? that's the question that nbc's peter alexander asked, a question that has been vexing the trump administration, while the trump administration has been working with saudi arabia to try to come up with what sources told "the washington post" would be, quote, a
10:05 pm
mutually agreeable explanation. that was their term for it. mutually agreeable explanation for what happened to and mall khashoggi. earlier today he tried to continue to buy time for saudi arabia to come up with their cover story while refusing to even acknowledge that he was asked more than once, is he dead. >> they also assured me that they will conduct a complete, thorough investigation of all of the facts surrounding mr. khashoggi and do so in a timely fashion. i told president trump this morning we ought to give them a few more days to complete that. >> why should saudi arabia be trusted to conduct a fair and impartial investigation when they're accused of the disappearance and apparent murder of jamal khashoggi? >> so we're all going to get to see the work, the responses the kingdom of saudi arabia takes with us. >> they made a personal commitment to me and the crown
10:06 pm
prince also made a commitment to the president when he spoke to him. >> according to "the times" that official is general ahmed al aziri. and "the new york times" also reporting the president's son-in-law jared kushner urging the president to stand behind the crown prince. quote, mr. kushner has argued that the crown prince can survive the outrage just as he has weathered past criticism. nbc news reporting tonight u.s. intelligence agencies investigating the killing of jamal khashoggi believe it's inconceivable that saudi crown prince mohammed bin salman had no connection to his death. earlier this week "the new york times" published images that
10:07 pm
show one of the alleged members of the 15-man team that is suspected of murdering jamal khashoggi also frequently traveled with the saudi crown prince. today a turkish newspaper released new surveillance evidence that showed the same man entering the saudi consulate hours before khashoggi disappeared. the images also show him at the saudi consul general's home later that day and then leaving an istanbul hotel and then at the airport to leave turkey that night. in an interview with "the new york times" today donald trump gave up the game of pretending that he was still waiting to find out what happened to jamal khashoggi. he told "the times" this one has caught the imagination of the world, unfortunately, it's not a positive -- not a positive unless the miracles of all miracles happens, i would acknowledge that he's dead. that's based on everything, the
10:08 pm
intelligence coming on all sides. joining us now an msnbc national security contributor, also joining us peter, senior fellow at the ethics and public center, an advisor to the past three, national political reporter for nbc news. and ned price, i wanted to get your reading of how the administration's language has changed or possibly whether donald trump himself has just fallen out of the course that mike pompeo was obviously trying to maintain of refusing to use the words dead or alive or just acknowledge there was even a question about is he dead. >> yeah, lawrence, i was reminded watching your intro this was the same mike pompeo who just earlier this week wrote an essay in foreign affairs on the u.s. strategy towards iran. and the last section of that essay is called the power of moral clarity.
10:09 pm
we have seen nothing but moral clarity from mike pompeo and his boss trump. it is certainly not moral clarity to travel to riyadh to be all laughs and all smiles next to mohammed bin salman who seems to be the prime suspect or the prime architect in this murder and then to come back to d.c. and claim that you issued something along the lines of an ultimatum. there is a tremendous discordance between those two. that is not moral clarity. what we have seen from mike pompeo is nothing but moral -- and donald trump is what seem tuesday be a coconspirator in the cover-up. there's an adage in this town the cover-up is worse than the crime. that is certainly not the case given the heinous crime we're
10:10 pm
talking about here, but there is a cover-up that is going on that the saudis seem to have been behind but that donald trump would have been all too happy to support. >> peter, the give the saudis more time -- give the saudis more time to figure out what happened in one of their consulates, how much time would that take? >> well, it would take in one sense forever and it would take no time at all because they know what happened. they were of course complicit. the crown prince was involved in this, and i think ned is right, this is part of a cover-up. i just want to say this idea of mike pompeo talking about moral clarity, what's so absurd about that is that presupposes there is in the president a person with a moral view of things. and i think the fundamental interpretive fact of the trump presidency and i think this saudi example is just one of the station of it, is this person is someone who's fundamentally
10:11 pm
amoral and immoral. he's a man in many respects without conscience. and most of us hear about this not just a murder but a particularly gruesome murder of dismemberment and torture and you're horrified by it, angered by it and you feel there has to be a response to it. i don't think donald trump is capable of that, and i think that we've seen that lack of human empathy and conscience in almost every arena of the trump presidency. it explains the cruelty, explains the policy at the border, separating kids from children. it explains the pathological lies. it explains the fact he's a man without loyalty. and i think that this is just the latest arena in which we're seeing this ugly drama play itself out. >> the republican chairman of the senate foreign relations committee, senator bob corker
10:12 pm
said this, this is going to come to a head in a very short amount of time. this isn't getting better over time. it seems to me in the next week or so people are going to know more about what happened. it can't go on that long. they need to come out and share their views of what happened and share with us. and josh, he's talking about the administration there when he says they need to come out and share their views. and so the trump administration has not been sharing their views with republican senators. >> they have not. they have been trying to keep their comments very limited. until the saudis come out with whatever their new explanation is going to be. and all indications, lawrence, is that the saudis are trying to reverse engineer how much information is already out there. how much does the u.s. intelligence community and other spy agencies already know about what happened, and therefore what can the saudis really get away with in their explanation?
10:13 pm
so the u.s. is trying not to get ahead of that. we see secretary pompeo saying we need to give the saudis a few more days to fully investigate this, and the u.s. light on this has been, look, they say they're going to do a transparent investigation, and we are going to see the results of that. and if it's a credible investigation, if it's thorough, we'll be able to see that. and if it's a sham and they're trying to cover things up, we'll be able to see that, too. but the question here that the state department, the white house, top u.s. officials have been unable to answer, lawrence, is how does an authoritarian government perform a full-fledged investigation when the chief culprit of who is likely implicated in this is the person atop that government? there seems to be no indication that the saudi government would be able to conduct an investigation that would turn up actually, yes, crown prince mohammed ordered a killing. so if that possibility of an investigation is taken off the table, it's very difficult to see how this turns out something that the world sees as credible. >> and ned price tonight
10:14 pm
secretary of state pompeo was running away from questions has he heard any audio recording of the murder, has he read any transcript of the murder, because reporting is running ahead of the official story as it's being manage bide both the saudis and the united states. and so reporters are now equipped with questions that are running ahead of where mike pompeo wants to be. >> yeah, lawrence, we're getting into pretty dangerous territory because it seems like what our intelligence community has in its possession is quite different from what we've heard from people like donald trump and mike pompeo. this is not the first time there's been a disparity. we need only look back at the russia case to see our intelligence community believing one thing firmly and unanimously and something else completely different coming from donald trump's mouth. but it seems like we're getting in that territory again. and this is going to create even
10:15 pm
more tension and frustration between donald trump and his intelligence community if he continues to spout conclusions, to say things like rogue killing teams that just don't comport with what our intelligence community already has in hand. >> peter whiner, how should a president handle a crisis like this with a geopolitical historic ally for which there are many reasons to try and maintain an alliance that works best when that ally is possibly implicated in something as bad as this? >> yeah, that's a good question. and i should stipulate that this is not an easy foreign policy challenge, any president would face a challenge for the reason that you said. i think what i would do first in terms of halting president trump is all of his snngts and his actions have made the situation worse not better. i think what you would want from a president is one to speak out
10:16 pm
with really some degree of moral clarity on this, and that is not what happened with trump. all of his reactions were really discordant with traditional american values. so one was nativistic. he said mr. khashoggi wasn't an american citizen. he's not caucasian, he's muslim. he's not really one of us. it was transactional, it's going to cost us money, and it was rogue killers. at the same time you've got to be canal to work with that regime and say there has to be a consequence to it without necessarily overturning the entire regime. the concern here if the worry is that the house of sod may fall in mishandling this so badly both them and us, there's so much pressure that is created is that it actually accelerates the fall, and that would be
10:17 pm
problematic because saudi arabia for all of its problems and oppressive ways is something of a bold work against iran. i think what we're seeing with trump is someone who is mishandling it and may get the worst of all possible worlds. >> thank you interest starting us off tonight. really appreciate it. and when we come back, donald trump's desperate lies and they are becoming more and more desperate lies about covering pre-existing conditions in health care policies. why the republicans are campaigning on the big lie. and as rachel said, we will be joined by former cia officer abigail spamberger who is running for congress, and she'll describe what she says are shameful comments made by congressman dave pratt.
10:18 pm
10:19 pm
10:20 pm
they will after i speak to them. i am in total support. also, democrats will destroy your medicare and i will keep it healthy and well." donald trump, of course, does not know the meaning of the word healthy. here is what donald trump
10:21 pm
promised when he was running for president. >> repeal and replace that horror show called obamacare. we're going to repeal and replace obamacare. we're losing with obamacare which will be repealed and replaced. obamacare is a disaster. we're going to repeal it and replace it. my poll numbers are going through the roof. a big part of it is obamacare because we're going to repeal it and replace it. >> and now republican poll numbers are in trouble because of exactly that. once elected donald trump and republicans tried to repeal obamacare and failed and republicans did manage to find room in their giant deficit exploding tax cut for the rich to effectively repeal the individual mandate to buy health insurance and obamacare. and then the trump justice department joined republican state attorneys general in a lawsuit that seeks to repeal all of obamacare including the legal provision that requires health insurance to cover pre-existing conditions.
10:22 pm
donald trump and the republicans have done everything they possibly can to eliminate the guarantee of health insurance for people with pre-existing conditions. and now that they have discovered that is very unpopular thing to do, they have simply begun to lie about their position while continuing to push the lawsuit that would in fact eliminate coverage for pre-existing conditions. >> we can protect pre-existing conditions, and you need to understand everyone agrees bexar going to protect pre-existing conditions. >> it was donald trump who called him lying ted, not me. ted cruz is lying, of course. and he is one of the republican senate candidates who's smart enough to know he is lying. republican senate candidate in arizona martha mcsally is taking the same kind of lies to voters there. josh holly, the republican candidate in missouri is telling the same kind of lie in his campaign against clara mccaskill
10:23 pm
who does support coverage for pre-existing conditions and actually voted for the only federal law in american history that does that, obamacare. republican governor scott walker is struggling in his re-election bid in wisconsin. republicans have actually advised the white house not to waste president trump's campaign time in the white house are they believe scott walker cannot win election, but president trump wants to go to wisconsin anyway, probably just to remind people he won wisconsin. and when president trump does campaign with scott walker in wisconsin you will surely hear some version of this big lie. >> covering pre-existing conditions is personal to me. plus it's just the right thing to do. as long as i'm governor i will always cover pre-existing conditions. >> it is the right thing to do, but governor scott walker is fully supportive of the wrong thing. he's fully supportive of his state attorney general who has joined the federal lawsuit to
10:24 pm
effectively repeal obamacare and eliminate the federal guarantee covering pre-existing conditions. joining us now an economic policy advisor to president biden and a former senior aide to president obama, and i have never before seen the strategy of let's all hold hands and just lie about everything we've been trying to do for the last two years. >> lawrence, voters trusting republicans to protect their pre-existing conditions at this stage will be like dorothy in the very last scene of the "wizard of oz" handing over toto to the wicked witch and saying this will be fine. he campaigned to get rid of it and then threw a beer bash in the rose garden to celebrate
10:25 pm
republicans passing a bill to get rid of it. if all that wasn't enough just the other day mitch mcconnell promised that the democrats don't take back the house and the senate, he will try again to get rid of it. so it's absolutely clear what's going to happen and the only way to protect coverage of pre-existing conditions is for voters to elect a democratic house and democratic senate, otherwise this will go away. >> can republicanps just get away with this lie? is the subject complicated enough that the voters just can't follow this? >> it's very clear logic that both you and ron klain laid out, and in fact broke my heart there for a second. of course, people who are paying any attention to the reality of
10:26 pm
the situation as the two of you just articulated have to know these lies are so pervasive. but there's a wrinkle i want people to know about. some of the republican plans argue that insurers must cover everyone, they can't deny coverage. and some of these plans actually do have that. however, they then say those insurers can charge people with pre-existing conditions whenever they want in terms of premiums and they doercht have to even cover illnesses related to the pre-existing condition. so if you have heart disease and you get coverage they can charge you hundreds of dollars for a premium, and if you have a heart attack the insurer can say we're not covering those claims because that was pre-existing. so it's precisely what you and ron said. sometimes you have to read the fine print, but i think at this
10:27 pm
point i've got to say, i mean if a voter does not recognize that these folks are not just gunning pre-existing conditions but actually gunning for medicare and social security to help offset the cost of their corporate tax cut, then they're just not paying attention. >> and ron, i think it's fair to assume that donald trump has absolutely no idea what he say talking about and has no idea how pre-existing conditions works in law now and how it would work if the lawsuit was successful. but people like ted cruz know exactly what they are lying about. >> yeah, you know, it really is interesting, as you said maybe donald trump doesn't know better. although it's kind of crazy he has his own attorney general in court suing to take away this coverage as he's promising he'll protect it. but a lot of these republicans do know better. what you're really seeing is that in a reversal is the affordable care act is popular. democrats are running on the affordable care act, and they're going to win elections on the affordable care act. that's a dramatic reversal in how the public regards this law.
10:28 pm
president obama, he was right in 2010. a lot of people paid the big political price to pass this law and finally people are appreciating what it does for people. >> what's interesting is i agree with ron about the popularity of the affordable care act. but i also would like to point out the unpopularity of the tax cut. okay, so the republican national committee just leaked a memo, came out where they were advising their candidates that voters recognize that republicans want to cut social security, medicare, medicaid in order to offset the costs of their tax cuts. that's not a popular message, and i think it's probably pretty hard at this point to find a republican who is running on these deficit inducing tax cuts because we now have republican leaders like mitch mcconnell
10:29 pm
pointing to those deficits as a rationale for cutting social security and medicare, programs that republican based voters actually like a lot. >> john bernstein, ron klain, thank you both for joining us tonight. and coming up virginia republican congressman james brat, his opponent is abigail spanberger, a former cia officer. and as rachel mentioned at the top of this hour, she will join us next. top of this hour, she will join us next. nings were made for better things, than psoriatic arthritis. as you and your rheumatologist consider treatments, ask if xeljanz xr is right for you. xeljanz xr is a once daily pill for psoriatic arthritis. taken with methotrexate or similar medicines, it can reduce joint pain... ...swelling and significantly improve physical function. xeljanz xr can lower your ability to fight infections, including tuberculosis. serious, sometimes fatal infections, lymphoma and other cancers have happened. don't start xeljanz xr if you have an infection. tears in the stomach or intestines, low blood cell counts and higher liver tests, and cholesterol levels have happened. your doctor should perform blood tests before you start and while taking xeljanz xr,
10:30 pm
and monitor certain liver tests. tell your doctor if you were in a region where fungal infections are common and if you have had tb, hepatitis b or c, or are prone to infections. xeljanz xr can reduce the symptoms of psoriatic arthritis. don't let another morning go by without talking to your rheumatologist about xeljanz xr. but let's be honest, nobody likes dealing with insurance. which is why esurance hired me, dennis quaid, as their spokesperson because apparently, i'm highly likable. see, they know it's confusing. i literally have no idea what i'm getting, dennis quaid. that's why they're making it simple, man in cafe. and more affordable. thank you, dennis quaid. you're welcome. that's a prop apple. i'd tell you more, but i only have 30 seconds. so here's a dramatic shot of their tagline
10:31 pm
so you'll remember it. esurance. it's surprisingly painless.
10:32 pm
republican congressman dave brat is in in a tight re-election race against democratic challenger abigail spanberger. he's in the normally safe republican district which he won in 2016 by 15 points while donald trump was winning the
10:33 pm
state of virginia by 5 points. now congressman brat believes he needs president trump's help. today he tweeted dave has my total endorsement. also today congressman brat issued this statement. as a christian we love the least of these. we visit those in prison as a member of the congress, one of the most moving experiences i have in this job is talking to recovering men and women fighting to rebuilding their lives. fighting to rebuilding their lives, there was their choice of words. a congressman issued that statement after a statement became public of what he said after speaking with prisoners at a county jail in virginia. >> you think you're having a hard time, i've got $5 million worth of negative ads coming at me. how do you think i'm feeling? i've got a daughter she's got to deal with that crap on tv every day.
10:34 pm
>> democratic candidate abigail spanberger tweeted this. it is absolutely shameful for dave brat to compare the hardship of addiction and the struggles of recovery to his campaign. this is an affront to every person in recovery and the virginians who die daily due to addiction. one of the many running for congress for the first time. >> before i announced my candidacy for congress. >> i chose to serve my country. >> i bled on foreign soil for people to have the right to vote. >> this the thfirst time i've run for office. >> i have never run for political office before. >> i started realizing maybe i should go on myself. >> i was like let's go, let's do this. >> and come november 6th i will continue to serve the people. >> of michigan. >> virginia. >> kentucky. >> of texas. >> i will continue to serve the people of the united states of america. >> are you ready to serve america? >> joining us now abigail spanberger in virginia's seventh district and former cia officer.
10:35 pm
abigail spanberger i want to get your reaction again to what congressman brat said. we heard him telling people in jail and struggling with their addiction problems, that he has problems, too, because he's trying to run for re-election to congress. >> yeah. to me his comments were just emblematic of how out of touch he is with the challenges people across our district are facing. i spend time talking with voters, listening to people's concerns and very personal, personal stories, and the idea that someone in a position of elected office, someone in a position of power would sit before people facing incredible challenges like substance use disorders in their own recovery
10:36 pm
and compare it to an election experience is just kind of beyond the pail for me. >> opioid addiction has hit the country hard. it's hit your district in a serious way. donald trump running for president said he was going to address this, he was going to fix it, the problem was going to go away. what has president trump -- what have you seen in your district that president trump and congressman brat have done? >> so in our district like so many districts across the country, the opioid crisis and substance use disorders continue to really impact people across the district. it's one of the top issues that people talk about, and we need to make a lot more forward movement. you know, congress passed a good bill but there's still a lot to be done. you have the rights of death by overdose in our district in the state is now -- it's continuing to rise. it's surpassed other causes of premature death, and, you know, it's got to be a focus that people continue to have.
10:37 pm
and i think looking at these comments i think the real issue is that when we are looking at a challenge facing people who are struggling with substances use disorders, we need to hear their stories and we need to listen to the challenges that people are facing with substance use disorders, with health care related issues and really try to find solutions. >> what is your background as a former cia officer, bring in terms of in your view in terms of an asset of possible service in congress? >> so my background with cia is one of service, first and foremost i was serving the mission of helping to keep our policy makers, our military and diplomats informed about issues of national security. and in order to do our job well, i needed to spend a lot of time listening, listening to people, asking the right questions, seeking to understand really
10:38 pm
complicated interrelated issues. so i think from a values perspective it's a focus to this country, but from a skill set it's a focus of really truly deeplyinatesing complicated issues. >> less than three weeks now in what is traditionally a republican district to the incumbent republican. what is the closing case for you to make to your district? >> at this point it's an issue of turnout. we have had over i think it was 137 events, meet and greet events across the district. we've done policy related events so we've done all the right things. it's about turnout at this point. we have an incredible field operation on the ground, over 4,000 volunteers registered with the campaign. just getting people excite said, making sure people know their voice matters and their voice
10:39 pm
counts, but their voice has to be heard and at the polls and making sure people know how to vote and how to get there and ensuring that they do. >> what has been your biggest surprise as a first time campaigner? >> really, for me the biggest surprise is i've had the level of personal stories, the depth of personal experiences people are willing to share with candidates, with me because they hope my story because the story will inform the policy objectives i pursue later, and the trust people put in you on the hope someday you might be able to help them is really profound and very, very special. >> abigail spanberger, thank you very much for joining us. i really appreciate it. >> thank you. thank you. and when we come back, with just 19 days until election day democratic senator john tester is leading in his re-election campaign in montana.
10:40 pm
and that's where donald trump decided to go to campaign tonight. the same? that's why capital one is building something completely different. capital one cafés. welcoming places with people here to help you, not sell you. with savings and checking accounts with no fees or minimums. that are easy to open from right here or anywhere in 5 minutes.
10:41 pm
no smoke. no mirrors. this is banking reimagined. what's in your wallet? jushis local miracle ear t at helped andrew hear more of the joy in her voice. just one hearing test is all it took for him to hear more of her laugh... and less of the background noise around him. for helen, just one visit to her local miracle-ear is all it took to learn how she can share more moments with her daughter. just one free hearing test could help you hear more... call now for your free hearing test from an industry leader: miracle-ear. if your moderate to severeor crohn's symptoms are holding you back, and your current treatment hasn't worked well enough it may be time for a change. ask your doctor about entyvio®, the only biologic developed and approved just for uc and crohn's. entyvio® works at the site of inflammation in the gi tract,
10:42 pm
and is clinically proven to help many patients achieve both symptom relief and remission. infusion and serious allergic reactions can happen during or after treatment. entyvio® may increase risk of infection, which can be serious. pml, a rare, serious, potentially fatal brain infection caused by a virus may be possible. tell your doctor if you have an infection experience frequent infections or have flu-like symptoms, or sores. liver problems can occur with entyvio®. if your uc or crohn's treatment isn't working for you, ask your gastroenterologist about entyvio®. entyvio®. relief and remission within reach. omar, check this out. uh, yeah, i was calling to see if you do laser hair removal. for men. notice that my hips are off the ground. [ engine revving ] and then, i'm gonna pike my hips back into downward dog. [ rhythmic tapping ] hey, the rain stopped.
10:43 pm
-a bad day on the road still beats a good one off it. -tell me about that dental procedure again! -i can still taste it in my mouth! -progressive helps keep you out there. -i can still taste it in my mouth! (nicki palmer) being a verizon engineer is about doing things right. and there's no shortcut to the right way. so when we roll out the nation's first 5g ultra wideband network, it'll be because we were the first to install the fiber-optics and small cells, and upgrade the towers that will change the way we learn, work and live. and i'll always be proud that we're not just building america's first 5g network. we're doing it right. with just 19 days until election day, early voting is already under way. in some states yesterday was the first day of early voting. in tennessee one of states that could decide which party controls the senate new polling is giving democrats a new hope of picking up the tennessee senate seat currently held by retiring republican senator bob
10:44 pm
corker. a poll shows phil bredesen one percentage point ahead of marsha blackburn. tonight the president was campaigning in montana trying to defeat the re-election campaign of montana's democratic senator john tester. >> montana to me is a very big and powerful state, i can tell you that. at least it will be after matt rosendale becomes your senator. >> donald trump won montana by 20 points in 2016, but democratic senator john tester has been consistently pulling ahead of his republican challenger. the latest polling shows the democrat at 49%, the republican at 45%. in a state the president won by 20 points. donald trump made the mistake of holding his rally in muzula
10:45 pm
county, one of the most liberal parts of the state of montana, and one of the few liberal counties donald trump lost in 2016. and tonight the resistance to donald trump appears strong. there's a giant m overlacking the county. today some residents added a few more letters to their giant "m" that president trump couldn't miss, spelling the word m-peach. on nearby mount laola, a giant "m" which now spells the word liar, and there's no doubt who they were talking about. cal perry will join us next with
10:46 pm
the latest on the race in montana and more. the latest on the race in montana and more now your insurance won't replace it outright because of depreciation. if your insurance won't replace your car, what good is it? you'd be better off just taking your money and throwing it right into the harbor. i'm gonna regret that. with new car replacement, if your brand new car gets totaled, liberty mutual will pay the entire value plus depreciation. liberty mutual insurance. ♪ liberty. liberty. liberty. liberty. ♪ after bill's back needed a vacation from his vacation. so he stepped on the dr. scholl's kiosk. it recommends our best custom fit orthotic to relieve foot, knee, or lower back pain so you can move more. dr. scholl's. born to move. ( ♪ )
10:47 pm
stop dancing around the pain that's keeping you awake. advil pm gives tossing and turning a rest and silences aches and pains. fall asleep faster, stay asleep longer with advil pm. fall asleep faster, stay asleep longer you're in the business of helping people. we're in the business of helping you. business loans for eligible card members up to fifty thousand dollars, decided in as little as 60 seconds. the powerful backing of american express. don't do business without it. i'm not picking it up. you pick it up! i'm not picking it up.
10:48 pm
i'll pick it up! they're clean! ♪'cuz my hiney's clean.♪ ♪oh yeah i'm charmin clean.♪ charmin ultra strong just cleans better. enjoy the go with charmin.
10:49 pm
you can do things like change your settings, learn tips and tricks, troubleshoot, and even manage your account. finding your xfinity username or wifi password, restarting your equipment, or paying your bill is easier than ever with x1. x1 help. another reason to love x1. say "teach me more" into your voice remote to get started. here is donald trump campaigning for the republican senate candidate in montana tonight. >> he used to say he wears a hairpiece, they don't say that anymore. >> that's what you get when donald trump comes to campaign for you.
10:50 pm
nbc's cal perry has been all over montana talking to voters about theelection. cal, what have you found? >> lawrence, you know, in montana it's about authenticity. montana is a long way from washington, d.c. people pride themselves on that. it's not just about who is the best rancher, though we do see tester and rosen dale firing back and forth at each other over that issue. authenticity in montana means independence, specifically independence from washington, d.c. politics. what does it mean to be montana? >> it's beautiful here. you've got mountains. you've got the lakes. you've got everything. >> i wouldn't leave here for nothing. >> whenever god comes to earth, he stays in montana. >> we have a lot of great things to offer. we're the last great place. >> montana means being in the mountains. that means hunting and fishing. >> here the way you live your life outdoors matters. people detest hunter because he doesn't have a hunting license. rosen dale is from maryland.
10:51 pm
he voted for the state lands. >> maryland and other states bought it all up and they blocked it all off. >> you say maryland because of rosendale, right? >> claims to be a cattle rancher, doesn't have a brand. doesn't own cattle. >> he portrays himself one way when he's in the state of montana, but when he's in washington, d.c., he's voting with chuck schumer and liberal democrats. >> people call montana the last best place. that's how important public lands are. you can go in this part of the state hunting on horseback to an entirely separate part of the state to yellow stone river where public lands are just as important . people come from all over the world to fish. is there a difference on tester and rosendale on public lands? >> i don't think there is a difference in public land issues in the state of montana. we all believe in public land. it is all a question whether you want the state to manage it or the feds. >> who should control public
10:52 pm
lands, the state, federal government -- >> the state. >> tell me why, sir. >> because the feds, there is too much bureaucracy. everything is done in d.c. nobody knows what goes on out here in the west. >> i think the state is more qualified to control public lands than the federal government sitting on their as in washington, d.c. >> folks do genuinely sincerely believe if somehow we transfer the public lands to the state, that everything would be solved, they'd have a much more direct access to the people that were making decisions about management policies on the land. >> the truth of the matter is we can't afford to run our office of public assistance. we had to close down our mental health center. we had to close down the job placement center, the job service. if you can't fund just basic social services for the state, how are you going to suddenly manage however many million acres we have of public land in montana? the answer is ron. >> whoever is managing those lands, be it the state or federal government, providing as much access as possible to the
10:53 pm
public for their lands is -- should be one of their highest priorities. >> you cannot be dogmatic. you can't be overly partisan because if you are, you're not going to get anything done. >> there is a big divide between urban and rural and i think in order to fix that, people need to see the west. they need to come out west and experience it and talk to people in the west firsthand. >> lawrence, these rallies that we see from the president which are really trump rock concerts, you see these consistent trump notes. one of them is of course on the media. there was a nasty one tonight about gianforte, how trump approved that assault. the report we're hearing more consistently is the idea he's worried about votes. he's worried about votes in the senate. a senator gets sick and we lose a vote, and with impeachment sitting on that mountain behind him, that's what he's thinking about. he's whipping votes and what a place to start in a state that he won by 20 points. it's a state where you can telekind of feels like he should be doing an end zone dance, lawrence.
10:54 pm
>> yeah, and, cal, it's stunning to see those signs on the hills there. who made the mistake of choosing missoula as the location for this event one of the liberal outposts in montana? >> it seems like an arrogant move. and an intentional one, and an overt move. this is a president who is more and more doing things overtly. he's doing things in the face of liberal cities around the country and, missoula is the one that is a little liberal leaning. he won the state by 20 points. his son has been out there hunting, holding these rallies, thumbing his nose at liberals, talking about the second amendment. this rally tonight was as trumpian as you can get, lawrence. >> and in montana, strong republican state in presidential elections, but it has been sending a democrat to the united states that senate at least one for a very long time, jon tester. maximum back us in the senate a couple decades before democrat, before jon tester. so there is a formula for democrats in montana.
10:55 pm
>> and, listen, you know, the republicans should be pretty happy with jon tester. he's not the most liberal person in washington d.c.. the problem is for donald trump, again, he doesn't vote like a republican. he may share some of the ideals as the republican party, but he votes like a democrat. and you see the touch stone issue. the thing that people really hit on is this schumer idea. oh, he votes with schumer, right? we heard that out in montana a lot. we heard this idea donald trump is going to have to defend donald trump one day on the floor of the senate, and that's the day that he's planning for and you can see it in these rallies. >> cal perry, thank you for your reporting from montana. really appreciate it. tonight's last word is next. ? ? fact is, there have been twenty-six in the last decade. allstate is adapting. with drones to assess home damage sooner. and if a flying object damages your car, you can snap a photo and get your claim processed in hours, not days. plus, allstate can pay your claim in minutes.
10:56 pm
now that you know the truth... are you in good hands? your digestive system has billions of bacteria but life can throw them off balance. re-align yourself with align probiotic. and try new align gummies with prebiotics and probiotics to help support digestive health.
10:57 pm
a car you can command when does that require mind-control?
10:58 pm
no. just some mind-blowing engineers from the ford motor company and pivotal who developed fordpass, allowing you to reach out to your car from wherever you are to check your fuel level, unlock your doors and start your engine... so when you're ready to go, your car is, too. magic can't make digital transformation happen... but we can. that's the power of pivotal, part of dell technologies.
10:59 pm
time for tonight's last word. >> allegations of voter suppression in the georgia governor's race, an associated press report revealed georgia put a hold on more than 53,000 voter registration applications with nearly 70% of them belonging to african americans. >> 70%, that's in the state that's only 30% black, by the way. so, if i do the math in my head, let me see, that's [ bleep ] racist. >> samantha b. gets tonight's last word. tonight's last word coming to
11:00 pm
you live from boston tonight. "the 11th hour" with brian williams starts now. >> tonight we have a new talking point for the midterm campaign at a rally in mont monlt. donald trump road tested the phrase democrats produce mobs republicans produce jobs. he also treated his audience to a thorough review of his 2016 victory. back at the white house, john kelly and john bolton got into a profane shouting match over immigration. one of the men left and didn't come back. the president admits today it certainly looks like jamal khashoggi is dead, as u.s. intelligence agencies believe it is inconceivable that the crown prince had no connection to his death. and the powerful words of steve schmidt who squarely took on the president earlier today and again sounded the alarm about what we're seeing as "the 11th hour" gets underway on a thursday night. well, good evening once again from our nbc news headquarters here in new york.


info Stream Only

Uploaded by TV Archive on