tv Andrea Mitchell Reports MSNBC January 18, 2011 1:00pm-2:00pm EST
they're back. with a promise to play nice. house republicans are prepare to go open debate today on repealing health care. the largely symbolic gesture, a big test of whether lawmakers can dial it down a notch. president obama rolls out his own counter punch in hostile territory. an op-ed about reviewing excessive regulations on business. this hour democratic party chairman tim kaine, top adviser to house speaker john boehner, david winston. and plus dick cheney as you haven't heard him before about his health, sarah palin, president obama. >> i think he'll be a one term president. >> and sarah palin redefining blood libel. i'm andrea mitchell live in washington. breaking news right now out of haiti. former dictator jean-claude
"baby doc" duvalier is in police custody. he made an unexpected return to the island sunday decades after it being exassigned. he's accused of stealing hundreds of millions of dollars from the country's treasury. kerry sanders is in part toort prince. were they arresti >> reporter: they're not saying specifically, but there was a tremendous a activity throughout the morning. first a few police officers showed up and hen they were being accompanied. they had riot gears on. as more arrived and as the just justice minister arrived an other officials began to make
their way in, it looked like it was perhaps turning in to -- i don't want to call it an arrest, but it appeared that they had to go through certain protocol because of his arrival in this country. as you know, the president of this country had said previously that were duvalier ever to return, he would be arrested. conflicted with that is what the prime minister has said which is that duvalier has the right to return to it this country as any owe hey shab. so after much of that confusion, duvalier came down the stairs, he waved to the cameras, he wasn't in handcuff, he wasn't with gun point or anything like that. but he came down and then this
slipped out the back, meanwhile out front, more and more supporters of baby doc arrived in the streets here and started to chant and sing and they were holding up pictures, all which is a surprise when you consider the atrocities that he's associated with in this country. and then he was taken away. the car it that he was taken away in had bulletproof glass. i noticed one of the windows looked like it had been shot. that may have been before, but he drove away and made his way down to the french embassy. we're in the quinot quite sure going to happen next. >> we're seeing amazing video that is coming in. and as you've been pointing out, there's a generation gap. the younger people don't remember the atrocity, they don't remember that this man and his wife are accused of stealing more than $500 million from the treasury. and so he's returning and as you
point out, there are people there who don't know the history of what the duvaliers did to this country. >> reporter: i think perhaps it's important to understand 51% of the population is under the age of 21. of course they have no memory, they only have the stories that their parents have told them. and with the life expectancy here quite frankly a lot of the people who are young adults now in their mid-30s or 40s don't really have their parents to turn to for their stories, so they just go with what they believe. and a lot of what people tell me it they believe is anybody, anybody who thinks that they can help this country is welcome. there is just so much difficulty here not only because of the political situation, not only because of the aftermath of the earthquake, but because the economy here even before the earthquake was not much of an economy. >> of course there is dispute
over president preval's re-election and a lot of political uncertainty, as well. kerry sander, be safe. thanks so much for your reporting. and on capitol hill at this moment, republicans have been waiting for this. one hour from now, they will be kicking off their effort to repeal health care reform p. kelly o'donnell is our capitol hill correspondent. all this breaking news from haiti, but a lot of news happening on capitol hill. what are you expecting today? >> reporter: what a study in contrast after the segment from haiti because here it is sort of be careful what you sooe say week, watch your tongue time, on capitol hill. members of both parties are saying they will tone down their rhetoric, but the issue is still an intense disagreement over repeal efforts to roll back the health care reform law. republicans promised they would do that when they ran the 2010 campaign season, they were able to take over power largely on that issue. so they will try to deliver by bringing this to debate and to a
vote on the house side. it getting tripped up if it goes over to the senate because the makeup is different there, democrats still in charge, but one thing we're seeing is a lot of intense outside input, the same kinds of groups that were vocal during the original health care reform issue are making their voices known again and we'll be watching closely to see how the language on capitol hill changed in light of all these new calls for civility. >> we'll test that right now with our next couple of guests. thank you very much, kelly. with me now, tim kaine from the hill. thank you very much. let's talk about why are democrats thinking that they can make a second impression or remake a first impression as chuck schumer has said on health care? what's the point of the whole debate? why not go in, get rid of it. you know that in the senate and with the white house veto threat it's never going to go anyplace anyway. >> i think it's important to
have this debate. they're going into their home, doctors offices and businesses and taking something away from them. millions of businesses are getting a tax credit. the repeal effort would take that away and raise business taxes. millions of seniors are getting help with prescription drugs a and preventive care. republicans would take that away. and tens of millions of youngsters are able to stay on family policies until they're age 26. the republicans would take that away. probably most staggering is the recent estimate that nearly half of adults under age 65 have a condition that could be a pre-existing condition used against them by an insurance company. 129 million americans have protection under this bill from pre-existing conditions. the republicans want to take that away. and we just want to make plain what the consequences are and that's what dnls a democrats wi. >> and you've got another
factor, sarah palin speaking out on fox with sean hannity and this was her explanation, defense, whatever you want to call it, about her use of the term blood libel last week. >> i don't know how the heck they would know whether i did or didn't know the term blood libel. nobody's ever asked me. it obviously means being falsely accused of having blood on your hands and in this case that's exactly what was going on. >> of course that's the way she terms it, her definite mission. there are a lot of groups that we heard saying that they take the ring meoriginal meaning and offense at it. what do you think of sarah palin's role right now? >> i think the explanation was into the persuasive. >> she pointed out the democrats have used the map in previous
cycles, as well. >> but i'm talking about her. she said -- her team tried to say it was surveyor symbols and they got called down on that. i don't think she was persuasive last night. i guess i think that she's saying her own thing, but it's a parallel universe to actually the work that's being done here. there's important work on important policy issues, entertainment industry individuals will do their thing, but the real work here to find solutions kind of happens regardless of the rhetoric that some are trying to get attention for. >> you're referring to sarah palin as an entertainment industry official, you don't think she's a political figure and a potential presidential candidate for the other side? >> i think people are in this for a lot of reasons. it's a venerable american
tradition. but that's not the same as the people who are actually governing and doing the job. and the people here in washington working on issues like health care and tackling one tough issue after the next, they're not leaving their post, ter they're doing their job. >> ouch. obviously a reference to the fact that she quit as governor after two years. let me also ask you about your former job as governor and whether you would consider running in virginia because there's talk now that jim webb is not going to be running for senate. what is the latest that you know? >> jim is somebody who makes a decision and when he's made it, he's announced. but i have no reason, none, in my dealings with the senator to believe anything else than that he is going to run again in 2012. >> has he raised the kind of money that would indicate to you that he's gearing up for a campaign? >> i believe just for a variety of reasons. again, he's not man a
announcement that he's going to run. i worked really hard for jim webb when i was governor in virginia. his win was a real watershed moment. i'll work every bit as hard for him in 2012 as i did in 2006. >> and if jim webb does not run, would you consider that senate race? >> no, i've got a job i really like right now. tough though it may be. and i'm doing what the president wants me to do. i think having been governor of extra have a, it's hard to top that. and so, no, my full expectation is that i'm going to be supporting a great virginia democrat and i believe that virginia democrat will be jim webb for the senate seat. >> okay, we'll have to leave it there. thank you very much, tim kaine. john boehner of course is now leading the charge to repeal the health care law. with me now is one of his closest advisers, david winston. thanks so much, good to see you. let's talk about the strategy. what are you hoping to accomplish strategy of repeal since it is largely symbolic in the end because the president
has the last word. >> i disagree, i don't think it is largely symbolic. what the republicans are trying to do here and given the fall campaign in terms of the debate over health care is say we want to start over, we want to figure out where we should go. this is the first step to reengaging the debate in terms of trying to move health care in a direction the republicans feel is a better direction in terms of the last election. so what you'll see is the vote tomorrow in terms of repeal, but then the next day hr-9 which is instructions to all the committees to begin to think about what should be replacing this existing health care bill. >> in fact there has been some criticism that the approach to repeal precedes replace. and you're talking about repeal, but you're not as republicans talking about exactly what you want in place. >> the next day we'll pursue that. and there are a variety of ideas out there. there's the ability of being able to purchase health care across state lines, there is liability reform, there is pugt
the cost of the doc fix to bill at a level that doesn't cost them money. one of the big problems that exist with the health care bill is you're putting 32 million people into a system and you're not adding one doctor or nurse. this is not going to improve the quaulgt of health care. we need a more comprehensive approach in terms of how do we it actually improve the quality of health care as opposed to that this is just a process by which you turn health care over to more government control and we don't feel that's the appropriate approach. >> david, when we're talking about more civility and crossing bipartisan lines, here we've got the visit of president hu of china, arguably the most important foreign policy relationship that we have with any other country outside of the ongoing wars. president hu is coming, there's a state dinner tomorrow night, the appearance, the protocol,
the red carpet. the speaker of the house has regretted he is not going to atten attend the president's invitation. this is what robert gibbs just said. >> i don't know what their response was in declining the invitation. we have invited, and this goes to previous state dinners, invited leaders from both party its and we hope that because of the importance of the relationship that they would attend. i don't know why he declined on this occasion. >> john boehner is in line for the presidency. i know he's said that he's going to be meeting with president hu on the hill will, but given the importance of this this, is not just some backward country. this is china. why wouldn't john boehner want to be at the state dinner some. >> i think he would. again, understand as you
defined, he's now the number three in term of succession. there are lots of responsibilities and there's lots of things he has to do. i'm sure he'd like to be there, but not knowing the notice that was given to him in terms of how much time he he had to be able to rearrange, since he was already meeting with the prime minister, my sense is at least he felt that in this particular case he had other responsibilities that he had to manage. again, he's someone who has a very complicated public schedule, as well. >> is there anything more important than spending time with the leader of china with the president of the united states, with the cabinet, with business leaders? >> i'm not arguing that it's not an important point, but there are also really important things in terms of getting the congress running, dealing with unemployment, economic growth, trying to deal with the fact that we have a huge national deficit, trying to get the congress ready to deal with
health care particularly in light of what happened last week, how do you creates an atmosphere where could you have a good political debate. that's also very important and that's his role to help create that environment. >> and you don't think it's a personal slap at the president and the first lady? >> no. >> okay. we'll leave it there. thank you very much. david winston. and up next, dick cheney on president obama, sarah palin and his fluunusual heart bumping device. plus why china may be america's most important foreign policy challenge. it blocks pain signals for deep relief precisely where you need it most. precise. only from the makers of tylenol.
until the combination of three good probiotics in phillips' colon health defended against the bad gas, diarrhea and constipation. ...and? it helped balance her colon. oh, now that's the best part. i love your work. [ female announcer ] phillips' colon health. tdd# 1-800-345-2550 are still talking about retirement tdd# 1-800-345-2550 like it's some kind of dream. tdd# 1-800-345-2550 it's either this magic number i'm supposed to reach, or... tdd# 1-800-345-2550 it's beach homes or it's starting a vineyard. tdd# 1-800-345-2550 come on! tdd# 1-800-345-2550 just help me figure it out in a practical, tdd# 1-800-345-2550 let's-make-this-happen kind of way. tdd# 1-800-345-2550 a vineyard? give me a break. tdd# 1-800-345-2550 [ male announcer ] looking for real-life answers tdd# 1-800-345-2550 to your retirement questions? tdd# 1-800-345-2550 get real. get started. talk to chuck. tdd# 1-800-345-2550
tdd# 1-800-345-2550 get real. get started. talk to chuck. everything is better with swanson broth in it. an essential ingredient in any kitchen. swanson 100% natural chicken broth. which beneful prepared meals. tonight? roasted chicken recipe? - savory rice and lamb stew. - [ barks ] you're right. tonight is a beef stew kind of night. [ announcer ] beneful prepared meals. another healthful, flavorful beneful.
his relationship with president obama, and his health. >> are you thinking about a heart transplant? >> i haven't made a decision yet. the technology has gotten better and better and we've got more experience of people living with this tech knowlednology. i'll have to make a decision at some point, but we haven't address that had yet. biggest threats we fails -- >> reporter: in the meantime cheney is now back in public and speaking out. >> you said that you thought that president obama was going to be a one term president. do you still? >> i do. >> because? >> well, because i think he embarked upon a course of action when he became president that did not have as much support as he thought it did. >> reporter: cha any side stepped getting in to the political fray especially over his opinion of sarah palin. >> interested in governor palin
like a lot of people are. i've met her. i thought she's got an interesting political career established. she's clearly a factor, has a strong following, she also has a lot of critics. >> do you think she's qualified to be president? >> i'm not going to say this one isn't or this one is. there will be ample time for that in the months ahead and i'll be happy to participate in that process when the time's right. >> i understand you want her reality show, though. >> i do. i think it's very good. i love alaska. >> reporter: but these days the former vice president is spending most of his time writing his memoirs with daughter, liz. >> word is it will be cap d can blunt, and some scores will be settled. >> i have a sense i'll get the
last word. >> where you write about the president? >> sure. we had some policy differences and i'll be forth right with my comments on those. >> in his memoir, he said about you ten years later, i've never regretted my decision to run with dick cheney. but he also writes that you offered and he considered dropping you from the ticket. and he says, quote, he's become a lightning rod for criticism, he was seen as dark and heartless, the darth vader of the administration. first of all, why did you offer to step aside? >> well, i actually went in about three different times because i didn't think he took me seriously the first time. and the reason i did it was i thought he needed to have the ability to do whatever was necessary to make sure he won. so i went to him and said, look, mr. president, i've taken a lot of incoming fire, it goes with the turf, but if you have any
desire to make a change here, i'll be perfectly happy to step aside so you can put somebody else in this job. and after i went in about the third time and reiterated that, then he went away, thought about it for a couple of weeks and came back and said, no, you're my guy. >> you're my guy. amazing stuff. jamie, that was extraordinary. >> thanks. >> first of all, sarah palin, that was hardly a huge endorsement. he's willing to talk about other things but about that, he's not going to become engaged. i got the sense that it this man who is so dedicated, whether you like him or not, to national security issues really doesn't think that she is up to the task on that agenda. >> in general he didn't want to talk about 2012, but he absolutely side stepped sarah palin. and i don't know what he really thinks, but in my experience, when alimentary to say, they dot
hesitate to say it. so the fact that he's not saying anything at all leads one to believe -- >> certain the commander in chief issue, since that is so central to everything that he cared about, that was his explanation for a lot of very controversial decisions that he in fact feels vindicated about on the subject of the war on terror. >> right. and when they were in office and mccain made the announcement, there have been reports already that they did not i think that she was a good choice, that she did not have the in-taellectual le heft for it. >> he made a lot of news by saying he went back three times with his offer to resign. >> that's all new p appare. apparently he really wanted to make sure the president considered this. we heard in the president's book that dick cheney made the offer once and he took a couple of weeks to think about it.
this is a little different slant on the story now that we know that he asked over and over and over again. and i think he said i'll get the last word on my book. president obama's book has come out, donald rumsfeld's book is coming out. but former vice president cheney's book is not expected out until the end of the summer, early september. he will have the last word. so on some of these different counts, you'll now get his take on it. >> fascinating stuff. everyone is commenting on how thin he look, but his color looks good, he seems to be functioning right well with this unusual heart pump. >> i think he actually looks very good if you look back at the presidential library ground breaking in texas, he was very, very thin. he lost 25, 30 pounds during surgery. so he's looking better and better, no question about it.
>> well, congratulations. >> thanks. and coming up next, another senate retirement putting democrats in a bind. we'll have the details. happybaby strives to make the best organic baby food. in a business like ours, personal connections are so important. we use our american express open gold card to further those connections. last year we took dozens of trips using membership rewards points to meet with the farmers that grow our sweet potatoes and merchants that sell our product. we've gone from being in 5 stores to 7,500. booming is using points to make connections that grow your business.
somewhere in america, there's a doctor who can peer into the future. there's a nurse who can access in an instant every patient's past. and because the whole hospital's working together, there's a family who can breathe easy, right now. somewhere in america, we've already answered some of the nation's toughest healthcare questions. and the over 60,000 people of siemens
are ready to do it again. siemens. answers. her morning begins with arthritis pain. that's a coffee and two pills. the afternoon tour begins with more pain and more pills. the evening guests arrive. back to sore knees. back to more pills. the day is done but hang on... her doctor recommended aleve. just 2 pills can keep arthritis pain away all day with fewer pills than tylenol. this is lara who chose 2 aleve and fewer pills for a day free of pain. and get the all day pain relief of aleve in liquid gels.
in a move that could signal looming trouble for democrats, kent conrad has announced he will not run for re-election. it could be a prime opportunity for republicans to pick up a seat. we should note that as i say msnbc contributor was the first to break it. david kennedy's national politics reporter is joining us now. what's the impact of kent conrad? he's not just a number. he's also a chief deficit hawk from the budget committee. so this is a pretty big impact on how the senate will operate. >> right, that's what he said in his comments. he went on a radio show in north dakota and said he wanted to
focus on policy for the next two years and on reducing the deficit and he said traveling around the country, having to raise money, constantly fending off attacks would distract him from doing that. but of course there's always political implications and political considerations here. and he did say that having lost cent senator byron dorgan to retirement and senator bopomero not having those two there also weighed on his decision. >> and looking ahead, it looks certainly that the republicans who had already announced a challenge to kent conrad have an expanding field. bh whom are you looking at from the democratic side? >> the republicans have a very deep bench in north dakota. i was told the problem will be trying to fund raise for a governor's race, a congressional race and a senate race in that seat and find competitive candidates. of course you have to look to
former attorney general heidi hidecamp, but she appears to want to run for governor. and then congressman earl pomeroy said he just moved to washington to become a health care lobbyist. >> okay, thank you very much for all of that. meanwhile, china's president hu arrives in washington this afternoon. there will be a private dinner with the president and all the fanfare of a state dinner the next night. at the same time the white house is trying to take a more assertive strategy with top cabinet members challenging china's stance on currency on trade, military and human rights affairs. william cohen, chairman of the cohen group, knows china well from a military standpoint, strategic standpoint. what is the most important challenge that we face right now from china? >> the most important thing that we need to do is set up a regime whereby we can have a measure of
trust and openness. right now the relationship is characterized by mistrust. will there's a sense of apprehension about what the chinese military is doing. it's quite opaque and more transparency needs to be achieved. so this entire relationship is undergoing a reevaluation. just last june, bob gates, secretary gates, his trip it china was canceled. the chinese canceled it because they didn't like the arm sales going taiwan. the fallout was seen both this china and united states as widening the gulf between our two countries. so this is an effort to put things back where we can talk to each other and then articulate what our respect of it interests are and see about if we can have some way of working together. >> gates then did go to china the week before last and it was not a very successful trip and
in fact there were very interesting signals because president hu didn't seem to know that his own military had tested stealth bomber. how is that possible that he'd not know they had this new technology? >> it's interesting about four years ago, wroi a novel in which i had an incident take place in the northwestern part of china dealing with the nuclear explosion min which the chinese president didn't have any knowledge of what was going on and i wrote it because of the growing perception that the chinese military was getting more power. >> does president hu have the power or does the military, do they have the real power? >> power has been dispersed somewhat. president h will u doesn't have the same power. he's sitting at a time when
there's growing economic power and much less political power that's concentrated in his office. so i think that's one of the reasons how he could have been surprised that his military was conducting a test that was basically designed to embarrass secretary gates. the timing of was. >> and do we have to worry that china holds so much of our debt? >> i think we have to worry about the size of our debt, indeed that china holds so much of it and that's why sewyou're seeing an effort to got our house in it order to maintain a strategic balance throughout the world and our currency and the viability of that currency is important for them. >> thank you very much, william cohen from the cohen group. and coming up next, the white house shuffle who is this in, who is out. we'll have more. plus the latest on gabrielle giffords. it's the only listerine® that gets teeth two shades whiter and makes tooth enamel two times stronger. get dual-action listerine® whitening rinse. building whiter, stronger teeth.
you'll have to pay five hundred bucks for your deductible. the truth? at allstate, you could pay zero. only allstate gives you a hundred dollars off your deductible the day you sign up. then another hundred off every year you don't have an accident. let the good hands reward your safe driving with a deductible that goes away. dollar for dollar, nobody protects you like allstate. ♪ topping the headlines, there is a growing likelihood of
significant spring flooding along the red river. officials say there is a 20% chance the river will hit a record high crest. doctors say that congress woman gabrielle giffords may be days or weeks away from leaving the hospital and she continues to recover from the gunshot wound to the head. medical staff are still watching to see whether giffords' speech will return. more chaos on the streets of tunisia. trouble is already brewing within the new coalition government there. the president and prime minister resigned from the ruling party today while maintain their positions in the coalition. the government was forred only yesterday after the dictator fled amid protests over high unemployment, government corruption and oppression. apple's fourth quarter earnings reports comes out this afternoon a day ofafter steve js
announced he's taking another medical leave. bill clinton is in chicago today helping rally support for his former aide, rahm emanuel, in the bid for chicago mayor. his departure has created just one of many new staff openings. the president has a new white house team signaling a new approach to congress. michael shearer is with us. let's talk about your cover stoefr astory and the whole change of the white house staff, what that really means. bill daley and the people he will bring in with him and the openings that still exist. the new press secretary appointment that we're all waiting for, all signaling a change in strategy. >> it's definitely a change. it's a change -- they wroughtbr outside who is as close to the inside as possible. bill daley not part of the true believer campaign, but he's
mentored both ram quu manual and david axelrod, so he's not unknown either. >> he's from chicago, but at the same time, has a former commerce secretary connections to business, connections to banking community which of course led to some criticism on the left. but he's known as a political figure. he knows how on for reelect people. >> the white house said there were three i think things that daley was bringing. first he would deal with the issue of the reputation for being too in-bred and insular. the same four or five people always in the room, same people that were there with the campaign, so he's a new face. second, he does have an ability on talk directly with the business community. the white house has made that a real priority of the second two years to reach out to the business community, you see the op-ed in the "wall street journal" today doing that. and the third thing is he's someone who can go on tv and be a surrogate for the president. one thing that the white house
was constantly frustrated with is they didn't have enough surrogates to go on, do the tv sunday shows that weren't the president, so the president was out there too much. and that led to a lot of criticism that he wasn't- >> i've never understood why they don't use the very excellent cabinet team. - >> i've never understood why they don't use the very excellent cabinet team.- >> i've never understood why they don't use the very excellent cabinet team. the other thing is bruce reed who comes from the whole centrist and deficit cutting background as the executive director of the deficit commission. that signals also a turn in direction. >> you look at the first two years, it was working with democrats in congress. the second two years will be negotiating with republicans. and bruce reed is someone who has done that, they call it triangulati triangulation. he's done the work before, he has a reputation among republicans and be able to be that person. >> and why the hold up on the replacement for robert gibbs? >> the way they explained it to
me is that gibbs told the president shortly before christmas, that they wanted to bring daley into place first. plouffe is leading the process. i was surprised, too they didn't have that lined up. it wasn't hard to see that gibbs radio would be rotating out, but they expect to have a new name by the end of the month. >> to be continued. we'll have have to see whether it will be male, female -- >> an insider, someone from the past. could be a lot of things. >> thank you very much. and up next, meet the man who sparked the campaign to break down the partisan divide at the state of the union. and why stop there. you're watching andrea mitchell reports. crunchy flakes and clusters, with a kiss of golden honey. delicious. and the same calories per serving as special k original. so, try honey roasted, honey bunches of oats! heck try 'em all.
steve: yeah, um, i just got a free rate quote on geico.com, saved a ton, and it only took me 5 minutes and 12 seconds! steve: i was wondering, is that some sort of record? gecko: that's a good question. let's have a look. curtis: mmmm, not quite. someone's got you beat by 8 seconds. gecko: still, i mean, that's... that's quite fast! steve: well, what if i told you i only used one hand? anncr: geico. 15 minutes could save you 15% or more on car insurance. sleep is here, on the wings of lunesta. and if you wake up often in the middle of the night... rest is here, on the wings of lunesta. lunesta helps you fall asleep and stay asleep, so you can wake up feeling rested. when taking lunesta, don't drive or operate machinery until you feel fully awake. walking, eating, driving, or engaging in other activities while asleep, without remembering it the next day, have been reported. abnormal behaviors may include aggressiveness, agitation, hallucinations or confusion.
in depressed patients, worsening of depression, including risk of suicide, may occur. alcohol may increase these risks. allergic reactions, such as tongue or throat swelling, occur rarely and may be fatal. side effects may include unpleasant taste, headache, dizziness and morning drowsiness. ask your doctor if lunesta is right for you. get lunesta for a $0 co-pay at lunesta.com. sleep well, on the wings of lunesta. hey tough guy, that cold needs alka seltzer plus! it has the cold-fighting power of an effervescent packed in a liquid-gel for all over relief! hiyah! dude! the president's call for more civility will be tested when the vote gets taken this
afternoon on the health care bill. you've changed the seating at the state of the union? >> you have to have something to tell your mom you're actually doing with your career. >> what are we going to do if we don't have this wave? it looks like a football stadium half the time. >> it's very clear that politics are part substance and part symbols and the substance is ultimately what matter, but the symbols matter, too. and every year americans watch this spectacle of both parties coming together, sitting like kids, boys on one side, girls on the other, as if that's actually representative of how the business should be done. we said very simply aend the pat say seating. show the country a simple idea that you're of different parties and you have substantial disagreements, but ultimately you're united serving the country. >> what do you say to those who say this is just symbolic,
there's still shrugging it out at committee hearing, you still have president releases coming out and hammering the president and vice versa from the democrats to the republicans. so nothing's really changing. >> we say this. this is not a panacea. in fact, no symbolism is a panacea. but forcing people to actually sit together instead of by their parties sends a very strong message to the country that they actually are willing to transcend their partisan differences. and by the way it's a silly tradition. and you can see that because first senator mark udall said he would do it. and then the wave started. and senator schumer and senator coburn and senator mccain and folks in the house and senate, steny hoyer and so on, they're doing it not because it's going to fix everything, but it's a silly tradition, it's time for it end even for one night.
aftof . >> after the state of the union, what is the long term goal? are you trying to create a third party, are you trying to talk mike bloomberg into running? >> third wave is about five years old and we're a moderate group traditionally associated with the centrist democratic wing. bill daley was our board member right before he left. our view is we seek to advance moderate policy and political agen agenda. this idea about changing the partisan seating is just one of the small ideas we have. but our objective here is very simple. can we actually show on the one night, the super bowl of american politics, when everyone american who is interested and tunes in, can we show that our politicians care more about service to the country than they did about sitting with members
of hair partheir party. >> it's a first step. thank you very much. we'll see you maybe after the fact and review the tapes. and what political story will be making headlines here in the next 24 hours some th. >> that's next. and be sure to follow the show online. [ coughs ] [ breathes deeply, wind blows ] something wrong with your squeegee, kid? uh, i'm a little sick. sick?! you gonna let a sore throat beat you? you're fearless! ahhhhhhhhh! atta boy! [ male announcer ] halls. a pep talk in every drop. to finish what you started today. for the aches and sleeplessness in between, there's motrin pm. no other medicine, not even advil pm, is more effective for pain and sleeplessness.
so which political story will be making headlines in the next 24 hours? msnbc contribute somewhere managing editor of postpolitics.com chris cillizza joining us. congratulations on breaking the kent conrad story. another announcement. joe lieberman will announce tomorrow what his plans are for re-election. do you think he's going to be leaving the senate? >> first of all, thank you. second of all, joe lieberman, gosh, i don't know the answer. this has become a national story because in 2006 lieberman was a
cause celeb for liberals, they beat him in the primary. he came back, ran as independent and won re-election. i don't think he can win re-election as a democrat. now, i think, and he said this on your show, i think this best option is to run as independent. the people i talked to say he's genuinely undecided. we expect an announcement tomorrow on whether he runs or not. i don't know. i haven't done enough reporting around it. but as a connecticut nate inand political junkie, fascinated t hear what he has to say. >> the point is that, we don't know whether he's announcing that he's leave organize that he's going to run as independent, republican, democrat. whom is he going to caucus with. >> you know, you make a good point. you make a really good point. when an incumbent senator says they're going to make an announcement about their political future, it's either
they're running or not running. it's a more varied decision, he could run as independent, republican, democrat, or choose not to run. you know, you've got four options as opposed to two. >> according to the wires, dick lugar, another veteran, is going to run in 2012. announcements are coming fast and furious. lieberman, the news conference scheduled within five minutes ago. we have not done the reporting. i expect we will be online, learning whether you've broken it or i or somebody else. >> we'll be trying. >> china tomorrow. president hu arriving in a couple of hours at andrews air force base. the vice president of the united states greeting him. this is not a small deal. a greeting from the vice president a private dinner in the old family dining room tonight. state visit and dinner tomorrow, news conference with the president, which we will be carrying live. also meetings jointly with the president and the business community.
this is the most important relationship that we have. >> absolutely. you know what? you hit on it. official state visit. when president hu came in 2006, bush had lunch with him. the vice president did not greet him at his plane, he did not have a news conference, there was no state dinner. this is a formal, big welcoming of president hu. two interesting, competing factors china's influence on the global economy, important to the united states and their record on human rights, a problem, how much does president obama address it? does he talk openly about it? we guess he would talk prooftly about it. two competing factors, economy and human rights record, impossible for the united states and president obama to ignore. >> and the importance they play toward north korea and iran. a lot of issues on the agenda tomorrow. thank you, chris. that does it for us for this edition of "andrea mitchell reports." tomorrow on the show, we'll have special, live coverage of president obama's join news
conference with china's president hu. richard lui in for tamron hall. what's next on "news nation"? >> have a very good afternoon. house republicans begin their attempt to repeal president obama's health care reform law. we're watching that as debate begins on the house floor. any minute right now, a live report from capitol hill. we continue to follow the breaking news out of haiti. a wild scene there as police lead former dictator jean-claude duvalier out of his hotel. will they charge the man known as baby doc with crimes committed under his regime? "news nation" is moments away. ih defended against the bad gas, diarrhea and constipation. ...and? it helped balance her colon. oh, now that's the best part. i love your work. [ female announcer ] phillips' colon health. ♪ >> woman: good night, gluttony-- a farewell long awaited.
good night, expected. >> ( yawning ) >> good night, outdated. >> ( click ) >> ( whimpers ) >> good night, fluffy. and good night, stuffy. >> ( clinking ) >> ( chewing ) >> good night, old luxury and all of your wares. good night, bygones everywhere. >> ( engine revs ) >> good morning, illumination. good morning, innovation. good morning, unequaled inspiration. >> ( heartbeats ) hot waffles... the smell of warm maple syrup. honeysuckle and rosemary. the smell of shaving cream.
whatever scents fill your household, purina tidy cats scoop helps neutralize odors in multiple cat homes... giving you just what you need to keep your house smelling like it should. purina tidy cats scoop. keep your home smelling like home. but when i was diagnosed with prostate cancer... i needed a coach. our doctor was great, but with so many tough decisions i felt lost. unitedhealthcare offered us a specially trained rn who helped us weigh and understand all our options. for me cancer was as scary as a fastball is to some of these kids. but my coach had hit that pitch before. turning data into useful answers. we're 78,000 people looking out for 70 million americans.
that's health in numbers. unitedhealthcare. developing now on "news nation," live pictures of the capitol building you see here where the house of representatives is expected to begin debate on the gop symbolic effort to repeal president obama's health care law. that debate and tomorrow's scheduled vote was post poped last week, as you remember, after the