minister of ireland charles flanigan. representatives from 193 member states meant to develop accorded approach to the refugee crisis. the number of displaced people surpassed world war ii levels with 65 million people fleeing violence or political persecution. ireland was ordered to collect $14.5 billion in unpaid taxes from apple. the irish government is appealing the ruling. i am pleased to have charles flanigan on the program. charles: very pleased to be here. jake: for people that might not be completely familiar with this and the details of ireland and apple, you don't want to give apple the 14.5 billion dollars. you want them to not have to pay that. explain that to our viewers. charles: this was announced by the commission on the relationship between apple and ireland. it funds foreign and direct investment. it gives jobs and in excess of 100,000 of our people. the european commission decided to embark on an investigation with the relationship between ireland and apple. we don't agree with the analysis and i fundamentally disagree with their findings. we don't accept t

an investigation of the british-- between ireland and apple am we don't agree with their analysis. i fundamentally disagree with their findings. i don't believe there is any-- we don't accept that finding of the eu exition. >> we conclude with evan osnos of "the new yorker" magazine. >> you could quite about the pros peck of a trump presidency as sigh fie or as fares, or from the other side as fan fiction. we said no, no, this is something ver different. this began with an observation which is that one of the few ingvar things that union fies the supporters is that neerlt side really believes will do a lot of the things that he says. >> tony blinken, charles flanagan and evan os dnos when we continue. >> fund sk provided by the >> rose: funding for "charlie rose" has been provided by the following: >> and by bloomberg, a provider >> and by bloomberg, a provider of multimedia news and information services worldwide. captioning sponsored by rose communications from our studios in new york city, this is charlie rose. >> good evening, i'm jake tapper filling in for charlie rose who is on

taxed advantageously. in this case, ireland. its corporate tax rate is the lowest in western europe and it has attracted more than 700 u.s. companies to set up shop there, including google and facebook. apple employs 6000 people in ireland. in this week's ruling, the eu commissioner said that ireland allowed apple to pay an effective tax rate of 1% on its profits in 2003, down to .005% in 2014, and that, she said, gave apple an unfair vantage. here she is in an interview with bloomberg tuesday. >> the tax rate in ireland is 12.5% and, obviously, most companies, national or multinational, they pay the corporate tax rate in ireland. and they have to look at some apple, onlyn case pay a tiny, tiny fraction of the taxes than they themselves have to pay, and that is obviously not fair competition. it is not a level playing field. emily: we also spoke to the irish finance minister and we will bring you his comments in a moment. first, take a listen to our conversation with "bloomberg intelligence" litigation specialist matt larson and alex webb on apple's response. >> a lot of people were sur

that apple must pay ireland more than $14 billion in back taxes. the impact of the decision clearly extends far beyond the interest of a single company or a single country. mark: sinn fein has come out and said, don't appeal. accept the money. why don't you just accept the money and shut up? 13 billion euros plus interest. that's a lot of money. >> because as minister for finance, i have a responsibility for advising the government on these matters. this is the government that rescued irish -- ireland from the verge of bankruptcy from 2011 on, and foreign direct investment and the creation of high level jobs is fundamental to our economic policies. we stand by our economic policies and we're going to protect our economic policies. we're not going to get into a situation of short-term gain for long-term damage to the economy. >> what have we heard from other tech companies? >> this is as we have yesterday that heard yesterday, i think some analysts, people were saying it's on the scale of one to 10, 10 being extremely damaging, the lower end about 2 to 3. the thing is ireland has 140

apple to pay a record tax bill. how is ireland responding? how has apple responded? >> there is massive shock here today. reports were saying the arrears could be as low as 100 million euros, yesterday afternoon, the sentiment has changed. figures might be in the billions, but i do not think anybody was prepared for a figure of over 13 billion euros, so it was a huge shock here. it sparked an intense debate about what they should do next. it is not clear that apple is not very happy, pointed out that corporate environments have paid its taxes and everything right, and it is not fair that it should be treated this way. there has been an angry response from ireland and apple back to the commission. mark: there is disappointment from both parties as well as the u.s. treasury. why did you feel the need to act unilaterally when the oecd has made so much progress over the last three years? margrethe: the case here is specific because we have a long-standing prohibition of member states handing out benefits or advantages to specific companies. this is the case here, more than it is the

company moves profits to where they're taxed advantageously. in this case, ireland. its corporate tax rate is the lowest in western europe and it is attracting more than 700 u.s. companies to set up shop, including google and facebook. apple employs 6000 people in ireland. in this week's ruling, the eu commissioner said that ireland glad to pay an effective tax .5%,that was down to which gave apple and unfair vantage. here she is in an interview with bloomberg tuesday. >> the tax rate in ireland is for .5% in most companies -- 12.5%, and most companies, they pay corporate tax rate in ireland. they have to look at some companies, in this case, apple, only pay a tiny tiny fraction of , the tax that they pay. that is not fair competition. it is not a level playing field. we also spoke to the irish finance minister and we will bring you his comments in a moment. just listen to litigation specialist matt larson and alex webb on apple's response. apple's defense is they have been an island for a long time. this agreement has been in place since 1991. it was always legal. they never lost any

, ireland. its corporate tax rate is the lowest in western europe and it has attracted more than 700 u.s. companies to set up shop, including google and facebook. apple employs 6000 people in ireland. in this week's ruling, the eu competition commissioner said that ireland glad to pay an -- allowed apple to pay an effective tax rate of less than down 2.005% in 2014, which gave apple and unfair advantage. here she is in an interview with bloomberg tuesday. >> the tax rate in ireland is 12.5%. obviously, most companies, national --nash onlynal or multinational, pay a tiny, tiny fraction of that they themselves have to pay. that is obviously not fair competition. it is not a level playing field emily: we also spoke to the irish finance minister and we will bring you his comments in a moment. but first take a listen to our bloomberg litigation analyst matt larson and alex webb on apple's response. >> a lot of people were surprised about the scale. of the back payment they will have to come up with. apple's defense is they have been on ireland for a long time. this agreement has been in place

. talking of desktop into the man who helped bring google to ireland. this is bloomberg. ♪ scarlet: live from bloomberg world headquarters in new york, i'm scarlet who. -- scarlet fu. new poll indicates voters are concerned about hillary clinton's help. -- health. 22% say that her health is above average. now, 41% say it is below average or poor and 50% say clinton has given false information about her health. appeared to stumble leaving a 9/11 event here in new york city. trumppowell calls donald "a national disgrace" and a leaked e-mail. on e-mails were posted dcleaks.com. ell says the e-mails are authentic and the hackers have a lot more. russia warns that u.s. backed rebels in syria are avoiding the cease-fire. artillery shells were fired 23 times mostly from areas controlled by rebel forces. syrian troops have not returned fire. the national football league is beginning to efforts to combat concussions. that is according to "the washington post." the plan is said to include money for better protective gear as well as medical research into the effect of head injuries. the leak

been bombings, shootings, and strikes in northern ireland. guerrillas fired at an israeli school bus near the lebanese border. >> the 1970s saw the development of the terrorist repertoire. >> gangs of young people, products of the riotous 1960s, prefer terror, kidnapping, bombing, arson, machine guns, death and destruction. >> it was a global thing. in the '70s, those who wanted change faster than was going to come resorted to violence. >> japan has had its first plane hijacking. >> the chronicle of terrorism which took them as far as athens, greece. >> most americans thought of terrorism as a problem that happens a world or half a world away. throughout the 1970s, terrorism began to hit home. >> an elegant townhouse in new york's greenwich village was destroyed by a series of dynamite explosions. >> authorities first assumed an accidental detonation in a gas line had been responsible, except that the blast had been too powerful, destroying the $100,000 house and badly damaging the two neighboring homes, one belonging to actor dustin hoffman. and as firemen picked their way through t

employs 6000 people in ireland. pay ad allowed apple to tax on it european profit then 2013 --2003. that gave apple and unfair to manage. here she is in an interview with bloomberg tuesday. >> the tax rate in ireland is for .5% in most companies -- 12.5%, and most companies, they pay corporate tax rate in ireland. they have to look at some ies penne tiny fraction of the tax that they pay. that is not fair competition. it is not a level playing field. >> we also spoke to the irish finance minister and we will bring you his comments in a moment. take a listen to matt larson and alex webb on apple." 's response. apple defense -- apple's defense, this agreement has been put into place since 1991 and it was all legal. the agreement was above board. >> we got a letter from tim cook. they included the original picture of steve jobs at the ireland factory. >> he opened a 60% plant in court. -- cork. one of --what are the next steps for apple and a legal battle? >> apple and ireland will appeal this decision to the european general court in luxembourg. it is the same court hearing the ,ppea

ireland and there's a lot of competition across the globe. from an ireland perspective, i suppose we will be relying on our offering of the track records. ireland is a home to a large amount of foreign direct investment particularly in financial services sector. the talent availability, the fact that we're english speaking i think is a significant advantage and the cultural and physical proximity to the u.k. ireland is probably the closest thing to the u.k. outside of the u.k. so i think all of those things will play in ireland's favor. kate: dublin has been firmly in the international spotlight because of the european commission rulings about apple's tax arrangements in ireland ordered to pay 13 billion in back taxes. surely that ruling will discourage companies considering operating there? >> no, i don't believe so. we have no evidence of that. we've seen significant investment even in recent weeks post the commission decision. ireland fundamentally disagrees with the commission decision in relation to the apple ruling and we believe the decision is flawed. ireland has decided to a

challenges for ireland's economy. tracy: and one of the most anticipated debates in politics. donald trump and hillary clinton are deadlock in polls ahead of tonight's face-off. scarlet: the tao is falling more than 150 point-- dow is falling more than 150 points. a lot of references to how this could be a game changer. 10 out of 11 major groups in the s&p 500 are down and the big laggards are financials, led by deutsche bank, another record low today. if you look at oil prices, joe and tracy, wti gaining. joe: today felt electric. so much excitement ahead of the debate, the stuff with deutsche bank going on. one of the more exciting news days in a while. tracy: there is definitely a lot going on, isn't there? people are excited about how it will come together. scarlet: within the financial three of the sick supercommittee's decline this group is at its lowest since early august. the exception worth the real estate companies. these were formally part of the financial group and now they are on their own and because of the dividends, especially the 10-year,gaps with a 2.5 percentage points f

watching what's happening in ireland after the european union ruled that ireland granted apple undue tax benefits. the parliament of ireland appealing the decision. the outcome of the appeal is expected sometime tonight. .ulia chatterly reports from >> reporter: an important vote, but also, just a symbolic one from the irish parliament tonight. voting on whether or not to back the government in their decision to appeal the european commission's decision to hit apple with that $14.5 billion tax bill. what the government has been saying all along is this appeal will succeed. why? because we never gave apple any kind of sweetheart deal or preferential treatment which is fine. but there's a bigger question here. what does this mean for other big tech companies here in ireland, the likes of microsoft, facebook? could they get the same deal as apple and is there a huge risk now that these companies get hit with the similar kind of tax bill as apple at some point in the future? that's the question i put to the irish prime minister. listen to what he had to say. >> the other cases on appeal to t

account. >>> we all remember kathy ireland has an icon from the '80s. the supermodel turn mogul is now one of the biggest names in business. she's the ceo of kathy ireland worldwide, a global empire worth more than $8 billion. she sat down with nbc's jenna bush hager to share lessons she learned along the way that can help small business owners. >> i'm kathy ireland, ceo of kathy ireland worldwide. nothing is impossible. if you can dream it, you can do it. her big dreams helped launch a global empire worth over $2 billion. >> kathy ireland for window world. >> kathy ireland weddings. >> kathy ireland home collection. >> her "sports illustrated" cover in 1989 is still the best selling issue of all time. but she was a business woman long before she was ceo of her own company. at 8, she became the first paper girl in santa barbara, california. >> my first day on the job i had a gentleman who was standing at the end of his driveway. he began yelling at me, what are you doing here? this is a boy's job. >>> we have breaking news at the hour. we'll talk to president obama making comments

looking forward to seeing what happens there today. >> speaking of apple, ireland's prime minister spoke to cnbc about apple's $14.5 million tax bill from the eu. julia is live this morning with more on that story. hey, julia. no sweetheart deal so i said okay then there's other big tech companies obviously operating here. does that mean they all got treated the same? the likes of alphabet, microsoft, facebook? and should we be expecting the european commission to be slapping those guys with with some unpaid tax charges at some point in the future? listen to what he had to say. >> and particularly ireland has been one of the foremost players on the oecd program to deal with this internationally. >> this is a legacy issue now. you have done many measures and enacted many measures to tackle this. why are you concerned that accepting this money now from apple will have an impact on future investment? because it's an old issue. it's an old issue and we can move forward now with future investment. >> first of all, the amount of money involved is quite unprecedented but secondly the commission

technology from the financial times. earlier today i spoke with jay ireland. africa is obviously a melting pot of innovation for ge. it is boosting revenue there and the headcount. it is facing difficult challenges that have a listen to what the ceo of what ge africa, jay ireland, had to say. >> we are working with a lot of development banks and commercial banks, exports and imports. and we are working from that perspective. projects areur focused around changing the dynamics of how things might get finance. we have a project in kenya where you're outfitting 98 hospitals with diagnostic imaging. and we worked through a couple of regional banks, standard bank and they have been great from the standpoint of putting together a structure with the government of kenya around public hospitals on a pay-as-you-go model. vonnie: you mentioned several different agencies and banks. make.s. bank can't decisions beyond $10 million, has that been a hindrance? jay ireland: it doesn't help. you from our perspective, we go elsewhere. france, the uk, italy, switzerland, china, india -- we also use that from

, will ireland be that big winner from brexit? we will think to the deputy governor of the irish central bank. hits one billion downloads. what next for this app? what does tech look like after brexit? this is bloomberg. ♪ guy: welcome back. let's check in on the markets and show you what is happening. we have something of a rally on our hands, as you can see. european equity markets are certainly trading higher and doing very nicely. let's talk about some of the moves. that's where it gets interesting. i want to take you to my mrr, the function showing me this column, up by 11%, dominated by oil, particularly the suppliers. most.e up more than though interestingly enough, the high over the last five years was 16 pounds. we're not training anything near that. just to give you context in terms of how far these stocks have fallen. but the energy sector is up 4.5% today. now let's turn to the central bank story that continues to dominate. everybody is waiting to see what will happen in december. we saw something of for the fed, quite a large amount of dissent. the bank of england

responsibility for tax says matters. they're asking ireland over a long period to be the tax collector for every member state in the european and the united states government. never happened anywhere in the world and irish people and irish politicians are rightly exercised about that process. the government has always had a hand in the approach when it came to apple. companies here will continue to invest. >> that was in fact a sequence. julia getting on the ground there. dublin reacting to the upcoming debate in parliament over the apple. >> it's also quite interesting, but not quite what we want. very interesting debate taking place there. we will bring you more on that in detail. >>> meanwhile, saudi arabia foreign minister says his country could expect a freeze in oil output, but warned iran could stop any attempt to reach an agreement. >>> italian prime minster matteo renzi announced the constitutional reform will be held on a sunday between november 15 and december 5. he said earlier it would likely be held in october. the leader reconfirmed he would quit politics if his proposed ref

that, as well as ireland. so, i asked margaret vest jaiga about this argument. when you said at one point pay 0.0005%, a number that tim cook has called political crap. what is your view of that? >> well, i've never seen math categorized like that, because we are obliged, of course, to do our case work-based on the facts of the case, not only because it can be appealed and go to court, but also because we have to do a good job. we have to make sure that we get it right and do the right thing. >> but isn't the heart of the matter really, especially when it comes to apple and these technology companies, the intellectual property of their sales, of iphones and other products, happens all in the united states. it is produced in the united states. so, why should the irish government claim the income tax on it? >> well, this is for apple. because we don't question where they book their profits. what we see is that they book a huge portion of their profits in ireland, not in the states. with the apple inc. of the u.s., they have this cost-sharing agreement where they pay every year, some y

didn't work out in a very messy way. his second try was ireland. do you remember when he was going to go to ireland? in june the trump campaign put out this statement saying they were going to be going to ireland. that was an interesting choice because there had been lots of robust and untidy irish protests over the years against previous american visitors who were not nearly as controversial as donald trump. so it raised eyebrows that he was going to brave what would certainly be an unwarm welcome from the people of ireland. to underscore those stakes, the irish prime minister announced publicly if donald trump did really decide to go to ireland, the prime minister would hope to meet him in person on that visit, but only so he could tell donald trump to his face how racist and dangerous he thinks he is. so after initially announcing that donald trump would be going to ireland, donald trump decided not to go to ireland. they never announced that he wouldn't be going, they just removed that trip from his itinerary. he did, however, take that same trip, just minus ireland. he did go

famine. the population of ireland went from 9 million to 3 million. a lot came to the u.s., to canada, to australia, new zealand, england-- those would've been mainly where the irish went. remember, in those days, when people left home, they didn't see their parents again, that was it. keep in mind that the people coming here didn't speak english. they were from the poorest parts of ireland. and it was tough. irish catholics, especially, they weren't very welcome. they were considered a lower class. what they did have, in spite of that poverty, they did have their culture, they had this amazingly rich repository of instrumental music, of song, of storytelling, in the irish language, of dancing. having socialization with neighbors, hearing the music-- that made up for that loss. that's what they shared together. that's what they passed on to their children. house sessions are a major component of traditional irish music. it's where people would congregate in ireland and even in my own house when i was growing up, both of my parents were from ireland. we had an irish session almo

at ireland after severe turbulence over the ocean. 12 people were injured including women and children. here is nbc's tom costello. >> reporter: on the ground in ireland, united flight 880 met by ambulance crews and medics tending to injured in the terminal. it was early in the morning when the bowing 767 ran into trouble over the atlantic. without warning, violent turbulence. >> a very huge drop in altitude, one right after the other. >> reporter: with at least a dozen people injured the pilots diverted to shannon, ireland. >> we just want to confirm the aircraft is norm and you're not landing heavy? >> at this time, there are no control problems. >> there are a number of people waiting for you. >> reporter: while on the ground they tweeted emergency landing in ireland, a few people had broken bones. others described the scene on board. >> it was like one of those "star trek" episodes, you go through a field of rocks in the space and banging against everything, actually banging against things. >> most of them that weren't buckled in, they hit the roof, the ceiling. there was

because of an alleged sweetheart go with ireland. the eu failed to build a case that ireland gave apple illegal state aid. since the ruling, "ran roughshod over the iphone maker." been publicly critical of this hearing. he with me to discuss, bloomberg and ourxecutive editor reporter who covers apple. what do we know about this meeting? >> pretty much all they said in the press release. they did not make the case effectively, this was illegal state aid provided to apple by the irish government. i don't think it's any surprise they come to that can vision because any tax apple has the pain europe, england is not have to pay. it's not that it doesn't want apple to pay tax, it just wanted to pay tax year. an interesting exchange on twitter between the commissioner herself and an asset manager who tweeted after -- at her. she responds, " i will." international politics being litigated on twitter. what she is saying there is that this is an apple issue, it is not even really a u.s. technology issue. all american companies have gotten very clever in the last couple of decades at minimizing th

launch of course the main focus, but ireland parliament will debate the decision to appeal the apple tax ruling today. julia chattily joins us live from dublin with the details to expect on that, julia. >> reporter: that debate has actually just started just in the last few moments so it's largely symbolic because the government has already decided to appeal this ruling. what we heard from the irish government last night too was if the appeal fails, they will except that $14.5 billion from apple to basically leave the government caught between a rock and a hard place. you've got the opposition parties here in ireland saying this is an example of the government cozying up to the big business at the expense of the irish taxpayer. you've got the government on the other hand saying we have an investment story to protect and big businesses like apple provide one in six jobs here in ireland. the critical question is what do voters think. i've been surprised just in the last 24 hours. by and large the people i've spoken to saying we back the government. they say we don't necessarily like the id

with martin shanahan, chairman of ida ireland is next. ♪ we' drowning in information. ♪ where, in all ofhis, is the sff that maers?e stakes , yo finances, how do you solve ts? you don't. you partner with a firm that advisegovernments and the rtune 500,an c deliven to person, on whamatters to you. rgan stanley. like our passive aggressive we could fenvironment. isss, we're not passive gressive. y, hey, hey, we're not passive gressive. there are no bad suggestions here. no matwell sd, ann.ey ar ve always mired w yo justay wt's in your head, without thinking. ve always mired w yo justay good point ted.ad, you' living proof that los aren't everything. thk you. welce. tso, fedex helpimplify our e-commer busin and th it paeaggressive environ. anted to say, you ys are doing what's that to an? x. helping small business simplify e-commerce. >>> the action that the european commission took is out of the framework of the policy. it is a retroactive tax that reaches into another country and another jurisdiction tax base, in order to make sure that a firm pays its taxes. we agree with them, the fi

drive rates lower. brexit opportunities, how will ireland whether the shock? we have an exclusive interview. i am frenzy in london. they sent me over so that we are not together so that we can give you more global perspective. we are talking brexit and pound. tom: lots to talk about into the weekend. i would suggest you need some sleep. the idea of deutsche bank. it is percolating. it is there. it will be a theme throughout five hours of surveillance today. francine: it feels like they are a theme every other day. let's get to first word news. >> u.s. secretary of state john kerry has abandoned efforts to salvage the cease-fire in syria. he said it was pointless to move ahead without a major gesture from russia. the u.s. accuses russia of failing to use their influence to stop the fighting. assad blames the u.s. for their troops collapse. is blaming thean u.s. for refusing to extradite a person he accuses of starting a failed coup. request must work its way through the judicial system. us tryn to us and let him. they said the court will decide. i'm sorry, but we cannot wait for th

, ireland, and turkey. the post-fed rally losing momentum. stocks hold the advance as shares slumped on -- earlier and oil falls ahead of the meeting. turkey and the u.s. are nato allies but it's too late -- geopolitical positions are becoming more conflicted. will hear from president under the president. and this is not the first time the social media giant faced chatter. this time of i really is on the table. markets close in two hours. julie hyman joins us with the latest. julie: as you can see the stock has taken a very sharp leg lower. down by 2.5% because research l releasingled gf data that iphone sales have and week. that is what traders are determining the drop to as we see it accelerate. the other thing waiting on stocks is crude oil after bloomberg news reported that a person familiar with a -- saudi arabia's plan, a delegate said saudi arabia is not willing to discuss any kind of output change or production change to stabilize the market at the opec meeting next week. you can see oil when those headlines came out it took a leg lower down by 4%. ig counthe weekly r numbers. t

loss i've had to endure. >> thousands came to pay the respects to ireland, a 13-year-old military war dog who deployments. >> we deployed to camp fallujah in iraq. >> ireland was medically retired in the southernlands took them into their home. >> how many lives she saved and how many explosives she had detected, which saved hundreds of lives of our active military over there, she led the way to detect the explosives and save their life. >> there was no quit in that dog. she had more drive than five other dogs. i don't have a bad memory >> over the years, ireland's condition continued to worsen and last month, she passed away. >> that's the best gift we could give her was to be able to let her go. >> reporter: although she's no longer by southernland's side, some of the best memories were the past seven years with family and friends that ireland helped bring him home to. >> my safety was never a concern. >> amazing story. who served overseas would receive. >> well, pro hockey in las vegas. we're still waiting for a las vegas. we're still waiting for a anymore for our the chef-inspired

asked for his thoughts on the european commission's decision against ireland and apple. >> i should learn more about the merits frt case. that's true. i've been reading some of the reports in the newspaper. we have obviously -- first, the commission is not using powers it does not have. powers over the taxation of the corporations. and aggressively or -- to direct, to tell ireland what it should do. the other story is the part of t the deals obtained by people of apple and others not only in ireland but luxembourg but the -- [ inaudible ] so that's -- there are quite numerous aspects of that. >> so it's the european commission overreaching? >> this argument could be formulated. but as i said, i'd be happy to answer these questions when i learn more about the merits of case. because a head-on collision. figures quoted by the european commission differ from what others are saying. it's a very provocative issue. >> julia joins us now around the desk here. julia, the drama continues. we're expecting ireland to vote on the issue to repeal it on wednesday. so what happens next? because th

ireland. but the top executive claims there is more. reporter: tim cook believes anti-american sentiment is behind the apple probe. in a radio interview, he says he will fight the demand for a $13 billion back payment in court. >> it is maddening, disappointing. it is clear that this comes from a political place. when you are accused of doing something that is so foreign to your values, it brings out an outrage in you. apple has always been about doing the right thing. reporter: the european commission accuses apple of paying 50 euros of taxes for every million of the euros generated. a tax rate of .005%. if ireland allows apple to pay a lower tax, it could counter state aid which is illegal in the eu. apple says it paid more tax, the second-largest in ireland. >> the figures that we use in our decision are the figures that we get from apple themselves. and some of the figures back from 2011 come from the u.s. hearings. there are very little, if any figures in the public domain. and our investigation is not in the apple corporation. as such, it is apple international and apple

ireland's cabinet chose to, parliament will debate the issue. but the prime minister said it was the country's right to question the eu's thinking. >> it is important we should appeal the decision so we can get certainty, and beyond that, i make no apology for defending the right to appeal. this is about ireland, our people, versus us as a sovereign nation. what we consider appropriate policies to devise, to devise job opportunities and employment careers. this is not about the -- this is about the right of a small nation. >> the subsidiary they only about 50 euros. it has imposed a hefty back tax bill on the giant. same company took advantage of much too favorable conditions. apple is launching its appeal against the ruling. javier: closely watched american employment data came in off target on friday. the unemployment rate in the united states remains unchanged at 4.9%. u.s. stocks finished higher, and investors weighed the likelihood of a rate hike. most important factors will be considered in adjusting monetary policy. sticking closer look at the numbers with jens in new york. th

, calling the ruling against its tax arrangements in ireland maddening and entirely political. the tech giants -- giant is appealing the order for dub in to pay $13 billion -- back taxes. >> two days on, apple c.e.o. tim cook says he can't accept the european commission's ruling and says he's confident the ruling will be a -- overturned on appeal. >> it's maddening. it's disappointing. it's clear that this comes from a political place. it has no basis in fact or in law. >> an argument backed by u.s. treasurely -- treasury secretary jack lew, who said the ruling seemed to unfairly target american companies. >> pattern of the action seems to be highly focused on u.s. firls. the largest combination -- actions do appear to be aimed squarely at our tax base. >> the commission rejected the accusations, saying their findings were based on tangible data and followed official procedures. >> the figures we use are the figures we get from apple themselves the the enforcement port -- part of the portfolio does not fit into any political picture. >> the ruling's caused a stir in ireland, where the c

have inis ireland for breakfast my first is to do 50 of the close of them and they would all come in for lunch it was a liquid lunch to have to get ready for that. >> us >> it would be a good eye-opener to two ready for theod afternoon of work. >> lots of whiskey there. it really does with the citruss and cloves. beautiful mexican. >> they are beer and an irish pub in san francisco not too they brought about the distillerybr in trouble. >> they make it available scotch rose the difference between irish and scotch whiskey? >> and overer in order to be a symbol scott mount is all part stole the triple pot part distilled threee different processes. >> so it is a different kind of complicated. >> caps on in scotland they have >> i have no idea where to get the water.ea >> what is going on here? >> sure about the oldest are here in this here is taking a spinoff of craft breweries through the reverse is the cycle the reverse the brewery in county cork now they have the last of jamison and the porkbarrel work? >> i actually don't drink that was hurt. that's why you are successful it is defi

not that they wouldn't have to pay them. >> it's going to be like ireland. >> no it's not going to be like ireland. there's a higher tax base in ireland. >> leave it to the leprechaun. i'm irish, kaitlyn, charlie and julie. we've got the stocks that our guys say will work for you so you don't have to. come back in a minute. jackie: as an 18 year old, i let my mistakes kind of take over my life. i was point-five credits away from completing high school and i didn't do it. angela: i got pregnant and i was the main one working so, i did what i had to do to survive. jocelyn: sentía que la escuela no era para mí. karim: most of my family they never graduated high school or even let alone go to college so i'm trying to break that barrier. jackie: my family never stopped pushing for me to be better because they knew what i could become and who i could become as a person. karim: everyday after work i went straight to school, studied hard, and it paid off. jocelyn: sentía como que si quiero cambiar el mundo tengo que cambiara mi primero. group: surprise! surprise! surprise! angela: i could

paying them. it's not that they wouldn't have to pay them. >> it's going to be like ireland. >> no it's not going to be like ireland. there's a higher tax base in ireland. >> leave it to the leprechaun. i'm irish, kaitlyn, charlie and julie. we've got the stocks that our guys say will work for you so you don't have to. come back in a minute. ♪ with this level of engineering... it's a performance machine. with this degree of intelligence... it's a supercomputer. with this grade of protection... it's a fortress. and with this standard of luxury... it's an oasis. introducing the completely redesigned e-class. it's everything you need it to be...and more. mercedes-benz. the best or nothing. it's a very specific moment, the launch window. we have to be very precise. if we're not ready when the planets are perfectly aligned, that's it. we need really tight temperature controls. engineering, aerodynamics- a split second too scrappin. propulsion, structural analysis- maple bourbon caramel. that's what we're working on right now. from design through production, siemens technology helps manufac

has divided opinion in ireland. the irish cabinet today try to explain why it is appealing a european commission decision to award its 13 billion in back taxes from apple. they say apple's low tax bill in the country constituted illegal state i aid. the government disagrees and is refuse to go collect. >> 30 billion euros would be difficult to turn down from moat countries. that is it exactly what the irish cabinet is doing. they are not following an order that apple pay back taxes in. >> nothing is being done wrong here. we have a matchless commitment to meeting the best international standards. >> the government rejects the implication that ireland is a tax haven, maintaining that they have the right to set a competitive corporate tax rate. it has one of the lowest rates in europe at 12.5%. mpared to 33% in spain and 20% in u.k. attracting that investment has become a cornerstone of the state economic policy. but not everyone agrees with the decision to appeal. opinion polls in ireland have shown majorities in favor of apple paying back taxing. they say big business should

not that they wouldn't have to pay them. >> it's going to be like ireland. >> no it's not going to be like ireland. there's a higher tax base in ireland. >> leave it to the leprechaun. i'm irish, kaitlyn, charlie and julie. we've got the stocks that our guys say will work for you so you don't have to. come back in a minute. woman: it's been a journey to get where i am. and i didn't get here alone. there were people who listened along the way. people who gave me options. kept me on track. and through it all, my retirement never got left behind. so today, i'm prepared for anything we may want tomorrow to be. every someday needs a plan. let's talk about your old 401(k) today. when you think of saving money, what comes to mind? your next getaway? connecting with family and friends? a big night out? or maybe your everyday shopping. whatever it is, aarp member advantages can help save you time and money along the way. so when you get there, you can enjoy it all the more. for less. surround yourself with savings at aarpadvantages.com >>> we're back to the stocks that will work for you. gary,