Skip to main content

tv   Inside Story 2017 Ep 268  Al Jazeera  September 27, 2017 10:32am-11:01am AST

10:32 am
you know what to five years in prison for her conviction on corruption charges you can lock was not in court to hear that judgment as she fled the court last month she's accused of wasting billions of dollars on a rice scheme which cause huge losses to the state. women will be allowed to drive in saudi arabia for the first time starting in june of next year king solomon issued a decree ending the kingdom status as the only country where it's forbidden the u.s. defense secretary james mattis is in the afghan capital kabul along with the native chief u.n. stoltenberg the unannounced high level visit comes weeks after president donald trump pledged to send more u.s. forces to afghanistan we're getting reports that a rocket landed near kabul airport after mr mattis arrived in afghanistan just a few hours ago we're following that still evolving story for you we'll update you as soon as we have any subsequent information more than forty thousand ranger have fled from me in marjah bangladesh in the past two days the u.n.
10:33 am
says the number of refugees escaping violence in me in mass rakhine state has risen to four hundred eighty pounds thirty minutes of al-jazeera world news in thirty minutes between now and then it's inside story up. on october the first catalonia plans to hold an independence referendum yet the central government insists it's unconstitutional and the courts have judged it illegal as the state drops down and catalans take to the streets where will this crisis and. zero for the latest. because it involved her voice in the referendum with hopes of getting their own homeland votes rejected by the iraqi government and neighboring countries to appease more could spark an ethnic sawed off the battle and a need for the region this is inside story.
10:34 am
hello and welcome to the program i'm in is a problem the kurdish referendum in iraq has been a long time coming it finally happened on monday after years of campaigning the kurds living in northern iraq have been pushing for independence and the end of world war one in two thousand and five an overwhelming majority said they wanted an independence referendum but it didn't happen now the family voted for secession in an official poll but will that actually translate to independence for the iraqi kurds we'll get to our guests in just a moment but first how the hamad sets up the story for us from at a b. in. there is certainly a sense of pride and satisfaction among people here pride because many say well they didn't expect to participate in such a vote in their lifetime and also satisfaction because in the run up to the
10:35 am
referendum they were there was a lot of apprehension. that violence could erupt in the disputed territories and specifically in kirkuk that did not happen in the day when by and large very safely now the problems that the kurdish region. was facing the day before the referendum are exactly the same and now now there's the added problems with baghdad the central government there making it clear that it regards the vote as unconstitutional prime minister. and making clear that he will not allow the decision to gratian of iraq in and the other side president. saying that the time for the fame partnership with iraq is making it clear that the some point this region will break away from iraq now besides all that it has to be said that
10:36 am
beyond this the threats nothing's has changed on the ground the security cooperation between the two sides is still ongoing very important for the ongoing offensive in how we judge and very important for the international community that it stays as such until the war against is over and that should take quite a while yet. thank you and well kurdish officials say the voters non-binding but regional powers have still expressed strong disapproval the iraqi government has denounced the referendum as unconstitutional turkey and iran with their own sizeable kurdish minorities also rejected the vote their concerns a kurdish state could motivate some of the movements and their own countries in the u.s. has spoken out against the referendum worried it might hurt efforts to fight isis and syria and u.n. secretary general antonio tara's issued a statement on monday warning of potentially destabilizing effects of the vote
10:37 am
let's bring in our panel now joining us from baghdad as alley al nash me an iraqi political analyst from had a beer ranch and i'll be a visiting fellow from the brookings doha center and from birmingham in the u.k. laugh after kurdish affairs analyst and director of alpha five consultancy welcome to the program mr allow the an if i missed out with you we are expecting a resounding vote but is the kurdish parliament prepared for independence are they united enough they only met for the first time in two years recently. i think the first thing to point out is that independence isn't going to emerge overnight over the space of the next few weeks this referendum as the kurdish leadership of pointed out and indeed other observers is essentially about firstly identifying what the will of the people is rallying
10:38 am
support for a potential kurdish state for a potential secession from the rest of iraq but it's also really to kick start formal negotiations regarding a potential to session from iraq that will require negotiations some kind of settlement with the baghdad government dealing with the multiple authorities in baghdad as well. whether the kurds are ready for independence will of course depend on. the unification of the parties but on that point it's worth bearing in mind that for the referendum there were very little hope so expectations that the parties the main parties would rally around a unified mobilize in support of the referendum those were proven wrong leading up to the referendum the kurdish leadership played a central role in getting together the parties and rallying the kurdish people for that unified stance on one kurdish independence but the crucial part of this is that independence will be part of a. long challenging process that will require negotiation not
10:39 am
negotiate not just with baghdad of course but also the region and the international community mr al nash me if the kurdish people vote for independence well iraq negotiate they have to. no of course mr nobody a brain mr to say yesterday there is no to get in between iraq and could the stand on the basis of intervention because of and it's not cons and constitutionals then they will refuse it if they want to make another negotiation about the budget that the ship has before us the constitution say that but if they are talking on the one base about the independent they're refusing from the bed at the iraqi parliament and from the iraqi prime minister i think they will not. mr at the end as the referendum unconstitutional as the iraqi government is saying. well the word unconstitutional is something which is thrown around very often quite recklessly
10:40 am
and lazy dare i say and has been the case and that has been the case for the past ten years this of course is a question of of law of politics but also one of international law as well the constitution of iraq itself stipulates that iraq is a voluntary union so much of the reasons behind this referendum stem from the crisis of governance and the authority in baghdad the breakdown of security the lack of reconciliation between the kurdish leadership between the k r g and the baghdad government those are all of course complicated aspects and issues that deserve a discussion and in their own and right but i think the reason why we have this current push toward sovereignty stems from the crisis that iraq as a whole faces this is one of lack of good governance one of the breakdown of authority the breakdown of security there fattah let me bring you in now the you
10:41 am
know kurds will say that this is constitutional because they signed up to iraq as part of a voluntary union and if they're no longer happy if that union isn't working for them they can walk away the iraqi government will of course say that the constitution doesn't allow for any sector of iraqi society to declare independence is it constitutional and does it does that even matter now at this point. i think the fact that the iraqi constitution doesn't provide for it doesn't make it unconstitutional there's many flaws with the iraqi constitution i mean one of the reasons we actually are in this position is that many of the difficult issues such as disputed territories was actually put off at the time of writing the constitution so we see the results of not having actually tackled those issues back in two thousand and five and two thousand and six that we are in this mess now. and it is a voluntary union and every nation has the right to self-determination it's not to
10:42 am
legally binding vote the chaos you have been very clear on that but they are letting their people express their opinion and it does look like it's going to be an overwhelming yes and since people do have the right to self-determination why have we heard from the un secretary general and tony attwood terrorism against us why is that you went against the vote when the u.n. charter. says that self-determination is enshrined in it i think unfortunately in the kurds are always the unfortunate victims of the political realities of the middle east you know everyone always tells the kurds when they all squat independence it's not the right time but really when is the right time there's many internal differences amongst the kurds but at the same time iraq is very much a failed state it can't protect itself and it's to be honest the reaction from baghdad has been predictable disappointing they actually haven't made any moves to really say look we don't want you to leave we want you to stay and i think that's a shame you know if they want iraq to remain as one entity then they also have to
10:43 am
come to the table with something that's more appealing than what we've had for the last ten fifteen years let me do you think that the iraqi government has done enough to keep the kurds happy have they been good hosts to the kurds in iraq. no you know the crisis in and i can snort only for the kurdish because all the iraqi they subletting you from the from the violence from the economic crisis in order that we can know to. targeted them and we cannot there could be snow in the second nationality you know they take all day. they talk all the high position in the iraqi government and they took the financial from the iraqi and they talk now more and more and they now call to rolling rolling more they demand to be fourteen years old before the american invasion in order that i don't think
10:44 am
there is some with the dealing between the iraqi government and with the kurdish no not us i am the iraqi and i know the goodness they have a right to make a state well but not against the interest now. more than any care injuries and they take all the opposition and they take a very good financial and from baghdad and they can't get on with all the sources. of the stand and the borders of a culture of more than that in order that i can say economic. better than that in the middle of the south in iraq in order that i think. the government. but it will the dealing but what there are seventy to about it's not only because they are good dish must not but they're but they are the crisis in the whole the iraq mr aladin do you agree that the kurdish government has only taken
10:45 am
from iraq they have of course had to economic success economic progress and we've had strong international condemnation to this referendum the turkish president saying that he's going to turn off the oil taps how would kurdistan export its oil and turkey did that. well i'll take the question in two parts the first is the reality is sovereign states have access to certain advantages certain benefits afforded to them by the international system it's true that the k r g did enter into a power sharing arrangement with baghdad since two thousand and three but at the same time that was an arrangement whereby the k r g was dependent on the politics and the nature of politics authority and governance in baghdad where baghdad became increasingly authoritarian where power became concentrated towards one particular side of one particular sphere that power sharing arrangement broke down over the past number of years particularly since the us withdrawal in two thousand and
10:46 am
eleven now in that relationship of dependency the k r g has been at a disadvantage for example since it economic crisis it's been unable to borrow from from financial markets because financial markets international organizations lend money generally to sovereign states that process has the pending on that recovery has depended on baghdad and because of the politics because of the breakdown in relations and politics in authority that simply hasn't happened the turkish government has of course issued a number of challenges threats through multiple channels particularly the media but it's still unclear whether those threats will actually materialize into anything practical i mean bill for example right now over the past few days there's been all sorts of gossip news rumors about. blockades being imposed. crossings being closed but none of that is actually founded on it has actually taken
10:47 am
place it's very important to separate what's gossip and news from the realities on the ground if indeed there is a blockade and it has to be the worst blockade in history most flights are operating for example turkish airways is still operating quite flights have been canceled much of this will depend on. what happens post referendum and from the people i've spoken to here within the kurdish leadership there is a willingness and an effort a genuine effort to. remedy tensions with baghdad to alleviate those concerns that regional powers have heard varying in mind of course that the k r g has over the past seven or eight years in particular strengthened its ties with countries like turkey there is on ongoing dialogue that will be crucial to ensuring cooler heads prevail mr allawi the next few weeks in particular you talk about the reality on the ground the reality on the ground since the referendum is iraqi and turkish
10:48 am
military exercises on the border further just how dangerous is the situation right now is the potential for conflict for a while and so here i mean the middle east as a whole is a volatile region so there is always the potential that it can cross into violent conflict i would hope that this is a case of saber rattling really everybody is talking quite aggressive language and sort of doesn't want to lose face doesn't want to be the person who sort of comes to the table first but i do hope that it won't cross into violent actions and that they do actually come to the table i think it's just the first step holding the referendum in terms of independence was actually the easy part it's not going to be easy to become independent somewhat maybe a mid term aim is to actually have a better form of me within iraq and to push for more in try and rights and actual equal behavior and to be treated as a partner
10:49 am
a true partner and in this to our national iraq what do you make of that will the iraqi government. giving the kurds greater autonomy treating them as a true partner. yes i think because the next three to demand and about in the money is that they give that authority to the government and i think it's not they winding their struggles and they why doing the difficult between the iraq and the stand i think will be limited in the many regions from a kind of cool core of the valley of. and valley of a more sane and i think they waiting sometimes to make a deal with the. side and with iran to make many things and cooperated with the sanctions economic sanctions i think the first economic sanction they cut the financials. to the support financial support to the government of could
10:50 am
withstand. the army of the stand and i think they will all fall to the. side when they stop the took a side stop the. i think the iraqis say they will all fall. to the brink of the company to the most to the builds most of the selves in order that i think we must wait sometimes and now in these days there is a military exercise that will haven't. taken it has done now between the iraqi army and army we will wait sometimes because they're in there according to the good stuff as the call to send say that and do all in order that we wait just sometimes some days or some weeks to know what is the result of what
10:51 am
is the reaction coming from could step mr nash me let's look at just some of the history the roots behind kurdish asked. now before we continue the discussion the kurds have wanted an independent state since the end of world war one when colonial powers divided up the middle east the territory was split between iraq syria turkey and iran were between twenty five and thirty million kurds now and the iraqi kurds a mainly in the north they have been relatively autonomous in flight nine hundred ninety one with a on federal state army and parliament but this referendum was about making independence official in syria u.s. backed kurds known as the syrian democratic forces have been fighting i saw in the north syrian kurds aim for assad to cleared autonomous region known as. turkey's kurds are mainly based in the southeast the kurdistan workers' party or p.k. k. is a kurdish rebel group fighting for autonomy in turkey since the nineteen eighties and
10:52 am
in iraq kurds make up around ten percent of the population this thought that if i could come to you now why should kurds should kurds do you think live by borders that were drawn up you know a colonial carved up essentially drawn up one hundred one years ago by an endless men if we look at the history with a little with little thought to linguistic cultural religious tribe all considerations yes i mean the kurds were provided for a nation in the treaty of server but unfortunately that was then negated by the treaty of lo sun i think you know one hundred of you being denied your nationhood and a hundred bloody years of genocide of chemical gassing of oppressed uprisings now i think it's all right to actually ask for independence is there ever going to be a good time are turkey iran and iraq going to want to ever see those territories
10:53 am
and syria probably not. but you know at the same time have they perhaps treated the kurds a little bit nicer they might of not been asking for independence in such sort of figure so. i do think the kurds have a right to ask for independence it won't be easy it will take time it will never happen overnight but i think this was a great step by the chaos. they actually went through with it i think a lot of people thought that it wouldn't happen in the end that they would call it off so the people have had their say they voted overwhelmingly for independence but now that's just the very first step on a long run and we have to remember where we are turkey iran and iraq and syria will be on a visit if we do one day get independence and we will need good relations with them because we'll be landlocked and the smash me what do you think of what miss father had to say how long do you think iraq can really deny the biggest ethnic group in the region without their own state their own nation you know this very big problem
10:54 am
because of this that i think state between the could stand and about and because the problem is the kurdish say all that i think there are kurdish there. they say yes it is scottish and christian and scottish and sometimes they talk in their top command they are good bush but they change their language this is against the history in order that the iraqi government and the historians say you know to their this is this is the places below baghdad in order that we are waiting and from fourteen years the size zero were called lee and do you believe george change their mind and they give a lot of money for their leaders to change their attitudes in order that we heard before the fire and we had many of the doves of us the deal the place the end or something of the took command they talk every day talk we are not command we are
10:55 am
kurdish vary but i village is they they brought us there to say burma's that leaders of the local leaders for many brigitta villages when they they make they are for them they make the independent. in order there we know and in our constitution we said we want a term we have a term that term say one hundred forty about that i think it places between and chemical and more sun valley now the problem is that i care about them and give them the mentor to the iraqi forces to go to content on the ground or link that to places that bases was and. under the league of the iraqi government before i sold but when the ice coming they could just use that and the contour of the about this land. of the body of a most of all i think the problem is between got to stand if they sold i think even the independent well i didn't stand all right mr nash may i just want to get around
10:56 am
and then he in here what do you think the kurds will do next you know how will they proceed and a region that completely disregards their independence how do they move forward. i think what this referendum has done it's taken the kurds. across a line whereby it can no longer be business as usual one positive outcome that could emanate from this referendum regionally that is and in terms of relations with baghdad and internationally is that it would encourage the region international powers like the us to take this break down in relations between the k r g and baghdad more seriously and play a more positive role and proactive role in mediating those tensions and finding that grand settlement that can stabilize iraq as a whole as it continues to struggle with the threat from isis terrorist attacks and
10:57 am
other threats to security as well for the kurdish leadership what i've witnessed here in erbil so far is a certain level headedness don't forget of course this is a leadership that has long standing ties to the main players actors in baghdad some of them even fought alongside each other against the former ba'ath regime for example i also mentioned earlier that the k r g has had a strong relationship and they continuously developing relationships with regional powers like turkey those channels will be crucial to ensuring things develop in a peaceful way and as i said earlier ensuring that cooler heads prevail at the end of the day war will be costly for everybody whether that's the key argy whether that's baghdad. this particular stretch right now as it continues its operations in the rest of iraq mr elden i'm afraid that is all the time we have today thank you to all our guests. and latha and thank you for watching you can see the program again any time by visiting our website al-jazeera dot com and
10:58 am
for further discussion go to our facebook page that facebook dot com forward slash and five story you can also join the conversation on twitter handles at age eight and five stories for me and of the problem and the whole team by fanatics. water scarcity is a serious problem we use more than probably you need to why it is you with impact if there are plans to urge demanding as much water you don't need to irrigate as much heinz me is the age old technique of collecting water from bald top water just came out of the air and we'll compare that to some tap water which could provide a solution to the pump and global water tank no i think it's time on the edges iraq . the story breaks. down what blanket coverage
10:59 am
follows experts from politicians off a path to choose i'm soundbites strong and stable leadership trying to play the media and shape the message in an age of simplistic narratives the listening post critiques the mainstream response today and the two hundredth day of this administration exposing the influences that drive the headlines at this time on al-jazeera history is so often told through the eyes of leaders but in amritsar india just thirty kilometers from the border with pakistan this old building is being transformed into a new museum mallika ahluwalia is the driving force behind amrit sars partition museum it's really shocking because if you think about the fact that within a few years of nine eleven happening and nine eleven museum was there and they are now numerous holocaust museums it's not beautiful apartheid museum so countries
11:00 am
around the world have walked to memorialize these events that have shaped them by dition is not about the political events that led up to partition it's about the impact on each person who went through it it's really important that we highlight the stories of humanity hopefully one outcome on this would be that we remember our shared humanity and the shared history. and over the airports or face an embargo the threat from baghdad after initial results show iraqi kurds voted for independence in the referendum.

25 Views

info Stream Only

Uploaded by TV Archive on