tv Inside Story 2019 Ep 335 Al Jazeera December 2, 2019 10:32am-11:01am +03
what isto i will write to the president of the labor party so that the process for a new leader sit for january 12th 2020. will resign is the leader of the labor party in the days after i will resign as prime minister. protesters in india have held more vigils for a 27 year old woman who was raped and murdered me hyderabad an angry crowd gathered outside the police station where 4 men are being held in connection with head to f campaign as they are calling for tougher laws and brought a change in society. well those are the headlines to join me for more news here on al-jazeera off the inside story stay with us. on counting recalls what started the protests in ecuador could it be a multi-billion dollar loan with both tax the good news corporation stereotypes of the poorest in the lobby and a good part of the economic policy did it help to plan recover from its last decade . counting the cost on algebra. they are hub partners
but germany's social democrats are just elected new leaders who want to leave angela merkel's grand coalition so that the chancellor save her government and what does this uncertainty mean for germany and for europe this is inside story. hello welcome to the program i'm adrian finnegan germany a social democrat so s.p.d. have chosen to leaders who want to leave angela merkel's grand coalition many of the party members say they want to focus on rebuilding support in the opposition the coalition between angela merkel's christian democrats and the s.p.d. was formed last year at the espy's new leaders ran on a joint ticket with
a promise to renegotiate a partnership deal on issues of spending and climate policy it's congress is expected to decide by next week on whether the policy will continue to support merkel but should the s.p.d. decide to leave the chancellor has the option of leading a minority government or forming a new coalition with smaller opposition parties a snap election is also on the cards with one of the s.p.d. as new leaders dull but volatile boyens spoke about the importance of keeping his party strong. we are very aware that this is not a question of victory or defeat but this is a question of keeping this great social democratic party together and bringing together again where it has already moved apart a bit i think that this is not only something that is great fun but also a great challenge meanwhile chancellor merkel says the results have not changed the coalition's agreement because. we want to rule to a new world we have created
a foundation for this and this internal decision of the is p d does not change anything on the condition of the coalition. now we must not discuss party but to look at the challenges germany is facing and to govern this country well and for that there is a foundation the coalition treaty between s.p.d. n.c.d. you and nothing changes that. let's bring in our guests then for today's discussion from poland we're joined by thorsten bet up director of the global public policy institute from amsterdam via skype julian managing director of vocal europe a foreign affairs think tank and from london we're joined by max for trap or thought of angle of merkel europe's most influential leader gentlemen welcome to you all thorsten let's start with you does this change in leadership at the s.t.p. mean that germany is now heading for an early election. thanks for having me no i
don't think it means that germany is heading for an early election at least not anytime soon if the social democrats actually decide under the new leadership to leave the coalition and that's a big if because the party convention still needs to decide in favor of it and then also the members of parliament the parliamentary group that has voiced some doubts whether they would follow such a vote they need to agree then the s.p.d. ministers will just leave the coalition we have a budget for 2020 already agreed on and i'm going to america will just lead a minority government through our 2020 her argument will be this is out of a sense of national responsibility germany has the e.u. presidency in the 2nd half of 2020 we cannot afford to hold elections now plus there is a big constitutional hurdles anyway to have early elections in germany so i don't assume that merkel will leave office any time soon but she'll govern with
a forecast of c.d.u. ministers if she has a minority government she can promote the c.d.u. party leader and i'd come combo or 2 vice chancellor that can russia her image so in very much works in the favor of merkel and the c.d.o. if the social democrats decide to leave the coalition judy and the new leadership of the s.t.p. says that it wants to renegotiate the terms of the grand coalition what does it want and are its coalition partners willing to give them what they want so what's happening now is that the split there wants to rejigger should the government spending and the climate change policy which d. so they do on the michael democrat have said is not on the table at school so was like a. d s but there will try and push for this whereas just now mark africa under said you could decide to push ahead for a model to government on bert's also i'm going to mark. ok matt can keep the
grand coalition together would she try to struggle on with a minority government when we haven't had a minority government before in jamey's that would be a new departure but then again you new things can happen but i think. i think. probably more for the social democrats to decide whether they want to to force the breakup of the coalition there's no guarantee that there would be a minority government if there were to be under some sort of scenario using some sort of constitutional shenanigan to get a new election they could become the 4th largest party i was reading an opinion poll from fortune cooper valan this morning when i was driving in here and they actually behind the f.t. in the opinion polls so the social democrats even if they're relatively strong. lenda level at the state level where they have i think 7 out of the 16 premia ships
in germany they are not in a strong position and for them to rock the boat would be be you know a callous act and also coming back to the question from before would they be able to negotiate any new coalition deal with the c.d.u. i think it's extremely unlikely and it could come. looking over her shoulder to the rights of flirtation math to pre-pay who's a challenge oh could be the challenger to so there's no way that the cd you could give way on issues on the left of the party man what is going on within the s d p then this this shift to the left why would the s.t.p. want to risk losing power and influence by putting the coalition at risk. i think one has to sort of perhaps even look at the labor party in britain and look at the internal workings of a political party like people join a political party because they have strong views now who lost the leadership
election is actually the 3rd most popular politician in germany but a political party does not reflect the people at logs they reflect the membership and a lot of people in the social democratic party feel that they went way too far when . it was chancellor they have embraced many thier right wing policies especially in social affairs issues and therefore i think they want to go back to basics they want to go you know solidify the base as it's called they want they want to win votes back from the left party possibly even from the green policy and they're looking towards a period in opposition where they can sort of cleanse themselves of. being tainted by the by the but by association with the. cd u.s.c.'s you do you agree with that because the s.t.p.
find itself in embroiled in some kind of internal turmoil could could division over the direction of the policy be destabilising for it could end up tearing it apart. this is already happening i mean the this election is the result of this it's a result of a. very deep for teac within the party the social democrats have been in power in germany at the national level for 16 out of the past 20 years they started out 20 years ago with more than 35 percent of the vote now they're pulling a at about 13 to 17 percent so they've lost the popularity tremendously and the many party members just want out they want out of government they think they need to go in opposition but they don't really have a path there this election that brought to relatives nobody aging nobodies or lightweight candidates to the to the helm of the of the party in
a sense was very much a read it's a geisha in off the gas shortages the reform that cuts to some well for spending that already that's when the when the party started tearing apart some of these wounds from the early 2000 set still haven't healed. the challenge or the other candidate that last. shot is very much an embodiment of the shorter centrist agenda now many just to long for return to whatever kind of core the s.p.d. is supposed to be out about the leftist core and they hope that then they will fare better but it's very hard to see if they jump out of the window nala say goodbye by a grand coalition we don't we're tired of government of germany then in fact headed for elections what's the offer of the social democrats to the population say please vote for us we want to be an opposition that's not exactly a winning winning formula is quite tragic that none of the 2 canada the pairs or
duels really offered the past what the future what social democracy in 10 years should be all about what what germany won't want to achieve in the in the coming 10 years none of the 2 fine. as to do all those really offered any sense any sense of that and neither does chancellor merkel for that matter so germany is very much adrift and dealing with its own internal divisions and much rather than looking to what the future at the moment ok julian i mean before we move on let's ask one more question about the s.t.p. you heard what torsten and matt were saying there is the party's dwindling popularity with voters simply because the party has moved too far towards the political center are its leaders right to do they need a reset i mean that's going to be the impression that people are going to be taking from this for example all of us has been said it is not doing very well the polling behind me going up they are almost that level stuff on the if there and some people
could draw from this conclusion that they've strayed from the last not taking enough socially democratic policies and putting it forward to the membership and pushing up towards the general public in germany and of course the problem when you're in coalition and we saw this and u.k. where the dems that's quite frequently you become tainted by the brush of having the d.m. majority party dictate in syria what exactly it wants as army goals to be and yes but there have more than likely been dragged so the sense of being seen as most of the party which is going to impact the popularity and we see that this could we could see that this is a move to attract the. to bring people back from the us to bring people back towards sensible social democratic policies and politics so i'd say this could be an explanation. i think this consensus among us here that the lection is possibly the least likely option but if there were to be
a general election in germany who would benefit most to the greens the f.t. which at least under its new leadership looks as though it will be moving further to the rice. no i think they if they would would do relatively well but they are in some ways an irrelevant thought because they are so far to the right that it's inconceivable that they could join a coalition that might be people who sort of privately in the c.s.u. and possibly even a cd you would contemplate that but that would would would would really not go down well in germany at large i think the party that would would really do well it's a green party we have had to pay nion poses a just in the green party could be even bigger than the c.d.u. there's a lot of sort of focus on environmental issues the green party have. at the state level have have done well they've showed they be efficient manages and so i think
the green party would do well and i think in some ways almost like a realignment in german politics where the green party is going to be the main party of the left and of course what will be then interesting is to see if we'll get the so-called jamaica coalition or a a coalition of the green party the cd u.c. as you and the liberals now they try to do that last time the liberals went weren't terribly keen and pulled out but i think that would probably be the the future but the a if t. don't have coalition tensional and they don't have blackmail potential so even if they were to get 15 percent of the votes. they will be politically speaking relatively irrelevant. after 10 years of stability and the angle of merkel where is germany headed right now will it be able to maintain its dominant. economic and political position within the e.u.
. that's a big question mark germany's very much adrift ever since the elections in 2017 germany has been extremely inward looking this called the so-called grand coalition was a very unhappy marriage from the get go only born out of the failure of the negotiations of the so-called jamaica coalition that then failed to come into existence its german is the current government doesn't show any path forward germans are divided still on issues of migration climate change and. we're wasting precious time actually to invest in a stronger europe a stronger europe that can defend itself also against an ever more aggressive china and we're investing we're failing to invest in our all in the strength of. our own industrial base germany had a fantastic economic development for the most part over the past 10 to 15 years
we've had a good run but it's very unclear whether germany is well prepared for kind of ensuring prosperity of our economy in the future we should be investing and discussing this right now but rather we are in the kind of dealing with this kind of petty internal domestic political turmoil and germany is very much adrift it's still a default big country in europe it won't just to become politically irrelevant way too big for this but right now we're not assuming any sort of leadership role that we've kind of given that to french president calls now the more active figure on the european political scene. julian. this this petty domestic incident internal turmoil is as thorsten put it to what extent is that diminishing germany's reputation for political stability and leadership within
the e.u. do you think well the problem is that it's not simply a da as you domestic politics are going to be having an impact on this is the shift of balance that's occurring across europe so for example since the election is going on. it's very much been a case of micron's been taken and the front seats in the european politics of the whole bunch of all of his commentary with his most recent comments on nato from has almost changed positions of germany and that is becoming a far more active and far more visible presence and i don't necessarily think that is surely going to be an issue of germany becoming irrelevant germany losing its power its what's we're likely to see is france and germany will switch places compared to where they were 5 or 10 years ago for example with france was seen as the problem child in europe the sort of the not very helpful partner who always made grandiose claims and graduate promises and never really the live it out in
german these case right now is that when the most powerful economies in europe if not the most powerful so that's won't go away unless germany somehow fulls into a recession in the coming year or 2 or the pending on how it becomes next chance for example if it because if it's aka it's likely that germany is going to loose lucky more presence and primarily for the fact that the cut tends to have lots of bits of agreements of president michel and may end up following in supporting his plans how ever i just want to go back to the point on the green party becoming more powerful it's true that i think that the green party is the single highest polling party in germany right now if it wasn't for the city to say yes to a coalition that's happened that takes place every election. the governor would be the biggest party in the bundestag. must undertake but that is going to have an effect on how the german politics is shaped and the us to these of the china russia
the us even within europe with the green new deal luna may have even more power than we expect and this need may lead suggest me having a more compositional maintaining them when it comes to syria european politics. it's going to go back to to the 1st part of what your view was saying that this this this potential for france and germany to to switch places almost within the e.u. to what extent is france looking to exploit this this diminishing of germany's reputation. well i think it frankly is quite fanciful because the french economy is nowhere near as strong as the german one i think does does a good talk but i'm not sure he does the same kind of walk he can say slightly know what you things about nato and about europe but he's got his own problems he's never quite recovered from the she dacian situation he has in that
a number of reforms which he was able to do because he's got a lot majority in that somebody nationality but they would also at some stage be french elections he is france in some ways is a great a problem child because we have 4 nationality we don't have anything like 4 nationality i mean a if be appropriate to the right of whole notion of they would would not in any way gain power so france is not a state of i think the problem we have in europe at the moment is that we have a very chaotic situation in britain which in a year's time could probably date to a heartbreaks that because i won't be a deal it's a lead has not exactly a stable government spain is trying to find a government germany is wobbling a bit and france is doing a good talk a macro is doing the good talk but the stability in france is in the longer run it's not to be taken for granted so i think the problem we have throughout europe
is that we really need now to have stability in germany so as the other ones can get on with the squabbling and i think relatively speaking i mean stability in germany is not catastrophic is just used to having absolute stability in germany and therefore we panic a bit and we should probably be concerned but i think we also need to put this into perspective matt what extent is all of this this to war within germany that ultimately to deal with and angela merkel is leadership i mean she's still chancellor of the she no longer needs. policy. no that's not is a problem of course schroeder also stood down when he didn't lead his own party he lost some sort of influence i think again we need to put it into perspective angela merkel is still by by some distance the most popular politician in germany the 2nd most popular is what happened who is the green one of the 2 green leaders and then all of this as the most popular so but i think the problem is that he's very much
in the sort of lame duck position if you saw at the conference the c.d.u. conference most is time she didn't talk she was just stating that checking her phone and the problem that we have in europe is that we're not quite sure who will be the next contender and the leader of the c.d.u. or the it's when i was sick a question in germany you know who's going to be the candidate for the chancellor for the for the c.d.u. . and i mean come on bow is is is not a charismatic politician noise angela merkel but what she's she's struggling even if she was able to to you know go for the civil you know back me a sacked me approach at the conference she doesn't look as sure footed as she could be and therefore people and talking about you know sudo from from bev area could be a chance to candidate he's not that popular generally in germany and clearly
schmetz could come in and he's a question of what's happening in the christian democrats you know rather than in germany the thing is a problem julian would would you agree with that very briefly yes and somewhere i would agree that it's it is a case of. europe we don't know who's going to believe. that that lack of stability which has been a bedrock of europe that sort of. decades now is very much a campus a problem because if you lose confidence in what's up in the country then as people say we see a wobble and sometimes some market's going to react something that's going to react some people could see also said dude. a dangerous person for gemma politics for example and i could have another come how people are viewing germany and this is problematic because all it takes is for example we end up in a situation as is pointed out where. the i have to maybe exploit this war and push
quite hard and have a very lucky election i think you have to respect the public ok i'm so sorry to interrupt you julian. i'm sorry thorsten we've got about a minute left on the program we have mentioned eastern europe but we talked about france germany switching places perhaps what about eastern europe particularly poland where does poland stand in the jockeying for for influence with it within the e.u. very briefly please in the polish government very much pro promotes its nationalist agenda cracking down on the rule of law domestically the same goes for for the hungary and prime minister our bansal they will of course promote their own national interest. and try to work together also with the new commission leadership for where that leaves europe it's very much up in the air the same. way it's very much up in the air who will be the next german chancellor right now none of the 3
parties the main 3 parties have a clear candidate for for chancellor if we had. elections tomorrow there's a lot of uncertainty in germany and that's just the name of the game at the moment gentlemen we're out of time many thanks indeed for being with us on today's inside story. as always thank you for watching the program don't forget you can see it at gannett any time just by going to the website at al-jazeera dot com for further discussion join us on our facebook page at facebook dot com forward slash a.j. inside story and you can join the conversation on twitter our handle at a j inside story for me adrian finnegan and the whole team here in doha thanks for watching i'll see you again i for. my.
in this life the most incredible stories are often true. and cheering go on experiences. makes the on for me or for me. in this life diversity makes a difference understanding the importance of being part of something much greater than all souls in this life what i want to use is freedom of expression. the right to mortgage. the law. into the dollar. because you dislike the design to understand that. makes us human. and the human condition is universal. global food production is wasteful and this training our planet. but pioneers are
adapting with new food sources jellyfish is delicious with a very light seafood taste and a texture and some that calum ari. and innovative production techniques i've seen a vertical farm before i would never in a restaurant after say this is great earthrise feeding the 1000000000 on a jersey to. on county macof what start the protest in ecuador could it be a multi-billion dollar loan with both tax the goodness to the corporation the stereotypes of the poor but even though i am a part of the economic policy did it help to plan recover from its lost decade. counting the costs on i'll just. join me many often as i put the upfront questions to my special guests and challenge them to some straight talking political. debate here.
the white house declares president donald trump won't participate in the next impeachment hearings calling the proceedings a baseless. and this is al jazeera live from also coming up the search for a new leader in iraq after huge often violent protests forced the resignation of prime minister abdul mahdi. someone shuts down its government and want to stop to help contain a measles outbreak that's killed more than 50 people mostly children. and leaders gather for climate talks in spain we'll explore what's at stake for fragile river systems in kenya.