Skip to main content

tv   CNN Newsroom  CNN  October 12, 2014 3:00pm-4:01pm PDT

3:00 pm
the deadly ebola virus appears to have been contracted by someone inside the united states for the first time. despite wearing protective gear. a nurse who had, quote, extensive contact with ebola patient thomas eric duncan has tested positive for the virus. meanwhile, the cdc says more cases are possible. coming up, a live report from dallas, plus our panel of doctors are standing by to answer your questions on ebola. all in the next hour of the "cnn newsroom" which begins right now. thanks for joining me in the "cnn newsroom." i'm ana cabrera. this hour we're fast forwarding to the week ahead. a look at all the stories you'll be talking about this week. of course, the two big stories in the headlines today, ebola and isis, both deadly threats. in iraq, the coalition's air campaign hasn't stopped isis. those terrorists are now just miles from baghdad's airport.
3:01 pm
could they cake iraq's capital? here at home, a new case of the ebola virus. the cdc says there is no risk to most of us, but can we trust officials? will we see more cases soon? not everyone was reassured by what we heard today. see what you think. >> we're here today to communicate about a health care worker who has contracted the ebola virus. >> there was a breach in protocol, and that breach in protocol resulted in this infection. >> the care of ebola can be done safely, but it's hard to do it safely. it is possible in the coming days that we will see additional cases of ebola. breaking the links in the chain of transmission is the key to preventing further spread. that's how we will stop it in
3:02 pm
dallas. >> so we begin with three questions for the week ahead about ebola. question number one, will we see more ebola cases this week? a breach in protocol. that's what's believed to be the reason for the first known tr s transmission of ebola virus on u.s. soil. that victim, a nurse, who had contact with thomas eric duncan before he died. doctors in boston are assessing a patient with ebola-like symptoms. the patient had recently been to liberia. question number two, will the u.s. troops help turn the tide? some soldiers are already in west africa. we'll hear from the man in charge of the mission there and look at whether it's fair to send our servicemen and women into the hot zone. question number three, what your concerns about ebola? we're taking your questions about ebola and will ask our panel of experts. tweet me your questions
3:03 pm
@anacabrera. s right now, let's get straight to dallas for more on this case of ebola. cnn's ed lavendera is joining me. has the hospital giving more details on how exactly this nurse was infect? >> reporter: the hospital simply saying at this point they're investigating a what they call a breach in protocol. this is in nurse who was responsible for being part of the team that took care of thomas eric duncan before he died here at this hospital last week. now they're try to figure out what went wrong here at this point. the hospital officials did say she was infected despite wearing the protective mask, gloves, go gowns, everything that was us in. somewhere along the way something broke down and she was contaminated and infected with the ebola virus. basically the most hospital officials have said today here, ana, she has a low amount of virus in her system, at that point, from a treatment standpoint, that could be a very
3:04 pm
good sign. medical experts say that the earlier you diagnose the virus, the better chance you have of survi surviving. >> given the fact that she contracted the ebola virus, and was wearing all that protective gear, is the hospital prepared to treat her? >> reporter: they basically brought her to the very same area where thomas eric duncan was treated and this is a large base, i believe a 24-bed area that has been quarantined while thomas eric duncan was being treated here. she was brought to that same area. and one of the things that they say they want to do this time around is limit the number of health care workers who are exposed to this second patient until they figure out exactly what went wrong and how she was able to be become infected. >> all right. ed lavendera, thanks for the update. a very small risk of spreading, no need for concern. at least that's what we were told days ago. now a nurse who cared for ebola victim thomas duncan has become
3:05 pm
infected with the deadly disease. how worried should we be? let's get perspective from dr. jorge rodriguez. dr. rodriguez, what are your thoughts about what's happening in dallas? >> well, it's unfortunate. no doubt about that. but unfortunately, it's also not unexpected. if you look at ebola worldwide, this is a disease that seems to contaminate caregivers at a very high rate. so nurses, doctors, people that clean and even care, you know, for the sick are much more likely to get it. right now, there is no need to panic. there isn't this treelike branching of contamination, so this person hasn't contaminated anybody we know of. i think it's to be expected that even with these protective gears, you know, you are potentially going to get contaminated. i mean, you have to take them off. there's probably contagion on the gloves, on the suits. they may get in the eye, in the hands. so there's a small chance of it.
3:06 pm
and we may see it again. >> and given what you just said, do you think there's a chance that we will see more health care workers, for example, maybe in dallas, or in other areas like nebraska or, you know, emory hospital in atlanta that have treated the ebola patients so thfar that have come to the u.s. or treated in the u.s., will we see more health care workers become infected? >> you know what, it's hard to predict that, but moy sense of feeling, yes, i think we will. look who's acquired ebola. in spain, it was a nursing assistant. here, it's a nurse. these are the people on the front lines dealing with the contagion every day. unfortunately, yes, i feel we're going to see more health care workers come down with ebola. >> some suggested we're focusing too much on ebola, so i want to turn slightly to enterovirus d-68 for a moment. >> right. >> this respiratory disease is now responsible for another death. we learn this was a 21-month-old
3:07 pm
girl who michigan who just died. enterovirus d-68 infected hundreds of children across country. should people be more concerned perhaps about this virus rather than ebola? >> yes. in short. i was talking to an official in dallas. first of all, it's airborne. secondly, it's affecting children that have respiratory diseases. that could be somehow ameliorated if the kids, you know, treated their asthma better, and it's now in almost all 50 states so we do have to pay very close attention to that. it's two cases right now, but when the winter comes, it may be more. so we do need to focus, i think, a little bit more on the enterovirus infection that's going around. >> all right. dr. jorge rodriguez, thanks so much for your time. countries in west africa, meantime, are coping with thousands of cases of ebola and increasingly they're looking to the u.s. for help. american troops are in the end
3:08 pm
center of the ebola outbreak. is it fair to ask them to catak up this mission? can they do it? that's ahead. also, your questions of all things ebola, as our fast forward look at the week ahead rolls on. creates something else as well: jobs all over america. engineering and innovation jobs. advanced safety systems & technology. shipping and manufacturing. across the united states, bp supports more than a quarter million jobs. when we set up operation in one part of the country, people in other parts go to work. that's not a coincidence. it's one more part of our commitment to america. revolutionary by every standard. and that became our passion. to always build something better, airplanes that fly cleaner and farther on less fuel. that redefine comfort and connect the world like never before. after all, you can't turn dreams into airplanes
3:09 pm
unless your passion for innovation is nonstop. ♪ ur day to unplug. unless your passion for innovation is nonstop. with centurylink as your technology partner, our visionary cloud infrastructure, and dedicated support, free you to focus on what matters. centurylink. your link to what's next.
3:10 pm
having a perfectly nice day, when out of nowhere a pick-up truck slams into your brand new car. one second it wasn't there and the next second... boom! you've had your first accident. now you have to make your first claim. so you talk to your insurance company and... boom! you're blindsided for a second time. they won't give you enough money to replace your brand new car. don't those people know you're already shaken up? liberty mutual's new car replacement will pay for the entire value of your car plus depreciation. call and for drivers with accident forgiveness, liberty mutual won't raise your rates due to your first accident. switch to liberty mutual insurance and you could save up to $423 dollars. call liberty mutual for a free quote today at
3:11 pm
see car insurance in a whole new light. liberty mutual insurance. welcome back. as we fast forward to the week ahead, question two, is the u.s. military up to the job of helping countries like liberia and sierra leone stop this outbreak of ebola? more and more, they're looking to the u.s. to help them turn the tide there. the burden is falling on the american military. if they can't help west africa beat ebola, then it's possible no one can. we met the man leading that mission in liberia. >> i'm a military soldier. i love to see military aircraft come in. so, absolutely, i'm excited. it's a great day. >> reporter: after weeks of preparation, the sounds of aircraft overhead signals a new
3:12 pm
phase in major general darryl williams' mission. >> the weather is tough. the terrain is tough. the infrastructure is challenging. and so these tools that you see coming in will give us the ability to operate with confidence and strength. >> reporter: williams has the unenviable job of leading the fight against an invisible enemy. >> we're glad you're here, man. >> reporter: tasked by president obama to help stop the spread of ebola. >> hey, come on over. >> reporter: and the clock is ticking. >> yeah, so this is how you make a hotel into an operational center. >> reporter: today he's conducting what kthey call a battlefield circulation of joint command. >> this is how we endure we stay safe. >> reporter: this battlefield requires a different kind of vigilance. >> hey, carry on. how's everybody doing? okay. take your seat. >> reporter: in a conference room in a liberian hotel, the operations nerve center. they're about to hit the ground running fitting in where they
3:13 pm
can. conscious that delays cost lives. this will be the site of the monrova medical unit, a facility specifically for health workers to be run by u.s. health teams. as a tent goes up, another hard-ron victory against the elements. outside liberians have come to watch. they've been coming every day, we're told. watching and waiting. >> we'll do a lot of tangible things. we'll build this hospital. we'll build these ebola treatment units. we'll provide these labs and a lot of these tangible things. there's a lot of intangible nature to this fight. u you want to give people the resiliency, the hope, that they can fight this see this through. >> reporter: and they're not alone. >> and they're not alone. over here is the building blocks are our soldiers and air meb and marines will live as they coordinate this effort. >> reporter: president obama pledged up to 4,000 troops, prepacked and ready to roll out. there's space here for 6 00, but
3:14 pm
more still will need to be found. another task on a very long list. the general's optimism, though, is facilitiering down to his men. what did you think when they asked you to come out here? >> i thought, let's do it, let's go. i was ready to go. in 24 hours we were here. >> reporter: there is no getting away from the magnitude of the task ahead. torrential rains, ravaged infrastructure, a disease that's now a pandemic. a mission like none they've undertaken. >> we were brought in to provide our unique capabilities and fill the gaps. the united states military, the department of defense is here to see this mission through. >> reporter: however long it takes? >> for however long it takes. >> reporter: cnn, monrovia, liberia. >> such brave men and women. how much is too much to ask of our troops? fighting wars, that's part of the job. fighting disease, that's an entirely difficult mission. retired marine corps general james williams is joining me now from dallas. general, good to see you.
3:15 pm
>> hello, how are you? >> good. thank you. is this mission creep, tackling an outbreak of a deadly disease? is his why men and women enlist in the military? >> no, not at all. bad guys or bad viruses, the u.s. military has been in these fights before. i mean, you know, we have specialized units within the military that deal with some of these outbreaks, whether its at ft. detrick at the operations there. certainly the cdc which is very apt at dealing with these, along with marine units, have done deaccontaminations in the past. and so, you know, you have general williams out there with his troops working on developing a hospital, setting that up. i'm sure they'll have deac decontamination areas. they know how to handle that. is this a little more serious than they have had in the past? absolutely. but, you know, how often do you have pandemics that cause these
3:16 pm
types of problems? >> there's been so much alarm today because we now know of the first u.s. transmission of the ebola virus involving a health care worker in the u.s. who was wearing all the protective clothing and was going, you know, following through on protocols. so are you confident that these military men and women are getting the resources that they need and are prepared adequately to do the job there? >> oh, absolutely. you know, if you -- as dr. fredon said many times in his interviews from the cdc, you know, when you follow the protocol, then you're going to be okay. if you breach the protocol, which means you probably didn't deacon tcontaminate properly wh means there's probably some fluid on maybe gloves or maybe on the gowns that did not become sterilized, and haven't been disposed of properly, that could lead to a breach in protocol. so, you know, we'll know more about that as they go through their investigation, but if you follow those protocols, and by
3:17 pm
the way, the cdc protocols are followed by everybody over the world. and so if you decide not to follow them, then you could likely have an infection and a contamination break out as probably has happened in this case. so it's absolutely essential for people to follow those rules because it will keep them safe. >> in your opinion, is the u.s. military there in west africa because this is a humanitarian crisis or because it's a threat to america? >> i think it's both. i mean, look, you know, you just can't allow humans to just die at will because of something that may be endemic to their area, when we have the capability to do something about it. but at the same time, it's about protecting america as much as it's about protecting the rest of the world. you know, let me use an example, you know, we were discussing the last couple of days here in
3:18 pm
dallas about should the dallas-ft. worth airport be part of the screening process? i would say, absolutely, because if i was flying from monrovia and i stop in dubai, for example, i can take a direct flight from dubai to dallas through the emirates flight. we have direct flights there every day. so i would say any port of entry, any transfer point that comes from africa, and there's a transfer point, there ought to be screenings. so i'm in agreement that some of our airports should probably be on there that are not on there now, but this is the debate for the health care workers and politicians to sort out. >> we really appreciate wrr thoughts. thanks for spending the time with me, general james williams. >> thank you. >> we appreciate it. coming up, your questions about the ebola outbreak, like, how do we know the virus isn't airborne? that's coming up. and then isis militants are closing in on baghdad. could iraq's capital fall into
3:19 pm
their hands? would we swoop in to save iraq's government? introducing dance-all-you-want bladder leak protection from the experts in feminine protection. new always discreet underwear, for sensitive bladders. only always discreet underwear has soft, dual leakguard barriers, to help stop leaks where they happen most. plus a discreet fit that hugs your curves. you barely feel it. new always discreet. now bladder leaks can feel like no big deal. because hey, pee happens. visit for coupons and your free sample.
3:20 pm
3:21 pm
3:22 pm
we've spent a lot of time talking today about the spread of ebola and latest case involving a nurse in texas. let's bring back my panel to help answer some of your questions. dr. jorge rodriguez, and dr. alexander garza. our first question is from a viewer who asks, there are several strains of the ebola virus. can mutations cause them to spread differently? dr. rodriguez, you want to take that one? >> well, mutations affect viruses in many difshferent way. a mutation can as easily make a virus less dangerous as it can a little bit more dangerous. so, we do know that there are many different types of strains of viruses, and some actually are much more dangerous than others. this one is -- has a morality of 50%. there's another type that has mortality of 90%. the answer to the question is yes, and we don't exactly know how that is going to be affected
3:23 pm
by mutations. >> and kathy also asks, is there proof that ebola is not airborne? and i think that is a question so many people want to know because it's spreading seemingly so rapidly. what do you say? >> well, it's important to understand a disease can spread rapidly even if it's not airborne. and in liberia, that's essentially what you're dealing with, a situation where you don't have enough health care workers, supplies and so on. in terms of whether there's proof of it not being airborne, there have been a number of studies looking at this issue, and it does not appear to be airborne, however, droplets of saliva, nasal secretions and so on, if you're in very close contact with those secretions, those could transmit. for example, if i sneezed on you, ana, and i had ebola, that could potentially transmit. >> or if somebody coughed or if there was fluid of some sort that came out that way. >> exactly. >> dr. garza, another asks, if
3:24 pm
health care workers did not break protocol, does this mean the virus is more easily spread than previously thought? >> yeah, and that's a good question. there's been some attention to this in the media. as far as we know, it's not easier -- more easier spread than we thought of before. but i think really the important point to focus on is following really strict protocol, and as was mentioned in the last hour, a devotion to training to make sure that people understand the protocols and have that educational support. >> is this just media hype, or is this as serious as it seems to be? dr. garza, you want to start with that one? >> sure. i think it's a little bit of both. and so any time we're confronted with something that is unusual, and something that is lethal, i think it's always going to be, you know, a little bit anxiety provoking in the american public. we've seen it before with h1n1.
3:25 pm
we saw it before with the fukushima disaster and radioactive material. it's not unexpected for the public to become very concerned with this and that's where your communications piece comes in. it's very critical so people understand the risks and common sense things and what they can do to protect themselves. >> i want to ask a question from rachel who tweets, are recovered patients still potentially contagious? dr. rodriguez? >> by in large, patients that have recovered from ebola are not that contagious. however, there are studies that have shown that you can find ebola, for example, in semen up to sometimes 90 days after someone has convalesced so there is a special for spread but a much lower degree than when a patient is very, very sick. >> a lot of people are asking this next question. how long does the ebola virus live on surfaces? say, protective gear, airplanes, bathrooms? what do you know about that, dr.
3:26 pm
gounder? >> right, so it has been shown that ebola can live on surfaces in ideal conditions, so that means cold temperature, in the dark, moist, humid conditions, for up to six days. however, that's not the typical hospital room. you're at room temperature with light. you know, bodily fluids will dry out. so you're really not looking at six days that ebola would be living on a hospital bed rail or counter. >> so that would be the longest duration. >> precisely. >> that's possible, but not likely. >> right. >> also, we've heard about pets being involved in cases. in spain, there was a dog that was euthanized. we now know there's a pet involved in this dallas case, too. and we don't know yet what's going to become of that dog or cat, whatever the pet is. what do we know about the transmission from animals to people, and vice versa, and beyond animals, technically, what about insects?
3:27 pm
dr. garza? >> right, so most of the studies on ebola have shown a couple of mammals act as reservoirs or actively have the disease. and of those, they're usually nonhuman primates. chimpanzees, monkeys, over in africa, as well as the fruit bat over in africa which is why the disease is mostly constrained to that typical area. now, there has been anecdotal and some case reports of founding antibodies to the virus in other animals such as dogs, but there's been no documented case of transmission of disease from these animals. >> here we are in the u.s. now seeing more ebola cases. dr. gounder, can a different climate cause the disease, the virus to adapt or mutate in some way? >> well, the climate that causes that kind of mutation is essentially the human immune system which puts pressure on the virus to mutate. for example, the seasonal flu. we need to get a flu shot every year because our immune systems react to the flu and select for
3:28 pm
flu viruses that will evade our immune system. so that's one important piece of the climate question. the other pieces are if you have drugs that are effective or vaccines that are effective, those could also start to select for ebola strains that could evade those approaches to treatment and prevention. >> dr. gounder, dr. garza, dr. rodriguez. thank you. great answers. great information. >> you're welcome. baghdad is under iraqi control. for now. will it stay the they way? we're looking at questions for the week ahead regarding isis. a big one, could isis take the iraqi capital? that's coming up. ncial tomorrows a reality for over 19 million people. [ susan ] my promotion allowed me to start investing for my retirement. transamerica made it easy. [ female announcer ] everyone has a moment when tomorrow becomes real. transamerica. transform tomorrow.
3:29 pm
3:30 pm
3:31 pm
it's a fresh approach on education-- superintendent of public instruction tom torlakson's blueprint for great schools. torlakson's blueprint outlines how investing in our schools will reduce class sizes, bring back music and art, and provide a well-rounded education. and torlakson's plan calls for more parental involvement. spending decisions about our education dollars should be made by parents and teachers, not by politicians.
3:32 pm
tell tom torlakson to keep fighting for a plan that invests in our public schools. welcome back. i'm ana cabrera. this hour we're fast forwarding to the week ahead and shifting gears just a little bit now to a deadlier threat than ebola. isis. bloodthirsty, ruthless, creeping closer to bpgd thataghdad. that's coming u. at the top on the next hour, what happened to a missing airliner? watch "vanished: the mystery of malaysia airlines flight 370", that's coming up at 7:00 eastern. okay. we're going to talk about the fight against isis now and address the questions you'll be asking in the coming days. question number one, will the city of baghdad fall to these
3:33 pm
islamic militant? look at this map. and that line of isis-controlled areas. it starts in syria. cuts through iraq's anbar province now and is aimed right at the capital. u.s. defense secretary chuck hagel says flat-out iraqi troops are fully in control of baghdad. we've got to ask for how long? question number two, president obama has already admitted to down playing isis calling them the jv team at one point, but is the u.s. still underestimating the threat these militants really pose? question number three, if the u.s. keeps dropping bombs and isis keeps advancing, taking more cities, maybe even baghdad, what will the u.s. do? here we go. the first question is about baghdad. isis militants, just a few miles from the airport and the city limits. so far, they've run pretty much roughshod over everywhere they've wanted to go. cnn military analyst retired lieutenant colonel rick francona is here. also with me retired marine corps major general james
3:34 pm
williams who commanded troops in iraq and afghanistan. colonel francona, yes or no, is baghdad in trouble? >> baghdad is in trouble but it's not ready to fall. there are going to be continued truck bombings, car bombings, suicide bombings. there will be indirect fire into the green zone, mortar fire, artillery fire, and there will be a threat to the airport, but the actual city, itself, i don't think it's in danger of falling, it's just too big for isis to take on right now. >> general womilliams, you've operated all over baghdad. the chairman of the joint chiefs of staff today said apache helicopter launched from the airport pushed isis fighters back from the airport but the airport apparently was threatened at some point. tell us how risky this is, how vulnerable the airport is and how difficult it is to defend the city of baghdad? >> i think if isis isolates the a airport and have any success at controlling any of the flights that come in and out, because that's where all the commercial
3:35 pm
flights come into, that could pose a great danger. you know, as colonel francona said, they may not be able to take all of baghdad, but they only need to take strategic positions in baghdad. the airport is one of them. and so even though the u.s. forces may be defending there, the question is, do we have enough to defend the airport and hold off their advance? >> your response? >> yeah, that's a really key point. the general talks about, do we have enough force there? what we've seen is isis is very adept at marshaling the force where they need them, when they need them. people say, they have 30,000 troops, how could they defend themselves against 200,000 man iraqi security forces? it's because the iraqis are spread out everywhere. isis only has to bring their forces where they need them. if they bring enough force down and go after the airport, it's going to put that airport at risk. i think there are about 200 american troops there plus apache helicopters, but that's
3:36 pm
not enough to defend it. >> colonel francona, we were talking earlier and you mentioned that isis has taken over kobani almost, taken over anbar province. it's really finding a way to really forcefully come in and take some pretty big areas. are we still talking about 30,000 fighters? >> it's hard to know what the numbers really are, but it's kind of amazing to watch this because they're controlling forces that are 400 miles apart. this is an organization we thought was a rag tag asymmetric warfare group but we're seeing effecti effective command and control. >> general williams, what are your thoughts if isis does indeed come in and get to the airport? how big of a blow is that going to be in the fight against isis? >> i think that's going to be certainly a psychological blow. it's also an operational and tactical blow because, for example, if you're in a big jumbo jet trying to land at baghdad international, and
3:37 pm
somebody has a surface-to-air missile, you know, they could certainly create great havoc. and if they do that, you know, no airline is going to fly in there and it's basically only going to be military personnel trying to defend that air field and trying to give order to chaos there. but i think we have a real decision here, and i think it rests in washington, d.c., and i think i can -- knowing general dempsey, i can sort of hear his tension in his voice in terms of what is the next thing that he really needs to do? and he may be feeling that he's handcuffed by the president and the national security council from doing what he really needs to do as the military commander. >> do you think boots on the ground, u.s. boots would be inevitable? >> well, i have advocated for that from the beginning of our discussion some weeks ago, and, you know, i think any general
3:38 pm
worth their salt in washington, d.c., or anywhere around the world would not take that option off the table because it gives them no flexibility. by saying you're not going to do that, i think it's given isis the license to run all over iraq. and i think that's exactly what they're doing. >> last word. >> perfect, i mean, that's exactly right. by taking it off the table, you've told isis that there's a capability they're not going to have to address. so it gives them a much freer hand in doing what they're doing. they know they're going to fight the iraqis and know that they've got much greater capability than they're going to need if they had to face us. >> colonel francona, general james williams, thanks so much. now, every white house tries to spin the news, as we know, but when are aides crossing the line? playing down the threat from ebola, to isis, saying baghdad is under control, or there's no risk from ebola? are officials misleading us? we'll look at whether we can take them at their word, coming
3:39 pm
up. think beat con men at their own game when you think aarp, you don't know "aarp." the aarp fraud watch network helps everyone protect themselves and their families against scams and identity theft. find more real possibilities at whenwork with equity experts who work with regional experts that's when expertise happens. mfs. because there is no expertise without collaboration.
3:40 pm
(receptionist) gunderman group is growing. getting in a groove. growth is gratifying. goal is to grow. gotta get greater growth. i just talked to ups. they got expert advise, special discounts, new technologies. like smart pick ups. they'll only show up when you print a label and it's automatic. we save time and money. time? money? time and money. awesome. awesome! awesome! awesome! awesome! (all) awesome! i love logistics.
3:41 pm
fifteen percent or more fifon car insurance.d save you everybody knows that. well, did you know certain cartoon characters should never have an energy drink? action! blah-becht-blah- blublublub-blah!!! geico®. introducing the birds of america collection. fifty stunning, hand-painted plates, commemorating the state birds of our proud nation. blah-becht-blah- blublublub-blah!!! geico®. fifteen minutes could save you fifteen percent or more on car insurance. faster than d-con. what will we do with all of these dead mice? tomcat presents dead mouse theatre. hey, ulfrik! hey, agnar! what's up with you? funny you ask. i'm actually here to pillage your town. [ villagers screaming ] but we went to summer camp together. summer camp is over. ♪ [ male announcer ] tomcat. [ cat meows ] [ male announcer ] engineered to kill.
3:42 pm
the u.s.-led coalition unleashing more air strikes on isis targets. nine of them this weekend, alone alone. isis is advancing. tightening its grip on anbar province. we learned from chairman martin dempsey that isis almost reached baghdad airport, so apache helicopters had to be brought in to protect it. the white house insists iraqi forces can defend the iraqi
3:43 pm
capital. david gergen, cnn senior political analyst, is joining me now. david, is the white house, do you think, so determined to put out fires politically, that they may be misleading the american public about the real threat of isis? >> i think that they have had a record of underestimating isis for a long time. right back from the beginning when, you know, the president called it a jv team. you know, and i'm sure he did that thinking that he was right and that's what the intelligence showed, but it was faulty intelligence. it's rooted way back in the failure to leave forces there which we could have anticipated more of this had we left moderate forces there. i don't think the white house is intentionally misleading the country, but i do think they put a gloss on it at times which sounds more like cheerleading than it does like, you know, just tell us the facts and we can figure it out. isis is clearly a much more dangerous threat to the stability of iraq, you know, to be so close to the baghdad
3:44 pm
airport indicates how vulnerable it continues to be. and we've got the situation in syria which is even more, i think -- it's more concerning, more distressing. i think what -- i think the message has been from the administration and isis that the bombing cannot defeat isis, it cannot destroy isis, but it can contain isis. what we have now seen is isis is not contained by the bombing. it's continuing to advance in northern syria, around baghdad and places around ramadi in iraq. >> right. >> i think they've got to be very, very careful to be straight with the country from now on out because this can be a long, drawn-out process and if people lose faith in what they're hearing just about what we did about body bags in vietnam years and years ago, then support first operation will just collapse. >> the president certainly doesn't seem to be garnering any
3:45 pm
fans. obama's strategy on isis ripped by not one, but two of his former defense secretaries leon panetta this week, robert gates previously. even jimmy carter got his claws out on this policy this week. of course, these are all pretty big players. what do you make of this criticism? >> well, the white house naturally has been very concerned, upset, angry about the criticisms coming from people who work for the president, coming at a time when he's still in office. so they've lashed back, and that's raised questions of whether it was appropriate for secretary gates, panetta, and others to criticize this way. i think that's a -- i think that's the wrong show. it's a sideshow. that's not the real issue here. the serious message is in these books, and what we ought to be thinking about is whether, in fact, as all of these people say, the same theme emerges from all these books. there's too much power centralized in the white house
3:46 pm
on these national security issues. the departments and agencies which have a lot of personnel, a lot of experts, and are normally brought in have been too marginalized. and furthermore, that some of the decisions seem to have gone through a political lens, or being seen through a political lens in the white house about what it does for re-election before the recent elections, president s presidential elections and what it might do to the president's popularity. that's very distressing. it does seem to me there are messages in these books that the president should take to heart. these are people who wish him well, basically, you know, gates and panetta. they write other things about him that are are very positive. i think he'll take that message to heart, and there are now stories coming out about the president may want to shake up his team after the midterm elections. i think he needs to consider that. whether he needs some fresh blood and, but i think particularly the issue is, is john kerry and his team at the state department sufficiently
3:47 pm
empowered to carry out their work? chuck hagel, defense secretary and his team, especially the joint chiefs and the military, are their sufficiently empowered? or is everything decided at the white house? that's a mistake. the white house needs to decide policy, but it's up to the departments and agencies to execute the policy under white house supervision. >> we'll have to leave it there. david gergen, thanks for your time and your insight. still ahead, we are learning new information about new ebola cases here in the u.s. we have the one in dallas and now reports of other potential ebola cases. we have new information when we come back. ♪ want to change the world? create things that help people. design safer cars. faster computers. smarter grids and smarter phones.
3:48 pm
think up new ways to produce energy. ♪ be an engineer. solve problems the world needs solved. what are you waiting for? changing the world is part of the job description. [ male announcer ] join the scientists and engineers of exxonmobil in inspiring america's future engineers. energy lives here.
3:49 pm
3:50 pm
having a perfectly nice day, when out of nowhere a pick-up truck slams into your brand new car. one second it wasn't there and the next second... boom! you've had your first accident. now you have to make your first claim. so you talk to your insurance company and... boom! you're blindsided for a second time. they won't give you enough money to replace your brand new car. don't those people know you're already shaken up? liberty mutual's new car replacement will pay for the entire value of your car plus depreciation. call and for drivers with accident forgiveness, liberty mutual won't raise your rates due to your first accident. switch to liberty mutual insurance and you could save up to $423 dollars. call liberty mutual for a free quote today at see car insurance in a whole new light. liberty mutual insurance.
3:51 pm
we mentioned earlearlier, a possible ebola case in suburban boston. a person recently back from liberia, exhibiting symptoms raising more concerns about whether the case in dallas isn't the only one in the u.s. right now. here's more from our affiliate wcvb. >> reporter: a frightening scene at the harvard vanguard medical associations after a patient who traveled to liberia arrived with a headache and muscle aches. the chief of infectious disease said out of an abundance of caution we notified authorities and moved the patient out of the building. that patient was taken to beth israel deaconist medical center in boston. the rest of the patients were told to stay in place in the facility for hours. this seven month pregnant woman
3:52 pm
finally decided to leave. >> we didn't get to wash our hands, didn't get to do anything. no one has told us what to do. they said, take a shower and check your temperature for the next 21 days. >> reporter: the patient of concern's suv was towed from the parking lot with orange biohazard stickers all over it. >> so we don't know just yet whether this is a confirmed case of ebola. they're working to confirm aye or nay. i want to bring in dr. celine gounder. we talked of the case in dallas, we know of the photographer in nebraska still being treated. ebola cases popped up all over the place. the pregnant woman is going to have to monitor herself for the next 21 days. >> it's important to remember as long as the epidemic is out of control in west africa, we are going to see more exported cases here in the u.s., and if we really want to deal with this, we have to go to the root of the problem. in terms of the response no
3:53 pm
boston, this is how things should work. we have a high index of suspicion. somebody comes in with symptoms, has a travel history, we get that information and act on it right away and seems to have happened in this case in contrast to what happened in dallas. >> we know this man was in liberia, and so that, again, brings up the question of why not cut out the flights to and from those countries in west africa that are affected? but a lot of medical experts say that won't solve the problem. >> a travel ban will not solve the problem. that's for a number of reasons. we're already having problems getting doctors, nurses and other aid workers into liberia to address the problem. you have to deal with the root of the problem. in addition, when you do something like instituting a travel ban, you reduce transparency, drive people underground. if someone wants to come over to the u.s., they will. this will just make it harder to detect those people and they'll be more afraid to come forward for medical services if they do develop symptoms. when we heard the press conference this morning with the
3:54 pm
cdc about this new case in dallas, you mentioned getting to the root of the problem. and we heard from the cdc director say the key to preventing further spread is to break the links, the chains of transmission and that requires properly diagnosed cases, isolation, identify the contact, actively monitor contacts for symptoms for up to 21 days. why not quarantine those potential contacts? i mean, in this case, the woman in dallas who now has ebola wasn't quarantined. >> now, remember, for one thing, we don't know if she's had direct contact with this suspected case. in addition, you're not infectious to other people until you have symptoms. so that's why if you can trust somebody to monitor their temperature and for other symptoms for 21 days, that can be safely done. >> dr. celine gounder, thanks so much for the information. >> my pleasure. >> we'll be right back. of the we gar and now angie's list
3:55 pm
is revolutionizing local service again. you can easily buy and schedule services from top-rated providers. conveniently stay up to date on progress. and effortlessly turn your photos into finished projects with our snapfix app. visit today. ♪ for over 19 million people. [ susan ] my promotion allowed me to start investing for my retirement. transamerica made it easy.
3:56 pm
[ female announcer ] everyone has a moment when tomorrow becomes real. transamerica. transform tomorrow. transamerica. i take prilosec otc each morning for my frequent heartburn. because it gives me... zero heartburn! prilosec otc. the number 1 doctor-recommended frequent heartburn medicine for 9 straight years. one pill each morning. 24 hours. zero heartburn.
3:57 pm
[light instrumental music] ♪ female announcer: recycle your old fridge and get $50. schedule your free pickup at:
3:58 pm
now, just a quick check of the headlines. a breach in protocol is believed to be the reason for the first known transmission of the ebola virus on u.s. soil. that victim, a nurse, who had extensive contact on multiple occasions with ebola victim thomas duncan before he died. the nurse, a woman, is said to be in stable condition. this as cnn now confirms doctors in boston are assessing a patient there with ebola-like symptoms. this patient had recently been to liberia. he went to a hospital complaining of a headache and
3:59 pm
muscle aches. we'll have details as we get them. oscar pistorius heads back to court in south africa on monday. the disgraced olympic track star will find out his fate of being convinced of culpable -- excuse me, convicted of culpable hz in the death of his girlfriend reeva steenkamp. he could be sentenced up to 15 years in jail or serve no time at all. personal belongings from the plane shot down over ukraine will soon be recovered and returned to the netherlands. a dutch government spokesman tells cnn ukrainian emergency services is allowed axis to the mh-17 crash site and crews will gather belongings from the site and local residents who have been storing some of them. the search for malaysia airlines flight 370 goes on. "vanished: the mystery of malaysia airlines flight 370" tonight on cnn. also tonight, a new anthony bourdain, visiting paraguay and
4:00 pm
unraveling a family mystery. that's coming up at 9:00 p.m. at 10:00 p.m., meet t"this e with lisa ling." stay with cnn and for news any time. thanks for joining me. i'm ana cabrera. the following is a cnn special report. it's one of the greatest mysteries of all-time. >> nobody expects a 7 77 to vanish. it doesn't happen. >> the state of the art aircraft with 239 people on board. disappeared without a trace. >> all communications are suddenly disabled. switched off. >> 370. >> how could it happen? >> you have a serious of events that appear to be human driven. >> 370. >> mistakes? >> everything went wrong there. it borders