Skip to main content

tv   CNN Special Report  CNN  March 28, 2015 8:00pm-9:01pm PDT

8:00 pm
part of the dust of history. but its lesson should not be forgotten. i'm soledad o'brien reporting from what was once jonestown in guyana, south america. the will following is a cnn special report. first bike ride ever. >> exactly five years ago, the mcstay family mysteriously vanished. >> 10:39 a.m. that morning i spoke to julie on the phone. everything was fine. >> immediately, i felt like something terrible happened to them. >> 9-1-1 emergency. >> with few clues, no answers, the case grown cold until the mystery turned out to be murder. >> it's everything that we know, that they were brutally murdered. >> a year ago, we talked
8:01 pm
exclusively to chase merritt. then a concerned mcstay family friend. >> joseph was my best friend. he was incredible. >> now charged with killing them all. >> this is a cold and callous murder of an entire family. >> follow our investigation, the evidence, the arrest, the accused. >> i have a past. >> in his own words. >> you were the last person he saw? >> i was definitely the last person he saw. >> chasing a killer. inside the mcstay family murders. ♪ ♪ sunny southern california. the beaches, the surf, the stunning pacific sunsets. >> yep, another beautiful day in paradise. southern california.
8:02 pm
>> there's mama again. >> a magical place to many including newlyweds joseph and summer mcstay who called this beach side community home. >> we live down by the pier. paradise. >> in 2007, the mcstays and their two young sons, giani and joey jr. appear to have it all. >> i'm having so much fun. >> love, family, and a promising new business. >> it's all julie ever wanted to be, an entrepreneur and work for himself. >> a dream that became a reality said his father, patrick, while joseph got the idea while running a gift shop. >> he called me one day and he said, dad, i'm selling these fountains for $224 a piece. he said, dad, i can do better. okay, $224, how much it cost you to make it?
8:03 pm
he said, $22. i said, you're kidding me. he said, i'm going to start making them in the garage, dad. he did. he sold 30 a month and it just took off from there. he's like, check this out. maybe we should try to build a site for these water fountains. >> dan cavanaugh built a website for what became joseph's new waterfall company, earth inspired products, or eip. >> what was originally a tiny start-up operation making nothing was eventually a successful online business. >> so successful, online orders began pouring in. >> i was his customer sales rep. >> gina watson worked for water -- for a waterfall manufacturer in florida. >> anytime he needed a real fancy custom job done or, you know, quote request for one, we'd work together on it, so i got to know him throughout the years. >> tell me what you thought of him. what was he like? >> well, personally, very nice guy.
8:04 pm
very generous. really not easy to anger and professionally, very, very good with customers. knew his stuff. >> joseph also knew how to spot talent and he believed he'd found it in welder chase merritt. >> joseph owned his own business. and i owned mine. i manufactured custom indoor waterfalls and he bought the waterfalls from me. >> this waterfall, i'm under the understanding that you're going to have a designated switch. >> we were anticipating probably $1.5 million in sales for 2010 >> while they met through business, the two quickly became close friends. >> we talked constantly. we played paint ball together all the time. he came down and had dinner with me and my family once or twice a week, virtually every week. joseph was my best friend. >> how was he to work with? >> oh, man.
8:05 pm
he was incredible. joseph was probably one of the nicest people i have ever met. he'd give you the shirt off his back. he was just a nice guy. >> so nice, joseph soon began lending chase money. when chase started having trouble making ends meet. >> they had an excel spread sheet and it maintained the balance of what chase owed joe and chase said i need three more grand for rent, and joe's like, you haven't finished the fountain yet. don't worry, lone me three gs and the next fountain, take it out of that. over 20 grand. and it was just this like rolling ledger. >> chase told us that rolling ledger was never a problem between him and joseph, but gina disagrees. >> joseph would take the hit if they had a chargeback or if somebody wasn't happy with the work. he'd already paid chase his part
8:06 pm
of it. so when the chargeback came through the account, it only hurt joseph. i think totalled about $100,000 worth of mistakes chase owed him for. >> while chase insists his debt was never that high, gina grew so concerned, she warned joseph that chase was bad news. >> i did raise concerns about chase that he would use materials that were cheaper or sometimes he would leave somebody high and dry without the fountain or without fixing it. and joseph really felt he could control that aspect of chase. he didn't seem to have any concerns at the time. >> no, he kind of blew me off. >> joseph's wife summer was no fan of chase's either. >> i know he wasn't fond of her and she wasn't fond of him. >> joseph loved her to death. you know, he thought she walked on water. honestly, i thought she was egotistical. i thought she thought her --
8:07 pm
didn't stink and joseph could do better. >> but joseph and summer were committed to building a life together with their two boys, and that meant moving out of their cramped apartment. >> they had been looking for houses for several years. >> thanksgiving weekend 2009, the mcstays finally purchased a new home outside san diego in fallbrook, california. chase merritt helped them move in. >> is this the house? >> with a brand new home and a booming new business, 2010 looked to be a promising new year for the mcstays. until suddenly the unimaginable happened. february 4th, 2010, the entire mcstay family vanished. >> i just knew. something told me i wasn't going to see him again.
8:08 pm
>> up next, what happened the day the mcstays disappeared. you were the last person he saw? >> i'm definitely the last person he saw. with no harsh fumes. if you want a paint without harmful chemicals. if you want a paint that's safer for your family, and the environment... only this can. natura from benjamin moore. paint like no other.
8:09 pm
(mom) when our little girl was we got a subaru. it's where she said her first word. (little girl) no! saw her first day of school. (little girl) bye bye! made a best friend forever. the back seat of my subaru is where she grew up. what? (announcer) the 2015 subaru forester (girl) what? (announcer) built to be there for your family. love. it's what makes a subaru, a subaru. he could install your your bceiling fan.e said he couldn't. and that one time ron said another chili dog was a good idea. yeah, it wasn't. so when ron said you'd never afford a john deere tractor, you knew better. now ron does too. introducing the e series. legendary john deere quality. unexpected low price. see your john deere dealer for great deere season savings
8:10 pm
on the e series family of tractors. now? can i at least put my shoes on? if your bladder is calling the shots ... you may have a medical condition called overactive bladder ... ...or oab you've got to be kidding me. i've had enough! it's time to talk to the doctor. ask your doctor how myrbetriq may help treat... ...oab symptoms of urgency, frequency, and leakage. which may mean fewer trips to the bathroom. myrbetriq (mirabegron) may increase your blood pressure. myrbetriq may increase your chances... ...of not being able to empty your bladder. tell your doctor right away if you have... ...trouble emptying your bladder or have a weak urine stream. myrbetriq may affect... ...or be affected by other medications... tell your doctor about all the medicines you take.
8:11 pm
before taking myrbetriq, tell your doctor if you have liver or kidney problems. common side effects include increased blood pressure, common cold symptoms, urinary tract infection, and headache. take charge by talking to your doctor about your oab symptoms and myrbetriq. find out if you can get your first prescription at no cost by visiting february 4th, 2010. when the sun rose on the mcstays' dream home, no one knew the nightmare that lay ahead. summer, a stay at home mom, was taking care of the kids. while joseph was taking care of business. >> customer service department and shipping had gotten a call from him on february 4th.
8:12 pm
just checking on an order. >> the morning of the 4th, i spoke to joey on the phone. >> he didn't let on anything was wrong? >> no, everything was fine. >> in fact, better than fine. joseph had just received a big paycheck for a fountain. $16,000. >> he was going to go to the bank and deposit a check. there was a branch of the bank right there on rancho cucamonga. >> we got together. we had a lot to talk about. >> chase merritt met joseph for lunch at chick-fil-a. >> we discussed, you know, more business that was going to be going on throughout the year. >> so he sounded like he was planning for the future. >> he was definitely planning for the future. >> it was the last known place joseph mcstay went that day. and chase merritt is certain he was the last person to see him.
8:13 pm
>> i'm definitely the last person he saw. >> what time did joey leave lunch? >> exactly what time, i don't remember. i mean, i wish i did, but it was just, you know, fairly blurry. >> chase does remember the handful of calls he said he had with joseph after that lunch. the last call came at 8:28 p.m., according to joseph's cell phone records. >> i don't personally remember that phone call. the fact is, i actually had to ask my girlfriend and she said, yeah. you picked it up and looked at it and decided not to answer it. >> have you thought about or speculated what it might have been, was he in trouble? >> and that's why it's a regret because there's a hundred different scenarios that could have been. >> chase says he tried to reach joseph the next morning.
8:14 pm
>> i had left a few messages and then the voicemail ended up being full. that's when i got really concerned. >> 1500 miles away in houston, patrick mcstay was frantic. he usually spoke to his son every day. >> i'm worried, what happened, is somebody hurt? did they go on a trip? >> six days would pass with no sign of the mcstays and then on february 10th, chase merritt said he went to check their home for the first time. >> he wasn't there. his truck was in the driveway. dogs were in the backyard with no food, no water. i walked around the house. i didn't see anything suspicious. >> did it surprise you that the dogs were outside? >> very much so. so much so that i called susan,
8:15 pm
joseph's mother, and told her, there's something amiss. >> i side, go down, if the dogs are there, move the dog bowls, the food and the water, and then we can see if they hired someone to feed the animals. well, then go back two days later and could tell the bowls were moved, obviously fed. so this is why we thought they were out of town. >> finally, eight days after anyone had heard from joseph, michael mcstay went to his brother's house with chase. who knew exactly how to get inside the locked home. >> joey had pretty serious allergies so he always kept his window open, always. >> they found a mess, rotten food on the counter. popcorn on the futon. clothes tossed all over the place. >> i don't remember a great deal
8:16 pm
of it because i was in the house for maybe three minutes, i think. not very long. i told michael at the time, you should probably call the sheriff's department. his response was simply, you know what? let's wait until the end of the weekend. >> san diego's sheriff, they have a rule anyway. after 10 days, it's automatically, they send out homicide. >> could you have reported them missing and gotten police action before the ten days? >> i don't know. i don't know. maybe. >> it would take until monday, february 15th, 11 days after the family went missing for michael to call the sheriff's department. investigators came to the house. immediately alerted homicide. but chose not to seal off the scene. >> they don't put any tape, crime scene tape, nothing, just locked the house back up and leave to get warrants.
8:17 pm
>> you've got a family that's missing for a week and they're still not going to call it a crime scene? it was mistakenly not a crime scene. >> this investigative journalist said he's never seen a case like this one. >> it took san diego investigators to get the warrants. three days where anyone could come and go. >> detectives just told me this is not a crime scene and i can do whatever i want. >> certain items that might have been really key to the big mystery of why they left the house are gone. touched, moved, cleaned up. it's ridiculous. >> clues and evidence disappeared from the house, just like the family of four who once called it home. coming up, the first break in this case comes in an unlikely place.
8:18 pm
60 miles south of the mcstay home. well, when you have copd, it can be hard to breathe. it can be hard to get air out, which can make it hard to get air in. so i talked to my doctor. she said... doctor: symbicort could help you breathe better, starting within 5 minutes. symbicort doesn't replace a rescue inhaler for sudden symptoms. symbicort helps provide significant improvement of your lung function. symbicort is for copd, including chronic bronchitis and emphysema. it should not be taken more than twice a day. symbicort contains formoterol. medicines like formoterol increase the risk of death from asthma problems. symbicort may increase your risk of lung infections, osteoporosis, and some eye problems. you should tell your doctor if you have a heart condition or high blood pressure before taking it. grandfather: symbicort could mean a day with better breathing. watch out, piggies! child giggles doctor: symbicort. breathe better starting within 5 minutes. call or go online to learn more about a free prescription offer.
8:19 pm
if you can't afford your medication, astrazeneca may be able to help. you know your dentures can try fixodent plus true feel. the smooth formula helps keep dentures in place. it's free of flavors and colorants, for a closer feeling to natural teeth. fixodent. and forget it.
8:20 pm
feduring sleep train's sundaytriple choice sale. to save big for a limited time, you can choose up to 48 months interest-free financing on a huge selection of tempur-pedic models. or choose to save hundreds on simmons beautyrest mattress sets. you can even choose $300 in free gifts with sleep train's most popular stearns & foster mattresses. the triple choice sale ends sunday at sleep train. ♪ sleep train your ticket to a better night's sleep ♪
8:21 pm
>> i know how this works. >> you're a master cappuccino maker. >> come here, mommy. >> after the mcstay family disappeared, their california house once filled with life now seemed frozen in time. a paper in the driveway, shoes by the front door.
8:22 pm
>> i feel bad i didn't notice anything. >> i'm shocked. i hope everything's okay. >> on february 8th, 60 miles south, police impounded a white isuzu trooper near the mexican border. >> it was towed from a parking lot abandoned. >> on the 15th, police realized the trooper belonged to the mcstays. >> there was nothing in that car to indicate that anything bad had happened. there was no blood splatter, no damage to the vehicle. >> and no indication why it was abandoned within walking distance of a border crossing. and then came evidence from a search of the mcstay home computer. >> somebody in the mcstay was searching on the computer for passports and traveling to mexico. >> in my mind, we shifted gears. okay, they're in cabo or they're in mexico? >> when san diego detectives focused their search on the mexico border, they found what seemed to be the biggest piece of evidence to date.
8:23 pm
>> tonight, where are the mcstays? >> authorities are poring over security tapes from border checkpoints. >> a grainy surveillance tape showed a family of four cross the border on february 8:00, around 7:00 p.m. the same day the car was impounded. investigators believed it could well have been the missing mcstay family. >> we had a strong reason to believe they had traveled to mexico. >> jan caldwell is the spokesperson for the san diego sheriff's department. >> we had the guy in mexico who thought he served them. somebody brought them cocktails and we did have sightings. >> while detectives pursued that theory, those who knew the mcstays insisted they were wrong. >> joseph had a very distinct walk, number one. he walked like a duck. and the man walking across the border was walking normally. >> did it look like summer or the kids?
8:24 pm
>> i told the detectives i didn't believe it was them. >> you've got one camera angle of the family crossing the border but there's cameras all over the parking lots. how come not one camera down there picked them up anywhere walking in the parking lots or across to the border? come on now. >> fearful that the sheriff's department was putting all their eggs in the wrong basket, patrick teamed up with an old friend of joseph's. gina watson. >> it became, i would say almost an obsession of looking for information. >> they quickly became seasoned investigators, scouring the internet, tracking down leads. evidence that gina believed poked holes in the theory that the family voluntarily went to mexico. and there was more. >> like all of their craigs list purchases, if a family was planning to disappear, why were they buying so much on craig's list? countertops, microwaves, things
8:25 pm
for the new house, going on all the way up to the disappearance. >> and then there's this. >> hey, don't go anywhere >> they don't go anywhere without the double stroller. >> what would be the need to walk across the border, why not just bring your car, what would be the need to go at that time of night? >> did you ever believe they disappeared intentionally on their own? >> no. immediately i felt like something terrible happened to them. >> but what and by whom? >> what's up, dudes? >> early on, friend and business associate chase merritt was top of the list. >> detectives are taking a look at joseph mcstay's business relationships. >> he spoke to us in his only television interview. >> i was the last person who saw him, so of course i was a person of interest. >> did detectives ask you if you killed joseph mcstay and his family? >> i don't recall them asking me that. >> nothing that direct. >> huh? >> not that directly?
8:26 pm
>> no, i don't recall them being that direct. >> you took a polygraph test. what did it show? >> i don't know. >> you passed the polygraph? >> apparently. i kind of simply assumed. well, apparently, that resolved any issues they may be looking at with me. >> it didn't resolve anything for gina and patrick. they still had their eyes on chase. >> this was one of the first things that i had put together. just simple everything that i could gather on chase. this was about the point where they couldn't get ahold of him again. the police wanted to talk to him again and they couldn't. >> i had contact with him in may of 2010. and then he disappeared. >> when chase resurfaced months later, patrick made sure to stay in touch. >> i wanted to keep that contact with him. what's the old saying? keep your friends close, keep your enemies closer.
8:27 pm
>> patrick and gina kept digging. but for the san diego sheriff's department, the case had gone cold. >> it's almost impossible to work a case without information flowing in. >> no leads, no answers to what happened to this loving, happy family of four. but that changed on november 11, 2013. >> 9-1-1 emergency, what are you reporting? >> two shallow graves unearthed in the mojave desert. >> i found what looks like part of a human skull. >> through the use of dental records, we're able to identify the adult victims as summer and joseph mcstay. we believe the other two sets of remains are that of the boys, their sons. >> when we come back, this new crime scene brings them closer
8:28 pm
to finding a suspect. "ride away" (by roy orbison begins to play) ♪ i ride the highway... ♪ i'm going my way... ♪i leave a story untold... he just keeps sending more pictures... if you're a free-range chicken, you roam free. it's what you do. if you want to save fifteen percent or more on car insurance, you switch to geico. it's what you do. ♪ two wheels a turnin'...
8:29 pm
i take prilosec otc each morning for my frequent heartburn. because it gives me... zero heartburn! prilosec otc. the number 1 doctor-recommended frequent heartburn medicine for 9 straight years. one pill each morning. 24 hours. zero heartburn.
8:30 pm
feget up to 48 months thrinterest-free financingain, on tempur-pedic. save hundreds on beautyrest. or choose $300 in free gifts with stearns & foster. the triple choice sale ends sunday at sleep train.
8:31 pm
for four years, patrick mcstay knew only that his family had vanished.
8:32 pm
this is where they were finally found. >> i have to see it and experience it. >> seeing it, patrick says, is crucial to catching the killer. >> it's awfully hard to imagine somebody just out of nowhere pulling off the road and coming here and finding this. >> finding this place. >> just, yeah. >> do you think it was somebody who knew the area? >> i think they had to. >> it's not an area where we would generally patrol. it is somewhat remote. >> san bernardino sheriff john mcmahon took over the case and -- when the remains were found, and spoke only to cnn. >> it's somewhat unusual to find four bodies in two shallow graves right next to one another and this one is especially rare because it's a mother, father, and two children. >> these graves would be the key
8:33 pm
to reigniting the cold case and unraveling the mystery. san bernardino district attorney, michael ramos. >> that was a huge break because up until that time, there was really no evidence of a murder. >> now, there were more than 100 new pieces of evidence. like tire tracks nearby and clothing in the graves. >> you're going to look and pick up anything that's anywhere near the desert that could tie an individual to it, tie a vehicle to the location, perhaps a murder weapon. >> finding the remains and the new evidence meant learning the cause of death, blunt force trauma. >> they were brutally murdered. a horrible cold callous murder. i pray that the suffering wasn't prolonged.
8:34 pm
>> so you're saying there is a chance that they did suffer, just so i'm clear, even with a one-strike, blunt of force trauma? >> there is a chance, yes. >> because it would have taken some time to die? >> yes, yes. >> from the start, san bernardino detectives say they had their eyes on chase merritt. the same chase merritt who began working with joseph mcstay years before. >> hi, welcome to your how-to video of installing your new water feature. >> back then, chase merritt was widely known as a friendly and talented welder whose laid back cowboy demeanor earned the trust of many, including his new business associate, joseph mcstay. >> i remember my first conversation with joey about chase merritt and he said, dad, you got to meet chase. you'll like him. >> many people did. >> when you first met him
8:35 pm
though, what were your first impressions of him? >> extremely friendly. outgoing. >> this is where chase and i dug -- >> jerry smith, a recreational gold prospector met chase in august of 2014. he asked us not to use his real name for his protection. jerry met chase through his new career, gold mining. >> my wife and i purchased a machine called the dry washer and there was a broken part, so i contacted the manufacturer and the manufacturer got me in touch with chase. >> after chase fixed his gear, jerry and his wife went gold prospecting with chase a handful of times in the high desert. >> he said, i know those areas like the back of my hand. >> but jerry says the chase merritt who showed up the last time they met was noticeably different from the friendly cowboy he had come to know. >> well, we were standing there.
8:36 pm
chase says to me, you probably know who i am. and i refer back to him, well, i said, not really because we just met you four or five weeks ago. he said, well, have you ever heard of the mcstay family? >> the family of four vanishes. >> jerry remembered hearing about the mcstays on the news but had no clue chase had any connection to them. >> he said he was joey's best friend and his business partner. he didn't seem sad at all talking about it. he was almost kind of cold. he also went on to talk about his wife, summer, he called her an f-ing bitch a couple of times. more and more he talked about things that were going on between him and the mcstay family, the more uneasy i got. >> his unease grew even more
8:37 pm
when chase insisted they hike here, to an even more secluded area. >> what was your gut telling you that day? >> i was getting spooked. hair standing up on my body. >> jerry quickly hiked back to his wife, packed up his $10,000 worth of prospecting gear and headed out of the desert. the next day, jerry decided he needed to tell someone what had happened. >> i made contact with sheriff's department homicide. >> what was their response? >> his response to me was he appreciated us calling and said it helps us build a character of somebody. >> little did jerry know that authorities already believe that chase merritt murdered the mcstays. weeks later, they made the announcement. >> charles "chase" merritt was identified as the suspect for the death of joseph, summer, gianni, and joseph mcstay. >> up next, how investigators
8:38 pm
finally cracked the case. >> we knew where mr. merritt was on a daily basis for the last year. ♪ if you want a paint that's more than just easy to scrub. if you want a paint that actually repels dirt and grime. if you want a paint that stand's up to life's wear and tear... only this can. regal select from benjamin moore. paint like no other.
8:39 pm
nascar®, i'm kevin nealon, comedian. and i'm arnold palmer, professional golfer. know what we have in common? we talked to our doctors about treatment with xarelto®. me, when i had a blood clot in my leg that could have traveled to my lungs. that's why i took xarelto®, too. xarelto® is proven to treat and help reduce the risk of dvt and pe blood clots. i took xarelto® for afib... an irregular heartbeat that can lead to a stroke from a blood clot. xarelto® is proven to reduce the risk of stroke in people with afib, not caused by a heart valve problem. hey, well i'm glad we got together. for people with afib currently well managed on warfarin, there is limited information on how xarelto® and warfarin compare in reducing the risk of stroke. i tried warfarin before, but the blood testing routine and dietary restrictions had me off my game. tell me about it. let's see, golf clinic, or blood clinic?
8:40 pm
ooh, that's a tough one. not this time. not with xarelto®. anything else? i'll have another arnold palmer. ok. make mine a kevin nealon. really, brian? hey, safety first. like all blood thinners, don't stop taking xarelto® without talking to your doctor, as this may increase your risk of a blood clot or stroke. while taking xarelto® you may bruise more easily, and it may take longer for bleeding to stop. xarelto® may increase your risk of bleeding if you take certain medicines. xarelto® can cause serious bleeding, and in rare cases may be fatal. get help right away if you develop unexpected bleeding, unusual bruising, or tingling. if you have had spinal anesthesia while on xarelto® watch for back pain or any nerve or muscle-related signs or symptoms. do not take xarelto® if you have an artificial heart valve, or abnormal bleeding. tell your doctor before all planned medical or dental procedures. before starting xarelto® tell your doctor about any conditions such as kidney, liver, or bleeding problems. xarelto® has been prescribed more than 11 million times in the u.s. and that number's growing. like your guys' scores. with xarelto® there is no regular blood monitoring, and no known dietary restrictions.
8:41 pm
treatment with xarelto® was the right move for us. ask your doctor about xarelto®. you may be able to get up to 12 months at no cost.
8:42 pm
less than a year ago, i made a promise to the family that our department would do everything in our power to solve this case. charles merritt was arrested on wednesday, november 5th, without incident. >> nearly five years after the mcstays vanished, 57-year-old charles "chase" merritt was arrested and charged for brutally killing his friend, joseph mcstay, joseph's wife summer and their two little boys, gianni and joey jr. >> although we can never bring them back, i hope this provides some level of closure. >> a lot of people say it's like lifting a ton off your shoulders. no, to me, it was more like a boulder falling on me. >> patrick mcstay's heartbreak was made worse by the news because like his son, joseph, he
8:43 pm
once put his trust in chase merritt. >> i was fooled like a lot of people at first. when i first talked to chase on the phone and the first words out of chase's mouth was joey talks about you, about his dad all the time. >> but as the months passed with no sign of joseph or his family, he grew suspicious when patrick and gina watson began investigating, they learned that chase has a criminal record stretching back nearly 40 years. >> mr. merritt had some prior felony convictions, spent some time in state prison. >> but while chase's record shows no sign of violence, district attorney michael ramos says his past is very telling. >> it's not uncommon for somebody to take that step from a non-serious non-violent felony to one of the worst crimes that we know of, murder.
8:44 pm
>> patrick and gina also uncovered a disturbing inconsistency, about that last lunch with joseph. the day he disappeared. this is what chase told us in his only television interview back in january of 2014. >> at lunch that day, he disappeared, he didn't express anything that was concerning or anything that he was worried about? >> no, no. no, he seemed happy. >> but chase told patrick something else entirely different when the two spoke months earlier. gina kept notes about their conversation. this is what he said the lunch was about. they fought on february 4th at lunch but that he worked it out. joseph was mad that the fountain was damaged and they had gotten a large chargeback. joseph wanted it fixed or some
8:45 pm
of the money back. and chase had already spent the money. >> in fact, joseph had told his father that he had grown increasingly unhappy with chase's work. >> the last year, joey talked about the quality of the fountains had slipped. joey wasn't happy with that. >> blaming chase at that point. >> yes, absolutely. he was getting complaints. >> so many complaints, joseph was questioning if chase should be part of his business at all. >> joey discussed with me about getting another welder. >> cutting chase out? >> not virtually cutting him out. giving him some competition. >> that competition, patrick says, could explain if chase did it, why he killed an innocent family. >> i guess the bottom line to me is money. >> i can't tell you the motive at this point in time. >> could it be money? >> i will only say, as we know,
8:46 pm
they were business associates. >> but ramos will say his team of investigators were suspicious of chase since the mcstays' remains were first discovered. >> we knew where mr. merritt was on a daily basis for the last year. >> watching him closely? >> watching him closely. >> and the more they watched, the more red flags came up. >> we know there have been many inconsistencies, not only with the interviews with the sheriff's department in our criminal investigation, but with whatever he talked to. his story is all over the place. >> including his story about that last phone call from joseph's phone. the one chase told us he didn't answer. >> i don't personally remember that phone call. >> but that's not what chase told patrick. >> patrick asked what the last conversation was about, he said -- meaning 8:28 p.m., that last
8:47 pm
phone call, he said it was a quick summing up about their conversation at lunch, about a copper fountain that needed fixing. so he told you he answered that call and talked? >> this is where one of the inconsistencies. >> would you ever expect this is how it would end in the desert like that? >> in the desert? i had no clue. >> mr. merritt was very familiar with the high desert in my county. >> i asked chase about that during our phone conversation and how odd for him, he said, to have to find all those years later they were found seven minutes from his sister's home. so definitely red flag. >> and then there's the mcstay house in fallbrook. >> investigators believe these murders occurred at their residence in fallbrook. >> murders that experts believe would have left extensive blood spatter. >> no clues here, is there? >> no. >> chase merritt told us he had
8:48 pm
been to the house several times before it was sealed off. what does that tell you, anything? >> number one, we're sitting here, he had access. number two, if he was there after they went missing, he had plenty of opportunity to, hypothetically speaking, clean up. he had plenty of opportunity. >> and he had the opportunity to cast doubt away from himself. >> does it surprise you he would go to the house and be the one who showed such concern and alert them missing? >> no. we've always heard about individuals that go back to the scene of the crime. it's not something that is uncommon. it's also a form of defense in the future. >> but while authorities are confident they found their killer, for patrick mcstay, one nagging question remains unanswered.
8:49 pm
>> i mean, how he supposedly loved my son. the question is, why did he do this to him? why to two little boys? i mean, he could have been known as uncle chase. >> when we come back, the prosecution's case against chase merritt. >> if this does go to trial, will you go? >> oh, absolutely. i want to look merritt in the face. saw her first day of school. (little girl) bye bye! made a best friend forever. the back seat of my subaru is where she grew up. what? (announcer) the 2015 subaru forester (girl) what? (announcer) built to be there for your family. love. it's what makes a subaru, a subaru.
8:50 pm
8:51 pm
8:52 pm
8:53 pm
this morning a major break in the case of the mcstay family. >> four murder charges against charles ray -- >> they are calling him a cold blooded and callous killer. >> killing a california family and burying their bodies in the desert. >> he is eligible for the death penalty. >> november 12th, 2014, chase merritt's first day in court. the first time he responds to the charges against him, not guilty. not surprising with what he told us a year early. in your gut, what do you think happened? >> i have absolutely no clue. >> words that patrick mcstay trusted for so long. >> i trusted him, because my son believed in him.
8:54 pm
>> now he sees a very different chase merritt. >> to me, he looked like a broken man, and he knew he was done. >> when the jury hears the evidence and we put it together for them, that they will find him guilty. >> but could the case be that solid and could one man have done it all? >> he's the only suspect in this murder case. >> i was honestly a bit shocked, especially that it was one person alone. >> i don't believe it. >> why not? >> just too much there. >> could one person kill a family of four, bury the bodies 100 miles north in the mojave desert, drop the car 250 miles south at the mexico border and being one person do all that and then return home to make it look like he was home that night to receive a phone call from joseph mcstay? >> yes. we have the evidence to prove that, yes.
8:55 pm
>> how strong is that proof? how reliable is the evidence gathered at the mcstay house weeks after investigators say they were murdered there? >> tons of critical evidence could have been lost in those first 15 days. >> 15 days when at least four people were in and out of the house. >> so many things in there that could have been relevant to the case. >> investigative journalist steph watts. >> we don't know if somebody in that house was related to or had knowledge of the crime could have removed items that could have been significant to solving this case. could have removed items that could have indicted them in this case. >> i don't think that you can seal a home for that long unless you are actually investigating a murder, and at that time, it wasn't. >> we know that the family members went in and out and susan mcstay cleaned the counters and she couldn't stand the house was dirty. she threw out dirty diapers.
8:56 pm
and mike mcstay took the video card out of the laptop computer, and brought home the laptop computer. how frustrating is that for you? >> if it is not an obvious murder investigation from the get-go, from the beginning, things like that are going to occur. >> things that could make chase -- make proving chase merritt's guilt beyond a reasonable doubt challenging. and how could they show that chase, a close family friend, had motive strong enough to kill two little boys in cold blood? >> i mean, just unthinkable that anybody could hurt two children like that, and especially being a mom, myself. >> did it ever play into who you suspected? >> the only thing that i could think is that perhaps the two children knew the killer and that's why they had to be killed as well. >> a killer the investigators believe knew exactly what he was doing.
8:57 pm
premeditated and deliberate, first-degree murder. we truly believe it. >> district attorney ramos doesn't believe this is an open and shut case, though. >> i think the biggest obstacle, we've talked about it, is time. people forget, and witnesses forget and the time frames in which whatever occurs and the evidence that could be lost. >> but patrick has faith in ramos and san bernardino investigato investigators, and he always has. >> they told me in the beginning, san bernardino, they would solve this case, they were committed to it. and i knew they would. >> god bless he and his family. it is usually a family member who keeps it alive, and keeps pushing, and something happened here, and something is not right. and it keeps it in the forefront, and it keeps it in everybody's minds. >> not only was she good at what she did, she knew joey. >> a man who has kept the memory of his son alive with the help of a woman he now calls his daughter.
8:58 pm
>> i have to say that the only person that i know in the whole thing that i could ever trust is her. you know. and she never once turned her back on me or betrayed the trust, you know. >> that is nice. >> trust and friendship that patrick says that he'll need as chase merritt goes on trial for murder, the murder of his loved ones, joseph, summer, gianni, and joey, jr. >> if this does go to trial, will you go? >> yes. definitely. >> it's important to you? >> absolutely. i want to look him in the face. let me tell you what one of the detectives told me. he says, i know, patrick, i know that you would like to give me 15 minutes with him, but i can't. and i said, yep, you are right. >> what would you ask him? >> i wouldn't ask him anything. there would be one person coming
8:59 pm
out of that room. >> a father consumed by anger and sadness, yet driven five years later by love and devotion. >> why did i keep going and why did i fight? one word, joey. my son. i love him. and he loved me. and i know he would be saying you're doing the right thing, dad. i know you'll do it, dad. -- captions by vitac --
9:00 pm
a beautiful home. an affluent. a vicious murder. while her husband mourned, investigators searched for clues. a greetings card. an exotic dancer, and an operating room schedule showed investigators a side of medicine they had not seen before. it was valentine's day, 2001. and susan hamilton had a busy day planned. her husband, dr. john hamilton, was an et


info Stream Only

Uploaded by TV Archive on