tv Larry King Live CNN April 30, 2010 12:00am-1:00am EDT
>> oh, yeah. i have the whole too short collection. it's way too long. >> tom foreman, thanks so much. that does it for this edition of 360. larry king starts right now. tonight, battle on the border. the growing rage. pro and cons. spawned by arizona's tough new immigration law. are hispanics unfairly targeted? can the law be enforced? could backlash ruin the state's economy? governor bill richardson and former attorney general alberto gonzales tear into the issue. let's get ready to rumble next on "larry king live." we begin first with breaking news.
an oil slick the size of delaware and rhode island combined is close to the gulf shore. it may well eclipse the exxon valdez disaster. a well that ruptured more than a week ago is responsible. efforts to shut it down failed. the slick covers as much as 600 square miles of square water. let's get more from weather anchor chad myers. >> it is a mess today because the winds shifted direction. they're now out of the southeast blowing this oil into the bayous of southeastern louisiana. well south of louisiana but into that little point that is the delta of new orleans. here is the map. here is the brown area where the brown oil is. the source there, obviously still coming out. yesterday, we found out about this time that there were not
only 1,000 barrels coming out per day -- that's about 42,000 gallons -- but there were maybe 5,000 barls coming out -- that's almost 200,000 gallons of oil coming out per day. so here it is, right on the shore of louisiana today. farther back up towards biloxi by saturday. into mobile bay by sunday. and then maybe as far east as pensacola. the good news right now, the oil that is coming on shore is almost tar balish. it's been in the water a very long time so they're coming out as kind of like balls of tar, if you would. the next layer is going to be more like mayonnaise because it's not going to be in the water as long, not going to evaporate as long. the devastating is that water and the oil that comes on shore as liquid like the exxon valdez, the animals get in this, it's plankton all the way to the river otter problem. we may not know about how many animals died from this.
this is basically the fishery of the gulf of mexico right here, and we will be killing plankton and what he's the plankton and what eelts the shrimp and all the way up the food chain. this is going to be one that we don't want to think about. this is going to be a very, very difficult, difficult days for those people down there. >> larry: great job, chad. is this a weather story? >> it was a weather story today because the wind was responsible of it coming back up and blowing that oil into the bayou. for the last couple of days, it was blowing it away. today that weather changed. >> larry: thanks, chad myers as always right on top of things. now we go on to the arizona immigration issue. joe martinez join us. the chief of police of carni, arizona. he joins us from the town of no goalless, on the mexican border in arizona. what's your view of this new law, chief? >> hi, larry. actually, the new law is not going to change a whole bunch in arizona. these are a set of laws that kind of parallel what we've got. i think you've got a lot of
people that are reacting to hype and i think we need to have more reality and less rhetoric and i think we're all going to be just fine. >> larry: what's the situation where you are? is that a big entry point there? >> actually, my town runs off of highway 177. and it has become a more and more popular thoroughfare for smugglers of both drugs and humansmugglers that go through our area. and that i think is what's being missed in all this. is that many of the vehicles that go through our area are loads of those illegal immigrants and narcotics. and those are the areas that we want to focus on here in arizona. we're not as some have unjustifiably suggested, going to stop anyone who may be
hispanic and shake them down to find out if they're in the country legally so i think -- go ahead, i'm sorry, larry. >> larry: the law requires that law enforcement officials who have a reasonable suspicion someone's an illegal alien to make a reasonable attempt to determine the status. how many does a law enforcement officer define reasonable suspicion? >> i'll tell you something. i covered an example of this just a couple of days ago. in a traffic stop that happens in our area off and on. you may make a traffic stop at 3:40 a.m. from what appears to be a vehicle with a lone driver in it. then when you get up to that vehicle, you shine your light into that vehicle and there's ten more people who are hiding inside the vehicle who all have
backpacks, carrying a great deal of water. those are the circumstances. so the hype of racial profiling is unfounded. we're not going to profile off of any kind of racial status. it's the circumstances that lead someone to believe that there's a reason to check that status. and the example i just gave you, that's a great example of how it comes into play, when you see people who are hiding. we're not going to go and stop someone that we see in our local restaurant or our local store and happen to ask them when we run across them in the store what their status is. it's in the investigation of crime. so not a whole lot's going to change at all for law enforcement. in terms of how we do business based on this new law. it's basically a charging for arizona is all. >> larry: thanks, chief.
the debate rages on. we will referee after this. you know, when i grow up, i'm going to own my own restaurant. i want to be a volunteer firefighter. when i grow up, i want to write a novel. i want to go on a road trip. when i grow up, i'm going to go there. i'm going to work with kids. i want to fix up old houses. [ female announcer ] at aarp we believe you're never done growing. i want to fall in love again. [ female announcer ] together we can discover the best of what's next at aarp.org. aflac is not more benefits at greater cost to your company insurance.
aflac is help protect and care for your employees at no cost to your company insurance. if all you know about us is... duck: aflac! ...then you don't know quack. to find out more visit getquack.com. female announcer: from jennifer, a microfiber sofa bed at the extraordinary price of $329. just $329.
joining us now, comedian carlos mencia. he became a naturalized u.s. citizen last year. and sheriff joe arpaio, of maricopa county, arizona. he returns to our cameras. he's been called the toughest sheriff in america. all right, carlos, what's your serious problem with this law? >> well, first of all, i am not carpooling in arizona, i'll tell you that right now. well, the basic problem with the law is, and here's the way i see it. i'm not defending illegal aliens. i'm defending americans. i think if you pull over americans like myself because i happen to be speaking spanish in my car, or because i happen to
have ten family members who look like me in my car, that's a violation of civil rights. i completely understand why officers like this law. because of course it makes it easier for them to do their job. but it will be easy to ask black kids, hey, show me your drug because you're showing saggy pants. put everybody who's white between the ages of -- hey, we've got serious killers on the look you fill the profile. this isn't right. >> larry: let's say it's midnight, sheriff. six mexican-americans are driving in a car through a street in your city. are they stopped? >> well, we're doing our crime suppression operation. you can see me being out in this windy weather. but we -- in two hours, we have stopped four vehicles for human smuggling. arrested 36 people for violating
that law that are here illegally. so we have the reason to do that. we have the probable caution. we've done 2,000 and courts upheld every one of those cases. we're not out there grabbing people on a street corner because they look like they're from another country. we do it pursuant to our normal operations. >> carlos, what's wrong with, bluntly put, being asked? as long as you're okay, being asked are you a citizen, prove it, so what? >> this is what we used to make fun of back in the days of russia. we fought a cold war because of this. we used to make jokes about, you know, show me your papers. that's just not the country that we as americans have ever wanted to live in. we live in a country that's based more on keeping people out of jail than putting innocent people in jail. and if they arrest illegal immigrants, that's -- i don't
have a problem with that. my problem is when they ask me for papers. when they ask me what i'm doing. you know, what if i'm there for cinco de mayo and i happen to be wearing the hat and the morocco just celebrating that moment? >> larry: sheriff, who is stopped? give me a prototype of who you stop. >> you know, let me say this about the identification. we ask everybody for their i.d., their driver's license, in the course of our duty. nothing unusual about that. we ask them, you know where were you born, your date of birth? so this happens every day in law enforcement. >> larry: this case -- speeding, passing a red light? do you stop people just indiscriminately? >> no. no, we do not do that. we don't take people off the street corners or go into residents and businesses. we don't do that. we have a state charge first and
then we have it to see if people are here illegally. >> larry: carlos, how's that different from any other law breaker or potential law breaker? >> if they ask me for my i.d. -- which, by the way, there have been times i forgot my wallet at home. they just write me a ticket for driving without the driver's license but they don't ask me to prove i'm an american. we're talking about, now, getting pulled over or committing a crime. that's fine. but that's not what the law says. the law basically states that in any legal encounter. so i might, you know, be somewhere where the cops are, and they can ask me. it's any legal encounter. it doesn't necessarily mean a criminal act has to be committed when this occurs. the officers can during a legal encounter do this. now, if they don't, that's one thing.
but the law allows them to. the law allows them to do it on the suspicion. i would be better off with the law that says, look if you're wearing pointy boots and a hat, we think you're an illegal. at least that would be specific. but this law, it actually brings into account a human being's prejudices, what they bring to the table, what they grew up with, what they think is an illegal. so here's what i'm saying. if you have a guy that's mexican-looking, latino-looking, and he's wearing a hat and pointy boots and a thick belt that guy might look illegal. you put that same attire on a white guy. that's what's wrong with the law. >> larry: we'll have the sheriff comment on that when we come back. still ahead -- i'll have your response in a moment, sir. former attorney general richardson will weigh in on this. th tums. calcium rich tums goes to work in seconds. nothing works faster. ♪ tum ta tum tum tums
in arteries is a real reason to lower cholesterol. and that along with diet, crestor does more than lower bad cholesterol, it raises good. crestor is also proven to slow the buildup of plaque in arteries. crestor isn't for everyone, like people with liver disease, or women who are nursing, pregnant, or may become pregnant. simple blood tests will check for liver problems. you should tell your doctor about other medicines you are taking, or if you have muscle pain or weakness. that could be a sign of serious side effects. while you've been building your life, plaque may have been building in your arteries. ask your doctor if crestor can help and go to crestor.com to get a free trial offer. announcer: if you can't afford your medication, astrazeneca may be able to help.
>> larry: we're back. sheriff arpaio, doesn't this put a lot of burden on the police officer? >> no. they're well trained. they know how to enforce all the laws. i don't think it does. just another law to enforce here in this new law just gives a little extra tool especially to my guys have been enforcing the
federal and state illegal immigration laws for three years. now if you come across someone here illegally, you now have the authority to arrest that person on a misdemeanor charge and book them into the jail versus turning them over to the u.s. government. >> and that's better law enforcement? in your opinion? than turning them over? >> yeah. yeah. you know if they see late the law, they should go to jail. that's going to be my policy when the law takes effect. we have 38,000 people. in our jails. 38,000 that are here illegally. right now in this area we have 100 people in jail right now charged with murder that are here illegally. so you do have crime associated with the illegal aliens coming into our country. >> larry: when does the law take effect, sheriff? >> it takes effect about 90 days. from probably today.
>> larry: all right, carlos, how do you respond to that? >> well you know, that's -- first of all, the police chief from earlier said this law doesn't really change anything. if it doesn't change anything, then why the law in the first place? look, as i said -- >> it does change. >> well, then if it does change, then he misspoke. but what i'm saying -- >> no, it does change. >> okay. if you're going to arrest illegal aliens, i don't have a problem with that. i don't have a problem with you doing whatever you need to do to clean up your state. i'm not there. you know, i have a brother who lives there. he tells me about the violence. he tells me about violence by illegal immigrants. i get all that. i just don't want you to trample on my rights or any american rights to do so. i know it makes it easier. but that's not cool. >> larry: carlos, how do you know someone is an illegal alien unless you investigate? >> well, you -- but they --
there are already laws in the books to do this. and for me this is -- the biggest problem, not with this bill, but with america in general is, we as americans are employing these illegal immigrants. if we didn't give them jobs, they wouldn't be here. this problem isn't really an illegal immigrant problem, it's really an american problem. we're giving these people work. you know why they don't have an illegal immigration problem in el salvador even though it's bordering mexico? because mexicans aren't going to el salvador. there's no work there. if there was no work here, they wouldn't be here. we're giving them work. we're doing that. and this is an us problem. i think we need to fix that problem -- >> larry: you agree with that, sheriff? >> well, first of all, carlos, violated the law crossing the border, coming into this area. we go into businesses and all the illegals, the majority, are there working, but they have
phony identification, which is another violation of the law. so we enforce the laws. they're taking up jobs, by the way, carlos. we have an economic problem here. people would do anything to get a job. yet we're giving these jobs to people that are here illegally and that's not right. that's not right. come here legally. >> i agree, but -- >> larry: hold it guys -- >> -- when you said we, those are people committing a crime as well. people are not supposed to employ illegal immigrants or people that don't have papers. >> larry: all right, we're just touching the surface here. thank you. carlos mencis and sheriff joe arpaio. you'll be on again, you guys. got to move on to other guests. how does the new law look from downtown l.a.? we're going to go live and find out next. [ male announcer ] ah, the office chameleon... appeasing the will of others and making no real decisions. i think the graph should be bigger. i agree. make it bigger. [ fly buzzing ] should be smaller, too, don't you think?
yeah, also make it smaller. smaller. bigger. black and white, color, plain... with polka dots? [ boss ] yeah. [ male announcer ] chameleon in your office? learn how to tame your leadership instincts at the leadership instinct simulcast hosted by express employment professionals. sign up now at myleadershipinstinct.com.
you have a lot of great people coming in, doing a lot of work, and i'm not so sure a lot of other people are going to be doing that work. so it is a very tough problem. but i do say this, you have a law or at least you have to establish a law, and i guess we're sort of a country -- and other people aren't supposed to be coming into a country
illegally. >> larry: you would not favor a boycott of any kind? >> no, i would not favor a boycott. >> larry: that was donald trump talking about arizona's new anti-illegal immigration law on last night's "larry king live." the new law generating lots of talk. carlos dias is a syndicated radio host and entertainment reporter, first generation america, son of a cuban immigrant. he joins us from olveria street in downtown l.a. what are people saying there? >> you know, it's tough to find anyone who is in support of this bill, larry. it's got emotions running hot. you mentioned my father, who's a cuban immigrant. i talked to him just before i came on. he came to this country in 1962 from cuba as part of the peter pan program and became an american citizen in 1968. i asked him what he thought of the bill. and he told me, you know, he's a big baseball fan. he said what if i go to arizona to see the diamondbacks play and i go to the game and i forget my
i.d.? i've been an american citizen for 42 years. yet i speak with a spanish accent and look very spanish. what happens to me if i'm stopped without proof of identification on me? obviously, a lot of people are not too supportive of this. i talked to several people from mera costa college. we talked earlier, you have some strong sentiments about this senate bill and it becoming a law. >> yes, i do. i'm completely against it. i think that anytime you have a law that gives so much power to the state and singles out a group, it's dangerous and it sends the wrong message to the community. i myself am an immigrant. i came in 1985 to the united states. and since then, i've earned a high school education. i have a bachelor's degree and two master degrees. all of it comes from the support that i felt from family and the community. that somehow you get people to be successful. the message we're sending out to
the immigrant community especially the latino community is wrong and it's going to impact our youth and so i want to make sure that i state that i'm completely against this law. >> and as a doctor at mera costa college what do you say to your students when they say, how can they be close to becoming a law, once it passed the senate? >> well, my students are asking, aren't there more immigrants than us? my latino students i work with. i myself am an immigrant. this law's outrageous because it really sanctions human rights violations. there's no way to profile people -- i myself am an immigrant. if i go to arizona, will they look at me as latino? i'm not. i'm dutch and indonesian. but i'm a target. and so i really reject this bill. >> all right.
well, larry, as you can see, down in los angeles, we have several opinions and most of them are not in favor of senate bill 1070. larry. >> larry: and we'll be checking back with you later, carlos, hang around. governor bill richardson and alberto gonzales are here to take on this debate. is arizona's new immigration law in their opinion unconstitutional or not? next. it can happen anytime.
an everyday moment can turn romantic at a moment's notice. and when it does, men with erectile dysfunction can be more confident in their ability to be ready with cialis for daily use. cialis for daily use is a clinically proven, low-dose tablet you take every day, so you can be ready anytime the moment's right for you and your partner. tell your doctor about your medical condition and all medications and ask if you're healthy enough for sexual activity. don't take cialis if you take nitrates for chest pain, as this may cause an unsafe drop in blood pressure. don't drink alcohol in excess with cialis. side effects may include headache, upset stomach, delayed back ache or muscle ache. to avoid long-term injury, seek immediate medical help for an erection lasting more than 4 hours. if you have any sudden decrease or loss in hearing or vision, stop taking cialis and call your doctor right away. ask your doctor if cialis for daily use is right for you. for a 30-tablet free trial offer, go to cialis.com.
[ female announcer ] switch to the new and improved swiffer sweepervac, and you'll dump your old broom. but don't worry, he'll find someone else. ♪ who's that lady? ♪ who's that lady? ♪ sexy lady ♪ who's that lady? [ female announcer ] new swiffer sweepervac does more than sweep. it has a powerful vacuum to suck up the big stuff. and electrostatic dry cloths to pick up the rest. it cleans better than a broom or your money back. [ slurping ] ♪
>> larry: governor bill richardson is the democratic governor of new mexico. he joins us from santa fe. alberto gonzales served as united states attorney general for president george w. bush. he's a visiting professor at texas tech university joining us from lubbock. i believe, general gonzales, this is the first time you've spoken out publicly about this law. what's your take? >> well, you know, larry, we have a great country because of adversity that flows from immigrants, quite frankly. i think that racial profiling is wrong. it is wrong. because -- it's unlawful. but it's also wrong because i think it runs counter to the
very essence of our country. asked whether or not this law constitutes racial profiling, i think that remains to be seen. i'm concerned, like everyone else, about the vagueness of the law and about the disgregs given to law enforcement. if we set aside this law because of concerns for potential abuse that would be an argument for setting aside a host of laws. virtually every tool given to law enforcement. because of potential abuse. i think we need to see what arizona does in terms of guidance, in terms of promulgating regulations to explain how this discretion is to be exercised, and then i think we're in a much better position to determine whether or not this is unlawful racial profiling. >> governor richardson, what's your response to that? >> well, i know the attorney general is acknowledging potential of racial profiling. i think it's going to lead to racial profiling. i think this law's
unconstitutional. my hope is the justice department, the obama administration, contests it on the ground, that you have state/local law enforcement trying to enforce a federal law. immigration is federal. it's very clear. and what this is going to do is not just lead to racial profiling, but you're also having other states like alabama, like minnesota, like georgia, just in the last few days, contemplate similar laws. it's going to be increasing a lot of attention among the hispanic community in this country. 30% -- i notice carlos, his family, 30% of arizonians are hispanic. and if you're dark complected or you're going to an arizona diamond back game, a police officer can come up and talk to you on the grounds that you look suspicious and ask you for your papers. that is clearly racial profiling. and i believe that's going to happen. so i hope that this law is struck down. >> general, if you were the current attorney general, would you attack it before the supreme court? >> well, i think we have to look at a number of things.
i think the governor is correct. i think you have to look to see whether or not has the federal government preempted this field. so i think it is an open question. as to whether or not arizona can even legislate in this area. and that is something obviously the department of justice is looking at. and that is what we would be looking at. let me just say this, with respect to racial profiling, if you can show me that the intent of this law is to facilitate racial profiling or that it results systematically in racial profiling, then i'll be the first in line to condemn it. all i'm saying is i'd like to see what arizona is going to do to address the issue of vagueness, to reassure the people of arizona that we've got a law that's effective and a law that also doesn't result in racial profiling. >> larry: all right, i'm going to take a break and have bill richardson respond to the statement by the former attorney general basically which is
>> larry: all right, governor richardson, the former attorney general alberto gonzales said let's see how it works. as we look at the border of no galless, arizona. what about giving it a chance, governor? >> i don't think it's practical or realistic or the right thick to do, larry. i think what we need to do is test the constitutionality of this law. i don't think it's going to stand up because this is a federal responsibility. you're going to cause enormous tension among the hispanic community in america. i think what we need to do is have the homeland security department instead of in arizona overseeing this problem. they should go after drug criminals, big criminals. and what we need, and i give credit to the bush administration for having done this, and now the obama administration for pushing it, is federal comprehensive immigration. a legalization plan, where it's earned. there's accountability. secondly, verification of workers. and, third, more border
security. more national guard. more border patrol. more technology on the border. we have drug cartels. we have violence on the border. i experience it right next to governor brewer in arizona. but let's take the law into our own hands and do something that is not only going to work but is going to violate our country's human rights. that's my view. >> larry: general, the democrats offered a new proposal today. do we need a tougher federal law? >> larry, let me clarify one point. i'm not saying let's see how it works as much as i'm saying that i'm not sure you can mount a successful court challenge as to racial profiling without seeing how the law is implemented. i think you can immediately challenge as to whether or not arizona has even the right to legislate in this field. again, i worry that a successful
court challenge might not succeed without seeing how this law is implemented in arizona. now with respect to the federal law, i think it's high time for the federal government to pass legislation to deal with immigration. in a post-9/11 world, we need to know who's entered this country and why -- we need a policy that's consistent with our economic policy and immigration policy consistent with our national security policy, including many of the things governor richardson just talked about. >> larry: governor, isn't it the federal responsibility in this? >> yeah, it is totally, larry, because what we're trying to do -- and what we should try to do is pass a law that brings more border control, more border technology, national guard. we also have to have a verification system for workers. you have to deal with employers that illegally hire workers. i think as the attorney general said, what are you going to do with the 11 million undocumented workers in america today?
you can't throw them out. many of them are contributing to the economy. but if there are those that, for instance, do not pass a background check, i think they should all speak english, they should all get in back of the line for those that are trying to get here legally. those i think are the criteria that we should use, not give them citizenship. i think that would be wrong. but earn legalization. then you have a level playing field. i think you have to do all three at the same time. i think the proposals from the congress, first border security, then legalization, it's not
going to work. you have to do is simultaneously. >> larry: didn't the bush administration pretty much propose that, what governor richardson just said? >> we tried, larry. president bush understood that in order to get part of the package, it would have to get passed all at one time. of course, he was unsuccessful in doing that. i think what's being lost in all the debate about what's going on in arizona is the fact the federal government has failed. the federal government has a responsibility to deal with the immigration issue. and they -- and the federal government has failed today in addressing it. i agree with many of the points made by governor richardson. i know one point that i disagree with many of my republican friends, with respect to the 13 million to 15 million undocumented aliens in this country. some believe they need to leave the country before any consideration of legalization in the future. i'm not sure that's practical. we had many discussions about this in the bush administration. there was serious doubt as to whether or not that was even practical. we need a policy that will work. and those kinds of notions i think while it may have some merits and benefits, again, it's about -- it's about looking at a policy, passing a policy that is effective and one that is
efficient. >> larry: we'll have more ahead in this very intelligent discussion on a very emotional topic. industry. energy. her. this. lives. how ? by bringing together... information. ... people ... ... machines ... ... systems ... ideas... verizon helps businesses worldwide... including fortune 500 companies... find and achieve... better. better. better. better.
better. better. this site has a should i try priceline instead? >> no it's a sale. nothing beats a sale! wrong move! you. you can save up to half off that sale when you name your own price on priceline. but this one's a deal...trust me. it's only pretending to be a deal. here, bid $79. got it. wow! you win this time good twin! there's no disguising the real deal.
>> larry: it's a night you never forget. i had a feeling that night that this show would make it. when you get down to it, it's who, what, when, where why. i'm there to ask questions. do my best. we want you to help us pick our top "larry king live" moments of the past 25 years. just go to cnn.com/larryking. have fun watching all the clips. and rank your top five. we'll reveal them during my silver anniversary week, beginning may 31st. now, let's check in with sanjay gupta hosting "a.c. 360" tonight. what's our lead, sanjay? >> a deadly blast is about to become an environmental disaster. that oil slick in the gulf of mexico is approaching land. it's also much worse than previously estimated. by one account, this could be nearly twice as bad as the exxon
valdez spill. the burning question of course, how did this happen? we're keeping them honest. also tonight, what does an illegal immigrant look like? that's a question stirring passion on both sides of arizona immigration debate and now congress says it's going to get involved. the raw politics ahead. also getting involved, shakira. the grammy-award winning singer in phoenix, fighting against what she calls an unjust law, at one point asking a sheriff if he was going to arrest her as well. larry, those stories and much more at the top of the hour. >> that's 10:00 eastern, 7:00 pacific with sanjay gupta sitting in for anderson cooper. we're back with richardson and gonzales. first, let's check in again with carlos dias, downtown, l.a.'s famous alvera street. more opinions about the new law. >> in all honesty, we were trying to find people who are in support of this new law and new bill. we've had some difficulties to be honest with you. a lot of people are very emotional about this, or against it.
we have some students here from mira costa college. dr. john kerwin. we talked earlier. this is something that affects you as well. >> it does. many of my students have come to the country recently. and the work that i do is to help them adjust to the challenges of this country. arizona's our neighbor. so we're rather close. i know it's a concern for our students. but i think, like the border fence, i like this is going to be another futile gesture against change that's inevitable. and ultimately i think really our challenge is how to find creative ways to embrace the future. and that future means a lot of change for this country. >> are your students when you talk to them, are they outraged by this? >> they are. i think they're affected personally. many of them have family that have been affected by immigration policy. and it's made adjusting to this country extremely difficult. so part of what our work is, is
to try to stabilize their situations, to provide them with the tools to move forward in this society, to give them the american dream. >> thank you, i really appreciate it. downtown l.a., the emotions are running very high about this bill. >> larry: thank you, carlos diaz, downtown los angeles. let's take a call for governor richardson and general gonzales. sierra vista, arizona, hello. >> caller: hi, larry. this is bob. yeah, what's your question? >> caller: i have the upmost respect for governor richardson and mr. gonzales. i live in arizona. we had a rancher killed here. i'm white anglo saxon protestant. ever since 9/11 when i travel i have to go through security checks in an parent don't feel that's violating my constitutional rights or i'm being discriminated against. we're just trying to protect safety of our country. and that's what we're trying to
do in arizona with this law. we're trying to protect our citizens. >> larry: governor? >> well, look, and i respect that gentleman a lot, cochis county is right next to new there's cartels coming in. his mexico and that rancher had tied to new mexico who was killed. there's border violence. there's cartels coming in. we need some help. we need national guardsmen, more of them. we have some. i deployed 35 recently. we need more border patrol. we need more technology at the border. i agree, we don't need a fence. you build a ten foot fence, you'll have 11-foot ladders. that's not going to work. we should look at immigration as
not just mexico. if you reform the immigration laws, it affects europeans, haitians, it affects all of us, larry. >> larry: i have to get a break in and then we'll have a response from alberto gonzalez. now our cnn hero of the week. a woman is committed to stopping any age-old industry. but today has become increasingly lucrative and dangerous, the kidnapping of trafficking of women and girls. from nepal to india. she intercepts kidnaps and prosecutes pimps. take a look. if someone says i want to make your child a prostitute, they would shoot them. but here, families, they are tricked all the time.
there is no way to escape. it is my strong hope to stop every nepali girl from being trafficked. when we go to the border, we are intercepting four girls. after the rescue, the girls are taken to nepal. >> good girl. >> they were totally psychologically broken. we give them whatever work they want to do. whatever training they want to do. there is always a small scarment but today something new in my life. they are my strength. >> larry: quite a lady. you want to nominate someone changing the world? visit cnn.com/heroes. right back with alberto gonzalez after this.
20 minutes later, she'll bring one into the world in seattle. later today, she'll help an accident victim in kansas. how can one nurse be in all these places? through the nurses she taught in this place. johnson & johnson knows, behind every nurse who touches a life... there's a nurse educator... who first touched them. ♪ you're a nurse ♪ you make a difference and now i know without enough, our bodies can steal it from our bones. only caltrate delivers 1200 mg of calcium and 800 iu of vitamin d, in just two tablets. share some tlc. tender loving caltrate,
i'm going to own my own restaurant. i want to be a volunteer firefighter. when i grow up, i want to write a novel. i want to go on a road trip. when i grow up, i'm going to go there. i'm going to work with kids. i want to fix up old houses. [ female announcer ] at aarp we believe you're never done growing. i want to fall in love again. [ female announcer ] together we can discover the best of what's next at aarp.org.
>> larry: general gonzales, how do you react to the caller that brings up what happened at airports? are airports different than arizona? >> well, listen, i'm all in favor of security at our airports. i'm all in favor of securing our borders. i want to make one point, larry, and i'm sure governor richardson agrees with this, he and i have met a lot of people in the law enforcement community. i would say 97%, 99% of them serve with integrity and good faith.
i'm sure and confident that the law enforcement community in arizona will implement this law in a way that meets the goals of the legislature. i worry about racial profiling, no question about it. i also worry about the fact that we don't have federal comprehensive immigration policy. i worry about discrimination. but i also worry about the fact that laws are being ignored. i think disregard of the law breeds further disowe bead yenz. that's not the america i know. >> larry: let's take another call. eugene, oregon. >> caller: thank you for taking my call. i'm against this whole thing. let's be honest, no one is willing to admit, the u.s. has az hunger for cheap labor and who else is going to do that cheap labor other than illegal immigrants? if we get rid of the illegal immigrants our economy will crash more. nobody is talking about that issue. i want to know why. >> larry: governor? >> medicare, social security buttressed by undocumented workers in our global economy, we need every possible person to compete.
there's also a need for legal immigration reform, not just illegal, that allows us to bring more workers that are skilled. i think the obama administration is on the right path here. pushing the congress, i think like president bush did, to pass comprehensive immigration. i think we need to do it this year, larry, along with an energy bill, along with efforts to improve the economy. the congress has, we have eight months to go. why can't they do all these things that need to be done before there's more tension, before other states take the law into their own hands? this is an important human rights issue for this country. >> larry: general gonzales, do you believe this might be an example that there is still, unfortunately, a lot of racism in america? >> larry: i believe that it still exists, larry.
we have an african-american president, an african-american attorney general, we've had a hispanic attorney general, we still need our civil rights law. there's still a need for the civil rights division at the department of justice. it does exist. i couldn't agree more with governor richardson about the need to have comprehensive immigration reform at the federal level today. not next year. but today. it is that important as far as i'm concerned. i said earlier that it needs to be consistent with our economic policy. i agree also with the governor that it should include additional visas for skilled workers, additional visa are for unskilled workers in those praises americans will not work, have no interest or desire in taking jobs in that area. and so, again, it's got to be comprehensive in order to be effective.
>> larry: we're running close on time. governor, what do you think about boycotting arizona? >> i don't think that's a good idea. that hurt a lot of people in arizona that don't agree with this law. it hurts some 100,000 hispanics that depend on tourism. i think we need to do it constructively in the congress with our laws. i'm not too crazy about boycotts, despite the fact i think arizona and its legislature made a huge mistake. they're our neighbor state, a good state. i don't believe that makes much sense to have economic boycotts >> larry: general, what do you think of a boycott? >> i don't see that would be effective and gain you much, larry, quite frankly. i think this is a very emotional issue. obviously, there are tough legal issues involved. like many things, many disputes in our country, ultimately it's going to be resolved in the courts. >> larry: thank you both, very much, for a very interesting discussion. our space aliens out to conquer earth?