Skip to main content

tv   The Journal Editorial Report  FOX News  May 26, 2018 12:00pm-1:00pm PDT

12:00 pm
paul: welcome to the journal editorial report, i'm paul gigot, senior intelligence and law enforcement officials held two-high level briefings thursday for republican and democratic lawmakers on the russia investigation amid allegation that is the fbi used a top secret informant to spy on the trump campaign. both meetings were held as the president raised new questions about the probe and called for the department of justice to look into whether his campaign was surveilled for political purposes. wall street journal columnist kim strassel has been following this story from the beginning. i spoke with her earlier. urging the justice department to
12:01 pm
cooperate with justice department committee and new cooperation but if history is a guide here we have to wait and see what happens because there's history of not cooperating. >> yeah, i would bet on not cooperation not only refusal to make documents available but serious redactions have been sent over, doj's refusal to make witnesses available for different members an committees in the house and in the senate. they don't want a lot of this information to come out so i think we can expect that it's all going to have to be pride out bit by bit. paul: okay, now we do -- the name of this contractor has been widely reported, but we know a fair number of things about it, he's an american who is resident in the uk, he met with three trump campaign officials, all of this from stories that clearly
12:02 pm
seemed leaked by the justice department and fbi, is that how you read it, they are responsible for leaking details? >> absolutely, according to government sources and that usually means department of justice, fbi, you also have to look at motives here. you know, this, paul, we have been in the journalism business for a long time. you always look to see who has an interest in putting it out, the stories that were written very much took the most kind line that you could to the department of justice and fbi even going so far to suggest this person who was spying on the trump campaign was not in fact, spying on the trump campaign but it very much designed to cast the fbi in the best light. paul: why are they blaming the house intelligence committee for having leaked this, the name, is there any evidence that that happened? >> there is absolutely no evidence that happened.
12:03 pm
just a curious point, look at the level of details that were put in the stories about the particular spy/informant. all reason devin nunes is going to the department of justice with a subpoena because he doesn't have the information about this person. they have the information about this person, so there's only one side that was in possession to leak in the first place. >> paul: we know from some reporting that this informant met with carter page, with george papadopoulos, clovis, trump officials, what else we want to learn about informant and what he was up to? >> most important question here is timeline. if you look at some of those stories that were leaked to the times, the washington post, they all went out of their, at least one of them went out of their way to say, none of these contacts took place until after the fbi started counterintelligence investigation on july 31st, 2016 but was know and we reported of at least one major interaction that this source carter page all
12:04 pm
the way back to july with invitation that had been extend to him for england beginning of june and other suspicious questions of people approached in the spring. this is a timeline question. when did the fbi first start using a person or more than one to look at the trump campaign and why? paul: okay, but why does the timeline matter? why does it matter if it happened in the spring? >> it matters because the fbi has doggedly stuck to this story that it only began this counterintelligence investigation because of information it received in the middle or toward the end of july about overheard conversation of trump aide george papadopoulos and claim that he knew something about russia and emails. if it started much sooner than that, obviously that was not the catalyst and it means the fbi hasn't been straight about what it was that had inspired it to get involved here and some people, you know, they worry is there political reason as well,
12:05 pm
what was going on? paul: was part of the motivation the christopher steele dossier, we know that was paid for the clinton campaign. we also want to know what government officials knew about this and what was the reason they gave for tasking this informant. all of that still has to be uncovered. >> yeah, and there's been increasing focus, for instance, on former cia director john brennan because there has been some suggestion that he might have been involved in some of this and maybe there was interagency task force from the sinning, starting in the spring when people began to have concerns about the trump campaign, that's something to look at. remember, we have pretty strict prohibitions, paul, on the cia and how it can monitor american citizens. >> what about this argument you hear from the critics of the president that he has crossed some ethical line by saying to justice, cooperate with the house intelligence committee? is that crossing a line?
12:06 pm
>> no, because it begins from the premise that it is somehow out of bounds to ask any questions about the investigators. look, we do have separations of power, we have a congress that's tasked with oversight of the executive branch and that is a way yod rawter -- you'd rather have do it and if the justice department is not going to cooperate with dually issued subpoenas, the president is absolutely right to tell the people who work for him that hay immediate to respond to and comply with congressional overnight. >> is the ultimate burden here maybe on the president to override the justice department and maybe declassify everything and say, look, you come in and look at, i'm saying it's okay, he has the power as president to do that? >> he ought to do it tomorrow in my mind, paul, because they are really the only organization, only body that can get to this, people have talked about inspector general at the justice
12:07 pm
department but he does not have subpoena powers and a lot of power, they need to have access to this. declassify for them. there's no problem about that. the gang of 8, the highest security clearances who have always in the past have been allow today look at material like this. paul: kim strassel, thanks. when we come back, president trump pulling out on sit-down with kim jong un, at least for now, so what's behind this diplomatic dance and what's next? >> we will see what happens. we are talking to them now. it was a very nice statement they put out. we will see what happens. managing blood sugar is not a marathon. it's a series of smart choices.
12:08 pm
and when you replace one meal or snack a day with glucerna made with carbsteady to help minimize blood sugar spikes you can really feel it. glucerna. everyday progress. find thenah.ote yet? honey look, your old portable cd player. my high school rethainer. oh don't... it's early 90s sitcom star dave coulier... cut...it...out! [laughing] what year is it? as long as stuff gets lost in the couch, you can count on geico saving folks money. fifteen minutes could save you fifteen percent or more on car insurance. ( ♪ ) your heart doesn't only belong to you. child: bye, grandpa! and if you have heart failure, entrusting your heart to entresto may help. entresto is a heart failure medicine that helps improve your heart's ability to pump blood to the body.
12:09 pm
in the largest heart failure study ever, entresto was proven superior at helping people stay alive and out of the hospital compared to a leading heart failure medicine. don't take entresto if pregnant. it can cause harm or death to an unborn baby. don't take entresto with an ace inhibitor or aliskiren, or if you've had angioedema with an ace or arb. the most serious side effects are angioedema, low blood pressure, kidney problems, or high blood potassium. ask your doctor about entresto. and help make more tomorrows possible. entresto, for heart failure. with savings on the new sleep number 360 smart bed. it senses your every move and automatically adjusts on both sides to keep you effortlessly comfortable. and snoring....
12:10 pm
does your bed do that? right now during our semi-annual sale save up to $700 on sleep number 360 smart beds. plus 36 month financing. ends memorial day. >> based on the recent statement of north korea, i have decided to terminate the planned summit on june 12th.
12:11 pm
well many things can happen and great opportunity lies ahead potentially. i believe this is a tremendous setback for north korea and, indeed, a setback for the world. paul: that was president trump thursday saying he had called off the planned summit with north korea blaming increasingly hostile rhetoric from the rogue regime. north korea responding in a statement, said pyongyang remained open to resolving issues with washington regardless of ways at any time any format, the president called that statement warm and productive on friday and talks are ongoing, so is there a diplomatic way forward? let's ask wall street journal and deputy editor dan henninger and columnist mary anastasia ogrady and bill mcgurn. >> i'm probably not as opposed the president sitting down with any leader at any time as some people are, however, you know
12:12 pm
the danger, right, it's like getting engaged and planning a wedding and then if the week before the wedding you're thinking, this isn't the gal for me -- [laughter] >> the pressure when she's in her dress and the cake is baked, the process overrides it. people talk that it's in kim's interest -- paul: it's in kim's agreement to have a meeting. >> right. paul: looks like he's a coleader. >> that's why we always have to keep our eye on the ball which is denying him the capacity to strike the united states with a nuclear weapon. if a talk was advanced and sincere, the danger is with north koreans have done these talks, i remember bill clinton staring across the dmz in 1994 if you pursue the nuke, it'll be the end of the country, it wasn't. so think know how -- that's the danger we forget what's at stake
12:13 pm
here. paul: yeah, mary, the threshold for me is has -- have the north koreans made a strategic effort to get rid of program, if they haven't, there's nothing talk about. >> the president is having doubts about that which is why we got to this point this week but i will give him credit, he never changed, you know, everybody explained this as the extreme pressure and he said nothing in that category has changed even as they've arranged this meeting. paul: u.s. pressure, sanctions? >> exactly. if i was the president i would not have made a commemorative coin in advance. you don't show good faith, we are not doing this. that's very different from the way president obama behaved with iran and cuba. paul: dan, we know that kim jong un wants a summit appearance at least even if he doesn't want to make any commitments from it because it puts him on the world stage as trump's equal.
12:14 pm
why is donald trump seemingly to eager to have a summit with kim? >> goes back to kim's sister meeting with president moon. it's always been a u.s. policy that what we want from north korea complete verifiable denuclearization and at that time the north koreans conveyed they might be willing to talk about that. secretary of state comp -- pompeo went to north korea and came back with the impression that that discussion was on and i think it happened after kim went from the second time to visit jinping in beijing, he pulled back. the united states started to get the strong impression that the north koreans were no longer interested and reject today routinely military exercises with south korea, we pulled back from that, they did not show up for logistical meetings in
12:15 pm
singapore, we were not able to get them on the phone. at this point, the u.s. decided that the north koreans were not negotiating in good faith and foreign ministry was saying at the time that they were a nuclear power and complete denuclearization was not their goal. after that, paul, what was there to talk about? paul: i agree, seems to me that donald trump was played in a way by president moon of south korea and maybe a little bit by the north koreans. i'm wondering why put the possibility back on the table? >> i don't know. i wouldn't have agreed to the meeting. it's not the think -- my whole view is that what the north koreans are doing are trying to get more time. even if they could delay a meeting, if secretary pompeo was right when he said the cia, that the north koreans are within handful of capacity to strike america, then what you want to do is play for time in these games but i think -- i think he showed who is insincere.
12:16 pm
i actually think he gains from it. >> do you agree with that or is this has been a setback? >> no, no, i think he is showing that they have to show good faith and if they're not going to do that, then never mind. i think it's something that he should be proud of having done. paul: where does it go from here? restore maximum pressure if the summit doesn't come off and keep squeezing them? >> they have to keep maximum pressure. >> i hope there's plan b from secretary mattis. if the talks -- paul: military action, right. >> if the talks don't produce anything, the north koreans don't agree, the president has made this a red line, they cannot get this capacity and what people forget nothing has really changed for japan and south korea. we are talking about an attack on the mainland, the capacity to do that. paul: u.s. mainland. >> i don't think kim will give up weapons likely. paul: thank you all. when we come back, president trump opening up a potential new
12:17 pm
front in the trade war, what his investigation into auto import could mean for american consumers and car makers next. >> i think your auto workers and auto companies in this country are going to be very happy with what's going to happen. only botox® cosmetic is fda approved to temporarily make frown lines, crow's feet and forehead lines look better. it's a quick 10 minute treatment given by a doctor to reduce those lines. ask your doctor about botox® cosmetic by name. the effects of botox® cosmetic, may spread hours to weeks after injection, causing serious symptoms. alert your doctor right away as difficulty swallowing, speaking, breathing, eye problems, or muscle weakness can be a sign of a life-threatening condition. do not receive botox® cosmetic if you have a skin infection. side effects may include allergic reactions,
12:18 pm
injection site pain, headache, eyelid and eyebrow drooping and eyelid swelling. tell your doctor about your medical history, muscle or nerve conditions, and medications including botulinum toxins as these may increase the risk of serious side effects. the details make a difference. the man makes them matter. see real results at botoxcosmetic.com/men. (vo)about what i eat.n selective this new beneful select 10, has 10 amazing ingredients! (avo) with real beef, plus accents of sunflower oil and apples, suddenly your dog's a health nut.
12:19 pm
(vo) the old me woulda been all over that. (avo) new beneful select 10. 10 ingredients. 1 thoughtful recipe
12:20 pm
oh hi sweetie, i just want to show you something. xfinity mobile: find my phone. [ phone rings ] look at you. this tech stuff is easy. [ whirring sound ] you want a cookie? it's a drone! i know. find your phone easily with the xfinity voice remote. one more way comcast is working to fit into your life, not the other way around. paul: president trump potentially opening a new front in the trade war this week instructing wilbur ross investigate whether automobile import pose a threat to national security. move is sure to further strain relations with american allies and could ultimately result in hefty tariffs for american buyers of foreign cars. so this action is being
12:21 pm
investigation being brought under section 232 of american trade law, the national security provision, are foreign cars a threat? >> of course not. 56% of all cars sold in the united states are made in the united states but we also make lots of parts and we do a lot of design and and research for cars so the auto industry in the country has probably never been healthier or not been healthier since maybe 1940 or something like that. i mean, it's globally competitive. it's using all the advantages of open trade to make itself stronger and so you not only have a strong u.s. base but have a very strong export component because of it. paul: when we talk about the u.s. auto industry, we don't mean ford, chrysler and gm, we are talking about mercedes, bmw, toyota, and nissan, they all make cars in the united states. >> well, one of donald trump's theories here is if he does this, then they'll have to come
12:22 pm
here and build more plants and make more cars here but, of course, what we know about a protected market is that the quality of the cars goes down, you know, for those of us who were alive in 1970's, cars didn't last, they were terrible, it was only opening in the car market that cars became a better experience for consumers. paul: why is donald trump doing this? >> i think it's mostly about nafta because if you take the cars made in the united states plus canada and méxico, you have something like 75% of all cars are made in north america, he's not getting the cooperation that he wanted on nafta and this is his response to that but he's forgetting here that first of all méxico -- his main thing is if he launches this investigation it's going to take 8 months, that's going to get him through the november election and he can say when people go to polls in november, oh, yeah, i didn't get the nafta deal but i'm being tough with canada and méxico because he's
12:23 pm
being criticized about that right now and in 8 months he's not going to win this appeal because it is not harming the industry. paul: dan, it's hard for me to determine, get a coherent strategy from the trump-trade team and in part, the president this week on china he was saying, it's a great deal after the weekend negotiations and then by the next day, not such a great deal and the next day after that, it's really a bad deal and we have to redo the whole thing. what -- what is going on here? >> well, it's very hard, i think donald trump likes to play three-dimensional negotiation chess and it's hard to keep your eye on the ball. as mary was suggesting, the national security threat from the auto industry very difficult to credit. currently there are 24 japanese and german auto factories in the united states employing american workers, all right. so then you have to go looking for other reasons, what might be going on here, mary suggesting
12:24 pm
forcing méxico's hand on nafta, i think another target here is germany and angela merkel, trump has several things going with her, the most important of which is the iranian nuclear deal, need her support on that, united states and england are very upset that the germans are negotiating gas pipeline with russia, they would like them to stop doing that and trump has said any number of times he wants the germans to increase military spending. i think part of this is to put pressure on her, get her attention, but, of course, the european union has already posed on array of countertariffs on american goods if we go through with auto tariffs. paul: japan, 11% of import are made in japan. japan is teaming up retaliation on steel and aluminum tariffs. how does this get japan to cooperate? >> i'm not sure it does. the auto workers would like the
12:25 pm
deal, some auto workers might like it. if you're work at at a tima plant in tennessee, you're an auto worker too, you might not like this as much. you know, it used to be that when you had a block aid and you prevented people from importing things, that was considered a -- an act of war. now that you have the white house sort of suggesting this on their own consumers, it's inconceivable to me and the same auto workers that might like the tax on foreign cars, the tariffs on it, they're complaining about the steel tariffs because that raises their costs. it's counterproductive across field. paul: there's a view politically that this helps president and republicans because they are speaking to workers. there's another side of the story, trade protectionism and potential retaliation is hurting parts to have farm bill, for example, which would be retaliation and also a problem and business decisions being
12:26 pm
held, delayed when the tariffs are going to hit, how bad will they be and so i think this is slowing growth and we are hearing that as ceo's get to earnings, well, this is my biggest concern now. >> yeah, i think one of the things that mysterious me that donald trump talks about the trade as if his trade partners don't have any way to respond and méxico has a lot of ways to respond. as you mentioned, it's a big importer of us, u.s. agriculture products, but don't forget that the u.s. has retaliation rights from the solar panels and the diswashers that trump put the tariffs on and if they use those retaliation rights on june -- paul: other countries in. >> méxico, mexico has retaliation rights and on june 1st, if the steel tariffs that donald trump has threatened on méxico go into effect, they can immediately use those retaliation rights and i think they will and that will harm red
12:27 pm
states. paul: all right, possibly trouble. democrats are still feeling the heat as polls show, what's behind the republican rebound? ♪ heartburn and gas? ♪ now fight both fast new tums chewy bites with gas relief all in one relief of heartburn and gas ♪ ♪ tum tum tum tums new tums chewy bites with gas relief so allstate is giving us money back on our bill.
12:28 pm
well, that seems fair. we didn't use it. wish we got money back on gym memberships. get money back hilarious. with claim-free rewards. switching to allstate is worth it. - anncr: as you grow older, -your brain naturally begins to change which may cause trouble with recall. - learning from him is great... when i can keep up! - anncr: thankfully, prevagen helps your brain and improves memory. - dad's got all the answers. - anncr: prevagen is now the number-one-selling brain health supplement in drug stores nationwide. - she outsmarts me every single time. - checkmate! you wanna play again? - anncr: prevagen. healthier brain. better life.
12:29 pm
12:30 pm
you're smart,eat you already knew that. but it's also great for finding the perfect used car. you'll see what a fair price is and you can connect with a truecar certified dealer. now you're even smarter. this is truecar. paul: good news for republican this is memorial day weekend as the midterm campaign season kicks into high gear, new polls show gop closing the gap when it comes to which party voters will support in november's
12:31 pm
congressional elections. latest real clear politics average showing the democrats lead narrowing to 4%, wall street journal columnist karl rove former senior advise the other george w. bush and fox news contributor. karl, good to see you again, thanks for coming in. the primaries have been rolling here, many states now. what's the big take away from your point of view? >> well, if you look at the generic ballot just before christmas, before they passed the tax cut, the democratic margin was 13 points, by mid february it was down to 9, by late march down to 7 and as you say memorial day weekend we find ourselves with 4 point advantage for the democrats. think about what's going on during that time, i think three things are at play here, one is improvement in the president's job approval, it's gone from being in the high 30's to the low 40's, that maybe 4-5 point increase may sound small but critical to the republicans and
12:32 pm
42, 43, 44% range. second of all, the economy, percentages of the economy are improving whether directly for tax cut or not, we can argue all day long but the fact of the matter is the way people -- paul: people feel better. >> democrats are going to primaries and are starting to see who the democrats are putting up and i'm not certain that's necessarily helping the democrats in each and every case. paul: you say that i've seen the race in nebraska, texas, pennsylvania, the left side of the party is winning in districts that are competitive districts where that kind of message may not play as well as centrist voice, is that your point? >> yeah, i think it's two things. one, they are nominating some left-leaning candidates like in nebraska and pennsylvania, one, but even when the candidates have entered the race not as left-wing candidate, the rhetoric that they feel compel
12:33 pm
today adopt in democratic primary places them to the left of where they need to be, remember, in order to twin house, the democrats will have to win districts that are at least purple and in some instances red. paul: okay, here is the thing, though, the buggy nerric ballot, there's no question it's tightening. the margin for holding the house according to kevin mccarthy, the majority leader is 6, within 6 the republicans think they can hold the house but this doesn't take into consideration, democratic voter enthusiasm. i've talked to republicans in some of the special races, ed gallespie told me the democratic didn't turn out entirely in the data on election day because democrats are so fired up that they exceed the polling, what do you think of that? >> i think that's accurate but a long time between november 2017 virginia governor's race and the november 2018 midterm elections and we have seen this year
12:34 pm
conflicting information. we've had a great deal of -- of media commentary that pointed towards big turnout by democrats in texas even suggesting that they might eclipse the republicans, well, half many people voted in republican primary and the runoff is the lowest in history and ohio republicans outvoted the democrats both parties had competitive primaries for governor, the republicans far outvoted the democrats. so, again, it's hard to say, i would say that enthusiasm is on the side of the democrats but whether that's sufficient enough, we don't know, we have an eternity to go between now and november and all kinds of things can happen to effect voter enthusiasm in each party's likelihood of turning out. paul: seems to me something else the happening and that is that the democrats who have focused on robert mueller, robert mueller, donald trump and now talking impeachment are begin to
12:35 pm
go shift, maybe impeachment is running republican enthusiasm. democrats are turning to health care, rising costs, rising premiums and gasoline prices which we know have gone up for a variety of reasons as the summer driving season increases. are those two republican vulnerabilities? >> they are. you put your finger on a really interesting point which is the democrats have moved away from impeachment. i think it's for two reasons, one it obscures chance to talk about broader issues and second of all, remember, in order to win these districts, in these states, many instances they will have to win swing independent voters and it's interesting, veterans are strong in favor of impeachment, republicans strongly oppose to it and independents tend to look more like the republicans than they do democrats. paul: if you were laying a democratic hat, you would say
12:36 pm
lay off impeachment? >> oh, yeah, the voices have been right on. whether or not every candidate is going to listen to him is another thing and during the primaries rhetoric, even if they have not come out and endorsed resistance by calling impeachment, candidates who have been moderate or centrist in views have adopted rhetoric which makes them sound off resistance. for example, in dallas, democrats talked about how trump will take us into a world that will destroy the world and it's common sense versus quote idiocy, the language even if they don't endorse, part to have resistance. paul: not necessarily swing district. >> plano. paul: thank you, karl.
12:37 pm
progressive patrons may be backfiring. finally. hey ron! they're finally taking down that schwab billboard. oh, not so fast, carl. ♪ oh no. schwab, again? index investing for that low? that's three times less than fidelity... ...and four times less than vanguard. what's next, no minimums? ...no minimums. schwab has lowered the cost of investing again. introducing the lowest cost index funds in the industry with no minimums. i bet they're calling about the schwab news.
12:38 pm
schwab. a modern approach to wealth management. burning, pins and needles, of diabetic nerve pain these feet... ... made waves in high school... ... had a ball being a dad... ...and built a career in construction. but i couldn't bear my diabetic nerve pain any longer. so i talked to my doctor and he prescribed lyrica. nerve damage from diabetes causes diabetic nerve pain. lyrica is fda approved to treat this pain from moderate to even severe diabetic nerve pain. lyrica may cause serious allergic reactions
12:39 pm
suicidal thoughts or actions. tell your doctor right away if you have these, new or worsening depression, or unusual changes in mood or behavior. or swelling, trouble breathing, rash, hives, blisters, muscle pain with fever, tired feeling or blurry vision. common side effects are dizziness, sleepiness, weight gain and swelling of hands, legs, and feet. don't drink alcohol while taking lyrica. don't drive or use machinery until you know how lyrica affects you. those who have had a drug or alcohol problem may be more likely to misuse lyrica. now i have less diabetic nerve pain. and i love building memories that can't be washed away. ask your doctor about lyrica.
12:40 pm
booking a flight doesn't have to be expensive. just go to priceline. it's the best place to book a flight a few days before my trip and still save up to 40%. just tap and go... for the best savings on flights, go to priceline. paul: starbucks finding itself at the center of another controversy this week, this time over new guest policy, the coffee chain announced last weekend that it would allow visitors to use its coffees including restrooms whether or not they make a purchase. a response to april arrest of two black men in one of its philadelphia stores. the new policy not a hit with
12:41 pm
all of the coffee chain's patrons however saying it won't leave seats to customers. starbucks close 8,000 stores this coming afternoon for mandatory racial bias training. we are back with dan henninger, mary anastasi au ogrady and jillian melchoir. >> it represents something and what it represents is howard schultz great insight when he was starting out with starbucks that liberalism was not nearly politics but the political liberalism had become a lifestyle, a way of thinking about the world, you know, in the old days you bought a coffee, you got black coffee in
12:42 pm
ceramic cup anymore, not anymore, you drink it through white foam and when you read on the wall, that you're not nearly buying coffee, your money is going to support coffee or even to fight climate change. paul: i tell you, dan, i still think it's about coffee, explain why howard schultz can't win here? >> after the incident in philadelphia which two black men were arrested in using the bathroom, weren't buying anything, said they were there on business, the manager had them arrested, there was a video made of it, it went viral. starbucks accused of being racist. now, one of the things that in this world you cannot be accused of and survive and so starbucks immediately announced as we just suggested in the introduction that they would close all 8,000 of their stores next tuesday afternoon to summit their employees to sensitivity training. i personally think, paul that
12:43 pm
the starbucks the most sensitive people in the world. i think they already know about trying not to be racist but you can't win, you cannot make progressives happy anymore, we have seen this on campus, we have seen this in corporations that you cannot apiece -- -- appease and that's what they are finding out. paul: what do you do? >> you have an investigation and if you do something wrong, you apologize. i think they are putting employees in a terrible position, it's not the first time they've done this. they did a race together, campaign, they are putting employees in front of culture war, creating situation where they have to engage awkward conversations about race. if they have complicated situation and they will will be accused of racism.
12:44 pm
paul: they should have kept policy, you to buy something to be in the store, whether you want to use bathroom or sit and use computer as we know millions and thousands of people do, certainly in starbucks i visit, but you to buy something, that's policy, sorry, you can't be here. >> a very reasonable policy. paul: other places follow it. mary, you're a starbucks patron, i have seen you around with the cup. [laughter] paul: what do you make to it as a customer? were that was a long time, paul. i stopped going and one of the problems is that we have been everywhere and some in new york were not as cleaned where they used to be. there's lots of competition and other coffee shops, two different chains opened in my neighborhood in brooklyn. so, you know, i don't think they are thinking very much of customers. to jillian's point, i grew up in new york, i remember walking up with my brothers, have to buy
12:45 pm
something if you want to use the bathroom, that's so standard. >> they put chalk out of business. >> they had great doughnuts. it's not just starbucks, we shouldn't beat on them alone. this week bell de blasio told nypd should issue summons to people smoking marijuana in public than arresting them. smoking marijuana public in new york is still illegal. paul: technically illegal. >> the police say you are putting us in a tough position, are we suppose to enforce the law, let people go out and do whatever they want, the progressive view is anything goes and you get this kind of confusion and even chaos about whether you're doing the right thing or enforcing the law. paul: all right, thank you all. when we come back, one year after protests, the backlash
12:46 pm
against the progressive schools from the unlikeliest of places. because of all those miles? and because ice is cold. what's in your wallet? hello. give me an hour in tanning room 3. cheers! that's confident. but it's not kayak confident. kayak searches hundreds of travel sites to help me plan the best trip. so i'm more than confident. forgot me goggles. kayak. search one and done. [stomach gurgles] ♪when you have nausea, heartburn, indigestion, upset stomach, diarrhea... girl, pepto ultra coating
12:47 pm
will treat your stomach right. nausea, heartburn, indigestion, upset stomach, diarrhea.♪ try new pepto with ultra coating.
12:48 pm
12:49 pm
paul: it's been a year since green state college with protest, day of absence in spring 2017 when activists asked white students faculty and staff to stay off campus to call attention to issues of racism, when professor objected and students disrupted class and staged wider protests on campus, what has happened at the college since those protests garnered national attention last year may surprise you as our own gillian melchoir reported. jillian, first background. public university?
12:50 pm
>> public university. paul: how many students? >> 3,000 to 3,500 a year. they are known for being progressive. to the left of berkeley. motto is in latin, let et owl hand out. as liberal as you can possibly get. paul: part of the traction, people go there knowing. >> yeah, absolutely. it draws progressives. paul: what happened here that created the controversy? >> we have two things, first is they were going through equity plan that rests on the assumption that white people are racists. paul: equity plan? what is that? >> one of the things it would have done if you're new hire, equity justification, you can't just teach chemistry, with a gender focus or race focus. paul: i see. that rules out me, okay. >> yes. second thing they did was day of absence where white students were asked to leave the campus, professor weinstein objected to this, he said he thought that
12:51 pm
was really offensive and racial segregation and that ended up triggering these massive protests. you had students occupying the building, holding professorses hostage and demanding firing. paul: and he was, in fact, forced to go, was he not? >> yeah, he sued the university for creating hostile environment, they settled for 500,000 as condition, he and his wife no longer teach there. paul: okay, what are we finding out now a year later about the impact of all this controversy? >> every university -- paul: university of missouri. >> every university where we have seen administration give-ins so radical protesters you see backlash. i was interested in evergreen because it has far-left reputation. there are a lot of people on the left who care about free speech and free inquiry and horrified by what they saw. it's losing support of donors,
12:52 pm
prospective students, enrollments down 17%, they will lose 500 to 60000 students? >> that's a lot for school, that's a big deal. >> financially in trouble, tuition is half of revenue. they had to tip into emergency fund. they are in trouble. paul: what's the response of the university to your reporting, you dug into public documents, you solicited documents and found out what they wouldn't have announced publicly? >> not our fault, this is the fault of weinstein for politicizing the issue. they say that this is the fault of the media, they're basically doubling down on the same identity politics, so i think they are going to see a lot more backlash. paul: any impact on the president of the school? >> still in place and putting inclusion at the center. paul: what's his name? >> george bridges. paul: he's still pushing accelerator down. bill, what do you make this as signal culturally, encouraged by
12:53 pm
what's happening? >> i'm encouraged by some of the response, this is since the french revolution, the left has been eating its own. at some point the revolution turns on the people, on campuses this is how we see the original progressive goals of color blindness, now led to gender quotas and all sorts of things, free speech is leading to speech codes and tolerance is leading to intolerance. they don't seem to be able to create rules of the game where everyone has -- to actually learn requires some basic values and they don't seem -- i don't blame students, i blame the faculty and the president, so few are willing to stand up to defend the institution that they run and we saw this in vietnam war too. think of the protests. more violent at universities where there was probably more support for the antiwar movement than there was in regular country. paul: dan, could this possibly be something of a culture
12:54 pm
turning point, do you think if people see that the university of missouri and evergreen, real consequences for allowing disorder to break out and dominate over education? >> it possibly could be, paul, as jillian reported, there are some people sending children to evergreen who self-identify as people of the left but say they are not signing up for something like this sort of chaos and i will say very interesting, paul, the washington post had a poll this week in which 50% of the people polled said that they think that demonstrations today are more violent and more unruly than they were 50 years ago and they don't like it, so i think the kind of just chaos that progressives are creating in places like ever green are being noticed. >> i think they are in real trouble. you know, it's been interesting talking to different students who considered evergreen,
12:55 pm
crossed it off list, one-third of the students said they were terrified of academics mobbing, so i think this university is in trouble. paul: great, thank you, jillian, catch podcast, 30 minutes on what happened at evergreen. we have to take one more break, when we come back hits and misses of the week. it's ok, it's ok. we've got time. ♪ [impact collision] rawwggwwrughh! [impact collision] ...ughhhh! what!!! seeing your real-life millennium falcon get damaged is painful enough. filing your insurance claim shouldn't be. esurance makes it easy. so you can get on to your next adventure. oh, we gotta pick up my mom. ...ughhhh! ♪ esurance. see solo: a star wars story now playing.
12:56 pm
a trip back to the dthe doctor's office, mean just for a shot. but why go back there, when you can stay home with neulasta onpro?
12:57 pm
strong chemo can put you at risk of serious infection. neulasta helps reduce infection risk by boosting your white blood cell count, which strengthens your immune system. in a key study, neulasta reduced the risk of infection from 17% to 1%, a 94% decrease. applied the day of chemo, neulasta onpro is designed to deliver neulasta the next day. neulasta is for certain cancer patients receiving strong chemotherapy. do not take neulasta if you're allergic to neulasta or neupogen (filgrastim). ruptured spleen, sometimes fatal as well as serious lung problems, allergic reactions, kidney injuries, and capillary leak syndrome have occurred. report abdominal or shoulder tip pain, trouble breathing or allergic reactions to your doctor right away. in patients with sickle cell disorders, serious, sometimes fatal crises can occur. the most common side effect is bone and muscle ache. so why go back there? if you'd rather be home, ask your doctor about neulasta onpro.
12:58 pm
>> my hit of the week is tough luf from parents who evicted their son in court. he was 30 year's old and he refused to leave.
12:59 pm
>> leave home. >> he didn't get out. italian restaurant offered him a job f he wants to stand on his own as 30-year-old, now is his chance. paul: any word whether he took it? >> no word yet. paul: dan. >> u.s. congress passed right to trial legislation which gives seriously-ill patients, allows food and drug administration and drug companies to give seriously-ill patients access to experimental drugs, far from ideal law but makes significant progress on the battle that goes back 30 years, president trump deserves credit for pushing right to trial legislation and he says he's going to sign it this week. paul: bill, i love my parents and they were great but i have to tell you when i was 22 i was out the door, man. [laughter] paul pail i didn't wanting to back and they didn't want me to go back. remember, if you have your own hit or miss, remember to tweet it to us, that's it for this
1:00 pm
week's show, thanks to my panel, thanks to all of you for watching, i'm paul gigot, we hope to see you right here next week. >> we begin with fox news alert, utah man who was jailed in venezuela for 2 years is about to be home free in america again, on his way to washington as we speak. 26-year-old joshua was released from prison today, had been arrested on weapon's charges in 2016 shortly after he got married. hello, everyone, welcome to news headquarters, i'm ed henry. >> i'm laura ingle, president trump to meet with holt at the white house today. ellison barber, big day there. >> yeah, laura, it is, according to president trump we expect holt to arrive around with his family, 7:00 o'clock this evening, he and his wife boarded a plane in venezuela thi