tv The Rachel Maddow Show MSNBC January 2, 2014 9:00pm-10:01pm PST
last month and giving a speech to foreign security ministers, in which he said, we can no longer sustain these u.s. policies. so i think we're seeing change ahead. >> ethan nadelmann and vanita, thank you both. that is "all in" for this evening. the rachel maddow show starts now. the first month that massachusetts did its own version of obamacare, the first month of health reform at the state level, where people were allowed to sign up on their own in massachusetts, state-wide enrollment for coverage in month number was a grand total of 123 people. not 123,000, just 123 people. by the end of the second month in massachusetts, 2,000 people had signed up for health insurance in that state. by the end of the third month, it was 5,000 people who had signed up for health insurance in massachusetts. so it was a very, very slow start, but then it took off. and the massachusetts plan,
which is the model for what we did as a country, massachusetts is now seen as a huge success, or it's at least seemed to have done exactly what it was designed to do. in massachusetts, something like 98% of the population now has health insurance because of that law. and that's how it started. that is the template. that is the blueprint that we are following for health reform nationwide. and now, now, because december has ended. again, happy new year, now we can see how we are doing as a country, alongside the blueprint, alongside that previous example of how massachusetts did a as state. we can look at our first three months against how massachusetts did in their first three months. we know that the massachusetts plans, the massachusetts plan worked in the end. and now we know, as a nation, that our experience with the first three months of this policy as a country, our first three months looks a lot like what those first three months looked like in new england seven years ago, on that much smaller
scale. everybody was very worried, when the first month's number came out on obamacare and showed that only 100,000 people had enrolled for health insurance. but by the end of the second month, nationwide, by the end of november, it was up to 365,000 people. now, we just got the new data for december, and it turns out that as went massachusetts, so goes the nation. we're now up to 2.1 million people enrolled. and that is just for people who have signed up for new health insurance using one of the exchanges. in addition to that, nationwide, another 3.9 million people have gotten new coverage thanks to obamacare. not through the exchanges, but, instead, through the expansion of existing insurance programs like medicaid or s-chip, which is the program for kids. so 2.1 million through the exchanges, another 3 million through these existing programs being expanded. how did 2013 end up going for the signature legislative achievement of this presidency? yes, it started off bumpy, but it kind of now looks like it's going to work. i don't know why more writing about obamacare doesn't compare obamacare to or at least put it in the context of the state where we piloted this
experience, just seven years ago, in massachusetts. but when you do compare them, when you compare the test drive to now owning the car, what's happening federally looks like it really does mirror the launch of that ultimately successful state-level program that nobody likes to call romney care. and this, of course, is good news if you want health reform to work. the number of people signing up and the rate at which that line graph is ascending, that's good news if you want health reform to work. it's terrible news if you want health reform to not to work. and one of the fascinating things to watch this year is going to be, what becomes of the right-wing cottage industry that sprung up over the last few months in this country to argue that people should not want to get health insurance. i mean, this is going to go down into the annals of american political history as one of the weirder things that the political right has ever worked on. and it may be just an obsession of right-wing groups that take money from the koch brothers. it does seem like most of these don't get insurance things are founded by the koch brothers, and the koch brothers are some of the world's richest men and they can afford all kinds of
expensive failures. but what's going to happen in the long run? what is going to happen over the course of this new year in 2014? what is going to happen to the giant, creepy, uncle sam papier-mache head that pops up in your gynecologist's office? as more and more americans decide they do want to get health insurance, are the koch brothers going to keep funding these ads and organizations, trying to convince college students that refusing to have health insurance is doing your part for the revolution or whatever? i think at the end of 2014, are they still doing to be trying to sell the idea that if you have health insurance, that means there will be a creepy puppet with a giant head doing your prostate exam. and you don't want that now, boys, do you? i mean, what happens to those ads? what happens to these groups? what happens to websites like this? uncover obamacare, which have been gleefully plotting the low number of people enrolling to get health insurance. but they stopped updating their ticker when the numbers got
uncomfortably high, so they keep showing old numbers. even though this particular group is based in florida, it's the same group that have been running those ads in florida, that tell people in alaska they shouldn't enroll for health insurance either. these billionaire-funded ad campaigns and websites and organizations telling americans that you're a sucker if you got health insurance, i think this is one of the weirdest and most underreported turns in right-wing politics this year. but the way things are going now, with health reform now seemingly starting to work, it's going to be fascinating over the course of 2014 to see if those groups stick around, to see if those groups and those campaigns
and those websites and those creepy ads are still around this time next year. but telling people not to get health insurance is not the only thing this these groups have been working on. the florida foundation for government accountability, this koch brothers affiliated group that ran the alaska don't enroll came, and then sent its experts traveling around not just to florida but to oklahoma and idaho and mississippi and new hampshire and virginia, telling all those state governments to make it as hard as possible for people to get health insurance in their states, that group is also now just turned up a as loser in another big political fight in florida. now, if you want to know what these koch brothers affiliated state groups are working on, other than telling people not to get health insurance, in florida they, at least, have been promoting forced drug tests for people who are on welfare. florida republican governor rick scott loved this idea when he
first ran for florida governor in 2010. after he signed it into law in 2011, the koch brothers connected florida group helped champion and defend this policy as well worth the money. that law ultimately led the state of florida to spend hundreds of thousands of dollars proving that, as it turns out, welfare recipients appear to use drugs at roughly one-fourth the rate of the general population. florida's drug test to the poor bill was initially proposed as a way that the state would save tons of money, but it ended up being a boondoggle, a hugely expensive way to discover almost no illegal drug use. and a series of court rulings has now found it to be wildly unconstitutional. a few months after the program was first implemented, a federal court ruling blocked it, and the court ruling, the judge of the court ruling went out of her way to basically laugh at the state for having cited one particular florida think tank for their evidence as to why the law was such a good idea. this was from the ruling. you almost never see anything this blunt in a court order. the state offers, as evidence of the cost savings, a pamphlet from the foundation for government accountability. the data contained in the pamphlet is not competent expert opinion nor is it offered as such, nor could it be reasonably
be construed as such. that's the koch brothers group that has been promoting this idea, right, the same koch brothers group that has been telling people not to get health insurance. they're the ones that came up with the idea that it's a great use of state funds. the court laughed out loud at that in their ruling. that court ruling was from the fall of 2011. just a few months before the florida drug test the poor policy went into effect. the policy got blocked by the courts. the state was mocked by trying to have pretended that this koch brothers group was some sort of expert think tank on the subject. but even after that, that same group, the koch brothers affiliated group, they traveled around the country marketing florida's great policy success as something that all the republican-controlled states should try to do. look, here's their press release about how they attended public hearings in georgia to share florida's drug test the poor success story. here's the guy who was the author of that pamphlet that the court laughed at in its court ruling. here's him being photographed
with a republican state senator from wisconsin. we got to hear all about florida's awesome new drug test to the poor law, when this group presented it as a success story, that other states should emulate at a conference hosted by alec, the conservative corporate funded policy group that markets model legislation for state lawmakers. that process of taking a piece of legislation that republicans managed to get passed somewhere and turning it into a national phenomenon, that is one thing that the right does really, really, really well right now. and so even as florida's policy, this drug test the poor policy, became a laughing stock in the state, even as it was declared unconstitutional as soon as they tried to put it into effect, even at it became a really obviously apparent boondoggle in the state that definitely wasn't going to save any money,s after the going to cost a ton of money, and that was going to expose the opposite of the problem that it purported to solve, even as all of that was happening, in florida, the place that came up with this law in the first place, these conservative groups, through networks like alec, right? they were able to convince other
repuican-controlled states to try it as well. lack, quote, in 2013, alone, at least 30 states proposed bills related to drug screening and testing, with some even extending it to federal benefits, including unemployment insurance. that's from the minneapolis "star tribune," which wrote about this over the holiday break. wrote about the reason of minnesota over the implementation of that state's version of the law. quote, there was little debate in the minnesota legislature last year when random drug testing was added to an amendment of an omnibus health bill. the bill passed the state senate in 2012. but now that it's going into effect, quote, counties across the state of minnesota are scrambling to enforce the rules. for many county governments across minnesota, the law has become a logistical headache. the new law, quote, could end up costing taxpayers far more than it saves. just one day before that, similar worries in the "kansas
city star", where missouri this past year was the most recent state to install drug testing for welfare recipients and where neighboring kansas is scheduled to be next. the program's price in missouri described as, quote, astronomical by one state's legislature, quote, a horrible waste of state resources. costs in missouri include $170,000 just for staffing administrative hearings for the people who are getting denied benefits. in kansas, they've already earmarked nearly $1 million to pay for this policy, including $600,000 for upgrading computers to get ready for the testing program. really? you think you're going to save money with that much money invested? on new year's eve, a federal appeals court in florida ruled again on the policy that started this new trend in the red states. remember, the florida policy was originally stopped by the courts just a few months after it was implemented in 2011. but on new year's eve, on tuesday night, the appeals court affirmed that ruling and shut the program down.
saying, in no uncertain terms, quote, there is no set of circumstances under which the warrantless, suspicionless drug testing at issue in this case could be constitutionally applied. it's over. i mean, rick scott in florida is running for re-election, as governor. he says he will appeal this ruling. he says he not only wants to deep this drug testing, he loves this program, but he wants to expand it and run on that when he runs for re-election. but unless the u.s. supreme court does something really unexpected and overturns this series of court rulings, it kind of seems like rick scott's signature drug test the poor policy is dead. it is at least dead at home. but thanks to the foundation for government accountability, this koch brothers related group, and thanks to alec and all these other right-wing groups that spread this stuff around the country, even though it's dead at home, policy like this may still be coming soon to a state near you. the day after that ruling, killing the florida policy, the jackson clarion ledger in mississippi ran an interview with mississippi's republican governor, phil bryant.
they asked him what his big ideas were for the state of 2014. and he said his big priority for mississippi, for 2014, for this new year is, drug testing for welfare recipients. it's constitutionally dead in the place that started it. everyone else that has taken it on thinks it's a failure and a boondoggle. but still, this stuff still keeps spreading. because if there's one thing the right actually is good at, it's spreading bad ideas nationwide. joining us now is the national director of the aclu of florida, eric simon. thank you for your time. i know that you're involved in this case that ultimately seems to have struck down florida governor rick scott's sort of signature drug testing law. why do you think the governor championed this law in the first place? was it addressing a known problem in the state? >> well, he trapped himself into this by his rhetoric when he was a candidate for governor. i have to say that what he did because shamelessly exploit ugly prejudices and false stereotypes that people have about the poor. i say shamelessly, because he knew the facts, some of the facts, beforehand. there was an experiment in florida several years ago that
failed and then he kept repeating the same thing over and over again, even after three months into the program, as you have just reported, the rate of positive tests for people who are applicants for welfare was about one-fourth of the general population. and he knew that. and he kept repeating it. and i think, frankly, what it's all about, it's more about politics than it is the law. it's his effort to exploit for political purposes, what he thinks are the ugly stereotypes and prejudices that people have about people on welfare. >> the thing that seems fascinating to me about this policy is that because of your court case, because of the case in florida that stopped this so early on, and because the initial data about what went wrong immediately with this policy once it was implemented, it seemed like it was very, very apparent to be a failure. just seemed like it was very clearly a misfire. hugely expensive. it showed the opposite of the problem that it purported to solve. it showed people who were receiving welfare benefits were using drugs at much smaller than the rate of the regular
population. so to see that failure in florida not translate into other states seeing that florida spread up so they don't have to, seeing it then thereafter spread around the country is a hard thing to understand. is there anything about this court ruling that will affect it applicability in other states. >> it depends what you mean by waste and failure. rick scott is spending other people's money. the fact that it doesn't work, i don't think he really cares about that. what is success and what's failure? it's a popular issue to be exploited by right-wing politicians like our governor. the fact that it doesn't work is irrelevant. the fact that it whips up the public and generates a lot of support, that's what he would define, i think, as success.
he rode into office, in part, this was one of his big issues, and apparently crusading on this issue, going all the way to the u.s. supreme court, is what he's prepared to run on for re-election. >> do you think if this does become an issue in his re-election effort, if the democrat running against him takes the opposite side of this argument, do you have any sense in florida about how that might cut politically? obviously, people pander on issues like this, because they think it's going to win them votes. >> i don't want to be pollyannish about it, but there are a lot of people that are very capable of being seduced by ugly store yo types and prejudices. bear in mind, rachel, this is -- you've been reporting on voting issues, well, this is one part of a comprehensive assault that
this governor has launched on the constitutional rights of the people of florida. we have been involved in about 12 different lawsuits, mostly on voting. some on drug testing. there's a companion lawsuit that we have in which he is insisting upon drug testing, not merely applicants for territory assistants, but all state workers. everybody who works for state government. this is part of a comprehensive assault on the constitutional rights of floridians that we are fighting back on. >> howard simon, executive director of the aclu of florida. thank you for being here tonight. congratulations on this ruling. thank you. >> thank you very much, rachel. >> i should tell you that we received a response from a representative for the koch brothers -- >> we received a response from a
representative from the koch brothers tonight, when we called to ask them about their thoughts on drug testing welfare recipients -- this group affiliated with them in florida has been promoting that alongside their promotion of more hard-profile issues like telling people not to get health insurance. the spokesperson for the koch brothers we reached tonight told us this on this subject. quote not sure i see how we would say anything to say on this, since we are not involved in this issue in any way." there you have it. much more to come. stay with us. asional have constipation, diarrhea, gas, bloating? yes! one phillips' colon health probiotic cap each day helps defend against these digestive issues... with three strains of good bacteria. [ phillips' lady ] live the regular life. phillips'.
it's hard to describe, because you have a numbness, but yet you have the pain like thousands of needles sticking in your foot. it was progressively getting worse, and at that point i knew i had to do something. once i started taking the lyrica the pain started subsiding. [ male announcer ] it's known that diabetes damages nerves. lyrica is fda approved to treat diabetic nerve pain. lyrica is not for everyone. it may cause serious allergic reactions or suicidal thoughts or actions. tell your doctor right away if you have these, new or worsening depression, or unusual changes in mood or behavior. or swelling, trouble breathing, rash, hives, blisters, changes in eyesight including blurry vision, muscle pain with fever, tired feeling, or skin sores from diabetes. common side effects are dizziness, sleepiness, weight gain and swelling of hands, legs and feet.
don't drink alcohol while taking lyrica. don't drive or use machinery until you know how lyrica affects you. those who have had a drug or alcohol problem may be more likely to misuse lyrica. ask your doctor about lyrica today. it's specific treatment for diabetic nerve pain. that talks about protecting, even after eating and drinking. crest pro-health has always done that. and addresses all these other areas as well. take your oral health to a new level. i am not gonna stop using pro-health. [ male announcer ] with the brand you can trust. go pro with crest pro-health.
[ male announcer ] this december, experience the gift of unsurpassed craftsmanship and some of the best offers of the year at the lexus december to remember sales event. this is the pursuit of perfection. this is sort of a stunning piece of video right here. check this out. this tape is paused right now, but what you're looking at off in the distance there, right underneath the big plume of smoke, that's a row of rail
cars. can you make that out? see that? that little bumpy line right there. those cars ran off the tracks, caught fire, and then this happened. >> there it goes. >> there it goes. >> wow. that rather armageddon-like mushroom cloud lit up the sky above north dakota, just a couple of days ago, earlier this week. and the reason that a train derailment turned into what looked like the end of the world is because that mile-long train which you see blowing up here, that train was in the process of transporting highly flammable crude oil across north dakota when this explosion happened. the train derailment and that subsequent massive explosion happened on monday afternoon in the town of casselton, north dakota, which is just outside of
fargo. casselton's a town of about 2,400 people. nearly all of them were forced to temporarily evacuate their homes after that explosion sent who knows what into the air above them. the fire ranged on for more than 24 hours. the temperature of the fire was reportedly so hot that fire crews could not get even close enough to it to try to start to put it out. so they just had to let it burn and burn and burn for more than a full day, before they could get close enough to fight it. the mayor of casselton, north dakota, told people, this is too close for comfort. there have been numerous derailments in the area. it's almost gotten to the point that it looks like not if we're going to have an accident, it's when. last month, the same rail company involved in this accident had another train derailment that involved rail cars that transport crude oil. in october, a north dakota farmer turned out what to be one of the largest oil spills in state history. 20,000 barrels of what leaked from a pipeline in his north dakota wheat fields. and while north dakota isn't the sight of the oil-related disaster, it is, in some ways,
the source of it. when that massive explosion in quebec in july killed 40,000 people, that explosion was caused by the derailment of a train, carrying a load of sweet, light crude from north dakota, from the bakken shale. north dakota over the last decade or so has become a state that's increasingly dependent on one industry. there's essentially an oil gold rush happening in north dakota right now. before the boom in 2008, the state was shipping about 18,000 barrels of oil a day by rail. by 2012, it wasn't 18,000 barrels a day, it was 425,000 barrels a day. and that number rose by another third in 2013. watching the state of north dakota deal with its sudden and new and dramatically different reality has been a fascinating experiment in watching the adaptability of governance. but the way that north dakota has adapted has also, sometimes, been alarming. this was the front page of the bismarck tribune newspaper
today. look at that right up there at the top. ross oil pit shut down. company ordered to stop using oil pit over town's drinking water. north dakota officials gave an oil company there the go-ahead to start dumping all their excess drilling material into a football field-sized waste pit on their drilling property. a waste pit that just happened to sit on top of one local town's water supply. what's the big deal? when residents there started to raise a fuss about it, officials finally ordered the company to stop dumping there. the local resident who raised the concerns about it in the first place told the paper, quote, it's a little frustrating, because we are not being protected by the people who are supposed to be protecting us. the state official, who's at least nominally in charge of protecting the state and its residents from the oil industry would be this guy. this is the state's top oil regulator. that train derailment and explosion that happened earlier this week on december 30th, just 2 1/2 weeks before that, the state's top regulator in charge
of the oil industry announced that his agency was putting together a special paper. a special paper to, quote, dispel this myth that oil is somehow an explosive, an explosive really dangerous thing to have traveling up and down your rail lines. he's going to do a special report to assure people there's no worries about shipping oil around the state. nothing to see here, folks. don't worry about a thing. why would you think it's dangerous or explosive? he said that 2 1/2 weeks before this happened. here's how weird things have gotten in north dakota. last month, state regulators determined that an energy company has been operating a pipeline in the state of north dakota for two years totally illegally. they had no permit to operate their pipeline. it was a natural gas pipeline. they never bothered to get the proper permits for it. by law, that kind of violation is subject to $10,000 fine. and not $10,000 total, but $10,000 per day, for each day the violation persists.
well, last month state regulators in north dakota looked into that violation. they determined that the company was, in fact, running an oil pipeline in the state for two years without a permit, and then they decided that the company will not face any fine whatsoever for doing that. no big deal! don't worry about it. don't worry about it, north dakota residents, nothing to see here. one of the commissioners who made that decision said that fining that company might deter other oil companies from considering future investments in the state. so, go ahead, companies. operate your pipelines without a permit. build illegally and operate them illegally. we don't care. north dakota is pumping a ton of oil and a ton of natural gas right now. north dakota is also, while they are doing that, experimenting with a type of governance that is usually called anarchy. corporate anarchy. and so far, the result is
kaboom. [ male announcer ] imagine this cute blob is metamucil. and this park is the inside of your body. see, the special psyllium fiber in metamucil actually gels. and that gelling helps to lower some cholesterol. metamucil. 3 amazing benefits in 1 super fiber. over the pizza place on chestnut street the modest first floor bedroom in tallinn, estonia and the southbound bus barreling down i-95. ♪ this magic moment it is the story of where every great idea begins. and of those who believed they had the power to do more. dell is honored to be part of some of the world's great stories. that began much the same way ours did. in a little dorm room -- 2713. ♪ this magic moment ♪ we're gonna be late. ♪
♪ ♪ oh are we early? [ male announcer ] commute your way with the bold, all-new nissan rogue. ♪ [ sniffles ] i have a big meeting when we land, but i am so stuffed up, i can't rest. [ male announcer ] truth is, nyquil cold and flu liquid gels don't unstuff your nose. they don't? [ male announcer ] nope. they don't have a decongestant. really? [ male announcer ] really. alka seltzer plus night fights your worst cold symptoms, plus has a fast-acting decongestant to relieve your stuffy nose. [ inhales deeply ] alka seltzer plus. oh. what a relief it is. [ male announcer ] can't find theraflu, try alka seltzer plus for fast liquid cold and flu relief. to stretch my party budget. but when my so-called bargain brand towel made a mess of things, i switched to bounty basic. look! one sheet of bounty basic is 50% stronger
we are watching heavy snow coming down in new york city in times square. snow is coming down hard. blowing and drifting is the snow across the harbor. 11 inches, 3 in central park, about two inches. these wind chill values, everyone is trying to clean up. so how'd you spend your holidays? reading spy novels and learning to lovely bitters all over again? me too. while we were all doing that, about 70 hearty souls spent their last week and a half stuck on a russian ship in antarctica. this is supposed to be a russian ice-breaking ship.
but on a trip home from a month-long research expedition, the icebreaker learned that it could not, in fact, break the necessary ice to keep moving and it got stuck. it got stuck on christmas eve and it stayed stuck until today when, finally, all 52 tourists and scientists on board got rescued. they got scooped up from a makeshift icy pel helipad and got flown to another ship nearby. crew members stayed on board with the ship so they can move it out of there when the sea ice breaks up. but the days stuck on the ship were not for nothing. the an arctic scientists said they used their stuck days to research the birds in the area. and drilled through the ice they were stuck in to take undersea photographs of whatever was alive down there and not stuck like them. we've got a story coming up in just a moment about an even more intrepid adventure at sea, including never before seen footage of something the united states has just invented. something that has never been done before, that is about to
[poof!] [beep] [clicks mouse] nice office. how you doing? good. automatic discounts the moment you sign up. [ female announcer ] covergirl p!nk. blend of rockstar and mama bear. her trublend? light 4. [ female announcer ] janelle. blend of punk and funk. deep 6. [ female announcer ] sofia. comedienne and colombiana. medium 6. [ female announcer ] now there's a trublend to match 99% of all women. find yours. it blends in. doesn't build up. [ female announcer ] for a flawless nude look. [ janelle ] so easy.
[ p!nk ] breezy. [ sofia ] beautiful. [ p!nk ] covergirl. [ female announcer ] find your trublend at covergirl.com. [ p!nk ] covergirl. peoi go to angie's listt for all kinds of reasons. to gauge whether or not the projects will be done in a timely fashion and within budget. angie's list members can tell you which provider is the best in town. you'll find reviews on everything from home repair to healthcare. now that we're expecting, i like the fact i can go onto angie's list and look for pediatricians. the service providers that i've found on angie's list actually have blown me away. find out why more than two million members count on angie's list. angie's list -- reviews you can trust. [ coughs ] i've got a big date, but my sinuses are acting up. it's time for advil cold and sinus. [ male announcer ] truth is that won't relieve all your symptoms. hmm? [ male announcer ] new alka seltzer plus-d relieves more symptoms than any other behind the counter liquid gel. thanks for the tip. [ male announcer ] no problem. oh...and hair products. aisle 9. [ inhales deeply ]
oh what a relief it is. ♪ this is a merchant vessel called the "cape ray," acquired by the united states of america in the 1990s. it's a 648-foot-long government-owned cargo ship. its crew is usually only about nine mariners. it's part of reserve of four dozen ships like this around the country that are kept in near operational state all the time, in case they're needed somewhere around the world. the "cape ray" from go to at-rest to fully operational in five to ten days which is impressively short. for such a big ship and for particularly for one with such a small crew. these cargo ships are flexible vessels that can be used in all sorts of circumstances. for example, in 2005, the cape ray was deployed to the gulf coast to deliver relief supplies for hurricane katrina. the cape ray was deployed again in 2010, to haiti, to help supply the relief effort after the massive earthquake in haiti.
the "cape ray" was activated twice to help move logistical supplies for the war in iraq. and again last year, the "cape ray" was used on the east coast for the relief efforts for hurricane sandy. it's now preparing to deploy again for its next big endeavor. but the "cape ray" is about to do something that it's never ever been done before anywhere in the world. you'll recall that in 2013, that was the year we did not go to war in syria, even though it seemed like we were going to, after the president announced that the syrian government had used chemical weapons against its own people. after he asked congress to authorize the use of military force, there was a diplomatic breakthrough on the issue. not a diplomatic breakthrough on the issue of the war overall so much, but on the specific issue of chemical weapons. it was a surprising, last-second, we're not going to bomb syria after all deal, in which syria not only admitted for the first time that they had chemical weapons, they agreed to
turn them over to be destroyed. and the inspectors went in, shown the facilities where are the stuff was stored, they were able to disabled the equipment that lets those be weaponized. the plans were started underway to get all of syria's chemical weapons moved out of that country and destroyed, even as the civil war there rages on. one problem, though. for a while, it seems like the biggest problem in this plan is that there was no were to ship this stuff. no country in the world wanted to have syria's chemical weapons on their territory. the nation of albania was asked. they said no. the nation of norway was asked. they also said no. finally, the united states started to consider a new plan to destroy syria's chemical weapons somewhere where there are no countries. eventually, the u.s. decided to dispose of syria's chemical weapons in the same place they disposed of the body of osama bin laden -- at sea.
in international waters. we know how to destroy chemical weapons. we've done it for years in places in this country like alabama and utah. but where it has never been done before, though, is on a ship floating around on the ocean. that is the political solution that apparently making the most sense for these chemical weapons and for now, that is the scientific solution that had to be invented, because it's never been done before. but the u.s. department of defense has now rolled out a new mobile system to destroy chemical weapons in bulk, on a ship, roiling out on the open ocean. >> this team's effort didn't start today. it started about a year ago. there was a recognition that something was going to happen in syria, in all likelihood, that would require us to do something with those chemical materials that were known to be there. we had no idea what senario it would be, that would play out. there were several options. i don't think we would have
picked the one that we're absolutely implementing now, if we had been asked to guess or even write down several possibilities. but a year ago, we were not in a position to do this. a year ago, we did not have the kind of capacity that was needed to go and remotely, in some other location, destroy chemical materials that were used in chemical weapons. >> a year ago, that process did not exist. but today, we got to take a firsthand look at this system. it's called the field deployable system. the system neutralizes chemical agents by mixing them with water, hot water and other chemical agents. you can see them stored here in these tanks. after mixing them in the system, they then get heated, and that turns them into compounds that can no longer be used as weapons. the liquid waste, the by-products of the process are then pumped into interim holding tanks for cooling, and eventually disposal by the same means that industrial waste is disposed of. this system, which, again, has
been invented for this process to be used at sea. it is a transportable system, it's self-sufficient and includes its own power generator. and for the first time on earth, it is designed to do this while floating. and consider the international effort here. the loading of the weapons is going to go first on to a danish ship, with support from the norwegians and the fins. russian and china say they will provide security in syrian territorial waters for that part of it. then that ship out of syria, carrying the weapons, is going to go to a port provided by italy. a port in italy, where the weapons will be cross-loaded on to the u.s. ship, the "cape ray," and then that u.s. ship will be sailing out to sea, into international waters, which nobody knows, and that's where the destruction of the chemical weapons will happen, using this process for chemical weapons that has never been done before. the process is expected to take 45 days. they're allotting themselves
twice that time to account for bad weather, during which time they will stop the process if they need to. this is brand-new technology. this is technology that has been used on land here in the u.s. to destroy chemical weapons, but it has never been tested at sea. it has never been used at sea. it is unclear, precisely, as to what we should expect, but this is a brand, brand-new thing. joining us now to help us understand is darrel kimball. he's executive director of the arms control association, which is a national nonpartisan group, supporting arms control policies and programs. mr. kimball, thanks very much for being here tonight. nice to have you here. >> good to be here. >> i am somebody who is interested in this stuff, but i have a totally nontechnical understanding of it. did i explain anything wrong there about what's about to happen here? >> your explanation was excellent. i mean, that's a very good technical description. i think you've summarized that this is unprecedented in the sense that this operation has not been done at sea. the technology has been proven, this hydraulasis technology, but
this is the first time they're doing this at sea. and i think it's going to be very difficult, but it's doable. it's a dangerous operation anytime you're dealing with these chemical weapons, precursor materials, as they're called, but they've got an expert team, many of them who are based from the aberdeen proving ground. it looks as though their going to be able to do this, if the chemical materials can be moved by the syrian government to the port of latokia and put on board that danish ship that you referred to. >> so that to you, at this point, is the question mark, or at least the thing that's worth worrying about the most in terms of the potential success of this operation, whether or not it can start, because the chemical weapons get moved to the right place to start the process. >> well, exactly. you know, the syrian government has been cooperating with every step of this chemical weapons elimination plan that was first worked out by the u.s. and russia, but they're now at the phase where they have to move in
dozens of ground transport vehicles, in big trucks, the material across land, on a road that is contested right now in the civil war. so, security is an issue. weather has been an issue. getting the right trucks and equipment to the syrians for the operation. russia has helped with that, has been an issue. my sources suggest that the syrians have all the equipment they need to move this, and so it's just a matter of making sure the road is secure, to get it to the port, so these operations at sea can begin to destroy this very dangerous material. >> what about the by-products of this process. obviously, we're not creating anything novel by virtue of doing this at sea rather than on land, but the products, the by-products that are the results of this hydralizing process are still dangerous. is it dangerous to have it on a ship rather than on dry land? >> the 1,700 tons of chemical
precursor material is going to be transformed into hazardous industrial chemical waste, the effluence. and that has to be disposed of on land, at sites that have yet to be determined. the organization for the prohibition of chemical weapons is now taking bids from about 38 different commercial entities to do that part of the work. so this is actually dangerous material, but it is not chemical weapons precursor material. these sort of operations, industrial chemical waste disposal are done all the time. some of them are transported on rail through our cities. like in the segment we just saw a few minutes ago. so all the steps in this operation have to be done carefully, but that part of the process is the least dangerous, but is getting this material on the ships, so it can be done properly, through this hydraulisis technology. >> darryl kimball, thanks very much for talking to us tonight. stay in touch. >> thank you. if you are ever completely lost and without a compass while
out walking with your dog, fear not. your dog can help. your dog might have a way to let you know where you are. just give him time. a moment of geek, coming up. a subaru... ...are the hands that do good things for the whole community: the environment, seniors, kids, and animals. that's why we created the share the love event. by the end of this year, the total donated by subaru could reach 35 million dollars. you get a great deal on a new subaru. we'll donate 250 dollars to a choice of charities that benefit your community. it feels good to be a helping hand.
to stretch my party budget. but when my so-called bargain brand towel made a mess of things, i switched to bounty basic. look! one sheet of bounty basic is 50% stronger than a full sheet of the bargain brand. bounty basic. the strong but affordable picker upper. diarrhea, gas, bloating? yes! one phillips' colon health probiotic cap each day helps defend against these digestive issues... with three strains of good bacteria. [ phillips' lady ] live the regular life. phillips'. ur?]7+expygcta8i
an interesting help wanted ad popped up in utah this week. the office of the attorney general in that state is officially looking for, quote, qualification and fee proposals for outside counsel to assist with the case of kitchenette et al versus herbert et al. the kitchen versus the herbert case is the case that shut utah's ban on same-sex marriage right before christmas. that ruling sent hundred of utah couples streaming to their county clerks' offices in some counties, salt lake people raced to the clerk's offices friday when the ruling happened. more people came back on sunday night to wait online all night sunday. to be first in line if they could when the clerk's offices opened up again on monday morning.
and that sort of immediate, race done to the clerk's office response, doesn't usually happen after a court ruling, right? i mean, utah is appealing the ruling. not necessarily a final decision. even so, there is usually a delay until things go into effect. right. in this case, it turns out utah screwed it up. state made a mistake in the way they handled the game marriage case. that's why all the couples in up taupe were literally able to run into their clerk's offices and start getting married as soon as the ruling came down. the utah attorney general's office its who screwed this up. like all attorney general's offices they're responsible for defending the state's laws in court. but in utah, that office has just been a bit of of a mess lately. this man, john swallow was just elected attorney general. he had to resign, not that long after being elected, after months of swirling allegations
about ethics violations, false, misleading statements abut his finances during his campaign and maybe a bribery plot that involved some one stealing part of the bribe. mr. swallow continues to deny allegations against him. he did quit as the attorney general of the state of utah at the beginning of september. once he quit, utah needed an acting attorney general immediately. that acting attorney general gig fell to this guy, brian tarbit. under this guy, brian tarbit, the federal court ruling came down on marriage before christmas, the friday before christmas. it turns out that the state attorney general's office forgot to tell the court that oh, hey in case your ruling will go against us, we want to ask ahead of time for a stay of the ruling we are going to appeal it. the acting attorney general in utah, the one filling in for the guy who got run out in disgrace, he forgot to file that request for a stay. just forgot to. and that's why the ruling was not stayed. and that is why it went into effect right then that very minute when the judge made his decision.
and that in the immediate sense is why hundreds of couples are legally and happily married in utah. the attorney general's office forgot to do something that you learn to dupe as a one l in law school even if your law school its not a good law school. wow. pretty quickly after the events. the governor chose a permanent attorney general. unfortunately for brian tarbit, brian tarbit was not the governor's choice. a giant failure. chose sean reyes. spent his first day on the job putting together working on utah's appeal of the district court same-sex marriage ruling. a little like having off to take the final exam on your first day of school. that is what brings us back to the help wanted ad. basically a giant sos from the brand new totally in turmoil screwup attorney general's office. the number one officer of the law is looking for help, help, help, from anybody. help from somebody, anybody who has experience in the federal courts of appeal and also please has expertise on the 14th amendment to the u.s. constitution and also please some understanding of a state's
right to define marriage. and can you start yesterday? today would be fine. tomorrow is a little late. according to the help wanted ad. proposals to help the state with its massive lawyering problems, are due in less than a week. applications due tuesday. 5:00 mountain time. must be welling to workweek ends. how is it going in the utah attorney general's office right now. think about it. seeing the first guy resign. the second guy lose the same-sex marriage case. fail to request the stay. then appointing a new guy to replace the losing, stay request failing guy. then begging anyone who can help to please help. i refer again to the help wanted ad. look. written proposals shall be submitted to brian tarbit by e-mail. that's who they had to put in charge of hiring the new help. the guy who was given the task of cleaning up the big mess, lost the case, forgot to file the stay request, then passed
over for the big job. now -- brian? we're going to need you to go ahead and look through the resume pile for anybody who can help us. help. the story is not over. the state has the asked the u.s. supreme court to put a hold on same-sex marriages in utah while the appeal is in process which could happen. so watch this space. but in the meantime, spare a thought for old brian tarbit, right? however it turns out, man, may 2014, job-wise go better for you than 2014 did. seriously. poor guy. [ bottle ] okay, listen up! i'm here to get the lady of the house back on her feet. [ all gasp ] oj, veggies -- you're cool. mayo? corn dogs? you are so outta here! aah! 'cause i'm re-workin' the menu, keeping her healthy and you on your toes. [ female announcer ] the complete balanced nutrition
of great-tasting ensure. 24 vitamins and minerals, antioxidants, and 9 grams of protein. i see you, cupcake! uh-oh! [ bottle ] the number one doctor recommended brand. ensure®. nutrition in charge™. aflac! got 'em. ♪ yeah, he's clean, boss. now listen to me, duck. i have an associate that met with, uh, an unfortunate accident. while he's been incapacitated, somebody's been paying him cash. now, is this your doing? aflac?
now, if i met with some such accident, would aflac pay me? ♪ nice. this is your stop. [ male announcer ] find out what aflac can do for you and your family... aflac? [ male announcer ] ...at aflac.com. and since he's such an adventurous little boy... whee! [ giggles ] [ grandma ] ...it gets filthy. but he's got such sensitive skin that you worry about what you use in the laundry. so, when i'm in charge, we do things grandma's way. my tide, downy, and bounce all come in free & gentle. so we get a cleaner, softer blankie. and grandma wins. [ giggles ] [ female announcer ] tide, downy, and bounce free & gentle. great on their own, even better together. [ sniffles ] i have a big meeting when we land, but i am so stuffed up, i can't rest. [ male announcer ] truth is, nyquil cold and flu liquid gels don't unstuff your nose. they don't? [ male announcer ] nope. they don't have a decongestant. really? [ male announcer ] really. alka seltzer plus night fights your worst cold symptoms,
plus has a fast-acting decongestant to relieve your stuffy nose. [ inhales deeply ] alka seltzer plus. oh. what a relief it is. [ male announcer ] can't find theraflu, try alka seltzer plus for fast liquid cold and flu relief. of the dusty basement at 1406 35th street the old dining table at 25th and hoffman. ...and the little room above the strip mall off roble avenue. ♪ this magic moment it is the story of where every great idea begins. and of those who believed they had the power to do more. dell is honored to be part of some of the world's great stories. that began much the same way ours did. in a little dorm room -- 2713. ♪ this magic moment ♪ if you are a dog owner or lover, this routine will look familiar to you.
circle, circle, circle, spiny dance your dog does before getting down to business. susan calls this squaring off to bunt when poppy does it. you know the move. you know what it means. if youtube is a guide, a thing people like to document abut their dogs. it is funny. probably somebody out there in a snowstorm with a plastic bag in one hand and camera in the other, giving this display on tape. a an explanation for why your dog does that just before going to the bathroom. turns out it is maybe not just for show. a team of scientists out of the czech republic in germany discovered that dogs have a directional tendency. results of a two year long study of 70 dogs, logging 2,000 owe -- occasions requiring plastic baggies and fire hydrants. their findings published in the journal "frontiers in zoology." they found that due to dog's extraordinary homing abilities,
turns out they prefer to ex-crete with their bodies aligned along a north/south axis. which means that these scientists, if correct, dogs are spinning around because they're aligning their butts to the earth's magnetic fields. dogs prefer a north-south direction for pooping. he is just trying to read his internal compass. trying to fiend north. circle, circle, sniff, north, poop. they measured pooping habits of dogs, beagle to transylvanian hounds, dogs are magnosensitive. birds use magnetic guidance to migrate. cattle, deer said to graze on a north/south axis. for dogs it's pooping. if you are ever lost with your dog, starless night, needed guidance or wanted to know. there is a scientific paper for
that. he knows what he is doing. i love my job. time for "the last word." have a great night. >> the holiday political truce is over. can democrats help bring help to the unemployed? can those on minimum wage get a raise? new signs are pointing to 2014 as the year of the liberal. >> i -- >> do solemnly swear. list push. >> the new direction for the democratic party. >> new progressive direction in new york. >> bill de blasio -- >> the 109th mayor of new york city. >> has many hoping for an era of progressive governance in gotham city. >> de blasio, a progressive champion.