Skip to main content

tv   The Rachel Maddow Show  MSNBC  February 19, 2014 1:00am-2:01am PST

1:00 am
he's resisted. as of yet. that will be very interesting battle to continue to watch. nick confessore, zephyr teachout. that's "all in." "the rachel maddow show" starts now. thanks to you at home for joining us. there's a lot going on in the news tonight including new reporting on the chris christie bridge lane scandal in new jersey. a new document has been uncovered. and some new figures are potentially being hauled into court in conjunction with the scandal. we'll get to that news this hour. also, there were another several dozen earthquakes in oklahoma today. several dozen. still with no official explanation. also an 84-year-old woman just got a shockingly long prison sentence because of a peace protest that she was part of. there's a lot going on tonight in the news. we're going it get to all of that and more throughout the course of the next hour. but we start here in 1989, in berlin. those iconic moments when the berlin wall was taken down, physically, by protesters
1:01 am
wielding sledgehammers and just tearing the wall apart by hand. that was 1989 when the berlin wall came down. it took until 1991, 2 years later, before the iron curtain had truly fallen completely. when the ussr, the soviet union spun apart into its pieces. the largest physical portion of what had been the soviet union, of course, survived more or less in tact as russia, but former soviet socialist republics like this one here, this big one, ukraine, they became their own nations in 1991 and in ukraine they did it without a war. yes, there were a lot of protests including some protests that ended in violence at the time but they did it without a war. well, today in the streets of ukraine, in the streets of ukraine's capital city, it very much looked like war. have you seen this today? we have had footage like this pouring in all day today for more than 12 hours it has looked
1:02 am
like this, and it is still going on now tonight. molotov cocktails, random explosions, large fires raging in close proximity to people. live ammunition. percussion grenades. hand to hand combat. images in the press of protesters on fire. including this one run by "the new york times" today. photos of grievously injured protesters and troops and police including some doctors on the scene saying they're treating live ammunition gunshot wounds. the latest death toll we have for what is going on in kiev right now is at least 18 people dead. but that number has been rising throughout the day and it's not clear whose official body count should necessarily be trusted here. this is an ongoing situation. these images you're looking at are not cold and combined images from a long time ago or a bunch of different protests. this is a live feed. we're showing you live pictures of what's happening right now tonight in kiev.
1:03 am
if the setting looks at all familiar for these images it's because the large-scale protests didn't just start now. the large-scale protests in kiev started in november. if you look at the map of ukraine, just in terms of where they are situated geographically in relation to other countries and other regions, obviously they are part of the former ussr. they have a long border with russia. they're not all that far from moscow. but much of ukraine, geographically and ethnically and to a growing extent politically, they orient themselves to the left of this map, to the west. toward europe as much as they do toward moscow. and these protests started, these mass protests started in november when ukraine's president had the opportunity to sign a huge trade deal with europe that would have knitted ukraine's economy much more into europe's economy. he had the opportunity to do that and he turned it down. he would not sign that deal and instead he essentially reupped with putin. reupped with moscow. he signed instead a $15 million
1:04 am
loan arrangement, and an arrangement to get lots of new cheap natural gas from vladimir putin as a replacement for that deal with europe that putin really did not want him to take. and that is when the mass protests started, and the opposition movement in ukraine is big. it's diverse. both in terms of its class and age and its range of ideologies and everything else. they, for a protest movement, for an opposition movement in a fairly repressive country, they're good at articulating what they stand for, what they stand against and have been really good at maintaining a huge presence visibly in public in the public square. and, yes, there have been moments of violence, but there have been longer stretches honestly it felt like a celebration, even at times an ongoing concert in the streets of kiev. and recently, really recently, like within the last few days, there had been hope that the standoff might have been, or might have politically negotiated ending. because the government floated the possibility of all the
1:05 am
protesters who had been arrested, they floated the possibility that those protesters might get some sort of amnesty. the amnesty deal was supposed to deescalate everything. reduce the threat of violence between the two sides, calm the situation down. the protesters who had been occupying city hall in kiev, in the capital city, they left two days ago after months of occupying that building because of the amnesty deal. but then today, it all just went off like a rocket. the government closed a new economic deal with russia yesterday. the protesters after only two days of being gone were back inside kiev city hall. they were back in huge numbers in independence square. and today, defying an order from the government that the protesters must leave and go home, they stayed. and ukrainian units drove armored vehicles into the barricades. those armored personnel carriers got stuck on the barricades. then they got set on fire.
1:06 am
the protesters besieged the troops in the personnel carriers. other troops came out to rescue their colleagues who were stuck. the personnel carriers were set alight. not just tear gas but grenades and molotov cocktails and what appears to be live fire. "the new york times" reporters on the scene today described, quote, elderly women clustered on the sidewalk, heedless of the gunshots and explosions, heckling, shouting at the police, shoot us, kill us, you bastards. the headquarters of the ruling party in ukraine were set on fire today. grenades and gunshots and fires as you can see raged all day today. the u.s. embassy tonight put out this statement to american citizens who may find themselves in ukraine, telling all americans to stay indoors, telling any u.s. citizens in hotels or buildings near the protests that they should leave if they can, if they can't, they should be prepared to stay
1:07 am
inside for several days. if large-scale clashes do continue to occur. meanwhile, the protesters are calling for more and more people, as many people as possible to find ways to head down to independence square and join them tonight in central kiev. to try to avoid police barricades by using side streets and alleys. the ukrainian government released its own statement today issuing a deadline, a deadline i should tell you has passed as of earlier tonight saying if the excesses of the protesters do not stop, quote, we will be required to restore order by all means provided by law. we will be forced to resort to harsh actions. nobody knows exactly what that means, but it looks like war already. and protesters have said they fear an escalation even beyond what we've seen today and tonight. vice president biden, tonight, has had a phone call with the president of ukraine. according to the white house readout from that call, mr. biden expressed grave concern regarding the crisis on the street there. he said the united states
1:08 am
condemns the violence calling on the ukrainian president to exercise restraint and pull back government forces. but looking at these pictures tonight, i mean, this is what it has been like all day, just watching this feed today in my office today, it's just been incredible. looking at these pictures tonight, looking at this ongoing battle, honestly while the olympics are under way not that far away next door in russia, it's clear russia, and geographically, russia a major player of what's going. it was the orientation that started this whole thing in the first place and the latest move by russia toward ukraine's government in the last 24 hours that seems to have set off the violence and the fires that are raging tonight. however much the ukrainians do or don't want it, it's clear that this is russia's corner of the world and they are key to what happens here. and to the safety of ukrainians who are out on the streets. but if that's so, if this is russia's corner of the world, what, if anything, do we have to
1:09 am
do with it? is there a way for any other country, is there an international way to be constructive in this situation with what looks like a civil war breaking out in the streets of a major nation? is there an international way to be constructive? is there an american way to be constructive in this situation or is this the sort of thing that we just need to monitor and watch and do nothing else? and is the obama administration inclined to try to find some sort of american way to resolve this situation? what is the obama presidency like when it comes to dealing with crises like this abroad in other people's necks of the woods? joining us now, andrea mitchell, nbc news chief foreign affairs correspondent and host of "andrea mitchell reports." thanks very much for being with us. >> you bet. >> we got this readout tonight of vice president biden calling the ukrainian president in the midst of the street battles going on in the capital city in kiev. why, why is it that it's vice president biden calling and not president obama? is this something you would expect to happen at a higher
1:10 am
level or a lower level? why him? >> it's a high level but not the highest level, and in fact, the very fact that putin has said, stay out of my backyard, would mean that it would be almost too much of an affront for president obama, himself, to get involved. one of the issues here has been the tug-of-war between putin saying this is my territory and the united states saying -- have a vested interest in this. look at what's happening in the streets. these like, battles. it doesn't look real. what we're seeing in the streets of kiev. yet it is all too real. and the deaths are real. and the stakes are very, very high. and think back to what happened just 24 hours ago. that's when putin upped the ante. he said he would guarantee these $2 billion in loans even as the rebel leaders were in berlin
1:11 am
visiting with angela merkel and the germans and the eu and you know the frustration that america has expressed through victoria nuland, the top official for europe, at the slowness of the european union to respond with money, to try to balance it and not have yanukovych, the president of ukraine be completely under the thrall of putin. the students, the others, protesters and rebel leaders saw russia offering this loan guarantee as the final blow to them that yunakovych was indeed going to be in line with russia and they would be completely frustrated in their efforts to align themselves with the west. >> andrea, these images that we're showing right now are live. it's just -- it's incredible. it's about 4:00 a.m., as you can see with the time stamp there, local time. this is happening right now. in terms of looking at the
1:12 am
dynamics under way, does the opposition in ukraine, either the organized opposition in terms of people who are in parliament and so forth, or the opposition leaders in the street, do they want and expect international help? do they see the united states as having a range of potential influence here? what are they asking for? >> well, the rebel leaders have been very much in touch with american and european union leaders, but the people in streets are not necessarily all connected. you mentioned the fact that there has been some violence. the rebel leaders have lost control of some of the people in the streets. this is not a completely unified situation, as these things never are. but they have been remarkably consistent given that this has been happening since december, as you pointed out. so the rebel leaders want help from us. they want some force to pull them back from putin's grasp. but putin is not going to negotiate on this. lavrov, his foreign minister
1:13 am
made it very clear in the last couple days with the west that they consider this their territory, and it would be as though they were mucking around in latin america, and you know how we feel about our territory. they feel that this is not a part of western europe. they think that this is part of the former soviet union. >> andrea, in terms of how these decisions are being made here in the united states, obviously that leaked phone conversation between victoria nuland and the ambassador to ukraine was fascinating just in terms of a window as to way our diplomats are working on this. but in the bigger picture, we've had two very high profile secretaries of state under president obama. hillary clinton first and now john kerry. when you look at a situation like ukraine or challenge of north korea with this report on their human rights that came out this week from the u.n. that was so harrowing. syria, these other challenges, foreign policy issues that are very vexing that the administration's dealing with. is the new state department noticeably different under john kerry since the departure of
1:14 am
hillary clinton? >> oh, yes. >> either in terms of their effectiveness or the way they approach this war? >> we don't know about the effectiveness but they're less risk averse. john kerry has run for president. he's not going to run for president again. hillary clinton very likely may. it's very clear the white house has controlled the foreign policy for both of these secretaries of state, but kerry has pushed back more and has been more aggressive in more cases. clinton chose the battles, but she was, first of all, very cautious about not picking a fight over with barack obama, this was the team of rivals and the fact she had run against him and they had been such political enemies, if you will, made it even more difficult for her to challenge him publicly, at least, on foreign policy. and then the national security council did not give her very much running room, so she chose things that were possible for her. women's issues and other issues of restoring respect for
1:15 am
american foreign policy after the wars in iraq and others that were very unpopular in europe. the tension policies of those, of course, have still continued in guantanamo, but trying to change some of the bush policies. that made the american foreign policy more popular initially, at least, under barack obama. but she didn't have that much leverage. as high profile as she was. she was greeted as a head of state in, you know, traveling with her in those first couple of years because she was hillary clinton. so she has a higher profile than john kerry. kerry is more willing to do, you know, the very tough slog of going back and forth between israel and palestine and what many people say is not going to be a productive mission, but he is taking some really big chances here. but in both their cases, and specifically with kerry, i think the most important thing that he's doing is iran, and that will be jeopardized by
1:16 am
challenging russia. but he last night joined other officials in the white house by really slapping at vladimir putin over his policy in syria. so they're all connected and it's hard to understand how he can make progress in iran while ignoring putin's role in syria, which they're no longer willing to do, and then you've got putin doing this in ukraine. it is very, very big crisis on a lot of fronts. >> it's a big crisis. it's one that's literally on fire right now. >> we. >> as you're pointing out, incredibly interwoven with these other dynamics. andrea mitchell. i miss talking to you. we haven't had you here in too long. thank you for being here tonight. >> you bet. >> andrea is the host of "andrea mitchell reports." move to a new time. moving to noon eastern starting on monday which means you need to change your whole day to accommodate that change in schedule. new reporting on the george washington bridge scandal in new jersey is coming up next.
1:17 am
please stay with us. try zyrtec-d® to powerfully clear your blocked nose and relieve your other allergy symptoms... so you can breathe easier all day. zyrtec-d®. find it at the pharmacy counter. zyrtec-d®. [ female announcer ] some people like to pretend a flood could never happen to them. and that their homeowners insurance protects them. [ thunder crashes ] it doesn't. stop pretending. only flood insurance covers floods. ♪ visit to learn your risk.
1:18 am
1:19 am
1:20 am
behold redactions. these black lines were not added by me. i'm more of a highlighter kind of gal. rather than a black magic marker person. when you get official redactions like in a publication, like in this book, "the black banners" about interrogating al qaeda suspects, in a book like that, publications, the redactions are nice and tidy because they do them with a machine.
1:21 am
when it's some guy crossing out things by hand, it admittedly looks a little more sketchy. in 908 pages of documents and e-mails and text messages that were handed over by chris christie ally david wildstein when the bridge lane scandal broke open in new jersey, either mr. wildstein or his lawyer just marked up by hand about 45 pages of the 908 pages. what's underneath the black marks? today somebody appears to have finally found out. the "star-ledger" and "bergen record" reporting today the special counsel met with david wildstein's lawyer in private and looked at the unredacted documents. at what was under the black magic marker. so the special counsel apparently has seen what has been blacked out in these documents. it's not clear that anyone else has seen them. except him. but apparently he has. in private. nobody else has seen them. certainly none of them have been made public. except for one. one line.
1:22 am
this is a really strange development. the newark "star-ledger" newspaper is reporting that it has obtained what appears to be one of these text messages that was crossed out in the public documents. now, oddly, the "star-ledger" is reporting that its editorial board specifically has this new text message, not one of its beat reporters who's been working the story, but somebody on their editorial board. and according to the "star-ledger" they say the text message they have obtained concerns this man. he's republican state senator in new jersey. and there's an interesting story about who he is. new jersey governor chris christie's first mentor in politics was a man named tom kean. his name looks like kean but pronounced cane. he represented chris christie's neighborhood when chris christie was a kid and the "new republic" reported when chris christie was 14 years old he walked up to his assemblyman's front door, tom
1:23 am
kean's doorbell, asked him for advice, how he, chris christie, could some day get elected to public office. he was 14. tom kean was his first mentor in politics. chris christie's first involvement in grown-up electoral politics was working on the tom kean for governor program and tom kean went on from the assembly to become a popular two-term governor of new jersey. when he left office, he was one of the most popular political figures in new jersey ever. tom kean was respected enough he was asked to co-chair the 9/11 commission after september 11th. tom kean and chris christie were long seen as inextricable in new jersey politics. that's why it was so notable and unexpected when chris christie moved against tom kean. as soon as chris christie was reelected to start his own second term as governor, one of the first moves he made after his re-election was to try to force the republicans in the legislature to drop their leadership in the senate. to drop their republican senate leader and pick somebody else
1:24 am
instead. the guy who chris christie was trying to force out as republican leader in the state senate is named tom kean. tom kean jr. the former governor's son. and what's worse, it didn't work. as soon as governor christie was re-elected he took a huge shot at the son of his former mentor, the son of the most respected republican in the state of new jersey and it didn't work. tom kean jr. survived and held on to his leadership position, but it was such a bizarre and unexpected move from chris christie to try to overthrow him. and here's the thing. here's the thing. here's the newly relevant thing. the guy who chris christie wanted to replace tom kean jr. with was this guy. kevin o'toole. chris christie wanted him, this guy, in place so badly as the top republican in the senate that he burned the strongest and oldest bridge he had in politics. he wanted kevin o'toole in there so bad he was willing to betray tom kean like that.
1:25 am
you want to know what happened to kevin o'toole? turns out he's the one senate republican who has been assigned to the committee investigating the bridge scandal. oh. and now the newark "star-ledger" reports it's received a text message that no one else has seen. david wildstein texts bill baroni something about an o'toole statement being ready right after bill baroni finished up his statement to the legislature. the cover story, what happened to the bridge lanes in september was nothing political, nothing untoward, it was just a traffic study. we know bill baroni gave that misleading testimony on november 25th, false testimony with the cover story about a traffic study that wasn't a real thing. that was november 25th. we also know right after that testimony was over, at noon that day, bill baroni texted david wildstein three question marks. this is as soon as he was done with the testimony. mr. wildstein's first response
1:26 am
was, port authority police department said all was fine. then bill baroni asks for trenton feedback specifically, and mr. wildstein texts back, good. trenton feedback. good. then there's a line that's redacted. then mr. baroni asks, just good? then he swears. then mr. wildstein goes on to assure him other trenton people who appear to be staffers in governor christie's office thought he did just great with his cover-up testimony. the "star-ledger" appears to be reporting that is where mr. wildstein texts this statement, o'toole statement ready, to bill baroni. o'toole statement ready. he sent that message right after bill baroni finished his testimony. sure enough on that same day, senator kevin o'toole released a statement that took the bill baroni line, repeated the story from his testimony, repeated the cover story about the supposed traffic study. the next day he published a similar version of the statement
1:27 am
as an op-ped in the newspaper, in the "bergen record." think about this for a second. in the legislature, the highest profile person advancing the cover-up, advancing the false cover story about the fake traffic study in a statement he released from his office then an op-ped he released the next day, which apparently was ready to go as soon as the testimony was over, ready to go already, really? within just a minute of the testimony on colluding? the guy who had that statement echoing the coverup, ready to go, was kevin o'toole. a very close ally of governor chris christie. somebody who governor chris christie had taken huge political risks for just a few weeks earlier. more importantly, though, that state senator is now a member of the committee that's investigating the scandal. the committee that's investigating the coverup which he, himself, knowingly or unknowingly personally advanced. he personally advanced the cover-up. whether or not he knew it was a cover-up. now he's investigating the cover-up? awkward, right? one of the committee co-chairs
1:28 am
today floated the possibility that senator kevin o'toole, a member of their own committee, might get a subpoena from the committee. very awkward. loretta weinberg telling the "star-ledger" tonight, quote, i could see such a scenario unless he comes forward with whatever information we has that we don't know. and meanwhile, it looks like chris christie's former campaign manager and former deputy chief of staff may be brought to court. they may have a court try to force them to comply with orders to hand over documents to the investigation. they are both refusing. today was the deadline. and now this is coming to a head. hold on. there's more. to shop online with her debit card. and so does bill, an identity thief who stole mary's identity, took over her bank accounts, and stole her hard-earned money. unfortunately, millions of americans just like you learn all it may take is a little misplaced information to wreak havoc on your life. this is identity theft.
1:29 am
and no one helps stop it better than lifelock. lifelock offers the most comprehensive identity theft protection available. if mary had lifelock's bank account alerts, she could have been notified in time to help stop it. lifelock's credit notification service is on the job 24/7. as soon as they detect a threat to your identity within their network, they will alert you, protecting you before the damage can be done. lifelock has the most comprehensive identity theft protection available, guarding your social security number, your money, your credit, even the equity in your home. my years as a prosecutor taught me that we all need to protect ourselves from crime. in today's world, that includes identity theft. it's a serious problem. we all have to protect ourselves. [ male announcer ] no one protects you better than lifelock. you even get a $1 million service guarantee. that's security no one can beat. you have so much to protect and nothing to lose when you call lifelock right now and get 60 days of identity theft protection risk free.
1:30 am
that's right. 60 days risk free. use promo code: take charge. order now and get this universal device charger, great for everything from smart phones and cameras to tablets, keeping your digital life powered at home, the office, or in the car... a $30 value, free! don't wait until you become the next victim. ♪ and get a universal device charger free. use promo code: take charge. ♪
1:31 am
a point of frustration for the committee is there are numerous documents that are redacted and for those listening, there's marker or black pen taken to obscure some of the language in some of the documents. >> the redactions occurred
1:32 am
either because the material redacted was from a date outside of the realm of dates sought by the subpoena of this committee, or did not deal with the subject matter of the subpoena. >> david wildstein's lawyer trying to explain to the new jersey legislature why either he or his client took a black marker to a sizable chunk of the paperwork they submitted under subpoena regarding the george washington bridge lane closures last year. we learned today the attorney for the joint investigating committee has since met with david wildstein's lawyer and has apparently seen what lies beneath all those black magic marker lines. also a new jersey newspaper is also now reporting that they've obtained a text message that was not part of the unredacted stuff that was previously revealed. joining us now to talk about this and more is the co-chairman of the new jersey legislative select committee investigation, assemblyman john wisniewski. >> rachel, good to be here. >> let me ask you about the
1:33 am
redactions first. this was my favorite page. the page that was entirely redacted. that must have been very handy. >> one of several. one of several. >> reid schar, special counsel, reportedly has seen what's beneath these redactions. why has he seen them and what does that mean about whether you're going to see them and whether or not the public will? >> it's a process that counsel worked out with one another. we wanted to see them from that day. you showed the clip where he was first at the committee meeting and we wanted to see them. so the attorney for mr. wildstein has agreed to provide them to our council who's going to review them and they're going to come to an agreement on what can be included. what we're told preliminarily, the statement made that they were outside the timeframe or subject matter, pretty much on the mark. a couple pages our council says should be included. we hope to have them included with the record and have more to say about that in the near future. looks like there's a very small subset, 40-some pages i think
1:34 am
out of the 900, that really probably should be included but others seem to be just outside the date range or talking about things that have nothing to do with the bridge. >> join say in the near future, what timeframe? >> the next week to ten days we'll have resolution on that. i think it would be important for the committee to have an understanding that our council looked at them, concurs with in some respects what is represented. the frustration that we had was just seeing them without any explanation raised suspicions. >> yeah. >> why are they redacted, who redacted them, what was the basis for the redactions? we're closer to having answer. >> the "star-ledger" is reporting on a text message they say was not in the unredacted material that was announced publicly. seems to me, the way they're describing it, it must be one of the lines that was redacted from the series of text messages we saw between david wildstein and bill baroni after he gave his cover-up testimony. according to the "star-ledger's"
1:35 am
reporting, they haven't published a primary document of any kind -- >> sure. >> -- they say that text message they've seen refers to state senator kevin o'toole who is on your committee that's investigating these issues. about him having a statement ready to go as soon as that testimony was over concerning the traffic study cover-up. how are you going to deal with that as a committee? >> well, two things. the members of the committee are appointed by the presiding officers, so senator weinberg and i, we serve on the committee at the appointment of the presiding officers. it's not our call. i mean, i think they're aware of this issue and going to have to deal with it. let me tell you about the frustrations sitting there in that committee meeting. bill baroni provided testimony, facts and figures, data, about every members' districts. how many cars go through the e-z pass lanes. we asked, can we have that data? no, no, we have to consult with counsel first. within three hours, all the data as i chair and the committee members were denied was in an
1:36 am
article that appeared online and the next day in the newspaper. there's a certain amount of frustration we couldn't get that data. we were denied that data then it appeared online and in a newspaper story. >> now the investigation into what was really going on there involves the person who got the data when you couldn't get it. >> yeah. certainly we're hoping senator o'toole will provide all of the relevant material to the committee so that the committee can make a determination about what facts are relevant. >> "star-ledger" also reporting tonight bill stepien, chris christie's former campaign manager and bridget anne kelly who sent the infamous e-mail may be brought to court over refusal to hand over documents to your committee. can you comment on that report to me? >> we read their objections. they had lengthy objections to the subpoenas. they weren't relevant, that they weren't part of the subject matter. they didn't seek to obtain information that was crucial to the investigation. we considered all of that. they made some legal arguments about the fifth amendment.
1:37 am
and we looked at those and said, look, this is not about testifying against yourself. this is about providing information needed for this investigation. there's still a disagreement. that's what lawyers do. we're going to continue to pursue our rights and we're confident that ultimately the committee will prevail and get the material we need. it's not going to happen as quickly as we like but we're on good solid legal ground. >> assemblyman john wisniewski. investigating the bridge scandal. thanks for your time tonight. lots happening all at once. i keep thinking this is going to slow down, but it doesn't. not yet. thank you, sir. all right. we'll be right back. stay with us. are you flo? yes. is this the thing you gave my husband? well, yeah, yes. the "name your price" tool. you tell us the price you want to pay, and we give you a range of options to choose from. careful, though -- that kind of power can go to your head. that explains a lot. yo, buddy! i got this. gimme one, gimme one, gimme one! the power of the "name your price" tool.
1:38 am
only from progressive.
1:39 am
1:40 am
if you look at pretty good sized earthquakes, magnitude 2.5 or more, the state of oklahoma is used to having, i don't know, say between 40 and 100 of those per year for the last few years. last year they got a huge spike in that size quake in oklahoma. more than 200 quakes of 2.5 or more magnitude. but now, not even two months into this year, oklahoma has already recorded 94 good sized quakes as of yesterday. and it turns out to show you what the pace is for this year, we're going to need a bigger chart. because in oklahoma, today, they have counted up another 39 earthquakes just today. and some of these are really small, but some of them cross that 2.5 magnitude threshold and a couple were magnitude 3.0 or larger. so we had to remake our chart of significant earthquakes in oklahoma. so far this year, they hit 94 yesterday. today, it's 103. if things keep going at this
1:41 am
pace in oklahoma, oklahoma will experience more than 780 significant earthquakes this year. and that's not counting all the teeny tiny ones. now, oklahoma is not in denial about its earthquake spike. even before the quite amped up rattling of the past few days and the past few weeks, oklahoma had hired a state seismologist to start looking into why this is happening. the swarm of earthquakes has lasted long enough now in oklahoma that the red cross has begun offering a what to do in an earthquake app to oklahoma residents. knowing to get yourself under a desk or into a door frame is one thing, but knowing what is causing this huge spike in quakes is a whole other deal. the oklahoma state seismologist says it may have something to do with injection wells. where fracking companies inject the wastewater used in fracturing shale and breaking up that rock to get at the natural gas that's trapped inside. the wastewater from that very water-intensive process has to go somewhere and a lot of times they inject that wastewater into
1:42 am
injection well sites. the state of oklahoma has more than 4,000 injection wells. the state seismologists told "the new york times" in december that injection wells can sometimes cause earthquakes. quote, could we be looking at some cumulative tipping point? question, that's absolutely possible." or it could be something else. the point is that it's hard to be sure in oklahoma. even as they're having this huge swarm of earthquakes right now. it's hard to draw a conclusion one way or the other about this particular side effect of this very lucrative oil and gas industry that's so important to the local economy. a few weeks ago an this show we reported on azle, texas, a suburb of ft. worth. neighbors there traced a swarm of quakes in their town and azle, a pair of local injection wells. when the people of azle could not get answers, they traveled 200 miles to the state capitol in austin to plead their state with regulators. azle, texas, is not the only place.
1:43 am
in southern texas, laredo, corpus christi, companies are fracking and dealing with the wastewater from fracking and shipping fossil fuels to the market. it's called the eagle ford shale. the eagle ford shale play. you can see here the wells in just one county in the eagle ford shale. in this part of southern texas, people who live next to the stuff say they are concerned about most is not necessarily earthquakes or, say, fears that their tap water might turn flammable as we've seen in other states with lots of fracking, what people in that part of texas are saying is the entire enterprise of getting this stuff out of the ground and ready for sale may be creating air pollution that they have not seen before. texas energy executives say their industry follows the rules. texas regulators say they say, quote, overall shale play activity does not significantly impact air quality or pose a threat to human health.
1:44 am
but people in that part of texas have filed nearly 300 complaints about oil and gas drills since january 2010, and it's not just one aspect of fracking or one by-product. it's the fracking, itself, and also the equipment used in drilling and the generators that power the equipment and the flares that burn off. it's the whole enterprise tip to tail. don't take my word for it. watch. >> chemicals released during oil and gas extraction include some of the most damaging volatile organic compounds or vocs, including benzene and toluene. linked to cancer, neurological problems and other serious illnesses. vocs are released at every phase of oil and gas development. drilling, fracking, production and processing. they're part of the fluid that's
1:45 am
used to fracture the shale and they're released from the earth when the rock is cracked open. vocs seep from well boers, tanks, flares and pipelines. they have an added danger, hydrogen sulfide. a naturally occurring gas you'll find in some shale areas of the country but is especially abundant here. in low concentrations, it makes people sick. in high concentrations, it can kill. >> over the past eight months, a website called inside climate news and senate republic integrity and our sister network the weather channel have been reporting out this story in south texas. today they released a long awaited report on the subject. it's called fracking, the eagle ford shale, big oil and bad air on the texas prairie. they followed families who lived within a couple miles of 50 wells. families who have for their daily horizon wide open texas and the full throttle machinery
1:46 am
of oil and gas. what they found is truly amazing and it's never been reported like this before. you're going to want to hear some of this. hold on to that thought.
1:47 am
1:48 am
people join angie's list for all kinds of reasons. i go to angie's list to gauge whether or not the projects will be done in a timely fashion and within budget. angie's list members can tell you which provider is the best in town. you'll find reviews on everything from home repair to healthcare. now that we're expecting, i like the fact i can go onto angie's list and look for pediatricians. the service providers that i've found on angie's list actually have blown me away. find out why more than two million members count on angie's list. angie's list -- reviews you can trust.
1:49 am
what's going on in the eagle ford shale is more subtle than a refinery explosion or an oil spill. a toxic soup of chemicals is being released into the air day in and day out.
1:50 am
we won't know the effects of these emissions for a very long time. >> the chemicals in the air, we can't get away from them. what's going on in the >> that was a clip from the new report fracking the eagleford shale, big oil and bad air on the texas prairie. i should note for the record that the oil and gas industry in texas is disputing the contention in this new report that emissions in that area are a threat to public health. but joining us now is jim morris, the senior reporter and editor at the center for public integrity, took part in this project. thanks for your time. >> thank you for having me. >> why did you pick the eagleford shale in south texas. why focus on that region when you're look into this issue? >> we picked the eagleford because it's one of the biggest in the world, and yet for some reason, it hasn't become part of the national conversation. people hadn't been paying much
1:51 am
attention to it beyond south texas. so that's why we looked at it. >> there's been a lot of concerns about fracking having potential effect on ground water. we've been reporting just recently a spike in quakes which may be caused because of the injection of water in the process. how did you know that quality of air is linked to that region of the country? why air pollution? >> we started to hear in the last year or two complaints from people about bad air and about illnesses they blame on the bad air. but if you look at complaints, a lot of people had to do with air. rotten egg odors, people who were nausea, nosebleeds, severe asthma attacks.
1:52 am
it was clear to us early on, those were air problems. those were all air related. i think that sort of helped steer us in that direction. >> your report today has landed with a big splash. texas state regulators pushed back immediately and hard today. they say overall fracking has no significant effect on air quality and they know that. how do you -- how do you respond to that given your own reporting on texas regulators? >> well, they don't know that. that was kind of one of the points. one of the main things we wanted to point out was there's not enough permanent air monitoring in large portions of the eagleford, you know, whether it's coincidence or not. areas of heaviest drilling, areas of the heaviest drilling where we did a lot of our work don't have permanent air monitors. they do spot monitoring, which has some value, but it's very much hit or miss. so if they -- you know, for them
1:53 am
to say they know there's not a problem, i think that's disingenuous. >> in terms of thinking about what might possibly make the situation better and what might be a way out of it, if that's your view at how state regulators have dealt with it, is there a role for federal regulators? is in a role for epa or somebody with jurisdiction to make a difference here? >> there is a role for the epa. but i think one thing a lot of people don't know is that when you're talking about the federal clean air act, enforcement of that act is delegated to the states. and so in this case, texas is sort of the first line of defense, or the last line of defense against air pollution. and yes, the epa in theory can step in. but the basic enforcement is left to the states. and for people in texas that hasn't been a really good situation. >> jim morris, the senior editor for the public center of integrity. a year-long project that's produced a very fascinating and controversial report.
1:54 am
thanks for your work on this and appreciate you being here. be right back. stay with us. [ male announcer ] this one goes out to all the congestion sufferers who feel like there's a brick on their face. who are so congested, it feels like the walls are closing in. ♪ who are so stuffed up, they feel like they're under water. try zyrtec-d® to powerfully clear your blocked nose and relieve your other allergy symptoms... so you can breathe easier all day. zyrtec-d®. find it at the pharmacy counter.
1:55 am
1:56 am
1:57 am
two summers ago on july 28, two summers ago at around 4:00 in the morning, three people infiltrated the y-12 national security complex, which is where the u.s. government stores all of our uranium for our nuclear warheads. they call it the fort knox of uranium. the three people hiked through the woods on the outskirts of the y-12 facility. once they got to the facility itself, they used bolt cutters to cut through three different perimeter fences. and then they walked right up to the interior storage facilities where the uranium is held. this is supposedly a secure facility and their getting into it did set off alarms but nobody quickly responded to those alarms. they were able to stay inside the facility for about an hour
1:58 am
before anybody came to check on what was going on there. while they were waiting for someone, anyone to respond to the alarms they set off, they spray painted anti-war slow sgans on the uranium storage facility. they splashed the storage container human blood they had brought to the protest for that purpose. but they did not try to get away. they just waited to be found. they brought snacks with them. they ate snacks, they prayed, they sang songs. they were just waiting for somebody to notice them in the shoot to kill zone they had infiltrated abhour before to try to raise awareness against nuclear weapons. and when somebody finally did find them, they did not resist. this past may, the three protesters, all senior citizens, two men and one woman, they were convicted of sabotage and of destruction of government property. their sentencing came down late this afternoon. the two men, male activists, they were sentenced to just over five years in prison for doing this. and the most senior of the three
1:59 am
convicted, sister megan rice, an 84-year-old catholic nun of the society of the holy child jesus, 84 years old, one sentenced to one month shy of three years in prison, which might not sound like much time in prison unless you're already 84 years old when you're starting your three-year prison sentence. whereupon this might be the rest of your life. three nonviolent offenders, peace protesters, senior citizens, convicted, sentenced and now incarcerated for gaining entry into what's supposed to be the fort knox of uranium, supposed to be one of the most secure places on the planet is not. and we know that now because these three, including an octogenarian nun were able to infiltrate it with bolt cutters and a handful of prayers. the worst harm they did was paint and exposing serious security flaws at that facility. and if you care about security at that facility, you now have them to thank for exposing the
2:00 am
flaws in it. now they're going to prison. was justice really served here? watch that space. good wednesday morning. violence crashes break out on the streets of the you're yan avian capital. doz ares are dead, russia is pointing the finger at the u.s. good news and bad news on what raise the federal minimum wage would do. an elderly nunn gets sent to the big house. $5,000 in damage and what they took? how two minnesota siblings deal with the dreaded kiss cam. thanks for joining us. breaking news out of ukraine. at least 25 people are dead and another 240 hospitalized after a day of deadly clashes between activists an


info Stream Only

Uploaded by TV Archive on