tv The 11th Hour With Brian Williams MSNBC December 1, 2017 1:00am-2:00am PST
nobody around him with reacquaint him with reality, either. >> that's a great point, joy reid. >> he's a pathological liar, too. he believes -- he seems to believe this stuff. >> yeah. >> when nixon lied, i think we knew he knew he was lying but we're not so sure about trump. >> yeah. >> thank you both for being here. that is "all in" for this evening. >> plus, is there a white house plan to replace secretary of state rex tillerson with cia director mike pompeo, the reporter broke the news is here with us live this evening. and our greatest ally across the atlantic had an uproar against the social media's media post. another busy night in this administration as "the 11th hour" gets under way.
>> good morning again, nbc news headquarters here in new york. day 315. we have breaking news at the top of the forecast on the matter o f the russia investigation. late tonight, the new york times posted this headline. trump pressed top republicans to end russia inquiry and whether trump's campaign helped them in any way. >> senator richard burr said in an interview that mr. trump told him he was eager to see an investigation that has over shadowed much of the first year of his presidency come to an end. it was something along the lines of i hope you can conclude this as quickly as possible mr. burr
said. he replied to mr. trump that when we have exhausted everybody we need to talk to, we'll finish. senator roy blount, a member of the intel committee to end the investigation swiftly. >> mr. trump called other lawmakers over the summer with requests that they push mr. burr, the inquiry, the senator who was alarmed of hearing words on the president's plead, they should urge mr. burr to bring the russia investigation to a close. the senator declined to reveal which colleagues mr. trump had contact with the request. the comment from the administration tonight is this. quote, "at no point had attempted to apply undo influence on committee members, the senator declined to reveal which colleagues mr. trump had contact with the request. the comment from the
administration tonight is this. quote, "at no point had attempted to apply undo influence on committee members, there is no evidence of collusion and these investigations must come to a fair and appropriate completion." several republicans interviewed by the "time" says trump's appeals came across as words of al political newcomer who do not know what's appropriate. listen to this from tonight's "rachel maddow's program" just how significant this is from joyce vance. >> the president tried with senator burr was not access null and proceeded to go everyone around him in an effort to put pressure for him. rachel, one thing we have to remember that unlikely we'll see a bob mueller indictment the president. it is more like lie that we'll
see this evidence packaged in some sort of a report that goes to the -- then will be used by folks in the house to gain whether or not impeachment is appropriate. >> important stuff right there. more on that later. attorney jeff sessions met with the house intel committee behind closed doors behind the russian matters. the democrats were less than thrilled with how he answered their questions. >> i asked the attorney general whether he was instructed by the president to take any action that he would believe hinder the russia investigation, he declined to answer the question. >> the attorney general is one of the most forgetful person out of the white house. >> jeff sessions answered questions today the same way he had before saying he never been directed to do anything illegal or proper.
nbc news is reporting donald trump jr. , will meet with the same committee next week. now to our lead off panel, michael crowdly and national security and jennifer rogers, former assistant of u.s. attorney for the southern district of new york. and ken thomas, white house reporter from the associated press, welcome to you all. michael, we'll begin with you, we knew that russia set the president off. we know that the president used the same kind of reasoning with comey face to face as he testified. we did not know about a telephone lobbying campaign of the investigation on this. >> we did know he made phone calls to other members. not only on capitol hill but for instance, figures in the intelligence committee, cleaning a similar case.
so it is with the pattern on the president. i think that -- a various piept point that there is a lot of circumstantial evidence. there is still circumstantial. was there really a collusion in it is the weaker part of the president. where as the obstruction of justice evidence is piling up and piling up and is really starting to look crystal clear. there is a very consistently discernible pattern. what's interesting to me is despite all of that and a lot of it has come out in a factual and credible way. it does not seem as though republicans in congress maybe the bar order of the president's
faith are bothered by it. they seem to be describing behaviors like this by americans come and arriving in london and driving on the side of the road and does not know what he's doing. and not that they think this is some true transgression that deserves this statement. >> talk about the president calling burr but the people around burr. if everything is reported in the new york times tonight is correct, were any laws broken? >> this is good evidence for the obstruction of justice is taken. i don't think it is strong enough for a separate case. but, what he was doing here and definitely trying to persuade but he did not have the same sway over congress as a political branch. i suspect it is not quite as
strong enough. it is very good evidence of his intense and motivation and other obstruction case with firing comey. i think it is important. i don't think it sets up a separate criminal case. >> i have a recollection of being a young man and hearing from a police officer through my car window that ignorance of law is no defense. people are saying look, he was new to government and the way the federal government, is that a defense? >> not to me. it is also not a defense in this case because we know that before this happened over the summer, he already fired comey in a
block back from that led to the mueller investigations. we know that he knew by now that you are not supposed to obstruct investigations where they are into you and your campaigns. so that does not fly at all. >> ken, how surprise were you to see these on the record quoting that senator burr fell compel to talk to the "time" on the record and there were other senators who were helping to paint the picture as well. this comes in advance of some important meetings on the hill. donald jr. will be meeting with the house next week. senator burr says he also wants to meet with don jr. before the end of the year. this could be a way for the senate republican to make clear that the president was in fact lobbying and trying to make them move a certain way. >> michael, the verbiage i am looking at side by side quotes. the president to comey. the president to senator burr as quoted by the principles as
turned around and reported by the news media. patterning does not make something true but patterning makes subsequent cases available. >> that's right. the president exhibited this behavior towards a variety of people. the fundamental question is, is this a man that truly believes that this is all over blown and unfair and should be wrapped up because of some kind of great and justice or this one has something to hide. the former, the reason to take seriously of the ladder case is the number of inconsistent and inaccurate and false statements that we have been getting about their behavior since the campaign and the inauguration stories that's changed and
updated and people have not been forthcoming. the benefit of the doubt right now is not with the president and his associates. when you see this behavior, you have to ask yourself is this case where there is really is something to hide. he's trying to paint it as a knee for a quick exoneration. this is diminishing my statute and my ability to lead the nation so do it for the good of america. you have to wonder what that is really about. >> jennifer, the new york time piece, it takes aim to point out some of these calls were made without the president. a lot of the business of the presidency has conducted with the crowd's list. you got your chief of staff, what would be the indicator there? he says he knows what he's doing when he makes these call and he
administers these pressures. and telling them to wrap it up is problematic because they are investigating him. it tells me he knows he's not supposed to do that and that's why he does it without answering him. >> can his defense be, i truly do not believe there is any collusion and i am in it to get the best for our country and this is a distraction. >> again, i don't think we have a case of obstruction based on this conduct with the senators. >> this adds to the pile. >> it adds to the pile. if he fires the fbi director, that's more than just lets move this along. that's like lets take out the person who's leading this charge. i don't think it is credible with respecting to fire comey. he can try it but it would not fly in the court of law. >> ken, the building behind you today scheduled the state of the union address for 2018. the president's first official state of the union as president, set the scene on the evening
where all of our attention is gathered beneath the dome and the president walks in the house chambers. it will be interesting a that point and we'll list investigation is still cranking away and you know lawyers for the president have, you know, assured him that in all likelihood this investigation will wrap up by the end of the year, perhaps the beginning of the year but i think this is the story is another example of why this investigation and the work being done behind me is likely to drag on. these committees are not going to file their reports and release their findings to the spring and the mueller investigation, it seems like we peel more of the onions and find more.
when we does go in the building and deliver the state of the union address. he very well can be dealing with this issue. >> jennifer, you are not speaking. do you think in plain english, we are getting started here. >> absolutely. the newsroom is like michael flynn is cooperating so we are just getting under way. >> so you concur. >> we have been hearing similar things that the president's lawyers are telling him that mueller could exonerate him by the end of the year. it seems impossible of that case. why would his lawyer be telling him that and telling media that. it is raising this expectation that's unrealistic. i find it a bit puzzle. >> thanks to michael and ken thomas and general ter rogers. >> it is been called the special relationship be with just his cell phone. how much damage has the president done to america's
the job, mr. president? do you want him to stay in his job? >> thanks everyone. that's a quick snapshot of the evolution of president trump relationship with the secretary of state, rex tillerson, former ceo of exxon mobile. today new york times broke this story detailing a secret plan being ouster and replaced by pompeo. public disclosure of mr. kelly's transition plan may have been met as a signal for the secretary to go. secretary tillerson have not been on the same page as the president. you will recall this nbc news report. tillerson openly disparaged the president and referring to him as a moron.
the white house was all public denials on any plans to push the president out. when it comes to questions like this. a senior staff and will the secretary no longer be here? >> i can tell you that chief of staff kelly called our department this morning and said that the rumors were not true and those reports are not true. >> a senior administration official did tell nbc news that tillerson has been discussing a year end departure with colleagues. a washington post reports from josh roggin says cia, pompeo has already been preparing to take over the chief department and also what tillerson said a month
ago. >> some day i feel like i need to do that. >> brings us to our panel to talk about this today. peter baker, and white house correspondent, and rick engel, former secretary of state and public affairs. >> welcome to you all. is this fish wrapped in paper and a bullet proof vest. thinks the most public message signal to rex tillerson? >> the president has been on the outs of the secretary now and with several months there would have to come a reckoning. it feel that is reckoning maybe
coming up the next few weeks. close to the end of the year or afterwards. the secretary was at the white house and he went for two different meetings. he's planning to go to europe and dealing with foreign counter parts and wondering will he be around much in the new year and what if it matters with they make a deal with him. >> the president is asking if you want rex tillerson on the job and his response is quote, "rex is here and in ducted to the hall-of-fame." >> not an endorsendorsement. if you listen to sarah sanders, she says there is no personal announcement to be made at this time. we'll see what tomorrow brings and tomorrow or a week from now brings.
john kelly is putting together a plan and he's looking into the future and he see as future which rex tillerson is not secretary of state and mike pompeo seems to have the president's favorites and he impressed the president as a cia director and to replace him. we are thinking that could be. that's what the people from the white house telling us or tom cotton. >> anita, pompeo brings an interesting resume. what would he bring to state that tillerson does not. >> they differ very, very much. all these things that the president differed from rex tillerson on north korea and the deal. this is something that pompeo is much more on the same page with the president and less about diplomacy which is an interesting job for him to be
taking the top diplomatic job in the united states. it would very much change the tone and tenure of the state department. a lot of people i talk to and people that support him and thinks he's a smart and nice guy, finds it curious that he would get this job. everyone during transition when they're trying to find a place for him. there was talk about him taking the secretary of state's job. the president has gotten closer to him over this full year here where as peter mentioned they had these daily intelligence briefings every morning and he often sticks around the white house and the president personally likes him. >> rick, i know it is hard for you to watch your formal colleague. the diplomats are gone. what would it be like if there is a change of power at the top to deal with. >> the more i think about this, this first year of the trump's presidency maybe looking back at the year of the moderates in the trump administrations. every time someone leaving is replaced by someone. the way the state department as an institution, it will look at pompeo as how it will regard the state department as an institution less so in terms of what his policy is. he's much more of a hard liner and tillerson was globalists and modestist.
with us to talk about this tonight, jeremy bash, former chief of staff at cia and an msnbc national security analyst. jeremy, you are often with us when we cover the moment of the terrorist attack and you had the opportunity to point out the lightning fast and constant communications between scotland yard and the united states, between the u.s. and the u.k. as part of that relationship. really their goal is getting together to form a safer world. talk about the relationship and how much damage this could cause. >> brian, in episode encapsulate the trump's presidency. first, he embraces his theories and embrace his quotes, alternative facts and downright lies and appearing to a right nationalists part of the country of the world. third, he's under mining our ally, our key ally, the most critical that have fought and died with under the circumstances -- us over the field all over the globes and he's putting our own personnel at risk and troops at risk. i cannot think of a single active that's more irresponsible and dangerous for the u.s. of what the president did today. >> the quote that you led the peace with, those are through all of this. she's one of the people that wants to get to, yes. she talks about how leaders are coming her way and how she's feeling comfortable of this.
what we see further away is the two important people who are retiring. jeff flake and bob corker. this maybe one of their last acts. they want to put a stamp down saying they left congress and the economy in a place that they can respect. >> while i have you on the sexual harassment front of the issue that's quickly approaching for 2017 and beyond, john conyers, what are the big names that have come out and called for the senior most man in the house to step down? >> well, we see speaker ryan and nancy pelosi says it is time for him to step down and we see many of his colleagues. they have staked out a space over decades as being people who see themselves as protector of women and champions of moving women up in powerful positions. it is hard for them to come out
though he's still a real estate dealer. i look back at months and gravity and that it is going to change. it has not changed one bit. it made him more than it is. i don't think he understands the laws and norms and he's bothered by this. he had a pebble in his shoes and wanted to get out. >> anita kumar, how do you part the reaction statement to the new york times article tonight, do you find the words curious? >> what are they going to say? we heard about him trying to circumvent the investigation other times. they don't have much to say.
it is just a normal conversation or whatever. it is damage story for them. terrific conversation based on tonight's breaking news with three great guests. peter baker, anita kumar and -- the damage is done and to what we call a special relationship when "the 11th hour" continues. this christmas, on the basis
an important message about health care reform. most americans must have health insurance by december 15th... or pay a tax penalty. even if you already have insurance, now's the time to cut through the confusion and explore all your options. you can spend hours searching for coverage on the healthcare exchange or you can make a single call to healthmarkets and let us do the legwork for you, at no cost or obligation. healthmarkets insurance agency searches thousands of health insurance plans, on the exchange and off from more than 120 leading companies... we'll find you the right coverage and guarantee the lowest price for plans we offer. and right now, you may qualify for a zero-dollar premium health plan. due to recent changes, government subsidies are higher than ever, and you may be able to get a health plan for free.... healthmarkets insurance agency will evaluate your needs, offer objective solutions, and even handle all your enrollment paperwork. with only a few days left, act now before december 15th. miss the enrollment deadline, and you could risk being uninsured for an entire year.
talk to us on the phone or meet with a local licensed representative - even if you're already insured. why pay more than you have to ... or risk going without the coverage you need? in the past 3 years alone, healthmarkets has enrolled americans in more than 1.1 million insurance policies put our free service to work for you. we can save you time and money. we did for donna in georgia. and she writes ... by working with a healthmarkets agent, i was able to save a bundle on my health insurance. and carlo in california tells us... our healthmarkets agent took the time to educate us and patiently answered all of our questions ... and here's what linda in kansas has to say ... i recommend anyone trying to use healthcare.gov to instead call healthmarkets. at healthmarkets, we make finding health insurance fast and easy ... because we know you have better things to do. you only have a few days left. call the number on your screen to find out if you qualify for a zero dollar premium health plan. call this number to get the coverage you need, act now before the december 15th deadline,
of what we already know about this, action is needed now. cancel the state's visit. >> the president was stupid? what he did. >> donald trump -- >> he's a racist and in competent. >> can you believe what they are saying in parliament as the white house continues to standby, anti-muslim videos shared by the president and
relations between the united states and one of its oldest and closest allies have deteriorated since president trump retweeted videos originally posted by a group called britain's first. the organization has been condemned by the british government. the white house today acknowledged the president was not familiar with the group before retweeting and they had this defense. >> look, i think what he's done is elevate the conversation to talk about the real issue and a real threat and that's extreme violent and terrorism, something that we know to be very real and something the president felt strongly talking about and bringing up and making sure it is an issue everyday that we are look the best way to protect americans. >> the telegraph in the u.k. reports a working visit planned for january is off.
quote, "the trip, a scaled down version of a state visit with no meeting with the queen was intended for mr. trump coming the u.k. while avoiding the mass protests a full state visit would likely trigger. however, the telegraph can reveal that the trip has been pushed into the long grass with no new date in the diary picked." with us to talk about this tonight, jeremy bash, former chief of staff at cia and an msnbc national security analyst.
jeremy, you are often with us when we cover the moment of the terrorist attack and you had the opportunity to point out the lightning fast and constant communications between scotland yard and the united states, between the u.s. and the u.k. as part of that relationship. really their goal is getting together to form a safer world. talk about the relationship and how much damage this could cause. >> brian, in episode encapsulate
the trump's presidency. first, he embraces his theories and embrace his quotes, alternative facts and downright lies and appearing to a right nationalists part of the country of the world. third, he's under mining our ally, our key ally, the most critical that have fought and died with under the circumstances -- us over the field all over the globes and he's putting our own personnel at risk and troops at risk. i cannot think of a single active that's more irresponsible and dangerous for the u.s. of what the president did today. >> the quote that you led the peace with, those are our friends talking. just imagine what our adversary would say. it gives credence and the jihadists and radicals to rise up. when our president used
conspiracy theorists and under mine our allies, that give us an open field to our adversaries to do the same. >> the one that i left off of the bio, with that in mind, i ask you about the "new york times" tonight making a call that can we wrap it up and let it go. >> my reaction for that, when you are under investigation for foreign obstruction of justice, it is not a good idea to engage in obstruction of justice. if people destroyed documents or tamper witnesses, that's a violation of federal law and the president putting the arms on senators to shut down this investigation is not much different. >> jeremy bash. it is always a pleasure to have you. thank you very much for joining us on a thursday night. coming up, some drama tonight in the u.s. senate that the republican in charge were not counting on. a late line report when we come right back.
deficit. it looks like some republican senators have been deficit hawks. those deficit hawks maybe digging in. they hoped to schedule a vote tomorrow. mercifully, we have someone with us tonight who can explain all of this as she does everyday, that's kelcy snow, congressional reporter for npr. kelcy, what's happening tonight and what's going on and what does the future hold, perhaps? >> leaders say it is a hiccup
and they hit a bump along the road and they're going to fix this problem over night. a group of these deficit hawks decided that they wanted to make sure that this bill was not going to add to the deficit in the long-term, in the future. there is a problem though that they got a score from the congressional scorekeeper from the jct that says this bill would only do a third of the work that they thought it would to grow in the economy. they had a bunch of money they needed to make up and they were starting to feel a bit squirmish. they're going back the drawing board and trying to find ways to make it. >> we saw corker that surrounded
him and johnson and flake and collins and if too much of that happens, 52-48 starts to go away really fast. >> it does. we should note that senator collins did kind of stay in line through all of this. she's one of the people that wants to get to, yes. she talks about how leaders are coming her way and how she's feeling comfortable of this. what we see further away is the
two important people who are retiring. jeff flake and bob corker. this maybe one of their last acts. they want to put a stamp down saying they left congress and the economy in a place that they can respect. >> while i have you on the sexual harassment front of the issue that's quickly approaching for 2017 and beyond, john conyers, what are the big names that have come out and called for the senior most man in the house to step down? >> well, we see speaker ryan and nancy pelosi says it is time for him to step down and we see many of his colleagues. they have staked out a space over decades as being people who see themselves as protector of women and champions of moving women up in powerful positions. kelcy snell, it is always a pleasure. thank you for explaining everything for us tonight on capitol hill. the american president believing in conspiracy theory and picking a fight from our closest allies. that's where steve schmidt comes in. he's back with us when we come back.
what concerns me is the american press of this end less attempt of labeling the guy as a i think he's crazy and unfit for office. >> the same man, republican senaor graham of south carolina today and rewind to february 2016 using the exact same language. president trump earned graham's support and he's now working score points among the gop base. steve schmidt is become with us
tonight. i think it is fair to say members of our on-air family hopes senator graham can be a bull work and a firewall and not a yes, man. if you don't mind from quoting from your twitter feed, quote, "always entertaining and never boring." >> what is it that you are voting for? they have zero idea and none. every single gen x should be outraged. the beggaring of the country for special interest donations is immoral. >> we are seeing total collapse
challenge of our time that's striving so much turbulent in our politics and extremism in the parties and the fact class p seen a real wage increase in a generation. it is creating a crisis of competence in free market american capitalism, for millennials, it's so many other americans. and it can have a profoundly bad effect for future opportunity in this country. this bill does nothing about that problem. it does nothing to drive economic growth. what it does do is, it lowers corporate tax rates. no one pays the statutory rate in the first place. and it does it by loading up another trillion and a half dollars on the national credit
card that will be paid by my kids and grandkids and your kids and grandkids, and it's just a travesty. >> steve, if we've got folks watching tonight who went off to war as young men and fought side-by-side with british soldiers, fought to keep the british isle free of tyranny and save the world, what would you say to them about what has become this week of our relationship with our greatest ally? >> well, the relationship -- the relationship is so much bigger than donald trump. the enduring ties between the british and american peoples, and i think tonight about the towering statue of fdr in london, wearing a naval cape. the indispensable partner to churchill in saving the world from the darkness.
the statue built by the melted down pennies and small donations of ordinary british men and women. the british parliament and their condemnation is righteous. what the president of the united states did, in tweeting out this video from a fascist, british extremist paramilitary group, a white supremacist group, which exalted in the president of the united states' recognition of it, for them to say he's not deserving of a state visit, though it breaks my heart to say it, i agree with them completely. if you look at it from the british perspective, to see this disgrace in the white house, in the oval office, to be standing next to her majesty, the queen, the assault on her dignity, that his presence would represent, the divisiveness that his visit would cause, the protests it would spark and the stain that it would leave on the relationship isn't worth it. >> steve, finally, your reaction to the reporting in "the new york times" tonight that the president made more than a round of calls to say, in effect, can't we just shut this thing down and move on, about the russia investigation? >> well, it's completely inappropriate for him to be doing so, and as we -- as we look at this -- at this investigation, whether it's the mueller investigation, which seems to be moving closer and closer to the oval office on the question of russia, but this just seems to me to be more evidence -- and i'm not sure if it's criminal evidence, but more evidence of a constantcy of an effort to obstruct the inquiries in finding out what happened in this election. when we think tonight about the question you previously asked, brian, what excitement vladimir putin must have to see the
condemnation in the british parliament of an american president. he probably can't believe his good luck and his good fortune to see the damage that this president is doing to america's essential alliances all over the world. >> powerful stuff, a sobering thought to end on. steve schmidt, thank you, friend. a final break for us. and coming up, how the white house plans to get the president as close as possible to a visit they said he would not make. we'll explain, right after this. jimmy's gotten used to his whole room smelling like sweaty odors.
yup, he's gone noseblind. he thinks it smells fine, but his mom smells this... luckily for all your hard-to-wash fabrics... ...there's febreze fabric refresher. febreze doesn't just mask, it eliminates odors you've... ...gone noseblind to. and try febreze unstopables for fabric. with up to twice the fresh scent power, you'll want to try it...
...again and again and maybe just one more time. indulge in irresistible freshness. febreze unstopables. breathe happy. last thing before we go here tonight has to do with a crafty move by the trump white house that seems to allow the president to campaign for roy moore in alabama in that senate race without really campaigning for roy moore. in fact, without really setting foot in the state of alabama. "the washington post" was the first to report that come next friday, donald trump will travel to pensacola, florida, for a political rally. pensacola, as you may know, is in the panhandle, often regarded as the de facto extension of southern alabama, and pensacola, just about 20 miles from the alabama line, shares a local news media market with mobile in alabama. "the post" reports trump is buoyed by moore's standing in
the polls and feels his support for moore, gets the credit for that. sarah huckabee sanders has said the president's schedule wouldn't allow a trip to alabama, but apparently there's time to go to florida. at the rally, the president is expected to attack national democrats and doug jones, the democrat running against roy moore. for his part, roy moore denies any wrongdoing and has, in, changed his story in recent days, after first, you may recall, telling sean hannity he remembered two of his accusers, even called one of them a good girl. he's now saying he's never met any of his accusers. the special election in alabama is december 12th. that is our broadcast for a thursday night. thank you so much for being here with us. good night from nbc news headquarters here in new york.
a possible shameup in the trump administration. nbc news learned a white house planned to replace secretary rex tillerson. unclear when or if it will happen. plus the tax bill republicans have been working on for weeks. finally comes to a head. number of gop holdouts expressing concern over how it would affect america's deficit. verdict in the case of katherine steinlye. convicted a homeless immigrant