Skip to main content

tv   The Rachel Maddow Show  MSNBC  May 7, 2018 9:00pm-10:00pm PDT

9:00 pm
those who have lost everything this week and while we can't stop what's happening, we can hope that everyone gets out of the way until mother nature decides that's enough of a show for now. that's our broadcast for a monday night. thank you so much for being here with us. good night from nbc news headquarters here in new york. a lot of news breaking this afternoon and into this evening. at the new yorker magazine tonight, they've just posted a bolt from the blue, a long story in which a number of women go on the record, including using their names, so these are not anonymous sources, claiming abusive behavior in personal relationships by new york's democratic attorney general, eric schneiderman. he's denying the allegations but these are two named accusers and the activity they're accusing him of is quite serious. again, the reporters on this
9:01 pm
story are jane mayer and ronan far roe. we're going to be speaking with jane about this stunning new report in just a moment. although eric snietermchneiderm just one state's attorney general, which is not the most high-profile gig in the country, after all, there are 49 other state attorneys general at any time, even still, schneiderman cuts an unusually high-profile. that's in part because the attorney general in new york state just tends to be a high-profile thing. the immediate previous owners of this job before him are andrew cuomo, who's now governor of new york, and elliot spitzer. who is a lot of things. also a former governor of new york. in addition, though, to that just being a high-profile job, eric schneiderman is also unusually high-profile, even for a new york attorney general right now. because of the perception or at least the theory that his office
9:02 pm
might essentially function as kind of a back-up to robert mueller's special counsel's office at some point if president trump decides to fire his way through the justice department to end the mueller probe or if he decides to issue presidential pardons to people who have thus far been caught up in the russia investigation. the theory has been that even if trump issued pardons to people like, say, paul manafort or hypothetically michael cohen or national security adviser mike flynn, attorney general eric schneiderman in new york state might at that point be able to bring parallel charges under state law, instead of federal law, which could allow charges against these people, hypothetically in the case of mr. cohen, to proceed regardless of the president's federal pardon powers. as of tonight. eric schneiderman is still in his job as new york state attorney general but the governor of new york, andrew cuomo, is now calling for his resignation. this explosive report has put a
9:03 pm
huge and hot spotlight on schneiderman. we will have more on that combi coming up. the last word from attorney general schneiderman himself is that he denies any wrong doing, denies any noncon sensual behavior with the women described in this article. this is a still developing story. we're going to have jane joining us in just a moment. we thought we would be able to get her on camera. i think we're going get her only on the phone because i think she is still working the story as it develops tonight. that's coming up. also, this afternoon, in the space of one single hour, the trump administration gave birth to a remarkable set of policy twins. the first twin, born just minutes ahead of her little sibling, was this announcement from first lady mateen trump. melania trump. >> i'm asking you all to join me in providing support and guidance to our children. let us teach children the
9:04 pm
importance of all aspects of their well being, which includes a social, emotional, and physical health. there are too many critical issues facing children today. children deserve every opportunity to enjoy their innocence. every child should know it is safe to make mistakes and that there are supportive adults and friends nearby to catch them if they fell. >> that was the first of two sort of policy twins that were born within the space of one hour in the trump administration today. first lady melania trump announcing, as of 3:21 p.m. that she will be created something called "bebest." she described it as an awareness campaign dedicated to the most valuable and fragile among us, our children. less than an hour later at 4:12 p.m., attorney general jeff sessions in california gave birth to the second twin when he
9:05 pm
announced that henceforth, the united states government will officially pursue a policy of forcibly tearing children away from their parents and incarcerating the parents, putting the kids in homes or shelters. separating parents and kids against their will is now the announced proud policy of the u.s. government in terms of border enforcement. the trump administration has been quietly pursuing a version of this policy for parents and kids crossing the u.s. border without papers, but now, as of today, they are formally announcing that this is what the u.s. government stands for. so, as the first lady said, children deserve every opportunity to enjoy their innocence. she said that within one hour of attorney general jeff sessions announcing that it will now be u.s. policy to rip children out of the arms of their parents and lock them up. and it is remarkable, and it will be seen as a landmark moment that the u.s. government is announcing and pursuing this policy of taking -- literally taking babies away from their
9:06 pm
mothers. this is not like grown kids. like babes in arms, infants, toddlers, being forcibly taken from their parents is now u.s. government policy at the border. which itself is, as i say, landmark moment. but the white house really did not do anybody any favors today by scheduling the announcement that we will rip babies from their mothers' arms to coincide almost exactly with a very rare public appearance by the first lady in which she announced how much she wants everybody to value children and take care of them. the most valuable and fragile among us. the white house also not doing the first lady any favors today when they, in conjunction with this appearance, put out this document and called it, quote, a booklet by first lady melania trump and the ftc. they sent out this document today saying it was created by mrs. trump. this brochure was actually created during the obama
9:07 pm
administration. all they did was put a new introduction on it with a picture from melania trump. they also changed the icon inside from an old-looking phone to a sort of new-looking phone to update the photography there. and there's nothing wrong with reissuing and redistributing a somewhat effective pamphlet on an important issue like cyber bullying but for the white house to put out an overt claim saying this was written by melania trump when anybody who's ever seen that document before would know that it was created years ago and distributed by the obama administration, that was an unkindness to her, especially after the fiasco involving her republican national convention speech, which turned out to be partially plagiarized from a speech by michelle obama. mrs. trump does not give very many public remarks. she has not been a high-profile public figure of any kind, let alone as a first lady. but that makes it doubly and triply important that it
9:08 pm
shouldn't be a scandal or embarrassment when she does appear in public. whoever's working on her staff and arranging things around her skimpy public schedule is not doing her any favors. shortly before the attorney general and the first lady gave their twin announcements about the u.s. government caring for children and forcibly separating them from their mothers and fathers, the white house announced that president trump will make an announcement early tomorrow afternoon about the iran nuclear deal. over the past two weeks, france sent its president, germany sent its chancellor, and britain sent its foreign minister to all try to persuade president trump to not pull out of the iran nuclear deal. it is nevertheless widely expected that that is what he will announce tomorrow. there is basically mainstream national security consensus in the united states that pulling out of the iran deal is equal parts reckless and pointless, and it is certainly vociferously opposed by most of our allies around the world.
9:09 pm
but the president campaigned against the iran deal, and he did just bring on the fox news channel's most vociferous proponent of war with iran as his national security adviser. so, the dollars to doughnuts bet tomorrow is that president trump will be announcing that the u.s. is withdrawing from that landmark deal. and alongside the anticipation of that announcement, we got an absolutely bizarre story today about some shady, covert, private detective style nonsense apparently targeting people who have advocated that the u.s. shouldn't pull out of that deal. colin call is not a household name. you might recognize him from seeing him on tv or reading an op ed, maybe. he was the national security adviser to joe biden when joe biden was vice president. before serving as the national
9:10 pm
security adviser, he served as a deputy secretary of defense, focusing on the middle east so he had important jobs in that area of policy within the obama administration, but i mean no disrespect by suggesting that he isn't exactly a household name. no offense at all but i imagine he is able to walk down most streets at most times of day without people dropping everything and exclaiming, hey, weren't you deputy assistant secretary of the middle east from 2009 to 2011? i think he's able to get by in life without that being a serious hindrance. nevertheless, he appears to have become the target of some sort of covert campaign, and it was not just him. it appears to have also been his family. hear's how he explained it over the weekend. "last year, my wife was serving on the fund-raising committee of my daughter's public charter school in washington, d.c. one day, out of the blue, he received an e-mail from someone
9:11 pm
claiming to represent a socially responsible private equity firm in the uk. this uk person said she was flying to d.c. soon and wanted to have coffee with my wife to discuss the possibility of including my daughter's school in their educational fund network." so basically a person calling from overseas saying i'm a socially responsible investment fund. we might want to give your kid's school some money. mr. kahl says, there was not a generic nigerian prince scam. this person had all sorts of specific information on my wife's volunteer duties. he says there was a website for this person's purported firm, this purported investment firm that this person said she represented, but he says the website, quote, no longer exists, by the way. the website has no depth to it and there was no detailed information about this uk person who had reached out to my wife. my wife shared the e-mail with me and with a few people we know in both finance and education fields. all agreed that the entire scenario seemed implausible. it seemed like an approach by a foreign intelligence entity.
9:12 pm
to test the implausibility, my wife kept trying to encourage this person over e-mail to meet with other fund-raising officers and school leadership while she was in d.c. she provided relevant contact info for such people, but this person in the uk kept insisting that she had to meet specifically with my wife. at that point, my wife stopped corresponding. it all happened in may and early june of last year. we actually, tonight, obtained a screen grab of the initial e-mail that was sent to colin kahl's wife last year. as you can see, that e-mail says, in part, my name is adriana. i'm writing to you on behalf of reuben capital partners. i'm currently seeking partners to build and coordinate the program internationally and i'm reaching out to you because of your affiliation with this charter school. i'll be flying to washington and would love to opportunity to
9:13 pm
meet you and perhaps think about possibilities for mutual collaboration. so that goes to colin kahl's wife. the next piece of the reporting puzzle comes from laura rosen, who sussed out that the name of the supposed british company -- what was it? reuben capital partners, this company reaching out to colin kahl's wife, that was the same company name that had been given in a totally different case to actress rose mcgowan when rose mcgowan received a remarkably similar approach when she was being targeted by a private intelligence group that had been hired by hollywood producer harvey weinstein. he was running a scorched earth campaign to discredit women who had accused him of sexual assault. this private firm that was reportedly hired by harvey weinstein's attorneys in the middle of the harvey weinstein story breaking out, that firm is
9:14 pm
reportedly a company called black cube. it's a private intelligence group based in israel that reporting on harvey weinstein's attorney's allegedly hiring black cube and then black cube basically approaching women who were accusers of harvey weinstein to try to get intel from them and ultimately to discredit them, that reporting was first done by ronan farrow at the new yorker.1yx
9:15 pm
colin kahl. and also against ben rhodes, who is a slightly higher profile national security official from the obama administration. he was a national security aide to president obama. this effort targeting colin kahl and ben rhodes appears to have been an effort to discredit the iran deal, which they both support and both had a role in negotiating. the idea of discrediting the two of them is apparently to try to prepare some sort of better political environment for president trump to dump out of that deal tomorrow. here's how mark townsend and jowl ye julia borger put it. aides to president donald trump hired an israeli agency to organize tra orchestrate a dirty ops campaign. they contacted private investigators in may last year to get dirt on ben rhodes and colin kahl as part of an
9:16 pm
elaborate attempt to discredit the iran deal. one source with details said the idea was that people acting for trump would discredit those who were pivotal in selling the deal, making it easier to pull out of it. now, ronan farrow at the new yorker corroborates much of that story but he has a source saying the effort was not bought and paid for by people in the trump administration. his source says it was, quote, for a private sector client pursuing commercial interests related to sanctions on iran. well, whoever did it, whoever paid for it, which is what i'm particularly interested in, this is obviously a bizarre and baroque twist to your usual tales about how u.s. foreign policy is made. trying to dig up dirt on colin kahl and ben rhodes because they were involved in the iran deal and if we can smear them, that makes the iran deal look bad and president trump can get out of
9:17 pm
it. if you're trying to think of a historical antecedent here, there's a reason you might be stuck on watergate, just to make the loop close even tighter, this is actually the latest reporting in a follow-up story tonight in "the guardian." in addition to this campaign targeting colin kahl and ben rhodes, according to "the guardian" tonight, in november 2017, the washington offices of a pro-iran nuclear deal advocacy group were burgled. according to officials from the organization, it was a sophisticated break-in this which the building's closed circuit tv and alarms were disabled. the thieves only took two computers used by senior officials, ignoring many other expensive electronics, including a new computer still in its box which was lying close to the entrance. so, ben rhodes and colin kahl apparently get targeted by this intel company. there is a burglary of an
9:18 pm
advocacy group that is also promoting and supporting the iran deal. "the guardian" is also describing activists, including iranian-american activists being targeted in what appear to be fake journalistic entreaties, reporters calling up activists and trying to elicit information from them that could potentially be used to make guys like colin kahl and ben rhodes look bad. it is a huge deal that the president is probably going to announce the death of the iran nuclear deal tomorrow. alongside that lends a bizarre cast to that huge deal, if part of the way they've tried to arrive at this political outcome is with this cloak and dagger alleged burglary and black ops targeting the family members of obama administration officials using foreign private intelligence groups. joining us now is colin kahl, former national security adviser to vice president biden. mr. kahl, thank you very much
9:19 pm
for being here. i really appreciate your time. >> sure. >> first of all, i manuimagine must be unnerving. second of all, i'm sorry that i implied that maybe people don't know you all across america on a first name basis just seeing you on the street. >> it's fine. >> okay. >> it's a good thing. >> yes, exactly, and i hope you can retain that for as long as you want. can you tell me your overall reaction to this reporting, how plausible you see all this reporting and if you have any insight into why this might have happened to you. >> yeah, it's a great question. i think the story is still taking shape. i'll just tell you about a week ago, those reporters from the obser observer and "the guardian" reached out to me and they essentially said, look, in the process of us doing an investigation on cambridge analytica, we came across references that trump aides had hired a foreign intel ops firm from israel to dig up dirt on you and ben to try to discredit
9:20 pm
the iran deal. have you heard about this? to which i responded, no, actually, i've never heard about this and that's crazy, do you have any more information? they then repeated -- they then, you know, published their article a few days later and kind of story snowballed from there to my wife's memory about this encounter, to ronan farrow's reporting and laurie's reporting and all the rest. i think the $64,000 question is really who paid for this firm. i think the evidence is pretty solid that this firm was behind it and the question is, why? i don't find it terribly plausible that this was corporate, you know, shipping interests or something like that. it doesn't make any sense why they would go after ben and me specifically in this regard. and the thing i keep coming back to was this -- this campaign was allegedly organized last may, so may of 2017, and it targeted ben and i, and we're both senior obama officials but we weren't the only officials involved in the iran deal, nor the most senior officials involved in the iran deal, and as you said, i'm less senior than ben, so why the
9:21 pm
two of us? why conjoin ben and i? and then i recalled that, you know, in may and june of last year, there were a bunch of trump aides, sebastian gorka in particular, out in public essentially arguing that there was a ben rhodes/colin ckahl nexus that was master minding this deep state conspiracy to leak things and bring the president down. there were leaks to right wing tabloids trying to smear ben and i and only ben and i and so it's just weird. it's weird that you had aides to the president of the united states trying to essentially put ben and i as a pair, blame us for all the ills in the middle east for the obama administration, say we were orchestrating the deep state, at the very same time that someone hired this foreign intel firm. so maybe it's completely a coincidence. i have zero, no evidence that trump aides were involved. the only thing i have is the reporting from the observer and
9:22 pm
"the guardian" but it's something that needs further investigation for sure. >> and do you know what the connection is with cambridge analytica? you mentioned that when you were first contacted by reporters for your comment on this story, they said that they had basically come across this information while they were investigating cambridge analytica. we should cambridge analytica just technically shut down. they were the data firm associated with the trump campaign and they've been the subject of some incredible reporting and expose, particularly in the uk in terms of their sort of dark tactics in elections and other intel and data-related concerns. do you know what the cambridge analytica connection would be here? >> i don't. i think it's worth talking to the reporters more about it. i can -- you know, there is some reporting, not from these reporters, but others that suggested that cambridge analytica and this organization in israel, black cube, had worked together before in other areas like nigeria for a contract they did for the government there, which is a little odd since black cube says they don't work with foreign
9:23 pm
governments but anyway. but i don't know whether that was the connection or rather some of the sourcing that came out of the cambridge analytica investigation also tipped them off to this other thing. i just don't know. >> colin kahl, former deputy assistant to president obama, national security adviser to vice president biden. as i say, i imagine this must be unnerving for you and your family. thanks for helping us understand it. please stay in touch with us about it. >> thanks, rachel. thank you. all right. much more ahead tonight. in just a moment, we're going to get the latest on this explosive new reporting in the new yorker. just posted tonight, allegations of physical and sexual abuse by one of the most powerful and high-profile attorneys general in the country. that story with the reporter who's breaking that story tonight is next. stay with us.enit for weakness. do not misjudge quiet tranquility with the power of 335 turbo-charged horses the lincoln mkx, more horsepower than the lexus rx350
9:24 pm
and a quiet interior from which to admire them. the lincoln spring sales event is here. for a limited time get 0% apr on the lincoln mkx. plus get $1000 bonus cash. ♪now i'm gonna tell my momma ♪that i'm a traveller ♪i'm gonna follow the sun♪ ♪now i'm gonna tell my momma ♪that i'm a traveller ♪i'm gonna follow the sun transitions™ light under control™ looking for a hotel that fits... trawhoooo.s™ ...your budget? tripadvisor now searches over... ...200 sites to find you the... ...hotel you want at the lowest price. grazi, gino! find a price that fits. tripadvisor.
9:25 pm
9:26 pm
get your groove on with one a day 50+. ♪ get ready for the wild life ♪ complete multivitamins with key nutrients that address 6 concerns of aging, including heart health, supported by b-vitamins. your one a day is showing.
9:27 pm
every state has an attorney general, they're almost all statewide elected jobs, pretty high-profile elected jobs. there are 22 democratic attorneys general in various states right now. just as republican attorneys general made a practice of suing president obama and blocking his administration in the courts, so now are democratic ags using
9:28 pm
their power in the states to fight trump administration policies wherever they can. on the environment, on immigration, you name it. and some of these state ags are more high-profile than others. by the end of last year, for example, the democratic ag in the state of new york has taken some form of action against president trump and the trump administration at least 100 times. new york attorney general eric schneiderman has taken on the trump administration over all sorts of policy matters, the muslim ban, reproductive rights, he brought that potent and ultimately successful fraud lawsuit against trump for trump university. the new york ag is also highly visible in national politics because his state level jurisdiction includes key figures in the russia investigation. eric schneiderman's office has reportedly teamed up with the special counsel on the trump investigation into paul manafort. trump's long-time personal
9:29 pm
lawyer, michael cohen, his home and office were all searched after a referral from the special counsel. michael cohen lives and works in new york state. with so much talk in washington that president trump will, at some point, fire his way through the justice department to stop the mueller investigation, new york attorney general eric schneiderman has been seen as one way to potentially keep the russia probe going. if the president fired everybody involved on the federal level or if he issued pardons to people for federal crimes. trump tower and close associates of trump have been based here in new york and so the idea is that a new york ag like schneiderman could bring state charges separate and apart from whatever happens at the federal level, just a couple weeks ago, he started laying the groundwork to change new york state law for just that eventuality. he started work on changing state law so he could still bring state charges even after a presidential pardon cleared somebody from federal charges. so, that's the context for what i'm about to tell you and the reason why eric schneiderman is
9:30 pm
a much higher profile state attorney general than almost anybody else. as i mentioned at the top of the show, "the new yorker" magazine tonight reports on the direct accounts of four women who accuse new york attorney general eric schneiderman of physical abuse in the past several years, going back to 2013. two of these women have not given their names. two women have gone on the record, named, identifiable. quoting "the new yorker," they accused schneiderman of having subjected them to nonconsensual physical violence. they allege that he repeatedly hit them, often after drinking, frequently in bed and never with their consent. the woman categoryize the abuse as assault. they did not report their allegations to the police at the time but both say they eventually sought medical attention after having been slapped across the ear and face and also choked. one of the women says that schneiderman warned her he could have her followed and her phones tapped. both say that he threatened to kill them if he broke up with
9:31 pm
them. it's described here in this new piece from the "new yorker" is harrowing. these women are alleging very similar acts of violence and degradation inflicted on them repeatedly without consent by eric schneiderman. in response to these allegations, mr. schneiderman has given this statement to the "new yorker." he says, in the privacy of intimate relationships, i have engaged in role-playing and other consensual sexual activity. i have not assaulted anyone. i have never engaged in nonconsensual sex, which is a line i would not cross. so that's the denial from the new york state ag. on the other side, these women apparently told friends about the alleged abuse while it was still going on, and those potential corroborator white nationalists a-- witnesses are vouching for these women now. they include high-profile figures. one of the women describes speaking out now as torturous.
9:32 pm
she says, i know it's going to be my word against his. she continues, what do you do if your abuser is the top law enforcement official in the state. not long after "the new yorker" accomplished the story tonight, new york's governor, andrew cuomo, called for attorney general eric schneiderman's resignation, saying my personal opinion is that given the damning pattern of facts and corroboration laid out in the article i do not believe it is possible for eric schneiderman to continue to serve as attorney general. further, governor andrew cuomo says he will ask a local district attorney to commence an immediate investigation and proceed as the facts merit. joining us now, by phone, is jane meyer, who reported this bombshell piece tonight along with ronan farrow in the "new yorker" magazine. jane, thank you very much for joining us. i know this is a busy night. >> good to be with you. thanks for having me. >> let me ask you first about that very last thing that i just said. governor cuomo is calling for eric schneiderman's resignation,
9:33 pm
also suggesting that some of the behavior that is described in your piece tonight may be criminal and may warrant a criminal investigation by a district attorney in the state of new york. is that -- in terms of your understanding of what's being alleged here, is it possible that the attorney general could be facing criminal liability for these actions? >> yeah, i think it is possible, and it's just an incredible turn of affairs since, as of this morning, you had instead the attorney general of new york, eric schneiderman, overseeing an investigation into the same district attorney, cyrus vance jr., in manhattan. so it is possible. it's a question, i suppose, also of whether the women will want to press charges, and i don't actually know whether that's true or not at this point, and -- but, you know, the stories they told us were certainly harrowing. >> you and ronan describe a
9:34 pm
very -- the very moving part of your piece, obviously, these are harrowing allegations, and the similarity between them, i think, doubles the weight in terms of how they come across as allegations, but there's this very moving portion of your reporting tonight where you essentially describe two women who had both had allegedly remarkable similar abusive experiences with the attorney general finding each other, talking to each other about it and being able to corroborate one another's experiences. that is -- it's a remarkable thing to read about and i don't need you to tell me too much about your sources but i'm interested in why those women were able to share something that intimate and personal. >> it is -- it was really interesting, watching this whole thing unfold and i think part of it was the backdrop was the me etoo movement, but also really the allegations that came out
9:35 pm
about rob porter and domestic violence, the top white house aide who had to resign because of the pictures of a black eye that his wife got and she said they were -- it was from him. and as these women who had dated eric schneiderman over the years watched all of these headlines and these stories unfolding, they felt they had some responsibility to speak up themselves. all of these women are -- excuse me, i'm sorry, i have a cough -- are supporters of -- were supporters of schneiderman. they are -- they were progressive feminists, very articulate people, who, you know, were, i would say at least of them were, you know, sort of described themselves as having been in love with him. so they were big supporters of his, but they also were supporters of, you know, women's empowerment and they felt tremendously conflicted as the
9:36 pm
news moved in this direction, and then with the attorney general, taking such a prominent role in, you know, supervising the weinstein case, which is, you know, one of the most high-profile sexual harassment cases in recent history, they just felt the hypocrisy became kind of untenable and they began to reach out to each other and form an alliance kind of, really. >> jane mayer, who along with ronan farrow has broken this remarkable story tonight, four women accused new york's attorney general of physical abuse. i know this continues to be a developing story, jane. thank you for joining us in the middle of this. i really appreciate it. i should mention, as i said at the top of the segment here, governor andrew cuomo, the democratic governor of new york state, has called on eric schneiderman to resign as new york's state attorney general over these allegations.
9:37 pm
he has also said that he's asked a local district attorney to commence an immediate investigation and proceed as the facts merit. the nypd has said in regard to this reporting involving eric schneiderman, quote, the nypd has no complaints on file. if the nypd receives complaints of a crime, it will investigate those complaints thoroughly. we also got a statement from senator kirsten gill brandt of new york. she said, based on this extensive ander's reportin extensive and serious reporting, i do not believe eric schneiderman should continue as attorney general. also just note one other thing about this reporting, in addition to these four women, two named, describing similar instances of physical violence, there's also extensive allegations here about heavy drinking, including one detail allegation about drinking while
9:38 pm
driving or driving while drunk. again, this is developing story. we will let you know more as we learn more over the course of this evening. stay with us. lumber and arms of steel ♪ ♪ he eats a bowl of hammers at every meal ♪ ♪ he holds your house in the palm of his hand ♪ ♪ he's your home and auto man ♪ big jim, he's got you covered ♪ ♪ great big jim, there ain't no other ♪ -so, this is covered, right? -yes, ma'am. take care of it for you right now. giddyup! drinking, including one detail mine's way better.
9:39 pm
this one's below market price and has bluetooth. same here, but this one has leather seats! use the app to compare price, features and value.
9:40 pm
a hilton getaway means you get more because... you get another day in paradise. get a sunset on a sunday. get more stories to share. get more from your summer getaway with exclusive hilton offers. book yours, only at
9:41 pm
today was inauguration day in russia. since this was the fourth time for vladimir putin, they decided to keep it low key, at least according to a weird video russian state television put out. it shows putin all alone in his office, presumably hard at work, when suddenly he gets a call to
9:42 pm
come on down, time to be president again. okay, guess i'll turn off the desk lamp. that excel spreadsheet will have to wait. takes his jacket that was draped over the back of his chair, so casual, puts it on and then we watch him start to make his way out of the office and the long tracking shot. big day. gets himself all straightened out, there is one guy whose hand he shakes but other than that, not a very busy day at the office, nobody else around and the camera literally follows putin all the way down the corridor, all the way through a whole bunch of different hallways and rooms in the kremlin, wordlessly, no sound, this is the start of putin's inauguration. we just follow him the entire way to the ceremony. and it goes on -- can we speed this up? yeah, thank you. just a nonstop shot of vladimir putin walking all the way from his office down the long winding corridors of the kremlin, nobody in sight, not speaking to anybody. the world just watches him walk for three straight minutes. at some point, putin finally
9:43 pm
makes it to his brand-new russian made limousine, very snazzy, that escorts him soundlessly over to the other side of the kremlin and then finally it's time, at the stroke of 12:00 the doors open up and turns out he's not alone at all. everybody's there and there's music. all of putin's friends have been waiting to patiently for him to arrive at his inauguration ceremony, like steven seagall and former chancellor of germany who now lives full-time in the critici kremlin's pocket. vladimir putin's inauguration was a much more choreographied event than what took place over this weekend. we've got footage from that in just a second that you will want to see. stay with us.
9:44 pm
what? directv gives you more for your thing. your... quitting cable and never looking back thing. directv is rated #1 in customer satisfaction over cable. switch to directv and now get a $100 reward card. more for your thing. that's our thing. call 1.800 directv. but as it grew bigger and bigger,ness. it took a whole lot more. that's why i switched to the spark cash card from capital one. with it, i earn unlimited 2% cash back on everything i buy. everything. what's in your wallet?
9:45 pm
"i have antivirus, but my computer's still slow..." "i think it's time for the fixmestick." fixmestick is a plug-in virus removal device. it's the smart, simple way to clean an infected computer, with a whole lot going on inside the stick... [computers sound] "this one got around the antivirus software!" "not a problem." "we're on it." and because it connects to the internet, fixmestick it's always up to date. ♪now i'm gonna tell my momma ♪that i'm a traveller ♪i'm gonna follow the sun♪ ♪now i'm gonna tell my momma ♪that i'm a traveller ♪i'm gonna follow the sun transitions™ light under control™
9:46 pm
>> tech: don't wait for a chip like this to crack your whole windshield. with safelite's exclusive resin, you get a strong repair that you can trust. plus, with most insurance a safelite repair is no cost to you. >> customer: really?! >> singers: safelite repair, safelite replace. this weekend, thousands of people took to the streets in cities across russia, including st. petersburg and moscow to protest vladimir putin's umpteenth inauguration.
9:47 pm
the protest is staying in office for six more years and hand picking fake opponents to ensure he would win this reelection. we're used to seeing robust protests take place against putin now, people waving flags and signs and saying, down with the czar. we're used to seeing violent arrests at these protests. over 1,600 people were arrested this weekend, including putin's main actual add very aversary, opposition leader. putin won this reelection after hand picking his fake opponents and jailing his real ones. this is a tactic we've grown accustomed to in putin's russia but we haven't been used to seeing all this stuff. these guys in the fur hats, not the guys wearing police visors, but the guys in fur hats are pro-kreml pro-kremlin cosack fighters. they were wielding leather whips to lash protesters. "the guardian" reports they will
9:48 pm
be out in full force during the world cup. according to dmocuments, moscows administration paid to train cossacks in how to ensure public safety. having cossack fighters out in the streets with whips taking on protesters seems bad, giving them a municipal contract and putting them in charge of public safety at an international event like the world cup, that seems even worse. vladimir putin's last term as president was marked by his decision to invade and take over part of another country, also invading syria, also, of course, monkey wrenching the american presidential election to the benefit of donald trump. but it seems at the start of his next term, it seems like things are getting worse. it just -- i mean, it seems like that the more attention you pay, the worse it seems. if you're somebody who takes a wider view, though, a longer view, a better informed view of putin and his place in russia right now, are things worse? or have they always been this
9:49 pm
bad? joining us now is michael, the former u.s. ambassador to russia, author of the very timely new book "from cold war to hot peace" an american ambassador in putin's russia, mr. ambassador, great to see you. thank you for joining us. congratulations on the book. >> fun to be on the set. >> great to have you here. congratulations both on the timing and the accomplishment of this. >> thank you. >> let me just ask, in terms of news right now, putin sworn in today for another six years, when he was first president, it was only a four-year term. now it's six years. this will be his 18th year in office. >> correct. depending on how you count the prime ministership. >> but he essentially seems like he was running the place while he was prime minister. do you think he'll be in office in office until he dies? >> probably so. he doesn't have a political party or a successor and there are people around him that depend on him for their money, the oligarchs, some of those people you showed in the video there, they can't afford for him to leave because once he does, and i think they're right about
9:50 pm
this, that regime will fall apart. >> what did you make of seeing those sort of paramilitary protesters with whips in the streets. >> well, it brought back memories because when i was ambassador in 2012, those guys, they didn't bring their whips, but they did bring their knives and big hats and they used to follow me around moscow all the time when i would show up to see a human rights activist or attend some event, they, along with these neonationalist kids, would show up with their cameras all the time wherever i went. but this is new. beating up on protesters, people who are not part of the government, that's new and that scares me.
9:51 pm
putin likes to have distance between the actual official government and other intermediaries and proxies that do these kinds of things. so he does it on lots of fronts so he can deny that they're not part of the government, so when they put out disinformation as they used to do with me as ambassador, they can say, well, that's not us. we have a free society. you got to -- mr. ambassador, you have to admire our independent free media here. pretty classic putin tactic. sometimes it gets out of hand when those agents don't exactly follow what putin wants to have than. >> or when it becomes too obvious that what they're doing can't be on their own terms. at the end of the book, you have this kind of sad moment. >> it's a tragedy. the book's a tragedy. >> it is. my life's work of trying to bring our two countries closer, of trying to integrate a democratic russia seems like a failure. to punctuate the tragedy, i'm now persona non grata in a
9:52 pm
country i love. you are not optimistic about the rest of your lifetime reversing these trends. >> i'm not optimistic in the short run because i do think putin's in power. i don't see that changing any time soon. but in the long run, i'm incredibly optimistic about russia and its future with the west and with democracy. >> because you love russia. >> well, a, i love russia because i'm passionate about russia but b, i'm also a social scientist and we know that the richer countries become, the more likely they are to become democratic. that's a trend we've seen for hundreds of years. russia's a pretty rich place with a lot of smart people. they have their heads down now. those brave people you showed, they have their heads up and they're getting hit. some of them were 12 years old, by the way, but a lot of the people that were protesting earlier, back when i was ambassador, they have their heads down now, they don't want to be arrested, they're breadwinners in their families, they can't go to jail but they haven't changed their preferences about putin and i think the era after putin will be very interesting and hopefully will move them in a more democratic direction and that means a closer relationship with the west. >> and the longer he stays in
9:53 pm
power, the more potent it is to be able to imagine russia without him. >> good point. >> which at this point is a revolution we're idea. well done. thank you. it's great to have you here. thanks. we'll be right back. stay with us. ering disaster. this year, they're not messing around. miracle-gro guarantees results with rich potting mix that uses ingredients fresh from the forest... and plant food that adds vital nutrition so you'll have three times the blooms. they bask in their success. miracle-gro. three times the beauty. one powerful guarantee.
9:54 pm
9:55 pm
9:56 pm
well, this evening has at least been efficient. tonight, "the new yorker" magazine reported on allegations from four women, two of them named, against new york attorney general eric schneiderman.
9:57 pm
the women allege that schneiderman slapped and choked them without their consent in the context of personal relationships. schneiderman gave "the new yorker" a statement tonight, denying the allegations, but mere hours after this report has been published this evening, new york's attorney general, eric schneiderman, has resigned. putting out a statement tonight, quote, it has been my great honor and privilege to serve as attorney general for the people of the state of new york. in the last several hours, serious allegations have been made against me. while these allegations are unrelated to my professional conduct, they will effectively prevent me from leading the office's work at this critical time. i therefore resign my office effective at the close of business on may 8, 2018. that would be tomorrow, 5:00. the job of picking someone to serve out his term now will fall to the notoriously insane new york state legislature. but wow. really big news tonight. the residencing gnation of new
9:58 pm
attorney general. stay with us. ful life lesson. and don't worry i have everything handled. i already spoke to our allstate agent, and i know that we have accident forgiveness. which is so smart on your guy's part. like fact that they'll just... forgive you... four weeks without the car. okay, yup. good night. with accident forgiveness your rates won't go up just because of an accident. switching to allstate is worth it. ♪now i'm gonna tell my momma ♪that i'm a traveller ♪i'm gonna follow the sun♪
9:59 pm
♪now i'm gonna tell my momma ♪that i'm a traveller ♪i'm gonna follow the sun transitions™ light under control™ with dell small businessout your technology advisors transitions™ you get the one-on-one partnership you need to grow your business. the dell vostro 15 laptop. contact a dell advisor today.
10:00 pm
again, the breaking news this hour, after jane mayer and ronan farrow publish allegations in the "new yorker" magazine from four schneiderman, he has just resigned effective close of business tomorrow. he said in a statement that he, quote, strongly contests the allegations. he says these allegations will prevent me from leading the office's work at this time, so i resign effective may 8, 2018. that's it for us. now it's time for "the last word with lawrence o'donnell." >> it's been extraordinary watching this develop. governor cuomo called for his allegations in the last hour and a half or so and that resignation was