Skip to main content

tv   Worlds Apart With Oksana Boyko  RT  December 29, 2013 5:29am-6:01am EST

5:29 am
two. hormone years two of fruit for peaceful society there is a lot of society building wisdom in religions. and i think it's not wrong but the secular state does give room for this community building force of religion when we talk about separation of church and state historically we have been talking about limiting the authority of the church and keeping the church from influencing state affairs but i think if you look around the world these days in most cases we have the opposite very strong states or it is the power of the states seems to be much stronger than the power of organized religions and. i think if you look at that from a so-so sociological point of view there are many advantages to a recruiting religion because believe it is time to be.
5:30 am
law abiding citizens they are more likely to gauge and pro-social behavior so doesn't that make religion's not only a natural ally of a state but to some extent its age and there are a very many different systems of state church state religion relations in the world . and you describe you describing just about one or two of the. also other religious. ways of life in history towards the state and the secular society. religion overwhelms the state which also is is a bad thing i think one should see that without overwhelming one of the other one should a system. religion does fulfill its toss of community building given the people a sense of life is there
5:31 am
a good reason for. to give them the opportunity to see that there is something beyond that there is something more than. so something that also goes beyond what the state can do do you think the state has anything any obligation to try to strengthen let's say traditional religions to promote kind of spirituality that you just mentioned or it should be allowed to religions themselves that they have to build themselves or strengthen the cells even in societies when. their support is not that strong. from my perspective states. have the task to foster freedom freedom of religion other freedoms also. should see to a framework where people can live their lives properly from their own freedom
5:32 am
inequality that means that the state should see two. perspectives in which religion can flourish but does not mean that it supports one against the other it just means that it supports religion as such but let me also say that religion has a very strong impact within the history of people this is why it's very different from one state and community to another. they have different experiences different historical developments different fears also and that means that there are some traditional religions in some countries that have contributed just by fact somewhat more to the way people live and think. hope and fear and this specific contribution can be taken up also by the state in
5:33 am
how to deal with religions i would like to come back to this issue of the interplay between the religious and national identity a bit later but before we go there you're famous countermand german economist karl marx is credited with saying that religion is the opium of the people and i think that quote has long been taken out of context because what he actually sat is that religion is the sigh of the oppressed creature the heart of a heartless world and the soul of soulless condition it is the opium of the people so essentially what he's saying is that religion was a painkiller you know the last cure for the hopeless rather than being. and the illicit drug the way it was to dish and only interpreted in many societies including here in russia i wonder if you actually agree with him that religion is something that flourishes one time me be maybe not so great
5:34 am
and maybe providing the last hope for the hopeless i think overdoing. but there is some truth in what he says. saying. gives the thing somewhat negative touch but what i think is true and right is that in fact religion so often. to give hope in difficult situations of life now the amount of being in suffering in the wall doesn't seem to be decreasing and we are in the midst of a major very prolonged can all make rises when many. they even in the west failed our social obligations and i think this is where many religious organizations step in and provide that much needed sometimes a comic sometimes spiritual how do you think. you know this is
5:35 am
a very difficult time for some of the states could also be seen as a golden opportunity for some of the organized religions all religions see together they in fact of the idea of helping people when the state does not fulfill its. preserving them fostering social cohesion and social welfare then it is a toss of the religion too in that way to step in and do what others should also do well i guess what i'm asking is that. you know the times of economic hardship create an additional incentive for people just to turn to. religious institutions as probably you know the last hold they if the times were a bit better they may have been living their normal lives but if they're seeking for help on this that is not there to provide that help religions may be the. last
5:36 am
hope that i think is true. religion very often is the last hope the last resort for people and it's good to have it. if it were not the hope and i wonder how that connection really is because i mean if you turn to something just because you cannot get any anywhere else that may be you know on the on the level of spirituality. may not be very genuine i'm in economic hardship is india there very strong motivator but ultimately what's really just cares about is the soul and on the condition of people in in this world right . i agree to some extent. life is more than just eating but without eating there is no life i would say that
5:37 am
if there is somebody really in need and there are so many people really in deep need one should not forget that there's nothing wrong about going into a temple into a church synagogue into a mosque in this religious field and ask for help do it and get nothing bad about it and very quickly before we go to the break pope francis in the few months that he's been in the holy see he's already made a couple of statements that quite. rigorously acting in a coach on the authority of the state for example he called for limiting the dictatorship of the economy for reforming the financial system and creating more compassionate society something that has long been perceived as essential to the job of the state and he won many supporters not only among believers but also nonbelievers i wonder if that is this side of our religion or this particular
5:38 am
religion regaining its moral authority or just a likable person emerging in a prominent role what do you refer to is not meant to be something against the state it is limiting the market to the only free market it's limiting exaggeration as i would see it in one direction in one field of life. i would agree that it's also the state should somewhat. regulate of. doing this the market the banks the money. the economy given it room making it developing. fully. avoid exaggerations i think the pope as many others also is emphasizing this need to have in structures for the well being of the people so that no one fact of
5:39 am
life gets exaggerated and takes hold of others. i think there's nothing wrong it's good to do that it is a task also religions to do that it's a toss of everybody in a way. have to take a short break now but whether they come back tolerance is one of the most frequent words used by religious leaders but why then is it in such short supply when it comes to interactions between believers and nonbelievers that's coming up in a few moments while the part of. the beginning you. know. it's full of life. in the end up temptation. the darkness last for six months.
5:40 am
old people. and it is easy to hide the rifle. because the oil or do so in a spiritual or a new indigenous people but the world those who do choose this frozen life. this is could be right. if you are. on their way to and talk to the crew of the i could to make sure that a face many challenges. here you have to look out for yourself crushing on to rocks trapped in pack ice in extreme conditions anything can happen and always comes. with surprises you have to keep your eyes because there's always something going wrong the ship carries huge reserves of water food fuel as well as helicopters and people able to survive extreme conditions really for anything even an apocalypse
5:41 am
she's really an incredible ship. this is academic if you're a radio check please respond. welcome back to all the part where we are discussing the relationship between. the member of the international consortium and really just that is dr roberts we were talking about the role of religion but in many countries especially in many western
5:42 am
countries atheist and gnostics are the fastest growing group in society and as that number becomes larger i think it is becoming increasingly more difficult to reconcile to dition the religious teachings realities of modern day lives for example basic high school education and some of the higher issues like human rights do you think. the legions can ever. compromise on some of those issues for example the teaching evolution or the issues of religious freedom from my perspective it's not true. secularism is gaining rapidly i think this securitization is already. coming to an end people people are coming back to religion there is a strong need for religion all over the world in the west in the east everywhere in the north and south. that. leads also to
5:43 am
a somewhat growing antagonism between those who like religion and those who don't but i guess what i mean is that some of the traditional religious teachings that clearly contradict the. some of the more the norm which you know some of the things that we know about human body the development of life on earth obviously there are in unless you take most of the religious teachings as a beautiful metaphor there is a clear conflict between the two and even when it comes to basic high school education. i think there is a looming conflict between what you tell. pupils about how life on earth originated which is no longer scientific question but for many religions this is still a very difficult issue to come to terms with. i see that some
5:44 am
would not think many but some religions do think that. evolution has not. happened and that is this is a wrong story. i can only say something about my own perspective from a religious point of view though. i would not take the teachings of the bible or the qur'an or other books in other religions. as substituting science as be in a better textbook of physics or biology. the bible doesn't tell you how evolution works but. it gives you a. perspective a sense why it happened not so much how it happened but i think we can see that
5:45 am
across many organized religions this returned literally topper taishan it's very prominent in this long for example and be reemerging of salafism man. but even then. christianity is literally in top rotation of holy books it is on the increase and that's where that conflict with science and. you know more to knowledge is a thing. very prominent i agree with that but i would rather think it's a conflict within religion itself it's the question of what religion really teaches what it's about. how to understand religious messages. from my personal perspective it is short sighted to be too literal. to expect that what has been written five thousand years ago or three thousand
5:46 am
years ago two thousand years ago would be. the. the. more exact description of the world functions technically. for me it's more a question of sense what religion teaches not so much the technique that works well let's take one can create example where where i think this conflict between. techniques and the meaning came to the fore last year germany was shaken by a court's ruling that bad male circumcision infant male circumcision for religious purposes and. that particular court ruling equated. religious rights your bodily harm and produced a very heated debate about the. limits of state authority and religious freedom and i know that you know in germany and that willing had no power of arrest later on
5:47 am
there was a ruling by the parliament made it clear that circumcision is legal but i wonder if you if you think that was a one off event or rather more conflict flag about to come because in addition to circumcision issue we also have the debate on. evolution and so on it was a. sign. representing. one important development or situation. that many people in society did not accept any more religious arguments religious reasons so only asking for the question of bodily harm which is an important thing to ask for . but that was the only thing that was seen. that
5:48 am
is something that was puzzling that only one issue was singled out one should the perspective now many religious debates in europe involve islam to some extent or another. i know that many at appearance of many other religions complain that sometimes the state encroaches on their religious freedom you mentioned some of that but. last year there was a report by amnesty international that. really. despite the presence of very strong and discrimination laws in europe. violations of those laws. in relation to muslims are not only tolerated but sometimes even encouraged it would seem. europe which is. you know to some extent the champion of human rights and all
5:49 am
sorts of liberties can be also surprisingly toller run to certain kinds of intolerance what do you think about that not all the people. with tolerance. welcoming and accommodating in western europe. but again also i see that there is a lot of attempts to do that properly. muslims have to find. their place have to adapt also. the existing society does have to adapt and to change one should be patient with pushing for ways to find good ways well i guess it's difficult to be patient when your being activists is grim and they hit it big as you said on the other hand the burley and social science center just published a study suggesting that two thirds of muslims in western europe hold their
5:50 am
religious rules above the laws of the countries that they live in that's compared to just thirteen percent of christians and i think what that shows is that certain religions relate to the state and its rules its laws differently than others and i wonder if that gives the state any state rights you differentiate between religions bit because i think the the level of expansion is that religions claim. is a bit different from others i'm very curious to read more into this so you're referring to. the question is how did they ask the questions mind you if you read the bible if you if you go in to christianity. you find the sentence that you should be god more than. that means
5:51 am
religious law more important more convincing those of the spirit it's of the very same thing that is now referred to the muslims muslims still no more than a lot of somewhat secularized christians. and when you see the german history would not. again mind you. i would have i would be more d's of more germans would have a bit more than the stated time it's a question of is it a good state or not well that's a very politically incorrect way to put it but whether religion is good or not because. you know there are certain countries like for example saudi arabia who are not where only very active but i would even say somewhat aggressive in spreading dire religious ideology and they they do that not only through the power of the
5:52 am
state but also through the power of money of often. targeting countries and societies that are simply unable to resist that pressure and i think that brings us again to the same issue of religious freedom very thorny issue because on the one had any. system of belief should be free you. recruit me out here and would use more predator means than others and you know again we don't want to lump all islamic streams together because islam is a very diverse a very complex religion that certain strains i think are more aggressive than others and i believe even in germany there has been some efforts to limit the spread of salafism for example first of all i think one should insist in it belongs to freedom of. under to some paulton fact of freedom of religion that everyone is
5:53 am
allowed also to spread his or her religion on the other also means of spreading that are wrong by force for example by military occupation what about money what about money we come to a sensitive issue which is very hard to. go to the very details this is what i would call and would what courts international courts already have called improper proselytism is something that can be limited but one should be very careful not to limit the proper proselytism the proper missionary but when you refer to salafism in germany again there was one incident which was in the press. muslims distributed the qur'an to the people in the streets i found
5:54 am
nothing wrong with not read the koran and read the bible but it's not just the reading of the qur'an i guess as ms more about interpret it qur'an in a particular way is when you want to talk about the need to preserve our religious freedom i'd also like to ask you very quickly whether there is a need to also preserve. the right to preserve your religious identity because religion as we mentioned earlier is a very important part of not only cultural identity of any given country of its national identity and when you have other states you know or other religions coming into your country it's understandable that some people mainly feel threatened that a very national cultural and religious self is being diluted do you think this issue could be and should be addressed through legislation i don't. but legislation can do a lot about this i see the fact i agree with you religion is
5:55 am
a very strong factor in identity also very often in national identity in the identity of people in their cultural identity i think we should see all this as a chance as a chance to learn also to learn ourselves but whoever does what of identity. can enrich this identity by speaking with others well as long as that in reaching is not fueled by the power of money especially oil money dr roberts thank you very much for your time and. join us again same place same time here are worlds apart.
5:56 am
street interesting. strategic we should try. a longer covert team of journalists trying to release wiki leaks documents them out throughout the united states it's right. there. may be a local media more pro-american they encounter fear ignorance and pressure. the country blocks the way to information freedom. media stuff on our t.v. . unexplored antarctica what is it in this icy expanse that attracts the people who come here. now i only go to the dacha. and enter into. a new generation of polar explorers is coming. we have a new group of specialists here now all of them are young how are they going to get
5:57 am
along with each other i don't know. but i used to be a bureaucrat. seriously. what adventures await in this mysterious land where do they live what do they eat and what are they actually doing in antarctica . with the pledge the players are taking the i'm very hard to make our lives again a little longer there's a lot that we never had sex with that hurt me there's no legs let alone. listen to this little i'm
5:58 am
listening. he survived war atrocities. to make a final decision. has changed his life and the world around him. by giving up. hope. and love to so many children. nikolai the american worker on to. the
5:59 am
mists right from the scene. of the first strike to lips and i predict pictures. coming on our reporters twitter and come on instagram. to be announced. on law. dramas that can't be ignored to the. stories of others for a few days to notice. the faces changing the world lights now. on the old picture of today's new life on demand from around the globe.
6:00 am
local. t.v. . breaking news an r.c. international a suspected female suicide bomber kills up to eighteen people in southern russia an explosion that ripped through the main railway station of all ground. this is international coming here live from moscow hello and welcome to the program and a fast of this suspected terror tragedy in southern russia where asian people are dead and dozens more injured and were thought to have been a suicide bombing at the main railway station in the city of volgograd. going off is across developed.


info Stream Only

Uploaded by TV Archive on